Evidence for the Moon and Sun shadows with cosmic rays at an average energy of 7 times 10 17, eV

summary

The gist

Interactions of cosmic rays with the Moon and the Sun produce deficits in their arrival-direction distributions relative to an isotropic flux Such shadows have been observed previously at energies…

In short

Researchers used data from the Pierre Auger Observatory to search for shadows in cosmic ray arrival directions caused by interactions with the Moon and Sun at very high energies (around 7x10^17 eV). They found a combined statistical significance of about 3 sigma, confirming that the observatory's surface detectors can accurately point toward celestial bodies. This observation validates the pointing accuracy of the detector.

Key concepts

Cosmic Ray Shadows
When high-energy cosmic rays interact with celestial bodies like the Moon or Sun, they are deflected away from their expected arrival direction. This creates a 'shadow' in the distribution of incoming particles relative to what would be expected if there were no obstruction.
Pierre Auger Observatory
This is a large array of detectors used to study cosmic rays. The study used data collected by this observatory, which consists of three detector arrays covering different areas and spacings, totaling over 10.6 million recorded events.
Angular Resolution
This measures how accurately the detector can determine the direction an incoming cosmic ray is coming from. The study calculated an overall angular resolution of (0.59+0.15-0.11) degrees, which validates the pointing accuracy of the surface detectors.
Li&Ma Formalism
This is a statistical method used to evaluate the significance of observing a certain number of events when comparing actual observations against an expected uniform distribution. It helps determine if the observed deficit is statistically significant.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Evidence for the Moon and Sun shadows with cosmic rays at an average energy of 7 times 10 17, eV · Read on arXiv

Pierre Auger Collaboration

Pierre Auger Observatory · Comision Nacional de Energia Atomica · Agencia Nacional de Promocion Cientíca y Tecnolígica (ANPCyT) · Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientícas y Tᦓcnicas (CONICET) · Gobierno de la Provincia de Mendoza · NDM Holdings and Valle Las Leđas

Interactions of cosmic rays with the Moon and the Sun produce deficits in their arrival-direction distributions relative to an isotropic flux. Such shadows have been observed previously at energies between 10 12, eV and 10 16, eV. We report the first observation of the Moon and Sun shadows at cosmic-ray energies larger than about 10 16, eV (average energy of 7 times10 17, eV), using data collected by the Pierre Auger Observatory. We employ data from three detector arrays covering 3000, km squared, 27, km squared, and 2, km squared, with spacings of 1500, m, 750, m, and 433, m, respectively. The data amount to over 10.6 million events. The Moon and Sun shadows are detected with a combined significance of approximately 3 sigma. These observations confirm the pointing accuracy of the Surface Detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory using celestial bodies. From the combined Sun and Moon shadows, we infer an overall angular resolution of (0.59+0.15-0.11).

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Evidence for the Moon and Sun shadows with cosmic rays at an average energy of 7 times 10 17, eV".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Interactions of cosmic rays with the Moon and the Sun produce deficits in their arrival-direction distributions relative to an isotropic flux Such shadows have been observed previously at energies between 1012 eV and 1016 eV We report the first observation of the Moon and Sun shadows at cosmic-ray energies larger than about 1016 eV (average energy of 7×10 17 eV), using data collected by the Pierre Auger Observatory The Moon and Sun shadows are detected with a combined significance of approximately 3sigma These observations confirm the pointing accuracy of the Surface Detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory using celestial bodies Observation Methodology The study utilized data from three detector arrays covering 3000 km2, 27 km2, and 2 km2, with spacings of 1500 m, 750 m, and 433 m, respectively The total dataset amount to over 10.6 million events The reconstruction procedure is only applied to events in which the SD station with the largest signal is surrounded by at least 5 active stations The arrival direction of each event is reconstructed by fitting the air-shower front to the signal start times recorded by the detector stations Shadow Detection and Significance To measure the flux deficit caused by occultation of cosmic rays by the Moon and the Sun, a constant event count per unit solid angle (dN/dΩ)exp was determined to be 764 000 sr−1 for the region around the Moon and 782 000 sr−1 for the region around the Sun A deficit of events can be observed in the first three bins, corresponding to angular distances δ < 0.8◦, where this deficit is less pronounced for the Sun The statistical significance of observing Nobs events given the uniform expectation Nexp is evaluated using the Li&Ma formalism

33: The combined Li&Ma significance is dominated by the Moon shadow, having a maximum of 3.6sigma at δ = 0.84◦ Angular Resolution Estimation The overall angular resolution enclosing 68% of the events is calculated as σ68 = (0.59+0.15−0.11)° for the combined data This result provides an independent validation of the pointing accuracy and angular resolution of the SD of the Pierre Auger Observatory at a mean cosmicray energy of 7×10 17 eV The most probable value obtained from the simulation is consistent with the result presented here, yielding σ68 = (0.65+0.2−0.1)° for the Moon data Systematic Uncertainties and Conclusion The largest systematic uncertainty on the angular resolution, ±0.03◦, arises from the assumption of a fixed angular radius for the Moon and the Sun The accumulated event statistics will increase the significance of these observations The number of shadowed events is consistent with the expected shadowing based on the size of the celestial bodies and the obtained overall angular resolution Page 1 --- Observation of the Moon and Sun shadows with cosmic rays at an average energy of 7×10 17 eV Interactions of cosmic rays with the Moon and the Sun produce deficits in their arrival-direction distributions relative to an isotropic flux Such shadows have been observed previously at energies between 1012 eV and 1016 eV We report the first observation of the Moon and Sun shadows at cosmic-ray energies larger than about 10 16 eV (average energy of 7×10 17 eV), using data collected by the Pierre Auger Observatory The Moon and Sun shadows are detected with a combined significance of approximately 3sigma These observations confirm the pointing accuracy of the Surface Detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory using celestial bodies Page 2 --- Table I.

Vera: Number of events in each data set, fraction, f, the average number of stations participating in the reconstruction, ⟨n⟩, and the data-taking period.

Jocelyn: Events recorded by SD-1500 are separated into vertical (vert.) and inclined (incl.) categories based on the reconstruction Angular Resolution Estimation The overall angular resolution enclosing 68% of the events is calculated as σ68 = (0.59+0.15−0.11)° for the combined data This result provides an independent validation of the pointing accuracy and angular resolution of the SD of the Pierre Auger Observatory at a mean cosmicray energy of 7×10 17 eV Page 3 --- Figure 1.

Vera: The configuration of the SD arrays Page 4 --- Figure 3.

Paper summary: Vera: So, we’re looking at this new paper, "Evidence for the Moon and Sun shadows with cosmic rays at an average energy of seven times ten to the seventeen electron volts" <ref:2608.04658#pg2>. It claims they found a real deficit in the arrival direction distributions of these cosmic rays compared to what you'd expect from an even distribution.

Jocelyn: It’s about how interactions between cosmic rays and the Moon and the Sun create these shadows, which they’ve seen before at lower energies, like between ten to sixteen electron volts. But this paper reports something new for much higher energies.

Subrahmanyan: So what is the main claim here? They are detecting these shadows at cosmic ray energies larger than about ten to the sixteen electron volts, with an average energy of seven times ten to the seventeen electron volts. That’s quite high up in the spectrum for this kind of effect.

Vera: Exactly. The core finding is that they used data from the Pierre Auger Observatory—specifically three different detector arrays covering three thousand square kilometers, twenty-seven square kilometers, and two square kilometers—and they found a combined significance of approximately three sigma for these Moon and Sun shadows.

Jocelyn: So what’s the bigger picture here? This observation confirms the pointing accuracy of the Surface Detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory when it uses celestial bodies like the Moon and Sun to help determine direction.

Subrahmanyan: That’s interesting because it means we can use these celestial objects as a kind of cosmic compass for our detectors at these energies. It’s a way to check how well our arrays are actually pointing where they think they are, which is important for any precision measurement in this field.

Vera: And when you look at the numbers, the paper estimates an overall angular resolution enclosing sixty-eight percent of the events as five point nine plus one point five minus zero point one eleven degrees. That figure gives us a good idea of how sharp our directional sensitivity is at seven times ten to the seventeen electron volt energy.

Jocelyn: That angular resolution calculation, (five point nine plus one point five minus zero point one eleven) degrees, is an independent way to validate the pointing accuracy of the Surface Detector when looking at these cosmic rays. It’s a good check on how well we’re doing with our directional measurements.

Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical standpoint, this angular resolution estimate helps constrain models of how these high-energy particles interact with the solar wind and interplanetary magnetic fields, which is where the shadowing comes from. It tells us something about the geometry of that interaction.

Vera: The paper also mentions some specific details about how they do their data analysis—for instance, they only reconstruct events if the station with the largest signal is surrounded by at least five active stations. That’s a practical step in filtering out noisy or incomplete event signals.

Jocelyn: They also calculated the expected event counts per solid angle for both the Moon and the Sun—about seven hundred sixty-four thousand steradians per square radian for the Moon and seven hundred eighty-two thousand steradians per square radian for the Sun.

Subrahmanyan: And they find a deficit in events in the first three bins, corresponding to angular distances smaller than zero point eight degrees, and they note that this deficit is less pronounced around the Sun compared to the Moon. That difference is linked to how the Moon's orbit precesses with respect to our own equator.

Vera: So we have a combined significance of about three sigma for the shadows, which is pretty solid evidence for this effect at these high energies, and they link this directly back to those specific angular distances.

Jocelyn: But the paper also points out a limitation. They say the largest systematic uncertainty on that angular resolution comes from assuming a fixed angular radius for both the Moon and the Sun when they do their analysis.

Subrahmanyan: That’s a key caveat, because if you don't know exactly how large those bodies are in terms of their effective shadow size, it adds an uncertainty of plus or minus zero point zero three degrees to that resolution. It shows that our knowledge of the celestial objects is a factor we need to account for.

Vera: So, while they’ve found this evidence at these higher energies, the precision of their measurement still depends on how well they model the actual size of the Moon and Sun in terms of shadowing.

Jocelyn: This observation confirms that when we use celestial bodies for pointing accuracy, we can get reliable results even when looking at very high energy cosmic rays. What this means for future work is that these celestial references are useful tools for calibrating our detectors across a wide range of energies.

Subrahmanyan: It suggests that to fully understand the physics of cosmic ray interactions with solar system bodies, we need better constraints on both the particle flux and the geometry of these shadows, which would require more precise measurements over longer time periods.

Conclusion: Vera: So, we've seen that Pierre Auger Observatory has three sigma evidence for Moon and Sun shadows at very high cosmic ray energies, specifically around seven times ten to the seventeen electron volts.

Jocelyn: It’s a solid confirmation of how well those surface detectors are actually pointing when they use celestial bodies as references.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmological view, this tells us something about the particle interactions in that extreme energy regime and how they're affected by our local solar system environment.

Vera: The authors used data from three different detector arrays to get this result, and their overall angular resolution calculation is five point nine plus one point five minus zero point one eleven degrees.

Jocelyn: That resolution number is what validates the pointing accuracy of the surface detector at that seven times ten to the seventeen electron volt energy.

Subrahmanyan: But remember, there's a systematic uncertainty there, about plus or minus zero point zero three degrees because they have to assume a fixed size for the Moon and Sun in their calculation.

Vera: That’s important; it shows that our knowledge of how big those celestial bodies are matters when we try to measure the pointing accuracy.

Jocelyn: So, what does this actually mean for the larger picture of cosmic ray physics?

Subrahmanyan: It means we can start using these shadows as a kind of cosmic compass to check the geometry and interaction models for particles at these high energies.

Vera: The implication is that if we keep collecting data like this, we should be able to refine our understanding of how cosmic rays behave near planets and the Sun.

Jocelyn: And what would it take next to really settle this down?

Subrahmanyan: We need more precise measurements over longer time periods to see if these shadows show up consistently and at even higher energies.

More episodes

← Home