pop-cosmos: Galaxy size evolution across structural and star-formation classifications in COSMOS-Web

summary

The gist

Galaxy sizes are correlated with stellar mass and redshift, as characterised by size scaling relations <ref:2606.28489#pg2> By investigating the size–mass and the size–redshift relations…

In short

The study combined stellar mass and star formation rate estimates from a generative model with size and morphology data from COSMOS-Web to investigate galaxy scaling relations. It found that classifying galaxies by star formation activity or morphology yields quantitatively different results, revealing distinct evolutionary pathways for quenching and structural transformation. Intrinsic scatter depends on structure, not star formation, constraining the galaxy-halo connection.

Key concepts

Size Scaling Relations
These are mathematical relationships describing how the physical size of a galaxy correlates with its stellar mass and redshift. The paper investigates these relations using different ways to classify galaxies—by how actively they form stars or their shape—to see if the relationship changes based on that classification.
sSFR/Morphology Splits
This refers to splitting the galaxy sample based on two different criteria: star formation activity (like specific star-formation rate) and structural markers (like bulge-to-total ratio). The analysis shows these splits result in quantitatively different slopes, intercepts, and scatter in the size-mass relationship.
Intrinsic Scatter
This measures the natural variation or 'noise' around the main trend line of a scaling relation. The paper found that this scatter is determined by a galaxy's structural morphology (e.g., disc vs. bulge) rather than its star formation rate, which helps explain how galaxies connect to their surrounding dark matter halos.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

pop-cosmos: Galaxy size evolution across structural and star-formation classifications in COSMOS-Web · Read on arXiv

Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge · Cavendish Laboratory Department of Physics University of Cambridge · The Oskar Klein Centre Department of Physics Stockholm University · Astrophysics Group Imperial College London Astrophysics Group · Department of Mathematics Imperial College London Department of Mathematics · Research Computing Services University of Cambridge Research Computing Services Institute for Gravitation & the Cosmos The Pennsylvania State University Institute for Gravitation & the Cosmos

Galaxy sizes are correlated with stellar mass and redshift, as characterised by size scaling relations. The inferred forms of these scaling relations are sensitive to how galaxies are classified -- either by their star formation activity (e.g. specific star-formation rate, sSFR) or by their morphology markers (e.g. bulge-to-total ratio, S' e rsic index). We combine stellar mass and sSFR estimates from pop-cosmos (a generative model trained on COSMOS2020 Spitzer IRAC Ch.1 <26) with size and morphology measurements from COSMOS-Web, obtaining 99,369 galaxies. By investigating the size-mass and the size-redshift relations, we show that: (i) the sSFR/morphology splits give quantitatively different slopes, intercepts, and intrinsic scatter behaviour; (ii) intrinsic scatter depends on structural morphology but not on sSFR, which constrains the galaxy-halo connection; (iii) the quiescent and bulge-dominated size-mass relations both show double-power law breaks, but at different pivot masses, indicating that quenching and structural transformation occur on different time-scales; (iv) the morphology-dependent trends are only recoverable from space-based imaging. Further, the quiescent pivot mass M about 10 10.7 M coincides with the mass scale at which AGN (infrared torus) bolometric luminosity fraction peaks in transitioning galaxies, while the bulge-dominated pivot mass M about 10 11.1 M coincides with the halo mass at which AGN-driven baryonic redistribution peaks, tracing the interval over which AGN feedback ramps from quenching onset to structural transformation.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "pop-cosmos: Galaxy size evolution across structural and star-formation classifications in COSMOS-Web".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Galaxy sizes are correlated with stellar mass and redshift, as characterised by size scaling relations <ref:2606.28489#pg2> By investigating the size–mass and the size–redshift relations, we show that (i) the sSFR/morphology splits give quantitatively different slopes, intercepts, and intrinsic scatter behaviour <ref:2606.28489#pg2> (ii) intrinsic scatter depends on structural morphology but not on sSFR, which constrains the galaxy–halo connection <ref:2606.28489#pg2> (iii) the quiescent and bulge-dominated size–mass relations both show double-power law breaks, but at different pivot masses, indicating that quenching and structural transformation occur on different time-scales <ref:2606.28489#pg2> (iv) the morphology-dependent trends are only recoverable from space-based imaging <ref:2606.28489#pg2>.

Vera: The analysis combines stellar mass and sSFR estimates from pop-cosmos (a generative model trained on COSMOS2020 Spitzer IRAC Ch.

Jocelyn: 1 < 26) with size and morphology measurements from COSMOS-Web, obtaining 99, 369 galaxies <ref:2606.28489#pg2>.

Vera: Physical parameters are estimated using pop-cosmos (Alsing et al.

Paper summary: Vera: So we’re looking at this new work called "pop-cosmos: Galaxy size evolution across structural and star-formation classifications in COSMOS-Web." Basically, the authors are trying to figure out how galaxy sizes relate to stellar mass and redshift using two different ways of sorting galaxies: by their star formation activity, like the specific star formation rate, or by their shape or morphology.

Jocelyn: What’s the main point here? It sounds like they’re saying that depending on whether you use those two different classification methods, you get totally different slopes and intercepts for how galaxy sizes evolve with mass and redshift.

Subrahmanyan: That’s significant because it suggests that the way we classify galaxies—whether we look at how actively they're forming stars or what their shape is—gives us fundamentally different pictures of their evolution. We need to figure out if those classifications are actually capturing the same physical things, or if they are pointing to different evolutionary paths entirely.

Vera: Right, and it seems the study combines estimates from a generative model called pop-cosmos, which uses data from Spitzer’s infrared channels, with actual size and morphology measurements from the COSMOS-Web survey to get this sample of ninety-nine thousand six hundred thirty nine galaxies.

Jocelyn: And what they find is that if you look at the intrinsic scatter—that little bit of randomness in how things vary around the main trend—it depends on the structural morphology, not on whether you use star formation activity as your sorting variable.

Subrahmanyan: That’s a crucial piece of information because it constrains our understanding of how galaxies connect to their dark matter halos. It implies that the shape of the galaxy itself is what links it to its environment, rather than just how fast it's making stars at any given moment.

Vera: They also found that when you look at quiescent galaxies or bulge-dominated systems, both show double power law breaks in their size and mass relations, but these breaks happen at different pivot masses. This suggests that quenching and structural transformation aren't happening on the same time scales across all galaxy types.

Jocelyn: So, it means quenching—that process where a galaxy stops forming stars—and the physical change in its structure are separate events happening at different times for those specific populations.

Subrahmanyan: Exactly. It tells us that we can’t treat quenching and structural transformation as one single evolutionary sequence; they happen sequentially across different mass scales, which is what the paper calls distinct evolutionary pathways.

Vera: The authors also point out that the trends you see depending on morphology are only really recoverable if you use space-based imaging, because ground-based observations just blur those structural classes together.

Jocelyn: That makes sense; we need higher resolution to see those subtle morphological differences that matter for these scaling relations.

Paper summary: Subrahmanyan: And they tie this all together by identifying specific mass scales where AGN feedback kicks in differently. They found a quiescent pivot mass around ten point five to ten point eight, which is when AGN bolometric luminosity peaks in transitioning galaxies <ref:2606.28489#pg1>.

Vera: And then there’s the bulge-dominated pivot mass, around ten point eleven to eleven point three, which maps to the halo mass where AGN-driven baryonic redistribution peaks <ref:2606.28489#pg3>. This covers the time interval from quenching onset to structural transformation.

Jocelyn: So they are linking these feedback processes directly to specific size and mass scales in a way that’s really hard to see without high resolution data.

Subrahmanyan: It provides a clear picture of how AGN feedback moves from quenching a galaxy to physically reshaping its structure, which is key for modeling the transition from discs to spheroids.

Vera: The paper title, "pop-cosmos: Galaxy size evolution across structural and star-formation classifications in COSMOS-Web," really highlights that the choice of classification method matters because it leads to different evolutionary conclusions.

Jocelyn: And the authors are making a strong argument that if we want to understand galaxy evolution, we can't just pick one way—either star formation or shape—and assume they mean the same thing.

Subrahmanyan: That’s right; the paper suggests these classifications capture different dimensions of galaxy evolution, and only by treating them as separate dimensions do we recover the full sequence of transitions from quenching to structural change.

Vera: So what does this mean for us in terms of observing galaxies? It means that when we look at a galaxy's size or mass relation, we need to know exactly how it’s shaped and how actively it’s forming stars to interpret the physics behind that trend correctly.

Jocelyn: It tells us that the relationship between a galaxy and its halo is more complex than just one simple scaling law; it depends on both structure and activity.

Subrahmanyan: Ultimately, the results show that we need space-based data to see these morphology-dependent trends clearly, because ground-based observations can't resolve those structural classes well enough.

Vera: That’s the core finding of this work on "pop-cosmos: Galaxy size evolution across structural and star-formation classifications in COSMOS-Web." It really pushes us to be careful about how we measure and classify these distant objects.

Jocelyn: And it gives us a detailed map of where the processes of quenching and structural transformation happen in terms of mass scales, which is really helpful for time evolution models.

Subrahmanyan: This paper lays out a framework where we can start separating the physics involved in different evolutionary steps, moving from quenching to reshaping structure, and that requires combining stellar mass estimates with precise morphological data.

Conclusion: Vera: So we're wrapping up this look at "pop-cosmos: Galaxy size evolution across structural and star-formation classifications in COSMOS-Web." Essentially, this paper shows that how we sort galaxies by their shape or by how fast they’re making stars matters a lot for understanding their growth.

Jocelyn: It boils down to the fact that those two sorting methods give us quantitatively different answers for things like size and mass scaling relations.

Subrahmanyan: That means if you use star formation rate as your metric versus bulge-to-total ratio, you get totally different slopes and intercepts for how galaxy sizes evolve with time or redshift.

Vera: And it’s not just about the slope; the paper points out that the intrinsic scatter in those relations depends on the structural shape of the galaxy, not just how active it is forming stars.

Jocelyn: So, that tells us something really specific about how these galaxies sit within their dark matter halos. It constrains what we think connects a galaxy to its environment.

Subrahmanyan: Yeah, and they find that quenching—when a galaxy stops making stars—and structural transformation happen on different time scales depending on whether you’re looking at quiescent or bulge-dominated systems.

Vera: That’s the big picture here; it shows we can't treat all galaxy evolution as one single story.

Jocelyn: Exactly. And the authors stress that seeing these structural trends only comes through space-based imaging, because ground-based telescopes just blur those details together too much.

Subrahmanyan: So, they identify specific mass scales where AGN feedback kicks in differently for quenching and reshaping structure, which is really useful for building models of how galaxies change shape.

Vera: It’s a detailed map showing exactly where these different physical processes happen in terms of galaxy mass.

Jocelyn: And it sets up the next question—if we can figure out these distinct thresholds, what kind of follow-up observations do we need to actually confirm them?

More episodes

← Home