Resolved Q 1 q - Q 7 gamma interference in B bar to X s gamma at NLO: Hard matching and radiative charm-loop jet function for m c to 0
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Resolved Q 1 q - Q 7 gamma interference in B bar to X s gamma at NLO".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The study investigates next-to-leading-order (NLO) QCD corrections to the subleading-power resolved photon contribution to B¯ → Xsγ arising from the interference of current-current and electromagnetic dipole operators, which is a main source of theoretical uncertainty in Standard Model predictions The objective is to determine all previously unknown perturbative ingredients at NLO in the limit of a vanishing charm-quark mass, mc → 0 Theoretical Framework and Factorization The analysis employs a factorisation theorem in softcollinear effective theory for the kinematic endpoint region, mb − 2Eγ = O(ΛQCD) This framework separates perturbative and non-perturbative dynamics The general factorisation formula is schematically represented as dΓ17(B¯ → Xsγ) dEγ ∼ H∗7γ Z10 du Hq1 (u) Z ∞−∞ dω1 J¯(u, ω1) Z Λ¯−∞ dω J(ω) g17(ω, ω1) The hard functions H7γ and Hq1 (u) combine the Wilson coefficients of the weak effective Hamiltonian with the hard-matching coefficients onto SCET Hard Matching and Renormalization The authors compute the mc-independent one-loop hard-matching coefficients, derive their renormalisation-group equations, and obtain accurate analytic approximations to their solutions by retaining the first two terms in a 1/Nc expansion The matching of the electromagnetic dipole operator Q7γ is matched to the SCET operator O7γ = −emb(ν) 4π2/2 χ¯hc n/¯2
in · ∂Aem⊥,hc: (1 + γ5)hv (2.1) The one-loop renormalisation factor ZO7γ(µ) is determined by summing the contributions from soft and hardcollinear loops, resulting in ZO7γ(µ) = 1 − αsCF/4π 1/ε2 + 1/ε ln µ2/mb2b + 5/2ε!
Kai: + O(α2s) RG Evolution of Hard Functions The evolution of the hard functions is governed by standard anomalous dimensions, and an approximate analytic solution to the non-local evolution equation is obtained using a large-Nc expansion The solution for Hq1 (u; µ) is approximated by an expression involving the leading-colour (LC) and next-to-leading-colour (NLC) coefficients, which agrees with the numerical solution of the full RG equation at the per-mille level Radiative Jet Function Calculation The two-loop radiative charm-loop jet function J¯(u, ω1) is computed analytically in the massless limit, mc → 0, retaining its full dependence on the fraction u of the large photon momentum carried by the charm quark The calculation involves a method-of-regions analysis to extract matrix elements of SCET-2 operators and subsequent integration to obtain J¯(u, ω1) = Eγ2/2π2ω1 + O(ε) Renormalisation Consistency Check The complete one-loop renormalisation kernel is derived from renormalisation-group consistency and verified to reproduce the two-loop pole structure at fixed u, providing a non-trivial cross-check of the analysis The calculation also predicts the corresponding singularities for mc ≠ 0 by convolving it with the LO jet function including its charm-mass dependence The results provide the complete theoretical framework for a renormalisation-group improved treatment of this subleading-power resolved-photon contribution The charm-mass dependence of the two-loop radiative jet function remains the only missing perturbative ingredient for phenomenological applications The analytic results serve as an important benchmark for this calculation A Collection of NLO Results Known in the Literature The hardcollinear jet function J was computed at NLO and NNLO in
12: and subsequently extended to N3 LO in
13: The non-perturbative shape function g17 was investigated in our previous work
4: , where we derived its one-loop anomalous dimension and obtained closed-form analytic solutions to the corresponding renormalisation-group equation A.2 Subleading Shape Function g17 The subleading shape function g17 is defined through the Fourier transform of the forward matrix element between static B¯-meson states The one-loop renormalisation factor Z17 of the “di-light-cone operator” O17 was derived in
4: The Abelian contribution coincides with the renormalisation factor of the leading shape function
11: B Renormalisation factors of WET operators and evanescent contributions The UV-renormalised b → sγ on-shell matrix element is obtained from Q7γ ren = ZMS77 ZMSmb Q7γ bare The renormalisation of the four-quark operators Qq1 and Qq2 requires an extension of the physical operator basis by two evanescent operators at one-loop order in QCD
22: C Details on the two-loop radiative charm-loop jet function The results read fH(u) = CA (−uε2 − 1/ε¯2 ln u¯ u¯ − ln u − (2u − u¯) ln ¯u + 1 + 3u− u2 h(4−3u) ln2 u+ (1 + 3u) ln2 u¯ + 4ln uū i− (3u + 1)h(u − 2) ln u − (1+ u) ln¯u i− π/26(u − 8-4 + Oε)) A.3 Hardcollinear jet function The hardcollinear quark propagator is defined by n/2 n¯ · pJ (p2; µ) = Z d 4 x e−ip·x ⟨0T χhc(0) χhc(x)0⟩ The corresponding hardcollinear jet function J is defined through the discontinuity of the propagator, J(p2; µ) = 1/2iπ Disc hiJ (p2; µ) i A.4 Subleading shape function g17 The subleading shape function g17 is defined through the Fourier transform of the forward matrix element between static B¯-meson states The soft Wilson lines Sn arise from the decoupling of the hardcollinear strange-quark propagator, while Sn¯ originate from the decoupling of the anti-hardcollinear propagators in the quark loop A.5 Hard matching coefficient The hard-matching coefficient H12 (u; µ, ν) defined in (2.14) can be extracted from the b → sqq¯ amplitude with on-shell partons The LO hard matching functions are given by H12 (u; µ, ν) = 12×2 + O(αs), at NLO this amounts to subtracting the O(αs) term of Z10 du′ ZO12 (u′, u; µ) A.6 Radiative charm-loop jet function The relevant linear combination reads J¯(u, ω1; µ) = 2Eγ ω1 + iη h2−(1 − ϵ) ¯j(u, ω1) − 2ϵ ¯j(1 − u, ω1) i The LO result is J¯(0)(u, ω1) = Eγ/2π2ω1 + O(ε) A.7 Strategy of the calculation and LO result In practice, instead of using SCET Feynman rules for the calculation of the time-ordered product, it is simpler to extract J¯(u, ω1) from a method-of-regions
28: analysis of QCD diagrams The LO result is J¯(0)(u, ω1) = 1/2π2 Eγ/ω1 − 2Eγω1u¯µ2/ -ε eγEε Γ(1 + ε) 1 − ε (uu¯) −ε
u + εu¯: = 2u + O(ε) A.8 NLO calculation At NLO, we distinguish two classes of diagrams, with representatives shown in Figs.
Mira: 9 and 10 The anti-hardcollinear jet function J¯(u, ω1; µ) is defined at the amplitude level and can be extracted from the partonic b → sγg decay induced by the four-quark operators Qq1,Qq2 A.9 Renormalisation factor The one-loop renormalisation factor of the radiative charm-loop jet function can thus be determined from ZO7γ, the (1, 1) entry of the matrix ZO12 and the non-Abelian part of Z17 given in (A.10) The result for NLO singularities is Z10 du dv Z ∞−∞ dω′1 Z(1) J¯(u, ω1, v, ω′1; µ) J¯(0) bare(v, ω′1) = −αs4πEγ/2π2ω1(CA2/uε2 + uε2/ -4 ln −2Eγω1µ2/ -3 ln u − 4 ln ¯u + CF uε(3 + 2ln¯u)) + Oε0 A.9 Renormalisation factor The one-loop renormalisation kernel (4.
Title and authors: Mira: Let's look at the title and authors of this paper, "Resolved Q one q - Q seven gamma interference in B bar to X s gamma at NLO: Hard matching and radiative charm-loop jet function for mc to zero" <ref:2611.14318#pg3,radiative charm-loop jet function>. It’s quite technical, but it tells you exactly what they are analyzing >
Kai: It sounds like the core of the work is about that resolved photon contribution in the B decay rate. The authors, Riccardo Bartocci, Philipp Böer, Kevin Brune and Tobias Hurthd from Karlsruhe Institute of Technology and CERN >
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, when you see "hard matching" and "radiative charm-loop jet function," it signals that they are working at the very high precision level where we need to know exactly how those different parts connect in the calculation >
Mira: The authors are focusing on NLO QCD corrections to this interference. They’re using a specific framework called Softcollinear Effective Theory or SCET for the kinematic endpoint region where m b minus two times the photon energy is of order Lambda QCD >
Kai: So, they're applying a factorization theorem that separates what’s perturbative from what’s non-perturbative dynamics in that specific kinematic area >
The paper's summary: Kai: To summarize what this paper says, they are studying the resolved contribution to B to X s gamma decay that comes from the interference between the current-current operator Q q one and the electromagnetic dipole operator Q7gamma > <ref:2611.14318#pg1,the current-current operator Q q 1 and the electromagnetic dipole operator>
Mira: They are using a factorization formula that looks like dGamma times photon energy is proportional to a hard function H7gamma, times another hard function Hq1, times some other functions involving soft momenta and jet functions >
Lev: The key result they want to get at this NLO level is determining all the previously unknown perturbative ingredients when you take the charm quark mass to zero, which is a big simplification for the Standard Model calculations >
Kai: They compute these mc independent one-loop hard-matching coefficients and then derive their renormalization group equations, getting analytic approximations by keeping just the first two terms in a one n c expansion >
The paper's improvements: Mira: One major improvement they are suggesting is the development of an RG improved perturbation theory treatment for this resolved photon contribution, which they say is needed because of the substantial scale ambiguity and charm-mass dependence at their leading order >
Kai: They are using that framework to systematically calculate radiative corrections, and they’ve set up a consistent renormalization group approach for it >
Lev: And what I find interesting is how they use the one loop renormalization kernel to predict the two loop pole structure at fixed u, which they claim is a non-trivial cross check of their factorization framework >
Mira: They also provide a way to develop a consistent framework for finite charm mass calculations by using that one loop kernel to predict the corresponding singularities when you consider charm mass not being zero >
Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up, this paper provides the complete theoretical framework for an RG improved treatment of this subleading power resolved-photon contribution to B to X s gamma >
Mira: The main point is that while they can’t get rid of the charm mass dependence entirely yet, the results give them a benchmark for phenomenological applications >
Lev: For real hardware, what this means is that the charm mass dependence of the two loop radiative charm-loop jet function remains the only missing perturbative ingredient for applying this to actual decay rates >
Kai: The analytic results they get here are serving as an important benchmark for that calculation, and they’ve also extended known results from other literature, like those on the hardcollinear jet function and the shape function g17 >
Mira: So, if we distill it down to what this means for us right now, it gives us a very solid way to handle these power-suppressed contributions in B physics by providing the necessary analytic tools >
Riccardo Bartocci, Philipp Bäoer, Kevin Brune, Tobias Hurthd
Institute for Theoretical Physics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology · Institute for Astroparticle Physics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology · ☓CERN, Theoretical Physics Department · ☓PRISMA+ Cluster of Excellence & Institute of Physics (THEP) & Mainz Institute for Theoretical Physics, Johannes Gutenberg University
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-11-10
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 32 pages, 11 figures. Analytic results for the master integrals provided as an ancillary Mathematica notebook
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: The study investigates next-to-leading-order (NLO) QCD corrections to the subleading-power resolved photon contribution to B¯ → Xsγ arising from the interference of current-current and…
Key concepts
- Factorization Theorem
- This theorem separates the complex dynamics of the B-to-X decay into simpler parts: hard functions (perturbative physics) and shape functions (non-perturbative physics). It allows physicists to calculate the decay rate by combining these components, making it easier to handle high-energy QCD effects.
- Hard Matching Coefficients
- These coefficients describe how the fundamental weak interaction operators are matched onto the specific framework used in this calculation (SCET). The authors computed these at one loop, deriving their renormalization group equations and finding analytic approximations that are accurate when considering the number of colors (Nc).
- Radiative Charm-Loop Jet Function
- This function describes the contribution from a radiative charm quark loop within the decay process. Calculating this at two loops in the massless limit provides a crucial, detailed perturbative ingredient. Its charm-mass dependence is noted as the key missing piece for precise phenomenological predictions.
- Renormalisation Consistency Check
- This involves verifying that the calculated one-loop renormalisation kernel is consistent with higher-order calculations (two-loop pole structure). This serves as a rigorous test of the entire factorization framework and ensures the theoretical results are internally consistent.
Terminology
Summary
The study investigates next-to-leading-order (NLO) QCD corrections to the subleading-power resolved photon contribution to B¯ → Xsγ arising from the interference of current-current and electromagnetic dipole operators, which is a main source of theoretical uncertainty in Standard Model predictions The objective is to determine all previously unknown perturbative ingredients at NLO in the limit of a vanishing charm-quark mass, mc → 0
Theoretical Framework and Factorization
The analysis employs a factorisation theorem in softcollinear effective theory for the kinematic endpoint region, mb − 2Eγ = O(ΛQCD) This framework separates perturbative and non-perturbative dynamics The general factorisation formula is schematically represented as dΓ17(B¯ → Xsγ) dEγ ∼ H∗7γ Z10 du Hq1 (u) Z ∞−∞ dω1 J¯(u, ω1) Z Λ¯−∞ dω J(ω) g17(ω, ω1) The hard functions H7γ and Hq1 (u) combine the Wilson coefficients of the weak effective Hamiltonian with the hard-matching coefficients onto SCET
Hard Matching and Renormalization
The authors compute the mc-independent one-loop hard-matching coefficients, derive their renormalisation-group equations, and obtain accurate analytic approximations to their solutions by retaining the first two terms in a 1/Nc expansion The matching of the electromagnetic dipole operator Q7γ is matched to the SCET operator O7γ = −emb(ν) 4π2/2 χ¯hc n/¯2 [in · ∂Aem⊥,hc](1 + γ5)hv (2.1) The one-loop renormalisation factor ZO7γ(µ) is determined by summing the contributions from soft and hardcollinear loops, resulting in ZO7γ(µ) = 1 − αsCF/4π 1/ε2 + 1/ε ln µ2/mb2b + 5/2ε! p. 3 + O(α2s)
RG Evolution of Hard Functions
The evolution of the hard functions is governed by standard anomalous dimensions, and an approximate analytic solution to the non-local evolution equation is obtained using a large-Nc expansion The solution for Hq1 (u; µ) is approximated by an expression involving the leading-colour (LC) and next-to-leading-colour (NLC) coefficients, which agrees with the numerical solution of the full RG equation at the per-mille level
Radiative Jet Function Calculation
The two-loop radiative charm-loop jet function J¯(u, ω1) is computed analytically in the massless limit, mc → 0, retaining its full dependence on the fraction u of the large photon momentum carried by the charm quark The calculation involves a method-of-regions analysis to extract matrix elements of SCET-2 operators and subsequent integration to obtain J¯(u, ω1) = Eγ2/2π2ω1 + O(ε)
Renormalisation Consistency Check
The complete one-loop renormalisation kernel is derived from renormalisation-group consistency and verified to reproduce the two-loop pole structure at fixed u, providing a non-trivial cross-check of the analysis The calculation also predicts the corresponding singularities for mc ≠ 0 by convolving it with the LO jet function including its charm-mass dependence
Conclusion and Benchmark
The results provide the complete theoretical framework for a renormalisation-group improved treatment of this subleading-power resolved-photon contribution The charm-mass dependence of the two-loop radiative jet function remains the only missing perturbative ingredient for phenomenological applications The analytic results serve as an important benchmark for this calculation
A Collection of NLO Results Known in the Literature
The hardcollinear jet function J was computed at NLO and NNLO in [12] and subsequently extended to N3 LO in [13] The non-perturbative shape function g17 was investigated in our previous work [4], where we derived its one-loop anomalous dimension and obtained closed-form analytic solutions to the corresponding renormalisation-group equation
A.2 Subleading Shape Function g17
The subleading shape function g17 is defined through the Fourier transform of the forward matrix element between static B¯-meson states The one-loop renormalisation factor Z17 of the “di-light-cone operator” O17 was derived in [4] The Abelian contribution coincides with the renormalisation factor of the leading shape function [11]
B Renormalisation factors of WET operators and evanescent contributions
The UV-renormalised b → sγ on-shell matrix element is obtained from Q7γ ren = ZMS77 ZMSmb Q7γ bare The renormalisation of the four-quark operators Qq1 and Qq2 requires an extension of the physical operator basis by two evanescent operators at one-loop order in QCD [22]
C Details on the two-loop radiative charm-loop jet function
The results read fH(u) = CA (−uε2 − 1/ε¯2 ln u¯ u¯ − ln u − (2u − u¯) ln ¯u + 1 + 3u− u2 h(4−3u) ln2 u+ (1 + 3u) ln2 u¯ + 4ln uū i− (3u + 1)h(u − 2) ln u − (1+ u) ln¯u i− π/26(u − 8-4 + Oε))
A.3 Hardcollinear jet function
The hardcollinear quark propagator is defined by n/2 n¯ · pJ (p2; µ) = Z d 4 x e−ip·x ⟨0T χhc(0) χhc(x)0⟩ The corresponding hardcollinear jet function J is defined through the discontinuity of the propagator, J(p2; µ) = 1/2iπ Disc hiJ (p2; µ) i
A.4 Subleading shape function g17
The subleading shape function g17 is defined through the Fourier transform of the forward matrix element between static B¯-meson states The soft Wilson lines Sn arise from the decoupling of the hardcollinear strange-quark propagator, while Sn¯ originate from the decoupling of the anti-hardcollinear propagators in the quark loop
A.5 Hard matching coefficient
The hard-matching coefficient H12 (u; µ, ν) defined in (2.14) can be extracted from the b → sqq¯ amplitude with on-shell partons The LO hard matching functions are given by H12 (u; µ, ν) = 12×2 + O(αs), at NLO this amounts to subtracting the O(αs) term of Z10 du′ ZO12 (u′, u; µ)
A.6 Radiative charm-loop jet function
The relevant linear combination reads J¯(u, ω1; µ) = 2Eγ ω1 + iη h2−(1 − ϵ) ¯j(u, ω1) − 2ϵ ¯j(1 − u, ω1) i The LO result is J¯(0)(u, ω1) = Eγ/2π2ω1 + O(ε)
A.7 Strategy of the calculation and LO result
In practice, instead of using SCET Feynman rules for the calculation of the time-ordered product, it is simpler to extract J¯(u, ω1) from a method-of-regions [28] analysis of QCD diagrams The LO result is J¯(0)(u, ω1) = 1/2π2 Eγ/ω1 − 2Eγω1u¯µ2/ -ε eγEε Γ(1 + ε) 1 − ε (uu¯) −ε [u + εu¯] = 2u + O(ε)
A.8 NLO calculation
At NLO, we distinguish two classes of diagrams, with representatives shown in Figs. 9 and 10 The anti-hardcollinear jet function J¯(u, ω1; µ) is defined at the amplitude level and can be extracted from the partonic b → sγg decay induced by the four-quark operators Qq1,Qq2
A.9 Renormalisation factor
The one-loop renormalisation factor of the radiative charm-loop jet function can thus be determined from ZO7γ, the (1, 1) entry of the matrix ZO12 and the non-Abelian part of Z17 given in (A.10) The result for NLO singularities is Z10 du dv Z ∞−∞ dω′1 Z(1) J¯(u, ω1, v, ω′1; µ) J¯(0) bare(v, ω′1) = −αs4πEγ/2π2ω1(CA2/uε2 + uε2/ -4 ln −2Eγω1µ2/ -3 ln u − 4 ln ¯u + CF uε(3 + 2ln¯u)) + Oε0
The one-loop renormalisation kernel (4.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve predictive capability for B to X s gamma decay rates by incorporating charm-quark mass effects into phenomenological analyses, as
mc enters only the antihardcollinear radiative charm-loop jet function
andmc dependence of the radiative charm-loop jet function remains the only missing perturbative ingredient for a phenomenological analysis within renormalisation-group-improved perturbation theory.
-
Enhance theoretical uncertainty quantification by utilizing the derived one loop renormalisation kernel to predict two loop pole structure at fixed u, which is described as a
non-trivial cross-check of our analysis
andprovides a non-trivial cross-check of the factorisation framework.
-
Enable systematic study of NLO corrections by using the complete set of NLO results derived for all diagrams in Figures 9 and 10, such as fA(u) through fI(u), to provide a comprehensive analytic benchmark.
-
Develop a consistent framework for finite charm mass calculations by using the one loop renormalisation kernel to
predict the corresponding singularities for mc != 0 by convolving it with the LO jet function including its charm-mass dependence and adding the known contribution from charm-mass renormalisation.
Sources
- Resolved $1/m_b$ contributions to $\bar B \to X_{s,d} \ell^+\ell^-$ and $\bar B \to X_s \gamma$
- Reevaluating Uncertainties in $\bar B\to X_s\gamma$ Decay
- Renormalisation group evolution of the shape function $g_{17}$ in $\bar{B}\to X_s \gamma$ and $\bar{B} \to X_s \ell^+\ell^-$ at subleading power
- NLO analysis of the subleading-power $Q_1-Q_{7\gamma}$ interference in $\bar{B}\to X_s\gamma$ at large photon energies
- Factorization at Subleading Power and Irreducible Uncertainties in $\bar B\to X_s\gamma$ Decay
- The Three-loop Quark Jet Function
- QED factorization of non-leptonic $B$ decays
- Light-cone distribution amplitudes of light mesons with QED effects
- NNLO vertex corrections to non-leptonic B decays: Tree amplitudes
- On the gauge-invariance of SCET beyond leading power
- Gauge invariance of radiative jet functions in the position-space formulation of SCET
- New Developments in FeynCalc 9.0
- FeynCalc 9.3: New features and improvements
- FeynCalc 10: Do multiloop integrals dream of computer codes?
- FIRE6: Feynman Integral REduction with Modular Arithmetic
- Presenting LiteRed: a tool for the Loop InTEgrals REDuction
- Multiloop integrals in dimensional regularization made simple
- Algorithmic transformation of multi-loop master integrals to a canonical basis with CANONICA
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses