Shortest period for outer orbit in compact hierarchical triple? Discovery of SB1 around V0885 Per
summary
The gist
I present a discovery of SB1 in the LAMOST-MRS spectra of eclipsing contact binary V 885 Per Spectroscopic orbit has period only P = 21.8 day…
In short
A third star, SB1, was discovered orbiting V885 Persei with an outer period of 21.8 days, potentially the shortest known outer orbit in a compact hierarchical triple system. Analysis using LAMOST spectra and modeling suggests two possible configurations: a CHT+1 (2+1+1) system where SB1 is bound to the inner pair, or an HQ (2+2) configuration involving another wide binary. The study also addresses time-varying orbital period changes due to magnetic activity or light travel effects.
Key concepts
- SB1
- This refers to a newly discovered third star that orbits the well-known contact binary V885 Persei. Its orbital period is measured at 21.8 days, making it a candidate for the shortest known outer orbit in this type of compact system.
- Hierarchical Triple System
- This describes a complex stellar arrangement where three stars are gravitationally bound, often with one star orbiting another pair. The paper investigates whether the discovered SB1 fits into a specific configuration within this triple structure.
- Time-Varying O’Connell Effect
- This phenomenon refers to gradual changes observed in the orbital period of the inner eclipsing pair over time. These changes are analyzed to determine if they are caused by an additional component, like SB1, or by internal factors such as magnetic activity on the stars.
- Light Time Travel Effect
- This hypothesis suggests that long-term changes in observed orbital periods can be explained by the effect of light traveling through space. This effect might be induced if there is an additional component influencing the system's light path.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Shortest period for outer orbit in compact hierarchical triple? Discovery of SB1 around V0885 Per · Paper Radio
- Model Atmospheres From Very Low Mass Stars to Brown Dwarfs
- Gaia Data Release 3: Summary of the content and survey properties
- Disentangling of spectra - theory and practice
- First double red giant Algol system with active mass transfer · Paper Radio
- LAMOST Medium-Resolution Spectroscopic Survey (LAMOST-MRS): Scientific goals and survey plan
- Fourier Disentangling Using the Technology of Virtual Observatory
The paper
Shortest period for outer orbit in compact hierarchical triple? Discovery of SB1 around V0885 Per · Read on arXiv
Mikhail Yu. Kovalev, Anton Valentinovich Khruslov
International Centre of Supernovae · Yunnan Key Laboratory · Yunnan Observatories · Chinese Academy of Sciences
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Shortest period for outer orbit in compact hierarchical triple? Discovery of SB1 around V0885 Per".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. I present a discovery of SB1 in the LAMOST-MRS spectra of eclipsing contact binary V 885 Per Spectroscopic orbit has period only P = 21.8 day, which will make it shortest known outer period in compact hierarchical triple system, if this SB1 is indeed bound to the inner system Unfortunately quality of available spectra don’t allow to give definitive answer to this question, with other orbital hierarchy like 2+2 is also possible Discovery and Orbital Period The paper reports the discovery of a third star, SB1, orbiting the well-known W UMa system V 885 Persei with an outer period of approximately Pout ∼ 21.8 days This period is noted as potentially the shortest known outer period in a compact hierarchical triple system if SB1 is bound to the inner system The authors detected SB1 in LAMOST medium resolution spectra using methods similar to Kovalev et al.
Vera: (2025) The spectroscopic orbit derived for SB1 has a period of P = 21.811 ± 0.001 days, with an eccentricity eB = 0.39 Data Analysis and Modeling The analysis involved multiple techniques to constrain the system parameters, including spectroscopy, light curve modeling, and spectral energy distribution fitting Spectroscopy The LAMOST MRS spectra were analyzed using a binary spectral model with two iterations The narrow-lined component contributes from one third to one half of total light, which is consistent with light curve (LC) based on ASAS-SN g band photometry The good quality of RV from the narrow lined component allows direct determination of SB1 orbit W-D Model The Wilson-Devinney code was used to fit the light curve and RVs for an inner contact system Fitted parameters for differential correction program include dimensionless potential omega, primary bandpass luminosity L1 and third light contribution L3 SED Fit The Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) was fitted using SEDFit code to archive photometry from VizieR The best fit parameters include a distance d = 335 pc, and effective temperatures Teff Aa,Ab,B = 5000, 5143, 5050 K Hierarchical System Configurations The results suggest two competing hierarchical configurations to explain the observed time-varying O’Connell effect 1.
Jocelyn: CHT+1 (2+1+1 configuration): This configuration suggests that star B with SB1 period of PB = 21.8 day is likely bound to the eclipsing system V 885 Per 2.
Vera: HQ (2+2 configuration): This alternative explanation involves star B orbiting another star, such as G4474, which seems to form a wide binary with V 885 Per The study concludes that the SB1 solution is consistent with results from spectral disentangling While the quality of available spectra does not allow for a clear detection of reflex motion for the barycenter of the inner contact system, future high-resolution spectroscopic observations scheduled around periastron passage will be very useful to confirm this finding Very large RUWE=19 gives hope that future data from Gaia DR4 will be very useful for analysis of V 885 Per, since the detection of astrometric orbit consistent with P = 21.8 day will be a strong evidence for V 885 Per being CHT Alternatively, an astrometric orbit with a large period could support a hierarchical quadruple configuration The inner contact binary shows time variable O’Connel effect, indicating strong magnetic activity Data Availability LAMOST spectra are available on lamost.org/dr11 Photometric datasets were downloaded from publicly available archives Supporting materials like radial velocities and outputs for VOKOREL runs including fitting logs have been uploaded to author webpage mkuasbest.github.io/webpage/v885per.zip Facilities include LAMOST, TESS, ASAS-SN, and SuperWASP The work is supported by International Centre of Supernovae (ICESUN), Yunnan Key Laboratory of Supernova Research (No.
Paper summary: Vera: So, we're looking at this paper now called "Shortest period for outer orbit in compact hierarchical triple? Discovery of SB1 around V eight hundred eighty-five Per" <ref:2604.20314#pg1,Discovery of SB1 around V 885 Per>. The main thing they're claiming is that they found a third star, SB1, orbiting the eclipsing contact binary V eight hundred eighty-five Per with an orbital period of only P equals twenty-one point eight day <ref:2604.20314#pg1,eclipsing contact binary V 885 Per>.
Jocelyn: That sounds really tight for an outer orbit, Vera. They say this would make it the shortest known outer period in a compact hierarchical triple system if SB1 is actually bound to that inner system. But they also add a bit of a caution there about other possibilities, like a two plus two configuration being possible too.
Subrahmanyan: A twenty-one point eight day period for an outer orbit is definitely interesting in the context of these compact hierarchical triples because those systems are often very tightly packed and hard to find, Subrahmanyan adds that this finding hinges on the assumption that SB1 is indeed bound to the inner system <ref:2604.20314#pg1,SB1 is indeed bound to the inner system>.
Vera: Right, and they did use LAMOST medium resolution spectra to find this third star. They derived a spectroscopic orbit for SB1 with a period of P equals twenty-one point eight one one plus or minus zero point one days and an eccentricity eB equal to zero point three nine <ref:2604.20314#pg2>.
Jocelyn: That measurement comes from analyzing the narrow-lined component in the LAMOST MRS spectra, which they say has good quality radial velocities that allow for a direct determination of the SB1 orbit. But they admit that the overall RV measurements have low precision because of very broad lines and low signal to noise of residual spectra.
Subrahmanyan: So, while they got this specific period from the narrow line data, they’re acknowledging that those other two components of the system have lower quality RVs, which limits how much they can constrain the inner system parameters.
Vera: They did use multiple techniques to put everything together—spectroscopy for orbits, light curve modeling, and spectral energy distribution fitting. In terms of spectroscopy, they analyzed the LAMOST MRS spectra using a binary spectral model with two iterations. The narrow-lined component contributes from one third to one half of the total light, which they say is consistent with what we see in the light curve based on ASAS-SN g band photometry.
Paper summary: Jocelyn: And when modeling, they used the Wilson-Devinney code to fit both the light curve and those radial velocities for an inner contact system. They also fitted a spectral energy distribution using SEDFit code to archive photometry from VizieR. The best fit parameters there include a distance d equal to three hundred thirty-five parsecs, and effective temperatures for the stars being five thousand five thousand one hundred forty-three and five thousand fifty Kelvin <ref:2604.20314#pg3>.
Subrahmanyan: That distance of three hundred thirty-five parsecs is a concrete number for the location of this system in space <ref:2604.20314#pg3>. Connecting this to the larger picture, Subrahmanyan thinks that if this structure is real, it pushes the limits on how compact these hierarchical triples can get before they break apart.
Vera: And then they looked at what those different orbital configurations might mean for time-varying O’Connell effect. They suggested two competing hierarchical configurations to explain those time-varying effects. First, they suggest a CHT plus one configuration, which implies star B with the twenty point one eight day period is likely bound to the eclipsing system V eight hundred eighty-five Per <ref:2604.20314#pg1>.
Jocelyn: And their second suggestion is an HQ configuration, which involves star B orbiting another star like G4474, suggesting that this wide binary might be what's causing things to change over time. They also mentioned that analysis of eclipse timing variations showed a gradual increase in the orbital period of the inner eclipsing pair, as well as long-term changes.
Subrahmanyan: That time travel effect they mentioned could be explained either by an additional component or by magnetic activity affecting the system’s dynamics. From a theoretical standpoint, Subrahmanyan thinks this ties directly into how external perturbations influence the orbital evolution of these compact systems.
Vera: The study concludes that the SB1 solution is consistent with results from spectral disentangling. But they also admit a limitation: because of the quality of available spectra, they don't allow for a clear detection of reflex motion for the barycenter of the inner contact system. They also point out that future high-resolution spectroscopic observations scheduled around periastron passage will be very useful to confirm this finding.
Jocelyn: It also mentions that a very large RUWE equal to nineteen gives hope that future data from Gaia DR4 will be useful for analyzing V eight hundred eighty-five Per, since the detection of an astrometric orbit consistent with a period of twenty point one eight day would be strong evidence for V eight hundred eighty-five Per being CHT <ref:2604.20314#pg1>.
Paper summary: Subrahmanyan: And if that astrometric orbit has a large period, it could support a hierarchical quadruple configuration instead of just the compact triple they initially looked at. This is an important piece because it tells us about the possible complexity of these stellar groupings in our galaxy.
Vera: So, to wrap up this paper "Shortest period for outer orbit in compact hierarchical triple? Discovery of SB1 around V eight hundred eighty-five Per", the authors found a third star, SB1, with an outer orbit period of twenty-one point eight day around V eight hundred eighty-five Per <ref:2604.20314#pg1,Discovery of SB1 around V 885 Per>. They found this result consistent with spectral disentangling but they stress that the quality of spectra means they can't confirm reflex motion for the inner system barycenter yet.
Jocelyn: And Subrahmanyan thinks this finding forces us to consider two different hierarchical setups, a compact triple plus one star, or a wider two plus two setup. The key thing to keep in mind is that while the twenty-one point eight day period is promising for being short, the uncertainty in the data quality means we can't definitively rule out those other possibilities right now <ref:2604.20314#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: Exactly, and what this means for cosmology is that finding an inner system with such a tight outer orbit puts a very specific constraint on how many stars can be packed into that kind of structure before they become unstable or change their orbits dramatically. We need better astrometric data to settle whether it's the CHT configuration or something more complex like a quadruple system.
Vera: And for us observing this, Jocelyn, the next step seems to be waiting for those high-resolution spectroscopic observations around periastron passage. That’s where we hope to get that definitive confirmation of the orbital motion.
Jocelyn: Right, and if we get a good astrometric orbit with that twenty-one point eight day period, that's a huge piece of evidence for V eight hundred eighty-five Per being CHT, which would be pretty significant for understanding these compact systems <ref:2604.20314#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: And the long-term changes they observed in the O’Connell effect, whether explained by light time travel or magnetic activity, are what Subrahmanyan thinks we need to watch closely with future observations to connect back to our models of structure formation.
Conclusion: Vera: So we're wrapping up this look at V eight hundred eighty-five Persei and that new star, SB1, found in the LAMOST spectra and how it fits into the bigger picture of hierarchical systems.
Jocelyn: Right, so to put it simply, they found a third star orbiting that contact binary with a period of twenty-one point eight days. That's what they're calling SB1.
Subrahmanyan: And that period is significant because if SB1 is bound to the inner system, this would be the shortest outer orbit we’ve seen in a compact hierarchical triple.
Vera: It’s a really tight number for an outer orbit in a compact system, but they have to be careful about how they get that result from the data.
Jocelyn: They did use LAMOST MRS spectra and derived an orbital period of twenty-one point eight one one plus or minus zero point zero zero one days for SB1.
Subrahmanyan: And that measurement comes from analyzing the narrow-lined component in those spectra, which they say gives them good radial velocities.
Vera: I'm interested in what that means for the structure of these systems, because it pushes the limits on how compact they can actually be before things break apart.
Jocelyn: They are also suggesting two different ways this system could be organized hierarchically to explain some other changes they saw over time.
Subrahmanyan: Two plus one plus one versus a two plus two configuration, which means this finding doesn't tell us the whole story about how these stars are arranged.
Vera: So what does that mean for the overall picture of V eight hundred eighty-five Persei? It shows there’s more complexity than just the binary we usually see.
Jocelyn: And they are waiting on some future high-resolution spectroscopy around periastron passage to get a clearer look at the inner system's motion.
Subrahmanyan: That astrometric data, if we get it, will be crucial because it could confirm this structure or show us a different kind of configuration entirely.
Vera: We’ll see if that Gaia DR4 data comes through and gives us the period we need to settle this down.
Jocelyn: And that's where our next talk is going to be, seeing what those follow-up observations reveal about these orbital dynamics.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO