Alfv'enic solar wind intervals observed by Solar Orbiter: Exploiting the capability of the SWA plasma suite and source region investigation

summary

The gist

Alfvénic slow wind intervals observed by Solar Orbiter provide key insights into the physical processes shaping Alfvénic solar wind streams by linking their characteristics to their solar origins…

In short

Solar Orbiter observed several Alfvénic solar wind intervals to understand their origins. Researchers analyzed plasma properties and magnetic field connections, finding that slow wind streams have characteristics similar to fast winds but originate from different coronal hole structures, providing insights into the diverse nature of solar wind streams.

Key concepts

Alfvénicity
This refers to fluctuations in the solar wind where velocity and magnetic field components are correlated. Analyzing these fluctuations helps characterize how energy is distributed within the plasma streams and identifies underlying physical processes shaping their structure.
Plasma Charge-State Ratios
The ratios of oxygen and carbon charge states in the solar wind indicate its origin. Lower ratios in intervals like AS1-AS3 suggest a slow wind origin, while lower ratios in the fast interval point toward coronal hole-associated (fast) solar wind.
Magnetic Connectivity Mapping
This technique uses magnetic field measurements and extrapolation methods to trace the path of solar wind streams back to their specific source regions in the Sun's corona. This helps determine if a stream originates from a coronal hole or another magnetic structure.
Turbulence Characterization
Researchers analyzed fluctuations across different frequencies using normalized power spectra. This allowed them to derive scaling laws like Kolmogorov and Kraichnan, characterizing the nature of turbulence present in the solar wind and how energy is balanced within these fluctuations.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Alfv'enic solar wind intervals observed by Solar Orbiter: Exploiting the capability of the SWA plasma suite and source region investigation · Read on arXiv

R. D’Amicis, J. M. Raines, S. Benella, M. Velli, O. Panasenco, G. Nicolaou, C. J. Owen, R. M.© Dewey, P.¨ Louarn, Ɠ Fedorov, S. T.’ Lepri, B. L.‘ Alterman, D. Perrone, R. De Marco, R. Bruno, L. Sorriso-Valvo, O. S.© Dhamane, Y.Ɔ Rivera, O. R.© Kieokaew, D. Verscharen, G. Consolini, S.◑ Yardley, V.É Réville, D. Telloni, D. Baker, G. Lewis, G.◑ Watson, C. Anekallu, orgs]: [

Institute for National Astrophysics (INAF) · University of Michigan · University of California Los Angeles · Advanced Heliophysics · University College London, Mullard Space Science Laboratory · Institut de Recherche en Astrophysique et Planétologie, CNRS, Université de Toulouse · Heliophysics Science Division NASA Goddard Space Flight Center · ASI - Italian Space Agency · CNR - National research Council ISTP - Institute for Plasmas Science and Technology · KTH Royal Institute of Technology School of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science Department of Electromagnetics and Plasma Physics · Center for Astrophysics USA · Institute for National Astrophysics INAF Osservatorio Astrofisico di Torino Charles University Czech Republich Southwest Research Institute Imperial College London LEONARDO SpA Planetek Italia S.R.L. TSD-Space

Fast and slow solar wind have distinct properties linked to their solar sources.Alfvénic slow wind complicates the usual speed-based classification, especially at intermediate speeds. Solar Orbiter's Solar Wind Analyzer (SWA) offers unique capabilities to investigate how Alfvénic slow wind differs from fast wind and relate these differences to their solar origins. In September 2022, Solar Orbiter observed several Alfvénic streams: one fast wind, three Alfvénic slow wind (AS1, AS2, AS3), and a moderate fast (FH) interval. We analyze these streams, combining plasma parameters from all SWA sensors with magnetic field measurements from the Magnetometer (MAG). A spectral analysis of magnetic and velocity fluctuations is used to characterize Alfvénicity. The magnetic connectivity of each stream to its solar source is examined using Potential Field Source Surface extrapolation combined with ballistic backmapping from the spacecraft. Proton velocity distribution functions show anisotropies and field-aligned beams characteristic of Alfvénic streams, while electron pitch-angle distributions reveal clear strahl populations. Oxygen and carbon charge-state ratios are low in fast wind but higher in AS1-AS3, consistent with slow wind origins. Magnetic connectivity suggests the fast wind originates from a large coronal hole; AS1 links to a pseudostreamer with high expansion factor; AS2, AS3, and FH connect to a negative-polarity coronal hole whose field lines cross a pseudostreamer that later dissipates. Spectral analysis indicates near energy equipartition in all intervals except AS2. The combined SWA observations offer key insights into the physical processes shaping Alfvénic solar wind streams. Our results reinforce that the simple fast/slow wind classification is inadequate for linking solar wind to sources, and suggest that Alfvénicity relates to the solar source conditions.

DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202558566

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Alfv'enic solar wind intervals observed by Solar Orbiter".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Alfvénic slow wind intervals observed by Solar Orbiter provide key insights into the physical processes shaping Alfvénic solar wind streams by linking their characteristics to their solar origins Context and Aims The study analyzes several Alfvénic intervals observed by Solar Orbiter during the second half of September 2022, preceding the second perihelion passage of the nominal phase of the mission The authors aim to highlight similarities and differences between various streams, including one fast wind, three Alfvénic slow wind (AS1, AS2, AS3), and a moderate fast (FH) interval.

Vera: The researchers combine plasma parameters from all SWA sensors with magnetic field measurements from the Magnetometer (MAG) They use spectral analysis of magnetic and velocity fluctuations to characterize Alfvénicity.

Jocelyn: The magnetic connectivity of each stream to its solar source is examined using Potential Field Source Surface extrapolation combined with ballistic backmapping from the spacecraft.

Vera: Key Results on Plasma Properties The proton velocity distribution functions show anisotropies and field-aligned beams characteristic of Alfvénic streams Electron pitch-angle distributions reveal clear strahl populations Oxygen and carbon charge-state ratios are low in the fast wind but higher in AS1–AS3, consistent with slow wind origins; FH shows intermediate values.

Title and authors: Vera: So we're talking about what this paper, "Alfvénic solar wind intervals observed by Solar Orbiter: Exploiting the capability of the SWA plasma suite and source region investigation," is actually trying to tell us. It’s not just about describing the streams, it’s about figuring out the connection between their look and their birth.

Jocelyn: They are focusing on those Alfvénic slow wind streams, AS1, AS2, and AS3, alongside a moderate fast interval FH. The main goal is to highlight how these different streams are related to where they originate in the solar atmosphere.

Subrahmanyan: It’s about understanding the physical processes shaping these streams by linking their measured characteristics to their solar origins. That means connecting what we see far away back to the Sun's corona.

Vera: The methodology involves combining plasma parameters with magnetic field measurements and then using spectral analysis of magnetic and velocity fluctuations to define what makes them Alfvénic.

Jocelyn: And they look at the magnetic connectivity of each stream to its solar source by using a technique called Potential Field Source Surface extrapolation combined with ballistic backmapping from the spacecraft.

Subrahmanyan: That's a specific way to map those magnetic links, trying to trace the field lines back toward their origin region on the Sun.

The paper's summary: Vera: So what does this paper actually find? It looks at several things about the plasma properties and then connects that to where they come from.

Jocelyn: They see anisotropies and field-aligned beams in the proton velocity distribution functions, which is a sign of Alfvénic streams. Electron pitch-angle distributions also show clear strahl populations.

Subrahmanyan: And what’s telling for the slow wind origins is that the oxygen and carbon charge-state ratios are low in the fast wind, but higher in AS1 through AS3, which is consistent with them coming from a slow wind origin.

Vera: The moderate fast interval FH shows intermediate values for those charge-state ratios, which helps differentiate it from the others. Magnetic connectivity suggests the fast wind comes from a large coronal hole.

Jocelyn: For the slower streams, AS1 links to a pseudostreamer with a high expansion factor. AS2, AS3, and FH connect to a negative polarity coronal hole where field lines cross another pseudostreamer that later dissipates.

Subrahmanyan: The spectral analysis shows near energy equipartition in all intervals except for AS2, which is an important detail for the turbulence physics we are trying to understand.

The paper's improvements: Vera: Now, the paper suggests some improvements to how this kind of study can be done better. They propose ways to make the source region identification more robust.

Jocelyn: They suggest a method that combines elemental composition, specifically oxygen seven plus and oxygen six plus ratios with Alfvénicity, to create a simplified, unambiguous map for identifying solar wind source regions.

Subrahmanyan: That’s clever because it gives us a way to narrow down the source region identification by using the chemical signatures alongside the turbulence measurements.

Vera: Another improvement is analyzing charge state ratios more carefully to differentiate between solar wind regimes. They note that the oxygen and carbon charge-state ratios were significantly lower during the Fast interval, which is characteristic of that coronal hole-associated fast solar wind compared to other intervals.

Jocelyn: And they also propose incorporating alpha particles into kinetic energy calculations, which leads to a result where the inclusion of alpha particles in the calculation leads the residual energy back toward equipartition.

Subrahmanyan: If you include those alpha particles, it helps fix that energy balance issue they found in AS2, making it look more balanced with what we expect.

Conclusion: Vera: So to wrap up this paper, the main implication is that the Alfvénic slow wind is emerging as a third class of solar wind. It has speeds typical of the nominal slow wind but other properties similar to fast winds.

Jocelyn: They find that beams in both proton and electron velocity distribution functions are typical for both fast and Alfvénic streams, which suggests a shared physical mechanism between them.

Subrahmanyan: The comparison between the fast and non-Alfvénic slow solar wind streams shows that the beams observed in Alfvénic slow wind are systematically broader and less intense than those detected in the fast wind.

Vera: They conclude that the variability among these different streams cannot simply be explained by radial evolution effects alone, so there is something more complex happening at play.

Jocelyn: The study of "Alfvénic solar wind intervals observed by Solar Orbiter: Exploiting the capability of the SWA plasma suite and source region investigation" gives us a clearer picture of how these streams are connected to their solar origins.

Subrahmanyan: It’s a solid piece of work because it suggests that whatever is driving this variability is not just simple radial movement, but something more intrinsic to the flow itself.

More episodes

← Home