Observational constraints on CO sequestration and disk mass in the planet-hosting PDS 70 disk
summary
The gist
Exoplanets accrete gas, dust, and ice from their natal environment, setting the chemical composition of their atmospheres and interiors The derived peak CO abundance is (4.8 + 4.3 − 2.7 − 17+8…
In short
Researchers used ALMA observations of PDS 70 to detect N2H+ and C17O, providing the first molecular tracers in this disk. Modeling constrained these detections to yield a peak CO abundance of (4.8 + 4.3 − 2.7 − 5.8 + 4.7 − 3)×10−6 relative to H2 and a disk mass of approximately 0.011+0.011−0.039+0.067−0.018 M⊙, assuming N2H+ is optically thin at 21 K.
Key concepts
- CO Sequestration
- This refers to the process where carbon monoxide (CO) is locked away in the outer layers of a disk, often forming ice or complex organic molecules. The study suggests these planets might accrete the final part of their atmospheres from this sequestered CO reservoir, which is important for understanding planetary chemistry.
- N2H+ Emission
- N2H+ is a molecule detected in the PDS 70 disk, observed via its J=1-0 transition at 93.173 GHz. Its emission characteristics are used to constrain the disk's chemical composition and formation location when assumed to be optically thin and excited at 21 K.
- Disk Mass Constraints
- The mass of the PDS 70 disk was estimated by fitting line fluxes with a framework developed by Trapman et al. This method compared results against thermochemical DALI models, yielding a disk mass consistent with independent measurements from rotation curves for similar disks.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Observational constraints on CO sequestration and disk mass in the planet-hosting PDS 70 disk · Paper Radio
- ALMA 873 mu m Polarization Observations of the PDS 70 Disk
- Extending dynamical mass measurements: probing GI as a possible origin of mm-dust spirals · Paper Radio
- Linking planet formation to exoplanet characteristics: C/O as a diagnostic of planet formation
The paper
Observational constraints on CO sequestration and disk mass in the planet-hosting PDS 70 disk · Read on arXiv
M. Leemker, S. Facchini, F. Zagaria, K. Doi, J. Bae, M. Benisty, H. B., Liu, C., Longarini, V., §ampinelli, L., §tapper, L. M., Ɠeague, R.
Dipartimento di Fisica of the University of Milano · Max Planck Institute for Astronomy · Department of Astronomy of the University of Florida · Department of Physics at National Sun Yat-Sen University · Center of Astronomy and Gravitation at National Taiwan Normal University · Institute of Astronomy at the University of Cambridge · Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences at Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Exoplanets accrete gas, dust, and ice from their natal environment, setting the chemical composition of their atmospheres and interiors. The abundance of the major volatiles in disks can be used to possibly link exoplanet atmospheres to their formation location in the disk. In this work, we aim to quantify the peak CO abundance and disk mass of the PDS 70 disk, the first disk with a direct confirmation of two accreting planets in its dust cavity. We present the first detection of N 2 H+ and C 17 O in this disk. The C 17 O emission shows marginal statistical evidence for an azimuthal asymmetry trailing that previously seen in the continuum emission. We then compare the disk integrated fluxes of N 2 H+, CO isotopologues, and the continuum to an existing grid of thermochemical models. We find that the derived disk mass drops by a factor of about 3.4 from 0.039+0.067-0.018 M to 0.011+0.011-0.006 M if the C 17 O line flux is included in the fitting procedure; the quoted intervals do not include systematic uncertainties. CO on the other hand is sequestered with an effective abundance of (4.8+4.3-2.7 - 17+8-8) times 10-6 relative to H 2 in the probed disk layers after accounting for CO freeze-out and isotope selective CO photodissociation for the adopted chemical network and ionization prescription. The range in peak CO abundances reflects the uncertainty in the N 2 H+ emission, assuming either optically thin emission at 21 K or optically thick emission. Therefore, the PDS 70 planets are possibly accreting the final portion of their atmospheres from the outer disk molecular layer where CO is sequestered. Thus, CO sequestering may need to be considered when interpreting the chemical composition of planetary atmospheres.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Observational constraints on CO sequestration and disk mass in the planet-hosting PDS 70 disk".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Exoplanets accrete gas, dust, and ice from their natal environment, setting the chemical composition of their atmospheres and interiors The derived peak CO abundance is (4.8 + 4.3 − 2.7 − 17+8 −8) × 10−6 H2 assuming that the N2H+ emission is optically thin and is characterized by an excitation temperature of 21 K The disk mass of the PDS 70 disk is 0.011+0.011 − 0.039+0.067 − 0.018 M⊙ (12+12 − 6 − 4) MJup assuming that the N2H+ emission is optically thin and emits at 21 K This work presents the first detection of N2H+ and C17O in the PDS 70 disk, both of which were serendipitously observed by ALMA Discovery of Molecular Tracers The research focuses on quantifying the peak CO abundance and disk mass of the PDS 70 disk, which is noted as "the first disk with a direct confirmation of two accreting planets in its dust cavity" The detection of N2H+ and C17O in this disk was achieved using ALMA observations, specifically the N2H+ J = 1 − 0 transition at 93.173 GHz and the C17O J = 3 − 2 transition at 337.061 GHz The C17O emission shows "marginal statistical evidence for an azimuthal asymmetry trailing that previously seen in the continuum emission" These detections are crucial because they allow for constraints on the disk's chemical composition and formation location Constraining Disk Properties via Modeling The authors leverage a framework developed by Trapman et al.
Vera: (2025b) to constrain the disk mass and CO abundance using these line fluxes together with archival continuum and other CO isotopologue observations The comparison is made against a grid of thermochemical DALI models, specifically utilizing the transition disk model grid where models have a dust cavity but no gas cavity The results from this method are in "good agreement with independent disk mass measurements from rotation curves for the disks in the exoALMA large program" Sensitivity to Observational Choices The derived parameters are sensitive to which fluxes are included in the fitting, as demonstrated by a comparison between fits including and excluding the C17O line flux The fit including the C17O line flux prefers a more extended disk with Rc = 58+9 − 7 au and a disk mass of Mdisk = 0.011+0.011 − 0.005 M⊙, whereas the fit excluding the C17O emission favors a smaller disk with Rc = 46+7 − 6 au and disk mass that is ∼ 3.4× lower The peak CO abundance is more or less independent of whether the C17O line flux is included in the fitting because "the CO depletion is mainly set by the N2H+ flux" Systematic Uncertainties and Future Directions The large gas gap observed in the PDS 70 disk, which is not included in the adopted model grid, may introduce "substantial systematic uncertainties in the inferred disk parameters that are not captured by the formal posterior distributions" A sensitivity test showed that doubling the integrated C17O flux almost exactly matches the posteriors when C17O is not included in the fitting, highlighting that derived disk mass, size and gas-to-dust mass ratio are sensitive to a factor of 2 change in the C17O flux A more flexible model grid including a range of gas cavity sizes and depletion factors is therefore needed to quantify these systematic effects The CO sequestering in the outer disk gas probed by the observations suggests that "the PDS 70 planets may accrete the final portion of their atmospheres from this CO sequestered reservoir" The findings suggest that CO sequestration may need to be considered when interpreting the chemical composition of planetary atmospheres The system is a good candidate to explore a direct link between the atmospheric composition of the planets and their natal environment Including grain surface chemistry involving CO ice can reconcile observed fluxes with model predictions, suggesting that at least part of the sequestered CO is locked in the form of e.g., CO2 ice and icy complex organic molecules METIS and HARMONI on the ELT can further improve our understanding by characterizing exoplanetary atmospheres The PDS 70 disk mass is similar to that of Herbig disks and massive T Tauri disks The derived peak CO abundance is similar to what is found in other T Tauri disks and is approximately an order of magnitude lower than that in the ISM after accounting for CO freeze-out and isotope selective photodissociation of CO Final Summary In summary, the effective peak CO abundance relative to H2 in the PDS 70 disk layers probed by the observations is (4.8 + 4.3 − 2.7 − 17+8 −8) × 10−6 The disk mass of the PDS 70 disk is 0.011+0.011 − 0.039+0.067 − 0.018 M⊙ assuming that the N2H+ emission is optically thin and emits at 21 K The range of a factor of ∼ 3.4 in the derived disk mass is driven by the dependence on whether the C17O 3 − 2 line flux is included in the mcmc sampling procedure The range is due to the optical depth and excitation temperature of the N2H+ emission and to a lesser degree to whether the C17O flux is included in the fitting The peak CO abundance is independent of this The derived peak CO abundance is not necessarily the global CO/H2 ratio in the disk but rather the peak CO abundance in the emitting layer probed by the observations Key Findings 1.
Jocelyn: The effective peak CO abundance relative to H2 in the PDS 70 disk layers probed by the observations is (4.8 + 4.3 − 2.7 − 17+8 −8) × 10−6 2.
Vera: The disk mass of the PDS 70 disk is 0.011+0.011 − 0.039+0.067 − 0.018 M⊙ (12+12 − 6 − 4) MJup assuming that the N2H+ emission is optically thin and emits at 21 K 3.
Paper summary: Vera: So, wrapping up this discussion on the paper "Observational constraints on CO sequestration and disk mass in the planet-hosting PDS seventy disk," we've seen how ALMA data lets us measure two key things: the peak carbon monoxide abundance and the total mass of that disk.
Jocelyn: And what this means is that these measurements give us a real number for how much carbon monoxide is present in the layers we can actually see, which is important for understanding the chemistry of planets forming around these disks >.
Subrahmanyan: The authors are using a framework from Trapman et al 2025b to combine their line fluxes with other data, and they're getting results for disk mass that match what we get from rotation curves of other exoplanet disks >.
Vera: And the authors are really careful about the uncertainties, showing how changing which lines you include, like C17O, shifts your calculated disk size and mass significantly >. That dependence on observational choices is something we have to keep in mind.
Jocelyn: But they also point out that their main finding on CO abundance is pretty stable because it's mainly set by the N2H plus flux. That’s a specific chemical detail about how those molecules behave in the disk environment >.
Subrahmanyan: That stability suggests that when we look at planet atmospheres later, we have to factor in this sequestration effect, meaning the carbon isn't just freely floating around; it's locked up somewhere else in that disk structure >. It’s not just a free abundance; there's a process happening.
Vera: Exactly. And they flag some limitations too because they didn't include the large gas gap observed in PDS seventy when they were building their model grid, which could introduce some big uncertainties into the final numbers >. That’s a specific thing that stops them from getting a perfectly clean result.
Jocelyn: So, to put it simply, this paper uses ALMA data to measure these molecular tracers to get constraints on disk mass and carbon monoxide sequestration, which helps us model the environments where planets actually grow >. It connects the gas we see directly to how those atmospheres form later on.
Conclusion: Vera: So we've been talking about these ALMA measurements on the PDS seventy disk, and now we're looking at what this paper is actually titled: "Observational constraints on CO sequestration and disk mass in the planet-hosting PDS seventy disk."
Jocelyn: It’s a pretty descriptive title. It tells you exactly what they’re measuring: not just the mass, but how much carbon monoxide is sequestered, which means locked up somewhere else in the dust or gas.
Subrahmanyan: That sequestration idea is key because it directly links the chemistry of those planets to their birth environment around PDS seventy.
Vera: The authors are using this data to show that these measurements aren't just numbers; they constrain a specific chemical process happening in the disk.
Jocelyn: They found that even though the peak carbon monoxide abundance is stable, you still have to be careful because it’s just the peak in one layer, not the whole thing.
Subrahmanyan: That dependence on where you are means that when we model a planet's atmosphere later, we need to account for this sequestered reservoir.
Vera: They suggest that grain surface chemistry involving carbon monoxide ice might actually help bridge the gap between what they see and what the models predict.
Jocelyn: So, it’s about linking the molecules we observe right now to how those atmospheres will evolve later on.
Subrahmanyan: The implication is that PDS seventy is a great place to study that direct link between a planet's atmosphere and its natal disk structure.
Vera: And they point to future tools like METIS and HARMONI on the ELT for further characterization of those exoplanetary atmospheres.
Jocelyn: So, the next thing we look at is how those specific molecular tracers reveal this hidden carbon chemistry that might be setting up planet formation.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO