The chi c1(3872) Multiplet in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model

arXiv:2611.14251 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The chi c1(3872) Multiplet in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper investigates the hidden-charm tetraquark spectrum using an extended diabatic dynamical diquark model to simultaneously reproduce experimental states like χc1(3872), Tcc¯1(3900), and Tcc¯1(4020) because the minimal model is insufficient, necessitating the restoration of spin- and isospin-dependent diquark-antidiquark interactions to align with established states.

Kai: Model Extension and Framework The study extends the original minimal form of the diabatic dynamical diquark model by restoring the spin- and isospin-dependent diquark-antidiquark interactions from the original adiabatic dynamical diquark model into the full diabatic potential to align with these three states.

Mira: Aligning this resulting framework to these three states allows for the prediction of the remaining members of the Σ+g (1S) multiplet through coupled-channel scattering simulations.

Kai: The model incorporates heavy-quark spin symmetry (HQSS) by imposing it upon the D(∗)D¯(∗) coupling, where HQSS breaking is taken only through the D-D∗ mass difference.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "The chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) Multiplet in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model," and what it’s trying to do is explain those three specific states: the chi c one eight seven two two, the Tcc bar one nine zero zero, and the Tcc bar one four zero two <ref:2611.14251#pg1,3872) Multiplet in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model>.

Mira: Exactly. The core idea here is that a simpler model just doesn't have enough ingredients to get all three of those experimental states right at once, so they’re taking a minimal model and extending it.

Lev: What that extension means in practice is they are going back and putting the spin- and isospin-dependent diquark-antidiquark interactions from an older model—the adiabatic dynamical diquark model—into the full diabatic potential.

Kai: So they're taking those interactions, which deal with how the light degrees of freedom interact with each other, and mixing them into the picture where you also have open dimeson channels coming in.

Mira: That mixing is what allows them to align this extended framework with those three specific experimental states, and because it does that, they can then predict what else should be there in the sum of all these states.

Lev: And they use coupled-channel scattering simulations on top of that, which is how you figure out the remaining members of that sigma plus g one s multiplet.

Kai: It seems like the paper is saying that by adding this spin and isospin dependence, they can finally get a consistent picture for the hidden charm sector.

Mira: And what's interesting from my side, it’s how they handle heavy quark spin symmetry. They impose that on the D star D bar coupling and only break it through the mass difference between a D meson and a D star meson.

Lev: That makes sense for a computational model; you want to keep the complexity manageable while still respecting those fundamental symmetries where possible, right?

Kai: Right, but they still have to deal with how the diabatic potential is built, which involves letting the delta bar delta pair mix with dimeson states like M one M bar two.

Paper summary: Mira: They define this diabatic potential matrix V j i as the interaction between the light degrees of freedom and the Hamiltonian H equals K heavy plus H light. Off-diagonal elements in that matrix are these mixing potentials between the pure diquark antidiquark state and pure dimeson states, modeled with a Gaussian form.

Lev: A Gaussian form is a common way to model those interactions when you're looking at potential energy surfaces; it keeps things mathematically tractable for solving the equations.

Kai: Then they combine that with the adiabatic fine structure corrections for the delta bar delta component into this diabatic framework, comparing what they get with their new method against what the pure adiabatic model predicts for that sigma plus g one s multiplet.

Mira: The original adiabatic model figured out how internal spin-dependent fine structure works through interactions between the delta and anti-delta quasiparticles, but here, the diabatic model shows how those delta bar delta configurations get modified and coupled to that open dimeson continuum.

Lev: So it’s a comparison between two ways of looking at the same physics; one focusing on internal spin structure directly, and the other focusing on how those configurations couple to external channels.

Kai: When they run the numerical search, they look for a common set of parameters by sampling over ranges for theta, delta, rho, and m delta.

Mira: They found a representative best candidate that predicts masses of three point nine eight one five gigaelectron volts for the chi c one eight seven two two, three point nine eight zero five gigaelectron volts for the tcc bar one nine zero zero, and four point zero two five zero gigaelectron volts for the tcc bar one four zero two <ref:2611.14251#pg3>.

Lev: Those predicted masses are right near where we expect those experimental states to be, which gives us some confidence in this parameter set.

Kai: The analysis shows that the intrinsic spin and isospin couplings of that fundamental delta bar delta pair are absolutely essential for getting the correct mass eigenvalues for all three states.

Mira: That’s a big statement because it means those internal interactions are driving the result more than just the external coupling to dimeson channels alone, which is what we saw in previous work.

Lev: It suggests that if you only looked at pure diabatic corrections, you wouldn't get this level of accuracy without explicitly including those spin-dependent terms.

Paper summary: Kai: So, the main point here is that the intrinsic spin and isospin couplings are key to reproducing the experimental mass eigenvalues for this hidden charm system.

Mira: And when you compare their results to the pure adiabatic model, they find that all calculated resonance locations lie within approximately ten mega electron volts of their corresponding pure adiabatic mass eigenvalue predictions in all cases.

Lev: Ten mega electron volts is a relatively tight margin, especially when you're dealing with these complex tetraquark systems; it suggests the basic pattern from the adiabatic Hamiltonian is holding up well.

Kai: It means much of that sigma plus g one s spectrum is established by those spin and isospin interactions, and these new couplings don't totally ruin the structure.

Mira: The resulting states might actually be characterized by their heavy quark spin state content, with mixed states being strongly dominated by a single scc bar spin configuration.

Lev: That’s a good characterization because it gives you a way to interpret the complex mixing you see in the coupled-channel results.

Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on "The chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) Multiplet in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model," it successfully describes that multiplet by adding spin and isospin dependence back into a diabatic framework <ref:2611.14251#pg1,3872) Multiplet in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model>.

Mira: They reproduce the three known states perfectly and predict the rest of the sigma plus g one s multiplet through coupled-channel simulations, which is what matters for testing the model's predictive power.

Lev: The paper also points out that since their calibration masses don't uniquely pin down one set of diabatic parameters, there are other regions in parameter space that might give different predictions for the unobserved members.

Kai: So it’s a call to action for future work; they need more measurements of masses and decay modes to really constrain those remaining parameters and see where else the model can go.

Mira: Ultimately, the paper shows how you can incorporate fine structure corrections into a diabatic framework while keeping the established description of the experimentally confirmed states intact.

Lev: It’s a solid way to build on older work without throwing out everything already understood about how these heavy quark systems behave.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve been looking at how they built this extended diabatic dynamical diquark model to get those three specific hidden charm states right, like chi c one eight seven two two, and the Tcc bar one nine zero zero, and the Tcc bar one four zero two.

Mira: Yeah, looking at the title of this paper ‘The chi c1(three thousand eight hundred seventy-two) Multiplet in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model’, it’s clear they’re tackling a problem where a simpler model just doesn't have enough pieces to fit everything.

Lev: What that means for us is they took that minimal setup and added back the spin and isospin dependence from an older model, making it diabatic, which lets the different configurations mix with open dimeson states.

Kai: And what they found is that those intrinsic spin couplings of the fundamental delta bar delta pair are absolutely essential for getting those correct mass eigenvalues.

Mira: That’s a big piece of information because it tells us that even when you introduce these external mixing channels, the internal spin structure of the diquark pair is what really sets the mass hierarchy.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, that suggests we can’t just ignore those internal spin interactions; they have to be there in your Hamiltonian setup if you want good results.

Kai: And when you look at the results, they found that all their calculated resonance locations fall within about ten mega electron volts of the pure adiabatic model's mass predictions.

Mira: Ten mega electron volts is a tight margin for these complex tetraquark systems, which suggests that most of what we’re seeing in this sigma plus g one s multiplet is set by those spin and isospin interactions alone.

Lev: So, much of the structure we see might be established by those basic adiabatic interactions before you even factor in the more complex couplings to dimeson channels.

Kai: The paper also points out that the way they fit those parameters doesn't give you one single set of numbers; there are other regions where they could get different predictions for those states we haven’t seen yet.

Mira: That means we still need more data, like better mass measurements and decay modes, to really narrow down where this model sits in the parameter space.

Lev: Exactly, because right now, if you only have these three calibration masses, you can't fully constrain the entire picture of what’s possible here.

Kai: It shows that we can incorporate those fine structure corrections into a diabatic framework while still keeping the established description of the known states intact.

Mira: So this paper gives us a solid way to build on older work, showing how you can integrate internal spin physics with external channel couplings without losing what we already know about these systems.

Richard F. Lebed, Ethan H. Pham

Department of Physics, Arizona State University

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 14 pages, 1 figure

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 85/100

The gist: The paper investigates the hidden-charm tetraquark spectrum using an extended diabatic dynamical diquark model to simultaneously reproduce experimental states like χc1(3872), Tcc¯1(3900)…

Key concepts

Extended Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model
This model goes beyond a simple version by allowing different configurations of constituents, like the $\delta\bar{\delta}$ pair mixing with dimeson states. It uses a potential matrix to describe these interactions, moving from a purely adiabatic view to one that accounts for mixing effects.
Heavy-Quark Spin Symmetry (HQSS)
This principle assumes that the heavy quarks behave as if they have no spin when interacting strongly. The model enforces this symmetry in the $\text{D}(^*)\text{D}^\bar{*}$ coupling, only allowing for symmetry breaking through the mass difference between D and D* states.
Diabatic Potential Construction
This involves defining a potential matrix that describes interactions between different internal configurations of the system. Off-diagonal elements model how pure diquarkantidiquark ($\delta\bar{\delta}$) states mix with dimeson states ($M1M^\bar{2}$), often using a Gaussian form.
Adiabatic Fine Structure
This refers to corrections within the original adiabatic model that account for spin-dependent interactions between the $\delta$ and $\bar{\delta}$ quasiparticles. The diabatic framework incorporates these corrections to better describe how the $\delta\bar{\delta}$ configurations are modified by coupling to open channels.

Terminology

Summary

The paper investigates the hidden-charm tetraquark spectrum using an extended diabatic dynamical diquark model to simultaneously reproduce experimental states like χc1(3872), Tcc¯1(3900), and Tcc¯1(4020) because the minimal model is insufficient, necessitating the restoration of spin- and isospin-dependent diquark-antidiquark interactions to align with established states. p. 0

Model Extension and Framework

The study extends the original minimal form of the diabatic dynamical diquark model by restoring the spin- and isospin-dependent diquark-antidiquark interactions from the original adiabatic dynamical diquark model into the full diabatic potential to align with these three states. Aligning this resulting framework to these three states allows for the prediction of the remaining members of the Σ+g (1S) multiplet through coupled-channel scattering simulations. p. 0 The model incorporates heavy-quark spin symmetry (HQSS) by imposing it upon the D(∗)D¯(∗) coupling, where HQSS breaking is taken only through the D-D∗ mass difference. p. 1

Diabatic Potential Construction

The diabatic dynamical diquark model extends the Born-Oppenheimer (BO) approach to allow interactions between different configurations of the constituents in a state, specifically allowing the δ¯δ pair to mix with dimeson states M1M¯2 ≡ (Qq¯′)(Qq¯). The diabatic potential matrix Vji(r, r0) is defined as the interaction between light degrees of freedom and the Hamiltonian H = Kheavy + Hlight. p. 2 Off-diagonal elements consist of mixing potentials between the pure diquarkantidiquark (δ¯δ) and pure dimeson (M1M¯2) states, modeled using a Gaussian form. p. 2

Incorporation of Adiabatic Fine Structure

The paper combines the adiabatic fine structure corrections for the δ¯δ component into the diabatic framework, comparing the predicted Σ+g (1S) spectrum with that of the pure adiabatic model. The original adiabatic model determines internal spin-dependent fine structure through interactions between δ and ¯δ quasiparticles. p. 5 The diabatic model, however, determines how the δ¯δ configurations are modified by and couple to the open dimeson continuum. p. 5

Numerical Results and Constraints

The search for a common set of parameters was performed via Latin hypercube sampling over the ranges of θ ∈ [0, π/2] rad, ∆ ∈ [0.01, 1.5] GeV, ρ ∈ [0. p. 201, 1.5] fm, and mδ ∈ [1. p. 28, 2.1] GeV. A representative best candidate yielded predicted masses of 3. p. 49815 GeV, 3. p. 49805 GeV, and 4. p. 40250 GeV for χc1(3872), Tcc¯1(3900), and Tcc¯1(4020). p. 4 The analysis shows that the intrinsic spin (and isospin) couplings of the fundamental δ¯δ pair are absolutely essential for reproducing the correct experimental mass eigenvalues. p. 4

Conclusion and Implications

The comparison between the pure adiabatic model and the diabatic construction shows that all calculated resonance locations lie within approximately 10 MeV of their corresponding pure-adiabatic mass eigenvalues. This suggests that much of the Σ+g (1S) mass spectrum is established by the adiabatic (iso)spin interactions and survives the introduction of explicit couplings to dimeson channels. p. 0 The resulting states may be characterized by their heavy-quark-spin state content, with mixed states being strongly dominated by a single scc¯ spin configuration. p. 9

Summary of Findings

The HQSS-constrained diabatic dynamical diquark model successfully describes the hidden-charm ground-state Σ+g (1S) multiplet by incorporating adiabatic fine structure corrections into the compact δ¯δ channel. The three experimentally identified states are reproduced by construction, and the remaining results constitute predictions of the model. p. 9 The similarity between the fitted spin-dependent parameters and those from a pure adiabatic analysis suggests that much of the Σ+g (1S) mass spectrum is established by these interactions. p. 1

Future Directions

The paper notes that the three calibration masses do not uniquely determine the underlying diabatic parameter set, suggesting alternate regions of parameter space may lead to different predictions for unobserved members. Additional measurements of masses, quantum numbers, decay modes, and resonance line shapes would provide crucial constraints on the remaining parameter space. p. 3 The construction demonstrates that the fine structure of the adiabatic dynamical diquark model can be incorporated into the spin-dependent diabatic framework while maintaining the established description of experimentally confirmed states. p. 0

Key Comparisons

The common terms M0 and ∆M0 have radically different interpretations, where M0 sets the common multiplet mass in the pure adiabatic model, whereas ∆M0 enters the present construction as a common shift to the δ¯δ channel potential compared to the D(∗)spinaveraged mass m0. The numerical similarity of κqQ and V0 between the two fits suggests that rather than pure diabatic corrections, the intrinsic spin-dependent interactions of the δ¯δ pair determine most of the mass hierarchy. p. 9 The resulting spectra preserve the mass ordering obtained from the pure adiabatic Hamiltonian. p. 9

State Characterization

The mixed 0++ and 1+− states were each found to be strongly dominated by a single heavy-quark spin configuration, providing an approximate heavy-spin-eigenstate characterization of the resulting states. The lowest mass eigenvalues obtained from the corrected diabatic calculation lie no more than 10 MeV from the corresponding pure adiabatic mass eigenvalues. p. 0 The state-by-state comparison shows that the lowest mass eigenvalues obtained from the corrected diabatic calculation lie no more than 10 MeV from the corresponding pure adiabatic mass eigenvalues. p. 0

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform simultaneous fitting of diabatic parameters theta, Delta, rho, and m delta against three experimental masses by minimizing total absolute error across all three systems. This allows for a rigorous determination of the minimal spin-independent Hamiltonian parameters required to reproduce the spectrum from known states.

  2. The improved system can calculate resonance structures for the full Sigma plus g (1S) multiplet by identifying decay modes and constructing scattering amplitudes for dimeson channels in a model where "the correction C -> Cn to the delta bar delta channel for the nth state is then varied until the resonant peak in this channel coincides with the experimental mass of the corresponding state."

  3. The system can determine a set of adiabatic parameters Delta M0, kappa qQ, and V0 by solving a system of linear equations derived from comparing diabatic corrections to known masses: The resulting system of equations is: (C3872 C3900 C4020) = (1-1-3 1 - cos (2theta) -1 − 2 sin (2theta) 1 + cos (2theta) −1 + 2 sin (2theta)) ((Delta M0 kappa qQ V0)).

Sources

Related papers