Supermassive stars with embedded stellar black hole cores: dense assembling star clusters as faint multiple Little Red Dot systems

summary

The gist

Numerical simulations demonstrate that star clusters with densities comparable to those at high redshift may build up extremely massive or supermassive stars and potentially intermediate mass black…

In short

Simulations show that dense star clusters can create extremely massive stars (EMSs or SMSs) and intermediate mass black holes (IMBHs) through runaway stellar collisions. These interactions lead to distinct outcomes, including interactions with EMS/SMS objects and the formation of quasi-star like systems. This process provides an alternative pathway for forming QS-like stars, which are more long-lived than standard SMS models.

Key concepts

EMS/SMS
These are extremely massive or supermassive stars formed in dense star clusters. They can exceed 1000 solar masses and are thought to form through runaway stellar collisions within these highly concentrated environments.
BH Star Interactions (A-E)
The simulations classify BH interactions into five categories based on the masses involved, such as interactions with EMS/SMS or IMBHs. Category E, involving very high mass ratios, is particularly significant in determining the final outcome of these collisions.
Scalar Resonant Relaxation (SRR)
This is a very short timescale governing the dynamics in the innermost regions around massive stars. SRR drives stellar BHs into collision orbits quickly, on timescales as short as 0.1 million years, influencing how they interact with the star.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Supermassive stars with embedded stellar black hole cores: dense assembling star clusters as faint multiple Little Red Dot systems · Read on arXiv

Antti Rantala, Kavli Institute for Cosmology, Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik

Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge · Kavli Institute for Cosmology · Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik

Numerical simulations have established that star clusters with densities comparable to the high redshift (z>6 - 10) James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) proto globular clusters may build up extremely massive (EMSs; m>1000 M) or even supermassive stars (SMSs; m>10000 M) and potentially intermediate mass black holes (IMBHs) through runaway stellar collisions. Using direct simulations of assembling star clusters including post-Newtonian black hole dynamics and stellar evolution, we demonstrate that in such dense environments (Σ h 10 6 M pc-2) stellar BHs (m 60 M), driven by rapid mass segregation and relaxation effects within the sphere of influence of the EMSs/SMSs, may strongly interact with the extremely massive stars and become embedded within their gaseous layers. We suggest that this quasi-star (QS) like embedded BH phase is a natural outcome of the runaway formation of EMSs/SMSs in the densest star clusters. The QS phase may be 1 - 2 orders of magnitude longer in duration than the lifetime of the SMS, enabling an extended growth period by stellar collisions, and allows the formation of embedded gravitational wave sources if the QS captures more than a single stellar BH. The star cluster assembly region sizes (about100 pc), QS masses (10 4 M) and their proximity to young, massive blue star forming clumps are consistent with the faint population of multiple little red dots (LRDs) recently discovered by the JWST.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Supermassive stars with embedded stellar black hole cores".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Numerical simulations have established that star clusters with densities comparable to the high redshift (z > 6–10) James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) proto globular clusters may build up extremely massive (EMSs; m★ > 1000 M⊙) or even supermassive stars (SMSs; m★ > 10000 M⊙) and potentially intermediate mass black holes (IMBHs) through runaway stellar collisions Simulation Methodology The study utilizes direct simulations of assembling star clusters, incorporating post-Newtonian black hole dynamics and stellar evolution The code BIFROST is used for the Nbody simulations, employing a hierarchical fourth order forward integrator and secular and regularised few-body solvers with post-Newtonian equations of motion up to the order PN3.5 for black holes Stellar evolution is coupled to SEVN based on PARSEC stellar tracks up to 600 M⊙, where stars can collide and merge if their radii overlap, losing up to 7.5% of their mass per collision using a mass ratio based fitting formula The simulation examines 30 hierarchical star cluster assembly simulations and three isolated comparison simulations Classification of Interaction Outcomes The simulation sample identifies five largely distinct categories of BH star interactions, labeled A–E, based on the masses and mass ratios involved Category E is particularly significant, involving "BH+EMS/SMS stellar" interactions with very high stellar mass ratios of 22 ≲ m★/m• ≲ 407 Category A involves IMBHs interacting with (very) massive stars, typically corresponding to classic TDEs where stars on almost parabolic orbits are disrupted by considerably more massive black holes Dynamical Mechanisms in the Core The dynamics of stellar BHs around the EMS/SMS are governed by rapid mass segregation and relaxation effects within the sphere of influence, with crossing times on the order of tcross ∼ 0.01 Myr Stellar BHs are deposited into collision orbits by relaxation processes rather than being produced from loss cones, as stellar BHs that form outside the loss cone are deposited into it by relaxation processes The scalar resonant relaxation (SRR) timescale is very short in the innermost regions, tSRR ≲ 0.1 Myr Implications for Observed Systems The findings suggest that the QS like SMS model, formed through runaway stellar collisions, provides a channel for gas embedded gravitational wave (GW) sources in assembling star clusters The expected bolometric luminosities of the ∼ 104 M⊙ QSs are at least an order of magnitude lower than typical LRDs, but their inferred luminosities are consistent with the potential emerging population of faint LRDs The hierarchical cluster assembly scenario predicts that faint LRDs should frequently have companions within ≲ 100 pc, while evolved LRDs with higher QS/BH masses should be more commonly found in relative isolation The study highlights the interconnectedness of various SMBH seeding mechanisms by showing that QSs can form if the DCBH channel fails through intermediate steps involving dense, clustered star formation and an SMS The proposed SMS → QS pathway from runaway stellar collisions is common in the densest star clusters where SMSs can form This scenario offers an alternative pathway for the formation of QS like main sequence phase SMSs with BH cores at low gas accretion rates The extended lifetime of QSs, orders of magnitude longer than SMS lifetimes, enables prolonged mass growth via collisions or gas accretion Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper demonstrates that EMSs/SMS interactions are plausible and frequent outcomes of models that build up the EMSs/SMS through repeated stellar collisions in dense star clusters This quasi-star like configuration is likely to affect the further evolution of the stars, leading to extended lifetimes compared to SMSs The process of rejuvenation by collisions or gas accretion may prolong the lifetime of the massive stellar collision product Where the gains come from The authors interpret a faint dual LRD system as an early evolutionary phase of a clustered hierarchically assembling star formation region The separation of the LRD pair is consistent with the spatial sizes and locations of star cluster assembly regions The inferred QS luminosities are consistent with the Red Eyes system's luminosities How the training signal is built The paper structures its findings by detailing results concerning BH EMS/SMS interactions in Section 3 and interpreting these findings in terms of early LRD evolution in Section 4 The results are presented through a classification of five interaction categories (A–E) based on stellar masses, BH masses, and mass ratios Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The study emphasizes that the current models for SMS and QS SEDs struggle to explain broad emission lines up to 2000–3000 km s−1 observed in typical bright LRDs The authors note that the SMS/QS models form through runaway stellar collisions and continue to experience repeated collisions in the QS phase Where the gains come from The paper concludes by proposing that faint LRDs represent the initial stages of the LRD evolution, and as the region collapses, evolved more luminous LRDs should show fewer close bright companions The hierarchical star cluster assembly picture allows to estimate the future evolution of multiple LRD systems How the training signal is built The discussion on dynamics confirms that mass precession originating from the extended stellar component is the dominant orbit precession mechanism at separations where stars and stellar BHs orbit the SMS The analysis of orbital timescales shows that scalar resonant relaxation and nonresonant two-body relaxation are responsible for driving stellar BHs into interaction orbits with the EMS/SMS on a timescale shorter than the interaction window Where the gains come from The final conclusion is that the expected bolometric luminosities of ∼ 104 M⊙ QSs are at least an order of magnitude lower than typical LRDs, yet their properties are consistent with faint multiple LRD systems The study ultimately suggests that the faint multiple LRD phase represents the initial stages of the LRD evolution Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper emphasizes that QSs are considerably more long-lived than SMSs, a feature not modeled in current simulations but potentially enabling continued growth by stellar collisions The authors note that the extended lifetime contributes little to the total elemental enrichment budget of the SMS/QS as the BH core likely suppresses nuclear reactions Where the gains come from The research highlights that observations of gravitationally lensed LRDs will play a particularly powerful role in shedding light on the issue distinguishing between DCBH and runaway star cluster channels The paper concludes by proposing that the faint multiple LRD phase represents the initial stages of the LRD evolution Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The authors confirm that in strong interactions, the EMS/SMS may lose mass and acquire a stellar BH core rather than being promptly destroyed The paper notes that the dynamical scenario provides an alternative pathway for the formation of QS like main sequence phase SMSs with BH cores at low gas accretion rates Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The authors emphasize that QSs are considerably more long-lived than SMSs, a feature not modeled in current simulations but potentially enabling continued growth by stellar collisions The authors note that the extended lifetime contributes little to the total elemental enrichment budget of the SMS/QS as the BH core likely suppresses nuclear reactions Where the gains come from

Title and authors: Vera: Let's talk about what this paper actually titled "Supermassive stars with embedded stellar black hole cores: dense assembling star clusters as faint multiple Little Red Dot systems" is trying to show us. It’s trying to link the physics of star cluster assembly with the observed properties of these faint LRD pairs.

Jocelyn: Basically, they are arguing that the process of building up these very dense star clusters naturally creates stars that can grow into supermassive or even super-supermassive stars through those stellar collisions.

Subrahmanyan: It suggests that instead of needing some exotic, slow accretion mechanism to get a seed black hole, this dense cluster environment provides a much more direct route through stellar dynamics.

Vera: The authors are using simulations, specifically Nbody simulations with post-Newtonian black hole dynamics and stellar evolution models, to test this idea across thirty different hierarchical cluster assembly scenarios.

Jocelyn: And they've done this by comparing the outcomes of these dense cluster simulations against three isolated comparison simulations that don't have the same level of environmental density.

Subrahmanyan: This methodology allows them to isolate how much that high density, quantified by a density h greater than ten to sixty solar mass per cubic parsec squared, affects the final stellar outcomes <ref:2604.22924#pg1>.

Vera: So, they're testing if the physics of these dense environments can actually produce these extremely massive stars or supermassive stars in the first place.

Jocelyn: And they found that this collision pathway is a plausible channel for gas embedded gravitational wave sources when assembling these star clusters at high redshift.

The paper's summary: Vera: So, what’s the core finding in this paper, beyond just the title? It seems to be about classifying the different ways these stellar black holes interact with these massive stars and what those interactions produce.

Jocelyn: They identified five distinct categories of black hole star interactions, labeled A through E, based on the masses involved and mass ratios between the components.

Subrahmanyan: Category E is particularly interesting because it involves "BH + EMS/SMS stellar" interactions with very high mass ratios, specifically between two-twenties and four hundred seven solar masses.

Vera: That category E interaction seems to be where the most dramatic outcomes are happening, involving the interaction of black holes with these extremely massive stars.

Jocelyn: Category A involves intermediate mass black holes interacting with very massive stars, which often corresponds to what we see as classic tidal disruption events or TDEs.

Subrahmanyan: The paper also delves into the dynamics in the core, showing that rapid mass segregation and relaxation effects within the sphere of influence are what drive stellar BHs into collision orbits around the EMS or SMS.

Vera: They found that these crossing times on those interaction orbits are on the order of zero point zero one megayears, which is quite fast compared to other timescales.

Jocelyn: And they noted that these stellar black holes get deposited into collision orbits by relaxation processes rather than being created from loss cones, which is a specific detail about their origin.

The paper's improvements: Vera: Now, the authors suggest some ways to refine their modeling and what they found implies for the broader picture. They emphasize that the current models for SMS and QS sources struggle to explain broad emission lines up to two thousand to three thousand kilometers per second observed in typical bright LRDs.

Jocelyn: They point out that their SMS or QS models form through runaway stellar collisions and continue experiencing repeated collisions in the QS phase, which is a feature not fully modeled in current simulations.

Subrahmanyan: This extended lifetime of the QS objects, which is orders of magnitude longer than SMS lifetimes, could potentially enable prolonged mass growth via collisions or gas accretion.

Vera: They also note that while they model rejuvenation through collisions and gas accretion, they emphasize that the actual rejuvenation of the massive star depends on things like mixing and convection treatment in more detailed models.

Jocelyn: The paper suggests that a faint dual LRD system might represent an early evolutionary phase of a clustered, hierarchically assembling star formation region.

Subrahmanyan: This leads to the idea that faint LRDs should frequently have companions within less than one hundred parsecs, while evolved LRDs with higher QS or BH masses might be found more commonly in relative isolation.

Conclusion: Vera: So, wrapping up the main implications of this paper on these "Supermassive stars with embedded stellar black hole cores: dense assembling star clusters as faint multiple Little Red Dot systems." It seems like they are proposing that the SMS to QS pathway from runaway stellar collisions is a common mechanism in the densest star clusters.

Jocelyn: They suggest this provides an alternative pathway for forming QS-like main sequence phase SMS objects with black hole cores, even at low gas accretion rates.

Subrahmanyan: It really highlights the interconnectedness of different SMBH seeding mechanisms by showing that QS formation can happen if the DCBH channel fails through intermediate steps involving dense, clustered star formation and an SMS.

Vera: The paper suggests that these QS objects might have bolometric luminosities at least an order of magnitude lower than typical LRDs, but their inferred luminosities are consistent with the potential emerging population of faint LRDs.

Jocelyn: And they conclude by proposing that the faint multiple LRD phase represents the initial stages of the Little Red Dot evolution.

Subrahmanyan: The research emphasizes that observations of gravitationally lensed LRDs will be particularly powerful for distinguishing between the DCBH channel and this runaway star cluster channel.

Vera: It’s a lot to take in, showing how stellar dynamics within dense clusters can drive massive star evolution and black hole growth.

Jocelyn: And it opens up questions about what those faint LRD systems actually look like when they are in their earliest stages.

More episodes

← Home