A new indirect approach for oxygen abundance determinations across a wide range of physical conditions
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "A new indirect approach for oxygen abundance determinations across a wide range of physical conditions".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. A new indirect approach for oxygen abundance determinations across a wide range of physical conditions presents an alternative method using sulfur electron temperature to derive oxygen abundances in HII regions, which mitigates systematic biases in direct measurements, especially in high-metallicity environments The new methodology is based on the derivation of the electron temperature of the double ionised sulfur, either by the direct measurement of the
SIII: auroral line or, at supersolar metalicities, from the S O23 parameter This new indirect method is able to extend the abundance gradient up to the very centre of the M101 galaxy (0.04 Re) This new methodology mitigates systematic biases in direct abundance determinations based on auroral lines, while opening up new opportunities to improve commonly used strong line abundance calibrations in the intermediate to high metallicity regime Mitigating Selection Biases The direct method for oxygen abundance determination is subject to significant selection effects and biases, particularly in the central regions of galaxies First, the exponential dependence of collisionally excited line emissivities on Te means that the observed line intensities are strongly weighted towards warmer parts of the nebular ionisation structure This effect is particularly important for oxygen, for which the temperature derived from the
OIII: lines can exceed the actual ionic temperature of O++ At high metallicities, most of the oxygen is in the form of O+ (87–95%; Díaz & Zamora 2022) then this effect cannot be considered important Second, in high metallicity regions, auroral lines are often difficult or impossible to detect since their emissivities decrease rapidly at low electron temperatures An alternative to the limitations associated with using oxygen as a reference element for determining gas-phase metallicity gradients is to consider alternative elements whose auroral lines remain detectable at lower electron temperatures, thereby extending the applicability of the direct method to higher metallicities Sulphur is a particularly suitable candidate for this purpose because its auroral emission line of
S III: at λ6312 are analogues to that of
OIII: at λ4363 Furthermore, in the case of sulphur, due to the lower excitation energies involved, the line emissivities are less dependent on Te which allows the line detection even at over-solar abundances (Díaz et al.
Vera: 2007; Díaz & Zamora 2022) The Indirect Methodology In this work, we propose a new methodology, referred to as the “indirect” method, to address these two biases affecting the central, high-metallicity regions of abundance gradients (i) the exponential dependence of collisionally excited line emissivities on Te means that the observed line intensities are strongly weighted towards warmer parts of the nebular ionisation structure (Shields & Searle 1978); and (ii) the oxygen auroral line,
OIII: λ4363 Å, is often difficult or impossible to detect in high metallicity regions (Te lower than 7000K) because their emissivities decrease rapidly at low electron temperatures (Bresolin 2008) Our new approach estimates Te
S III: from strong emission lines, avoiding the selection effects associated with the detection of auroral lines, and uses it to derive direct chemical abundances By estimating the oxygen and sulphur electron temperatures from Te
S III: , we also mitigate the bias arising from the overestimation of Te
OII: when inferred from Te
OIII: Calibration Parameters Several strong line calibrations have been proposed in the literature to estimate chemical abundances in ionised nebulae, based on individual elements or combinations of emission lines from different species (e.g.
Jocelyn: Pagel et al.
Vera: 1979; Denicoló et al.
Paper summary: Vera: So, this paper you're looking at here, "A new indirect approach for oxygen abundance determinations across a wide range of physical conditions," it seems like they are proposing a totally different way to figure out how much oxygen is in these HII regions Jocelyn That’s right. They’re using sulfur emission lines instead of just the direct measurements of oxygen lines, and they want this new method to work across a wide range of physical conditions, especially at high metallicities Subrahmanyan That sounds like they are trying to fix some known problems with the standard abundance calibrations Vera Exactly. The abstract says their methodology is based on deriving the electron temperature of double ionised sulfur, either by directly measuring that auroral sulfur line, or if the metallicity is high enough, using something called a parameter called S O23 Jocelyn That S O23 parameter sounds like a clever way to get that temperature when the direct line is too weak to see Subrahmanyan So they’re basically trying to bypass the detection issues of those auroral lines entirely by using sulfur as a proxy for temperature first Vera Right. And then they use that sulfur temperature estimate to derive the chemical abundances for oxygen and other elements Jocelyn That connects it back to what we need: actual abundance determinations.
Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical standpoint, the paper claims this indirect method mitigates systematic biases that plague direct measurements, particularly in high-metallicity environments Vera This is interesting because those biases usually come from the way lines are weighted by temperature and selection effects Jocelyn So what they’re doing is trying to fix two main issues: first, the exponential dependence of line emissivities on temperature means we mostly see warmer parts of the nebula, which can overestimate our oxygen temperature if we just look at the triple ionised oxygen lines Subrahmanyan And second, at high metallicity, those auroral lines for oxygen often become impossible to detect because their emission drops so fast at lower electron temperatures Vera
Paper summary: Jocelyn: So the idea is that by estimating the sulfur electron temperature from these strong emission lines, they can avoid those detection biases and then use that to get better abundance estimates for oxygen Subrahmanyan They also mention that this indirect approach helps mitigate a specific bias arising when you infer the oxygen temperature from the triple ionised oxygen lines, which tends to overestimate it Vera That’s a double win, trying to fix both detection issues and temperature overestimations at once.
Vera: And they test this by using M101 as a benchmark galaxy along its radial profile Jocelyn That lets them see how well the method works across the whole gradient of that spiral galaxy Subrahmanyan The paper suggests that if you include these indirect estimates, you can extend the abundance gradient all the way to the very center of M101, down to a radius of zero point zero four Re Vera That’s a significant extension compared to what they get when they only consider regions where direct auroral lines are actually detected Jocelyn
Subrahmanyan: Extending the gradient means you can map out the metallicity structure much more steeply in the inner regions, which is crucial for understanding how gas flows and forms stars in dense environments Vera The results they show suggest that when they include these indirect estimates, the inferred central metallicity actually increases from eight point seven six to eight point nine four at a radius of less than or equal to one point five Re Jocelyn That small increase in the central value is what makes them think this method is really doing something useful for mapping out structure formation Subrahmanyan
Vera: So, if you’re driving around and looking at a nebula, the naive question would be, "How do we know which temperature we're actually seeing?"
Jocelyn: And the numbers they give us show that this indirect approach using sulfur helps us get closer to what might be the true abundance structure in those dense areas Subrahmanyan But there are clear limitations mentioned in the paper. They state that strong-line methods, even with these new corrections, are still subject to systematic uncertainties and they aren't free from biases Vera And specifically, they acknowledge that their method is based on assumptions about the Galactic extinction law and theoretical Balmer and helium ratios when using parameters like S O23 Jocelyn
Paper summary: Jocelyn: So, even with this new indirect approach for oxygen abundance determinations across a wide range of physical conditions, the paper flags that their methodology relies on certain assumptions about dust distribution and theoretical line ratios to be fully accurate Subrahmanyan They also note that strong-line methods in general still carry systematic uncertainties Vera It’s not a perfect fix for every single thing.
Subrahmanyan: When you think about the bigger cosmic picture, this work suggests that we can finally push our understanding of chemical evolution into regions where direct measurements have historically failed Jocelyn If this method can reliably map those gradients out to the galactic centers, it gives us better constraints on how metals are distributed throughout galaxies Vera It opens up new opportunities to improve those commonly used strong line abundance calibrations in the intermediate to high metallicity regime because of what they found here >
Jocelyn: So, basically, they’ve developed a way to get oxygen abundances that works better when things get crowded and hot Subrahmanyan The authors are testing this using M101 as their test case for the whole radial profile Vera It shows that including these indirect estimates leads to a steeper abundance gradient in those inner regions >
Vera: And if you only used the direct measurements where the auroral lines were clearly visible, you would get a less steep gradient Jocelyn That’s the key finding there about how much detail this new approach adds to our picture >
Subrahmanyan: What this means for future work is that we need to figure out how robust these S O23 parameter estimates are when applied across different types of galaxies beyond M101 Vera And maybe we need more observations of these specific sulfur lines to better constrain the temperature dependence Jocelyn
Jocelyn: Right. So they’ve given us a new tool, based on sulfur temperature, that helps us map oxygen abundance gradients in places where the old direct methods were struggling with detection and bias >
Conclusion: Vera: So we've been looking at this paper about oxygen abundance determinations across different physical conditions, and what they're proposing is a new indirect method using sulfur electron temperature to get those abundances right in HII regions.
Jocelyn: Right, so they’re trying to bypass some of the problems you get with direct measurements, especially when the galaxies are really dense.
Subrahmanyan: Essentially, they’re using sulfur as a proxy for temperature because it behaves differently than oxygen in certain high-metallicity environments where those direct oxygen lines get tricky to see.
Vera: Exactly. They use something called the electron temperature of double ionised sulfur, either by measuring its auroral line or using a parameter called the S O23 parameter if the metals are high enough.
Jocelyn: And they claim this lets them extend those abundance gradients much further out into the core of galaxies, like M101.
Subrahmanyan: That extension is what's important because it shows that we can map out how metals are distributed in the very center of a galaxy with more detail than before.
Vera: They found that including these indirect estimates helps create a steeper abundance gradient in the inner regions, which is less steep when you only look at where you can directly see those auroral lines.
Jocelyn: So it’s about getting a better picture of the central structure of galaxies by using this indirect temperature method.
Subrahmanyan: It opens up new ways to test our models of chemical evolution in high-metallicity environments, which is what we need to confirm whether our theories about how stars form and die are correct.
S. Zamora, Asier Castrillo, A. I. Díaz, Marta Gavilán
Scuola Normale Superiore · Observatorio AstronÒmico Nazionale (IGN) · Departamento de Fa Tࣩrica, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid · CIAFF, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid
astro-ph.GA
Submitted: 2026-11-11
Updated: 2026-11-11
Comments: 12 pages, 10 figures, Submitted to Astronomy & Astrophysics
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 79/100
The gist: A new indirect approach for oxygen abundance determinations across a wide range of physical conditions presents an alternative method using sulfur electron temperature to derive oxygen abundances in…
Key concepts
- Direct Abundance Determination Biases
- Traditional methods for finding oxygen abundance suffer from selection biases. Line intensities are often weighted toward warmer regions because their brightness depends exponentially on temperature. Furthermore, auroral lines become hard to detect at low temperatures, especially in high-metallicity environments where most oxygen exists as O+.
- Indirect Methodology
- This new approach estimates the electron temperature of double ionised sulfur ([S III]) using strong emission lines instead of relying on faint auroral lines. This estimated temperature is then used to calculate chemical abundances, which helps bypass the detection biases and provides a more reliable measurement.
- O23 and S23 Parameters
- The O23 parameter combines strong [OII] and [OIII] lines to estimate oxygen abundance across various HII regions. Similarly, the S23 parameter combines [SII] and [SIII] lines. The ratio between these two parameters is proposed as a reliable indicator for high-metallicity regions because their complementary behavior compensates for individual calibration trends.
Terminology
Summary
A new indirect approach for oxygen abundance determinations across a wide range of physical conditions presents an alternative method using sulfur electron temperature to derive oxygen abundances in HII regions, which mitigates systematic biases in direct measurements, especially in high-metallicity environments
The new methodology is based on the derivation of the electron temperature of the double ionised sulfur, either by the direct measurement of the [SIII] auroral line or, at supersolar metalicities, from the S O23 parameter This new indirect method is able to extend the abundance gradient up to the very centre of the M101 galaxy (0.04 Re) This new methodology mitigates systematic biases in direct abundance determinations based on auroral lines, while opening up new opportunities to improve commonly used strong line abundance calibrations in the intermediate to high metallicity regime
Mitigating Selection Biases
The direct method for oxygen abundance determination is subject to significant selection effects and biases, particularly in the central regions of galaxies First, the exponential dependence of collisionally excited line emissivities on Te means that the observed line intensities are strongly weighted towards warmer parts of the nebular ionisation structure This effect is particularly important for oxygen, for which the temperature derived from the [OIII] lines can exceed the actual ionic temperature of O++ At high metallicities, most of the oxygen is in the form of O+ (87–95%; Díaz & Zamora 2022) then this effect cannot be considered important Second, in high metallicity regions, auroral lines are often difficult or impossible to detect since their emissivities decrease rapidly at low electron temperatures An alternative to the limitations associated with using oxygen as a reference element for determining gas-phase metallicity gradients is to consider alternative elements whose auroral lines remain detectable at lower electron temperatures, thereby extending the applicability of the direct method to higher metallicities Sulphur is a particularly suitable candidate for this purpose because its auroral emission line of [S III] at λ6312 are analogues to that of [OIII] at λ4363 Furthermore, in the case of sulphur, due to the lower excitation energies involved, the line emissivities are less dependent on Te which allows the line detection even at over-solar abundances (Díaz et al. 2007; Díaz & Zamora 2022)
The Indirect Methodology
In this work, we propose a new methodology, referred to as the “indirect” method, to address these two biases affecting the central, high-metallicity regions of abundance gradients (i) the exponential dependence of collisionally excited line emissivities on Te means that the observed line intensities are strongly weighted towards warmer parts of the nebular ionisation structure (Shields & Searle 1978); and (ii) the oxygen auroral line, [OIII]λ4363 Å, is often difficult or impossible to detect in high metallicity regions (Te lower than 7000K) because their emissivities decrease rapidly at low electron temperatures (Bresolin 2008) Our new approach estimates Te[S III] from strong emission lines, avoiding the selection effects associated with the detection of auroral lines, and uses it to derive direct chemical abundances By estimating the oxygen and sulphur electron temperatures from Te[S III], we also mitigate the bias arising from the overestimation of Te[OII] when inferred from Te[OIII]
Calibration Parameters
Several strong line calibrations have been proposed in the literature to estimate chemical abundances in ionised nebulae, based on individual elements or combinations of emission lines from different species (e.g. Pagel et al. p. 1 Article
tions of emission lines have been proposed as abundance calibrators. Among them, one of the most widely used is the R23 (or
O23) parameter, originally proposed by Pagel et al. Pagel et al. 1979; Denicoló et al. Among these, the O23 parameter is one of
the most widely used indicators of oxygen abundance. Its main
advantage is that it combines strong [OII] and [OIII] emission
lines, making it applicable to a broad range of HII regions, even
Fig. It was defined as (Díaz et al. 2000):
S O23 =
S 23
O23
=
[S II]λλ6717, 6731 + [S III]λλ9069, 9532
[OII]λλ3727, 3729 + [OIII]λλ4959, 5007 (1)
This parameter provides a single-valued metallicity estimate
because, when both parameters lie on their upper-metallicity
branches, their complementary behaviour compensates for the
trend of each individual calibrator.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Results and Gradients
The results show that including the indirect estimates allows us to extend the abundance gradient to the innermost regions, resulting in a steeper abundance gradient When only regions with detected auroral lines are considered, the derived gradient is less steep Including the indirect estimates allows us to extend the analysis to the innermost regions, resulting in a steeper abundance gradient The inner regions, at R/Re ≲ 1.5, where direct measurements are unavailable, show that the inferred central metallicity increases from 8. p. 6 5, where direct measurements are
unavailable. As a result, the inferred central metallicity increases
from 8. As a result, the inferred central metallicity increases
from 8. 94, corresponding to an increase of 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced abundance gradient determination: The improved system can derive oxygen abundance gradients up to 0.04 Re in M101 by using sulfur electron temperature as a tracer, mitigating systematic biases from direct auroral line measurements at high metallicities.
-
Bias mitigation in high metallicity regimes: The system can estimate Te[S III] from strong emission lines to derive Te[OII] and Te[OIII], which mitigates the bias arising from the overestimation of Te[OII] when inferred from Te[OIII].
-
Robust calibration selection: The improved AI can use the S O23 parameter to provide a single-valued metallicity estimate, avoiding the complications associated with the branch transition or turnover region that affect other calibrators like R23.
-
Physical condition decoupling: The system can calibrate electron temperature first and then derive chemical abundance separately, allowing for explicit consideration of physical conditions like effective temperature and ionisation parameter without requiring explicit corrections for the ionisation structure.
-
Extended radial coverage analysis: By combining direct and indirect measurements, the system can extend the analysis to innermost regions where auroral lines are not detected, achieving radial coverage up to 0.14 Re instead of the limited range provided by only direct measurements.
Abstract
In this work we present a new approach to derive HII region metal abundances based on sulfur emission lines. We select M101 as benchmark galaxy to test our new methodology along the wide metallicity gradient of this huge face-on star-forming spiral. Based on previous studies, we compile a sample of 151 HII regions and compare their properties base on the galaxy radial profile. The new methodology is based on the derivation of the electron temperature of the double ionised sulfur, either by the direct measurement of the [SIII] auroral line or, at supersolar metalicities, from the SO 23 parameter. This new indirect method is able to extend the abundance gradient up to the very centre of the M101 galaxy (0.04 R e). This new methodology mitigates systematic biases in direct abundance determinations based on auroral lines, while opening up new opportunities to improve commonly used strong line abundance calibrations in the intermediate to high metallicity regime.
Sources
- Measuring Chemical Abundances in Extragalactic Metal-Rich HII Regions
- The electron temperature in ionized nebulae
- Nebular abundances in galaxies: Beware of biases
Related papers
- The Pristine survey XXVIII. Journey to the Galactic outskirts: Mapping the outer halo red giant stars down to the very metal-poor end
- Origins of Extreme Emission-Line Ratios in z > 3 Galaxies: Insights from the Lumen Model
- The Kinematically Hot, Extremely Metal-Poor C-19 Stellar Stream in DESI DR2
- UV slopes of Starforming Galaxies in Strong Lensing fields at the Epoch of Reionization with JWST
- Evolution of Binaries Under Stochastic Perturbations
- The hydrodynamical response of cold circumgalactic clouds to quasar radiation