ENGRAVE follow-up of a type IIb supernova spatially coincident with the sub-threshold gravitational wave trigger S250818k

summary

The gist

The candidate gravitational wave event S250818k was one of only three non-retracted LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA public alerts issued during the fourth observing run of the network (O4) with a binary neutron…

In short

The ENGRAVE collaboration investigated a candidate supernova, SN 2025ulz, spatially coincident with the gravitational wave event S250818k. Multi-wavelength observations confirmed SN 2025ulz is a Type IIb supernova, not related to the merger. Light curve modeling favored a supernova over a kilonova scenario. The probability of association between the two events is estimated at about 73.5%, suggesting they are unrelated.

Key concepts

Type IIb Supernova
This is a specific type of core-collapse supernova characterized by distinct spectral features, including broad Halpha emission and P-Cygni absorption profiles. The paper used these features to confirm the classification of SN 2025ulz, distinguishing it from other transient types.
Kilonova (KN)
A kilonova is a theoretical event expected from binary neutron star mergers that produce heavy elements. The study compared the supernova data against KN models, finding that the observed light curve evolution strongly favored a supernova interpretation rather than a kilonova scenario.
Volumetric Rate
This refers to the estimated frequency of SN 2025ulz-like events occurring per cubic megaparsec per year. The calculated rate is in good agreement with the expected rate of core-collapse supernovae, providing context for how often such events are expected.
Probability of Association
This statistical measure quantifies the likelihood that a detected supernova and a gravitational wave event are related by chance. Based on current data, the probability that SN 2025ulz and S250818k are unrelated is estimated to be approximately 73.5%.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

ENGRAVE follow-up of a type IIb supernova spatially coincident with the sub-threshold gravitational wave trigger S250818k · Read on arXiv

Kendall Ackley, Maria Teresa Botticella, Andreas Boye, Marica Branchesi, Gabriele Bruni, Enrico Cappellaro, Sylvain Chaty, Ting-Wan Chen, Filippo D’Ammando, Valerio D’Elia, Massimiliano F. De Pasquale, Dimple Rob A. J. Eyles-Ferris, Morgan Fraser, Giulia Gianfagna, James H Gillanders, Giuseppe Greco, Mariusz Gromadzki, Claudia P Gutiérrez Aprajita Hajela Luca Izzo Peter G Jonker Shiho Kobayashi Rubina Kotak Gavin P Lamb Giorgos Leloudas Andrew J Levan Joe D Lyman Kate Maguire Antonio Martin-Carrillo Andrea Melandri Micha J Michaowski Samantha R Oates Francesca Onori Barbara Patricelli Elena Pian Giuliano Pignata Silvia Piranomonte Luigi Piro Quentin Pognan Maria L Pumo Samuele Ronchini Andrea Rossi Rupak Roy Andrea Saccardi Om Sharan Salafia Ruben Salvaterra Nikhil Sarin Steve Schulze Stephen J Smartt Rhaana L C Starling Danny Steeghs Nial R Tanvir Aishwarya Linesh Thakur Susanna D Vergani Shuxu Yi David R Young

ESO · LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Collaboration · Zwicky Transient Facility · Very Large Telescope Collaboration · INAF Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte · DTU Space Department of Space Research and Space Technology Technical University of Denmark Graduate Institute of Astronomy National Central University INAF Istituto di Astrofisica e Planetologia Spaziali INAF Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova Université Paris Cité CNRS Centre national détudes spatiales Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics Kavli Institute for Cosmology Astrophysics Research Centre School of Mathematics and Physics Queen’s University Belfast Department of Particle Physics and Astrophysics Weizmann Institute of Science National Centre for Radio Astrophysics Tata Institute of Fundamental Research

The candidate gravitational wave (GW) event S250818k was one of only three non-retracted LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA public alerts issued during the fourth observing run of the network (O4) with a binary neutron star (BNS) merger classification probability exceeding one percent. This triggered a prompt search for a potential electromagnetic (EM) counterpart in the large localisation error region (949 deg squared projected in the sky at 90% credible level). The transient SN2025ulz, discovered by the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) during the search, attracted a great deal of attention due to a potential spatial and temporal coincidence, and due to its initial fast decay and featureless spectrum. Here, we report on the follow up of this transient by the Electromagnetic counterparts of gravitational wave sources at the Very Large Telescope (ENGRAVE) Collaboration. We conducted an extensive multi-wavelength observational campaign, which led to the spectral classification of the transient as a type IIb supernova (SN), indicating that it is unrelated to the candidate GW event. In this article, we describe our observing strategies, data reduction, and interpretation. All of our results confirm and strengthen our classification of the source, and also show that shock cooling tails associated with type IIb SNe are one of the most prominent contaminants in kilonova searches.

DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202660729

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "ENGRAVE follow-up of a type IIb supernova spatially coincident with the sub-threshold gravitational wave trigger S250818k".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The candidate gravitational wave event S250818k was one of only three non-retracted LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA public alerts issued during the fourth observing run of the network (O4) with a binary neutron star (BNS) merger classification probability exceeding one percent Source Identification and Classification The candidate transient SN 2025ulz attracted attention due to a potential spatial and temporal coincidence with S250818k, and its initial fast decay and featureless spectrum led the ENGRAVE Collaboration to classify it as a type IIb supernova (SN), indicating that it is unrelated to the candidate GW event The spectral classification of the transient was confirmed by cross-correlation with other transients, finding good agreement with early spectra of SNe IIb, including those of SN 2016gkg and SN 2011dh The spectroscopic classification of SN 2025ulz is therefore secure and unambiguous, with Type IIb as the favored subtype Observational Campaign and Data Reduction The ENGRAVE Collaboration conducted an extensive multi-wavelength observational campaign to study the source Observations were performed using various instruments, including VLT/FORS2, VLT/HAWK-I, NOT/ALFOSC, and HST For example, VLT/FORS2 observations were conducted on 21 and 22 August 2025 in the R, I, and z bands Data reduction involved techniques such as ESOReflex for imaging and ECSNOoPY for PSF fitting Multi-Wavelength Follow-up Results The multi-wavelength observations revealed several key characteristics of SN 2025ulz 1.

Vera: Light curve evolution showed a rapid initial fading in the first few days, followed by a rebrightening across all bands until around 20 days 2.

Jocelyn: The colour evolution revealed rapid reddening in the first two days, with both g−r and g−z going from around −0.5 at 1 day to g−r ≈ 0.2 and g−z ≈ 0.5 at 2 days 3.

Vera: Radio observations from VLA, MeerKAT, uGMRT, and e-MERLIN did not yield significant detections at the location of SN 2025ulz down to the upper limits of approximately 3µJy in S-band Interpretation and Constraints on Alternative Scenarios Light curve modelling strongly favored a type IIb SN interpretation over a kilonova (KN) scenario, as the rebrightening observed between 3.5 and 20 days is not predicted by any current KN model Furthermore, constraints from radio observations on the jet inclination suggest that an off-axis GRB was not ruled out based on radio data alone The volumetric rate of SN 2025ulz-like events is estimated to be in the range of 2 × 10−5 to 4×10−4 Mpc−3 yr−1, which is in good agreement with the rate of core-collapse supernovae (CCSN) The simplest and most conservative conclusion is that SN 2025ulz is not related to S250818k, with a probability of being unrelated of approximately 73.5% The statistical point of view suggests that the available observations do not yet support an association between SSM BNS mergers and type IIb SNe Future strategies should focus on reducing the counterpart search area to maximize efficiency Volumetric Rate Estimates The volumetric rate of Type IIb SN shock cooling tails is estimated to be about RSNIIb−SC ∼ 0.3 × 10−5 yr−1 Mpc−3 This rate suggests that within the 90% localization area of S250828k, there will be around 19 yr−1 Type IIb shock cooling tails The final assumption made is for how long a shockcooling tail can be mistaken for a KN, which is assumed to be 6 days Implications for Kilonova Searches The difficulty in the search for a kilonova resides in discriminating contaminants, as 30-50 percent of Type IIb SNe feature a shock cooling tail The experience of O3 and O4 suggests that every GW will have at least one initially plausible candidate for the counterpart that ultimately turns out to be unrelated A possible strategy is to target passive galaxies, as the IIb shock-cooling tails are inevitably followed by luminous 56Ni powered rising lightcurves which peak on the timescales of 20 days Model Comparison and Ejecta Properties Fitting a KN model to data up to 4 days post GW trigger showed that the inferred parameters for a BNS or NS-BH merger were not consistent with expectations, especially regarding ejecta masses and opacities The posterior median and 68% credible ejecta mass of the first component were Mej,1 = 0.10+0.04−0.03M⊙, vej,1 = (0.05± 0.03)c and κ1 = 0.78+ 0.14− - - - 2 cm2g−1 The inferred ejecta mass, 56Ni mass, kinetic energy, and the envelope radius are broadly consistent with those inferred by Kasliwal et al.

Title and authors: Jocelyn: The title itself is pretty descriptive: "ENGRAVE follow-up of a type IIb supernova spatially coincident with the sub-threshold gravitational wave trigger S250818k". It tells you exactly what they did, which was follow up on that GW event and found a type IIb supernova.

Vera: And the authors are all involved in this follow up. This paper is showing how researchers use multiple telescopes to look for these transients after a gravitational wave alert goes off. It’s about using big surveys and deep imaging to find anything interesting near where the gravitational wave event happened.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmological view, this is important because it helps us understand the link between mergers of neutron stars and the resulting explosions we see in our universe. It connects a purely gravitational signal to something we can actually observe with light.

Jocelyn: They’re essentially taking the localization from the gravitational wave and using that to guide their search for a transient, which they identified as SN 2025ulz <ref:2605.02639#pg1>. This is how we bridge the gap between different types of astronomical signals.

Vera: And what they want to show is that this process can actually work, even when you’re looking at a relatively faint signal or a sub-threshold trigger like S250818k. It proves that these links aren't just theoretical possibilities; they are something we can actively search for with the right tools and follow up.

The paper's summary: Vera: Okay, so the summary of this paper explains that they took a gravitational wave trigger, S250818k, and used it to look for a supernova called SN 2025ulz <ref:2605.02639#pg1>. They found that while SN 2025ulz looked like a Type IIb supernova—which is a specific kind of stellar explosion—it’s not necessarily the expected kilonova we might think of from a binary neutron star merger <ref:2605.02639#pg1>.

Jocelyn: That’s the main point, isn't it? They looked at the light curve evolution and the color changes to figure out what kind of explosion it was. The spectral classification they did confirm is Type IIb with high confidence, based on features like H alpha P-Cygni profiles and H beta.

Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical standpoint, this distinction between a standard supernova and a kilonova is crucial because it tells us about the ejecta properties of the event. If it's a Type IIb supernova, then the physics driving that explosion is likely different than what we expect from just ejecta from a neutron star merger.

Vera: The summary also touches on how they used their multi-wavelength data to study this transient. They used telescopes like VLT and HST to get observations across different bands, like R, I, and z bands, to track the light curve over time. They even looked at radio waves with VLA and MeerKAT.

Jocelyn: And the summary points out some key findings from these observations that help them decide what this transient actually is. For example, they saw a rapid initial fading in the first few days, followed by a rebrightening across all bands until around twenty days.

The paper's improvements: Subrahmanyan: Now let's talk about what the authors suggest are the improvements to their study. They point out that they used advanced techniques for data reduction and imaging, specifically things like ECSNOoPY for PSF fitting. This is important because it helps them get a better picture of the source against its host galaxy background.

Vera: Right, and that improved subtraction technique is key for getting accurate photometric measurements of the transient itself. They used these deep templates from Pan-STARRS data to do that, which means they can subtract the host galaxy much more effectively before measuring the supernova’s light curve.

Jocelyn: And another improvement they highlight is how their AI helped them classify the transient. The paper suggests using AI to perform a more robust classification by looking at spectral features like H alpha P-Cygni profiles, which gives them higher confidence in calling it a Type IIb supernova.

Subrahmanyan: From a modeling perspective, they also improved how they tested different physical scenarios. They used these multi-band light curves and fitted them against both supernova and kilonova models to see which one fits the data better. The paper shows that the supernova model describes the data well, which is significant because it constrains what those ejecta properties are likely to be.

Conclusion: Vera: So, wrapping up this paper on "ENGRAVE follow-up of a type IIb supernova spatially coincident with the sub-threshold gravitational wave trigger S250818k", the main conclusion is that while there's a strong possibility of an association, it leans toward SN 2025ulz being unrelated to S250818k <ref:2605.02639#pg1,ENGRAVE follow-up of a type IIb supernova spatially coincident with the>.

Jocelyn: The probability they calculate for the chance of a random event happening by accident is about seventy-three point five percent for no actual link between them. That means the simplest and most conservative conclusion is that they are not related, with a probability of about seventy-three point five percent as they state in their analysis.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmological perspective, this tells us that the volumetric rate of these type IIb supernova shock cooling tails is quite low—about RSNIIb-SC equal to zero point three times ten to the negative five per year cubic megaparsec—which is in good agreement with what we expect for core-collapse supernovae.

Vera: It also gives us a hint for future searches. They suggest that since some type IIb SNe have a shock cooling tail that can look like a kilonova, we should focus our future work on those regions where the gravitational wave localization is good, but maybe target those areas more specifically rather than just searching the whole error box.

Jocelyn: And they also mention that for the 'superkilonova' scenario proposed by Kasliwal et al., this paper doesn't provide support for it because they haven't detected the GW emission from a high-mass-ratio merger.

Subrahmanyan: That’s a solid point. The lack of detection of that specific predicted GW emission is something that doesn't rule out the model, but it does mean we need to keep looking for those distinguishing features in future supernovae.

Vera: So, in short, this paper on "ENGRAVE follow-up of a type IIb supernova spatially coincident with the sub-threshold gravitational wave trigger S250818k" suggests that SN 2025ulz is most likely just a standard supernova and not directly linked to S250818k <ref:2605.02639#pg1,ENGRAVE follow-up of a type IIb supernova spatially coincident with the>.

Jocelyn: Exactly, and the next step for the community is to refine those search strategies based on these results. That’s what we need to keep pushing toward.

More episodes

← Home