Dilution of cosmological relics and gravitational waves from a supercooled electroweak phase transition in classically scale-invariant models
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Dilution of cosmological relics and gravitational waves from a supercooled electroweak phase transition in classically scale-invariant models".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Dilution of cosmological relics and gravitational waves from a supercooled electroweak phase transition in classically scale-invariant models is studied to determine its consequences for pre-existing relics and gravitational waves Model Setup and Symmetry Breaking The study investigates a classically scale-invariant extension of the Standard Model featuring a real singlet s and NQ real scalars Qi that couple to the Higgs doublet and to the singlet through portals αQ and βQ Electroweak symmetry is broken along a Gildener-Weinberg flat direction, resulting in a light dilaton with a mass of about 27 GeV The classical Lagrangian contains no mass terms at tree level, and the electroweak scale is generated radiatively through dimensional transmutation The vacuum of interest is defined by a nonzero vS breaking the Z2 symmetry, with bubbles nucleating toward +vS and −vS with equal probability Transition Dynamics and Completion The transition proceeds in a single, strongly supercooled step through percolation and completion in a vacuum-dominated background The bounce action is computed along the two-dimensional tunnelling path, and the false-vacuum fraction is tracked with the vacuum energy included in the expansion rate The transition completes within a few percent in temperature, with completion following percolation The lower edge of the viable region is set by the onset of QCD effects at Tp ≃ 1.5 GeV, not by a failure of percolation Energy Budget and Dilution Effects The released vacuum energy is distributed into three places: the gradient and kinetic energy of the scalar field in the bubble walls, bulk motion of the plasma, and heat The fraction carried by the scalar field at collision is κcol, which is below 10−10 at the benchmarks The fraction of the total energy density in bulk fluid motion is K, which is 0.99 for BP1 The resulting entropy injection D grows from D ≃ 4 × 10 cubed at the completion edge to D ≳ 103 near the completion edge Gravitational Wave Signal and Observability The acoustic gravitational-wave spectrum is sourced by the fluid rather than by the scalar field, and its peak follows an approximate scaling relation set by the vacuum energy The peak frequencies lie between 0.3 and 1.5 mHz with h2omegapeak between a few times 10−12 and 10−9 The signal-to-noise ratios for LISA are between 140 and about 2 × 10 cubed in four years of observation Consequences for Pre-existing Relics The transition dilutes pre-existing relics by up to several orders of magnitude, reducing the abundance YX = nX/s of any species X that is out of equilibrium during the transition and is not produced by the reheated plasma For a thermal relic that freezes out before the transition, its mass window is bounded by mDM ≳ 25 Treh, which can be as heavy as mU√D, of order 10 6–10 7 GeV for the strongest transitions Dependence on Model Parameters The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q, with a residual dependence on NQ at the level of tens of percent in Tp and a factor of a few in D The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis The transition completes, nearly all of the released energy goes into the plasma, and pre-existing relics are diluted accordingly The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis Appendix A Every result of sections IV–VIII rests on the bounce action S3(T) and on the fit used to differentiate and integrate it The residuals of ln(S3/T) about the smoothing fit for 1264 bounce solutions near the transition, with a Gaussian of the measured rms width The uncertainties quoted in tables II and III come from a residual bootstrap The choice of the smoothing parameter moves β/H by up to 20% Appendix B The finite-temperature potential of section III A is a one-loop expression with the leading infrared contributions resummed The Parwani resummation lowers the percolation temperature by 12–13% at all three benchmarks, which increases the strength by a factor of 1.65–1.8 and the entropy injection by a factor of 1.35–1.55 Lowering ΠQ by 15% reduces the thermal barrier and acts in the same direction, but less strongly The peak amplitude increases by 20–60% The scale dependence is therefore smaller than the dependence on the resummation prescription for Tp, α and D, and comparable to it for the gravitational-wave amplitude Appendix C The model can also be tested at colliders A calculation of the wall velocity beyond the leading-order friction estimate is needed for αQ/4π ≳ 0.15, including BP3, where the Qi are reflected by the wall Most importantly, a dedicated numerical study of acoustic production for α≫ 1 with ultrarelativistic walls would turn the amplitude estimates of this work into firm predictions for the space-based interferometers Appendix D The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q, with a residual dependence on NQ at the level of tens of percent in Tp and a factor of a few in D The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis Appendix E The singlet scale is bounded from below by Higgs signal strength The mixing angle grows as vS decreases, and at vS = 0.7 TeV the signal strength lies between 0.89 and 0.93, at the edge of the allowed range Appendix F The renormalisation scale moves by between −7% and +5%, the entropy injection by between −11% and +22%, and Treh by at most about one percent The peak amplitude, which scales approximately as (β/H)−2, inherits this scatter and changes by between −21% and +72% The scale dependence is therefore smaller than the dependence on the resummation prescription for Tp, α and D, and comparable to it for the gravitational-wave amplitude Appendix G The peak frequency is fixed by β/H and Treh, and the amplitude at that frequency fixes Treh and hence ∆V0 The model can also be tested at colliders A calculation of the wall velocity beyond the leading-order friction estimate is needed for αQ/4π ≳ 0.15, including BP3, where the Qi are reflected by the wall The most important point is that a dedicated numerical study of acoustic production for α≫ 1 with ultrarelativistic walls would turn the amplitude estimates of this work into firm predictions for the space-based interferometers Appendix H The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q, with a residual dependence on NQ at the level of tens of percent in Tp and a factor of a few in D The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis Appendix I The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q, with a residual dependence on NQ at the level of tens of percent in Tp and a factor of a few in D The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis Appendix J The model can also be tested at colliders A calculation of the wall velocity beyond the leading-order friction estimate is needed for αQ/4π ≳ 0.
Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap where we are: we're talking about this paper on "Dilution of cosmological relics and gravitational waves from a supercooled electroweak phase transition in classically scale-invariant models". The thesis is that this specific class of model allows for the dilution of pre-existing relics by many orders of magnitude because the transition injects a lot of entropy into the plasma >
Mira: Exactly. It claims that because species decouple before this transition don't share in that reheating, so their abundance is diluted by every single unit of entropy produced during the electroweak phase transition >
Lev: They are looking at a classically scale-invariant extension of the Standard Model with a real singlet s and some real scalars Qi coupled to the Higgs doublet and to the singlet through portals alpha Q and beta Q >
Kai: This structure leads to an electroweak scale generated radiatively, and because there are no tree level mass terms, it keeps the symmetric phase metastable down to very low temperatures >
Mira: They study this transition by computing the bounce along a two dimensional tunnelling path and following the false-vacuum fraction through percolation and completion >
Lev: The key finding is that this transition proceeds in a single, strongly supercooled step and completes above the QCD scale over a region of parameter space consistent with Higgs measurements and perturbativity >
Kai: And despite being strongly supercooled, it’s still fast enough to be relevant for these cosmological effects >
Mira: The results also show how this relates to the gravitational wave signal of the first-order transition, showing that its peak frequencies lie between zero point three and one point five mhz >
Lev: So what matters is that they haven't fully established how large this dilution is in a concrete, radiatively broken electroweak sector, or how it correlates with the gravitational wave signal >
Kai: That’s the gap they are filling, which means this paper provides the framework for understanding these cosmological effects in these types of models >
Conclusion: Mira: So, looking at this paper on "Dilution of cosmological relics and gravitational waves from a supercooled electroweak phase transition in classically scale-invariant models", the main point is that this specific mechanism can dilute old particles by many orders of magnitude because of the entropy dumped into the plasma >
Kai: And it also links this to gravitational waves, suggesting we might be able to use LISA to look for these waves if our parameters are right >
Lev: The implication for us as researchers is that the results depend on that combination of N Q alpha squared Q and they need a Higgs signal strength greater than one teraelectron volt >
Mira: So in simple terms, it means we need to tune the model parameters correctly—specifically that mixing angle and the portal strength—to get a strong enough transition to see these cosmological effects >
Kai: And if we tune it right, this paper shows us what kind of relic mass window we should expect to be looking for when searching for dark matter >
Lev: The main thing they flag is that the gravitational wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty, so those predictions need careful handling when you use them >
Arnab Chaudhuri
School of Advanced Sciences, Vellore Institute of Technology · Vellore Institute of Technology
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-11-12
Updated: 2026-11-12
Comments: 31 pages, 14 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: Dilution of cosmological relics and gravitational waves from a supercooled electroweak phase transition in classically scale-invariant models is studied to determine its consequences for pre-existing…
Key concepts
- Electroweak Symmetry Breaking
- This process describes how the fundamental forces split into their current forms. In this model, it occurs along a flat direction in the theory, creating a light dilaton field with a mass around 27 GeV. The electroweak scale is generated through radiative corrections rather than being present at tree level.
- Dilution of Relics
- When the universe undergoes this phase transition, any particles that were out of equilibrium before it are diluted. This means their abundance relative to the total entropy drops by several orders of magnitude. For thermal relics, this limits their possible mass range based on the transition's strength.
- Acoustic Gravitational Waves
- These gravitational waves are produced by the fluid motions within the plasma during the phase transition, rather than just by scalar field oscillations. The spectrum is sourced by vacuum energy scaling, with peak frequencies between 0.3 and 1.5 mHz, making them potentially detectable by space-based interferometers like LISA.
Terminology
Summary
Dilution of cosmological relics and gravitational waves from a supercooled electroweak phase transition in classically scale-invariant models is studied to determine its consequences for pre-existing relics and gravitational waves
Model Setup and Symmetry Breaking
The study investigates a classically scale-invariant extension of the Standard Model featuring a real singlet s and NQ real scalars Qi that couple to the Higgs doublet and to the singlet through portals αQ and βQ Electroweak symmetry is broken along a Gildener-Weinberg flat direction, resulting in a light dilaton with a mass of about 27 GeV The classical Lagrangian contains no mass terms at tree level, and the electroweak scale is generated radiatively through dimensional transmutation The vacuum of interest is defined by a nonzero vS breaking the Z2 symmetry, with bubbles nucleating toward +vS and −vS with equal probability
Transition Dynamics and Completion
The transition proceeds in a single, strongly supercooled step through percolation and completion in a vacuum-dominated background The bounce action is computed along the two-dimensional tunnelling path, and the false-vacuum fraction is tracked with the vacuum energy included in the expansion rate The transition completes within a few percent in temperature, with completion following percolation The lower edge of the viable region is set by the onset of QCD effects at Tp ≃ 1.5 GeV, not by a failure of percolation
Energy Budget and Dilution Effects
The released vacuum energy is distributed into three places: the gradient and kinetic energy of the scalar field in the bubble walls, bulk motion of the plasma, and heat The fraction carried by the scalar field at collision is κcol, which is below 10−10 at the benchmarks The fraction of the total energy density in bulk fluid motion is K, which is 0.99 for BP1 The resulting entropy injection D grows from D ≃ 4 × 10 cubed at the completion edge to D ≳ 103 near the completion edge
Gravitational Wave Signal and Observability
The acoustic gravitational-wave spectrum is sourced by the fluid rather than by the scalar field, and its peak follows an approximate scaling relation set by the vacuum energy The peak frequencies lie between 0.3 and 1.5 mHz with h2omegapeak between a few times 10−12 and 10−9 The signal-to-noise ratios for LISA are between 140 and about 2 × 10 cubed in four years of observation
Consequences for Pre-existing Relics
The transition dilutes pre-existing relics by up to several orders of magnitude, reducing the abundance YX = nX/s of any species X that is out of equilibrium during the transition and is not produced by the reheated plasma For a thermal relic that freezes out before the transition, its mass window is bounded by mDM ≳ 25 Treh, which can be as heavy as mU√D, of order 10 6–10 7 GeV for the strongest transitions
Dependence on Model Parameters
The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q, with a residual dependence on NQ at the level of tens of percent in Tp and a factor of a few in D The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis
Conclusion
The transition completes, nearly all of the released energy goes into the plasma, and pre-existing relics are diluted accordingly The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis
Appendix A
Every result of sections IV–VIII rests on the bounce action S3(T) and on the fit used to differentiate and integrate it The residuals of ln(S3/T) about the smoothing fit for 1264 bounce solutions near the transition, with a Gaussian of the measured rms width The uncertainties quoted in tables II and III come from a residual bootstrap The choice of the smoothing parameter moves β/H by up to 20%
Appendix B
The finite-temperature potential of section III A is a one-loop expression with the leading infrared contributions resummed The Parwani resummation lowers the percolation temperature by 12–13% at all three benchmarks, which increases the strength by a factor of 1.65–1.8 and the entropy injection by a factor of 1. p. 0 The bubble walls reach their terminal velocity early, and almost all of the released
vacuum energy goes into bulk motion of the plasma, which thermalises and reheats the universe
close to the scale set by the vacuum energy. The resulting entropy injection dilutes pre-existing relics
by up to several orders of magnitude.Where the paper says it
Appendix C
The model can also be tested at colliders A calculation of the wall velocity beyond the leading-order friction estimate is needed for αQ/4π ≳ 0.15, including BP3, where the Qi are reflected by the wall Most importantly, a dedicated numerical study of acoustic production for α≫ 1 with ultrarelativistic walls would turn the amplitude estimates of this work into firm predictions for the space-based interferometers
Appendix D
The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q, with a residual dependence on NQ at the level of tens of percent in Tp and a factor of a few in D The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis
Appendix E
The singlet scale is bounded from below by Higgs signal strength The mixing angle grows as vS decreases, and at vS = 0.7 TeV the signal strength lies between 0. p. 4 Between 15 and 35 GeV the
observed limit lies at ξ
2 ≃ 0. The singlet admixture grows as βQ decreases, while the dilaton becomes
lighter, so the bound excludes points at small βQ that the Higgs signal strength allows, namely βQ/4π ≲ 0.Where the paper says it
Appendix F
The renormalisation scale moves by between −7% and +5%, the entropy injection by between −11% and +22%, and Treh by at most about one percent The peak amplitude, which scales approximately as (β/H)−2, inherits this scatter and changes by between −21% and +72% The scale dependence is therefore smaller than the dependence on the resummation prescription for Tp, α and D, and comparable to it for the gravitational-wave amplitude
Appendix G
The peak frequency is fixed by β/H and Treh, and the amplitude at that frequency fixes Treh and hence ∆V0 The model can also be tested at colliders A calculation of the wall velocity beyond the leading-order friction estimate is needed for αQ/4π ≳ 0.15, including BP3, where the Qi are reflected by the wall The most important point is that a dedicated numerical study of acoustic production for α≫ 1 with ultrarelativistic walls would turn the amplitude estimates of this work into firm predictions for the space-based interferometers
Appendix H
The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q, with a residual dependence on NQ at the level of tens of percent in Tp and a factor of a few in D The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis
Appendix I
The results depend on the multiplicity and the portal at leading order through the combination NQα2Q, with a residual dependence on NQ at the level of tens of percent in Tp and a factor of a few in D The Higgs signal strength requires vS ≳ 1 TeV The gravitational-wave amplitudes carry the largest uncertainty of the analysis
Appendix J
The model can also be tested at colliders A calculation of the wall velocity beyond the leading-order friction estimate is needed for αQ/4π ≳ 0.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved system can accurately predict gravitational-wave peak frequencies from measured parameters like beta/H and reheating temperature, as shown in Section VII A and Figure 9.
-
Improved system can estimate the entropy injection D for supercooled transitions by using the scaling relation D proportional to T to the power of -4 times p, which is fixed by vacuum energy.
-
Improved system can determine if a pre-existing gravitational-wave background is suppressed by calculating the dilution factor D4/3 relative to radiation, as described in Section VI C.
-
Improved system can assess the detectability of the transition signal for LISA and DECIGO by computing signal-to-noise ratios based on the scaling relation derived in Section VII C and Figure 11.
-
Improved system can identify regions of parameter space that are excluded by experimental constraints, such as Higgs signal strength or LEP bounds, by mapping them onto Figure 7.
-
Improved system can predict the terminal Lorentz factor of bubble walls using next-to-leading-order friction estimates from Section V B and Table III, which is crucial for determining the energy budget.
Abstract
In classically scale-invariant extensions of the Standard Model the electroweak scale is generated radiatively, and the absence of tree-level mass terms keeps the symmetric phase metastable down to very low temperatures. We study the resulting phase transition in a model with a real singlet and several additional scalars coupled to the Higgs doublet and to the singlet, in which electroweak symmetry is broken along a Gildener-Weinberg flat direction and a light dilaton appears in the spectrum. Computing the bounce along the two-dimensional tunnelling path and following the false-vacuum fraction through percolation and completion, we find that the transition proceeds in a single, strongly supercooled step and completes above the QCD scale over a region of parameter space consistent with Higgs measurements and perturbativity. Despite the strong supercooling the transition is fast. The bubble walls reach their terminal velocity early, and almost all of the released vacuum energy goes into bulk motion of the plasma, which thermalises and reheats the universe close to the scale set by the vacuum energy. The resulting entropy injection dilutes pre-existing relics by up to several orders of magnitude. It raises the baryon asymmetry that must be present before the transition, relaxes the unitarity bound on the mass of thermal dark matter, and suppresses earlier gravitational-wave backgrounds. If the acoustic description of gravitational-wave production extends to this regime, the signal peaks in the millihertz band, follows an approximate scaling relation between peak amplitude and frequency set by the vacuum energy, and would be observed by LISA throughout the viable region. The results depend on the multiplicity of the new scalars and their Higgs portal coupling at leading order through a single combination, and require the singlet scale to lie at or above the TeV scale.
Sources
- A solution to the hierarchy problem from an almost decoupled hidden sector within a classically scale invariant theory
- Classically Conformal B-L extended Standard Model
- Dynamical generation of the weak and Dark Matter scale
- Discriminative phenomenological features of scale invariant models for electroweak symmetry breaking
- Phase transition and gravitational wave phenomenology of scalar conformal extensions of the Standard Model
- Gravitational Waves from Phase Transitions in Models with Charged Singlets
- Gravitational Waves from Phase Transitions in Scale Invariant Models
- Cosmological Consequences of Nearly Conformal Dynamics at the TeV scale
- QCD-Electroweak First-Order Phase Transition in a Supercooled Universe
- QCD-induced Electroweak Phase Transition
- The Supercooled Universe
- Probing classically conformal $B-L$ model with gravitational waves
- Synergy between measurements of the gravitational wave and the triple Higgs coupling in probing first order phase transition
- Gravitational waves from first order electroweak phase transition in models with the $U(1)_X^{}$ gauge symmetry
- Gravitational waves from conformal symmetry breaking
- Gravitational wave energy budget in strongly supercooled phase transitions
- Updated predictions for gravitational waves produced in a strongly supercooled phase transition
- Gravitational wave spectra from strongly supercooled phase transitions
- Conformal model for gravitational waves and dark matter: A status update
- Can supercooled phase transitions explain the gravitational wave background observed by pulsar timing arrays?
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses