SN 2024abfl: A Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova in NGC 2146 from a Low-Mass Red Supergiant Progenitor
summary
The gist
SN 2024abfl is a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova originating from a low-mass red supergiant progenitor in NGC 2146…
In short
SN 2024abfl is a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova in NGC 2146 from a low-mass red supergiant progenitor. Analysis of its light curve and spectra estimated a very low 56Ni mass (0.009 M⊙), lower explosion energy, and ejecta mass, classifying it as an LLSN IIP. This supports the idea that low-mass progenitors lead to less energetic explosions.
Key concepts
- Type IIP Supernova
- This is a type of supernova that results from the collapse of a red supergiant star. The 'p' in Type IIP indicates it has a relatively long plateau phase in its light curve, caused by the interaction between the expanding supernova ejecta and the dense hydrogen envelope surrounding the progenitor star.
- 56Ni Mass
- This refers to the mass of Nickel-56 synthesized during the explosion. It is a key indicator of how much radioactive material was produced in a supernova. In this case, it was estimated to be very low (around 0.009 M⊙), suggesting a less energetic explosion.
- LLSNe IIP Classification
- This classification groups supernovae with lower luminosity than normal Type IIP events. SN 2024abfl fits this category due to its low plateau brightness and derived parameters, which are consistent with explosions from lower-mass progenitors.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- SN 2024abfl: A Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova in NGC 2146 from a Low-Mass Red Supergiant Progenitor · Paper Radio
- Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernovae from the Zwicky Transient Facility Census of the Local Universe. II: Lightcurve Analysis
- SN 2024abfl: A Flat-Plateau, Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova with Early CSM Interaction
The paper
SN 2024abfl: A Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova in NGC 2146 from a Low-Mass Red Supergiant Progenitor · Read on arXiv
Xiaohan Chen, Ning-Chen Sun, Qiang Xi, Chun Chen, Yu Zhang, Zexi Niu, Junjie Jin, Yiming Mao, Beichuan Wang, §Samaporn Tinyanont8§Krittapas Chanchaiworawit8§Kanthanakorn Noysena8“David Aguado9, 10▵Ismael Perez-Fournon9, 10▵Frédérick Poidevin9, 10▵Justyn R. Maund13, Xunhao Chen, Pengliang Du, §David López Fernández-Nespral9, 10▵Liguo Fang1▵Guolin Gao1, 2▵Jiupeng Guo1, Min He1, Xinyi Hong1, 3, Zhigang Hou1, Qingzheng Li1, Wenxiong Li1, Tongyu Liu1, §Alicia López-Oramas9, 10▵Haiyang Mu1, §César Rojas-Bravo3, Jianfeng Tian1, Jinhu Wang1, Lingzhi Wang15, 16▵Rui Wang1, Yanan Wang1, Ziyang Wang11, 12▵Klaas Wiersema14Ying Wu, §Guo Zhen17, 18▵Jie Zheng1, Guoyin Zhu1, Yinan Zhu1, Zhou Fan3§▵Jing Li2△Hong Wu1, Jifeng Liu4
National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences · School of Physics and Astronomy, China West Normal University · School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences · Institute for Frontiers in Astronomy and Astrophysics, Beijing Normal University · School of Physics and Astronomy, Sun Yat-sen University · Dipartimento di Fisica, Universita di Napoli “Federico II” · National Astronomical Research Institute of Thailand · Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias · Universidad de La Laguna, Departamento de Astrofisica · School of Physics and Astronomy, Beijing Normal University · Department of Physics, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Beijing Normal University · Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202659221
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "SN 2024abfl: A Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova in NGC 2146 from a Low-Mass Red Supergiant Progenitor".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. SN 2024abfl is a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova originating from a low-mass red supergiant progenitor in NGC 2146, which is important because it helps constrain the diversity in explosion properties of Type IIP supernovae Explosion Characteristics and Progenitor Constraints The study presents photometric and spectroscopic observations of SN 2024abfl, a SN IIP in NGC 2146 with a directly detected red supergiant (RSG) progenitor The authors find that it has a low plateau luminosity (MV ∼ −15 mag) and a relatively long plateau length (∼ 126.5 days) By fitting a semi-analytical model, they estimated a 56Ni mass of ∼ 0.009 M⊙, an initial kinetic energy of ∼ 0.42 foe, an initial thermal energy of ∼ 0.03 foe and an ejecta mass of ∼ 8.3 M⊙ The spectral evolution is similar to other SNe IIP, except for much lower ejecta velocities at similar epochs They estimate the progenitor mass to be ≤ 15M⊙ based on nebular spectra.
Vera: Photometric Analysis and Modeling The multi-band photometric monitoring revealed that the plateau has typical magnitudes of MV ∼ −15 mag They estimated the plateau length by fitting an analytic function, obtaining a best-fitting value of tPT = 126.54 ± 0.65 days The bolometric light curve analysis indicated an initial peak luminosity of ∼ 3.8×10 41 erg s−1 and a high temperature of ∼ 1.5×10 4 K The tail luminosity implies a 56Ni mass of ∼ 0.009 M⊙.
Jocelyn: Analytical modeling using the Markov Chain Monte Carlo version of the semi-analytic light curve code resulted in an estimated 56Ni mass of ∼ 0.009 M⊙, consistent with the tail bolometric luminosity.
Vera: Spectroscopic Findings and Kinematics The spectra exhibit an early blue continuum that turns red over time During the plateau phase, the Hα emission component becomes increasingly prominent and metal lines emerge, such as Fe ii (λλ 5169, 5018, 4924) and Ca ii infrared (IR) triplet (λλ 8498, 8542, 8662) From t = 37.3 days, a high-velocity Hα absorption feature emerges at −4000 km s−1.
Title and authors: Vera: So we're talking today about this paper, "SN 2024abfl: A Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova in NGC two thousand one hundred forty-six from a Low-Mass Red Supergiant Progenitor <ref:2602.04309#pg1,SN 2024abfl: A Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova in NGC 2146 from>." It’s an interesting case because it helps us figure out the variety in how these Type IIP supernovae actually explode.
Jocelyn: Yeah, this specific supernova is important because it shows us that there are different explosion properties possible for these events than we thought we knew. It's not just one way they happen across the board, right?
Subrahmanyan: Exactly. We've seen the "RSG problem" where stellar models predict certain mass ranges for red supergiants, but what direct detections show is often a different picture, and this paper seems to be probing that gap with SN 2024abfl <ref:2602.04309#pg1>.
Vera: Right. What this paper does is look at the photometry and spectroscopy of SN 2024abfl to constrain its physics <ref:2602.04309#pg1>. They find it’s a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova in the galaxy NGC two thousand one hundred forty-six and they directly detected the red supergiant progenitor star <ref:2602.04309#pg1,a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova in>.
Jocelyn: And what they found about that specific event is that it has a relatively long plateau duration of about one hundred twenty-six point five days, and its plateau luminosity is quite low at magnitude MV around negative fifteen.
Subrahmanyan: That low luminosity and long plateau time immediately tell us something about the explosion itself—it points toward a much lower energy release compared to what we might expect from typical Type IIP events, which is what they are aiming to constrain.
Vera: They use a semi-analytical model to fit the light curve data, and based on that fitting, they estimate a nickel mass of about zero point nine solar masses. That’s quite low for a supernova explosion.
Jocelyn: And they also estimate an initial kinetic energy of about zero point four two foe and an initial thermal energy of about zero point zero three foe, which gives us a picture of the overall explosion dynamics.
Subrahmanyan: Those numbers are key because when you put them together—low nickel mass, low explosion energy—they fall right into the range they define for Low-Luminosity Type IIP supernovae, which is between a nickel mass of zero point zero zero one and zero point two five solar masses and an explosion energy between zero point one and zero point two eight foe.
Vera: And they also estimate the ejecta mass to be about eight point three solar masses, which is what we expect from a progenitor star in that mass range.
Jocelyn: They are also looking at the spectral evolution, which gives us clues about how the material is moving and what elements are present as it expands.
Subrahmanyan: And spectroscopically, they found that while the general spectral evolution is similar to other Type IIP supernovae, they see much lower ejecta velocities at similar epochs.
Vera: But there are some interesting kinematic features they found during the plateau phase, like a high-velocity H alpha absorption feature emerging at negative four thousand two hundred kilometers per second around day thirty-nine point six.
Title and authors: Jocelyn: That high velocity feature suggests something specific is happening in the inner ejecta, and they suggest it could be caused by a plume of matter moving toward us at a higher speed.
Subrahmanyan: And then later on, around day sixty-three point five, they see two emission features appearing at plus or minus two thousand kilometers per second. They suggest these might be caused by some interaction with the circumstellar medium.
Vera: So the paper is using these detailed spectral and photometric constraints to get their final estimates on the progenitor mass.
Jocelyn: And in the nebular phase, they analyze the flux ratio of oxygen lines to calcium lines, specifically O I over Ca II. They find that this ratio is smaller than zero point seven five at day one hundred ninety-six point three.
Subrahmanyan: That low flux ratio is what allows them to estimate the progenitor mass to be less than or equal to fifteen solar masses, which aligns nicely with their direct detection results.
Vera: So, when you look at the overall picture—the low nickel mass, the lower explosion energy, and that progenitor mass constraint—it all fits together well within the Low-Luminosity Supernova IIP category they defined.
Jocelyn: It’s interesting how SN 2024abfl acts as a benchmark for these lower-energy explosions originating from red supergiants <ref:2602.04309#pg1>. It helps narrow down the range of possibilities for these events.
Subrahmanyan: This kind of work is crucial because it connects the observed explosion properties back to the initial mass and evolutionary path of the progenitor star, which feeds directly into our models of stellar evolution and supernova progenitors.
Vera: They are also comparing their results to previous estimates from other studies, like those by Gerard et al. two thousand twenty-six and Das et al. two thousand twenty-five b, and they find their values are consistent within the uncertainties of those previous works.
Jocelyn: It’s good that the constraints on the progenitor mass, which was inferred from nebular spectra, match what they found through direct detection observations of red supergiants in this case.
Subrahmanyan: Consistency across different ways of inferring progenitor properties is always a strong sign for the physical interpretation of these supernova events.
Vera: The main thing here is that this paper solidifies the classification of SN 2024abfl as a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova from a low-mass red supergiant progenitor <ref:2602.04309#pg1,from a low-mass red supergiant progenitor>.
Jocelyn: It’s a clear picture, showing us one specific pathway for these lower energy events in our universe.
Subrahmanyan: This work helps refine the boundaries of what we consider to be LLSNe IIP based on these specific observational constraints.
Vera: So, that wraps up our look at this paper. It's a solid piece of work for constraining the explosion physics of low-luminosity Type IIP supernovae.
Jocelyn: We'll take a quick break and come back to talk about other interesting transients in the sky.
Subrahmanyan: Stick with us, we’ll be right back after this short pause.
The paper's summary: Vera: So, to wrap up what we just talked about, this paper is essentially saying that SN 2024abfl is a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova that came from a very low-mass red supergiant progenitor star located in the galaxy NGC two thousand one hundred forty-six <ref:2602.04309#pg1,a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova>.
Jocelyn: Right. And the main point they’re making here is that this event helps us map out the diversity of explosions for Type IIP supernovae, showing that there isn't just one way these things happen.
Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical side, it’s interesting because it constrains the physics of these low-energy events. We're seeing evidence pointing toward lower nickel mass and lower explosion energy than some other Type IIP models predict for similar progenitors.
Vera: Exactly, and that links back to what we thought about the progenitor star itself. They found that the progenitor mass seems consistent with direct detection results for red supergiants in this case.
Jocelyn: And they use those spectroscopic details—like the oxygen to calcium flux ratio—to nail down that progenitor mass estimate, suggesting it’s at most fifteen solar masses.
Subrahmanyan: That puts it right in that low-mass regime we've been discussing for these events, which is a critical piece of the puzzle for understanding stellar evolution pathways.
Vera: The authors are essentially using this specific supernova as a benchmark to define what we call Low-Luminosity Type IIP supernovae based on these new constraints.
Jocelyn: So, if you’re driving or cooking and you want to know more about these low-energy explosions, this paper shows us exactly what kind of things we should be looking for in the sky.
Subrahmanyan: It opens up new avenues for theoretical modeling because we now have a better case study on how lower explosion energies affect the structure of the ejecta.
Vera: And it also gives us a clearer picture of what's happening inside those envelopes, like those high-velocity features they saw during the plateau phase.
Jocelyn: It’s really about connecting what we see with direct detection observations to our simulations of how stars explode when they die.
Subrahmanyan: The next step would be to use these derived parameters—the nickel mass, the kinetic energy—to test those specific semi-analytical models against other candidates we find.
Vera: That sounds like a solid plan. And it makes you wonder what other low-luminosity events we might find in galaxies beyond NGC two thousand one hundred forty-six that fit this same profile.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we've discussed the main findings of SN 2024abfl and how they help define low-luminosity Type IIP supernovae in this galaxy NGC two thousand one hundred forty-six <ref:2602.04309#pg1>.
Vera: Right. And now we look at what the authors suggest they could do with this work going forward, because that's often where the real science gets started.
Jocelyn: They are pointing toward needing more detailed follow-up observations to really nail down those kinematic features they saw in the spectra, like that high-velocity absorption feature.
Subrahmanyan: From a cosmology perspective, they suggest using these specific explosion parameters—the kinetic energy and ejecta mass—to run simulations of structure formation in low-mass halos.
Vera: They want to use those derived numbers to test whether the explosion energy they found is consistent with models of red supergiant collapse.
Jocelyn: And they are also suggesting that future time-domain observations should focus on catching those emission features, like the ones at plus or minus two thousand kilometers per second, as they evolve.
Subrahmanyan: That would give us crucial data on the interaction between the supernova ejecta and any surrounding circumstellar material from that progenitor star.
Vera: It seems like a roadmap for how to move from just observing one event to building a broader picture of these low-energy explosions.
Jocelyn: Exactly, it moves us toward needing better instruments capable of catching those fast moving features in the early phases of the explosion.
Subrahmanyan: And if we can confirm that these low-mass progenitors are indeed common, it changes how we predict the overall rate of supernova production in galaxies.
Vera: It really shows that even low-luminosity events have complex internal structures, which is something we need to keep looking for in future surveys.
Jocelyn: So the next thing we should be watching is whether these suggestions lead to new observational targets that might reveal more of this diversity in the universe.
Conclusion: Vera: So we've just been walking through the data on SN 2024abfl: A Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova in NGC two thousand one hundred forty-six from a Low-Mass Red Supergiant Progenitor, and it seems like this event really helps us define the boundaries for lower energy explosions <ref:2602.04309#pg1,SN 2024abfl: A Low-Luminosity Type IIP Supernova in NGC>.
Jocelyn: Yeah, the paper’s main takeaway is that this specific supernova provides a strong case study for understanding how low nickel mass and lower explosion energy relate to red supergiant progenitors.
Subrahmanyan: It confirms that these low-energy outcomes aren't just theoretical curiosities; they are observable phenomena linked to specific progenitor conditions like the mass of nine to twelve solar masses.
Vera: And by constraining that progenitor mass so tightly, the authors give us a much clearer handle on what kind of star dies in this way.
Jocelyn: It’s important because it tells us how diverse the explosion physics can be even when starting from a similar stellar type like a red supergiant.
Subrahmanyan: This observation impacts our simulations because we need to incorporate these lower energy scenarios more robustly into our models of galactic evolution.
Vera: So, to wrap up, this study on SN 2024abfl gives us solid observational constraints on the physics of low-luminosity Type IIP supernovae from low-mass progenitors <ref:2602.04309#pg1>.
Jocelyn: It’s a good piece of work because it connects direct detection with detailed spectroscopic evolution to pin down the explosion parameters.
Subrahmanyan: We need more observations like this to see if these constraints hold up when we look at other galaxies or different types of progenitors.
Vera: Exactly, and that opens the door for us to look for more of these faint events in upcoming surveys.
Jocelyn: Next time we talk about a transient event, I want us to keep an eye on those low-luminosity transients that fit this profile we just discussed.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO