Probing Solar-Wind Structure During Crab Pulsar Conjunctions with Dispersion and Faraday Rotation

summary

The gist

Observations of the Crab pulsar (PSR B0531+21) during solar conjunction probe plasma structure in the inner solar wind through radio-propagation effects The 2025 DM time series is distinguished from…

In short

The study analyzed radio signals from the Crab pulsar during solar conjunctions using dispersion measure (DM) and rotation measure (RM) data from 2022–2026. It found a distinct secondary DM enhancement in 2025, which is about 10 times larger than normal scatter. These measurements helped estimate the electron-density-weighted magnetic field near the Sun, revealing significant magnetic field variations in 2025.

Key concepts

Dispersion Measure (DM)
DM measures how much a radio signal's frequency is shifted as it passes through a plasma along the line of sight. It is directly related to the free-electron number density ($n_e$) of the intervening gas. By measuring DM, scientists can map out electron density variations in the solar wind and interplanetary medium.
Rotation Measure (RM)
RM measures how much a radio signal's polarization angle is rotated as it passes through a magnetized plasma. This rotation is caused by the line-of-sight magnetic field ($B_{\parallel}$) interacting with the electron density. RM data allows researchers to probe the structure and strength of magnetic fields in space.
Conjunction Excursions
Conjunctions occur when the Earth, Sun, and a spacecraft (like the Crab pulsar) are aligned in a way that maximizes their interaction with solar plasma. During these times, both DM and RM measurements show significant excursions or changes in sign, which are consistent with crossing boundaries between different magnetic sectors of the heliosphere.
Electron-Density-Weighted Field ($\langle B_{\parallel} \rangle$)
This quantity estimates the average strength of the magnetic field component pointing along the line of sight, weighted by local electron density. By relating DM and RM measurements using a specific slope, researchers can estimate this magnetic field strength near conjunctions, finding it to be between 0.2 and 10 mG in some sectors.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Probing Solar-Wind Structure During Crab Pulsar Conjunctions with Dispersion and Faraday Rotation · Read on arXiv

Huiyu Xiao, Daniel Baker, Thierry Serafin Nadeau, Hao Shen, Dongzi Li, Ue-Li Pen

Department of Physics, University of Toronto · Academia Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Toronto Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Canadian Institute for Theoretical Astrophysics University of Toronto

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Probing Solar-Wind Structure During Crab Pulsar Conjunctions with Dispersion and Faraday Rotation".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Observations of the Crab pulsar (PSR B0531+21) during solar conjunction probe plasma structure in the inner solar wind through radio-propagation effects The 2025 DM time series is distinguished from those of the other years by a secondary enhancement on 21 June, about one week after the main conjunction peak In our scattering-corrected DM measurements, this feature, ∆DM = (3.95 ± 0.20) × 10−3 pc cm−3, is about 20 times the day-to-day DM scatter outside the conjunction window The RM time series, measured by combining the single pulses of each observation and corrected for the ionospheric contribution, show conjunction excursions of up to ∼ 60 rad m−2 and changes of sign consistent with crossings of heliospheric magnetic-sector boundaries, but no counterpart to the secondary 2025 DM feature or to a similar post-conjunction DM tail in 2026 From the slope of the RM excess against the DM excess we estimate the electron-density-weighted line-of-sight magnetic field; for the sectors with significant slopes, ⟨B∥⟩ is at least ∼ 0.2 to ∼ 10 mG near conjunction, largest in 2025 Measurement Methodology The study analyzes dispersion measure (DM) and rotation measure (RM) measurements from annual conjunctions of the Crab pulsar using data obtained with the Canadian Hydrogen Intensity Mapping Experiment (CHIME) spanning 2022–2026 The DM is defined as DM = Z/LOS ne dl, where ne is the free-electron number density along the line of sight The RM is given by RM = 0.812 Z/LOS ne B∥ dl, for ne in cm−3, B∥ in µG, and dl in pc Simultaneous measurements of DM and RM can therefore provide complementary constraints on electron-density and magnetic-field variations DM Analysis The analysis involves fitting the observed DM time series to a baseline using Equation (7), DMbg(t) = at + b, to define the background-subtracted DM as ∆DM(t) = DMobs(t) − DMbg(t) The analysis also incorporates a joint dispersion–scattering fit using an exponentially modified Gaussian profile to separate scattering from dispersive delays The background subtraction process involves removing baseline days one at a time while the largest residual exceeds four times the robust scatter, refitting after each removal RM and Field Estimation The electron-density-weighted mean line-of-sight field is estimated using Equation (12), ⟨B∥⟩ = R ne B∥ dl / R ne dl = 1.232 µG ∆RM/(rad m−2) ∆DM/(pc cm−3) The slope of ∆RM against ∆DM is used to estimate this ratio, employing orthogonal distance regression to account for errors on both axes RM excursions near conjunction reach +56 rad m−2 and change sign within the window in three of the five years, consistent with crossings of magnetic-sector boundaries Key Findings and Interpretation The DM peaks in each year occur near the expected annual conjunction time, falling on 14 June in 2024 and 2026 and on 15 June in the other years In 2025, a separate enhancement of (3.95 ± 0.20) × 10−3 pc cm−3 follows on 21 June, after the DM has returned to the background The largest ⟨B∥⟩ occurs in 2025 and is about 50 times below the value near closest approach in the same year The secondary 2025 DM feature and the post-conjunction DM tail of 2026 carry little RM Limitations and Outlook A priority is to improve the profile model used for DM, as echoes in the Crab Nebula can produce non-exponential scattering tails Extending the analysis to additional years will help determine whether the two-feature structure observed in 2025 is unusual or part of a broader pattern of year-to-year variability A comparison of ⟨B∥⟩ with potential-field source-surface models would test the sector interpretation of the RM sign changes The comparison with in situ measurements from Parker Solar Probe neither confirms nor excludes a solar-wind origin of the 2025 feature APPENDIX A.

Vera: VALIDATION OF THE DM AND RM ESTIMATORS The validation tests show that with the correct index, the bias is between −0.06 and 0×10−3 pc cm−3 for τ600 ≥ 10 µs A wrong index or a two-component tail produces an absolute bias of up to 0.21×10−3 pc cm−3 The scatter of the recovered values between realizations is 1.2 times the median bootstrap uncertainty, so the bootstrap uncertainties should be scaled up by about 20% The per-pulse delay selection of Section 4.1 already recovers some of the days closest to the Sun The scattering index is fixed at α = 4 in the DM fit; simulations show that a true index of 3.5 or 4.4 would change ∆DM near conjunction by at most 0.05 × 10−3 pc cm−3 The per-pulse selection recovers some, but not all, of the days of largest ∆DM, which carry the most weight The secondary DM enhancement has little associated RM A comparison of ⟨B∥⟩ with potential-field source-surface models would test the sector interpretation of the RM sign changes by predicting the dates at which the line of sight crosses the heliospheric current sheet in each year The DM time-variable or Gaussian-process solar-wind models developed for pulsar timing would provide a predictive baseline A comparison of that baseline with our data would show whether the 2025 secondary enhancement departs from a smoothly varying wind The per-pulse polarization calibration, in particular of the leakage that we suspect produces the near-zero RM solution, would allow the remaining ones to be recovered The per-pulse selection recovers 14 June 2022, but the 15 June 2025 observation, between +57 on 14 June and +24 on 16 June, remains ambiguous and is excluded from the fit even though its RM may be genuine The scattering index is fixed at α = 4 in the DM fit; simulations show that a true index of 3.5 or 4.4 would change ∆DM near conjunction by at most 0.05 × 10−3 pc cm−3 The per-pulse selection recovers some, but not all, of the days of largest ∆DM, which carry the most weight We have measured the DM and RM of the Crab pulsar through five solar conjunctions, 2022–2026, with CHIME The DM rises toward every conjunction and peaks on 14 or 15 June at (6.8–20.4)×10−3 pc cm−3 above the background In 2025, and only in that year, a separate enhancement of (3.95 ± 0.20) × 10−3 pc cm−3 follows on 21 June, after the DM has returned to the background RM excursions reach +56 rad m−2 and change sign within the window in three of the five years, consistent with crossings of magnetic-sector boundaries The slope of ∆RM against ∆DM gives ⟨B∥⟩ of at least ∼ 0.2–10 mG for the sectors with significant slopes, largest in 2025 The secondary 2025 DM feature and the post-conjunction DM tail of 2026 carry little RM A priority is to improve the profile model used for DM, as echoes in the Crab Nebula can produce non-exponential scattering tails Extending the analysis to additional years will help determine whether the two-feature structure observed in 2025 is unusual or part of a broader pattern of year-to-year variability A comparison of ⟨B∥⟩ with potential-field source-surface models would test the sector interpretation of the RM sign changes by predicting the dates at which the line of sight crosses the heliospheric current sheet in each year The DM time-variable or Gaussian-process solar-wind models developed for pulsar timing would provide a predictive baseline A comparison of that baseline with our data would show whether the 2025 secondary enhancement departs from a smoothly varying wind We also made an exploratory comparison with in situ measurements from Parker Solar Probe, using Solar Probe Cup (SPC) and SPAN-I data from the SWEAP suite For each June 2025 CHIME observation, PSP densities within ±10 minutes set the normalization of a spherically symmetric ne ∝ r −2 profile, which was integrated along the Earth–Crab line of sight This construction extrapolates a local measurement under a symmetry that is known to underfit near-ecliptic lines of sight The ion densities require a composition assumption to give ne, and contemporaneous sampling does not establish that PSP and the line of sight intersect the same plasma Coronagraph images and coronal-mass-ejection catalogs could provide an additional test, requiring consistency in propagation direction and travel time rather than temporal proximity alone The CHIME/FRB baseband recording system is funded in part by a grant from the CFI 2015 Innovation Fund (Project 33213) and by contributions from the provinces of British Columbia, Qu´ebec and Ontario The NASA Parker Solar Probe mission and the SWEAP team for the use of their data are publicly available from the SWEAP data archive The UQRG global ionospheric maps and the IGRF geomagnetic model used for the ionospheric correction are publicly available Page 15 --- The daily DM and RM measurements, the ionospheric RM corrections, and the per-pulse RM fits used in this work are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request The CHIME baseband data are held by the CHIME/FRB Collaboration The Parker Solar Probe SWEAP data are publicly available from the SWEAP data archive The UQRG global ionospheric maps and the IGRF geomagnetic model used for the ionospheric correction are publicly available The daily DM and RM measurements, the ionospheric RM corrections, and the per-pulse RM fits used in this work are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request The CHIME baseband data are held by the CHIME/FRB Collaboration The Parker Solar Probe SWEAP data are publicly available from the SWEAP data archive The UQRG global ionospheric maps and the IGRF geomagnetic model used for the ionospheric correction are publicly available Page 15 --- The daily DM and RM measurements, the ionospheric RM corrections, and the per-pulse RM fits used in this work are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request The CHIME baseband data are held by the CHIME/FRB Collaboration The Parker Solar Probe SWEAP data are publicly available from the SWEAP data archive The UQRG global ionospheric maps and the IGRF geomagnetic model used for the ionospheric correction are publicly available

Title and authors: Vera: Let's talk about the title and the people who did this work. The paper is called "Probing Solar-Wind Structure During Crab Pulsar Conjunctions with Dispersion and Faraday Rotation". It’s really descriptive about what they are trying to achieve.

Jocelyn: And the authors are Huiyu Xiao, Daniel Baker, Thierry Serafin Nadeau, Hao Shen, Dongzi Li, and Ue-Li Pen. They’re a team from different parts of the field—astronomy and astrophysics.

Subrahmanyan: I look at this team structure and think it shows how important it is to combine observational astronomy with theory to understand these things; you need people who can handle the raw data and people who can connect those measurements to bigger cosmic structures.

Vera: Right. So, what does this actually mean in plain terms for someone listening? It’s that they are using the Crab pulsar as a tool to look *inside* the solar wind, not just at it from a distance.

Jocelyn: They are essentially measuring how the plasma density and magnetic field change as we move through our solar system's influence, using two different radio measurements—dispersion measure and rotation measure.

Subrahmanyan: This helps us constrain models of the solar wind itself, which is crucial because the solar wind is what shapes the environment around planets and dictates how cosmic rays interact with interstellar space.

The paper's summary: Vera: So, let's get into what they actually found in this paper. The main takeaway is that they analyzed dispersion measure and rotation measure measurements from the annual conjunctions of the Crab pulsar from two thousand twenty-two through two thousand twenty-six.

Jocelyn: They found that the dispersion measure rises toward every conjunction, peaking on June fifteenth in most years, but then in two thousand twenty-five there was this secondary enhancement on June 21st that returned to background levels a week later <ref:2611.06723#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: That secondary enhancement is quantified as three point nine five times ten to the minus three parsecs per centimeter cubed, and it's about twenty times larger than the typical day-to-day scatter outside the main conjunction window.

Vera: And they also looked at rotation measure, and they found these excursions up to sixty radians per square meter during conjunctions, which points toward crossings of magnetic-sector boundaries in our solar system.

Jocelyn: But again, this is key: they didn't see a similar feature in two thousand twenty-six after the main conjunction either.

Subrahmanyan: That lack of a counterpart suggests that this specific behavior in two thousand twenty-five might be an unusual event, which means we have to think about what could cause such a localized fluctuation in the solar wind structure.

The paper's improvements: Vera: Now, the authors themselves suggest some ways to improve how they do this work. They point out that they need to get better at modeling dispersion measure and scattering, specifically by improving the profile model used for dispersion measure because echoes in the Crab Nebula can cause non-exponential scattering tails.

Jocelyn: And they also discuss making the rotation measure analysis stronger by incorporating pulse-by-pulse polarization calibration. They suspect that this helps them resolve a near-zero rotation measure solution that they think is there, but it can't be recovered with just the standard methods.

Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical side, they suggest using orthogonal distance regression when estimating the electron density weighted line of sight magnetic field because ordinary least squares in dispersion measure would bias that slope low. This gives them a more robust estimate of that mean line of sight magnetic field strength near conjunction.

Vera: So, to summarize these improvements: better scattering models for DM, better polarization calibration for RM, and using orthogonal distance regression to get a better magnetic field measurement.

Conclusion: Jocelyn: So to wrap up on the paper "Probing Solar-Wind Structure During Crab Pulsar Conjunctions with Dispersion and Faraday Rotation", they found a distinct secondary feature in the dispersion measure during the two thousand twenty-five conjunction, which is larger than usual, but that this feature didn't repeat in two thousand twenty-six.

Vera: The implication for us is that we need to keep looking at these year-to-year variations because if this pattern continues, it could tell us a lot about the variability of the solar wind structure.

Subrahmanyan: I think the real value here is in how we use this technique to test models. They suggest comparing their electron density weighted mean line of sight magnetic field estimates with potential-field source-surface models to see if those magnetic field sign changes align with where we predict the line of sight crosses the heliospheric current sheet in each year.

Jocelyn: And finally, they acknowledge that one limitation is that they need to improve their profile model for dispersion measure because echoes in the Crab Nebula can create non-exponential scattering tails, which could mess up their density measurements.

Vera: So we have a paper that gives us concrete numbers on what happened during specific conjunctions and points us toward better modeling techniques to get even more precise information on the solar wind structure.

Jocelyn: That's it for this discussion of "Probing Solar-Wind Structure During Crab Pulsar Conjunctions with Dispersion and Faraday Rotation".

More episodes

← Home