Probing the extreme quantum violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality

arXiv:2611.16401 · quant-ph · Submitted 2026-11-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Probing the extreme quantum violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The present work critically examines the reasoning behind purported violations of the temporal Tsirelson bound (TTB) for Leggett-Garg inequalities and demonstrates that such arguments suffer from conceptual shortcomings.

Kai: Conceptual Shortcomings in TTB Violation The authors show that the proposed TTB violations rely on frameworks that go beyond the standard LG framework.

Mira: Specifically, they demonstrate that due to a degeneracy-breaking measurement employed in

33: , the derivation of three correlations in the LG functional is effectively performed for two different states.

Kai: Furthermore, they show that the three correlations in the LG functional in

47: are effectively evaluated for four observables instead of three observables in the conventional LG framework.

Paper summary: Kai: So this paper dives into those arguments for TTB violations by looking closely at how they use specific experimental setups. They point out that when you use a degeneracy-breaking measurement, the way you calculate those three correlations in the LG functional is actually treating two different quantum states instead of one.

Mira: That’s a big detail because usually, in the standard Leggett-Garg framework, you derive those correlations for only one state at a time. This paper shows that this difference means their calculation is not mapping onto the standard framework correctly.

Lev: So they are essentially showing that the setup described in "Probing the extreme quantum violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality" doesn't fit the conventional way we derive those bounds, which is important for figuring out what it takes to actually run this on real hardware.

Kai: They also look at another argument involving unitaries and showed that these evolutions lead to a functional where three correlations are being computed for four different observables instead of just three. It’s a mismatch in the counting of things.

Mira: When you count observables differently, your bound calculation changes completely. This means the results they claim violate the TTB don't actually challenge macrorealism because they are using a different mathematical structure than what is typically assumed for this test.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if you were trying to build a test based on these specific setups without correcting for these counting issues, you’d be aiming at the wrong target entirely.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper "Probing the extreme quantum violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality" is really a critical look at why certain papers claimed they found TTB violations in quantum theory. They show that those claims rely on using frameworks that are different from the standard Leggett-Garg framework.

Mira: Specifically, they highlight how degeneracy-breaking measurements and certain unitary evolutions lead to counting issues—calculating three correlations for two states or four observables instead of what’s expected. This means the macrorealist bound settles at K less than or equal to three, which doesn't allow for a TTB violation.

Lev: So what this means for us is that if you want to test macrorealism against quantum mechanics with these specific techniques, you need to fix these conceptual shortcomings first. Otherwise, the results don't actually test the core incompatibility between macrorealism and quantum theory at all.

Kai: It’s about being precise with how we set up the measurement and how we count the possible outcomes in our theoretical model. The paper shows that once those conceptual issues are addressed, there is no violation of the TTB under these conditions.

Mira: The authors conclude that depending on how you interpret those ontic states in a macrorealist model, you might get two possible bounds, but if you consider two distinct distributions for those states, no violation of the LG inequality occurs. It puts things back to where they started regarding the main test.

Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Technology Hyderabad

quant-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-12

Updated: 2026-11-12

DOI: 10.1103/xtdq-bt2f

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 73/100

The gist: The present work critically examines the reasoning behind purported violations of the temporal Tsirelson bound (TTB) for Leggett-Garg inequalities and demonstrates that such arguments suffer from…

Key concepts

Leggett-Garg (LG) Inequalities
These inequalities are mathematical tests designed to check if quantum mechanics is compatible with a classical worldview called macrorealism. They compare predictions made by quantum theory against what a realistic, macroscopic system should allow, setting limits on how correlations between measurements can behave.
Temporal Tsirelson Bound (TTB)
This is the expected maximum level of violation for LG inequalities in standard quantum mechanics, analogous to the Tsirelson bound for Bell inequalities. The paper investigates whether this bound can actually be exceeded, as some studies have suggested it might.
Degeneracy-Breaking Measurement
This is a specific type of measurement technique used in the study. The authors show that using such a measurement causes the calculation of correlations within the LG functional to effectively involve two different quantum states instead of one, which is different from the standard setup.

Terminology

Summary

The present work critically examines the reasoning behind purported violations of the temporal Tsirelson bound (TTB) for Leggett-Garg inequalities and demonstrates that such arguments suffer from conceptual shortcomings. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this work, we critically examine the reasoning underlying these purported TTB violations and show that the corresponding arguments suffer from conceptual shortcomings. We further show that once these conceptual issues are addressed appropriately, the macrorealist bound of LG inequality reaches the algebraic maximum, and hence no violation of the TTB is obtained.

Conceptual Shortcomings in TTB Violation

The authors show that the proposed TTB violations rely on frameworks that go beyond the standard LG framework. Specifically, they demonstrate that due to a degeneracy-breaking measurement employed in [33], the derivation of three correlations in the LG functional is effectively performed for two different states. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this paper, we show that there are conceptual gaps in those arguments [33, 47] as they differ from the conventional LG framework. We show that, due to the degeneracy-breaking measurement employed in [33], the derivation of three correlations in the LG functional is effectively performed for two different states.

Furthermore, they show that the three correlations in the LG functional in [47] are effectively evaluated for four observables instead of three observables in the conventional LG framework. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We show that, due to the degeneracy-breaking measurement employed in [33], the derivation of three correlations in the LG functional is effectively performed for two different states. We further show that the three correlations in the LG functional in [47] are effectively evaluated for four observables instead of three observables in the conventional LG framework.

These frameworks differ from the standard LG framework. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We demonstrate that the theoretical frameworks introduced in [33, 47] go beyond the standard LG framework. Furthermore, we show that their macrorealist bounds differ from those of the standard LG framework and that, following an appropriate revision of these macrorealist bounds, no violation of TTB can be observed.

Pruning Redundant Reasoning Tokens

The paper addresses two main purported violations of the TTB: one by Budroni and Emary [33] invoking a degeneracy-breaking measurement, and another by Chatterjee et al. [47] considering the superposition of unitaries. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Budroni and Emary [33] have argued that TTB can be violated if a degeneracy-breaking measurement is used for state reduction. Very recently, considering the evolution between two measurements governed by the superposition of unitaries, Chatterjee et al.

The authors provide simpler examples to reproduce the results of [33, 47]. p. 1
Where the paper says it

They considered that the evolution between two measurements is governed by the superposition of unitaries and argue that such evolution is the key to obtain the algebraic maximum KQ = 3. In this work, for better understanding, we first provide simpler examples to reproduce the results of [33, 47].

They show that for three observables which are mutually commuting in the coarse-grained Luders measurement scenario, the TTB is violated only by using a fine-grained degeneracy-breaking measurement. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We show that for three observables which are mutually commuting in the coarse-grained Luders measurement scenario, the TTB is ¨ violated if the fine-grained degeneracy-breaking measurement scheme is employed. We then show that the complex calculation using the linear superposition of unitaries used in [47] is not necessary to obtain the violation of TTB.

How the Training Signal is Built

The authors demonstrate that in scenarios involving degeneracy-breaking measurements, the LG functional becomes Kdb = ⟨M1M2⟩ρ′ + ⟨M2M3⟩ρ′′ − ⟨M1M3⟩ρ′, which is different from Eq. (1) as the three correlations in Eq. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this paper, we show that there are conceptual gaps in those arguments [33, 47] as they differ from the conventional LG framework. We show that, due to the degeneracy-breaking measurement employed in [33], the derivation of three correlations in the LG functional is effectively performed for two different states.

(24) are derived for two different states ρ′ and ρ''. This difference contrasts with the conventional LG framework where the correlations in Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we show that there are conceptual gaps in those arguments [33, 47] as they differ from the conventional LG framework. We show that, due to the degeneracy-breaking measurement employed in [33], the derivation of three correlations in the LG functional is effectively performed for two different states.

(1) were needed to be derived for one state ρ. p. 4
Where the paper says it

This clearly differs from the conventional LG framework where the correlations in Eq. (1) were needed to be derived for one state ρ.

Where the Gains Come From

The analysis concludes that when a macrorealist may consider two inequivalent ontic distributions µ(λ′) and µ(λ′′) corresponding to two different states ρ′ and ρ'', the observable M2 can take the value +1 in the correlation ⟨M1M2⟩λ′ and −1 in ⟨M2M3⟩λ′, yielding the macrorealist bound of LG functional K ≤ 3 from Eq. (24). This outcome implies that no violation of LG inequality occurs in a macrorealist model under this interpretation. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Then no violation of LG inequality occurs in a macrorealist model. We leave it for reader which interpretation they choose.

The paper also shows that the unitary evolutions taken in [47] lead to an LG functional in Eq. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(24) where three correlations are effectively derived for two different initial states. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Specifically, we demonstrated that the action of degeneracybreaking measurement employed in [33] leads to the LG functional in Eq. (24) where three correlations are effectively derived for two different initial states.

Furthermore, we showed that the unitary evolutions taken in [47] lead to an LG functional in Eq.

(30) where three correlations are effectively computed for four observables. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, we showed that the unitary evolutions taken in [47] lead to an LG functional in Eq. (30) where three correlations are effectively computed for four observables.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, we showed that the unitary evolutions taken in [47] lead to an LG functional in Eq. (30) where three correlations are effectively computed for four observables.

Summary and Discussion

In sum, the authors argue that the frameworks invoked to exhibit TTB violations differ from the conventional LG framework. Specifically, they demonstrate that the action of degeneracybreaking measurement employed in [33] leads to the LG functional in Eq. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Further we argue that the frameworks invoked to exhibit TTB violations differ from the conventional LG framework. Specifically, we demonstrated that the action of degeneracybreaking measurement employed in [33] leads to the LG functional in Eq.

(24) where three correlations are effectively derived for two different initial states. Furthermore, they showed that the unitary evolutions taken in [47] lead to an LG functional in Eq. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(24) where three correlations are effectively derived for two different initial states. Furthermore, we showed that the unitary evolutions taken in [47] lead to an LG functional in Eq.

(30) where three correlations are effectively computed for four observables. Therefore, in the framework proposed in [33, 47], the appropriate macrorealist bound becomes K ≤ 3, implying that there is no violation of the LG inequality. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(30) where three correlations are effectively computed for four observables. Therefore, in the framework proposed in[33, 47], the appropriate macrorealist bound becomes K ≤ 3, implying that there is no violation of the LG inequality.

Hence, the TTB violations reported in [33, 47] have only a limited bearing on the conventional LG framework and consequently do not constitute a test of the incompatibility between macrorealism and quantum theory. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Therefore, in the framework proposed in[33, 47], the appropriate macrorealist bound becomes K ≤ 3, implying that there is no violation of the LG inequality. Hence, the TTB violations reported in [33, 47] have only a limited bearing on the conventional LG framework and, consequently, do not constitute a test of the incompatibility between macrorealism and quantum theory.

The paper also shows that the results of [47] can be obtained without the superposition of unitaries. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Instead of non commuting observables taken in [33], we reproduce the TTB violation by considering three observables which are mutually commuting in the coarse-grained Luders ¨ measurement scenario. We also showed that the results of [47] can be obtained without the superposition of unitaries.

The authors conclude by stating that there can be two possible bounds in a macrorealist model depending upon the way one interprets the description of ontic states in a macrorealist model. p. 4
Where the paper says it

(1) were needed to be derived for one state ρ. We would like to state that there can be two possible bounds in a macrorealist model depending upon the way one interprets the description of ontic states in a macrorealist model.

The final result is that if two distinct ontic distributions are considered, no violation of LG inequality occurs. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In such a case, for two distinct ontic distributions, the observable M2 can take the value +1 in the correlation ⟨M1M2⟩λ ′ and −1 in ⟨M2M3⟩λ ′′ , yielding the macrorealist bound of LG functional K ≤ 3 from Eq. Then no violation of LG inequality occurs in a macrorealist model.

The paper emphasizes that the fine-grained projectors of M2, in general, do not commute with projectors of M1 and M3. p. 3
Where the paper says it

For example, the coarse-grained projectors corresponding to M1, M2 and M3 are commuting. But the fine-grained projectors of M2, in general, do not commute with projectors of M1 and M3.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Develop a framework to rigorously test whether purported violations of temporal Tsirelson bound (TTB) in quantum mechanics are truly representative of incompatibility between macrorealism and quantum theory by showing that such arguments rely on frameworks that go beyond the standard LG framework.

  2. Enhance AI systems to distinguish between different interpretations of macrorealist bounds, specifically by differentiating between the case where rho' and rho'' are macrorealistically equivalent leading to a bound of K less than or equal to 1, versus cases with two distinct ontic distributions mu(lambda') and mu(lambda'') corresponding to two different states rho' and rho''.

  3. Create AI systems capable of analyzing the conceptual gaps in arguments claiming TTB violation by systematically comparing the derivation pathways in degenerate-breaking measurement scenarios (Budroni and Emary [33]) versus those involving superposition of unitaries (Chatterjee et al. [47]).

  4. Implement a method for deriving the actual macrorealist bound of the LG functional when applying fine-grained degeneracy-breaking projective measurements, showing that this revised bound reaches the algebraic maximum, thereby confirming that no violation of TTB is obtained.

  5. Improve AI's ability to analyze measurement scenarios by distinguishing between coarse-grained degeneracy-preserving measurements and fine-grained degeneracy-breaking measurements, specifically noting how the latter inject[s] a form of non-commutativity leading to the violation of TTB when applied to mutually commuting observables.

Abstract

The Leggett-Garg (LG) inequalities were formulated for testing the incompatibility between the classical worldview of macrorealism and quantum theory. By analogy with the Tsirelson bound for Bell inequalities, the maximal quantum violation of LG inequalities is commonly referred to as the temporal Tsirelson bound (TTB). Nevertheless, several studies have claimed that, unlike the Tsirelson bound, the TTB can be exceeded within quantum theory. In particular, by employing degeneracy-breaking measurement in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 050401 (2014)] and by using the superposition of unitaries in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 220202 (2025)], it is argued that the TTB can be violated. In this work, we critically examine the reasoning underlying these purported TTB violations and show that the corresponding arguments suffer from conceptual shortcomings. We further show that once these conceptual issues are addressed appropriately, the macrorealist bound of LG inequality reaches the algebraic maximum, and hence no violation of the TTB is obtained. In particular, we demonstrate that the proposed TTB violations rely on frameworks that go beyond the standard LG framework, and therefore are of no relevance for testing the incompatibility between macrorealism and quantum theory.

Sources

Related papers