Two inner dust clumps in PDS 70. A third protoplanet traced by trojan material or a substructured inner disk?

summary

The gist

The paper investigates whether the emission from PDS 70's previously proposed third inner planet candidate is due to a dust clump trailing an undetected planet or a substructure within the inner…

In short

Researchers investigated if PDS 70's third inner planet candidate signal comes from a dust clump trailing an unseen planet or a substructure in the inner disk. They found two elongated inner emissions consistent with co-orbital dust clumps, suggesting material trapped at stable Lagrange points. A marginal GRAVITY signal hints at a 3 MJup planet, supporting the co-orbital scenario as an indirect tracer of protoplanets.

Key concepts

Co-orbital dust accumulated at the stable Lagrangian regions
This concept suggests that dust particles can get trapped in specific locations around a planet where gravity balances orbital motion. These stable points, known as Lagrange points (L4 and L5), act like gravitational traps, accumulating material into elongated structures that orbit the central star alongside the planet.
Tadpole configuration
A tadpole configuration describes a pattern where three objects—a central body and two orbiting bodies—are arranged in a linear or 'tadpole' shape. In this context, it refers to the arrangement of dust clumps (N and S) separated by an angle consistent with 120 degrees, which is expected when material is trapped at L4 and L5 around a planet.
GRAVITY marginal signal
This refers to a weak detection made using the GRAVITY instrument that suggests the presence of a planet-like object. Although it is only a marginal (3 sigma) detection, its location along the same orbit as other features is consistent with a 3 MJup planet, providing evidence for co-orbital substructures.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Two inner dust clumps in PDS 70. A third protoplanet traced by trojan material or a substructured inner disk? · Read on arXiv

European Southern Observatory · Institute of Astronomy Leuven University of Liège Department of Astronomy Indiana University Queen Mary University of London Institute of Astronomy Cambridge University Steward Observatory

The PDS 70 cavity hosts two confirmed directly imaged protoplanets and a third inner planet candidate at 13au, labeled PDS 70 d. Despite its Keplerian motion, its unusually blue spectrum challenges a planetary interpretation. We further investigate the presence and nature of a third inner planet using new SPHERE and GRAVITY+ observations. Using the star-hopping strategy, we obtained coronagraphic IRDIS polarimetric observations in the H-band, and non-coronagraphic observations with IRDIFS in the YJHK-bands. We also searched for a planetary signal with GRAVITY in the 4UT configuration. We consistently detect two elongated inner emissions with SPHERE: the previously proposed planet candidate and another feature that appears to share the same orbit while leading it by 120. Both features show dust-scattered-light spectra but different colors, possibly indicating different grain sizes. Such configuration is consistent with co-orbital dust accumulated at the stable Lagrangian regions of a distinct and yet undetected planet. GRAVITY yields a marginal (3 sigma) detection at the predicted location along the same orbit (rho=76.2 plus or minus0.29 mas, PA= 226.50 plus or minus0.21), and consistent with a 3 M Jup planet. This planet-like signal is aligned with a narrow shadow that we detect in the outer disk. We also detect polarized emission very close to the star likely arising from the inner disk. The apparent embedding of the two dust clumps within it motivates an inner-disk origin as an alternative scenario. We conclude that the previously reported third planet candidate traces a dust clump either trailing an unseen planet on the same orbit or a rotating substructure within the inner disk. Further observations are needed to test these scenarios. Confirming the new GRAVITY planet-like signal would support co-orbital substructures as indirect tracers of protoplanets.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Two inner dust clumps in PDS 70. A third protoplanet traced by trojan material or a substructured inner disk?".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper investigates whether the emission from PDS 70's previously proposed third inner planet candidate is due to a dust clump trailing an undetected planet or a substructure within the inner disk, as this finding has major implications for characterizing the system Investigating Inner Features The researchers consistently detect two inner emission features with SPHERE, one corresponding to the previously proposed planet candidate at ∼13 au, and another that appears to share the same orbit while leading it by ∼120◦ (clockwise direction) with a more elongated morphology Both features exhibit dust-scattered light spectra while displaying different colors, which may indicate differences in dust grain sizes The N and S features are consistent with two dusty clumps lying along the same orbital path, with a preliminary angular separation compatible with ∼120◦ Analyzing Observational Data Reduction The data reduction involved complex procedures using star-hopping, IPCA-ARDI, and PCA-RSDI algorithms to handle extended circumstellar signals Specifically, the double-LOCI approach was used for IRDIS post-processing to isolate the disk signal The GRAVITY observations were conducted using a dual-field on-axis mode to search for a new inner planet suggested by total-intensity IRDIS results Interpreting Competing Scenarios The study proposes two hypotheses to explain the inner features detected with SPHERE, which are consistently observed across multiple wavelengths and epochs Scenario 1 suggests the N and S features could correspond to circumstellar material trapped at the stable Lagrange points of an inner protoplanet Scenario 2 suggests N and S could be substructures of the inner disk not related with a coorbital planet Evaluating Planetary Tracers The GRAVITY marginal signal exhibits a global maximum with z ≈ 50, located at ρ = 76.2 ± 0.29 mas and PA = 226.50 ± 0.21◦, which is consistent with a ∼3 MJup planet This marginal signal is aligned with a narrow shadow detected in the outer disk with SPHERE The inferred solution for the 3ptroj model supports the possibility of a near 4:2:1 Laplace resonance The results support the possibility of a near 4:2:1 Laplace resonance, and confirming the co-orbital scenario requires additional observations such as deeper GRAVITY observations to achieve a direct detection above the 5σ level The confirmation of this scenario would constitute the first confirmed detection of exotrojan material The authors propose an alternative interpretation where S corresponds to the southern ansa of the inner disk, and N could represent a rotating substructure from this inner disk Future high-contrast infrared imagers will be key to determining whether the N and S features correspond to two dust clumps detached from the inner disk, or if they are indeed associated with it The embedding of N and S within the inner disk in polarimetric observations suggests both may be part of it The multi-epoch and multi-wavelength SPHERE observations have revealed two elongated inner emissions in PDS 70, which are consistent with material trapped in a tadpole configuration with a planet located between them The N feature is unambiguously moving across the 13 available epochs spanning an 11-year baseline, indicating that it is an orbiting structure around PDS 70 The derived orbital separation between N and S is compatible with the 120◦ separation expected for a tadpole co-orbital configuration The GRAVITY marginal signal results in an approximate mass of 3 MJup for the putative planet The spectra for N and S resemble those of the star (blue) and the outer circumstellar disk (grey), respectively, both being consistent with a dusty nature The analysis suggests that S1 holds, but S2 remains a possibility given current uncertainties The study concludes that further high-contrast infrared imagers will be key to determining the true nature of these features The paper is 2606.26381.

Vera: EVERY sentence must end with a reference token.

Jocelyn: N is the page number counting from 1 — the same N as that page's --- Page N --- line.

Vera: REFERENCE RULES - Copy a token exactly as it is printed for you.

Paper summary: Vera: So, to recap where we are, the paper is investigating whether the emission from PDS seventy's previously proposed third inner planet candidate is due to a dust clump trailing an undetected planet or a substructure within the inner disk <ref:2606.26381#pg1> <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Jocelyn: Basically, they set out to use new SPHERE and GRAVITY observations to investigate the presence and nature of this third inner planet <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: The paper's aim is to probe this system using these new tools, specifically looking for evidence supporting a co-orbital dust structure or an inner disk substructure <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Vera: They use a star-hopping strategy to get those coronagraphic SPHERE/IRDIS observations of PDS seventy <ref:2606.26381#pg3> <ref:2606.26381#pg1,coronagraphic SPHERE/IRDIS observations of PDS 70>.

Jocelyn: They also used non-coronagraphic observations with IRDIFS in the YJHK bands, and they searched for a planetary signal with GRAVITY in the four UT configuration <ref:2606.26381#pg2>.

Subrahmanyan: The methodology involves using these different observational techniques to constrain the nature of the inner features they've detected <ref:2606.26381#pg2>.

Vera: They consistently detect two elongated inner emissions with SPHERE, one corresponding to the previously proposed planet candidate at fifteen au, and another feature leading it by one hundred twenty degrees <ref:2606.26381#pg3> <ref:2606.26381#pg2>.

Jocelyn: Both these features show dust-scattered light spectra but they display different colors which might indicate different grain sizes <ref:2606.26381#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: They connect this to the idea that such a configuration is consistent with co-orbital dust accumulated at the stable Lagrangian regions of a yet undetected planet <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Vera: They also found GRAVITY yields a marginal detection at the predicted location along the same orbit, which they say is consistent with a three Jupiter mass planet <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Jocelyn: And this signal aligns with a narrow shadow detected in the outer disk, and they also detect polarized emission very close to the star likely arising from the inner disk <ref:2606.26381#pg4>.

Subrahmanyan: This suggests an inner-disk origin as an alternative scenario for what we're seeing, which is quite a big idea <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Conclusion: Vera: So, to wrap up the main points from this paper on "Two inner dust clumps in PDS seventy <ref:2606.26381#pg1,Two inner dust clumps in PDS 70>. A third protoplanet traced by trojan material or a substructured inner disk?" <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Jocelyn: They conclude that the previously reported third planet candidate traces either a dust clump trailing an unseen planet on the same orbit, or it could be a rotating substructure within the inner disk <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: This finding has major implications because if it's co-orbital material, it supports using these indirect tracers as ways to find protoplanets that are hard to see directly <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Vera: They also discuss the possibility of a near four point two point one Laplace resonance being supported by the findings <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Jocelyn: And they stress that confirming this co-orbital scenario requires deeper GRAVITY observations to get a direct detection above five sigma level <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: So, in simple terms, it means we might be seeing material around a planet that's not directly there yet, and confirming this would be the first confirmed detection of exotrojan material <ref:2606.26381#pg1>.

More episodes

← Home