SuSy and CoDy Radiation from Evaporating Black Holes

arXiv:2611.14563 · hep-ph, astro-ph.HE, gr-qc · Submitted 2026-11-06 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "SuSy and CoDy Radiation from Evaporating Black Holes".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We investigate the interplay between physics beyond the Standard Model and modified spacetime geometries in shaping the photon and neutrino spectra from evaporating black holes The effects of new particle physics and modified spacetime geometries can become intertwined in specific energy regimes, altering the resulting spectral signatures Photon and neutrino spectra provide complementary probes of new particle physics and black hole geometry, with predicted spectral enhancements extending into the energy ranges accessible to current and future high-energy observatories.

Kai: BSM Scenarios for Black Hole Evaporation The study examines three representative supersymmetric (SuSy) benchmarks and a composite dynamics (CoDy) scenario in BlackHawk The SuSy scenario is built upon the Poincar´e algebra, where new symmetry generators relate particles of different spin.

Mira: The CoDy scenario consists of extending the gauge symmetry of the SM by a new confining force, whose charged matter fermions replace the Brout-Englert-Higgs sector.

Kai: These models predict new heavy particles and interactions around the TeV scale.

Paper summary: Kai: So wrapping up this paper "SuSy and CoDy Radiation from Evaporating Black Holes", the main thing is that they've shown how physics beyond the Standard Model and modified spacetime geometry combine to affect the photon and neutrino spectra from evaporating black holes <ref:2611.14563#pg1>.

Mira: They tested three supersymmetric scenarios and a composite dynamics scenario against both standard Schwarzschild black holes and regular ones like polymerized, Hayward, or Simpson–Visser geometries <ref:2611.14563#pg2>.

Lev: The key implication for us is that these BSM scenarios produce spectral excesses near the TeV scale, which is right in the range of what present instruments can detect <ref:2611.14563#pg2>.

Kai: They also found that the composite Higgs benchmark gives a narrow feature of the first kind from a decay of a singlet pion-like state to a Z gamma <ref:2611.14563#pg2>.

Mira: And they pointed out that black hole geometry and particle content are not separate things; they depend on each other in shaping these spectra <ref:2611.14563#pg2>.

Lev: The paper's limitation is that the neutrino channel is restricted by flux and exposure time, but for photons, the instantaneous spectra they computed should be confronted with observed signals integrated over the instrument exposure time <ref:2611.14563#pg2>.

Conclusion: Kai: So this paper is looking at how new physics and weird black hole shapes create signals from black holes that are shrinking fast.

Mira: It’s about supersymmetric models and composite dynamics interacting with different types of black hole geometries, specifically regular ones like polymerized or Hayward ones.

Lev: Basically, they're mapping out the photon and neutrino output from these evaporating objects to see what kind of new particles or gravity modifications we might be seeing.

Kai: The authors are looking at three supersymmetric scenarios and one composite dynamics scenario. They’re using black hole evaporation codes, BlackHawk version three point zero specifically.

Mira: And they’ve found that these different models produce spectral excesses in the energy range near the TeV scale, which is something current instruments can actually probe.

Lev: That's interesting because it means if we see a photon or a neutrino from an evaporating black hole, we might be seeing evidence for these specific types of new physics or spacetime modifications.

Kai: It really shows that the geometry and particle content aren't totally separate things; they influence each other in shaping what you actually measure.

Mira: Yeah, it suggests that even if we can't see the black hole itself, the radiation we get is a fingerprint of both what’s happening inside and how spacetime behaves near these objects.

Lev: The neutrino channel is limited by flux and exposure time, but for photons, the instantaneous spectra they calculated should be compared to actual data integrated over the instrument’s measurement record.

Kai: So, it gives us a concrete prediction of where we might look for these signals in upcoming experiments.

Laboratoire de Physique Théorique et Hautes Energies (LPTHE) · ψQTC Quantum Theory Center University of Southern Denmark Campusvej 55 Odense Denmark · Dip. di Fisica ’ Pancini UniversitƠ di Napoli Federico II Via Cintia 80126 Napoli Italy · Institute for Particle Physics Phenomenology Durham Univ South Road DH1 3LE Durham United Kingdom · Scuola Superiore Meridionale UniversitƠ di Napoli Federico II Largo San Marcellino 10 80138 Napoli Italy

hep-ph, astro-ph.HE, gr-qc

Submitted: 2026-11-06

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: 49 pages, 11 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 70/100

The gist: We investigate the interplay between physics beyond the Standard Model and modified spacetime geometries in shaping the photon and neutrino spectra from evaporating black holes The effects of new…

Key concepts

BSM Scenarios for Black Hole Evaporation
These are theoretical models extending the Standard Model of particle physics. The study tests three supersymmetric (SuSy) scenarios based on Poincaré algebra and a composite dynamics (CoDy) scenario involving a new confining force. These models predict new heavy particles and interactions around the TeV scale, which influence how black holes evaporate.
Regular Black Hole Geometries
Instead of standard Schwarzschild black holes, the research uses 'regular' geometries like polymerized, Hayward, and Simpson–Visser black holes. These are proposed solutions to a more complete theory of gravity that modifies General Relativity at very small length scales. This modification changes the spacetime around the black hole.
Photon and Neutrino Spectra
These are the specific energy distributions of light particles (photons) and neutrinos emitted during black hole evaporation. The study uses a code called BlackHawk to compute these spectra for different black hole masses, showing that BSM effects create detectable enhancements in the photon spectrum around TeV energies.
Composite Higgs Benchmark
This specific BSM scenario suggests a narrow spectral feature arising from the decay of a hypothetical singlet pion-like state into a Z boson and a photon. This provides a distinct signature compared to other models, helping researchers discriminate between different theoretical frameworks.

Terminology

Summary

We investigate the interplay between physics beyond the Standard Model and modified spacetime geometries in shaping the photon and neutrino spectra from evaporating black holes The effects of new particle physics and modified spacetime geometries can become intertwined in specific energy regimes, altering the resulting spectral signatures Photon and neutrino spectra provide complementary probes of new particle physics and black hole geometry, with predicted spectral enhancements extending into the energy ranges accessible to current and future high-energy observatories. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Crucially, we show that the effects of new particle physics and modified spacetime geometries can become intertwined in specific energy regimes, altering the resulting spectral signatures. Our results demonstrate that photon and neutrino spectra provide complementary probes of new particle physics and black hole geometry, with predicted spectral enhancements extending into the energy ranges accessible to current and future high-energy observatories.

BSM Scenarios for Black Hole Evaporation

The study examines three representative supersymmetric (SuSy) benchmarks and a composite dynamics (CoDy) scenario in BlackHawk The SuSy scenario is built upon the Poincar´e algebra, where new symmetry generators relate particles of different spin. The CoDy scenario consists of extending the gauge symmetry of the SM by a new confining force, whose charged matter fermions replace the Brout-Englert-Higgs sector. p. 2

Where the paper says it

the Poincar´e algebra, where the new symmetry generators relate particles of different spin. Instead, the CoDy scenario consists in extending the gauge symmetry of the SM by a new confining force, whose charged matter fermions replace the Brout-Englert-Higgs sector.

These models predict new heavy particles and interactions around the TeV scale. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In both cases, the main theoretical and phenomenological result is the prediction of new heavy particles and interactions around the TeV scale [15]. Models based on SuSy and CoDy are currently being tested in collider searches [16], without yet having statistical evidence for the existence of new particles due to the limited energy range of colliders and to the difficulty to distinguish a clean signature of a new heavy particle from the SM backgrounds.

Regularized Black Hole Geometries

The research considers Schwarzschild black holes and regular black holes geometries, namely polymerized, Hayward, and Simpson–Visser black holes. Regular black holes (RBHs) are thought as possible solutions of a more complete, potentially quantum, theory of gravity that is expected to modify GR dynamics at lengths smaller than a characteristic scale l. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The singularity issue in GR can be addressed via a violation of the strong energy condition in the vicinity of the centre of BHs [19], leading to non-singular spacetimes [20, 21], known as regular black holes (RBHs). These are thought as possible solutions of a more complete, potentially quantum, theory of gravity that is expected to modify GR dynamics at lengths smaller than a characteristic scale ℓ, effectively resolving the central singularity.

The metric of polymerized BHs is parameterized in terms of a small parameter ε. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In parallel, phenomenological studies have investigated the potential of current and future gamma-ray detectors to probe BSM dark sectors through the observation of nearby PBH bursts [51]. Recently, a new source was proposed via the possible production of small black holes, dubbed “black morsels”, during the merger of astrophysical BHs [52] which have been discovered via their gravitational wave emission.

The Hayward metric is a standard example of a static, spherically symmetric RBH. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Distinguishing the metric of RBHs from that of the singular BHs, stemming from GR, could be possible in principle through the observation of gravitational waves signal coming from their coalescence [22–25], however this usually requires compact object mergers of masses well below the ones of astrophysical BHs and an experimental sensitivity far beyond the current one. In this work, we aim at investigating whether BSM scenarios and RBH metrics can affect the physics of BHs in an observable way.

Results for Photon and Neutrino Spectra

The photon and neutrino spectra are generated thanks to the public code BlackHawk v3.0. The spectra are computed instantaneously for two BH masses: MBH = 1010 g in the left panel (corresponding to TH ∼ 1 TeV), and MBH = 5 × 108 g in the left panel (corresponding to TH ∼ 20 TeV). p. 0

Where the paper says it

New degrees of freedom at the TeV scale become accessible at Hawking temperatures corresponding to black hole masses of approximately MBH ∼ 1010 g. We show that physics beyond the Standard Model produces distinctive signatures in both the instantaneous secondary-photon and neutrino spectra.

The results show that BSM scenarios produce excesses at energies close to the TeV, within range of present instruments.

Comparison with Observational Ranges

The peaks of the relative enhancement consistently lie in the range ∼ 102–104 GeV, which overlaps the sensitivity windows of current gammaray instruments. The shape of the excess discriminates between benchmarks: a direct radiative decay produces a narrow bump whose height is stable with temperature, as in the NMSSM through the neutralino decay χe02 → χe01γ, while heavy states feeding multistep cascades produce a broad enhancement that grows with temperature, as in M125τ. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We show that physics beyond the Standard Model produces distinctive signatures in both the instantaneous secondary-photon and neutrino spectra. Radiative decays generate narrow spectral features with approximately temperature-independent relative amplitudes, while multistep decay cascades produce broad enhancements that become increasingly pronounced at higher temperatures.

The composite Higgs benchmark shows a narrow feature of the first kind, from the decay of a singlet pion-like state s → Zγ. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Some SuSy scenarios have already been considered in the literature [28, 29], in this work we analyse specific benchmark models based on the minimal (MSSM) and next-to-minimal (NMSSM) realizations, which are compatible with the Higgs physics and the current collider bounds. Furthermore, we consider CoDy models where the Higgs boson emerges as a light, pion-like, bound state [30] of a QCD-like confining dynamics.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Some SuSy scenarios have already been considered in the literature [28, 29], in this work we analyse specific benchmark models based on the minimal (MSSM) and next-to-minimal (NMSSM) realizations, which are compatible with the Higgs physics and the current collider bounds. Furthermore, we consider CoDy models where the Higgs boson emerges as a light, pion-like, bound state [30] of a QCD-like confining dynamics.

Conclusions and Outlook

The spectra of photons and neutrinos, produced via BlackHawk v3.0 combined with our transfer functions, show that BSM scenarios produce excesses at energies close to the TeV, within range of present instruments. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Our main scope is, therefore, to produce transfer function tables for the SuSy and CoDy benchmarks. For the SM [45], and few examples of BSM [46], BlackHawk uses Pythia [57], a code developed within the context of collider physics.

The composite Higgs benchmark shows a narrow feature of the first kind, from the decay of a singlet pion-like state s → Zγ. We also showed that BH geometry and particle content do not decouple. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Crucially, we show that the effects of new particle physics and modified spacetime geometries can become intertwined in specific energy regimes, altering the resulting spectral signatures. Our results demonstrate that photon and neutrino spectra provide complementary probes of new particle physics and black hole geometry, with predicted spectral enhancements extending into the energy ranges accessible to current and future high-energy observatories.

If photons emitted by an evaporating primordial black hole, or a distant localized population of black holes, is observed, the instantaneous spectra we computed should be confronted to the observed signals integrated over the instrument exposure time. The neutrino channel is limited here by flux and exposure time. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Models based on SuSy and CoDy are currently being tested in collider searches [16], without yet having statistical evidence for the existence of new particles due to the limited energy range of colliders and to the difficulty to distinguish a clean signature of a new heavy particle from the SM backgrounds. Notably, the SM also falls short of describing well-established phenomena, such as the asymmetry of matter over antimatter, the presence of dark matter and dark energy, neutrino masses and cosmic inflation: many BSM models addressing naturalness incorporate at least one of them.

The work indicates that BSM scenarios produce excesses at energies close to the TeV, within range of present instruments.

Appendix A: Additional secondary spectra

Here we present some additional spectra, particularly focusing on neutrino spectra (Figures 8 and 9). The time evolution of the secondary neutrino spectrum for a Schwarzschild black hole of initial mass M = 1010 g, comparing across the different benchmarks, with the ratio of Eq. p. 0

Where the paper says it

New degrees of freedom at the TeV scale become accessible at Hawking temperatures corresponding to black hole masses of approximately MBH ∼ 1010 g. We show that physics beyond the Standard Model produces distinctive signatures in both the instantaneous secondary-photon and neutrino spectra.

(15) in the lower panels is shown in Figure 8. p. 8
Where the paper says it

0 for our results. We consider the production of new CoDy states in two steps: 1) if the Hawking temperature is lower than the CoDy scale, we only include the production of SM particles; 2) when TH is larger than such scale, we consider production of the CoDy constituents together with SM states.

The time evolution of the secondary neutrino spectrum for a black hole of initial mass M = 1010 g, and a near-final stage of temperature TH= 20 TeV is shown in Figure 9. p. 0
Where the paper says it

New degrees of freedom at the TeV scale become accessible at Hawking temperatures corresponding to black hole masses of approximately MBH ∼ 1010 g. We show that physics beyond the Standard Model produces distinctive signatures in both the instantaneous secondary-photon and neutrino spectra.

The instantaneous photon emission spectra for Kerr black holes with fixed mass M = 1010g and different dimensionless spin parameters a∗ is shown in Figure 10. p. 0
Where the paper says it

New degrees of freedom at the TeV scale become accessible at Hawking temperatures corresponding to black hole masses of approximately MBH ∼ 1010 g. We show that physics beyond the Standard Model produces distinctive signatures in both the instantaneous secondary-photon and neutrino spectra.

The instantaneous photon emission spectra for polymerized LQG black holes with fixed mass M = 1010 g for different physical values of the polymerization parameter ε is shown in Figure 11. p. 0
Where the paper says it

New degrees of freedom at the TeV scale become accessible at Hawking temperatures corresponding to black hole masses of approximately MBH ∼ 1010 g. We show that physics beyond the Standard Model produces distinctive signatures in both the instantaneous secondary-photon and neutrino spectra.

The comparison between Hayward and Simpson–Visser metric, for a black hole of mass 1010g and a scan of different regularization parameters L is shown in Figure 6. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We consider both Schwarzschild black holes and regular black holes geometries, namely polymerized, Hayward, and Simpson–Visser black holes. New degrees of freedom at the TeV scale become accessible at Hawking temperatures corresponding to black hole masses of approximately MBH ∼ 1010 g.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved particle spectrum prediction by integrating BSM benchmarks into BlackHawk v3.0 to allow for computing secondary particle fluxes from SuSy and CoDy models.

  2. Enhanced ability to distinguish between different BSM scenarios by analyzing spectral enhancements, such as "a direct radiative decay produces a narrow bump whose height is stable with temperature, as in the NMSSM through the neutralino decay chi02 -> chi01gamma".

  3. Capability to probe deviations from classical General Relativity by comparing photon and neutrino spectra against those from regular black hole metrics like Hayward and Simpson-Visser.

  4. Improved understanding of the interplay between new particle physics and modified spacetime geometries in specific energy regimes by analyzing how the effects of new particle physics and modified spacetime geometries can become intertwined in specific energy regimes, altering the resulting spectral signatures.

  5. Enhanced sensitivity to observational windows by calculating normalized HAWC photon-event spectra for a BH of mass 1010 g across different BSM benchmarks, showing that the peaks of the relative enhancement consistently lie in the range 102–104 GeV, which overlaps the sensitivity windows of current gamma-ray instruments.

Abstract

We investigate the interplay between physics beyond the Standard Model and modified spacetime geometries in shaping the photon and neutrino spectra from evaporating black holes. We implement three representative supersymmetric (SuSy) benchmarks and a composite dynamics (CoDy) scenario in BlackHawk. We consider both Schwarzschild black holes and regular black holes geometries, namely polymerized, Hayward, and Simpson--Visser black holes. New degrees of freedom at the TeV scale become accessible at Hawking temperatures corresponding to black hole masses of approximately M BH about 10 10, g. We show that physics beyond the Standard Model produces distinctive signatures in both the instantaneous secondary-photon and neutrino spectra. Radiative decays generate narrow spectral features with approximately temperature-independent relative amplitudes, while multistep decay cascades produce broad enhancements that become increasingly pronounced at higher temperatures. In contrast, compressed mass spectra exhibit no localized features. Crucially, we show that the effects of new particle physics and modified spacetime geometries can become intertwined in specific energy regimes, altering the resulting spectral signatures. Our results demonstrate that photon and neutrino spectra provide complementary probes of new particle physics and black hole geometry, with predicted spectral enhancements extending into the energy ranges accessible to current and future high-energy observatories.

Sources

Related papers