Sailing with the winds of HL Tau: the JWST view
summary
The gist
The paper provides a first overview of Cycle 3 James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) program targeting HL Tau…
In short
JWST observations of HL Tau revealed a stratified outflow system with distinct jet and wind components. The findings suggest a magnetically driven disk-wind scenario where different structures originate at varying distances from the star. The inner disk chemistry shows a complex water distribution, indicating pebble drift enrichment in the outer regions.
Key concepts
- Stratified Outflow
- The outflow system has distinct layers or components, such as atomic jets and molecular winds, with different kinematics and chemical properties. This layering suggests that these structures are not uniform but arise from different physical processes occurring at various locations within the system.
- Magnetically Driven Disk-Wind Scenario
- This model proposes that the outflow is driven by magnetic fields originating in the disk. In this scenario, distinct components of the wind—like jets and winds—are launched from different radii within the disk, leading to their observed stratification and varying velocities.
- Water Emission Lines
- Observations of water molecules in the inner disk spectrum show a rich forest of rotational lines dominated by cold-warm emission. A three-component model fits these lines, revealing excitation temperatures suggesting distinct thermal conditions for different regions within the disk structure.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
The paper
Sailing with the winds of HL Tau: the JWST view · Read on arXiv
T. Nony, F. Bacciotti, C. Dougados, M.G. Navarro, B. Nisini, P. Kavanagh, A. Banzatti, V. Delabrosse, L., , , , , ,
Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Bordeaux, University of Bordeaux, CNRS · INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri, INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CNRS IPAG · Department of Physics, Maynooth University · Texas State University · PSL University Sorbonne Université Observatoire de Paris LERMA CNRS UMR 8112 · INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte, INAF - Istituto di Radioastronomia, Bologna
Studying protostellar ejections is crucial to understanding the formation of young stars and planetary systems. The Class I/II star HL Tau, with its ringed disk and prominent bipolar outflows, is a benchmark system for these studies. We provide a first overview of our Cycle 3 JWST program targeting HL Tau, focusing on the morphology and kinematics of the various wind components as well as on the water emission lines excited in the inner disk. Our observations cover the 1.66-28 μ m spectral range, combining NIRSpec and MIRI MRS mosaics to map the inner 10" of the red-shifted lobe of the outflow and the base of the blue-shifted lobe. In the red-shifted lobe we observe a stratified wind of three nested layers: a fast, highly collimated atomic jet structured in a chain of eight knots and with radial velocities of 160 km/s; a wide-angle H 2 wind with velocities of 45 km/s exhibiting complex arc-like substructures; and a warm gas shell, of radial velocity of 35 km/s, visible in low-excitation transitions of CO (ν =1-0). This CO shell appears co-spatial with the CO (J=2-1) emission detected by ALMA with velocities from 3 to 25 km/s. In the first 1" of the blue-shifted lobe we detect a similar stratification, but the jet is faster and less collimated. The observed stratification and kinematics of the flow may support a magnetically driven disk-wind scenario in which the distinct components originate in the disk at progressively larger distances from the star. However, while the external components observed in CO have the laminar and regular appearance predicted for such winds, the knots in the inner jet and the arcs in the wind could be the manifestation of a pulsed ejection mechanism. Additionally, in MIRI spectra taken at the star position we detect a forest of water lines dominated by cold-to-warm (< 500 K) gas. Their distribution suggests an extended reservoir of sublimated ices.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Sailing with the winds of HL Tau: the JWST view".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper provides a first overview of Cycle 3 James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) program targeting HL Tau, focusing on the morphology and kinematics of various wind components as well as on water emission lines excited in the inner disk The observed stratification and kinematics of the flow may support a magnetically driven disk-wind scenario in which the distinct components originate in the disk at progressively larger distances from the star Observational Strategy The JWST observations were conducted using NIRSpec and MIRI covering the 1.66–28 µm spectral range, combining a 2×2 NIRSpec mosaic and a 2×(1×2) MIRI MRS mosaic to map the inner 10" of the red-shifted lobe of the outflow and the base of the blue-shifted lobe The MIRI MRS mode adopted for the observations uses four IFU channels, to continuously cover the spectral range between 4.9 and 27.9 µm The NIRSpec IFU data were acquired using a 2×2 mosaic (with V3 PA of 80◦), covering a total Field of View (FoV) of 5′′ × 4′′ The total FoV varies from about 6′′ × 6′′ (Channel 1) to 10'' × 10'' (with a 10% overlap) Jet Morphology and Kinematics The atomic jet shines in a large number of atomic forbidden emission lines of various species, with a significant variation in luminosity among the different tracers In the red-shifted lobe, the jet exhibits a knotty structure, with at least eight well-identified knots, separated by about 0.7′′ on average, and average radial velocities of about 160 km s−1 The jet appears strongly collimated, with a semi-opening angle of 1◦ The base of the jet, estimated geometrically, suggests an origin within an upper limit of 10 au from the star The blue-shifted jet appears faster and less collimated than the redshifted jet in the first 1′, with a velocity of ∼ −175 km s−1 and a wider initial opening angle (5◦) Molecular Wind Structure The H2 wind is revealed in a total of 38 rotational and ro-vibrational transitions, with average radial velocities of 45 km s−1 (red-shifted) and 19 km s−1 (blue-shifted) The H2 wind reveals a complex internal structure of arc-like features and bubbles, with higher excitation on the inner side toward the star, consistent with expanding shells The tip of the H2 arcs is in some cases close to the position of jet knots, which may suggest an interpretation in terms of propagating bow shocks Inner Disk Chemistry The MIRI spectrum of HL Tau extracted toward the star reveals a rich forest of rotational and ro-vibrational water lines, dominated by cold-warm (≤500 K) emission A three-component slab model fits the water lines, indicating excitation temperatures of ∼820 K, ∼440 K, and ∼220 K for the hot, warm, and cold components, respectively The prominent cold water excess suggests an extended disk region (possibly up to a radius of 26 au) enriched by inward drift and sublimation of icy pebbles The outflow system driven by HL Tau presents a stratified chemical and kinematical structure, commonly seen in many other young sources Such a layered structure could be consistent with a continuous magnetically driven disk wind (Blandford & Payne 1982; Ray & Ferreira 2021) The available information, however, could also be compatible with a scenario in which the layered structure revealed by JWST originates from the interaction of an X-wind or a pulsed jet, with an outer cold disk wind revealed by ALMA (Bacciotti et al.
Vera: 2025) The first analysis of the JWST observations of HL Tau already appears to provide interesting constraints on the launching, collimation, and feedback of protostellar winds, as well as on the inner disk physics Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The jet exhibits a knotty structure with at least eight well-identified knots, separated by about 0.7′′ on average The average space velocity of the jet is 230 km s−1 The base of the jet, estimated geometrically, suggests an origin within an upper limit of 10 au from the star How the training signal is built The radial velocities determined for all the lines detected in the spectrum in Fig.
Jocelyn: 4 and for representative lines in the AB knot of the blue-shifted jet result in an average radial velocity of about 157 km s−1 and-172 km s−1, respectively The average radial velocity between the lines, weighted by the uncertainty, is about 157 km s−1 and-172 km s−1 in the redand blue-shifted jet, respectively Where the gains come from The cold component of CO outflow observed with ALMA extends beyond the warm CO and has a radial velocity of only 3 to 20 km s−1 The excitation temperature T ∼ 820 K, N ∼ 1018 cm−2, and Req ∼ 1 au for the hot component, T ∼ 440 K, N ∼ 2×10 18 cm−2, and Req ∼ 2.3 au for the warm component The cold component gives T ∼ 260 K, N ∼ 5 × 10 15 cm−2, and Req ∼ 26 au The prominent cold water excess suggests an extended disk region (possibly up to a radius of 26 au) enriched by inward drift and sublimation of icy pebbles The ALMA best-fit model produces IR lines that are factors of ∼ 3–30 stronger than observed (even if we limit the model to the inner 15 au), while the MIRI+PACS best-fit model produces millimeter lines that are factors of ∼ 100–1000 weaker The very prominent “cold excess" emission observed in HL Tau may have the origin proposed for other disks: the enrichment of water vapor by inward drift and sublimation of icy pebbles from the outer disk The inner dust gap detected at 13 au (ALMA Partnership et al.
Vera: 2015), however, would not be expected to deliver a large icy mass to the inner region where pebbles sublimate at the closest distance to the star reached by the midplane snowline (proposed to be within 6 au, Leemker et al.
Title and authors: Vera: So we're looking at this paper now called "Sailing with the winds of HL Tau: the JWST view," and it’s about using the James Webb Space Telescope to really see what's happening in that outflow system around HL Tau. It focuses on mapping out the shape and motion of all these different wind parts, plus those water emission lines in the inner disk.
Jocelyn: Right, so it’s not just one view; it’s a deep dive into how layered this outflow is and how fast everything is moving within those structures. It’s really trying to figure out if that stratification points toward a magnetically driven disk-wind scenario where the different parts come from the disk at progressively farther distances from the star.
Subrahmanyan: That idea of stratification, Vera, it connects directly to structure formation theory. If you see distinct components originating at different radii, that implies a mechanism governing how material moves through the disk and launches these outflows, which is a key question for us in cosmology.
Vera: Exactly. The observation strategy involved using NIRSpec and MIRI over the one point six six to twenty-eight micrometer range, combining different mosaics to map out the inner ten arcseconds of that red-shifted lobe and the base of the blue-shifted lobe.
Jocelyn: And they used a MIRI MRS mode with four IFU channels, covering spectral ranges from four point nine to twenty seven point nine micrometers, which is pretty comprehensive for seeing those molecular signatures.
Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical standpoint, that combination of high spectral and angular resolution is what’s needed to resolve the fine details of the morphology you're talking about.
Vera: Moving on to the jet itself, they found that the atomic jet shows up in a lot of different atomic forbidden emission lines from various species, and there's a big change in brightness between those tracers.
Jocelyn: In that red-shifted lobe, the jet has this knotty structure with at least eight well-identified knots spaced about zero point seven arcseconds apart on average, and the average radial velocities for those are about one hundred sixty kilometers per second.
Subrahmanyan: A velocity of one hundred sixty kilometers per second gives us a sense of the bulk motion within that specific part of the outflow. How does that compare to what we might expect from MHD simulations?
Vera: The jet itself looks strongly collimated, with a semi-opening angle around one degree, and geometrically estimating the base suggests its origin is within an upper limit of ten astronomical units from the star.
Jocelyn: But then you look at the blue-shifted jet, it appears faster and less collimated than the red-shifted jet in the first arcsecond, with a velocity of about negative one hundred seventy five kilometers per second and a wider initial opening angle of five degrees.
Title and authors: Subrahmanyan: That difference in kinematics between the two lobes suggests something complex is happening at the launch point, maybe different magnetic field geometries or interaction with surrounding material.
Vera: Now let's shift to the molecular wind, they revealed that there’s this hydrogen two wind showing up in thirty-eight rotational and ro vibrational transitions.
Jocelyn: The average radial velocities for that H2 wind are about forty five kilometers per second on the red-shifted side and nineteen kilometers per second on the blue-shifted side.
Subrahmanyan: Those velocities are quite slow compared to the atomic jet, suggesting a different energy source or driving mechanism for that molecular outflow component.
Vera: The H2 wind reveals this complex internal structure of arc like features and bubbles, and it seems more excited on the inner side toward the star, which is consistent with expanding shells.
Jocelyn: And interesting thing is that the tips of these H2 arcs are in some cases close to where those jet knots are located, which might suggest an interpretation involving propagating bow shocks.
Subrahmanyan: That connection between the molecular structure and the atomic jet features would be a powerful constraint for modeling how momentum is transferred from the disk wind into the fast jet component.
Vera: Then we get to the inner disk chemistry using MIRI, which extracted toward HL Tau shows a rich forest of rotational and ro vibrational water lines, dominated by cold warm emission under five hundred Kelvin.
Jocelyn: They fit this with a three component slab model for the water lines, indicating excitation temperatures of about eight hundred twenty Kelvin for the hot component, four hundred forty Kelvin for the warm component, and two hundred twenty Kelvin for the cold one.
Subrahmanyan: That temperature structure—hot to warm to cold—that’s exactly what you see in many evolved disks where different material resides at different thermal conditions.
Vera: The prominent cold water excess suggests an extended disk region possibly up to a radius of twenty six astronomical units, enriched by inward drift and sublimation of icy pebbles.
Jocelyn: That cold component is key because it implies a lot of material is out there, potentially up to twenty six astronomical units away from the star.
Subrahmanyan: But we have to be careful about that size; if those pebbles sublimate at the closest distance, which is maybe within six astronomical units based on some models, then the disk wouldn't really be enriched by that cold water at that inner region.
Vera: That’s a valid point, because ALMA data suggests a very prominent cold water excess compared to other disks of similar age.
Title and authors: Jocelyn: And they compare their model results with ALMA, finding the MIRI plus PACS best fit produces millimeter lines that are factors of one hundred to one thousand weaker than what ALMA produces.
Subrahmanyan: That discrepancy between the infrared and millimeter measurements is a significant challenge for us when trying to constrain the total icy mass budget in these systems.
Vera: The paper suggests that this prominent cold water excess could require either a more massive disk, a leaky inner gap, or simply an earlier and stronger phase of pebble drift into the inner region.
Jocelyn: It’s interesting how they frame it as those three possibilities to explain the observation.
Subrahmanyan: If we consider those dynamical models that include dust evolution, they find that inner disk gaps are usually the most efficient in regulating inflow of icy pebbles, which could prevent the disk from being strongly enriched by cold water vapor at the snowline depending on how leaky that gap is to those icy solids.
Vera: So it sounds like this JWST study gives us strong constraints on both the launching and collimation of protostellar winds, and also puts pressure on how we model pebble drift in the inner disk.
Jocelyn: It does provide interesting constraints on the launching, collimation, and feedback of protostellar winds, as well as on the inner disk physics around HL Tau.
Subrahmanyan: I think this first analysis of the JWST observations of HL Tau already provides some interesting constraints on the launching, collimation, and feedback of protostellar winds.
Vera: Before we wrap up this session on "Sailing with the winds of HL Tau: the JWST view," it’s been fascinating to see how these distinct kinematic and chemical layers line up.
Jocelyn: I agree; seeing that stratified structure is really important for testing those magnetically driven disk wind scenarios we discussed earlier.
Subrahmanyan: And that stratification is what ties all these observations together into a single, complex physical picture of the system’s evolution.
Vera: So, to wrap up this paper and its implications, it shows us that outflows aren't simple things; they have distinct layers driven by different physics at different radii.
Jocelyn: It really highlights how important high spectral resolution observations from JWST are for peeling back these layers of information.
Subrahmanyan: And the comparison between the IR and millimeter data on the water lines gives us a real test to see if our current disk evolution models can account for that cold excess.
Vera: That’s what we’ll be thinking about as we look at future observations to settle these questions about pebble drift versus gap leakage.
Jocelyn: And next time, we'll talk about those other interesting papers on arXiv that are keeping us busy.
The paper's summary: Jocelyn: What’s interesting here is how they see this stratification in the flow and kinematics. It suggests that these distinct parts might be coming from different places in the disk at progressively larger distances from the star.
Subrahmanyan: That idea of a layered structure, Jocelyn, it really supports a magnetically driven disk-wind scenario where those different components originate in the disk at progressively larger distances.
Vera: And they used NIRSpec and MIRI over a wide range of wavelengths to map out the inner ten arcseconds of that red-shifted lobe and the base of the blue-shifted lobe, which is how they got these initial views.
Jocelyn: They look at the atomic jet, and it shows this knotty structure with at least eight well-identified knots in the red-shifted lobe, separated by about zero point seven arcseconds on average.
Vera: And those knots have average radial velocities of about one hundred sixty kilometers per second. That gives us a baseline for how fast that material is moving through the jet.
Subrahmanyan: That velocity scale helps us put constraints on the driving mechanism, Vera, because it tells us what kind of momentum transfer is happening at that launch point.
Jocelyn: Then you look at the molecular wind, and they find hydrogen two wind showing up in thirty-eight rotational and ro vibrational transitions.
Vera: And those H2 winds have average radial velocities of about forty five kilometers per second on the red-shifted side and nineteen kilometers per second on the blue-shifted side.
Subrahmanyan: That difference in molecular velocity is important because it suggests a different energy source or driving mechanism for that molecular outflow component compared to the fast atomic jet.
Jocelyn: They also see complex internal structure in that H2 wind, with arc like features and bubbles, and those tips are sometimes close to where those jet knots are located.
Vera: That connection between the molecular structure and the atomic jet features might suggest an interpretation involving propagating bow shocks.
Subrahmanyan: If that’s true, it’s a crucial piece of evidence for modeling how momentum gets transferred from the disk wind into the fast jet component.
Jocelyn: The inner disk chemistry is where they get really detailed with MIRI, showing a rich forest of rotational and ro vibrational water lines toward the star.
Vera: They fit this with a three component slab model for those water lines, giving us excitation temperatures of eight hundred twenty Kelvin for the hot component, four hundred forty Kelvin for the warm one, and two hundred twenty Kelvin for the cold one.
Subrahmanyan: That temperature structure—hot to warm to cold—that’s exactly what you see in many evolved disks where different material resides at different thermal conditions.
Jocelyn: And they highlight a prominent cold water excess, which they suggest points toward an extended disk region possibly up to twenty six astronomical units away, enriched by inward drift and sublimation of icy pebbles.
Vera: That cold component is key because it implies a lot of material is out there, potentially up to twenty six astronomical units away from the star.
Subrahmanyan: But we have to be careful about that size; if those pebbles sublimate at the closest distance, which is maybe within six astronomical units based on some models, then the disk wouldn't really be enriched by that cold water at that inner region.
Jocelyn: That’s a valid point because they compare their model results with ALMA data and find a big discrepancy between what they predict for millimeter lines and what ALMA actually sees.
Vera: So it sounds like this JWST study gives us strong constraints on both the launching and collimation of protostellar winds, and also puts pressure on how we model pebble drift in the inner disk.
Subrahmanyan: I think this first analysis of the JWST observations already provides some interesting constraints on the launching, collimation, and feedback of protostellar winds around HL Tau.
Jocelyn: Seeing that stratified structure is really important for testing those magnetically driven disk wind scenarios we discussed earlier.
Vera: And that stratification is what ties all these observations together into a single, complex physical picture of the system’s evolution.
Subrahmanyan: So, to wrap up this paper and its implications, it shows us that outflows aren't simple things; they have distinct layers driven by different physics at different radii.
Jocelyn: It really highlights how important high spectral resolution observations from JWST are for peeling back these layers of information.
Vera: And the comparison between the infrared and millimeter data on the water lines gives us a real test to see if our current disk evolution models can account for that cold excess.
Subrahmanyan: That’s what we’ll be thinking about as we look at future observations to settle these questions about pebble drift versus gap leakage.
The paper's improvements: Jocelyn: So, looking at how they did it, they suggest that to really nail these stratified outflows, they need to integrate data from multiple spectral lines like iron plus iron plus manganese plus argon in the atomic jet.
Vera: That’s right; integrating those different atomic tracers would give us a much better picture of that knotty structure and how fast those parts are actually moving.
Subrahmanyan: And that would let us test hypotheses about the physical origin of those knots, like whether it's a pulsed ejection mechanism or maybe a laminar magnetohydrodynamic flow heated by ambipolar diffusion.
Jocelyn: That’s interesting because comparing the atomic jet features to the molecular hydrogen arc structures could really help us figure out that dynamical relationship.
Vera: And for the inner disk physics, they suggest fitting those water rotational line spectra with a three component slab model, which gives us excitation temperatures and column densities for hot, warm, and cold parts.
Subrahmanyan: That temperature structure—hot to warm to cold—that’s exactly what you see in many evolved disks where different material resides at different thermal conditions.
Jocelyn: And they also suggest comparing the spatial distribution and excitation conditions of warm water with cold water and hydrogen two zero zero S nine lines, which points toward potential non-LTE effects like infrared or ultraviolet pumping for the warmer component.
Vera: That’s a great point because it moves us beyond just measuring temperatures to understanding how those molecules are actually being excited in that environment.
Subrahmanyan: And they evaluate the potential influence of disk evolution on water vapor enrichment by comparing the best fit model results, suggesting that a prominent cold water excess requires either a more massive disk, a leaky inner gap, or an earlier and stronger phase of pebble drift into the inner region.
Jocelyn: So if those pebbles don't get delivered to the innermost region because of a leaky gap, that could prevent the disk from being strongly enriched by cold water vapor at the snowline.
Vera: It’s a key limitation they admit; their method can constrain the structure but doesn't fully resolve the physical process causing that pebble drift or gap leakage.
Subrahmanyan: That leaves us with a clear path forward, Vera: next time, we need to look at ALMA data again to see if those gap models can actually explain that cold water excess they are seeing.
Conclusion: Jocelyn: So, to wrap up this look at HL Tau using the JWST, they’ve shown how this outflow system is really stratified chemically and kinematically, which suggests a layered structure driven by different physics at different radii.
Vera: Exactly. It points toward that continuous magnetically driven disk wind scenario where the distinct components originate in the disk at progressively larger distances from the star.
Subrahmanyan: That stratification is key for cosmology because it tells us how momentum and material are distributed across a system, which is vital for understanding structure formation in general.
Jocelyn: They also found that this layered structure could be consistent with an X-wind or a pulsed jet scenario interacting with an outer cold disk wind revealed by ALMA.
Vera: And the data they collected, the full paper "Sailing with the winds of HL Tau: the JWST view," gives us some strong constraints on launching, collimation, and feedback of protostellar winds.
Subrahmanyan: I think that first analysis already provides some interesting constraints on those launching and collimation issues.
Jocelyn: It’s fascinating how they connect these disparate observations—the fast jet, the slow molecular wind, and the inner disk chemistry—into one coherent picture.
Vera: Seeing that stratification is really important for testing those magnetically driven disk wind scenarios we discussed earlier.
Subrahmanyan: That stratification is what ties all these observations together into a single, complex physical picture of the system’s evolution.
Jocelyn: It really highlights how important high spectral resolution observations from JWST are for peeling back these layers of information.
Vera: And the comparison between the infrared and millimeter data on the water lines gives us a real test to see if our current disk evolution models can account for that cold excess.
Subrahmanyan: That’s what we’ll be thinking about as we look at future observations to settle those questions about pebble drift versus gap leakage.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO