Earth-sized tests of long-range neutrino interactions
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Earth-sized tests of long-range neutrino interactions".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Neutrinos may experience a new long-range force that distinguishes their flavors, mediated by an ultralight neutral boson of a new U(1)' gauge symmetry and sourced by the electrons and nucleons of ordinary matter The Earth is then both the source of the potential and the medium that the neutrinos cross This work computes a potential at each point along every neutrino's path, from a layered model of the Earth, and from each height in the atmosphere at which the neutrino can be produced Using this potential, they fit the DeepCore data with the systematic uncertainties of that analysis.
Kai: Long-Range Interaction Mechanism The idea of a long-range force coupled to a conserved charge goes back to Ref.
1: , for baryon number; Ref.
2: extended it to the number of each lepton flavor Gauging one of them introduces a new neutral boson, Z′, of a U(1)' symmetry For an ultralight Z′, with a mass m′ between 10−15 and 10−9 eV, the force has a range of about 200 m to 30 Earth radii Through this long-range interaction (LRI), the electrons, protons, and neutrons of the Earth create a potential that acts differently on each neutrino flavor, proportionally to the square of g′, the coupling of the Z′.
Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap what this paper "Earth-sized tests of long-range neutrino interactions" is about, the main thesis is that neutrinos could have a new long-range force that distinguishes their flavors, mediated by an ultralight neutral boson from a U(one) symmetry <ref:2611.14642#pg1,a new long-range force that distinguishes their flavors, mediated by an>.
Mira: And the core claim they make is that because the Earth is both the source and the medium, atmospheric neutrinos crossing it would feel this flavor-dependent potential that modifies how they oscillate. Earlier analyses often simplified this by assuming a constant potential along the path or just following some local density of matter.
Lev: This paper goes deeper than that; they compute the potential exactly at every point along each neutrino's path, using a layered model of the Earth, and also considering all possible production heights in the atmosphere to see how that affects things.
Kai: They use this super detailed potential to fit data from IceCube DeepCore, incorporating all the known systematic uncertainties and priors used in that analysis. They are testing eight different U(one) symmetries, and they set upper limits on the coupling constant g prime for each one based on this fit <ref:2611.14642#pg1>.
Mira: What's really interesting is how they handle the potential; it changes along the path, especially when the force range is shorter than about one Earth radius, because each stretch of that path feels mostly the matter closest to it.
Lev: That makes sense from a hardware standpoint; if you're building a detector, you have to account for this spatial variation when modeling how particles interact over long distances.
Kai: And they compare their results to previous studies, and they show that by calculating the potential at every point instead of holding it fixed at the detector location, their limit on g prime is about one point zero three to one point five times stronger in some ranges and two to two point seven times stronger in others.
Mira: It’s a bit complex because they also find that the constraints are strongest for those symmetries where the potential affects muon and tau neutrinos, which gets boosted by a factor of about one point four five once you include their respective charges.
Lev: That comparison between the constant potential approach and this new path-dependent calculation is really important for seeing how much more information we can extract from the same experimental data.
Kai: So, this work is essentially showing that by being meticulous about modeling the Earth's influence on neutrinos, we can put much tighter constraints on these new physics models.
Conclusion: Mira: Looking at "Earth-sized tests of long-range neutrino interactions," it’s clear they are pushing the limits of how much we can constrain new physics from atmospheric neutrino data.
Kai: The authors are testing a specific mechanism where neutrinos could have a flavor-dependent potential caused by an ultralight neutral boson from a new U(one) symmetry, and they show that the Earth's structure makes this potential very path-dependent <ref:2611.14642#pg1,by an ultralight neutral boson>.
Lev: It’s important to remember that this isn't just about finding some new particle; it’s about using existing atmospheric neutrino data to probe physics occurring at very large scales with relatively weak coupling constants.
Mira: The implication is that if we detect these flavor-dependent effects, it would tell us a lot about the structure of the universe and the existence of these new gauge symmetries.
Kai: They're suggesting that future detectors, like IceCube Upgrade or KM3NeT/ORCA or HyperKamiokande and DUNE, could be used to tighten these limits further because they can measure this path-dependent potential directly.
Lev: If the potential inside the Earth varies by a factor of about two or more between the detector and the center, that variation itself becomes a measurable signal we can try to exploit in future experiments.
Kai: So, the paper's main contribution is moving beyond simple models of a constant potential to an exact calculation that accounts for the specific geometry of neutrinos crossing our planet.
Dyer F. Cardenas, *, Mauricio Bustamante, †
SecciƓon FƓsica, Department of Sciences, Pontificia Universidad Catņlica del Perﲭelo Perﲭelo · Niels Bohr International Academy, Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen
hep-ph, hep-ex, hep-th
Submitted: 2026-11-10
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures, plus appendices; files available at https://github.com/mbustama/nu-lri-earth.git
Code: https://github.com/mbustama/nu-lri-earth
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: Neutrinos may experience a new long-range force that distinguishes their flavors, mediated by an ultralight neutral boson of a new U(1)' gauge symmetry and sourced by the electrons and nucleons of…
Key concepts
- Long-Range Interaction (LRI)
- This is a hypothetical force where electrons, protons, and neutrons in the Earth create a potential that acts differently on each neutrino flavor. It is mediated by an ultralight neutral boson (Z') with a mass between 10^-15 and 10^-9 eV, giving the interaction a range of about 200 meters to 30 Earth radii.
- U(1)' Gauge Symmetry
- This is a new type of symmetry in physics that introduces a new neutral boson, called the Z', to mediate the long-range force. This symmetry governs how the neutrinos interact with matter, allowing for flavor-dependent interactions that are not present in standard model physics.
- Potential Variation Along Path
- Unlike previous analyses that used a constant potential value, this study computes the potential at every single point along a neutrino's path through the Earth or atmosphere. This accounts for how the potential changes as the neutrino moves, providing a more accurate fit to experimental data.
- Flavor-Dependent Potential
- The core finding is that different neutrinos experience different potentials depending on their flavor (e.g., muon vs. tau). The strength of this difference is crucial for setting constraints on the new force, as the analysis focuses on symmetries where this potential difference is significant.
Terminology
Summary
Neutrinos may experience a new long-range force that distinguishes their flavors, mediated by an ultralight neutral boson of a new U(1)' gauge symmetry and sourced by the electrons and nucleons of ordinary matter The Earth is then both the source of the potential and the medium that the neutrinos cross This work computes a potential at each point along every neutrino's path, from a layered model of the Earth, and from each height in the atmosphere at which the neutrino can be produced Using this potential, they fit the DeepCore data with the systematic uncertainties of that analysis.
Long-Range Interaction Mechanism
The idea of a long-range force coupled to a conserved charge goes back to Ref. [1], for baryon number; Ref. p. 0 [2] extended it to the number of each lepton flavor Gauging one of them introduces a new neutral boson, Z′, of a U(1)' symmetry For an ultralight Z′, with a mass m′ between 10−15 and 10−9 eV, the force has a range of about 200 m to 30 Earth radii Through this long-range interaction (LRI), the electrons, protons, and neutrons of the Earth create a potential that acts differently on each neutrino flavor, proportionally to the square of g′, the coupling of the Z′. The potential on ν α at r is given by Vα(r) = g′2 bα X f=e,p,n Ψf (r), (2)
Analysis Methodology
The authors compute the potential at each point along the path of every neutrino, from the matter of a layered model of the Earth, and from each height in the atmosphere at which the neutrino can be produced They use this potential to fit the DeepCore data with its nuisance parameters, priors, and test statistic of the IceCube analysis The DeepCore analysis is most sensitive to the LRI near about 24 GeV. They study 14 U(1)' symmetries For the eight whose potential differs between νµ and ντ, they set upper limits on g′ across their window of masses.
Comparison with Previous Work
The constant potential of earlier analyses (Sec. I) misses how the potential changes along each path Section IV A compares their limits with those of the constant potential, with everything else unchanged The authors compute the potential at every point along the path, instead of holding it at its value at the detector, makes their limit on g′ 1. p. 32 times stronger at the longest ranges and 2–2. p. 17 times stronger at ranges shorter than about 600 km
Key Results and Constraints
The authors find that their limit on g′ is 1.03–1.5 times stronger than the earlier DeepCore limit of Ref. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 [10] wherever both exist The two analyses differ in more than the potential, however Among the other symmetries, those whose potential acts on νµ −ντ have the strongest limits, by a factor of about 1. p. 1 p. 1 p. 145 once their charges are accounted for. p. 1 p. 1
Conclusion and Outlook
A new long-range force between neutrinos and matter, different for each flavor, would let the electrons and nucleons of the Earth act on the atmospheric neutrinos that cross it Detectors under construction or planned, such as the IceCube Upgrade [71], KM3NeT/ORCA [72], HyperKamiokande [73], and DUNE [74], could tighten these limits. The potential inside the Earth varies along each path, by a factor of about 2 or more between the detector and the center. p. 1
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
Neutrinos may experience a new long-range force that distinguishes their flavors, mediated by an ultralight neutral boson of a new U(1)' gauge symmetry and sourced by the electrons and nucleons of ordinary matter The Earth is then both the source of the potential and the medium that the neutrinos cross This work computes a potential at each point along every neutrino's path, from a layered model of the Earth, and from each height in the atmosphere at which the neutrino can be produced Using this potential, they fit the DeepCore data with its nuisance parameters, priors, and test statistic of the IceCube analysis.
How the training signal is built
The authors compute the potential at each point along the path of every neutrino, from the matter of a layered model of the Earth, and from each height in the atmosphere at which the neutrino can be produced Using this potential, they fit the DeepCore data with its nuisance parameters, priors, and test statistic of the IceCube analysis The DeepCore analysis is most sensitive to the LRI near about 24 GeV.
Where the gains come from
The authors find that their limit on g′ is 1.03–1.5 times stronger than the earlier DeepCore limit of Ref. [10] wherever both exist The two analyses differ in more than the potential, however. p. 1 p. 1 Among the other symmetries, those whose potential acts on νµ −ντ have the strongest limits, by a factor of about 1.45 once their charges are accounted for. The sensitivity rests on the difference between the potentials of νµ and ντ. p. 9
The authors compute the potential at each point along the path of every neutrino, from the matter of a layered model of the Earth, and from each height in the atmosphere at which the neutrino can be produced Using this potential, they fit the DeepCore data with its nuisance parameters, priors, and test statistic of the IceCube analysis The DeepCore analysis is most sensitive to the LRI near about 24 GeV.
The authors find that their limit on g′ is 1.03–1.5 times stronger than the earlier DeepCore limit of Ref. [10] wherever both exist The two analyses differ in more than the potential, however. Among the other symmetries, those whose potential acts on νµ −ντ have the strongest limits, by a factor of about 1.45 once their charges are accounted for The sensitivity rests on the difference between the potentials of νµ and ντ. p. 9
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Develop an AI system capable of computing neutrino oscillation probabilities using Magnus integration for any Hermitian Hamiltonian, as described in Section II D. This allows the AI to accurately model flavor evolution when a long-range interaction potential VLRI is present, moving beyond simpler constant potential approximations.
-
Implement a simulation module that computes the matter potential at every point along each neutrino path from a layered Earth model and incorporates production heights from atmospheric neutrino flux distributions (Eq. 7). This enables the AI to analyze how the LRI potential varies with distance and location relative to different Earth layers, which is crucial for high precision.
-
Create an analysis pipeline that fits IceCube DeepCore data by including both oscillation parameters and nuisance parameters, explicitly allowing the LRI potential VLRI(r) to be computed at each point along the path. This allows for a comparison between results where the potential is held constant versus when it varies along each path, as detailed in Section IV A.
-
Design a statistical inference engine that utilizes asymptotic thresholds derived from pseudo-experiments instead of standard Wilks' theorem values for setting upper limits on coupling constants g prime, as suggested in Appendix E. This provides more accurate and conservative confidence level reporting for the final constraints.
-
Build a constraint generation tool that can systematically explore the parameter space of 14 U(1)' symmetries by calculating the effective coupling g p0 k for each mass window from 10-26 to 10-9 eV. This allows the AI to rapidly map out which symmetries are most constrained by atmospheric neutrino data across different energy scales.
-
Integrate a test suite that compares the derived limits on g prime against constraints from tests of the equivalence principle, including bounds from MICROSCOPE and Eot-Wash experiments, as discussed in Section C. This ensures the derived constraints are robust against competing experimental bounds.
Sources
- Leptons and Photons
- Model for a Light Z' Boson
- The Physics of Heavy Z' Gauge Bosons
- Non-Standard Neutrino Interactions and Neutral Gauge Bosons
- First Constraints on Long-Range Neutrino Interactions using IceCube DeepCore
- Torsion-balance tests of the weak equivalence principle
- MICROSCOPE mission: final results of the test of the Equivalence Principle
- Test of the Equivalence Principle Using a Rotating Torsion Balance
- How strong can the coupling of leptonic photons be?
- Neutrino oscillations in the Sun probe long-range leptonic forces
- Constraints on flavor-dependent long range forces from solar neutrinos and KamLAND
- Probing long-range leptonic forces with solar and reactor neutrinos
- Constraints on flavour-dependent long-range forces from atmospheric neutrino observations at Super-Kamiokande
- Long-range forces : atmospheric neutrino oscillation at a magnetized detector
- Can INO be Sensitive to Flavor-Dependent Long-Range Forces?
- Gauged L_mu - L_tau and different Muon Neutrino and Anti-Neutrino Oscillations: MINOS and beyond
- Long-Range Lepton Flavor Interactions and Neutrino Oscillations
- Exploring Flavor-Dependent Long-Range Forces in Long-Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Experiments
- Flavor-dependent long-range neutrino interactions in DUNE & T2HK: alone they constrain, together they discover
- A plethora of long-range neutrino interactions probed by DUNE and T2HK
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses