Dwarf galaxy simulations with stellar-core mass- and metallicity-dependent core-collapse supernova explosion energies

arXiv:2611.14437 · astro-ph.GA · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Dwarf galaxy simulations with stellar-core mass- and metallicity-dependent core-collapse supernova explosion energies".

Paper summary: Vera: So, looking at the whole "Dwarf galaxy simulations with stellar-core mass- and metallicity-dependent core-collapse supernova explosion energies" paper, the central idea is using a new prescription for explosion energies that scales with core mass and metallicity.

Jocelyn: And what it does is change the outcome for these dwarf galaxies by reducing the average supernova energy per star formation rate to about zero point three billion ergs in a low-metallicity dwarf galaxy simulation <ref:2611.14437#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: That reduction, as they model it, leads to a higher star formation rate that varies less over time and significantly reduces the mass-loading factors of the outflows. The paper also shows two point seven times more stellar mass black holes being produced when integrated over a billion years of star formation in those simulations.

Vera: And this is tied to how they model both failed supernovae and partial fallback of ejecta mass, which gives them a more complete picture of black hole formation pathways. They also found that the lower explosion energy runs result in more massive star clusters and an enhanced fraction of supernovae closely associated with their birth clusters.

Jocelyn: So, the title itself sets up the problem: how core mass and metallicity affect supernova explosions in dwarf galaxies, which then feeds into galaxy evolution models. It's a study connecting stellar physics to galactic structure.

Subrahmanyan: What this means for the broader field is that we need to reconcile our understanding of feedback processes with observations of galaxy properties, especially concerning star formation rates and black hole growth in low-mass systems. We need to see if these results hold up when compared against other observational constraints.

Conclusion: Vera: So we're wrapping up this piece on core-collapse supernova explosion energies in dwarf galaxies and how those numbers actually shift what we think about galaxy evolution.

Jocelyn: It sounds like they’ve done a lot of heavy lifting here, looking at how the mass of the star's core and its metallicity affect the explosion energy.

Subrahmanyan: Yeah, they introduced this new prescription for how energetic those supernovae are, calling it M25, which is dependent on both the core mass and what's in there—the metallicity.

Vera: And what they found is that when you use this variable energy model in a low-metallicity dwarf galaxy simulation, the average supernova energy per star formation rate comes out to about zero point three billion ergs.

Jocelyn: That’s a big drop compared to the standard one billion ergs they usually use in these models, so what does that actually do for the galaxy?

Subrahmanyan: It means that this lower average energy per star formation rate results in a higher star formation rate with less time variability and it reduces the outflow rates.

Vera: And those reduced outflow rates lead to lower mass-loading factors, which are basically the ratio of how much gas is being made to how much gas is being blown away.

Jocelyn: So, instead of huge winds blowing all the gas out of the galaxy quickly, you get a more steady inflow and star formation.

Subrahmanyan: Exactly. And in terms of black holes, they found that integrating this full M25 model over a billion years produces two point seven times more stellar mass black holes compared to their original models.

Vera: That’s a significant increase in the total number of black holes we expect to see in these galaxies over time.

Jocelyn: It’s interesting because it also ties into how they model both failed supernovae and the partial fallback of ejecta mass, giving a more complete picture of how those black holes actually form.

Subrahmanyan: And it also points to a potential dearth in the distribution of black hole masses between ten and fifteen solar masses, which aligns with some gravitational wave observations from binary black hole mergers.

Vera: So this work suggests that adjusting the input physics for supernova explosions can really alter our picture of how galaxies build up stars and grow their central black holes.

Jocelyn: It makes you wonder what other types of feedback we should be looking at in these simulations next, or if there are other observational constraints that could confirm these energy reductions.

Natalia Lahén, Kiril Maltsev, Thorsten Naab, Hans-Thomas Janka

Max Planck Institute for Astrophysics · Zentrum für Astronomie der University Heidelberg · Max Planck Institute for Astronomy

astro-ph.GA

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 20 pages, 14 figures, submitted to MNRAS

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) are a critical source of thermal and kinetic energy and chemically enriched material in galaxies The new average-Eexpl that amounts to ∼33% of the 1 B = 1051 erg…

Key concepts

Eexpl
This is the explosion energy for a core-collapse supernova. The new model makes this energy dependent on the mass of the star's core and its metallicity. This allows researchers to better simulate how much energy is released during a supernova based on the specific properties of the star that exploded.
M25 Model
This is a novel prescription linking massive star evolution to CCSN outcomes. It uses final carbon-oxygen core mass and metallicity to determine explosion energies, including scenarios where the supernova fails or ejecta partially falls back onto the remnant core, providing a more realistic range of possibilities.
Mass-loading factor
This measures how much material is ejected from a galaxy compared to its star formation rate. The new model predicts lower mass-loading factors, meaning less gas is blown out into space by supernovae. This suggests that galaxies retain more of their gas for future star formation.
BH Formation via SN Failures
This concept describes how black holes form during a supernova when the explosion does not successfully eject all the material. In this model, if the supernova fails, it can lead directly to the formation of a black hole without needing other mechanisms like direct collapse.

Terminology

Summary

Core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) are a critical source of thermal and kinetic energy and chemically enriched material in galaxies The new average-Eexpl that amounts to ∼33% of the 1 B = 1051 erg traditionally assumed in sub-resolution CCSNmodels results in increased and less bursty star formation, reduced outflows and mass-loading factors, increased star cluster formation efficiency, and enhanced chemical enrichment and metal-recycling in star-forming regions. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The most significant change is instead brought about by the new average-𝐸expl that amounts to ∼33% of the 1 B = 1051 erg traditionally assumed in sub-resolution CCSNmodels. This reduction results in increased and less bursty star formation, reduced outflows and mass-loading factors, increased star cluster formation efficiency, and enhanced chemical enrichment and metal-recycling in star-forming regions.

Modeling Novel Explosion Physics

The authors implement a novel core-mass- and metallicity-dependent prescription for stellar explodability and CCSN explosion energies, Eexpl, in the SPHGal galaxy evolution code. This prescription accounts for black hole (BH) formation via SN failures and via partial fallback of ejecta mass. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Leveraging recent advances in CCSN modelling, we implement a novel core-mass- and metallicity-dependent prescription for stellar explodability and CCSN explosion energies, 𝐸expl, in the SPHGal galaxy evolution code. It accounts for black hole (BH) formation via SN failures and via partial fallback of ejecta mass, and adopts an explosion-progenitor connection calibrated to three-dimensional CCSN simulations, such that 𝐸expl varies between < 0.

They adopt an explosion-progenitor connection calibrated to three-dimensional CCSN simulations, such that Eexpl varies between < 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Leveraging recent advances in CCSN modelling, we implement a novel core-mass- and metallicity-dependent prescription for stellar explodability and CCSN explosion energies, 𝐸expl, in the SPHGal galaxy evolution code. It accounts for black hole (BH) formation via SN failures and via partial fallback of ejecta mass, and adopts an explosion-progenitor connection calibrated to three-dimensional CCSN simulations, such that 𝐸expl varies between < 0.

1–2 B. The M25 model links massive star evolution models to CCSN outcomes using the final carbon-oxygen (CO) core mass, MCO, and a continuous Z-dependence. p. 1
Where the paper says it

As an alternative to looking up the SN outcome from a tabulated set of explosion properties at fixed 𝑍 and 𝑀ZAMS, here we establish a link between massive star evolution models and CCSN outcomes using the final carbon-oxygen (CO) core mass, 𝑀CO, and a continuous 𝑍-dependence. We study the effects of a statistical CCSN model predicting explodability outcomes (failed vs successful SN) and compact remnants (neutron star [NS] vs BH) as a function of a star’s 𝑀CO and 𝑍, introduced in Maltsev et al.

Impact on Galaxy Evolution

The new M25, variable E CCSN prescription results in 2.7 times more stellar mass BHs being produced when integrated over 1 Gyr of star formation. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We ran simulations of isolated low-metallicity galaxies with variations in the input stellar feedback models. With the new explodability prescription nearly three times more BHs form compared to the canonical CCSN-model, but the reduced number of successful CCSNe has minimal impact on galactic star formation owing to the low fraction of failed CCSNe.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We ran simulations of isolated low-metallicity galaxies with variations in the input stellar feedback models. With the new explodability prescription nearly three times more BHs form compared to the canonical CCSN-model, but the reduced number of successful CCSNe has minimal impact on galactic star formation owing to the low fraction of failed CCSNe.

The average CCSN Eexpl obtained with the full M25, variable E model in a low-metallicity dwarf galaxy simulation is 0. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Globally integrated properties of the dwarf galaxies run in isolation for 1 Gyr (see text for explanations). The line colours from darkest to lightest indicate the simulations run with the full M25, variable E explosion model, the M25 explosion model with a fixed 1 B CCSN energy, the Original simulation using the Lahén et al.

p. 7
Where the paper says it

Globally integrated properties of the dwarf galaxies run in isolation for 1 Gyr (see text for explanations). The line colours from darkest to lightest indicate the simulations run with the full M25, variable E explosion model, the M25 explosion model with a fixed 1 B CCSN energy, the Original simulation using the Lahén et al.

p. 7
Where the paper says it

Globally integrated properties of the dwarf galaxies run in isolation for 1 Gyr (see text for explanations). The line colours from darkest to lightest indicate the simulations run with the full M25, variable E explosion model, the M25 explosion model with a fixed 1 B CCSN energy, the Original simulation using the Lahén et al.

33 B, which is 33% of the standard 1 B typically assumed in galaxy evolution models. p. 0
Where the paper says it

These results stand in contrast with outflow-launching and baryon cycle modelling in lower-resolution galaxy simulations in which canonical (i. , 1 B) CCSN feedback is typically assumed to produce galaxy models that match observed scaling relations.

The reduced CCSN energy per SFR results in a higher SFR with less time-variability and reduces the outflow rates, in a similar way as a flat reduction of the fiducial CCSN energy does. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The time-evolution is averaged every 10 Myr (1 Myr snapshot interval). In the top two rows we show the star formation rate (SFR), mass outflow rate (OFR), number of CCSN, CCSN energy production, mass yield from CCSNe and recycling of the CCSN material inside new stars, each reported per Myr.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

The time-evolution is averaged every 10 Myr (1 Myr snapshot interval). In the top two rows we show the star formation rate (SFR), mass outflow rate (OFR), number of CCSN, CCSN energy production, mass yield from CCSNe and recycling of the CCSN material inside new stars, each reported per Myr.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

The time-evolution is averaged every 10 Myr (1 Myr snapshot interval). In the top two rows we show the star formation rate (SFR), mass outflow rate (OFR), number of CCSN, CCSN energy production, mass yield from CCSNe and recycling of the CCSN material inside new stars, each reported per Myr.

Feedback and Outflow Dynamics

The mass-loading factors (as measured at a height of 1 kpc) are of the order of 2 for the 1 B simulations and a factor of 2–5 less for the reduced energy simulations. The new M25, variable E CCSN prescription results in galaxy evolution more akin to the 0. p. 8

Where the paper says it

In the M25, variable E run, the average 𝐸expl = 0. 33 B results in galaxy evolution more akin to the 0.

1 B simulation but with some burstiness in the outflows. p. 8
Where the paper says it

33 B results in galaxy evolution more akin to the 0. 1 B simulation but with some burstiness in the outflows.

The resulting low mass-loading factors – defined as ratios of SFR to OFR – are therefore below unity with the new CCSN feedback model. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We quantify the mass-loading factors in Fig. 5, defined as SFR per outflow rate.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

We quantify the mass-loading factors in Fig. 5, defined as SFR per outflow rate.

Remnant Formation and Chemical Enrichment

The fraction of BHs among the dead massive stars is 2.7 times higher in the M25 models compared to the Original models. p. 9

Where the paper says it

1, the overall fraction of BHs among the dead massive stars is 2. 7 times higher in the M25 models compared to the Original models.

The average CCSN Eexpl obtained with the full M25, variable E model in a low-metallicity dwarf galaxy simulation is 0.33 B. The reduced CCSN energy per SFR results in a higher SFR with less time-variability and reduces the outflow rates, in a similar way as a flat reduction of the fiducial CCSN energy does.

Cluster Properties

The lower Eexpl-runs result in more massive star clusters. The fraction of CCSNe closely associated with their birth clusters is also enhanced in those simulations. p. 8

Where the paper says it

6 agree well with the other simulations in which the CCSN energy is fixed at 1 B. Once the CCSNe set in, the enhanced outflows compensate for the prolonged star formation episodes and no excess metal-recycling occurs.

Conclusion

The new M25, variable E CCSN prescription results in 2.7 times more stellar mass BHs being produced when integrated over 1 Gyr of star formation. The average CCSN Eexpl obtained with the full M25, variable E model in a low-metallicity dwarf galaxy simulation is 0.33 B. The reduced CCSN energy per SFR results in a higher SFR with less time-variability and reduces the outflow rates, in a similar way as a flat reduction of the fiducial CCSN energy does. The resulting low mass-loading factors – defined as ratios of SFR to OFR – are therefore below unity with the new CCSN feedback model. The reduction and delay of the CCSN feedback energy furMNRAS 000, 1–19 (2026>

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 provides a description of the simulation method, including the new CCSN explodability and Eexpl-prescription explored here given in Section 2. p. 1

Where the paper says it

This paper is organized as follows. Section 2 provides a description of the simulation method, including the new CCSN explodability and 𝐸expl-prescription explored here given in Section 2.

4. Section 3 gives results of the impact of CCSN model variation on isolated dwarf galaxy evolution on a timescale of 1 Gyr, comparing star formation rates, CCSN environments and star cluster properties. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Section 2 provides a description of the simulation method, including the new CCSN explodability and 𝐸expl-prescription explored here given in Section 2. Section 3 gives results of the impact of CCSN model variation on isolated dwarf galaxy evolution on a timescale of 1 Gyr, comparing star formation rates, CCSN environments and star cluster properties.

Section 4 discusses these upon the background of observational constraints, and section 5 provides conclusions. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Section 3 gives results of the impact of CCSN model variation on isolated dwarf galaxy evolution on a timescale of 1 Gyr, comparing star formation rates, CCSN environments and star cluster properties. Section 4 discusses these upon the background of observational constraints, and section 5 provides conclusions.

How the training signal is built

The M25 model is constructed as follows: (i) Fitting the explosion energy, E˜expl, predicted by M16 as a function of MCO of the single-star SN progenitor models from Schneider et al. (2021) and Schneider et al. p. 3

Where the paper says it

(2016) (hereafter: M16) with parameter choice as in Schneider et al. (2021), when used to explode the 𝑍 = 𝑍⊙ (Schneider et al.

(2023) at Z⊙ and Z⊙/10. p. 1
Where the paper says it

2026); the successes in explaining the peak-trough distribution of chirp masses (low-mass end) of gravitational wave detected binary BH mergers via failed explosions of massive stars undergoing isolated binary evolution (Schneider et al. 2023); and the inferred negligible natal kick velocity of a BH in a binary with a luminous companion star (Vigna-Gómez et al.

(ii) Introducing the failed SN regimes as in M25, over which E˜expl = 0 B. p. 4
Where the paper says it

(2023) at 𝑍⊙ and 𝑍⊙/10, respectively. (ii) Introducing the failed SN regimes as in M25, over which 𝐸˜ expl = 0 B.

(iii) For the general Z-dependence, interpolating the E˜expl − MCO relation at these two Z grid points according to a log Z-scaling law. p. 4
Where the paper says it

(ii) Introducing the failed SN regimes as in M25, over which 𝐸˜ expl = 0 B. (iii) For the general 𝑍-dependence, interpolating the 𝐸˜ expl − 𝑀CO relation at these two 𝑍 grid points according to a log 𝑍-scaling law.

(iv) Re-calibrating the explosion energy predictions, E˜expl −→ Eexpl (5) for improved agreement with the explosion-progenitor connection as obtained from three-dimensional (3D) CCSN simulations. p. 4
Where the paper says it

(iii) For the general 𝑍-dependence, interpolating the 𝐸˜ expl − 𝑀CO relation at these two 𝑍 grid points according to a log 𝑍-scaling law. (iv) Re-calibrating the explosion energy predictions, 𝐸˜ expl −→ 𝐸expl (5) for improved agreement with the explosion-progenitor connection as obtained from three-dimensional (3D) CCSN simulations.

Where the gains come from

The M25 model provides sphgal with the distribution of explosion energies – ranging from < 0.1 up to 2 B – for successful CCSNe, of failed supernovae outcomes that result in direct-collapse BH formation, and also accounts for BH formation via partial fallback of SN ejecta mass. p. 3

Where the paper says it

For the generalized 𝑍-dependence of the 𝑀CO thresholds demarcating the intermediate-mass failed SN window and high-mass failed SN domain, the authors adopt a parametric log 𝑍-scaling law. We assume that the resulting BH mass, 𝑀BH, is given by the final total mass, 𝑀final, of the non-exploding progenitor star: 𝑀BH = 𝑀final (3) Fallback-BH formation and SN ejecta masses: While SN failure is the dominant BH formation channel, M25 also statistically models BH formation via partial fallback of SN ejecta mass onto the proto-NS in successful CCSN explosions, thereby pushing it beyond the stability limit.

The M25 explodability model is calibrated to the SN outcomes predicted by 3D CCSN simulations. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In our galaxy simulations, since we use the BoOST massive single-star models at variable 𝑍 and no binary evolutionary models, we only use the M25 prescription for hydrogen-rich envelope retaining SN progenitors. M25 is calibrated to the SN outcomes predicted by 2 We neglect the BH forming pulsational PISNe here MNRAS 000, 1–19 (2026)

This model partially addresses the RSG problem by the SN failure of progenitors within the intermediate-mass range, is consistent with the failed SN interpretation of the N6946-BH1 observation. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The ∼ 10 M⊙-dip is indeed observed, and several other CCSN models do not reproduce it under the same model variation conditions in the binary population synthesis setup. Furthermore, M25 partially addresses the RSG problem by the SN failure of progenitors within the intermediate-mass range, is consistent with the failed SN interpretation of the N6946-BH1 observation (Gerke et al.

The M25 results in a prominent dearth in the distribution of BH masses between ∼ 10–∼ 15 M⊙. This predicted BH formation landscape recently received support by gravitational wave observations of binary BH (BBH) mergers with the release of the latest (GWTC-5) data catalog available to date. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(2026) for its recent use in studies of BH demographics in simulated Milky-Way like galaxies). This predicted BH formation landscape recently received support by gravitational wave observations of binary BH (BBH) mergers with the release of the latest (GWTC-5) data catalog available to date (The LIGO Scientific Collaboration et al.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can now predict supernova explosion energies Eexpl for massive stars by using a novel core-mass- and metallicity-dependent prescription based on 3D CCSN simulations, accounting for black hole formation via SN failures and partial fallback of ejecta mass, with Eexpl varying between less than 0.1 to 2 B.

  2. Improved AI can model the impact of progenitor dependence of SN explodability and Eexpl on star-forming galaxies by linking massive star evolution models to CCSN outcomes using the final carbon-oxygen core mass MCO and a continuous metallicity dependence, studying both failed and successful SN outcomes.

  3. Improved AI can perform galaxy evolution simulations using the sphgal code incorporating the M25, variable E model to study dwarf galaxy evolution on a timescale of 1 Gyr, comparing star formation rates, CCSN environments, and star cluster properties against canonical models.

  4. Improved AI can quantify the resulting chemical enrichment by showing how different CCSN energy implementations affect metal recycling in star-forming regions and stellar metallicities over a Gyr timescale.

  5. Improved AI can assess the impact of SN feedback on galactic mass outflow dynamics by calculating mass-loading factors as ratios of SFR to OFR, demonstrating that the new model results in lower and less variable outflow rates compared to canonical implementations.

  6. Improved AI can predict the resulting star cluster properties by showing how reduced CCSN energy leads to more massive star clusters, and how this affects the star cluster formation efficiency (CFE).

  7. Improved AI can analyze the spatial distribution of CCSN explosion sites by mapping ambient hydrogen number densities around explosions in different simulation runs, revealing shifts in density based on CCSN energy and progenitor metallicity.

Abstract

Core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) are a critical source of thermal and kinetic energy and chemically enriched material in galaxies. Leveraging recent advances in CCSN modelling, we implement a novel core-mass- and metallicity-dependent prescription for stellar explodability and CCSN explosion energies, E expl, in the SPHGal galaxy evolution code. It accounts for black hole (BH) formation via SN failures and via partial fallback of ejecta mass, and adopts an explosion-progenitor connection calibrated to three-dimensional CCSN simulations, such that E expl varies between <0.1 - 2, B. We ran simulations of isolated low-metallicity galaxies with variations in the input stellar feedback models. With the new explodability prescription nearly three times more BHs form compared to the canonical CCSN-model, but the reduced number of successful CCSNe has minimal impact on galactic star formation owing to the low fraction of failed CCSNe. While BH formation contributes to removal of matter from the galactic baryon cycle, the latter remains driven by galactic outflows, and most compact remnant mass is stored in white dwarves. The most significant change is instead brought about by the new average- E expl that amounts to about33 % of the 1, B=10 51, erg traditionally assumed in sub-resolution CCSN-models. This reduction results in increased and less bursty star formation, reduced outflows and mass-loading factors, increased star cluster formation efficiency, and enhanced chemical enrichment and metal-recycling in star-forming regions. These results stand in contrast with outflow-launching and baryon cycle modelling in lower-resolution galaxy simulations in which canonical (i.e., 1, B) CCSN feedback is typically assumed to produce galaxy models that match observed scaling relations.

Sources

Related papers