Sign changing pairing in single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 revealed by nonmagnetic impurity bound states

arXiv:2611.16679 · cond-mat.supr-con, cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2026-11-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Sign changing pairing in single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 revealed by nonmagnetic impurity bound states".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The discovery of high-temperature superconductivity in single layer FeSe epitaxially grown on SrTiO3(001) substrates has instigated extensive debate over whether its pairing symmetry is conventional sign-preserving s-wave or unconventional sign-changing The authors probe the pairing state for single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 grown by molecular beam epitaxy using scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy.

Kai: They observe robust in-gap bound states induced by non-magnetic Fevacancy defects within the Fe-plane, which exhibit strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry with two-fold symmetry in hole states and four-fold in electron states.

Mira: The bound states exhibit no energy shift or splitting under an applied magnetic field, consistent with a sign-changing order parameter.

Kai: This is further confirmed by defect bound state quasiparticle interference that shows a sign changing behavior with a pair of corresponding peaks at the positive and negative energies near the impurity bound states.

Paper summary: Kai: To get into the details, the core argument of this paper is that they are using impurity scattering to figure out the pairing symmetry. They found these induced bound states and their spatial asymmetry, which they argue strongly suggest a sign-changing pairing scenario >

Mira: The context for this is that single layer FeSe has multiple bands crossing the Fermi level, which makes determining the symmetry really hard. This lack of hole pockets also challenges some theories involving spin fluctuations that predict a sign reversal between electron and hole pockets >

Lev: And they're looking at what this means for real hardware. If you were building a qubit system based on this material, you’d need to consider how these impurity-induced states affect the quasiparticle excitations that cause decoherence >

Kai: They also mention earlier conflicting results from other STM work. Some studies suggested plain s-wave based on quasiparticle interference off surface adsorbates like nonmagnetic zinc, silver, and potassium atoms where no bound states were seen >

Mira: But then recent work showed that even with nonmagnetic surface potassium and lead adatoms, they found bound states near the gap edge after careful data analysis >

Lev: That's a key point because it shows that even subtle changes in the scattering environment can push us away from the simple s-wave picture >

Kai: So, what's their final claim about what this all means for single layer FeSe? It seems they rule out plain s-wave pairing and leave two possibilities: either an s plus minus sign pairing or a nodeless d wave >

Conclusion: Mira: Looking at the title, "Sign changing pairing in single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 revealed by nonmagnetic impurity bound states," it sums up the whole investigation perfectly >

Kai: It tells us that even when you introduce something seemingly benign like a non-magnetic defect, you can get deep insight into the fundamental nature of superconductivity itself >

Lev: For someone working on error correction, this is important because it suggests that we might not be looking at a single, simple symmetry across the whole material >

Mira: It implies that the physics could be more complex than just s-wave or d-wave. The paper shows that sign reversal is a real possibility in this system >

Kai: The implication for materials science is that we can use these subtle impurity effects to distinguish between different pairing symmetries, which was previously very difficult to do reliably >

Huimin Zhang, Zhuozhi Ge, Michael Weinert, Lian Li

Department of Physics and Astronomy, West Virginia University · Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee

cond-mat.supr-con, cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2026-11-12

Updated: 2026-11-12

DOI: 10.1038/s42005-020-0351-1

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: The discovery of high-temperature superconductivity in single layer FeSe epitaxially grown on SrTiO3(001) substrates has instigated extensive debate over whether its pairing symmetry is conventional…

Key concepts

Sign Changing Order Parameter
This refers to the superconducting gap function, which changes its sign when moving from one part of the material to another. In this context, it means the pairing symmetry is not a simple conventional type like s-wave but involves a more complex structure where the pairing interaction flips its sign.
In-gap Bound States
These are electronic states that appear within the energy gap of a superconductor, usually caused by impurities. Their presence and specific spatial distribution provide crucial clues about the underlying superconducting pairing symmetry, distinguishing between different possibilities like s-wave or d-wave pairing.
Electron-Hole Asymmetry
This describes how the electronic states near the Fermi level behave differently for electrons (positive energy) versus holes (negative energy). The paper found strong asymmetry in the spatial distribution of these bound states, which is a key signature pointing towards an unconventional, sign-changing pairing symmetry.

Terminology

Summary

The discovery of high-temperature superconductivity in single layer FeSe epitaxially grown on SrTiO3(001) substrates has instigated extensive debate over whether its pairing symmetry is conventional sign-preserving s-wave or unconventional sign-changing The authors probe the pairing state for single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 grown by molecular beam epitaxy using scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract The discovery of high-temperature superconductivity in single layer FeSe epitaxially grown on SrTiO3(001) substrates has instigated extensive debate over whether its pairing symmetry is conventional sign-preserving s-wave or unconventional sign-changing. Here we probe the pairing state for single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 grown by molecular beam epitaxy using scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy.

They observe robust in-gap bound states induced by non-magnetic Fevacancy defects within the Fe-plane, which exhibit strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry with two-fold symmetry in hole states and four-fold in electron states. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Here we probe the pairing state for single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 grown by molecular beam epitaxy using scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy. We observe robust in-gap bound states induced by non-magnetic Fevacancy defects within the Fe-plane, which exhibit strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry with two-fold symmetry in hole states and four-fold in electron states.

The bound states exhibit no energy shift or splitting under an applied magnetic field, consistent with a sign-changing order parameter. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We observe robust in-gap bound states induced by non-magnetic Fevacancy defects within the Fe-plane, which exhibit strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry with two-fold symmetry in hole states and four-fold in electron states. The bound states exhibit no energy shift or splitting under an applied magnetic field, consistent with a sign-changing order parameter.

This is further confirmed by defect bound state quasiparticle interference that shows a sign changing behavior with a pair of corresponding peaks at the positive and negative energies near the impurity bound states. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The bound states exhibit no energy shift or splitting under an applied magnetic field, consistent with a sign-changing order parameter. This is further confirmed by defect bound state quasiparticle interference that shows a sign changing behavior with a pair of corresponding peaks at the positive and negative energies near the impurity bound states.

Their findings provide unambiguous evidence for a sign-changing pairing symmetry for single layer FeSe/SrTiO3. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is further confirmed by defect bound state quasiparticle interference that shows a sign changing behavior with a pair of corresponding peaks at the positive and negative energies near the impurity bound states. Our findings provide unambiguous evidence for a sign-changing pairing symmetry for single layer FeSe/SrTiO3.

Probing Superconducting Symmetry

The investigation into the superconducting pairing symmetry in single layer FeSe/STO is crucial due to the multiple bands crossing the Fermi level, which gives rise to a number of pairing symmetries. The lack of hole pockets challenges the spin fluctuation picture that involves a sign reversal order parameter between the electron and hole pockets. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Because of electron doping from the STO substrate8 , the Fermi surface of FeSe/STO consists of only electron pockets at the Brillouin zone (BZ) corner M points, while the hole pockets at  point are entirely below the Fermi energy9,10. The lack of hole pockets challenges the spin fluctuation picture that involves a sign reversal order parameter between the electron and hole pockets11,12.

This has instigated extensive debate on the symmetry of pairing state in single layer FeSe, with leading contender being sign-preserving conventional s-wave pairing, and unconventional sign-changing extended s-wave and nodeless d-wave pairing, where experimental validation are sorely needed. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The lack of hole pockets challenges the spin fluctuation picture that involves a sign reversal order parameter between the electron and hole pockets11,12. This has instigated extensive debate on the symmetry of pairing state in single layer FeSe, with leading contender being sign-preserving conventional s-wave pairing13, and unconventional sign-changing extended s-wave14,15 and nodeless d-wave pairing16–19 , where experimental validation are sorely needed20 .

The authors probe bound states induced by non-magnetic impurities within the Fe-plane of single layer FeSe/STO, whose nonmagnetic nature is verified by magnetic field dependent studies. p. 2
Where the paper says it

As such, the pairing symmetry for single layer FeSe/STO remains controversial, and unambiguous verification of induced in-gap bound states and quasiparticle scattering off nonmagnetic impurities within the Fe plane is crucial. In this work, we probe bound states induced by non-magnetic impurities within the Fe-plane of single layer FeSe/STO, whose nonmagnetic nature is verified by magnetic field dependent studies.

Evidence from Impurity Bound States

The study utilizes impurity scattering to investigate the superconducting pairing symmetry of single layer FeSe/STO, but with conflicting results. Earlier STM work suggested a plain s-wave based on quasiparticle interference off adsorbates on the surface of FeSe, where no impurity-induced bound states were observed for nonmagnetic Zn, Ag, and K adatoms. p. 2

Where the paper says it

A plain s-wave has been suggested in an earlier STM work13, based on quasiparticle interference off adsorbates on the surface of FeSe, where no impurity-induced bound states were observed for nonmagnetic Zn, Ag, and K adatoms. However, more recent work shows that even for nonmagnetic surface K 21 and Pb adatoms 22, bound states near the superconducting gap edge were found after careful data analysis.

More recent work shows that even for nonmagnetic surface K and Pb adatoms, bound states near the superconducting gap edge were found after careful data analysis. p. 2
Where the paper says it

A plain s-wave has been suggested in an earlier STM work13, based on quasiparticle interference off adsorbates on the surface of FeSe, where no impurity-induced bound states were observed for nonmagnetic Zn, Ag, and K adatoms. However, more recent work shows that even for nonmagnetic surface K 21 and Pb adatoms 22, bound states near the superconducting gap edge were found after careful data analysis.

The emergence of these induced bound states indicates sign-reversing pairing scenarios, challenging the plain s-wave pairing symmetry. p. 2
Where the paper says it

However, more recent work shows that even for nonmagnetic surface K 21 and Pb adatoms 22, bound states near the superconducting gap edge were found after careful data analysis. The emergence of the induced bound states by these nonmagnetic surface adatoms21,22 indicates sign-reversing pairing scenarios, challenging the plain s-wave pairing symmetry.

Spatial and Energy Dependence

The in-gap bound states exhibit a strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry, which provides unambiguous evidence for sign-changing pairing symmetry. Specifically, the hole-like (negative energy) bound state at −4. p. 5

Where the paper says it

6 like states (Figs. Specifically, the hole-like (negative energy) bound state at −4.

4 meV exhibits a two-fold symmetry (Fig. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Specifically, the hole-like (negative energy) bound state at −4. 4 meV exhibits a two-fold symmetry (Fig.

2b), while the electron-like (positive energy) bound state at +4. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2b), where the intensity is the strongest directly at the impurity site (Fig. In contrast, the electron-like (positive energy) bound state at +4.

4 meV exhibits a four-fold symmetry with the highest intensity at the four lobes. p. 5
Where the paper says it

In contrast, the electron-like (positive energy) bound state at +4. 4 meV exhibits a four-fold symmetry with the highest intensity at the four lobes (Fig.

A strong electron-hole asymmetry is clearly seen here where the local maxima and minima occur at different lattice sites with respect to the impurity. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2c), as shown in the dI/dV spectrum taken at one of the lobes in Fig. A strong electron-hole asymmetry is clearly seen here where the local maxima and minima occur at different lattice sites with respect to the impurity.

Overall, the spatial distribution at +4. p. 5
Where the paper says it

S7, where the intensity of the hole state decreases from the defect site to the nearest neighbor (NN), next nearest neighbor (NNN), 3rd NN, and so on, while the electron state emerges, with increasing intensity in the reverse order, reaching maximum at 3 rd NN. Overall, the spatial distribution at +4.

4 meV shows a C2 symmetry, while at −4. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Overall, the spatial distribution at +4. 4 meV shows a C2 symmetry, while at −4.

4 meV it is approximately C4 symmetric. p. 5
Where the paper says it

4 meV shows a C2 symmetry, while at −4. 4 meV it is approximately C4 symmetric.

These observations of the in-gap bound states and spatial electron-hole asymmetry are similar to those of in d-wave cuprate superconductors, indicating an unconventional pairing symmetry in single layer FeSe/STO. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Similar electron-hole asymmetry is also observed for type B defect, as shown in Supplementary Fig. These observations of the in-gap bound states and spatial electron-hole asymmetry are similar to those of in d-wave cuprate superconductors1–3 , indicating an unconventional pairing symmetry in single layer FeSe/STO.

Phase-Referenced Confirmation

The defect bound state phase-reference quasiparticle interference reveals corresponding positive and negative peaks at the bound state energies, indicating a sign changing pairing parameter. The phase term can be expressed as cos(thetaq,-E - thetaq,+E) = cos(thetaq,-E cos thetaq,+E + sin thetaq,-E sin thetaq,+E) = Re[g(q,−E)]g(q,−E)/Re[g(q,+E)]g(q,+E) + Im[g(q,−E)]g(q,−E)/Im[g(q,+E)]g(q,+E). If there is a sign change between the initial and final state, the phase shift would be pi, hence inducing a negative value since cos(thetaq,-E - thetaq,+E) = cos(pi) = −1. p. 7

Where the paper says it

For unconventional superconductors with sign change between different Fermi surfaces, additional phase shifts are expected near the bound state induced by nonmagnetic impurities. This phase information can be obtained from the recently developed defect bound states-QPI technique24–27, where a pair of positive and negative peaks are expected to appear in gpr (q,+E) and gpr (q,−E), respectively, at energies near the nonmagnetic impurity bound-state energies ±EB (see Methods).

Conclusion

In conclusion, the possibility of plain s-wave can be ruled out, which leaves two scenarios for the pairing symmetry of single layer FeSe/STO: s+− and nodeless d-wave. Their recent work shows that one-dimensional scattering where the momentum q is always perpendicular to edges can provide a means to further differentiate these two pairing scenarios. p. 9

Where the paper says it

S19), hence cannot be distinguished by this method. Our recent work shows that one-dimensional scattering where the momentum q is always perpendicular to edges can provide a means to further differentiate these two pairing scenarios37 .

The authors systematically studied the in-gap bound states induced by nonmagnetic impurities within the Fe-plane in single layer FeSe/STO by STM/S. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Our recent work shows that one-dimensional scattering where the momentum q is always perpendicular to edges can provide a means to further differentiate these two pairing scenarios37 . In conclusion, we systematically studied the in-gap bound states induced by nonmagnetic impurities within the Fe-plane in single layer FeSe/STO by STM/S.

These bound states exhibit a strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry whose energy position is correlated with local doping. p. 9
Where the paper says it

In conclusion, we systematically studied the in-gap bound states induced by nonmagnetic impurities within the Fe-plane in single layer FeSe/STO by STM/S. These bound states exhibit a strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry whose energy position is correlated with local doping.

They further carry out phase-referenced defect bound state QPI, which reveals corresponding positive and negative peaks at the bound state energies, indicating a sign change for the order parameter. p. 9
Where the paper says it

These bound states exhibit a strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry whose energy position is correlated with local doping. We further carry out phase-referenced defect bound state QPI, which reveals corresponding positive and negative peaks at the bound state energies, indicating a sign change for the order parameter.

Methods

Single layer FeSe films were prepared by MBE under the Se-rich conditions using high purity Fe (99.995%) and Se (99.9999%) from an e-beam source and a K-cell on the Nb-doped (0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract The discovery of high-temperature superconductivity in single layer FeSe epitaxially grown on SrTiO3(001) substrates has instigated extensive debate over whether its pairing symmetry is conventional sign-preserving s-wave or unconventional sign-changing. Here we probe the pairing state for single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 grown by molecular beam epitaxy using scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy.

05 wt.%) SrTiO3(001) substrate at 400 °C. p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 Sign changing pairing in single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 revealed by nonmagnetic impurity bound states Huimin Zhang1 , Zhuozhi Ge1,2 , Michael Weinert2 , and Lian Li1★ 1Department of Physics and Astronomy, West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV 26506, USA 2Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI 53201, USA ★Correspondence to: lian. edu Abstract The discovery of high-temperature superconductivity in single layer FeSe epitaxially grown on SrTiO3(001) substrates has instigated extensive debate over whether its pairing symmetry is conventional sign-preserving s-wave or unconventional sign-changing.

The as-grown FeSe films were capped with approximately 20 nm amorphous Se films, and then transferred in air to a Unisoku-1300 STM system where they were annealed at 200 °C for 2 hrs first to remove the extra Se and subsequently at between 460 and 480 °C for 1 h to reach superconductivity. p. 3
Where the paper says it

01011 cm-2 , higher density (1. 51013 cm-2 ) can be introduced by capping the FeSe films with amorphous Se film first, and then annealing to remove the Se layer (Supplementary Fig.

Low-temperature STM/S measurements were carried out using a polycrystalline PtIr tip. p. 4
Where the paper says it

1e&f) further indicate that while the intensities of these states are slightly suppressed in an external magnetic field; no shift or splitting of these peaks are observed up to 9 T out-of-plane or 2 T in-plane fields, indicating both these types of defects are nonmagnetic. We have also carried out tunneling spectroscopy measurements at 400 mK with improved energy resolution of 0.

Data Availability

The data supporting the findings of this study are available within the paper, its Supplementary Information files, and from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can definitively determine pairing symmetry by analyzing defect bound state phase reference quasiparticle interference data using equations (1) through (3). This allows for a direct determination of a sign change for the order parameter if a phase shift of pi is observed in the negative energy signal as described in page 12.

  2. Improved AI systems can distinguish between plain s-wave, nodeless d-wave, and bonding-antibonding s-wave pairing symmetries by analyzing spatial electron hole asymmetry observed in bound states. This asymmetry, such as the two-fold symmetry (Fig. 2b) for the hole-like (negative energy) bound state at-4.4 meV and four-fold symmetry with the highest intensity at the four lobes (Fig. 2c) for electron states, provides a signature of unconventional pairing.

  3. Improved AI systems can correlate local doping levels with bound state energy positions to predict the nature of defect-induced shifts in normal states. For instance, the paper shows the normal-state peak energy shifts downward as the bound state shifts towards the superconducting edge, suggesting that local electron doping is one of possible causes for the energy shift of the bound states (page 7).

Abstract

The discovery of high-temperature superconductivity in single layer FeSe epitaxially grown on SrTiO3(001) substrates has instigated extensive debate over whether its pairing symmetry is conventional sign-preserving s-wave or unconventional sign-changing. Here we probe the pairing state for single layer FeSe/SrTiO3 grown by molecular beam epitaxy using scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy. We observe robust in-gap bound states induced by non-magnetic Fe-vacancy defects within the Fe-plane, which exhibit strong spatial electron-hole asymmetry with two-fold symmetry in hole states and four-fold in electron states. The bound states exhibit no energy shift or splitting under an applied magnetic field, consistent with a sign-changing order parameter.

Related papers