Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective 13 C NMR in alpha -(BETS) 2 I 3

arXiv:2611.16939 · cond-mat.str-el · Submitted 2026-11-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective 13 C NMR in alpha -(BETS) 2 I 3".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective 13C NMR in α-(BETS)2I3 reports evidence that the low-temperature insulating phase of α-(BETS)2I3 preserves both inversion and time-reversal symmetries using site-selective 13C nuclear magnetic resonance The NMR spectra exhibit no additional splitting down to 2 K and remain fully described by one quartet and two doublets associated with the three types of molecular sites, A (=A′), B and C sites, demonstrating the preservation of inversion symmetry Furthermore, no anomalous line broadening or critical enhancement of the nuclear spinlattice relaxation rate is observed, indicating the absence of magnetic ordering and time-reversalsymmetry breaking Nature of the Insulating State The paper investigates whether the insulating phase of α-(BETS)2I3 arises from spontaneous symmetry breaking or remains a symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state The results demonstrate that the low-temperature insulating phase preserves both inversion and time-reversal symmetries down to at least 2 K The absence of magnetic and charge ordering indicates that the low-temperature phase is a symmetrypreserving gapped Dirac state This conclusion is supported by the observation that no additional resonance lines appear at any temperature, and linewidths remain nearly constant across TMI without an abrupt broadening indicative of the emergence of static internal magnetic fields Spin Susceptibility and Electronic Structure Site-selective spin susceptibilities reveal a characteristic relation, χC > χA > χB, which is a characteristic feature of tilted Dirac cones such as in α-(ET)2I3 under pressure This relation persists over the entire temperature range and suggests that its low-energy electronic structure is likewise governed by tilted Dirac-cone bands The overall magnitude of the local susceptibility is substantially reduced, indicating a lower density of states in α-(BETS)2I3, which is consistent with increases in overlap integrals between molecular orbitals by the Se substitution The absence of a negative B-site susceptibility indicates that the inter-band Coulomb interactions may be weaker than α-(ET)2I3 Spin-Orbit Coupling and Gap Opening The suppression of low-energy spin excitations, such as the ferrimagnetic-like spin excitations observed in α-(ET)2I3, is absent in α-(BETS)2I3 The absence of these excitations suggests that a gap opens around the Dirac point, which is naturally expected when a gap opens around the Dirac point, suppressing the density of states available for low-energy excitations This behavior is consistent with the enhanced spin–orbit coupling due to selenium atoms possessing stronger spin–orbit coupling than sulfur atoms in α-(ET)2I3 Constraints on Topological Phases The symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state demonstrated by the present NMR measurements is compatible with the possibility that α-(BETS)2I3 may host a correlated quantum spin Hall state stabilized by the interplay between spin–orbit coupling and electron correlations While NMR primarily probes bulk electronic properties and is not directly sensitive to topological edge modes, the present data offers the microscopic constraints that any candidate ground states must satisfy The work suggests that a correlated quantum spin Hall phase is among possible ground states, although direct verification will require complementary probes sensitive to edge-state transport or spin-current phenomena These results establish that the insulating ground state of α-(BETS)2I3 preserves both inversion symmetry and time-reversal symmetry and is therefore distinct from conventional charge-ordered or magnetically ordered insulating states Together with the observed suppression of low-energy spin excitations, the present findings are consistent with a symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state due to the enhanced spin–orbit coupling and provide important microscopic constraints on theoretical descriptions of α-(BETS)2I3 α-(BETS)2I3 should be a rare example of a molecular Dirac system whose insulating ground state preserves both inversion and time-reversal symmetries Acknowledgments This work was supported by the JSPS Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research (Grant No.

Kai: 17K05846, 18H05225, 19H01846, 20K20894, 20KK0060, 21K18144, 23K25815 and 24K21525), the Mitsubishi Foundation (Grant No.

Mira: 202110014), Iketani Science and Technology Foundation (Grant No.

Kai: 0381093-A) and the Japan Science and Technology Support for Pioneering Research Initiated by the Next Generation (Grant No.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're diving into this paper today called "Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective thirteen C NMR in alpha -(BETS) two I three" <ref:2611.16939#pg1,Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective>. We’re looking at how they used nuclear magnetic resonance to figure out the nature of this insulating phase.

Mira: Exactly. They're trying to figure out if this low-temperature insulating state is something that breaks symmetry, or if it keeps its inversion and time-reversal symmetries intact as a gapped Dirac state.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, knowing the symmetry is key because if you can’t preserve time-reversal symmetry, your error correction codes have to be way more complicated to handle the resulting magnetic order.

Kai: Right. So what they found is that their NMR spectra showed no new splitting down to two Kelvin and it was still described by one quartet and two doublets for the three types of molecular sites A, B, and C.

Mira: That specific pattern tells us something about the local environment that suggests inversion symmetry is preserved across those sites.

Lev: It also means they didn't see any anomalous line broadening or critical enhancement of the nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rate, which rules out magnetic ordering or time-reversal symmetry breaking effects.

Kai: That’s a big deal because usually when you have magnetic order, you expect to see some kind of broadening in those NMR signals.

Mira: And that absence of those features strongly points toward the low-temperature phase being a symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state rather than some spontaneously broken phase.

Lev: If it’s a gapped Dirac state, it implies there’s a gap opening around the Dirac point, which is what we expect when you have strong spin-orbit coupling.

Kai: That brings us to the next part of what this paper suggests about their findings and how they interpreted those measurements.

Mira: The paper suggests that this symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state is compatible with alpha -(BETS)2I3 potentially hosting a correlated quantum spin Hall state, stabilized by the interplay between spin-orbit coupling and electron correlations <ref:2611.16939#pg1,symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state>.

Lev: That’s interesting because it gives us a microscopic constraint on what any candidate ground states for that system might have to satisfy, even though NMR itself doesn't directly probe those edge modes.

Kai: So it’s not saying they found the quantum spin Hall state directly, but theNMR data provides necessary conditions that any such state must meet.

Title and authors: Mira: Right. And they also looked at how this relates to the electronic structure by looking at site-selective spin susceptibilities, and they found a characteristic relation where chi C is greater than chi A which is greater than chi B.

Lev: That chi ratio is a signature of tilted Dirac cones, like what we saw in alpha -(ET)2I3 under pressure, suggesting the low-energy electronic structure here follows that same pattern <ref:2611.16939#pg1>.

Kai: They also noted that the overall magnitude of this local susceptibility is substantially reduced, which they link to increases in overlap integrals between molecular orbitals because of the selenium substitution.

Mira: And they also found no negative B-site susceptibility, which they suggest means the inter-band Coulomb interactions might be weaker than in alpha -(ET)2I3 <ref:2611.16939#pg1>.

Lev: It’s a nice comparison point for understanding how changing those atoms affects the correlation strength and the resulting magnetic response.

Kai: Moving on to what this paper suggests we should improve or consider next, they focus on how site-selective NMR can be used to predict insulating ground state symmetry by incorporating these constraints into theoretical models for molecular Dirac systems.

Mira: That means we need to train our AI models not just on the final spectra, but using those specific spectral features like the lack of additional splitting down to two Kelvin as a direct filter for symmetry preservation in theory.

Lev: We can use that feature—that no additional splitting—as a hard constraint when testing different theoretical descriptions of these molecular systems to see which one actually holds up.

Kai: And then they also explored how we can improve our understanding of electronic structure mapping by training models to correlate site-specific spin susceptibilities with momentum space contributions in tilted Dirac cones.

Mira: That lets the AI use that chi C greater than chi A greater than chi B relation as a feature to predict which molecular orbitals contribute most strongly to different regions of momentum space.

Lev: If we can link those susceptibility ratios directly to specific band structures, it helps us understand how the tilt in the Dirac cone dictates those spin correlations.

Kai: Another improvement they suggest is developing capabilities for characterizing magnetic symmetry by analyzing the angular dependence of NMR spectra to detect subtle symmetry breaking effects.

Mira: We can train a system to look for no line splitting, no anomalous broadening, and no additional resonance features across various field orientations as evidence that inversion and time-reversal symmetries are actually preserved.

Lev: That’s a way to probe the internal magnetic fields generated by potential magnetic order without having to rely solely on the static measurements they did.

Title and authors: Kai: Then there's refining the prediction of low-energy spin dynamics by linking the temperature evolution of nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rates to microscopic gap opening mechanisms.

Mira: They want us to use that activation energy value, which they found at delta over k b equals two hundred ten plus or minus forty-one Kelvin, to predict whether the insulating phase is actually due to a spin-orbit coupling induced gap.

Lev: That specific activation energy measurement gives us a concrete benchmark for testing those spin-orbit coupling induced gap theories against the actual temperature dependence of the relaxation rate.

Kai: And finally, they suggest using NMR data as necessary conditions for potential exotic states to get better constraints on correlated topological phases.

Mira: So we can train the system to recognize that that characteristic site-selective spin susceptibility relation, chi C greater than chi A greater than chi B, is a signature compatible with correlated quantum spin Hall phases.

Lev: It’s a way for the AI to flag those systems as promising candidates for topological phases based on their local magnetic response characteristics.

Kai: So to wrap this up, the paper "Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective thirteen C NMR in alpha -(BETS) two I three" establishes that the insulating ground state preserves both inversion symmetry and time-reversal symmetry <ref:2611.16939#pg1,Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective>.

Mira: It’s distinct from those conventional charge-ordered or magnetically ordered insulators, which is a key distinction we need to keep in mind.

Lev: Coupled with the observed suppression of low-energy spin excitations, this finding is consistent with a symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state due to that enhanced spin-orbit coupling.

Kai: It suggests that alpha -(BETS)2I3 might be a rare example of a molecular Dirac system where the insulating ground state preserves both inversion and time-reversal symmetries <ref:2611.16939#pg1,preserves both inversion and time-reversal symmetries>.

Mira: That’s the core implication: this material could be one of those rare examples, and it opens up new avenues for understanding molecular Dirac systems.

Lev: For real hardware, knowing that the low-energy excitations are gapped helps us design systems where we don't have to worry about those low-energy magnetic fluctuations dominating the physics.

Kai: We’ve got a lot of material here on how to use site-selective probes like NMR to dissect these complex quantum materials.

Mira: It’s about moving beyond just seeing a phase and starting to map out the fundamental symmetries that define that phase.

Lev: Next up, we look at how this relates back to those other papers on quantum simulation and computational complexity in topological phases.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap, they used site-selective NMR on alpha-(BETS)2I3 to show that its low temperature insulating state doesn't break time-reversal symmetry or inversion symmetry, which is pretty unusual for an insulator <ref:2611.16939#pg1>.

Mira: Yeah, the point is that they found no new splitting in the NMR spectra down to two Kelvin and those signals were consistent with three types of molecular sites A B and C.

Lev: That lack of spectral splitting means they didn't see any magnetic order or static internal fields messing with the nuclear spins, which is good for error correction because it keeps things relatively clean.

Kai: It also told them that the absence of line broadening in their spin-lattice relaxation rate measurements confirms there isn't a critical enhancement of those fluctuations either.

Mira: That lack of magnetic signatures is what leads them to conclude it’s a symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state, not something spontaneously broken.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if it’s a Dirac state, it means there is a gap opening around the Dirac point, which suggests that strong spin-orbit coupling might be doing the heavy lifting here.

Kai: They also looked at how this relates to other electronic structure maps and found a relationship between site selective spin susceptibilities where chi C is bigger than chi A which is bigger than chi B.

Mira: That ratio in the susceptibility tells us about the tilt of the Dirac cones, showing that these low-energy electronic structures follow a similar pattern to those we see in materials like alpha-(ET)2I3 under pressure <ref:2611.16939#pg1>.

Lev: If we can use that susceptibility relation to map out which molecular orbitals contribute most strongly to which momentum space regions, it helps us predict the exact nature of the gap opening they observed.

Kai: They also pointed out that the overall magnitude of this local susceptibility is reduced compared to other systems, and they linked that reduction directly to increased overlap integrals between those molecular orbitals because of the selenium substitution.

Mira: That suggests you get better orbital mixing with more selenium, which changes the density of states in a way that lowers the susceptibility while maintaining these symmetry properties.

Lev: And they mentioned that no negative B site susceptibility was found, which they interpreted as meaning the inter band Coulomb interactions might be weaker than in alpha-(ET)2I3 <ref:2611.16939#pg1>.

Kai: So essentially, this paper is using these local magnetic probes to build a picture of the bulk electronic state’s fundamental symmetries and its underlying topology.

Mira: It frames the insulating ground state as something very specific: it’s a gapped Dirac state that respects both inversion and time-reversal symmetry.

Lev: And this has some major implications because if we're looking for correlated topological phases, like a quantum spin Hall state, this provides the necessary constraints for what that ground state must look like microscopically.

Kai: It’s not a direct proof of the topological phase itself, but it gives us the required conditions so that any theoretical model we build has to satisfy these symmetry requirements if it wants to describe alpha-(BETS)2I3 <ref:2611.16939#pg1>.

Mira: And they suggest this is one of those rare examples where a molecular Dirac system manages to maintain both those symmetries in its insulating state.

Lev: If this holds up, it means we’ve found a new class of molecular materials that could host topological physics, even if we can't directly see the edge modes with these probes.

Kai: So, the next step for us is to take these constraints and plug them into our larger theoretical models for correlated topological states.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we're looking at what the authors suggest for moving forward with this research on alpha-(BETS)2I3 <ref:2611.16939#pg1>.

Mira: They’re focused on using site selective NMR to better predict if an insulating state will preserve symmetry by incorporating those spectral constraints directly into their theoretical models for molecular Dirac systems.

Lev: That means we need to train the AI not just on the final spectra, but using things like that lack of additional splitting down to two Kelvin as a direct filter in the theory.

Kai: They also want to improve electronic structure mapping by training models so they can correlate site selective spin susceptibilities with momentum space contributions in tilted Dirac cones.

Mira: That lets the AI use that chi C greater than chi A greater than chi B relation as a feature to predict which molecular orbitals contribute most strongly to different regions of momentum space.

Lev: If we can link those susceptibility ratios directly to specific band structures, it helps us understand how the tilt in the Dirac cone dictates those spin correlations.

Kai: Another suggestion is developing capabilities for characterizing magnetic symmetry by analyzing the angular dependence of NMR spectra to detect subtle breaking effects.

Mira: We can train a system to look for no line splitting, no anomalous broadening, and no additional resonance features across various field orientations as evidence that inversion and time-reversal symmetries are actually preserved.

Lev: That’s a way to probe the internal magnetic fields without relying only on static measurements they did.

Kai: Then they propose refining the prediction of low-energy spin dynamics by linking temperature evolution of nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rates to microscopic gap opening mechanisms.

Mira: They want us to use that activation energy value, which is about delta over k b equals two one zero plus or minus forty one Kelvin, to predict whether the insulating phase is due to a spin-orbit coupling induced gap.

Lev: That specific activation energy measurement gives us a concrete benchmark for testing those spin-orbit coupling induced gap theories against the actual temperature dependence of the relaxation rate.

Kai: And finally, they want us to use NMR data as necessary conditions for potential exotic states to get better constraints on correlated topological phases.

Mira: So we train the system to recognize that that characteristic site selective spin susceptibility relation, chi C greater than chi A greater than chi B, is a signature compatible with correlated quantum spin Hall phases.

Lev: It’s a way for the AI to flag those systems as promising candidates for topological phases based on their local magnetic response characteristics.

Kai: This whole direction points toward using these NMR techniques not just to characterize what's there, but to set up better predictive tools for finding exotic quantum states in molecular materials.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this look at alpha-(BETS)2I3 and its insulating phase, which they call "Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective thirteen C NMR <ref:2611.16939#pg1,Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective>."

Mira: Basically, they proved that the low temperature insulating state doesn't break inversion or time reversal symmetry because their NMR measurements showed no extra splitting down to two Kelvin.

Lev: That absence of magnetic signatures is what really matters for us in error correction because it means we don't have those static internal fields messing up our qubits.

Kai: It suggests that the material is behaving like a gapped Dirac state, which implies there’s a gap opening around the Dirac point due to strong spin-orbit coupling.

Mira: And they connect this to site selective spin susceptibilities, showing that chi C is bigger than chi A which is bigger than chi B, which points toward how the tilt of the Dirac cone dictates those electronic structures.

Lev: If we can map that susceptibility ratio directly to band structures, it gives us a roadmap for predicting the exact nature of the gap opening they observed.

Kai: They also showed this symmetry-preserving state is compatible with hosting a correlated quantum spin Hall state, even if their NMR data doesn't directly see those edge modes.

Mira: It means these NMR measurements provide necessary conditions for any candidate ground state to satisfy if it wants to be a topological phase.

Lev: For real hardware, knowing that the low energy excitations are gapped helps us design systems where we don't have to worry about those low energy magnetic fluctuations dominating the physics.

Kai: So, this paper establishes alpha-(BETS)2I3 as a rare example of a molecular Dirac system that keeps both inversion and time reversal symmetry in its insulating ground state <ref:2611.16939#pg1,both inversion and time reversal>.

Mira: It’s distinct from conventional insulators because it respects those fundamental symmetries, which is a key distinction we need to keep in mind when thinking about new materials.

Lev: If they can push the theory forward by linking these NMR constraints to topological phase signatures, that opens up a lot of new avenues for designing molecular qubits.

Kai: It really shows how site selective probes like NMR can be used to dissect these complex quantum materials and define their fundamental symmetries.

Department of Applied Physics, University of Tokyo · Max-Planck-Institute for Solid State Research Institute for Solid State Research Germany Institute for Solid State Research Physics Institute, University of Stuttgart

cond-mat.str-el

Submitted: 2026-11-12

Updated: 2026-11-17

Comments: 10 pages. 9 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 81/100

The gist: Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective 13C NMR in α-(BETS)2I3 reports evidence that the low-temperature insulating phase of α-(BETS)2I3 preserves both inversion and…

Key concepts

Symmetry Preservation
This refers to whether the insulating state of $\alpha ext{-(BETS)}_2\text{I}_3$ keeps its mirror symmetry (inversion) and time-reversal symmetry intact. The NMR data showed no extra splitting or broadening, proving these symmetries are preserved at low temperatures.
Gapped Dirac State
This describes a specific type of electronic structure where electrons behave like massless particles near a point in momentum space (the Dirac point). A 'gap' means there is an energy barrier preventing excitations, which opens up the insulating state observed in the material.
Site-Selective NMR
This technique uses ${}^{13} ext{C}$ NMR to probe specific molecular sites within the crystal. By looking at how different carbon atoms respond to magnetic fields, researchers can map out how electronic properties vary across different parts of the molecule.

Terminology

Summary

Symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state revealed by site-selective 13C NMR in α-(BETS)2I3 reports evidence that the low-temperature insulating phase of α-(BETS)2I3 preserves both inversion and time-reversal symmetries using site-selective 13C nuclear magnetic resonance The NMR spectra exhibit no additional splitting down to 2 K and remain fully described by one quartet and two doublets associated with the three types of molecular sites, A (=A′), B and C sites, demonstrating the preservation of inversion symmetry Furthermore, no anomalous line broadening or critical enhancement of the nuclear spinlattice relaxation rate is observed, indicating the absence of magnetic ordering and time-reversalsymmetry breaking

Nature of the Insulating State

The paper investigates whether the insulating phase of α-(BETS)2I3 arises from spontaneous symmetry breaking or remains a symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state The results demonstrate that the low-temperature insulating phase preserves both inversion and time-reversal symmetries down to at least 2 K The absence of magnetic and charge ordering indicates that the low-temperature phase is a symmetrypreserving gapped Dirac state This conclusion is supported by the observation that no additional resonance lines appear at any temperature, and linewidths remain nearly constant across TMI without an abrupt broadening indicative of the emergence of static internal magnetic fields

Spin Susceptibility and Electronic Structure

Site-selective spin susceptibilities reveal a characteristic relation, χC > χA > χB, which is a characteristic feature of tilted Dirac cones such as in α-(ET)2I3 under pressure This relation persists over the entire temperature range and suggests that its low-energy electronic structure is likewise governed by tilted Dirac-cone bands The overall magnitude of the local susceptibility is substantially reduced, indicating a lower density of states in α-(BETS)2I3, which is consistent with increases in overlap integrals between molecular orbitals by the Se substitution The absence of a negative B-site susceptibility indicates that the inter-band Coulomb interactions may be weaker than α-(ET)2I3

Spin-Orbit Coupling and Gap Opening

The suppression of low-energy spin excitations, such as the ferrimagnetic-like spin excitations observed in α-(ET)2I3, is absent in α-(BETS)2I3 The absence of these excitations suggests that a gap opens around the Dirac point, which is naturally expected when a gap opens around the Dirac point, suppressing the density of states available for low-energy excitations This behavior is consistent with the enhanced spin–orbit coupling due to selenium atoms possessing stronger spin–orbit coupling than sulfur atoms in α-(ET)2I3

Constraints on Topological Phases

The symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state demonstrated by the present NMR measurements is compatible with the possibility that α-(BETS)2I3 may host a correlated quantum spin Hall state stabilized by the interplay between spin–orbit coupling and electron correlations While NMR primarily probes bulk electronic properties and is not directly sensitive to topological edge modes, the present data offers the microscopic constraints that any candidate ground states must satisfy The work suggests that a correlated quantum spin Hall phase is among possible ground states, although direct verification will require complementary probes sensitive to edge-state transport or spin-current phenomena

Conclusion

These results establish that the insulating ground state of α-(BETS)2I3 preserves both inversion symmetry and time-reversal symmetry and is therefore distinct from conventional charge-ordered or magnetically ordered insulating states Together with the observed suppression of low-energy spin excitations, the present findings are consistent with a symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state due to the enhanced spin–orbit coupling and provide important microscopic constraints on theoretical descriptions of α-(BETS)2I3 α-(BETS)2I3 should be a rare example of a molecular Dirac system whose insulating ground state preserves both inversion and time-reversal symmetries

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the JSPS Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research (Grant No. 17K05846, 18H05225, 19H01846, 20K20894, 20KK0060, 21K18144, 23K25815 and 24K21525), the Mitsubishi Foundation (Grant No. p. 9 202110014), Iketani Science and Technology Foundation (Grant No. p. 9 0381093-A) and the Japan Science and Technology Support for Pioneering Research Initiated by the Next Generation (Grant No. p. 9 JPMJSP2108) K. p. 9 K. acknowledges the support from the JSPS Core-to-Core Program (JPJSCCA20240001) and the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation We also thank the Cryogenic Research Center at the University of Tokyo for supporting the lowtemperature experiments

References

[1] K. S. Novoselov, A. p. 9 p. 9 K. Geim, S. V. Morozov, D. p. 9 Jiang, Y. Zhang, S. V. Dubonos, I. p. 9 V., Grigorieva, and A. p. 9, Firsov, Science 306, 666 (2004)

[2] K. S. Novoselov, A. K. Geim, S. V., Morozov, D. p. 9, Jiang, M. I., Katsnelson, I. p. 9 V., Grigorieva, S. p. 9 V., Dubonos, and A. p. 9, Firsov, Nature 438, 197 (2005)

[3] M. Hirata, K. Ishikawa, K. p. 9 p. 9 Miyagawa, M. p. 0 Tamura, C. Berthier, D. p. 9, Basko, A., Kobayashi, G. p. 9, Matsuno, and K. p. 9, Kanoda, Nat. p. 9 Commun. 7, 12666 (2016)

[4] M. Hirata, K. Ishikawa, G. p. 9, Matsuno, A. p. 9, Kobayashi, K. p. 9, Miyagawa, M. p. 0 p. 0, Tamura, C. p. 9, Berthier, and K. p. 9 p. 9, Kanoda, Science 358, 1403 (2017)

[5] M. Hirata, A. Kobayashi, C. p. 9 Berthier, and K., Kanoda, Rep. p. 9 Prog. Phys. 84, 036502 (2021)

[6] N. Tajima, S., Sugawara, M. p. 9, Tamura, Y. p. 9, Nishio, and K. p. 9, Kajita, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 75, 051010 (2006)

[7] S. Katayama, A. p. 9, Kobayashi, and Y. p. 9, Suzumura, J. p. 9 Phys. Soc. Jpn. 75, 054705 (2006)

[8] D. Ohki, M., Hirata, T., Tani, K., Kanoda, and A. p. 9, Kobayashi, Physical Review Research 2, 033479 (2020)

[9] T. Osada, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 93, 123703 (2024)

[10] T. Osada, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn., 94, 113701 (2025)

[11] T. Kakiuchi, Y. p. 9, Wakabayashi, H. p. 9, Sawa, T., Takahashi, and T. p. 9, Nakamura, J. p. 9 Phys. Soc. Jpn. 76, 18 (2007)

[12] T. Kawai and A. p. 9 Kawamoto, J. p. 9 Phys. Soc. Jpn., 78, 074711 (2009)

[13] K. Ishikawa, M. p. 9, Hirata, D., Liu, K., Miyagawa, M., Tamura, and K. p. 9, Kanoda, Phys. p. 9 p. 9 p. 9 Rev. B 94, 085154 (2016)

[14] R. Kato, H. Kobayashi, and A. p. 9, Kobayashi, Synthetic Metals 42, 2093 (1991)

[15] M. Inokuchi, H. p. 9 p. 9, Tajima, A. p. 9 p. 9, Kobayashi, H. p. 9 p. 9, Kuroda, R., Kato, T. Naito, and H. p. 9 p. 9, Kobayashi, Synth. p. 9 Met. 56, 2495 (1993)

[16] M. Inokuchi, H., Tajima, A., Kobayashi, T. p. 9 Ohta, H., Kuroda, R., Kato, T. Naito, and H., Kobayashi, Bull. p. 9 Chem. Soc. Jpn. 68, 547 (1995)

[17] H. Kobayashi, H., Bui, and A., Kobayashi, Chemical Reviews 104, 5265 (2004)

[18] S. M. Winter, K. Riedl, and R. p. 9, Valent´ı, Phys. p. 9 Rev. B 95, 1 (2017)

[19] T. Tsumuraya and Y. p. 9, Suzumura, The European Physical Journal B 94, 17 (2021)

[20] R. Kondo, S., Kagoshima, N. p. 9, Tajima, and R. p. 9, Kato, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 78, 114714 (2009)

[21] S. Raghu, X. L., Qi, C., Honerkamp, and S. p. 9, Zhang, Physical Review Letters 100, 10. p. 91103/PhysRevLett. p. 9100.156401 (2008)

[22] D. Ohki, K., Yoshimi, and A. p. 9 p. 9, Kobayashi, Phys. p. 9 p. 9 Rev. B 105, 1 (2022)

[23] T. Konoike, T. p. 9, Terashima, S. p. 9, Uji, Y., Hattori, and R. p. 9, Kato, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 91, 1 (2022)

[24] K. Miyagawa, A. p. 0 Kawamoto, and K. p. 9, Kanoda, Phys. Rev. B 62, R7679 (2000)

[25] J. Powles and P. p. 9, Mansfield, Physics Letters 2, 58 (1962)

[26] A. Kawamoto, K. p. 9 Miyagawa, Y. p. 0, Nakazawa, and K. p. 9, Kanoda, Phys. Rev. B 52, 15522 (1995)

[27] M. Hirata, K. Ishikawa, K., Miyagawa, K. p. 0, Kanoda, and M. p. 9, Tamura, Phys. p. 9 Rev. B 84, 125133 (2011)

[28] T. Moriya, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn., 75, 054705 (2006)

[29] S. Kitou, T., Tsumuraya, H. p. 9, Sawahata, F. p. 9, Ishii, K., Hiraki, T. p. 0, Nakamura, N. p. 9, Katayama, and H. p. 9, Sawa, Phys. p. 9 Rev. B 103, 035135 (2021)

[30] K. I. Hiraki, S., Harada, K., Arai, Y., Takano, T., Takahashi, N. p. 9, Tajima, R. p. 9, Kato, and T. p. 0 Naito, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 80, 1 (2011)

[31] S. Priya, M., Wenzel, O., Iakutkina, M. p. 9, Schmidt, C. p. 9, Prange, D., Schweitzer, Y. p. 9, Saito, R., Kato, K., Hiraki, and M. p. 0 Dressel, Phys. p. 9 Rev. B 112, 245158 (2025)

[32] G. Matsuno and A. p. 9 p. 9, Kobayashi, J. p. 9 p. 9 Phys. Soc. Jpn., 86, 014705 (2017)

[33] G. Matsuno and A., Kobayashi, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn., 87, 054706 (2018)

[34] D. Ohki, K., Yoshimi, and A., Kobayashi, Phys. Rev. B 102, 1 (2020)

[35] D. Ohki, K., Yoshimi, A. p. 9, Kobayashi, and T. p. 9 Misawa, Phys. p. 9 Rev. B 107, 1 (2023)

[36] T. Nomoto, S., Imajo, H., Akutsu, Y., Nakazawa, and Y. p. 9, Kohama, Nature Communications 14, 2130 (2023)

[37] T. Osada, JPSJ News and Comments 20, 10. p. 97566/jpsjnc. p. 920.06 (2023)

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improve prediction of insulating ground state symmetry by incorporating site-selective NMR constraints into theoretical models for molecular Dirac systems. This allows AI to distinguish between spontaneous symmetry breaking or remains a symmetry-preserving gapped Dirac state based on observed spectral features like no additional splitting down to 2 K.

  2. Enhance understanding of electronic structure mapping by training models to correlate site-specific spin susceptibilities with momentum space contributions in tilted Dirac cones. The AI can use the relation "chiC > chiA > chiB" as a feature to predict the relative contribution of different molecular orbitals to different regions of momentum space.

  3. Develop capabilities for characterizing magnetic symmetry by analyzing angular dependence of NMR spectra to detect subtle symmetry breaking effects. The system can be trained to identify no line splitting, anomalous broadening, or additional resonance features across various field orientations as evidence for preserving inversion and time-reversal symmetries.

  4. Refine the prediction of low-energy spin dynamics by linking the temperature evolution of nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rates to microscopic gap opening mechanisms. The AI can use the observed activation energy of delta/kB = 210 ± 41 K to predict whether the insulating phase is due to a spin–orbit-coupling induced gap.

  5. Improve constraints on correlated topological phases by using NMR data as necessary conditions for potential exotic states. The system can be trained to recognize that the observed "site-selective spin susceptibilities exhibit the characteristic relation chiC > chiA > chiB as a signature compatible with correlated quantum spin Hall phases."

Related papers