Verifiable Settlement and Pricing for Local Energy Markets: Architecture and Deployment on Hyperledger Besu

arXiv:2611.16495 · cs.CR, cs.GT, q-fin.TR · Submitted 2026-11-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Security Radio. Generated commentary on the latest security and cryptography papers.

Nadia: We're looking at the paper: "Verifiable Settlement and Pricing for Local Energy Markets".

Elias: Here's the gist of the paper. We implement privacy-preserving local electricity exchanges using an automated market maker on the Hyperledger Besu network under QBFT consensus The proposed protocol operator collects individual electricity positions off-chain and publishes aggregate supply and demand on the blockchain, where smart contracts compute market prices every fifteen minutes Individual positions remain off-chain; Poseidon2 commitments and UltraHonk zeroknowledge proofs, generated from Noir circuits, verify aggregation, payments, and daily balance updates The architecture retains community coordination while making financial execution independently auditable Market Mechanism Design The paper addresses the challenge of realizing the economic value of local electricity trading by introducing an automated market maker (AMM) that aggregates community supply and demand to determine prices every fifteen minutes.

Nadia: The mechanism allocates the gains from local exchanges according to predefined pricing rules derived from economic principles like individual rationality and budget balance The relevant outside options are the tariffs at which a participant would otherwise transact with its electricity supplier or other grid-facing counterparty, expressed as an export remuneration (feed-in rate) λ and a retail import tariff λ.

Elias: Three pricing rules are considered: the mid-market rate (MMR) rule

13: , the supply–demand ratio (SDR) rule

13: , and the hyperbolic rule.

Nadia: Architectural Hybrid Approach The proposed architecture adopts a hybrid structure where the organizing entity retains coordination, data-management, and compliance functions, while households remain responsible for their own electricity decisions The first challenge involves the confidentiality of household electricity data; publishing individual positions on-chain would expose detailed consumption and generation patterns.

Title and authors: Nadia: So we're looking at "Verifiable Settlement and Pricing for Local Energy Markets: Architecture and Deployment on Hyperledger Besu". It sounds super technical, but at its core, it's about creating a way for neighbors to trade electricity locally without everyone having to share all their private usage data.

Elias: Yeah, the title makes it sound like we're solving two big problems: how to set prices fairly and how to make sure those trades actually happen securely on a blockchain. It’s about building an actual market mechanism for local exchanges using that Hyperledger Besu network under QBFT consensus.

Nadia: Exactly, and the key thing they propose is keeping the actual electricity positions off-chain while still getting verified settlement on-chain. They're using this automated market maker to figure out prices every fifteen minutes based on what everyone is doing right now.

Priya: I'm curious about that "off-chain" part. If individual positions are staying private, what does that mean for the data we actually get to see before we trust the system?

Elias: Well, they use cryptographic commitments and zero knowledge proofs from Noir circuits to prove that those private positions match up with the aggregate supply and demand they publish on the ledger. It’s a way to show consistency without revealing what any single household is doing.

Nadia: That sounds like a real win for privacy. The paper says this architecture lets the community operator handle coordination while making sure financial execution is independently auditable, which I think addresses a lot of the trust issues in these kinds of systems.

Priya: And that independence from the operator's financial calculations is important. If we can't see their private profit calculations, we need a strong way to check if they followed the agreed rules.

The paper's summary: Nadia: Okay, so what’s the actual mechanism they’re proposing for pricing? They introduce an automated market maker, or AMM, which aggregates the community supply and demand every fifteen minutes to determine market prices.

Elias: That AMM is supposed to allocate gains from these local exchanges based on predefined rules that come from economic principles like individual rationality and budget balance. It’s not just random pricing; it’s structured so people have a reason to participate.

Priya: I'm thinking about those pricing rules. The paper mentions three specific options: the mid-market rate, which is based on some existing tariff structure, the supply demand ratio rule, and a hyperbolic rule. Which one seems most practical for a community to actually adopt?

Elias: They test all three of them because they are different ways to distribute the surplus. The goal is to see how these different pricing rules affect the outcome when people are making their own decisions about trading energy.

Nadia: And they also have this hybrid architecture where the organizing entity does the coordination and compliance, but households keep control over their own electricity decisions, which is a pretty smart way to handle the coordination costs.

Priya: I still have that confidentiality concern nagging at me. They admit that a conventional on-chain setup would expose detailed consumption patterns like occupancy and daily routines if everyone published their positions every fifteen minutes, so this structure seems necessary for privacy.

The paper's improvements: Elias: Moving into the improvements, they focus heavily on the verification layer. They use Poseidon2 commitments and UltraHonk zero knowledge proofs to verify aggregation, payments, and daily balance updates without revealing individual electricity profiles.

Nadia: And they have this second type of proof which is really interesting—it lets a member prove the value of their committed balance when they need recourse or independent withdrawal. It’s about giving users some control back over their commitments.

Priya: That sounds like a significant step for user trust, because it means the system isn't just pushing data; it’s proving that what you committed to is actually correct against the public prices and balances.

Elias: The paper enforces this by having a batch circuit that connects six specific conditions together: binding and aggregation, payments and balance updates, conservation and participation, and participation eligibility. It ties everything together in one verifiable way.

Nadia: They also do the math on a very practical level in their experiments. They found that daily settlement uses approximately nineteen million gas when they run the ten-household simulation using simulated US residential profiles <ref:2611.16495#pg1,daily settlement uses approximately 19 million gas>.

Conclusion: Nadia: So, to wrap this up, "Verifiable Settlement and Pricing for Local Energy Markets: Architecture and Deployment on Hyperledger Besu" is proposing a system where an AMM calculates prices every fifteen minutes, uses zero knowledge proofs to keep household data private while verifying the trades on a shared ledger.

Elias: The main implication is that this structure lets the community operator coordinate things while keeping financial execution auditable, and it allows communities to choose how they distribute gains using those three different pricing rules.

Priya: From my side, what I’m seeing is that the architecture solves the privacy problem by separating private positions from public aggregates, which is a huge hurdle in these systems. However, we still need to keep an eye on how robust those zero knowledge proofs are under real-world stress.

Nadia: Right, so while it's a strong framework for privacy and coordination, we still have to worry about the practical adoption hurdles like coordination costs mentioned in earlier discussions.

Elias: Exactly, and that leads us into thinking about how these pricing rules—mid-market rate versus supply demand ratio versus hyperbolic rule—actually translate into real-world financial incentives for people to invest in things like solar panels.

Priya: I think the paper’s analysis of strategic scheduling is helpful because it shows that even when people try to optimize their own schedules, the resulting efficiency loss compared to centralized coordination is only about one dollar per household within each rule set.

Nadia: So, the paper suggests that while market design matters a lot for efficiency, this verifiable settlement architecture provides a solid technical foundation for making those designs transparent and secure on a blockchain.

Elias: It gives us a reproducible basis to study how market design interacts with technical verification and participant incentives in these local energy exchanges.

Michele Fabia, Baptiste Leloupb

Télécom Paris · CREST

cs.CR, cs.GT, q-fin.TR

Submitted: 2026-11-12

Updated: 2026-11-12

Code: https://github.com/AztecProtocol/aztec-packages

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 90/100

The gist: We implement privacy-preserving local electricity exchanges using an automated market maker on the Hyperledger Besu network under QBFT consensus The proposed protocol operator collects individual…

Key concepts

Automated Market Maker (AMM)
The AMM aggregates community electricity supply and demand to determine market prices every fifteen minutes. It uses cryptographic commitments to keep individual user positions private while calculating the necessary market rates based on predefined economic rules.
Zero-Knowledge Proofs (ZKPs)
Poseidon2 commitments and UltraHonk ZKPs are used to verify that the aggregated data, payments, and daily balances are consistent with committed electricity positions. This allows verification without exposing sensitive household consumption patterns or individual transaction details.
Hybrid Architecture
The system combines centralized coordination (for operator functions like compliance) with decentralized execution (where households manage their own decisions). This structure ensures community oversight while maintaining user autonomy over their energy choices.
Pricing Rules
The protocol supports three distinct pricing rules—Mid-market Rate, Supply–Demand Ratio (SDR), and Hyperbolic Rule—to distribute trading gains. These rules are derived from economic principles like individual rationality to ensure fair allocation of profits among participants.

Terminology

Summary

We implement privacy-preserving local electricity exchanges using an automated market maker on the Hyperledger Besu network under QBFT consensus The proposed protocol operator collects individual electricity positions off-chain and publishes aggregate supply and demand on the blockchain, where smart contracts compute market prices every fifteen minutes Individual positions remain off-chain; Poseidon2 commitments and UltraHonk zeroknowledge proofs, generated from Noir circuits, verify aggregation, payments, and daily balance updates The architecture retains community coordination while making financial execution independently auditable

Market Mechanism Design

The paper addresses the challenge of realizing the economic value of local electricity trading by introducing an automated market maker (AMM) that aggregates community supply and demand to determine prices every fifteen minutes. The mechanism allocates the gains from local exchanges according to predefined pricing rules derived from economic principles like individual rationality and budget balance The relevant outside options are the tariffs at which a participant would otherwise transact with its electricity supplier or other grid-facing counterparty, expressed as an export remuneration (feed-in rate) λ and a retail import tariff λ. p. 5 Three pricing rules are considered: the mid-market rate (MMR) rule [13], the supply–demand ratio (SDR) rule [13], and the hyperbolic rule. p. 6

Architectural Hybrid Approach

The proposed architecture adopts a hybrid structure where the organizing entity retains coordination, data-management, and compliance functions, while households remain responsible for their own electricity decisions The first challenge involves the confidentiality of household electricity data; publishing individual positions on-chain would expose detailed consumption and generation patterns. To solve this, cryptographic commitments and zero-knowledge proofs establish the consistency of these positions with published aggregates, individual payments, and account balances without revealing private information The protocol uses a shared ledger on Hyperledger Besu under QBFT consensus to verify financial settlement independently of the operator's financial calculations.

Verification and Settlement Procedures

The verification layer relies on two types of cryptographic proofs, where the first establishes that individual payments and account updates are consistent with committed electricity positions and the prices recorded on-chain without revealing underlying household data The second allows a member to prove the value of a committed balance when recourse or independent withdrawal requires it. A batch circuit enforces six conditions connecting committed electricity positions to public prices and individual accounts, including binding and aggregation, payments and balance updates, conservation and participation, and participation eligibility The protocol determines electricity prices every fifteen minutes but processes financial transfers once per day to allow time for cryptographic verification and member recourse. p. 0

Experimental Results

The experimental testing on a ten-household community using simulated US residential profiles showed that daily settlement uses approximately 19 million gas and produces eight-member proofs in 2.4 seconds Over four simulated days, local trading covers 34. p. 04% of demand and reduces grid-only costs by 30. p. 05% under assumed tariffs Numerically computed ϵ-Nash Equilibrium electricity profiles capture 83–88% of the social planner surplus The community gain equals the tariff spread multiplied by matched electricity, demonstrating a reduction in grid-only net bill from a baseline of 144. p. 001 USD to 72.88 USD under the mid-market rate rule. p. 6

Incentives and Efficiency Gains

The simulation of strategic scheduling showed that household equilibria recover approximately 83–88% of the additional planner gain, highlighting the multiplicity of equilibria The worst ratio observed across the three pricing rules is 1.082, which yields a theoretical upper bound PoA ≤ Pn G∗n CSP = 1. p. 347 These results demonstrate that strategic scheduling generates only a modest efficiency loss relative to centralized coordination, with community bills differing by less than one dollar within each pricing rule. p. 2 The protocol offers a reproducible basis for studying how market design, technical verification and participant incentives interact. p. 3

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Automated market maker (AMM) for local electricity exchanges: The system can compute prices every fifteen minutes by aggregating community supply and demand while keeping individual positions off-chain via cryptographic commitments.

  2. Verifiable settlement mechanism: It uses Poseidon2 commitments and UltraHonk zero-knowledge proofs to verify aggregation, payments, and daily balance updates without disclosing individual electricity profiles.

  3. Independent auditability: Signed receipts and member-triggered recourse prevent unverified or partial settlement, allowing households to independently check their commitments against the operator's records.

  4. Regulatory compliance: The architecture retains a community operator for coordination while applying agreed pricing rules through smart contracts, ensuring that any proposed settlement must pass the prescribed rules set by smart contracts.

  5. Pricing rule flexibility: The system supports three distinct pricing rules—Mid-market Rate, Supply–Demand Ratio (SDR), and Hyperbolic Rule—allowing communities to choose how the resulting gain is distributed among prosumers.

  6. Strategic scheduling analysis: The protocol allows for household decisions regarding storage and flexible consumption, enabling the evaluation of equilibrium profiles under both independent optimization and social planner coordination.

Sources

Related papers