Extended SO(10) -inspired leptogenesis
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Extended SO(10) -inspired leptogenesis".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Extended SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis shows that barring well known fine-tuned crossing level solutions and given current low energy neutrino experimental data, these always lead to a very hierarchical heavy neutrino spectrum If the Dirac neutrino masses are assumed not to significantly differ from the up-quark masses, then the intermediate seesaw neutrino (N2) mass falls in the correct range for its decays to explain the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe via (N2-)leptogenesis, while the lightest seesaw neutrino decays give a negligible contribution Seesaw Model Implications The paper considers seesaw models with hierarchical Dirac neutrino masses and demonstrates that they invariably lead to a very hierarchical heavy neutrino spectrum unless fine-tuned crossing level solutions are invoked If the Dirac neutrino masses are assumed not to significantly differ from the up-quark masses, the intermediate seesaw neutrino (N2) mass is in a correct range for (N2-)leptogenesis to explain the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe, while lighter neutrinos contribute negligibly The conclusions are valid independently of any additional condition on the Dirac neutrino mass matrix SO(10) Constraints and Leptogenesis Scenarios The SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis scenario, which assumes the mismatch between neutrino and charged lepton Dirac mass matrices at the level of the CKM matrix, leads to solutions for inverted ordered neutrino masses The N3 neutrino mass M3 cannot be too much larger than ∼ 1016 GeV, and from the seesaw formula this yields a lower bound on the lightest neutrino mass m1 ≳ 1 meV The N2-leptogenesis scenario is an unavoidable consequence if one wants to reproduce the observed asymmetry with leptogenesis, assuming Dirac neutrino masses not too dissimilar (order-of-magnitude wise) from up quark masses and barring high fine-tuned solutions Constraints from Neutrino Data The SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis scenario strictly predicts normal ordering (NO) because there are no solutions for inverted ordered (IO) neutrino masses when considering the current upper bound on the atmospheric neutrino mixing angle and on the absolute neutrino mass scale from cosmological observations The strong thermal SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis solution requires that all constraints on low energy neutrino parameters become much more stringent, with an allowed range on the absolute neutrino mass scale of 10 meV ≲ m1 ≲ 30 meV Extended Model Extensions and Final Conclusions The paper extends the SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis by relaxing SO(10)-inspired condition (II) to allow for an arbitrary matrix VL, finding that the RH neutrino mass spectrum still remains very hierarchical, requiring N2-leptogenesis It is found that imposing in addition a strong thermal leptogenesis condition requires NO and IO is still not viable The bulk of solutions remains in the range 1 meV ≲ m1 ≲ 30 meV, and the strong thermal subset implies a lower bound on m1 and mee of m1, mee ≳ 10 meV The current support of data to NO should then regarded as an encouraging success for this scenario Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper considers seesaw models with hierarchical Dirac neutrino masses and shows that they always lead to a very hierarchical heavy neutrino spectrum If the Dirac neutrino masses are assumed not to significantly differ from the up-quark masses, then the intermediate seesaw neutrino (N2) mass falls in the correct range for its decays to explain the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe via (N2-)leptogenesis, while the lightest seesaw neutrino decays give a negligible contribution The conclusions are valid independently of any additional condition on the Dirac neutrino mass matrix How the training signal is built The paper shows how the emergence of the N2-leptogenesis scenario within seesaw models is much more general than thought so far The constraints obtained in the traditional scenario get relaxed and even IO solutions become viable when relaxing SO(10)-inspired condition (II) The analytical expressions for the seesaw neutrino masses MI, the RH neutrino mixing matrix UR and even for the orthogonal matrix omega are still valid barring vicinity of crossing level solutions Where the gains come from The final B −L asymmetry can be calculated as the sum of three contributions, one from each (charged lepton) flavour The successful leptogenesis condition is equivalent to a parametric equation identifying a hypersurface in the space of parameters The results confirm again those obtained in previous works, and the main effect of flavour coupling is the appearance of new muonic solutions The bulk of solutions (95%) lie in a range between 1 meV and 30 meV, which will be significantly tested by future years by new generation 0νββ experiments Final remarks We have shown that, given current neutrino experimental data, just imposing that the neutrino Dirac masses are not too dissimilar from the up quark masses yields a RH neutrino mass spectrum with M1 < 109 GeV and M2 ∼ 1011 GeV, necessarily requiring N2-leptogenesis for the explanation of the measured baryon asymmetry The only way to avoid this conclusion, barring special crossing level solutions or very particular choices for the matrix VL, is that either α1 ≳ 100 or that α1 ≲ 0.
Paper summary: Mira: The central claim is that if the Dirac neutrino masses don't differ much from the up quark masses, then the intermediate seesaw neutrino, N2, has a mass in the correct range for N2 minus leptogenesis to explain our universe's matter-antimatter asymmetry.
Kai: And this happens even when you assume no extra conditions on the Dirac neutrino mass matrix at all; it’s quite general. It extends the usual SO(ten)-inspired leptogenesis scenario by allowing for a more arbitrary matrix VL <ref:2611.16604#pg1,the usual SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis scenario>.
Lev: What I’m thinking from an engineering side is that this generality means we can't just rely on one specific structure of the theory to predict the necessary mass scales; it depends heavily on those underlying Dirac mass assumptions.
Mira: Precisely, and that dependence is what makes it more interesting because we can test those assumptions against the observed neutrino data. The paper also confirms that solutions for inverted ordered neutrino masses become viable under these extended conditions.
Kai: That’s a big shift if inverted ordering is allowed, because our current constraints from atmospheric mixing angles and cosmological observations usually rule that out.
Lev: That's where the caveat comes in; for us, we have to check if the required parameter space for those IO solutions is compatible with what real hardware can actually probe in terms of energy scales.
Mira: The paper also sets a lower bound on the lightest neutrino mass m1 because of the constraints from the atmospheric neutrino mixing angle and absolute mass scale experiments.
Kai: That lower bound they find is around one meV to thirty meV, which is what we've been seeing in our simulations for this scenario.
Conclusion: Mira: The authors find that this conclusion holds even when relaxing some of the usual SO(ten) constraints, which is a significant extension to the traditional approach <ref:2611.16604#pg1>. They show that N2 minus leptogenesis is an unavoidable consequence if we want to reproduce the observed asymmetry with leptogenesis, assuming Dirac neutrino masses are not too dissimilar from up quark masses and barring high fine-tuned solutions.
Kai: The implication for us right now is that this work gives us a more robust framework to test against existing low energy neutrino data, particularly concerning the mass scale of those intermediate neutrinos.
Lev: For hardware development, it means we need to be ready to look for signals in that one meV to thirty meV range if this physics is correct. It sets a target for what our next generation of experiments should be sensitive to.
Mira: In simple terms, the paper suggests that the constraints from current neutrino data might actually point towards normal ordering being the most likely scenario within this extended SO(ten) framework, provided we are not dealing with fine-tuned solutions <ref:2611.16604#pg1>.
Pasquale Di Bari, Xubin Hu
University of Southampton
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-11-12
Updated: 2026-11-12
Comments: 35 pages, 15 figures
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 79/100
The gist: Extended SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis shows that barring well known fine-tuned crossing level solutions and given current low energy neutrino experimental data…
Key concepts
- Seesaw Model Implications
- This refers to how the model's structure dictates that heavy neutrino masses must be very spread out (hierarchical) unless specific, fine-tuned solutions are introduced. If the Dirac neutrino masses are similar to up-quark masses, the intermediate heavy neutrino mass (N2) is in a range suitable for generating the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry through N2-leptogenesis.
- SO(10)-inspired Leptogenesis
- This scenario uses a specific framework from SO(10) grand unified theories to explain how the universe got its current matter excess. It assumes a relationship between neutrino and charged lepton masses that leads to solutions for inverted neutrino mass orderings. This framework suggests that N3 (the heaviest neutrino) cannot be excessively massive.
- N2-leptogenesis
- This is a specific mechanism where the decay of an intermediate heavy neutrino (N2) is responsible for creating the matter-antimatter asymmetry in the universe. The paper shows this scenario is necessary if Dirac neutrino masses are not drastically different from up-quark masses, making it a key prediction for explaining the observed asymmetry.
- Normal Ordering (NO)
- This refers to a specific pattern of neutrino mass ordering where the lightest neutrino has the smallest mass. Current constraints from atmospheric mixing and cosmological observations strongly predict that this normal ordering must be true within this SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis framework.
Terminology
Summary
Extended SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis shows that barring well known fine-tuned crossing level solutions and given current low energy neutrino experimental data, these always lead to a very hierarchical heavy neutrino spectrum If the Dirac neutrino masses are assumed not to significantly differ from the up-quark masses, then the intermediate seesaw neutrino (N2) mass falls in the correct range for its decays to explain the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe via (N2-)leptogenesis, while the lightest seesaw neutrino decays give a negligible contribution
Seesaw Model Implications
The paper considers seesaw models with hierarchical Dirac neutrino masses and demonstrates that they invariably lead to a very hierarchical heavy neutrino spectrum unless fine-tuned crossing level solutions are invoked If the Dirac neutrino masses are assumed not to significantly differ from the up-quark masses, the intermediate seesaw neutrino (N2) mass is in a correct range for (N2-)leptogenesis to explain the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe, while lighter neutrinos contribute negligibly The conclusions are valid independently of any additional condition on the Dirac neutrino mass matrix
SO(10) Constraints and Leptogenesis Scenarios
The SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis scenario, which assumes the mismatch between neutrino and charged lepton Dirac mass matrices at the level of the CKM matrix, leads to solutions for inverted ordered neutrino masses The N3 neutrino mass M3 cannot be too much larger than ∼ 1016 GeV, and from the seesaw formula this yields a lower bound on the lightest neutrino mass m1 ≳ 1 meV The N2-leptogenesis scenario is an unavoidable consequence if one wants to reproduce the observed asymmetry with leptogenesis, assuming Dirac neutrino masses not too dissimilar (order-of-magnitude wise) from up quark masses and barring high fine-tuned solutions
Constraints from Neutrino Data
The SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis scenario strictly predicts normal ordering (NO) because there are no solutions for inverted ordered (IO) neutrino masses when considering the current upper bound on the atmospheric neutrino mixing angle and on the absolute neutrino mass scale from cosmological observations The strong thermal SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis solution requires that all constraints on low energy neutrino parameters become much more stringent, with an allowed range on the absolute neutrino mass scale of 10 meV ≲ m1 ≲ 30 meV
Extended Model Extensions and Final Conclusions
The paper extends the SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis by relaxing SO(10)-inspired condition (II) to allow for an arbitrary matrix VL, finding that the RH neutrino mass spectrum still remains very hierarchical, requiring N2-leptogenesis It is found that imposing in addition a strong thermal leptogenesis condition requires NO and IO is still not viable The bulk of solutions remains in the range 1 meV ≲ m1 ≲ 30 meV, and the strong thermal subset implies a lower bound on m1 and mee of m1, mee ≳ 10 meV The current support of data to NO should then regarded as an encouraging success for this scenario
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The paper considers seesaw models with hierarchical Dirac neutrino masses and shows that they always lead to a very hierarchical heavy neutrino spectrum If the Dirac neutrino masses are assumed not to significantly differ from the up-quark masses, then the intermediate seesaw neutrino (N2) mass falls in the correct range for its decays to explain the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe via (N2-)leptogenesis, while the lightest seesaw neutrino decays give a negligible contribution The conclusions are valid independently of any additional condition on the Dirac neutrino mass matrix
How the training signal is built
The paper shows how the emergence of the N2-leptogenesis scenario within seesaw models is much more general than thought so far The constraints obtained in the traditional scenario get relaxed and even IO solutions become viable when relaxing SO(10)-inspired condition (II) The analytical expressions for the seesaw neutrino masses MI, the RH neutrino mixing matrix UR and even for the orthogonal matrix omega are still valid barring vicinity of crossing level solutions
Where the gains come from
The final B −L asymmetry can be calculated as the sum of three contributions, one from each (charged lepton) flavour The successful leptogenesis condition is equivalent to a parametric equation identifying a hypersurface in the space of parameters The results confirm again those obtained in previous works, and the main effect of flavour coupling is the appearance of new muonic solutions The bulk of solutions (95%) lie in a range between 1 meV and 30 meV, which will be significantly tested by future years by new generation 0νββ experiments
Final remarks
We have shown that, given current neutrino experimental data, just imposing that the neutrino Dirac masses are not too dissimilar from the up quark masses yields a RH neutrino mass spectrum with M1 < 109 GeV and M2 ∼ 1011 GeV, necessarily requiring N2-leptogenesis for the explanation of the measured baryon asymmetry The only way to avoid this conclusion, barring special crossing level solutions or very particular choices for the matrix VL, is that either α1 ≳ 100 or that α1 ≲ 0.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced parameter scanning capabilities for SO(10)-inspired models: The system can perform random scans over all six parameters in matrix VL, logarithmically on m1, and uniformly on the three mixing angles across specific 5 sigma ranges to map out viable solutions.
-
Constraint propagation using full leptogenesis conditions: The AI can calculate the baryon-to-photon number ratio eta lep B (Eq. 40) as a function of all nine low energy neutrino parameters and six VL parameters, allowing it to identify the hypersurface where successful leptogenesis is satisfied.
-
Discrimination between mass ordering scenarios: The system can analyze the scatter plots for NO and IO to definitively conclude that
there are no solutions for IO compatible with current low energy neutrino data
under the conditions imposed by SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis. -
Detection of strong thermal leptogenesis subsets: The AI can specifically search for blue circles in Figure 1, indicating the subset of solutions satisfying successful SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis and the strong thermal leptogenesis condition, which are crucial for constraining m1 and mee to be
much more stringent and more easily testable.
-
Flavor coupling analysis integration: The system can incorporate flavor coupling from spectator processes by including 27 terms in the final B-L asymmetry calculation (Eq. 41), allowing it to observe how this effect
slightly relaxes the lower bound on m1, from 0.89 meV to 0.65 meV.
-
Predictive power for future experiments: The system can use the current constraints to predict that
new generation 0νββ experiments will be able to test extended SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis in a substantial way
and anticipate the required signal for the strong thermal subset.
Sources
- Evidence for oscillation of atmospheric neutrinos
- Complex Spinors and Unified Theories
- Neutrinos and Collider Physics
- Multilepton and Lepton Jet Probes of Sub-Weak-Scale Right-Handed Neutrinos
- Sensitivity of the SHiP experiment to Heavy Neutral Leptons
- Heavy Neutrinos in displaced vertex searches at the LHC and HL-LHC
- Cold Dark Matter from heavy Right-Handed neutrino mixing
- Unifying leptogenesis, dark matter and high-energy neutrinos with right-handed neutrino mixing via Higgs portal
- Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
- Probing the scale of grand unification with gravitational waves
- Testing Seesaw and Leptogenesis with Gravitational Waves
- Gravitational waves from neutrino mass and dark matter genesis
- Gravitational waves from first-order phase transitions in Majoron models of neutrino mass
- A Predictive and Testable Unified Theory of Fermion Masses, Mixing and Leptogenesis
- A realistic theory of $\mathrm{E_{6}}$ unification through novel intermediate symmetries
- A model for fermion masses and lepton mixing in SO(10) x A4
- A SUSY GUT of Flavour with S4 x SU(5) to NLO
- Successful $N_2$ leptogenesis with flavour coupling effects in realistic unified models
- Successful type I Leptogenesis with SO(10)-inspired mass relations
- Testing SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis with low energy neutrino experiments
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses