The slower rotation of planet-hosting stars revisited
summary
The gist
The paper revisits previous studies to conclude that statistically planet-hosting stars rotate slower than stars without detected planets…
In short
This study re-examines previous findings that planet-hosting stars rotate slower than non-hosting stars using updated stellar and planetary data. By comparing rotation periods to temperature expectations, researchers found a statistically significant shift in period ratios for shorter rotation periods, suggesting a connection between stellar rotation and planet occurrence.
Key concepts
- Rotation Period Ratio (r)
- This is the comparison between the actual observed rotational period of a star and what its period should be based only on its effective temperature. A ratio significantly different from one indicates that the star's rotation deviates from what is expected for its temperature alone, which is key to linking rotation to planet presence.
- Gaia DR3 Catalogue
- This refers to the latest data catalogue released by the European Space Agency's Gaia mission. Using this updated catalogue provides more precise measurements of stellar parameters like effective temperature, which are crucial for accurately modeling how a star's rotation period relates to its physical properties.
- Kepler/TESS Samples
- These are large surveys that measure the rotational periods of stars using light curves from space telescopes. The study uses these samples to find planet hosts and non-hosts, comparing the rotational characteristics of these two groups to test the hypothesis about rotation and planets.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- The slower rotation of planet-hosting stars revisited · Paper Radio
- Revisiting Stellar equatorial rotational velocities with Gaia DR3 line broadening -- the dependence on temperature, mass and age
The paper
The slower rotation of planet-hosting stars revisited · Read on arXiv
Avraham Binnenfeld, Amitay Sussholz, Simchon Faigler, Tsevi Mazeh
Institute of Physics, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne · School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University · Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie
Previous studies combined rotation periods derived from Kepler photometry, stellar parameters from previous Gaia Data Releases, and planet hosts from the NASA Exoplanet Archive to conclude that statistically planet-hosting stars rotate slower than stars without detected planets. Here, we revisit these studies by using similar Kepler rotational period sample, but with an updated Gaia DR3-based stellar parameter catalogue and an updated exoplanet catalogue. We apply minimal sample cuts in evolutionary state, metallicity, and distance, and then model the stellar rotation period as a function of effective temperature alone. For each star, we derive the ratio of its observed period to the temperature-expected period, and compare the ratio distributions for the planet-host and non-host stars. For periods shorter than 20 d, the planet-host distribution of this ratio is shifted towards longer periods; the period-ratio median is 15% larger for hosts than for non-hosts (p KS = 2.4 x 10-4). We also examine the recently published TESS All-Sky Rotation Survey (TARS) and find a similar trend. However, the strongly structured period distribution precludes a robust comparison between the host and the non-host stars. Therefore, the updated analysis, using more robust stellar and planetary parameters, recovers the previously reported association, strengthening the case for a genuine connection between stellar rotation and planet occurrence.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The slower rotation of planet-hosting stars revisited".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper revisits previous studies to conclude that statistically planet-hosting stars rotate slower than stars without detected planets, using updated stellar and planetary parameters to strengthen the case for a genuine connection between stellar rotation and planet occurrence Revisiting Previous Findings Previous studies combined rotation periods derived from Kepler photometry, stellar parameters from previous Gaia Data Releases, and planet hosts from the NASA Exoplanet Archive to conclude that statistically planet-hosting stars rotate slower than stars without detected planets In this work, the authors revisit this result by using similar Kepler rotational period samples but with an updated Gaia DR3-based stellar parameter catalogue and an updated exoplanet catalogue They apply minimal sample cuts in evolutionary state, metallicity, and distance and then model the stellar rotation period as a function of effective temperature alone For each star, they derive the ratio of its observed period to the temperature-expected period and compare the ratio distributions for the planet-host and non-host stars Updated Kepler Analysis The updated analysis uses homogeneous measurements from Gaia DR3 for stellar parameters and updates the planet-host sample using the current exoplanet census The analysis restricts itself to stars with 4500 ≤ Teff ≤ 6000 K and removes evolved stars by fitting a main-sequence region in a colour–magnitude diagram They restrict the comparison to the region of distance and metallicity where detected hosts are sufficiently represented, adopting d ≤ 1300 pc and
M/H: GSP−Phot > −0.4 The retained region contains 400 detected hosts among 12525 stars, or 3.2% Rotation Period Ratios The authors model the dependence of rotation period on effective temperature alone using a third-degree polynomial relation, ln Prot,expected = a0 + a1x + a2x2 + a3x3 where x = Teff − 5500 K They compare the period ratio r = Prot,obs/Prot,expected for the 1 < Prot ≤ 20 d and 20 < Prot ≤ 30 d intervals separately For the interval 1 < Prot ≤ 20 d, the median period ratios are 0.909 for hosts and 0.800 for non-hosts, giving a ratio of medians of 1.14 The two-sided KS test gives DKS = 0.156 and pKS = 2.4×10−4 TESS Rotational Periods The authors examine the TESS All-Sky Rotation Survey (TARS) as a possible independent test, but find that the strongly structured period distribution precludes a robust comparison between host and non-host stars For Prot ≤ 20 d, the nominal sample contains 228 hosts and 97260 non-hosts The median period ratio is about 8.5% larger for hosts than for non-hosts, with pKS = 5.6 × 10−3, formally in the same direction as the Kepler result However, the TARS period distribution shows substantial structure and is not considered a robust independent test Discussion and Implications The offset found in their sample, expressed fractionally, is comparable in scale to the result of Sibony et al.
Vera: (2022), who measured a rotation period difference of 1.63±0.40 d The difference weakened when rapidly rotating stars were excluded and disappeared for Prot > 15 d, similar to their null result for periods above 20 d They note that the hosts are more metal-rich and slightly brighter, but these differences have almost no effect on the detected period shift The comparison is limited by incompleteness in both planet detection and rotation-period recovery, as rapid rotators tend to be more active and variable Further study could make use of observed stellar line broadening, together with estimates of stellar radii, to infer stellar rotational velocities The authors conclude that they do not regard the current TARS catalogue as sufficiently reliable to test whether the Kepler shift is reproduced with TESS The authors find no significant difference between the distributions in the 20 < Prot ≤ 30 d interval when comparing hosts and non-hosts The result is limited to the period range in which the MMA catalogue is comparatively reliable, concentrating on periods shorter than 20 d Slow stellar rotations are harder to measure, and long periods are more susceptible to aliases and catalogue-dependent systematics The authors suggest that the apparent effect could be confined to a certain period range, potentially reflecting the strong period dependence of rotation-period detectability Acknowledgments The authors thank the anonymous referee for their careful and constructive comments, which led them to revisit key aspects of the analysis and substantially improved their manuscript This work used data from the European Space Agency (ESA) mission Gaia, processed by the Gaia Data Processing and Analysis Consortium (DPAC) This research has also used the NASA Exoplanet Archive, which is operated by the California Institute of Technology under contract with NASA through the Exoplanet Exploration Program This work includes data from the Kepler and TESS missions Funding for Kepler and TESS is provided by NASA References The references listed include publications such as Skumanich 1972, Bouvier et al.
Jocelyn: 2014, and Sibony et al.
Vera: 2022 The authors also cite work from Canto Martins et al.
Paper summary: Vera: So we're looking at this paper right now called "The slower rotation of planet-hosting stars revisited," and it’s revisiting some older findings about how fast stars spin compared to whether they have planets.
Jocelyn: The main idea here is that the authors are using updated data from the Gaia Data Release three to look at this connection again, specifically comparing planet hosts with non-hosts.
Subrahmanyan: So essentially they are taking what was done before, combining old Kepler rotation periods with older stellar parameters and an old planet catalog, and they are running a fresh test.
Vera: Right. They aren't just repeating the old work; they’re updating the input data significantly to see if that original conclusion holds up or needs changing.
Jocelyn: What they claim is that statistically, planet-hosting stars rotate slower than stars without detected planets, but this new analysis tries to strengthen that case using better stellar and planetary catalogs.
Subrahmanyan: The paper says they use similar Kepler rotational period samples but with an updated Gaia DR3 based stellar parameter catalogue and a current exoplanet catalogue. That’s the main change in their setup.
Vera: They are applying minimal sample cuts to things like evolutionary state, metallicity, and distance before they start modeling the stellar rotation period as a function of effective temperature alone.
Jocelyn: And then they look at the ratio of the observed period to what’s expected based on that temperature, comparing those ratios for host stars versus non-host stars in different periods.
Subrahmanyan: They model it using a third degree polynomial relation for the rotation period compared to effective temperature, where x is effective temperature minus five hundred fifty Kelvin.
Vera: They compare the ratio distributions for two specific intervals: one from one degree less than twenty days, and another from twenty days up to thirty days.
Jocelyn: For that first interval of one day less than twenty days, they found the median period ratios are zero point nine zero nine for hosts and zero point eight zero zero for non-hosts <ref:2611.08267#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: And when you calculate the ratio of those medians, it gives a ratio of medians of one point one three seven. They also run a KS test on that comparison and get a DKS value of zero point one five six with a p value of two point four times ten to the negative four.
Vera: That p value is relatively small, suggesting there’s some statistical difference between those two groups in that shorter period range.
Jocelyn: They also look at the TESS All-Sky Rotation Survey, which is another independent test to see if they get the same result.
Subrahmanyan: The TESS analysis shows a different picture because the strongly structured period distribution makes it hard to compare host and non-host stars robustly.
Paper summary: Vera: They found that for periods less than twenty days in TESS, the median period ratio is about eight point five percent larger for hosts than for non-hosts, with a p value of five point six times ten to the negative three.
Jocelyn: That p value goes in the same direction as their Kepler result, which is interesting because it supports the original finding but also shows some difference in how they're observing things.
Subrahmanyan: But they note that this TESS period distribution has substantial structure, so it’s not considered a robust independent test for this specific comparison.
Vera: The authors also point out that the offset they found in their sample, when expressed as a fraction, is on a scale comparable to what another study measured with a rotation period difference of one point six three plus or minus zero point four zero days.
Jocelyn: They also mention that this difference weakens when you exclude rapidly rotating stars and disappears for periods greater than fifteen days, which is similar to their null result for periods above twenty days.
Subrahmanyan: They note that the hosts are more metal-rich and slightly brighter, but they say those differences don't have much effect on the detected period shift.
Vera: The paper does admit a limitation here; they mention that the comparison is limited by incompleteness in both planet detection and rotation period recovery.
Jocelyn: They also suggest that for future work, observing stellar line broadening together with estimates of stellar radii could help them infer stellar rotational velocities more directly.
Subrahmanyan: The authors conclude that they don't regard the current TESS catalogue as reliable enough to test whether the Kepler shift is reproduced with TESS, and they limit their findings to the period range where their main catalogue is considered reliable, which is shorter than twenty days.
Vera: So what this means for us listening right now is that we’re seeing a potential signal here, but it seems very dependent on how fast the star rotates, which might only be visible in shorter periods.
Jocelyn: It sounds like the effect might be confined to a certain period range because slow stellar rotations are harder to measure and long periods are more susceptible to catalogue-dependent systematics.
Subrahmanyan: The implication is that we might not see this clear shift across all rotation periods, but rather it's strongly tied to the specific period range we’re looking at.
Vera: So, in a nutshell, the paper "The slower rotation of planet-hosting stars revisited" uses updated parameters to confirm that planet hosts tend to be slower rotators than non-hosts in certain short period ranges, but they stress that this effect is highly sensitive to the data used and the period being measured.
Jocelyn: That’s it. We’ll keep an eye on those shorter periods for any further confirmation of this rotation link between planets and stars.
Conclusion: Vera: So, this paper is revisiting an older idea about whether stars that host planets spin slower than those that don't at all, which they call "The slower rotation of planet-hosting stars revisited."
Jocelyn: Yeah, the authors are taking old data and running a fresh test to see if they can prove this connection again with better information.
Subrahmanyan: They’re using updated stellar parameters from Gaia three and a newer catalog of planets to make their comparison stronger.
Vera: The main point is that they are looking at how the rotation period changes when you look at stars with planets versus those without them, especially in specific ranges.
Jocelyn: And they found that in some of those specific period ranges, the planet-hosting stars do indeed show a shift towards longer periods compared to their non-host counterparts.
Subrahmanyan: This is relevant because if it’s true, it links the physical rotation of a star to whether or not it has formed a planet around it.
Vera: It suggests that stellar rotation might be a factor in planet formation, but they are being careful about the limitations of their data set.
Jocelyn: They admit that they can't use every single TESS observation as proof yet because the period distribution there is too messy to compare reliably between hosts and non-hosts.
Subrahmanyan: The authors conclude that this effect might only be visible in certain period ranges, probably shorter ones, because slow rotators are harder to measure across the whole sky.
Vera: It means we might need to look really closely at those shorter rotation periods when we search for planet hosts in our surveys.
Jocelyn: And if this connection holds up with future observations, it could help us understand the physical processes that actually lead to planet formation around these stars.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO