Accretion across scales: streamers, surface-layer transport, and rapid replenishment in young protoplanetary discs
summary
The gist
Protoplanetary discs evolve around newly-formed stars through an interplay of infall from surrounding turbulent cloud material, accretion towards the young star…
In short
Researchers used 3D MHD simulations to study protoplanetary disc evolution around young stars in turbulent environments. They found that transient high-density streamers drive anisotropic mass delivery comparable to background accretion, and that discs are continuously replenished by surface layer transport on ~10 kyr timescales. This replenishment, turbulence, and streamer events generally hinder planet formation in the outer disc.
Key concepts
- Transient High-Density Streamers
- These are temporary streams of dense material that pass through the disc. They can cause significant disruptions to the disc structure, such as truncating its size and rearranging its angular momentum budget, and they drive mass delivery rates similar to the steady background accretion flow.
- Rapid Replenishment
- The outer parts of young discs are constantly fed material from surrounding cloud environments. This replenishment timescale is short, around 10 kyr in the outer disc, which is fast enough to continuously supply gas and turbulence, preventing conditions suitable for planet formation.
- Accretion Bursts
- Some systems exhibit sudden, large increases in accretion rates (up to two orders of magnitude) over short timescales. These bursts are linked to local regions within the disc that become weakly gravitationally unstable, driving spiral waves that transport angular momentum and fuel the increased accretion.
- Magnetic Field Morphology
- The magnetic field changes significantly over time. Initially, it is uniform and positive in the disc. Later, it winds up azimuthally and reverses across the midplane, creating a current sheet in the midplane which influences how mass flows through the disc layers.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Accretion across scales: streamers, surface-layer transport, and rapid replenishment in young protoplanetary discs · Paper Radio
- Numerical Insights into Disk Accretion, Eccentricity, and Kinematics in the Class 0 phase
- The Impact of Radiation Environment on the Evolution and Fragmentation of Protostellar Discs
- Conditions for planetesimal formation via the streaming instability persist under turbulence driven by magnetorotational instability · Paper Radio
- Protostellar disks in their natural habitat -- the formation of protostars and their accretion disks in the turbulent and magnetized interstellar medium
The paper
Accretion across scales: streamers, surface-layer transport, and rapid replenishment in young protoplanetary discs · Read on arXiv
C. Granzow Holm, M. Lambrechts, M. Kuffmeier, A. Johansen, T. Haugbölle, Å. Nordlund
Centre for Star and Planet Formation, Globe Institute, University of Copenhagen · Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen
Protoplanetary discs evolve around newly-formed stars through an interplay of infall from surrounding turbulent cloud material, accretion towards the young star, and outflow driven mass-loss. It has been challenging to determine if discs are fed predominantly through infall along the disc midplane, or along the poles, and if accretion occurs in a steady or burst-like fashion. Here, we present a suite of 3D ideal magnetohydrodynamical simulations of protoplanetary disc formation and evolution in a dynamic, large-scale molecular cloud environment using the adaptive mesh refinement framework DISPATCH. We focus on nine stellar systems, where we resolve discs down to a scale of 0.8 au. Across the sample, stellar accretion proceeds at rates of about 10-5 M yr-1 over 10 5 yr, with significant variability. Discs grow to 100 au scales and remain gravitationally stable in time, with disc-to-star mass ratios below 10 %. Transient high-density streamers, with 10 kyr infall times, can drive anisotropic mass delivery at rates comparable to the background accretion flow. Their interaction with discs typically results in a temporary reduction of the disc size by half, and disc mass by 40 %. During later quiescent disc evolution stages (t 50 kyr), accretion predominantly occurs through the midplane and disc surface layers. This is associated with the development of a toroidal magnetic field morphology, which includes field reversals across both disc surfaces. In this way, the full disc mass reservoir is replenished on 10 kyr-timescales. These findings support that the outer parts of very young discs, when well-ionised and close to the ideal MHD regime, are not yet conducive to planet formation, due to high replenishment rates, strong turbulence, and disruptive streamer infall events.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Accretion across scales".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Protoplanetary discs evolve around newly-formed stars through an interplay of infall from surrounding turbulent cloud material, accretion towards the young star, and outflow driven mass-loss <ref:2608.02204#pg2> The most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is that transient high-density streamers, with 10 kyr infall times, can drive anisotropic mass delivery at rates comparable to the background accretion flow <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Simulation Methodology The researchers present a suite of 3D ideal magnetohydrodynamical simulations of protoplanetary disc formation and evolution in a dynamic, large-scale molecular cloud environment using the adaptive mesh refinement framework dispatch <ref:2608.02204#pg6> They focus on nine stellar systems, where discs are resolved down to a scale of 0.8 au <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Stellar accretion proceeds at rates of ∼10−5 M⊙ yr−1 over 105 yr, with significant variability <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Transient high-density streamers can drive anisotropic mass delivery at rates comparable to the background accretion flow <ref:2608.02204#pg2> During later quiescent disc evolution stages (t ≳50 kyr), accretion predominantly occurs through the midplane and disc surface layers <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Disc Dynamics and Replenishment The outer parts of very young discs, when well-ionised and close to the ideal MHD regime, are not yet conducive to planet formation, due to high replenishment rates, strong turbulence, and disruptive streamer infall events <ref:2608.02204#pg2> The disc undergoes a formation epoch (t After t ≈ 50 kyr, the surface layers above and below the disc midplane are dominated by inwards flowing material, supplying ∼10−5 M⊙ yr−1 of gas to the star <ref:2608.02204#pg2> The replenishment timescale in the outer disc (r ≳ 20 au) is approximately τouter rep ≈ 10 kyr, well within our simulation time of t = 100 kyr <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Streamer Influence on Disc Structure Massive streamer events, such as s13a, deposit a total mass of 0.4 M⊙, disrupting the existing disc morphology <ref:2608.02204#pg2> This interaction leads to the disc getting truncated, followed by a period of about 10 kyr where the disc rapidly grows in radius <ref:2608.02204#pg2> The deposition of streamer material corresponds to a major re-arrangement of the angular momentum budget of the disc <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Evolutionary Diversity and Accretion Bursts All systems, except system 162, show short accretion peaks where the accretion rates suddenly increase by one to two orders of magnitude on a short timescale of approximately ∼ 100 yr <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Systems 13, 14 and 122 exhibit prominent accretion bursts with strength of M˙star∼10−4 M⊙ yr−1, recurring with an approximate minimum timescale of 10 kyr <ref:2608.02204#pg2> The origin of these outbursts is correlated with short-lived local regions of the disc that are weakly gravitationally unstable and drive temporary spiral waves that transport angular momentum and drive increased accretion rates <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Magnetic Field Morphology During disc formation (t ≲ 50 kyr), a near uniform positive toroidal magnetic field threads the disc <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Later evolution (t ≳ 50 kyr) shows the winding up of an azimuthal magnetic field and a reversal across the disc midplane <ref:2608.02204#pg2> The toroidal field alters back to positive across the lower disc surface (θ ≲ −30◦), producing a reverted azimuthal field symmetry across the midplane <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Implications for Planet Formation In general, these young discs in our simulations are not conducive to planet formation <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Dust coagulation is hindered by the high degree of turbulence, leading to efficient fragmentation down to sub-mm sized particles <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Planet formation, at least in the outer parts of protoplanetary discs, requires more quiescent conditions likely found at later, less infall-dominated times <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Common to all systems, however, is that young discs are continuously fed cloud material and that discs are repeatedly replenished by accretion flows predominantly along the disc surface <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Additionally, streamers provide an important interplay between the environment and the disc – with massive destroyerclass streamers truncating discs and re-arranging their angular momentum budget <ref:2608.02204#pg2> Acknowledgements M.
Vera: L.
Jocelyn: acknowledges funding by the European Research Council (ERC Starting Grant 101041466-EXODOSS) <ref:2608.02204#pg2> The work by M.
Vera: K.
Title and authors: Vera: So we're looking at this paper titled "Accretion across scales: streamers, surface-layer transport, and rapid replenishment in young protoplanetary discs". What’s the main idea here? It seems to be tackling how gas gets onto stars in these discs.
Jocelyn: Yeah, it looks like they're exploring the different ways this feeding happens. It’s not just one steady flow, but a mix of things.
Subrahmanyan: That sounds like they’re trying to figure out if we can ever get a consistent picture of accretion or if it’s always bursty and chaotic.
Vera: Exactly. They use these three dee ideal magnetohydrodynamical simulations in a dynamic cloud environment, focusing on nine stellar systems, resolved down to about zero point eight au. That gives us a good view of the scales they're working with <ref:2608.02204#pg2>.
Jocelyn: And they are looking at accretion rates around ten minus five solar masses per year over a time of one hundred five years, which is pretty long for these simulations <ref:2608.02204#pg3>.
Subrahmanyan: That timescale gives us a chance to see if the physics changes as the disc evolves from forming to being more settled.
Vera: Right. The title suggests they are looking at three specific things: streamers, surface-layer transport, and rapid replenishment. I wonder how much of each part dominates what they find?
The paper's summary: Jocelyn: Well, the summary is pretty detailed about the interplay between infall from the cloud material and accretion towards the star <ref:2608.02204#pg1>. They are trying to determine if gas flows predominantly along the disc midplane or along the poles, and whether this accretion is steady or burst-like <ref:2608.02204#pg1>.
Vera: That seems like a big question for understanding planet formation potential. They find that transient high-density streamers, with infall times of about ten kyr, can actually drive anisotropic mass delivery rates that are comparable to the background accretion flow <ref:2608.02204#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: Anisotropic delivery means it’s not uniform across the disc; some parts get fed much more than others, which really messes with our models of how planets build up.
Jocelyn: And they also point out that during later, quieter stages of disc evolution, say after time t greater than fifty kyr, accretion happens mostly through the midplane and the surface layers <ref:2608.02204#pg2>.
Vera: So they're showing a transition in how things are fed onto the star depending on how long the disc has been evolving. It’s a bit of a switch in physics, really.
Subrahmanyan: That transition is key for structure formation models because it tells us when we can expect more predictable accretion behavior to occur, which would be helpful for understanding core accretion scenarios <ref:2608.02204#pg2>.
The paper's improvements: Vera: Now they also discuss how their simulation setup has been improved. They suggest incorporating a "rapid replenishment" mechanism on timescales of about ten kyr by looking at the toroidal magnetic field morphology, which includes field reversals across both disc surfaces <ref:2608.02204#pg5>.
Jocelyn: That sounds like they're trying to model that continuous feeding process better, especially since we see these replenishment timescales are really short in the outer disc, around ten kyr <ref:2608.02204#pg3>.
Subrahmanyan: If they can model that replenishment mechanism better, it helps us understand how the disc mass reservoir is maintained over long periods, which is a big piece of the puzzle for structure formation theory <ref:2608.02204#pg5>.
Vera: And they also look at how massive streamer events, like s13a, can disrupt the whole disc structure by depositing a total mass of zero point four solar masses <ref:2608.02204#pg5>.
Jocelyn: So the sequence is a big disruption from the streamer, then a period where the disc rapidly grows in radius for about ten kyr, which re-arranges the whole angular momentum budget <ref:2608.02204#pg5>.
Subrahmanyan: That rapid growth phase after truncation is interesting because it suggests that while a massive event can disrupt things, the system might bounce back quickly depending on how the disc structure handles that angular momentum change.
Conclusion: Vera: So, wrapping up this paper "Accretion across scales: streamers, surface-layer transport, and rapid replenishment in young protoplanetary discs", it seems the main conclusion is that young discs are continuously fed cloud material and that they get repeatedly replenished by accretion flows predominantly along the disc surface <ref:2608.02204#pg1>.
Jocelyn: And those massive streamers really show how important the environment is—they act as a major interplay, truncating discs and re-arranging their angular momentum budget <ref:2608.02204#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical side, the implication is that we need to consider these variable accretion patterns and replenishment timescales when modeling planet formation in the outer regions of protoplanetary discs <ref:2608.02204#pg5>.
Vera: And for someone listening just to the show, it means those young discs aren't static; they are constantly being fed material from the surrounding cloud and kept replenished by accretion along the surface <ref:2608.02204#pg1>.
Jocelyn: It’s a reminder that even during quiescent periods, we see these bursts of activity, like those accretion bursts correlated with marginal instability that drive increased accretion rates <ref:2608.02204#pg4>.
Subrahmanyan: I just think the work on "Accretion across scales: streamers, surface-layer transport, and rapid replenishment in young protoplanetary discs" gives us a much more realistic picture of how gas moves in these environments than simpler models might suggest <ref:2608.02204#pg1>.
Vera: It definitely does. We'll keep an eye on how these simulation results inform our actual observational constraints from surveys and spectroscopy next time.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO