Probing the Seed Effect of Supermassive Primordial Black Holes with Weak Gravitational Lensing
summary
The gist
We investigate the cosmological implications of supermassive primordial black holes (PBHs) as a component of dark matter (DM)…
In short
The study investigates supermassive primordial black holes (PBHs) as dark matter seeds, focusing on their 'seed effect' where PBHs accrete surrounding matter to form dense DM spikes. Using weak gravitational lensing data from DES Y3, the research found that these structures enhance the matter power spectrum and placed stringent upper limits on the abundance of supermassive PBHs, showing constraints are stronger for larger PBH masses.
Key concepts
- Seed Effect
- This effect occurs when individual massive PBHs act as gravitational seeds. They attract surrounding dark matter, causing it to clump into dense 'DM spikes' and forming 'dressed PBHs.' These structures create nonlinear gravity effects that significantly boost the matter power spectrum on small scales, unlike the simpler Poisson effect.
- Matter Power Spectrum P(k)
- This describes how the density of matter in the universe is distributed across different spatial scales (wavenumbers, k). The presence of dressed PBHs modifies this spectrum, especially at small scales. Researchers use this modification to constrain how many supermassive PBHs exist and what their mass distribution might be.
- Weak Gravitational Lensing
- This technique measures the subtle distortion in the shapes of distant galaxies caused by intervening dark matter structures. By analyzing these distortions, researchers can probe the small-scale matter distribution generated by the seed effect, providing a sensitive way to constrain PBH abundance and mass.
- Dressed PBHs
- These are supermassive PBHs that have grown by accreting surrounding dark matter. They are not just bare black holes but are surrounded by extended DM halos and exhibit steep, concentrated density profiles often called 'DM spikes.' These structures are the physical manifestation of the seed effect.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Probing the Seed Effect of Supermassive Primordial Black Holes with Weak Gravitational Lensing · Paper Radio
- Black hole formation and slow-roll inflation
- Primordial Black Holes
- New cosmological constraints on primordial black holes
- Primordial Black Holes as All Dark Matter
- Effects of Critical Collapse on Primordial Black-Hole Mass Spectra
- PBH Dark Matter in Supergravity Inflation Models
- Primordial black holes from supersymmetry in the early universe
- Did LIGO detect dark matter?
- A Preferred Mass Range for Primordial Black Hole Formation and Black Holes as Dark Matter Revisited
- Primordial Black Holes for the LIGO Events in the Axion-like Curvaton Model
- Gravitational Wave signatures of inflationary models from Primordial Black Hole Dark Matter
- Inflationary Primordial Black Holes as All Dark Matter
- Primordial Black Hole Dark Matter and LIGO/Virgo Merger Rate from Inflation with Running Spectral Indices: Formation in the Matter- and/or Radiation-Dominated Universe
- Primordial Black Holes from Inflaton Fragmentation into Oscillons
- Primordial black holes from the QCD epoch: Linking dark matter, baryogenesis and anthropic selection
- Constraints on Primordial Black Holes
- Primordial black holes from long-range scalar forces and scalar radiative cooling
- Exploring Primordial Black Holes from the Multiverse with Optical Telescopes
- Primordial Black Holes as a dark matter candidate
- A brief review on primordial black holes as dark matter
The paper
Probing the Seed Effect of Supermassive Primordial Black Holes with Weak Gravitational Lensing · Read on arXiv
Division of Science, National Astronomical Observatory of Japan · Department of Astronomy, The University of Tokyo · Department of Astronomical Science, The Graduate University for Advanced Studies (SOKENDAI) · Theory Center, IPNS, KEK · Kavli Institute for Particle Physics and Cosmology (WPI), The University of Tokyo
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Probing the Seed Effect of Supermassive Primordial Black Holes with Weak Gravitational Lensing".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. We investigate the cosmological implications of supermassive primordial black holes (PBHs) as a component of dark matter (DM), focusing on their seed effect on large-scale structure formation The seed effect arises because PBHs act as early gravitational seeds, accreting surrounding DM and developing dense DM spikes to form dressed PBHs These structures enhance the matter power spectrum, particularly on small scales Weak lensing places competitive constraints on supermassive PBHs, with the upper limits on fPBH becoming progressively stronger toward higher PBH masses The Seed Effect Mechanism The seed effect is distinguished from the Poisson effect by arising because individual PBHs act as localized gravitational seeds that attract surrounding matter and accelerate the formation of nonlinear structures This process transforms initially bare PBHs into dressed PBHs surrounded by extended DM halos, which can generate steep and highly concentrated DM density profiles often referred to as DM spikes These dressed PBHs provide a physical realization of the seed effect by behaving as compact nonlinear structures whose masses and spatial profiles evolve through the accretion of ambient matter Modeling the Matter Power Spectrum Modification The population of dressed PBHs can substantially modify the matter power spectrum P(k), particularly its one-halo contribution on small scales In the standard halo model, these dressed PBHs introduce an additional population of unusually compact halos and can therefore enhance the power spectrum at large wavenumbers To account for uncertainties in the accretion history of the surrounding DM, two prescriptions are considered: an optimistic scenario (Case 1) and a conservative scenario (Case 2) These scenarios predict different modifications to the 1-halo term Constraints from Weak Gravitational Lensing Weak gravitational lensing is used as a sensitive probe of the small-scale matter structures generated by the seed effect The analysis utilizes cosmic shear measurements from the Dark Energy Survey Year 3 (DES Y3) to constrain the PBH fraction fPBH as a function of the PBH mass MPBH Case 1, which predicts more efficient DM accretion and hence a larger enhancement of the matter power spectrum, yields stronger constraints than Case 2 The results demonstrate that the absence of an observed small-scale excess in the cosmic-shear correlation functions places stringent limits on the abundance of supermassive PBHs Future Prospects and Complementarity The constraints derived from this work are competitive with those based primarily on PBH-induced Poisson isocurvature perturbations, including those from the Lyman-α forest and 21-cm cosmology The forecast for the Vera C.
Vera: Rubin Observatory’s Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) suggests that constraints could improve by approximately two orders of magnitude Future joint analyses combining cosmic shear with galaxy clustering, CMB lensing, the Lyman-α forest, and 21-cm observations will provide complementary scale and redshift information to break parameter degeneracies Where the gains come from The constraints are derived by incorporating dressed PBHs into the halo-model framework of the nonlinear matter power spectrum The analysis uses a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampler to derive upper limits on fPBH as a function of MPBH The comparison between Case 1 and Case 2 allows for the assessment of how the halo mass accretion process impacts the 1-halo power enhancement The results establish weak gravitational lensing as a sensitive probe of the seed effect and demonstrate its potential to complement other cosmological and astrophysical searches Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper focuses on the seed contribution rather than extrapolating the linear Poisson power spectrum beyond kcut, which characterizes the scale where discrete nature becomes nonlinear The use of a negative top-hat compensation shell is introduced to account for matter redistribution during halo growth, ensuring consistency with background evolution by making u(k → 0) → 0 The constraints at the highest PBH masses are interpreted within the idealized halomodel framework adopted in this work due to potential non-Gaussian covariance and sample variance How the training signal is built The analysis models each PBH-seeded halo as an isolated object and approximates its late-time evolution using two fixed accretion prescriptions The 95% confidence level (C.L.) upper limits on fPBH are calculated by using the profile likelihood method The constraints are derived from the DES Y3 cosmicshear data (solid lines) and the mock LSST cosmic shear data (dashed lines) Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The authors state that these results do not constitute evidence for a dressed-PBH signal but rather demonstrate that the absence of an observed small-scale excess in the cosmic-shear correlation functions places stringent limits on the abundance of supermassive PBHs The findings show that weak gravitational lensing provides a complementary probe of the PBH seed effect that is directly sensitive to the resulting redistribution of matter The authors acknowledge that a more complete treatment would require high-resolution cosmological simulations capable of following the formation, overlap, tidal evolution, and hierarchical merging of PBH-seeded halos Where the gains come from The LSST forecast improves sensitivity by more than two orders of magnitude due to larger survey area and enhanced statistical sensitivity The constraints are particularly competitive in the regime of rare and supermassive PBHs compared to existing constraints based on PBH-induced Poisson isocurvature perturbations The analysis demonstrates how weak gravitational lensing can probe the small-scale matter structures generated by the seed effect Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The results show that for Case 1, DES Y3 data excludes fPBH values above 10−4 for MPBH ≳ 1010M⊙ The conservative model (Case 2) yields relatively relaxed bounds compared to Case 1, particularly below 1012M⊙ The upper limit on fPBH becomes progressively stronger with increasing MPBH because a more massive MPBH seed facilitates the accretion of a larger DM halo The analysis relies on several simplifying assumptions, including modeling each PBH-seeded halo as an isolated object How the training signal is built The total matter power spectrum is schematically represented as the sum of the standard adiabatic component and the PBH-induced isocurvature component The linear Poisson description becomes inadequate on sufficiently small scales, requiring explicit modeling of gravitational structures surrounding individual PBHs The characteristic wavenumber kcut defines the scale at which the discrete nature of the PBH population becomes nonlinear Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper concludes that future weak-lensing measurements from Rubin Observatory’s Legacy Survey of Space and Time and from Euclid will substantially improve the statistical sensitivity to dressed PBHs Joint analyses combining cosmic shear with galaxy clustering, CMB lensing, the Lyman-α forest, and 21-cm observations will provide complementary scale and redshift information This approach aims to help break parameter degeneracies and enable more robust tests of the remaining PBH parameter space The constraints are derived from the DES Y3 cosmicshear data (solid lines) and the mock LSST cosmic shear data (dashed lines) The analysis includes six ΛCDM parameters plus two additional parameters for the dressed-PBHs component, MPBH and fPBH Where the gains come from The inclusion of the 1-halo contribution from dressed PBHs into the halo-model framework is key to enhancing the matter power spectrum on small scales The use of cosmic shear probes the distribution of matter without requiring it to emit light or follow a prescribed galaxy-bias relation The results clearly demonstrate that dressed PBHs introduce a characteristic and potentially observable signature in the matter power spectrum at small, non-linear scales The constraints are derived from the DES Y3 cosmicshear data (solid lines) and the mock LSST cosmic shear data (dashed lines) The analysis uses the HMCode prescription to compute the nonlinear matter power spectrum for the ΛCDM baseline Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper establishes that weak gravitational lensing is a sensitive probe of the seed effect of supermassive PBHs and demonstrates its potential to complement other cosmological and astrophysical searches The absence of an observed small-scale excess in the cosmic-shear correlation functions places stringent limits on the abundance of supermassive PBHs The study provides constraints complementary to those derived from the conventional Poisson contribution The authors acknowledge that neighboring dressed halos may overlap, merge into larger host halos, or undergo tidal stripping, which can alter their contribution to the power spectrum The phenomenological compensation profile adopted provides only an approximate description of the matter removed from the surroundings during halo growth How the training signal is built The total angular power spectrum entering the shear correlation functions is modeled as Cij tot(l) = CijGG(l) + CijGI (l) + CijIG(l) + CijII (l) The lensing-efficiency kernel Wi(χ) is defined using the scale factor a(χ), Hubble constant H0, and matter density parameter Ωm The analysis uses the Boltzmann solver CLASS to compute the nonlinear matter power spectrum for the ΛCDM baseline The constraints are derived from the DES Y3 cosmicshear data (solid lines) and the mock LSST cosmic shear data (dashed lines) Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The analysis includes the baryon omegab and CDM energy densities omegaCDM, the amplitude As and spectral index ns of primordial scalar perturbations The optical depth to reionization τreio and the angular size of the horizon at the last scattering surface θ are included in global parameter estimation The prior ranges for each parameter are shown in Table 1 The analysis uses flat priors within the specified ranges for all parameters The paper was in part supported by the JSPS KAKENHI Grant No.
Jocelyn: JP24K07027 (KK) The authors acknowledge support from the East Asian Core Observatories Association Fellowship The references list includes
3: B.
Vera: J.
Paper summary: Vera: The paper "Probing the Seed Effect of Supermassive Primordial Black Holes with Weak Gravitational Lensing" investigates whether supermassive primordial black holes could be a component of dark matter and what effect that has on how large structures form in the universe.
Jocelyn: They distinguish between two effects: the Poisson effect, which is just fluctuations in the discrete number density of PBHs, and the seed effect, where individual black holes act as gravitational seeds that attract surrounding dark matter to form dressed PBHs with dense spikes.
Subrahmanyan: This seed effect is significant because it enhances the matter power spectrum particularly on small scales. They model this using two accretion scenarios: an optimistic Case one and a conservative Case two which predict different modifications to the one-halo term <ref:2611.07574#pg1>.
Vera: The paper uses weak gravitational lensing data from the Dark Energy Survey Year three or DES Y3 to constrain the PBH fraction, fPBH, as a function of black hole mass, MPBH <ref:2611.07574#pg2>.
Jocelyn: They find that Case one which predicts more efficient dark matter accretion and thus a larger enhancement to the matter power spectrum, yields stronger constraints than Case two <ref:2611.07574#pg1>. For instance, Case one excludes fPBH greater than ten-four for MPBH greater than ten ten solar masses.
Subrahmanyan: They also forecast that the Vera C. Rubin Observatory's Legacy Survey of Space and Time, or LSST, could improve these constraints by about two orders of magnitude when using mock weak-lensing data.
Vera: Essentially, they are establishing weak gravitational lensing as a sensitive probe for the seed effect of supermassive PBHs and showing its potential to complement other cosmological searches.
Jocelyn: The analysis uses an MCMC sampler to get those upper limits on fPBH based on the DES Y3 cosmicshear data and mock LSST cosmic shear data.
Conclusion: Vera: So, looking at this paper, the authors are using weak gravitational lensing to test a specific mechanism for supermassive primordial black holes acting as dark matter seeds.
Jocelyn: The title itself points directly to what they are doing: probing the seed effect of these objects using lensing. It's about finding those dense spikes of dark matter that form around them.
Subrahmanyan: What this means for cosmology is that if you find a signal, it tells us something specific about the nature of dark matter and how structure formation proceeds on small scales, which is where standard models can become less certain.
Vera: The paper sets very clear limits on the abundance of these supermassive PBHs based on current observations from DES Y3 data. They show that if we don't see any excess in the small-scale cosmic shear correlation functions, those black holes probably aren't as numerous as some models might suggest.
Jocelyn: It's not a definitive proof of a dressed-PBH signal, but it does put strong limits on the fraction of dark matter that could be made up of supermassive PBHs under these specific conditions.
Subrahmanyan: Ultimately, this work demonstrates that weak gravitational lensing is a sensitive probe for the seed effect and shows its potential to complement other searches in our field. It helps us narrow down the parameter space for supermassive PBHs significantly.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO