Critical behavior of the bosonized Schwinger model with uniform matrix product states

arXiv:2611.16092 · hep-lat, hep-th · Submitted 2026-11-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Lattice. The day in lattice field theory: what the simulations put on the table.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Critical behavior of the bosonized Schwinger model with uniform matrix product states".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Quantum electrodynamics in two spacetime dimensions, also known as the Schwinger model, admits a dual formulation in terms of a non-compact boson field The dimensionless critical mass (m/g)c, where g is the gauge coupling, provides a benchmark for Hamiltonian lattice calculations The result for the critical mass, (m/g)c = 0.333 555(5), agrees with recent staggered-fermion determinations at comparable precision Bosonized Lattice Formulation and Basis The paper determines the critical mass using a bosonized lattice Hamiltonian, solving the resulting chain with the VUMPS algorithm The Hamiltonian is derived by gauging a U(1) symmetry of the compact boson in the modified Villain formulation, leading to a non-compact scalar whose quadratic potential comes from the electric energy To handle the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, an optimized local basis is employed, chosen as eigenstates of the one-site reduced density matrix of the free (m = 0) chain The local cutoff limits the number of states at each site, and charge conjugation C acts as (−1)n on the oscillator level n Critical Point Determination and Extrapolation The critical point is located by extrapolating in bond dimension, where the departure from criticality is described by a signed parameter t The finite-entanglement law ξD ∝ Dκ is used to extrapolate the critical-mass estimate m∗(a, D) A joint fit is applied to the data, fitting the form ϵ1(m, D) = p1

m − m∗(a): + c1 δ(m, D) The primary result is obtained by averaging nineteen continuum fits with Akaike weights Continuum Analysis and Results The continuum analysis involves fitting several functions to the critical masses in Table 1, retaining fits that meet a common residual criterion The primary estimate is given by m∗(a) = c0 + c2z squared + c2Lz squared ln z + Rq(z) The final result obtained from the weighted average is (m/g)c = 0.333 555(5) Lattice Corrections and Fitting Assumptions The continuum fits use even powers of ga and a logarithm at order (ga)2, assuming the critical mass has a Taylor expansion in the coefficients of these corrections The analysis tests various fitting functions, including those with logarithms at order z4 and beyond The uncertainty budget combines propagated input uncertainties with the spread among the fitted continuum values The paper determines the critical mass at θ = π with a bosonized lattice Hamiltonian and charge-conjugationpreserving uniform MPS The agreement with staggered-fermion results provides a check using a different lattice formulation The result is conditional on the fitting functions and on the averaging prescription.

Kai: References

3: S.

Mira: R.

Kai: Coleman, “More About the Massive Schwinger Model,” Annals Phys.

Title and authors: Kai: So, moving on from the results, let’s look at the improvements this paper suggests for this work. They are proposing a few ways to make their determination of the critical mass more robust and less dependent on arbitrary choices.

Mira: They suggest implementing a full uncertainty budget using an equation they call equation thirty one, which combines propagated input uncertainties with the spread among those fitted continuum values to give us delta quoted. That’s supposed to be a way to get a more rigorous assessment of the result's reliability than just looking at single-source errors.

Lev: From my perspective, that uncertainty budget is crucial for any serious computational work; it forces you to account for all those dependencies in one go instead of just reporting what the error bars on each individual calculation say.

Kai: And they also suggest enhancing extrapolation stability by incorporating a two-stage method described in section three point two, which compares joint fits with fixed masses against separate fixed-mass extrapolations. That gives a direct check on whether their leading scaling approximation is actually valid.

Mira: I agree, that comparison between the joint fits and the separate extrapolations is how you really test if your basic scaling assumption holds up under different conditions.

Lev: That two-stage method sounds like it adds a layer of validation to the extrapolation process, which would be necessary before we trust a number derived from such complex fitting procedures.

Kai: They also suggest improving continuum fitting robustness by systematically testing different truncations of equation twenty one and various logarithmic terms, as detailed in table three and table four. This is to make sure the final result isn't overly dependent on arbitrary choices in those expansions.

Mira: Testing different truncations of that expansion is smart because it helps you see if the result changes drastically when you keep or discard certain higher-order terms, which points to where your approximation is breaking down.

Lev: If you can show that the result doesn't change much when you add more terms, then your approximation is probably sound enough for practical use in a simulation.

Kai: And they also test the effect of adding logarithmic terms of order four with coefficients up to four times ten minus three, which lets them quantify how much their primary result really depends on those higher-order corrections.

Mira: Quantifying the dependence on those order four terms is important because it shows us exactly how sensitive the critical mass estimate is to physics we haven't explicitly included yet.

Lev: That level of detail helps you decide if you need to spend more computation chasing that next level of accuracy or if your current precision is sufficient for what you need.

Kai: It’s all about getting a more systematic way to analyze these dependencies, which is what makes this work more reproducible across different computational setups.

Mira: And the final suggestion in section four point five is to employ a series of checks, such as varying averaging prescriptions and input masses, to demonstrate the dependence of the final result on those choices and provide bounds on their influence.

Lev: That kind of systematic checking is what separates a good simulation from one that just spits out a number without really understanding its limitations.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to wrap this up for this paper, they determined the critical mass at theta equals pi using their bosonized lattice Hamiltonian and charge conjugation preserving uniform matrix product state. The main implication is the agreement with staggered fermion results at comparable precision.

Mira: They confirm that zero point three three three five five with an uncertainty of five is a solid benchmark derived from this specific computational approach. It’s a good cross-check using different lattice artifacts to validate the method, which is what they wanted.

Lev: For real hardware, it means we have a number that can be reliably compared against what we might eventually measure on our actual systems, provided we account for those fitting function choices and averaging prescriptions.

Kai: It’s conditional on those choices, but they did test them to show the dependence of the final result on them.

Mira: So, it’s a solid piece of information that comes from a specific computational path in lattice field theory and offers a cross-check against another way of doing things.

Lev: And for now, the number stands as one more data point for understanding the phase diagram near the quantum critical point in the bosonized Schwinger model.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we just talked about the critical mass for this Schwinger model using bosonized lattice methods and how it checks out against other things like staggered fermions. Now, let's look at what the authors suggest to make this calculation better.

Mira: They’re proposing a few ways to sharpen that number. First, they want a full uncertainty budget. That means combining all the errors from the input data with the spread from all those different continuum fits to give us one single delta quoted value.

Lev: That uncertainty budget is key because it forces you to account for everything at once instead of just looking at one error bar on a single calculation. It makes the result way more trustworthy for real hardware testing later.

Kai: Exactly. And they also suggest a two-stage method for extrapolation stability, comparing joint fits with fixed masses against separate extrapolations with fixed masses to see if the leading scaling approximation actually holds up.

Mira: That comparison is important because it directly tests if their basic scaling assumption is valid under different conditions. It’s how you check if the math they used to simplify things makes sense when you stress it a little.

Lev: If that two-stage method shows consistency, then we have more confidence in the result before we even think about running it on actual hardware with all its overhead.

Kai: Then there's improving how they fit those continuum results by systematically testing different truncations of the equation they use for expansion and checking various logarithmic terms.

Mira: That systematic testing is smart because it shows if the final number changes drastically just because you keep or drop certain higher-order terms in that expansion. It helps you see where the approximation might be breaking down.

Lev: If you can show that the result doesn't shift much when you add more terms, then your current level of accuracy is probably fine for what we need right now.

Kai: They also want to increase sensitivity by explicitly testing adding logarithmic terms of order four with coefficients up to four times ten minus three. This lets them quantify how much that primary result really depends on physics they haven't even explicitly included yet.

Mira: Quantifying the dependence on those higher order terms is important because it shows us exactly how sensitive the critical mass estimate is to physics we haven't fully modeled yet. It tells us what’s missing from the current theory.

Lev: That level of detail helps you decide if you need to spend more computation chasing that next level of accuracy or if your current precision is good enough for the experiment.

Kai: And finally, in section four point five, they suggest a series of checks, like varying averaging prescriptions and input masses to show how much those choices affect the final result.

Mira: That kind of systematic checking is what separates a good simulation from one that just spits out a number without really understanding its limitations. It shows you where the assumptions are actually holding up.

Lev: So they’re building this result in a way that lets us see not just the answer, but how fragile it is to the choices we make in setting up the simulation.

Kai: It sounds like they're really focused on making sure this number isn't just a lucky guess based on one set of assumptions.

Mira: Yeah, they’re taking that rigorous approach because when you’re dealing with these complex lattice models, you can’t afford to be sloppy about the dependencies.

Lev: And once we have this better benchmark for the critical mass, it gives us a much clearer target for what our real error correction systems need to handle.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve covered how they improved their calculation of the critical mass for this paper, "Critical behavior of the bosonized Schwinger model with uniform matrix product states."

Mira: Right, they're focusing on making sure that number is solid by adding a full uncertainty budget and testing different mathematical expansions to see how much it depends on those assumptions.

Lev: That level of rigor is what we need before we even think about running this thing on actual hardware with all the noise and overhead involved in error correction.

Kai: It sounds like they’re really focused on making sure this number isn't just a lucky guess based on one set of assumptions.

Mira: They are definitely pushing that systematic checking because when you’re dealing with these complex lattice models, you can’t afford to be sloppy about the dependencies.

Lev: And once we have this better benchmark for the critical mass, it gives us a much clearer target for what our real error correction systems need to handle.

Kai: So, they've found a way to get a more reliable estimate by being very systematic about how they analyze the results of the bosonized lattice Hamiltonian.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work because it doesn't just give you one answer; it shows you the landscape of uncertainty around that answer.

Lev: And knowing where those uncertainties land helps us figure out what kind of error correction architecture we actually need to build for real experiments.

Takuya Okuda

Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, University of Tokyo

hep-lat, hep-th

Submitted: 2026-11-11

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: 36 pages, 2 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Quantum electrodynamics in two spacetime dimensions, also known as the Schwinger model, admits a dual formulation in terms of a non-compact boson field The dimensionless critical mass (m/g)c…

Key concepts

Bosonized Lattice Formulation
This involves transforming the complex gauge theory problem into a simpler one involving a non-compact boson field. The Hamiltonian is derived by gauging a U(1) symmetry of this boson, leading to an effective scalar field whose potential describes the electric energy in the system.
Uniform MPS Basis
To handle the large Hilbert space, an optimized local basis is used, chosen as eigenstates of the free (m=0) chain's reduced density matrix. This local cutoff limits the number of states at each site, and charge conjugation acts as a specific operator on these states.
Critical Point Determination
The critical point is found by analyzing how the system behaves near criticality using a signed parameter 't'. The finite-entanglement law ($\xi_D \propto D\kappa$) is employed to extrapolate the critical mass estimate, and a joint fit of nineteen continuum fits yields the final result.

Terminology

Summary

Quantum electrodynamics in two spacetime dimensions, also known as the Schwinger model, admits a dual formulation in terms of a non-compact boson field The dimensionless critical mass (m/g)c, where g is the gauge coupling, provides a benchmark for Hamiltonian lattice calculations The result for the critical mass, (m/g)c = 0. p. 0333 555(5), agrees with recent staggered-fermion determinations at comparable precision

Bosonized Lattice Formulation and Basis

The paper determines the critical mass using a bosonized lattice Hamiltonian, solving the resulting chain with the VUMPS algorithm The Hamiltonian is derived by gauging a U(1) symmetry of the compact boson in the modified Villain formulation, leading to a non-compact scalar whose quadratic potential comes from the electric energy To handle the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, an optimized local basis is employed, chosen as eigenstates of the one-site reduced density matrix of the free (m = 0) chain The local cutoff limits the number of states at each site, and charge conjugation C acts as (−1)n on the oscillator level n

Critical Point Determination and Extrapolation

The critical point is located by extrapolating in bond dimension, where the departure from criticality is described by a signed parameter t The finite-entanglement law ξD ∝ Dκ is used to extrapolate the critical-mass estimate m∗(a, D) A joint fit is applied to the data, fitting the form ϵ1(m, D) = p1 [m − m∗(a)] + c1 δ(m, D) The primary result is obtained by averaging nineteen continuum fits with Akaike weights

Continuum Analysis and Results

The continuum analysis involves fitting several functions to the critical masses in Table 1, retaining fits that meet a common residual criterion The primary estimate is given by m∗(a) = c0 + c2z squared + c2Lz squared ln z + Rq(z) The final result obtained from the weighted average is (m/g)c = 0.333 555(5)

Lattice Corrections and Fitting Assumptions

The continuum fits use even powers of ga and a logarithm at order (ga)2, assuming the critical mass has a Taylor expansion in the coefficients of these corrections The analysis tests various fitting functions, including those with logarithms at order z4 and beyond The uncertainty budget combines propagated input uncertainties with the spread among the fitted continuum values

Conclusion

The paper determines the critical mass at θ = π with a bosonized lattice Hamiltonian and charge-conjugationpreserving uniform MPS The agreement with staggered-fermion results provides a check using a different lattice formulation The result is conditional on the fitting functions and on the averaging prescription.

References

[3] S. R. Coleman, “More About the Massive Schwinger Model,” Annals Phys. p. 0 101 (1976) 239

[4] C. J. Hamer, J. B. Kogut, D. P. Crewther, and M. M. Mazzolini, “The Massive Schwinger Model on a Lattice: Background Field, Chiral Symmetry and the String Tension,” Nucl. p. 0 Phys. B 208 (1982) 413–438

[5] T. Byrnes, P. Sriganesh, R. J. Bursill, and C. J. Hamer, “Density matrix renormalization group approach to the massive Schwinger model,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. D 66 (2002) 013002

[6] Y. Shimizu and Y. Kuramashi, “Critical behavior of the lattice Schwinger model with a topological term at θ = π using the Grassmann tensor renormalization group,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. D 90 no. 7, (2014) 074503

[7] B. Buyens, J. Haegeman, K. Van Acoleyen, H. Verschelde, and F. Verstraete, “Matrix product states for gauge field theories,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. Lett. 113 (2014) 091601

[8] E. Arguello Cruz, G. Tarnopolsky, and Y. Xin, “Precision study of the massive Schwinger model near quantum criticality,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 112 no. 3, (2025) 034023

[9] H. Fujii, K. Fujikura, Y. Kikukawa, T. Okuda, and J. p. 0 W. Pedersen, “Critical behavior of the Schwinger model via gauge-invariant variational uniform matrix product states,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 111 no. 9, (2025) 094505

[10] N. Klco and M. J. Savage, “Digitization of scalar fields for quantum computing,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. A 99 no. 5, (2019) 052335

[11] G. Calliari, M. Di Liberto, H. Pichler, and T. V. Zache, “Quantum Simulating Continuum Field Theories with Large-Spin Lattice Models,” PRX Quantum 6 no. p. 0 3, (2025) 030304

[12] I. Bender, H. J. Rothe, and K. p. 1 D. Rothe, “Monte Carlo Study of Screening Versus Confinement in the Massless and Massive Schwinger Model,” Nucl. p. 1 Phys. B 251 (1985) 745–763

[13] H. Ohata, “Monte Carlo study of Schwinger model without the sign problem,” JHEP 12 (2023) 007

[14] H. Ohata, “Phase diagram near the quantum critical point in Schwinger model at θ = π: analogy with quantum Ising chain,” PTEP 2024 no. p. 1 1, (2024) 013B02

[15] L. Fazza and T. Sulejmanpasic, “Lattice quantum Villain Hamiltonians: compact scalars, U(1) gauge theories, fracton models and quantum Ising model dualities,” JHEP 05 (2023) 017

[16] S. Seifnashri, “Exactly Solvable 1+1d Chiral Lattice Gauge Theories,” arXiv:2601. p. 214359

[17] S. R. Coleman, R. p. 0 Jackiw, and L. Susskind, “Charge Shielding and Quark Confinement in the Massive Schwinger Model,” Annals Phys. p. 0 93 (1975) 267

[18] V. Zauner-Stauber, L. Vanderstraeten, M. T. Fishman, F. Verstraete, and J. Haegeman, “Variational optimization algorithms for uniform matrix product states,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. B 97 no. 4, (2018) 045145

[19] Z. Lu and S.-H. Shao, “Fermionic Villain model with exact lattice chiral symmetries,” arXiv:2608. p. 102728

[20] R. Belyansky, S. Whitsitt, N. Mueller, A. Fahimniya, E. R. Bennewitz, Z. Davoudi, and A. V. Gorshkov, “High-Energy Collision of Quarks and Mesons in the Schwinger Model: From Tensor Networks to Circuit QED,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. Lett. 132 no. 9, (2024) 091903

[21] K. Symanzik, “Continuum Limit and Improved Action in Lattice Theories. p. 1 p. 1 1. Principles and Theory,” Nucl. p. 0 Phys. B 226 (1983) 187–204

[22] K. Symanzik, “Continuum Limit and Improved Action in Lattice Theories. 2. O(N) Nonlinear Sigma Model in Perturbation Theory,” Nucl. p. 0 Phys. B 226 (1983) 205–227

[33] K. E. Cahill and R. J. Glauber, “Ordered expansions in boson amplitude operators,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. 177 (1969) 1857–1881

[34] S. Singh, R. N. C. Pfeifer, and G. Vidal, “Tensor network decompositions in the presence of a global symmetry,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. A 82 (2010) 050301

[35] V. Zauner, D. Draxler, L. Vanderstraeten, M. Degroote, J. Haegeman, M. M. Rams, V. Stojevic, N. Schuch, and F. Verstraete, “Transfer Matrices and Excitations with Matrix Product States,” New J. p. 0 Phys. 17 no. 5, (2015) 053002

[36] D. P´erez-Garc´ıa, M. M. Wolf, M. Sanz, F. Verstraete, and J. I. Cirac, “String order and symmetries in quantum spin lattices,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. Lett. 100 (2008) 167202

[37] L. Tagliacozzo, T. R. de Oliveira, S. Iblisdir, and J. I. Latorre, “Scaling of entanglement support for Matrix Product States,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. B 78 (2008) 024410

[38] F. Pollmann, S. Mukerjee, A. M. Turner, and J. E. Moore, “Theory of Finite-Entanglement Scaling at One-Dimensional Quantum Critical Points,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. Lett. 102 no. 25, (2009) 255701

[39] B. Vanhecke, J. Haegeman, K. Van Acoleyen, L. Vanderstraeten, and F. Verstraete, “Scaling Hypothesis for Matrix Product States,” Phys. p. 6 Rev. Lett. 123 no. 25, (2019) 250604

[40] M. M. Rams, P. Czarnik, and L. Cincio, “Precise extrapolation of the correlation function asymptotics in uniform tensor network states with application to the Bose-Hubbard and XXZ models,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. X 8 (2018) 041033

[41] J. T. Schneider, A. p. 6 Ueda, Y. Liu, A. M. L¨auchli, M. Oshikawa, and L. Tagliacozzo, “Self-congruent point in critical matrix product states: An effective field theory for finite-entanglement scaling,” SciPost Phys. p. 6 18 no. 4, (2025) 142

[42] T. Okuda, “Critical behavior of the bosonized Schwinger model with uniform matrix product states: data and code,” Zenodo, 2026. p. 0 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo. p. 922669406

[43] H. Akaike, “A new look at the statistical model identification,” IEEE Trans. p. 1 Automatic Control 19 no. p. 1 6, (1974) 716–723

[44] F. Steffens and C. Urbach, “Symanzik Effective Hamiltonian for Lattice Quantum Field Theories,” arXiv:2611. p. 112520

[45] L. Devos, M. Van Damme, and J. Haegeman, “MPSKit,” 2026

[46] L. Devos and J. Haegeman, “TensorKit.jl,” 2026

Summary

The dimensionless critical mass (m/g)c = 0.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improve critical mass estimation by implementing a full uncertainty budget using Eq (31), which combines propagated input uncertainties with spread among fitted continuum values to yield Delta quoted. This allows for a more rigorous assessment of the result's reliability than relying on single-source errors alone.

  2. Enhance extrapolation stability by incorporating the two-stage method described in Section 3.2, which compares joint fits with fixed masses against separate fixed-mass extrapolations, providing a direct check on the validity of the leading scaling approximation.

  3. Improve continuum fitting robustness by systematically testing different truncations of Eq (21) and various logarithmic terms (as detailed in Table 3 and Table 4) to ensure the final result is not overly dependent on arbitrary fitting choices.

  4. Increase sensitivity to omitted physics by explicitly testing the effect of adding logarithmic terms of order z four with coefficients up to four times 10 minus three, allowing researchers to quantify how much the primary result depends on these higher-order corrections.

  5. Enhance systematic uncertainty analysis by employing a series of checks in Section 4.5, such as varying averaging prescriptions and input masses, to demonstrate the dependence of the final result on these choices and provide bounds on their influence.

Sources

Related papers