Renormalization-group flow of nucleon-- delta contact interactions with an explicit delta: decoupling and the scale dependence of large- N c relations
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Renormalization-group flow of nucleon-- delta contact interactions with an explicit delta".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Renormalization-group flow of nucleon–∆ contact interactions with an explicit delta: decoupling and the scale dependence of large-Nc relations is studied to determine which large-Nc relations among couplings are invariant under the flow and what controls the scale dependence The Core Study We study the leading-order (LO) contact interactions among nucleons and ∆ isobars under a Wilsonian renormalization-group flow with a sharp momentum cutoff, keeping the ∆ as an explicit coupled channel, and determine which large-Nc relations among the couplings are invariant under the flow The two-channel flow with the ∆∆ threshold inside the cutoff range is solved exactly, and the closed channels decouple with relative corrections of order Λ 2/κ 2∆∆, where κ∆∆ = p 2MΔ(MΔ − MN) is the closed-channel momentum Applying the 1/Nc expansion of the Hartree Hamiltonian to the N–∆ system, we find that a generalized time reversal removes all corrections of relative order 1/Nc, that the LO fixes eleven of the 18 S-wave couplings in terms of seven, and that the exact-SU(4) two-parameter form used in the literature differs from the LO by an operator of relative order 1/N2c with matrix elements of order one in the ∆ channels Symmetry and Invariants The eight spin–isospin flip relations are exact invariants of the flow, because the two sectors of a flip pair contain the same channels and have identical loop integrals, and this remains true when the central part of one-pion exchange is iterated in the S-waves The eigenchannel relations hold only at the scale at which they are imposed Their running is controlled by κ∆∆, which is of order N0c, and by a parameter that the NN data do not fix, so that the 1/Nc expansion does not remove it The large-Nc relations between open and closed channels therefore constrain the potential at one scale Flow Dynamics and Decoupling The flow of the exact LO flow is given by Λ dC/dΛ = C D C, D = diag(µ1/π2, µ2/π2Λ 3/(Λ squared + κ 2∆∆), (10) The solution to this equation involves a constant symmetric matrix K, which is the negative inverse of the threshold amplitude matrix In the decoupled regime Λ << κ∆∆ the running quantities η(Λ) and C¯22(Λ) approach their infrared limits ηK and C¯K, which are exact RG invariants, and they approach them with corrections of relative order Λ 2/κ 2∆∆ The eigenchannel relation (C∆∆ − CNN)/Ctr = √5 therefore holds at the scale at which it is imposed and at no other, and without an assumption on βˆ it cannot be imposed at a definite scale Scale Dependence and Constraints The running of the angle in Eq.
Kai: (35) is governed by the difference between the closed ∆∆ loop and the open NN loop at the NN threshold, ∆B(Λ) ≡ B2(0; Λ) − B1(0; Λ) = µ1Λ - µ2F(Λ)/π2, tan 2θ(Λ) = 2βM12/β(M11 − M22) -
∆B(Λ) − ∆B(ΛH): The running is of order 10◦ to 30◦ in the eigenchannel angle between 770 and 140 MeV The large-Nc counting makes the statement sharper, where a consistent large-Nc counting maximizes the violation of these relations by the flow rather than removing it The flip relation between the (S, I) = (3, 0) and (0, 3) channels of ∆∆ scattering predicts equal scattering lengths at LO, a basis-independent and RG-invariant statement The results of this work are statements about the contact sector The natural test is lattice QCD at heavy pion masses, where the ∆ is stable, with the two ∆∆ scattering lengths and the NN scattering lengths all taken at the same pion mass The flip relation between the (S, I) = (3, 0) and (0, 3) channels of ∆∆ scattering predicts equal scattering lengths at LO, a basis-independent and RG-invariant statement The natural test is lattice QCD at heavy pion masses, where the ∆ is stable, with the two ∆∆ scattering lengths and the NN scattering lengths all taken at the same pion mass Acknowledgments D.F.V.
Mira: gratefully acknowledges the Department of Science and Technology–Science Education Institute (DOST–SEI) for scholarship support and the Khon Kaen Particle Physics and Cosmology Theory Group (KKPaCT) at Khon Kaen University, Thailand, for hosting the Research Enhancement Program (SANDWICH) J.B.M.
Kai: acknowledges the generous financial support from Mindanao State University - Iligan Institute of Technology DS has received funding support from the Fundamental Fund of Khon Kaen University Generative AI tools (Claude, Anthropic, and ChatGPT, OpenAI) were used to assist with the drafting and grammatical correction of the manuscript text and with numerical implementation The authors directed this assistance, verified all scientific content and equations against their own calculations, and take full responsibility for the paper Appendix A Natural units ħ = c = 1 are used, with ħc = 197.327 MeV fm The kinematics is nonrelativistic in every channel i, with reduced mass µi, threshold energy Ei measured from the NN threshold, and orbital angular momentum li The inputs are MN = 938.9 MeV, MΔ = 1232 MeV, δM = MΔ − MN = 293.1 MeV, µNN = MN /2 = 469.5 MeV, µNΔ = MNMΔ/(MN + MΔ) = 532.8 MeV and µ∆∆ = MΔ/2 = 616.0 MeV The NN scattering lengths are as = −23.74 fm and at = 5.42 fm, so that 1/as = −8.31 MeV, 1/at = 36.4 MeV and 1/as − 1/at = −44.7 MeV The physical effective ranges quoted in Sec.
Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper titled "Renormalization-group flow of nucleon-- delta contact interactions with an explicit delta: decoupling and the scale dependence of large-Nc relations". Basically, they're studying how these contact interactions between nucleons and delta isobars change when you let them flow through a renormalization group with a momentum cutoff.
Mira: The main thing they're trying to figure out is which of those large-Nc relations among the couplings stay the same when you let this flow happen, and what controls that scale dependence. It seems like they're looking at how these couplings behave as you change the energy scale of your theory.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it sounds like they are setting up a boundary condition at a high cutoff Lambda H and letting it flow down to a low cutoff Lambda L to see what sticks. That sounds computationally heavy if you're trying to run this on real hardware; where does the overhead land for that?
Kai: Well, the paper says they solve the two-channel flow with the delta delta threshold inside that cutoff range exactly, and that closed channels decouple automatically when you get corrections of order Lambda squared over kappa squared times delta delta, where kappa times delta delta is a specific momentum quantity.
Mira: That decoupling is key because it means we can focus on what's left over after the channels separate. They find that applying the one-Nc expansion to the Hartree Hamiltonian for this nucleon delta system shows that a generalized time reversal removes all corrections of order one over Nc.
Lev: Removing corrections of order one over Nc is good, but what about those relative corrections of order one over Nc squared? The paper mentions that the exact SU four two-parameter form they use in the literature differs from their leading-order expansion by an operator of relative order one over N to the power two with matrix elements that are just size one in the delta channels.
Kai: That's a lot of structure there. It seems like they've fixed eleven out of eighteen S wave couplings in terms of just seven, but they still have these other terms coming from those delta channels, which is what you need to watch when building models.
Mira: And the eight spin isospin flip relations are exact invariants under the flow because both sectors of a flip pair have identical loop integrals and the same channel structure, even when you iterate the central part of one pion exchange in those S waves.
Paper summary: Lev: If those flip relations are exact invariants, that simplifies things, but they also said those eigenchannel relations only hold at the scale where you impose them. The running of that angle is controlled by that kappa times delta delta quantity and some other parameter from the NN data that isn't fixed by anything we know yet.
Kai: That means the large-Nc relations between open and closed channels actually constrain the potential at one specific scale, not all scales. The flow dynamics are described by an equation where Lambda times dC over dLambda equals C times D times C, with D being a diagonal matrix involving those kappa and delta delta terms.
Mira: When you're in the decoupled regime, which is when the cutoff Lambda is much smaller than that kappa times delta delta quantity, the running quantities eta and C bar two two approach their infrared limits which are exact renormalization group invariants.
Lev: So even if we are far down in energy, these things settle to a value that doesn't change anymore, but they get there with corrections of order Lambda squared over kappa squared times delta delta. That's the scale dependence you have to account for when you try to pin down a value.
Kai: The paper also discusses the running of an angle in an equation where it depends on the difference between the closed delta delta loop and the open nucleon nucleon loop at that specific NN threshold. This difference is called delta B of lambda, which is equal to mu one times lambda minus mu two F of lambda over pi over two.
Mira: And from that, tan two theta runs by about ten to thirty degrees in the range between seven hundred seventy MeV and one thousand forty MeV, depending on the specific energy you're looking at. That running is controlled by this difference in the loop integrals.
Lev: That range of ten to thirty degrees is quite large for a physical observable, so it suggests that we need very precise measurements or very careful control over those loop integrals when we try to fix the couplings.
Kai: The large-Nc counting sharpens things up, suggesting that a consistent large-Nc counting actually maximizes the violation of these relations by the flow rather than just removing them entirely.
Paper summary: Mira: So looking at the overall structure, they conclude that for this paper "Renormalization-group flow of nucleon-- delta contact interactions with an explicit delta: decoupling and the scale dependence of large-Nc relations", what they're really saying is that the flip relation between the S equals three zero channel and the zero three channel of delta delta scattering predicts equal scattering lengths at leading order.
Lev: That statement is about a basis independent and renormalization group invariant thing, which is pretty strong if it holds up under these flow conditions. The natural test they suggest is lattice QCD at heavy pion masses where the delta is stable, with all those scattering lengths taken at the same pion mass.
Kai: It sounds like they are trying to establish a fundamental relationship that isn't just dependent on some arbitrary choice of scale or regularization scheme.
Mira: Exactly, and they are focusing on the contact sector here, which means these relations apply to the short-distance interactions between these particles. The natural test is lattice QCD at heavy pion masses where the delta is stable, with the two delta delta scattering lengths and those nucleon nucleon scattering lengths all taken at that same pion mass.
Lev: So what this changes for us listening right now is that when we try to fit models to experimental data, we need to be very careful about which large-Nc relations are actually robust under a flow. It's not just about finding one set of couplings; it's about finding the ones that don't run too much.
Kai: And they point out a limitation, which is that the closed channels only stay invariant in the decoupled regime and get violated by about ten percent between two different cutoffs they tested.
Mira: That ten percent violation is significant because it shows how sensitive these relations are to the specific momentum cutoff you choose when you're not deep enough in that decoupled regime. It tells us where our current constraints might be weakest.
Lev: And they also state that the flip-odd part of this boundary condition exceeds what's implied by leading order couplings by more than an order of magnitude, so a quantitative saturation analysis requires looking at the full one boson exchange potential at energy scales around seven hundred seventy MeV.
Kai: So it's a call for us to move beyond just the leading-order contact terms and really look at those next-to-leading order potentials when we want to get a more complete picture of how these interactions evolve with scale.
Mira: That's what they are doing, connecting the large-Nc structure of the couplings to something measurable, even if it requires pushing into higher order potentials for a full saturation analysis.
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up on this paper about the renormalization group flow of nucleon delta contact interactions with an explicit delta: decoupling and the scale dependence of large n c relations, right?
Mira: Yeah, it’s about finding which large n c relations among couplings stay the same when you let these interactions flow through a momentum cutoff. It looks at how those couplings change with energy scale.
Lev: From my side, I'm interested in what this means for running on real hardware; we need to know if these scale dependencies are manageable or if they make the error fall off too slowly.
Kai: The authors study the leading order contact interactions among nucleons and delta isobars under a Wilsonian renormalization group flow with a sharp momentum cutoff, keeping the delta as an explicit coupled channel.
Mira: They solve that two-channel flow exactly when the delta delta threshold is inside the cutoff range, and they find that closed channels decouple with relative corrections of order lambda squared over kappa squared times delta delta.
Lev: That decoupling is a big deal because it means we can focus on what's left over after those channels separate, which simplifies the math for running simulations.
Kai: Applying the one n c expansion to the Hartree Hamiltonian for this nucleon delta system, they find that a generalized time reversal removes all corrections of order one over n c.
Mira: They also found that eleven out of eighteen s wave couplings are fixed in terms of just seven, with the exact su four two parameter form differing from their leading order by an operator of relative order one over n to the power two.
Lev: That relative correction term is what we need to watch; it means the large n c counting isn't perfectly clean at all levels.
Kai: The eight spin isospin flip relations are exact invariants under the flow because both sectors of a flip pair have identical loop integrals and they remain true even when you iterate the central part of one pion exchange in those s waves.
Mira: Those eigenchannel relations only hold at the scale where they are imposed, and their running is controlled by that kappa times delta delta quantity, which is of order n c times zero c.
Lev: So those large n c relations between open and closed channels actually constrain the potential at one specific scale, not all scales simultaneously.
Kai: The natural test they suggest is lattice quantum chromodynamics at heavy pion masses where the delta is stable, with the two delta delta scattering lengths and those nucleon nucleon scattering lengths all taken at that same pion mass.
Mira: That setup tests a statement about equal scattering lengths for s equals three zero and zero three channels of delta delta scattering, which they claim is basis independent and renormalization group invariant.
Lev: If it holds up there, it’s a solid prediction that doesn't depend on the specific model we use to describe the interaction at low energy.
Kai: The next step is checking if those constraints hold when we move away from leading order and look at higher order potentials for a full saturation analysis.
Dominador F. Vaso, Jr., Daris Samart, Jingle B. Magallanes
Department of Physics, Mindanao State University - Iligan Institute of Technology · Khon Kaen Particle Physics and Cosmology Theory Group (KKPaCT), Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, Khon Kaen University · Mindanao State University - Iligan Institute of Technology
hep-ph, nucl-th
Submitted: 2026-11-10
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 23 pages, 5 figures, 5 tables
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 65/100
The gist: Renormalization-group flow of nucleon–∆ contact interactions with an explicit delta: decoupling and the scale dependence of large-Nc relations is studied to determine which large-Nc relations…
Key concepts
- Renormalization-group flow
- This is a mathematical procedure used to see how physical parameters (like coupling strengths) change as you look at physics at different energy scales. In this study, it tracks how the nucleon-delta interactions evolve as the momentum cutoff changes.
- Large-$N_c$ relations
- These are relationships between different coupling constants that become exact when the number of colors ($N_c$) in quantum chromodynamics is very large. The paper checks which of these relations remain true (invariant) or how they change as the energy scale flows.
- Decoupling regime
- This describes a specific physical situation where certain channels, like the $\Delta\Delta$ channel, effectively separate from the main interaction at low energies. In this regime, the flow equations simplify significantly, and some relations become exact invariants.
Terminology
Summary
Renormalization-group flow of nucleon–∆ contact interactions with an explicit delta: decoupling and the scale dependence of large-Nc relations is studied to determine which large-Nc relations among couplings are invariant under the flow and what controls the scale dependence
The Core Study
We study the leading-order (LO) contact interactions among nucleons and ∆ isobars under a Wilsonian renormalization-group flow with a sharp momentum cutoff, keeping the ∆ as an explicit coupled channel, and determine which large-Nc relations among the couplings are invariant under the flow The two-channel flow with the ∆∆ threshold inside the cutoff range is solved exactly, and the closed channels decouple with relative corrections of order Λ 2/κ 2∆∆, where κ∆∆ = p 2MΔ(MΔ − MN) is the closed-channel momentum Applying the 1/Nc expansion of the Hartree Hamiltonian to the N–∆ system, we find that a generalized time reversal removes all corrections of relative order 1/Nc, that the LO fixes eleven of the 18 S-wave couplings in terms of seven, and that the exact-SU(4) two-parameter form used in the literature differs from the LO by an operator of relative order 1/N2c with matrix elements of order one in the ∆ channels
Symmetry and Invariants
The eight spin–isospin flip relations are exact invariants of the flow, because the two sectors of a flip pair contain the same channels and have identical loop integrals, and this remains true when the central part of one-pion exchange is iterated in the S-waves The eigenchannel relations hold only at the scale at which they are imposed Their running is controlled by κ∆∆, which is of order N0c, and by a parameter that the NN data do not fix, so that the 1/Nc expansion does not remove it The large-Nc relations between open and closed channels therefore constrain the potential at one scale
Flow Dynamics and Decoupling
The flow of the exact LO flow is given by Λ dC/dΛ = C D C, D = diag(µ1/π2, µ2/π2Λ 3/(Λ squared + κ 2∆∆), (10) The solution to this equation involves a constant symmetric matrix K, which is the negative inverse of the threshold amplitude matrix In the decoupled regime Λ << κ∆∆ the running quantities η(Λ) and C¯22(Λ) approach their infrared limits ηK and C¯K, which are exact RG invariants, and they approach them with corrections of relative order Λ 2/κ 2∆∆ The eigenchannel relation (C∆∆ − CNN)/Ctr = √5 therefore holds at the scale at which it is imposed and at no other, and without an assumption on βˆ it cannot be imposed at a definite scale
Scale Dependence and Constraints
The running of the angle in Eq. (35) is governed by the difference between the closed ∆∆ loop and the open NN loop at the NN threshold, ∆B(Λ) ≡ B2(0; Λ) − B1(0; Λ) = µ1Λ - µ2F(Λ)/π2, tan 2θ(Λ) = 2βM12/β(M11 − M22) - [∆B(Λ) − ∆B(ΛH)] The running is of order 10◦ to 30◦ in the eigenchannel angle between 770 and 140 MeV The large-Nc counting makes the statement sharper, where a consistent large-Nc counting maximizes the violation of these relations by the flow rather than removing it
Conclusion and Outlook
The flip relation between the (S, I) = (3, 0) and (0, 3) channels of ∆∆ scattering predicts equal scattering lengths at LO, a basis-independent and RG-invariant statement The results of this work are statements about the contact sector The natural test is lattice QCD at heavy pion masses, where the ∆ is stable, with the two ∆∆ scattering lengths and the NN scattering lengths all taken at the same pion mass The flip relation between the (S, I) = (3, 0) and (0, 3) channels of ∆∆ scattering predicts equal scattering lengths at LO, a basis-independent and RG-invariant statement The natural test is lattice QCD at heavy pion masses, where the ∆ is stable, with the two ∆∆ scattering lengths and the NN scattering lengths all taken at the same pion mass
Acknowledgments
D.F.V. gratefully acknowledges the Department of Science and Technology–Science Education Institute (DOST–SEI) for scholarship support and the Khon Kaen Particle Physics and Cosmology Theory Group (KKPaCT) at Khon Kaen University, Thailand, for hosting the Research Enhancement Program (SANDWICH) J. p. 0 ,1, 2, ∗ Daris Samart,2, † and Jingle B. Magallanes1, ‡
1Department of Physics, Mindanao State University - Iligan Institute of Technology, Iligan City, 9200, Philippines
2Khon Kaen Particle Physics and Cosmology Theory Group (KKPaCT),
Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, Khon Kaen University, Khon Kaen 40002, Thailand
(Dated: November 11, 2026)
We study the leading-order (LO) contact interactions among nucleons and ∆ isobars under a
Wilsonian renormalization-group flow with a sharp momentum cutoff, keeping the ∆ as an explicit coupled channel, and determine which large-Nc relations among the couplings are invariant under the flow.Where the paper says it
Appendix A
Natural units ħ = c = 1 are used, with ħc = 197.327 MeV fm The kinematics is nonrelativistic in every channel i, with reduced mass µi, threshold energy Ei measured from the NN threshold, and orbital angular momentum li The inputs are MN = 938. p. 1 Throughout this work, we keep the ∆ as an explicit
coupled channel and follow the momentum-independent
contact couplings with the Wilsonian RG flow of a sharp
momentum cutoff. In this mass-dependent scheme the
closed channels decouple automatically as the cutoff
passes below the channel momenta κ∆∆ = 850 MeV
and κN∆ = 559 MeV, with power corrections, and the
two-channel flow with the ∆∆ threshold inside the cutoff
range is solved exactly. INTRODUCTION
Chiral effective field theory (ChEFT) [1, 2] provides a
systematic framework for explaining the nuclear forces,
in which pion exchange gives the long-range part of
the baryon–baryon potential and contact interactions
with low-energy constants (LECs) encode the short-range
part. The ∆(1232) is the lowest excitation of the nucleon,
with the mass splitting δM ≡ M∆ −MN = 293 MeV, and
it is the only baryon besides the nucleon that enters twoflavor nuclear EFT as an explicit degree of freedom. INTRODUCTION
Chiral effective field theory (ChEFT) [1, 2] provides a
systematic framework for explaining the nuclear forces,
in which pion exchange gives the long-range part of
the baryon–baryon potential and contact interactions
with low-energy constants (LECs) encode the short-range
part. The ∆(1232) is the lowest excitation of the nucleon,
with the mass splitting δM ≡ M∆ −MN = 293 MeV, and
it is the only baryon besides the nucleon that enters twoflavor nuclear EFT as an explicit degree of freedom. INTRODUCTION
Chiral effective field theory (ChEFT) [1, 2] provides a
systematic framework for explaining the nuclear forces,
in which pion exchange gives the long-range part of
the baryon–baryon potential and contact interactions
with low-energy constants (LECs) encode the short-range
part. The ∆(1232) is the lowest excitation of the nucleon,
with the mass splitting δM ≡ M∆ −MN = 293 MeV, and
it is the only baryon besides the nucleon that enters twoflavor nuclear EFT as an explicit degree of freedom. INTRODUCTION
Chiral effective field theory (ChEFT) [1, 2] provides a
systematic framework for explaining the nuclear forces,
in which pion exchange gives the long-range part of
the baryon–baryon potential and contact interactions
with low-energy constants (LECs) encode the short-range
part. The ∆(1232) is the lowest excitation of the nucleon,
with the mass splitting δM ≡ M∆ −MN = 293 MeV, and
it is the only baryon besides the nucleon that enters twoflavor nuclear EFT as an explicit degree of freedom. Large-Nc relations between open and closed channels therefore constrain the potential at one scale. The flip relation between the (S, I) = (3, 0) and (0, 3) channels of ∆∆ scattering predicts equal
scattering lengths at LO, which lattice QCD at heavy pion masses can test. INTRODUCTION
Chiral effective field theory (ChEFT) [1, 2] provides a
systematic framework for explaining the nuclear forces,
in which pion exchange gives the long-range part of
the baryon–baryon potential and contact interactions
with low-energy constants (LECs) encode the short-range
part. The ∆(1232) is the lowest excitation of the nucleon,
with the mass splitting δM ≡ M∆ −MN = 293 MeV, and
it is the only baryon besides the nucleon that enters twoflavor nuclear EFT as an explicit degree of freedom. INTRODUCTION
Chiral effective field theory (ChEFT) [1, 2] provides a
systematic framework for explaining the nuclear forces,
in which pion exchange gives the long-range part of
the baryon–baryon potential and contact interactions
with low-energy constants (LECs) encode the short-range
part. The ∆(1232) is the lowest excitation of the nucleon,
with the mass splitting δM ≡ M∆ −MN = 293 MeV, and
it is the only baryon besides the nucleon that enters twoflavor nuclear EFT as an explicit degree of freedom. It is a regulator artifact of the
size of the NLO operator. For this reason a LO cutoff
theory reproduces the physical effective ranges for Λ ≃
90–145 MeV, and the residual cutoff dependence of LO
observables scales as 1/Λ [32]. [7], define the couplings of the
S-wave (S, I) sectors that flow, and enumerate these sectors. III we solve the cutoff flow of the coupled
NN–∆∆ sectors with the threshold inside it and derive
the decoupling of the closed channels. Its inclusion requires the Wilsonian flow with a longrange potential [26–29], in which the S-wave one-pion exchange is perturbative in the 1S0 channel away from the
amplitude pole [30] and the tensor force makes the triplet
channels nonperturbative above a few hundred MeV [31]. The contact flow is therefore exact as a statement about
the contact theory and not yet a statement about nature,
and Sec. INTRODUCTION
Chiral effective field theory (ChEFT) [1, 2] provides a
systematic framework for explaining the nuclear forces,
in which pion exchange gives the long-range part of
the baryon–baryon potential and contact interactions
with low-energy constants (LECs) encode the short-range
part. The ∆(1232) is the lowest excitation of the nucleon,
with the mass splitting δM ≡ M∆ −MN = 293 MeV, and
it is the only baryon besides the nucleon that enters twoflavor nuclear EFT as an explicit degree of freedom. Throughout this work, we keep the ∆ as an explicit
coupled channel and follow the momentum-independent
contact couplings with the Wilsonian RG flow of a sharp
momentum cutoff. In this mass-dependent scheme the
closed channels decouple automatically as the cutoff
passes below the channel momenta κ∆∆ = 850 MeV
and κN∆ = 559 MeV, with power corrections, and the
two-channel flow with the ∆∆ threshold inside the cutoff
range is solved exactly. (A2) with a sharp cutoff (App. B),
B2(E; Λ) = −
µ2
π
2
h
Λ−κ arctan
Λ
κ
i
, κ =
p
2µ2(2δM − E),
(8)
with κ(0) = κ∆∆.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix B
With k squared = 2µ(E − Ei) and a sharp cutoff, the loop integral of a channel with orbital angular momentum l and separable form factor q l is B(l)(E; Λ) = µ/π2 Z Λ 0 dq/(q 2+2lk squared − q squared + iε For l = 0 and k squared > 0, k < Λ, the principal value of R Λ 0 dq/(k squared − q 2) is 1/2k ln Λ+kΛ−k and the delta function gives-iπ/(2k), which yields Eq. (5) For k squared = −κ squared < 0, R Λ 0 dq/(κ squared + q 2) = 1/κ arctan Λκ, which yields Eq. p. 4 (A2) with a sharp cutoff (App. B),
B2(E; Λ) = −
µ2
π
2
h
Λ−κ arctan
Λ
κ
i
, κ =
p
2µ2(2δM − E),
(8)
with κ(0) = κ∆∆.Where the paper says it
Appendix C
With the rescaling Vˆ = (Λ/π2)M M 1/2V M 1/2 with M = diag(µi), together with ˆki = ki/Λ and κˆi = κi(0)/Λ, Λ∂ΛV= V D V with D diagonal, Dii = 1/(1−ˆk 2m Vˆmj, (C1) since Λ(1+l i+l j)/π2 + 2l m/Λ squared + l i+l j + 2l m = Λ squared
Appendix D
The totally symmetric representation of SU(4) with Nc boxes is realized by Nc bosons in the four single-quark states Ps, t⟩, with the one-body operators X = αβ Xαβa†αaβ for the single-quark matrices σ i/2 ⊗ 1, 1 ⊗ τ a/2 and σ i ⊗ τ a/4 Its dimension is Nc+3 cubed, equal to 20 at Nc = 3
Appendix E
With C-1(ΛH) = α M + βM and K = α M + βM − B(ΛH), the eigen-couplings are 1/v± = α + βλ±, and fixing their ratio rv = v+/v− gives α = cβ with c = (rvλ+ − λ−)/(1 − rv)
Appendix F
The couplings to the ∆ are taken equal to those of the nucleon, which is the SU(6) relation and, for the ω and the vector coupling of the ρ, these mesons couple to baryon-number and isospin currents at LO in 1/Nc The spin-dependent terms of vector exchange arise at order q 2/M 2: the spin–orbit terms i(S i+S j)·(q×k) and, from the magnetic couplings, (1+(κ) 2(S i ×q)·(S j ×q)/(4M 2), with the appropriate spin operators of App. A for each baryon pair
Appendix G
The spin matrices of Ref. [7] are, in the basis of decreasing magnetic quantum number, S 1 = 1/√6 -√3 0 1 0, S 2 = -i/sqrt6 √3 0 1 0, S 3 = diag(3, 1, −1, −3), for the ∆ → N transition
Appendix H
The partial waves are labeled 2S+1LJ with total isospin I Two-baryon spin and isospin states are coupled with Condon–Shortley phases, and the first particle label refers to the first baryon in the channel name For identical baryons (NN, ∆∆) the Pauli principle requires L+S+I odd, and the coupled states NN; S, I⟩ and ∆∆; S, I⟩ with S+I odd are antisymmetric as they stand The NΔ channel carries no Pauli constraint
Appendix I
The isospin matrices τ a, T a† and Θ a are given by the same matrices in isospin space The products satisfy S iS j† = 1/3(2δij −iϵijkσk), S i†S j = 1/3δij − 1/3Σij + iϵijkΣk and Σ iΣj = 5δij + 4Σij + iϵijkΣk, and Σ ij and Σ ijk are symmetric and traceless, which we have verified numerically
Appendix J
The relation among closed channels only are invariant in the decoupled regime and violated at the 10% level between the two cutoffs considered here The eigenchannel relation of the (0, 1) sector, which connects the open NN channel to the closed ∆∆ channel, runs by an amount controlled by κ∆∆ and by βˆ, which is of order one at the physical point and grows with Nc in the Hartree counting
Appendix K
The size of the flip-odd term relative to a natural ∆∆ coupling, 1/a(3,0) = 0, is 6 δNN (ΛH) C(3,0)∆∆∆∆(ΛH) = −0.76, −0.38, −0.19 (46) at ΛH = 770, 1500 and 300 MeV
Appendix L
The natural test is lattice QCD at heavy pion masses, where the ∆ is stable, with the two ∆∆ scattering lengths and the NN scattering lengths all taken at the same pion mass The flip relation between the (S, I) = (3, 0) and (0, 3) channels of ∆∆ scattering predicts equal scattering lengths at LO, a basis-independent and RG-invariant statement
Appendix M
The flip relations are the large-Nc statements that the flow transmits exactly, because the two sectors of a flip pair have identical loops, also when the central part of onepion exchange is iterated in the S-waves They are the large-Nc input for the ∆ channels that can be imposed at any scale The eigenchannel relations of the NN–∆∆ sectors hold only at the scale at which they are imposed
Appendix N
The closed channels only are invariant in the decoupled regime and violated at the 10% level between the two cutoffs considered here
Appendix O
The flip-odd part of this boundary condition exceeds the one implied by the LO couplings by more than an order of magnitude A quantitative saturation analysis of the ∆ channels requires the full one-boson-exchange potential at q ΛH The flip relation between the (S, I) = (3, 0) and (0, 3) channels of ∆∆ scattering predicts equal scattering lengths at LO, a basis-independent and RG-invariant statement
Appendix P
The size of the flip-odd term relative to a natural ∆∆ coupling, 1/a(3,0) = 0, is 6 δNN (ΛH) C(3,0)∆∆∆∆(ΛH) = −0.76, −0.38, −0.19 (46) at ΛH = 770, 1500 and 300 MeV
Appendix Q
The minimal scheme of Eq. (28) takes g constant and gives ζ = 6, the sign of ζ is positive whenever g varies slowly between −15/4 and λ− = -3. p. 3 The potentials
of Ref. [7] are defined with the opposite overall sign to
ours, as we infer from their K-matrix relation, in which
a positive potential gives a positive phase shift, and from
the sign of their one-pion-exchange potential (App.Where the paper says it
Appendix R
The sign of Eq.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Ability to analyze renormalization group flow of nucleon–Delta contact interactions with an explicit Delta as a coupled channel, determining which large-Nc relations among couplings are invariant under flow.
-
Capability to solve exactly two-channel flows with the Delta-Delta threshold inside the cutoff range and determine how closed channels decouple with relative corrections of order Lambda squared over kappa squared Delta Delta.
-
Proficiency in applying the 1/Nc expansion of the Hartree Hamiltonian to N–Delta systems to fix eleven of eighteen S-wave couplings in terms of seven, and identifying which eight spin–isospin flip relations are exact invariants under flow.
-
Skill in analyzing the scale dependence of eigenchannel relations between open and closed channels, controlling this running by kappa Delta Delta being of order N zero c and a parameter not fixed by NN data.
-
Capability to determine that large-Nc relations constrain the potential at one scale, rather than the amplitude, which is demonstrated through the comparison with Ref [23, 24].
-
Proficiency in understanding that flip relations C(S,I) = C(I,S) are exact invariants of the flow because
the two sectors of a flip pair contain the same channels and have identical loop integrals.
-
Skill in analyzing the running of eigenchannel relations between cutoffs by examining the difference between the open NN loop and closed Delta Delta loop, controlled by kappa Delta Delta.
-
Ability to interpret that in nature, delta M is of the same size as momenta of low-energy theory and the Kappa Delta Delta lies far above NN threshold, which means large-Nc relations are not scale independent statements.
-
Skill in recognizing that the running of eigenchannel relations persists at large Nc because
with M Delta ∼ Nc and delta M ∼ 1/Nc the momentum kappa Delta Delta is of order N zero c,
and the Hartree counting enhances this by N two c relative to the splitting of eigen-couplings. -
Proficiency in identifying that flip relations are exact invariants at every Nc and every kappa Delta Delta because
the two sectors of a flip pair have identical loops, also when the central part of one-pion exchange is iterated in the S-waves.
-
Capability to analyze how the eigenchannel relation (C Delta Delta minus C NN) over C Tr is governed by kappa Delta Delta and a boundary condition parameter, noting its running as
of order 10 to 30 degrees in the eigenchannel angle between 770 and 140 MeV.
-
Skill in understanding that the closed channel momentum kappa Delta Delta = sqrt(2 M Delta delta M) is of order N zero c, which controls the scale dependence of eigenchannel relations.
-
Capability to evaluate how the running of the angle in Eq (35) is governed by
the difference between the closed Delta Delta loop and the open NN loop at the NN threshold,
denoted as delta B(Lambda). -
Proficiency in recognizing that for beta hat small,
the angle stays close to theta A,
while for beta hat large, it moves toward the channel axes, indicating thatthe eigenchannel relation (C Delta Delta minus C NN)/C Tr = sqrt(5) therefore holds at the scale at which it is imposed and at no other.
-
Skill in recognizing that the absence of a transition coupling in Eq (41) for contact terms generated by rho, omega and scalar exchange is an artifact of q zero truncation, not a physical statement about nature.
Abstract
We study the leading-order (LO) contact interactions among nucleons and Δ isobars under a Wilsonian renormalization-group flow with a sharp momentum cutoff, keeping the Δ as an explicit coupled channel, and determine which large- N c relations among the couplings are invariant under the flow. The two-channel flow with the ΔΔ threshold inside the cutoff range is solved exactly, and the closed channels decouple with relative corrections of order Λ 2/κ ΔΔ squared, where κ ΔΔ= sqrt 2M Δ(M Δ-M N) is the closed-channel momentum. Applying the 1/N c expansion of the Hartree Hamiltonian to the N -- Δ system, we find that a generalized time reversal removes all corrections of relative order 1/N c, that the LO fixes eleven of the 18 S-wave couplings in terms of seven, and that the exact-SU(4) two-parameter form used in the literature differs from the LO by an operator of relative order 1/N c squared with matrix elements of order one in the Δ channels. The eight spin--isospin flip relations are exact invariants of the flow, also when the central part of one-pion exchange is iterated in the S waves. The eigenchannel relations of the NN -- ΔΔ sectors hold only at the scale at which they are imposed. Their running is controlled by κ ΔΔ, which is of order N c 0, and by a parameter that the NN data do not fix, so that the 1/N c expansion does not remove it. Large- N c relations between open and closed channels therefore constrain the potential at one scale. The flip relation between the (S,I)=(3,0) and (0,3) channels of ΔΔ scattering predicts equal scattering lengths at LO, which lattice QCD at heavy pion masses can test.
Sources
- The Two-Nucleon Potential from Chiral Lagrangians
- Nuclear forces with Delta-excitations up to next-to-next-to-leading order I: peripheral nucleon-nucleon waves
- Minimally non-local nucleon-nucleon potentials with chiral two-pion exchange including $\Delta$'s
- Delta isobars and nuclear saturation
- Nucleon-Nucleon Scattering with Coupled Nucleon-Delta Channels in Chiral Effective Field Theory
- The 1/N Expansion for Baryons
- Spin-Flavor Structure of Large N Baryons
- The Spin-Flavor Dependence of Nuclear Forces from Large-N QCD
- The Nucleon-Nucleon Potential in the 1/N_c Expansion
- Large-$N_c$ Relationships Among Two-Derivative Pionless Effective Field Theory Couplings
- Implications of Large-$N_c$ QCD for the NN Interaction
- The role of intermediate $\Delta\Delta$ states in nucleon-nucleon scattering in the large-$N_c$ and unitary limits, and $\Delta\Delta$ and $\Omega\Omega$ scattering
- The $1/N_c$ Operator Analysis of the Combined Octet and Decuplet Baryons Contact Interactions in SU(3) Chiral Effective Field Theory
- Resonance saturation for four-nucleon operators
- A New Expansion for Nucleon-Nucleon Interactions
- Two-Nucleon Systems from Effective Field Theory
- Large-$N_c$ and renormalization group constraints on parity-violating low-energy coefficients for three-derivative operators in pionless effective field theory
- Three-nucleon forces in the 1/Nc expansion
- The Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction and Large N_c QCD
- The large-N(c) nuclear potential puzzle
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses