Nucleon sigma terms in lattice QCD at physical pion mass and in the continuum

arXiv:2611.14103 · hep-lat, hep-ex, hep-ph, nucl-th · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Lattice. The day in lattice field theory: what the simulations put on the table.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Nucleon sigma terms in lattice QCD at physical pion mass and in the continuum".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Nucleon sigma terms in lattice QCD at physical pion mass and in the continuum determines the light, strange and charm σ-terms of the nucleon using four Nf = 2+1+1 twisted-mass gauge ensembles simulated at physical pion masses and with approximately the same spatial volumes.

Kai: The global fits to all ensembles yield σπN = 53.0(7.4)(1.6) MeV, σs = 58.2(17.0)(2.1) MeV and σc = 112(28)(25) MeV.

Mira: Determination of Sigma Terms The sigma terms are defined as σq = mq⟨Nqq¯ N⟩ = mq ∂mN /∂mq, which measure how sensitive the nucleon mass is to the quark mass mq of each quark flavor q.

Kai: The light-quark sigma term is given by σπN = ml⟨N(⃗p, s)uu¯ + ¯ddN(⃗p, s)⟩, with ml = (mu + md)/2.

Paper summary: Kai: Okay, to recap, this paper, "Nucleon sigma terms in lattice QCD at physical pion mass and in the continuum," is about calculating how sensitive the nucleon mass is to quark masses.

Mira: Specifically, they are looking for three sigma terms: light quark sigma pi N, strange quark sigma s, and charm quark sigma c.

Lev: The core idea here is using four twisted-mass gauge ensembles that simulate two up and down quarks, a strange quark, and a charm quark with physical pion masses.

Kai: And they use these ensembles to get the results in the continuum limit by fitting parameters like the sigma term itself and an energy gap.

Mira: The main claim is that they can determine these three sigma terms with statistical and systematic uncertainties for all three sectors.

Kai: It’s crucial to note that their results come from a global fit across all ensembles, which allows for a more stringent continuum extrapolation by including a linear dependence on the squared lattice spacing in the parameters.

Mira: This global fit also tests whether their method of accounting for multiparticle contributions is robust without imposing extra constraints.

Lev: So, in short, they are providing concrete numbers for sigma pi N equals fifty-three point zero sigma s equals fifty-eight point two and sigma c equals eleven two <ref:2611.14103#pg1>.

Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about the title of this paper and the authors—Christos Iona, Giannis Koutsou, Yan Li, Srijit Paul, and Ferenc Pittler—what's the bigger picture here?

Mira: The implication is that we have a better handle on how quark masses affect the nucleon structure when we use physical pion mass simulations.

Lev: For experimentalists at the LHC or other particle physics experiments, these sigma terms give them parameters to constrain dark matter interactions and predictions for muon to electron conversion in nuclei.

Kai: They are providing concrete values that feed directly into those searches for new physics because they help calculate things like the Higgs nucleon coupling.

Mira: So, by getting these specific numbers for the light, strange, and charm sigma terms, this paper gives researchers valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics.

Lev: The method itself is solid because it handles excited state contamination reasonably well and uses a global fit to get to the continuum limit in one step by including a linear dependence on the squared lattice spacing in the parameters.

Constantia Alexandrou, Christos Iona, Giannis Koutsou, Yan Li, Srijit Paul, *Ferenc Pittler

University of Cyprus · Computation-based Science and Technology Research Center, The Cyprus Institute

hep-lat, hep-ex, hep-ph, nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 92/100

The gist: Nucleon sigma terms in lattice QCD at physical pion mass and in the continuum determines the light, strange and charm σ-terms of the nucleon using four Nf = 2+1+1 twisted-mass gauge ensembles…

Key concepts

Sigma Terms ($\sigma_q$)
These terms measure how sensitive the nucleon mass is to changes in the mass of a specific quark flavor ($m_q$). They quantify how much the nucleon's mass 'responds' to that quark's mass, providing crucial information about the internal structure of nucleons.
Lattice QCD Simulation
This involves simulating Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the theory of strong interactions, on a discrete spacetime grid (lattice). The simulations used four ensembles with $N_f = 2+1+1$ quarks, allowing for light, strange, and charm quarks at physical pion masses.
Continuum Limit Extrapolation
Since lattice calculations are done on a finite grid (discretization), results must be extrapolated to the true continuum limit (infinite lattice spacing $a \to 0$). This paper used two methods—two-step fitting and a global fit including an explicit linear term in $a^2$—to achieve this extrapolation.
Phenomenological Relevance
The calculated sigma terms are vital for connecting nuclear physics experiments (like those at LZ or XENONnT) to fundamental particle physics, such as constraints on dark-matter couplings and predictions for Higgs-mediated processes in nuclei.

Terminology

Summary

Nucleon sigma terms in lattice QCD at physical pion mass and in the continuum determines the light, strange and charm σ-terms of the nucleon using four Nf = 2+1+1 twisted-mass gauge ensembles simulated at physical pion masses and with approximately the same spatial volumes. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Box 20537, 1678 Nicosia, Cyprus 2Computation-based Science and Technology Research Center, The Cyprus Institute, 20 Kavafi Str. , Nicosia 2121, Cyprus We determine the light, strange and charm σ-terms of the nucleon in lattice QCD using four Nf = 2+1+1 twisted-mass gauge ensembles simulated at physical pion masses and with approximately the same spatial volumes.

The global fits to all ensembles yield σπN = 53. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Both valence and sea quark contributions are analysed accounting for excited-state contamination from low-lying multihadron states. We perform global fits to all ensembles, that yield σπN = 53.

0(7.4)(1.6) MeV, σs = 58. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We perform global fits to all ensembles, that yield σπN = 53. 6) MeV, σs = 58.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We perform global fits to all ensembles, that yield σπN = 53. 6) MeV, σs = 58.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We perform global fits to all ensembles, that yield σπN = 53. 6) MeV, σs = 58.

2(17.0)(2.1) MeV and σc = 112(28)(25) MeV. p. 0
Where the paper says it

6) MeV, σs = 58. 1) MeV and σc = 112(28)(25) MeV, with statistical and systematic uncertainties, respectively.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

6) MeV, σs = 58. 1) MeV and σc = 112(28)(25) MeV, with statistical and systematic uncertainties, respectively.

Determination of Sigma Terms

The sigma terms are defined as σq = mq⟨Nqq¯ N⟩ = mq ∂mN /∂mq, which measure how sensitive the nucleon mass is to the quark mass mq of each quark flavor q. The light-quark sigma term is given by σπN = ml⟨N(⃗p, s)uu¯ + ¯ddN(⃗p, s)⟩, with ml = (mu + md)/2. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The same matrix elements enter predictions for Higgs-mediated µ → e conversion in the nuclei [11]. Lattice QCD determinations of the light-quark sigma term σπN disagree among themselves and with phenomenology.

The strange and charm sigma terms are determined using purely disconnected contributions. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Conclusions. — A comprehensive analysis is carried out to extract the light, strange and charm sigma terms of the nucleon in the continuum limit, using only ensembles at physical pion mass and taking into account systematic uncertainties.

Lattice Setup and Simulation Details

The lattice setup employs four ETMC gauge ensembles with a mass degenerate up and down quarks, a strange and a charm quark (Nf = 2 + 1 + 1) with their mass fixed to approximately their physical values. This discretization scheme at maximal twist gives automatic O(a) improvement of physical observables. p. 0

Where the paper says it

—We employ four ETMC gauge ensembles with a mass degenerate up and down quarks, a strange and a charm quark (Nf = 2 + 1 + 1) with their mass fixed to approximately their physical values [27–29]. This lattice discretization scheme at maximal twist gives automatic O(a) improvement of physical observables [30, 31], so the leading cutoff effects are O(a 2 ).

The spatial extent of the ensembles is L ≃ 5. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This lattice discretization scheme at maximal twist gives automatic O(a) improvement of physical observables [30, 31], so the leading cutoff effects are O(a 2 ). The spatial extent of the ensembles is L ≃ 5.

1–5.5 fm, giving mπL ≃ 3. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The spatial extent of the ensembles is L ≃ 5. 5 fm, giving mπL ≃ 3.

6–3.9.

Extraction Methodology and Uncertainty Handling

To extract the nucleon matrix elements, the authors compute two-point functions C2(ts) and connected three-point functions C3(tins, ts). The ratio R(tins, ts) is formed by dividing the connected term by the two-point function computed with the same statistics. p. 1

Where the paper says it

(2) The connected term exists only for q = u, d, so σs and σc are purely disconnected. Each term is divided by the two-point function computed with the same statistics.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2) The connected term exists only for q = u, d, so σs and σc are purely disconnected. Each term is divided by the two-point function computed with the same statistics.

The continuum limit is taken using two approaches: a two-step procedure where each ensemble's ratio is fitted separately and then extrapolated linearly in a 2 as σ(a) = σ + b a2, and a global fit where the continuum extrapolation is performed in one step by including an explicit linear in a squared dependence for the parameters.

Results and Comparisons

The global fit results yield σπN = 53.0(7.4)(1.6) MeV, σs = 58.2(17.0)(2.1) MeV and σc = 112(28)(25) MeV. The results show that the light and strange ratios lie 30–45% below σ(aj), which indicates the size of the excited-state contribution removed by the fit. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Even at the largest separations the light and strange ratios lie 30–45% below σ(aj ), which shows the size of the excitedstate contribution removed by the fit, while the charm ratio is flat within its errors. We show the results from the two analysis approaches in Fig.

For σc, a constant fit is used, yielding σc = 102(25)(5) MeV. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The gray band and the number in each panel give σ(aj ) = σ + b a2 j of the global fit at the lattice spacing of that ensemble, averaged over the fit windows; σc is fitted with a constant, the same on every ensemble. σc constant, σc = 102(25)(5) MeV, where the first error is statistical and the second the systematic error from the variation over the fit windows.

The results for σπN and σs are in agreement with most lattice determinations except the one from JLQCD which obtained a smaller value for σπN. p. 3
Where the paper says it

We distinguish three classes of determinations: those that compute the nucleon matrix elements of the scalar operator, as in this work, those that use the Feynman–Hellmann approach, and those that use the hybrid method of MILC for σs [44, 45]. Our values for σπN and σs are in agreement with most lattice determinations except the one from JLQCD which obtained a smaller value for σπN .

Phenomenological Relevance

The sigma terms are essential to translate nuclear-recoil limits from LZ, XENONnT, and PandaX-4T into constraints on dark-matter couplings to quarks. They are also important for predictions for Higgs-mediated µ → e conversion in the nuclei. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In particular, they are essential to translate nuclear-recoil limits from LZ, XENONnT, and PandaX-4T into constraints on dark-matter couplings to quarks [8–10]. The same matrix elements enter predictions for Higgs-mediated µ → e conversion in the nuclei [11].

The Higgs–nucleon coupling at leading order in the heavy-quark matching is fN = 2/9 + 7/9(σπN + σs)/mN = 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Our values for σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics. For dark-matter direct detection, our σπN and σs give the Higgs–nucleon coupling at leading order in the heavy-quark matching [1, 6], fN = 2 9 + 7 9 (σπN + σs)/mN = 0.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Our values for σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics. For dark-matter direct detection, our σπN and σs give the Higgs–nucleon coupling at leading order in the heavy-quark matching [1, 6], fN = 2 9 + 7 9 (σπN + σs)/mN = 0.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Our values for σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics. For dark-matter direct detection, our σπN and σs give the Higgs–nucleon coupling at leading order in the heavy-quark matching [1, 6], fN = 2 9 + 7 9 (σπN + σs)/mN = 0.

314(16). The values for σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The analysis includes the accommodation of multiparticle states extracting an energy gap close to the Nππ threshold, a finding that is consistent with a variational analysis for B64 [38], where adding nucleon– σ-meson interpolators and solving the generalized eigenvalue problem [51] substantially reduces the time dependence of the light-quark ratio. Our values for σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics.

Conclusions

A comprehensive analysis is carried out to extract the light, strange and charm sigma terms of the nucleon in the continuum limit, using only ensembles at physical pion mass and taking into account systematic uncertainties. The analysis includes the accommodation of multiparticle states extracting an energy gap close to the Nππ threshold. p. 3

Where the paper says it

— A comprehensive analysis is carried out to extract the light, strange and charm sigma terms of the nucleon in the continuum limit, using only ensembles at physical pion mass and taking into account systematic uncertainties. The analysis includes the accommodation of multiparticle states extracting an energy gap close to the Nππ threshold, a finding that is consistent with a variational analysis for B64 [38], where adding nucleon– σ-meson interpolators and solving the generalized eigenvalue problem [51] substantially reduces the time dependence of the light-quark ratio.

The authors conclude that their values for σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The analysis includes the accommodation of multiparticle states extracting an energy gap close to the Nππ threshold, a finding that is consistent with a variational analysis for B64 [38], where adding nucleon– σ-meson interpolators and solving the generalized eigenvalue problem [51] substantially reduces the time dependence of the light-quark ratio. Our values for σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics.

The light quark sector energy gap, ∆E3pt = 310(72)(21) MeV, agrees within its error with the Nπ and Nππ levels of the four ensembles. p. 2
Where the paper says it

3 MeV for the other ensembles, is well within our statistical error and would change the continuum value by about 1 MeV, so we do not correct for it. The energy gap, ∆E3pt = 310(72)(21) MeV from the light quark sector, agrees within its error with the Nπ and Nππ levels of the four ensembles and is well below ∆E2pt ≈ 600 MeV [32].

The per-ensemble route gives σπN = 52. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The energy gap, ∆E3pt = 310(72)(21) MeV from the light quark sector, agrees within its error with the Nπ and Nππ levels of the four ensembles and is well below ∆E2pt ≈ 600 MeV [32]. The per-ensemble route which is the continuum extrapolation of the results of the four ensembles fitted individually, gives σπN = 52.

0(9.3)(2.5) MeV, σs = 55. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We perform global fits to all ensembles, that yield σπN = 53. 6) MeV, σs = 58.

1(17.0)(1.8) MeV and σc = 64(89) MeV. p. 0
Where the paper says it

6) MeV, σs = 58. 1) MeV and σc = 112(28)(25) MeV, with statistical and systematic uncertainties, respectively.

The global fit results in σπN = 53. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We show the results from the two analysis approaches in Fig. We quote the global fit results, which extrapolates the ratios to the continuum in one step and takes the correlation between σ(a) and the gap into account, and obtain σπN = 53.

0(7.6) MeV, σs = 58.2(17.1) MeV, and σc = 112(38) MeV. p. 0
Where the paper says it

6) MeV, σs = 58. 1) MeV and σc = 112(28)(25) MeV, with statistical and systematic uncertainties, respectively.

The final uncertainty for σc is the sum of the two in quadrature. p. 2
Where the paper says it

1) MeV = 58. 1) MeV, (6) σc = 112(28)(25) MeV = 112(38) MeV, where the first error is statistical and the second systematic, and the final uncertainty, given last, is the sum of the two in quadrature.

The a squared slopes of the global fits are compatible with zero, with b = −1. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For σc the systematic error includes the 24 MeV from the unresolved a 2 dependence. The a 2 slopes of the global fits are compatible with zero; for σπN , b = −1.

7(1.3) GeV fm−2 for σπN. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The a 2 slopes of the global fits are compatible with zero; for σπN , b = −1. 3) GeV fm−2 amounts to −21(15)% at the coarsest lattice spacing.

The energy gap, ∆E3pt = 360–450 MeV from the light quark sector, agrees within its error with the Nπ and Nππ levels of the four ensembles. p. 2
Where the paper says it

3 MeV for the other ensembles, is well within our statistical error and would change the continuum value by about 1 MeV, so we do not correct for it. The energy gap, ∆E3pt = 310(72)(21) MeV from the light quark sector, agrees within its error with the Nπ and Nππ levels of the four ensembles and is well below ∆E2pt ≈ 600 MeV [32].

The energy gap is well below ∆E2pt ≈ 600 MeV. p. 2
Where the paper says it

3 MeV for the other ensembles, is well within our statistical error and would change the continuum value by about 1 MeV, so we do not correct for it. The energy gap, ∆E3pt = 310(72)(21) MeV from the light quark sector, agrees within its error with the Nπ and Nππ levels of the four ensembles and is well below ∆E2pt ≈ 600 MeV [32].

The results on σc do not provide a stringent test of heavyquark decoupling at the charm mass. p. 3
Where the paper says it

However, the present 34% precision on σc does not provide a stringent test of heavyquark decoupling at the charm mass. The results on σπN extracted probing the dependence of the nucleon mass on the light quark mass within the Feynman–Hellmann approach tend to give lower values [19, 47].

The results on σπN extracted probing the dependence of the nucleon mass on the light quark mass within the Feynman–Hellmann approach tend to give lower values. p. 3
Where the paper says it

However, the present 34% precision on σc does not provide a stringent test of heavyquark decoupling at the charm mass. The results on σπN extracted probing the dependence of the nucleon mass on the light quark mass within the Feynman–Hellmann approach tend to give lower values [19, 47].

The heavy-quark expansion gives at leading order σHQE c = 2/27 mN − σπN − σs ≈ 61 MeV, which agrees with our quoted value. p. 3
Where the paper says it

For σc there are three other lattice values [17, 21, 46], all in agreement with the value extracted from this analysis. The heavy-quark expansion [1] gives at leading order σ HQE c = 2 27 mN − σπN − σs ≈ 61 MeV, which agrees with our quoted value.

The Higgs–nucleon coupling at leading order in the heavy-quark matching is fN = 2/9 + 7/9(σπN + σs)/mN = 0.314(16). The statistical and systematic errors are added in quadrature. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Circles: σ(aj ) = σ + b a2 j of the global fit at the lattice spacing of each ensemble, averaged over the fit windows (constant for σc); squares: the fits of each ensemble separately. Solid (dashed) curves with bands and stars at a = 0: the continuum extrapolation of the global (perensemble) route, linear in a 2 except for σc, with statistical and systematic errors added in quadrature.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Circles: σ(aj ) = σ + b a2 j of the global fit at the lattice spacing of each ensemble, averaged over the fit windows (constant for σc); squares: the fits of each ensemble separately. Solid (dashed) curves with bands and stars at a = 0: the continuum extrapolation of the global (perensemble) route, linear in a 2 except for σc, with statistical and systematic errors added in quadrature.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Circles: σ(aj ) = σ + b a2 j of the global fit at the lattice spacing of each ensemble, averaged over the fit windows (constant for σc); squares: the fits of each ensemble separately. Solid (dashed) curves with bands and stars at a = 0: the continuum extrapolation of the global (perensemble) route, linear in a 2 except for σc, with statistical and systematic errors added in quadrature.

The authors acknowledge partial support from the projects 3D-nucleon (EXCELLENCE/0421/0043), IMAGE-N (EXCELLENCE/0524/0459), MuonHVP (EXCELLENCE/0524/0017), PulseQCD (EXCELLENCE/0524/0269), Baryon8 (EXCELLENCE/0524/0001), RobustSigma (EXCELLENCE/0925/0325), DeNuTra (EXCELLENCE/524/0455), LENA-QCD (POST-DOC/0925-ROandOther/0180) and partonWF (VISION ERC/0525/0010) funded by the European Regional Development Fund and the Republic of Cyprus through the Cyprus Research and Innovation Foundation. p. 4
Where the paper says it

— We would like to thank all members of the Extended Twisted Mass Collaboration for a very enjoyable cooperation. acknowledge partial support from the projects 3D-nucleon (EXCELLENCE/0421/0043), IMAGE-N (EXCELLENCE/0524/0459), MuonHVP (EXCELLENCE/0524/0017), PulseQCD (EXCELLENCE/0524/0269), Baryon8 (EXCELLENCE/0524/0001), RobustSigma (EXCELLENCE/0925/0325), DeNuTra (EXCELLENCE/524/0455), LENA-QCD (POST-DOC/0925 - ROandOther/0180) and partonWF (VISION ERC/0525/0010) funded by the European Regional Development Fund and the Republic of Cyprus through the Cyprus Research and Innovation Foundation.

The authors gratefully acknowledge the Gauss Centre for Supercomputing e. p. 4
Where the paper says it

101072344, project AQTIVATE (Advanced computing, QuanTum algorIthms and data-driVen Approaches for science, Technology and Engineering). The authors gratefully acknowledge the Gauss Centre for Supercomputing e.

V. (www.gauss-centre. p. 4
Where the paper says it

101072344, project AQTIVATE (Advanced computing, QuanTum algorIthms and data-driVen Approaches for science, Technology and Engineering). The authors gratefully acknowledge the Gauss Centre for Supercomputing e.

eu) for funding this project by providing computing time through the John von Neumann Institute for Computing (NIC) on the GCS Supercomputers JUWELS, JUWELS Booster [52] and JUPITER Booster at J¨ulich Supercomputing Centre (JSC). p. 4
Where the paper says it

gauss-centre. eu) for funding this project by providing computing time through the John von Neumann Institute for Computing (NIC) on the GCS Supercomputers JUWELS, JUWELS Booster [52] and JUPITER Booster at J¨ulich Supercomputing Centre (JSC).

The authors also acknowledge computing time granted on Piz Daint and Alps at Centro Svizzero di Calcolo Scientifico (CSCS) via the projects s1174 and lp139. p. 4
Where the paper says it

eu) for funding this project by providing computing time through the John von Neumann Institute for Computing (NIC) on the GCS Supercomputers JUWELS, JUWELS Booster [52] and JUPITER Booster at J¨ulich Supercomputing Centre (JSC). We also acknowledge computing time granted on Piz Daint and Alps at Centro Svizzero di Calcolo Scientifico (CSCS) via the projects s1174 and lp139.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper determines the light, strange and charm sigma terms of the nucleon in the continuum limit using four Nf = 2+1+1 twisted-mass gauge ensembles simulated at physical pion masses and with approximately the same spatial volumes. The analysis accounts for excited-state contamination from low-lying multihadron states when extracting the nucleon matrix elements. p. 0

Where the paper says it

049 fm, with an action that has O(a) improvement, enable extrapolating the results to the continuum limit. Both valence and sea quark contributions are analysed accounting for excited-state contamination from low-lying multihadron states.

How the training signal is built

The extraction of the nucleon matrix elements involves computing two-point functions C2(ts) and connected three-point functions C3(tins, ts). The ratio R(tins, ts) is formed by dividing the connected term by the two-point function computed with the same statistics. The extraction method involves fitting the effective mass meff, j (t) = E0,j (aj)+log (1 + c1,j e −∆E2pt,j(aj)ts, with t and the energies in lattice units. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In the denominator, we truncate the spectral decomposition of C2,j to the first excited state, so that c1,j = |Z1,j/Z0,j | 2 is the ratio of the overlaps for the first excited state and the nucleon computed on that ensemble. We determine the mass of the nucleon mN,j (aj ) and the energy gap ∆E2pt,j (aj ) by fitting the effective mass meff, j (t) = E0,j (aj )+log (1 + c1,j e −∆E2pt,j (aj )t ) (1 + c1,j e−∆E2pt,j (aj )(t+1)) (5) with t and the energies in lattice units, and then give them as input in Eq.

Where the gains come from

The primary gain comes from performing a global fit across all ensembles in addition to fitting the data from individual ensembles. This enables a more stringent continuum extrapolation, while testing the impact of multiparticle contributions without imposing constraints. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We take multiparticle states into account when extracting the nucleon matrix elements, and we perform a global fit across the four ensembles in addition to fitting the data from individual ensembles. This enables a more stringent continuum extrapolation, while testing the impact of multiparticle contributions without imposing constraints.

The global fit extrapolates σ(a) to the continuum in one step by including a linear in a squared dependence for the fit parameters. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The fit thus extrapolates σ(a) to the continuum in one step. The global fit uses the same R windows r = (t low s , tcut ins ) on every ensemble and gives the continuum value σr directly in each window.

The analysis of multiparticle states is consistent with a variational analysis for B64. p. 3
Where the paper says it

— A comprehensive analysis is carried out to extract the light, strange and charm sigma terms of the nucleon in the continuum limit, using only ensembles at physical pion mass and taking into account systematic uncertainties. The analysis includes the accommodation of multiparticle states extracting an energy gap close to the Nππ threshold, a finding that is consistent with a variational analysis for B64 [38], where adding nucleon– σ-meson interpolators and solving the generalized eigenvalue problem [51] substantially reduces the time dependence of the light-quark ratio.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

— A comprehensive analysis is carried out to extract the light, strange and charm sigma terms of the nucleon in the continuum limit, using only ensembles at physical pion mass and taking into account systematic uncertainties. The analysis includes the accommodation of multiparticle states extracting an energy gap close to the Nππ threshold, a finding that is consistent with a variational analysis for B64 [38], where adding nucleon– σ-meson interpolators and solving the generalized eigenvalue problem [51] substantially reduces the time dependence of the light-quark ratio.

The results on σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The analysis includes the accommodation of multiparticle states extracting an energy gap close to the Nππ threshold, a finding that is consistent with a variational analysis for B64 [38], where adding nucleon– σ-meson interpolators and solving the generalized eigenvalue problem [51] substantially reduces the time dependence of the light-quark ratio. Our values for σs and σc provide valuable input for phenomenological searches for beyond the Standard Model physics.

The Higgs–nucleon coupling at leading order in the heavy-quark matching is fN = 2/9 + 7/9(σπN + σs)/mN = 0.314(16). The statistical and systematic errors are added in quadrature.

The authors take multiparticle states into account when extracting the nucleon matrix elements, which is necessary because the scalar current excites certain nucleon and pion states strongly while they are barely visible in the determination of the nucleon mass. The analysis of multiparticle states is consistent with a variational analysis for B64.

The authors allow the effective excitedstate gap in the three-point function to differ from that of the nucleon two-point function, and determine it across the four ensembles without priors. The fit windows variations in t low s and t cut ins are given in Ref. p. 2

Where the paper says it

3 fm on every ensemble. The fit windows variations in t low s and t cut ins are given in Ref.

[32]. The authors quote the global fit results, which extrapolate the ratios to the continuum in one step and take the correlation between σ(a) and the gap into account. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We show the results from the two analysis approaches in Fig. We quote the global fit results, which extrapolates the ratios to the continuum in one step and takes the correlation between σ(a) and the gap into account, and obtain σπN = 53.

The global fit uses a linear in a squared dependence in the fit parameters that describe physical quantities, namely the sigma term σ(a) and the energy gap ∆E3pt(a). The covariance is block diagonal because the ensembles are independent. p. 2

Where the paper says it

σ, ∆E3pt, b and bE are the only parameters common to all ensembles when fitting the ratio. The amplitudes Aj and Bj are free on each ensemble, no priors are used, and the covariance is block diagonal because the ensembles are independent.

The fit thus extrapolates σ(a) to the continuum in one step. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The amplitudes Aj and Bj are free on each ensemble, no priors are used, and the covariance is block diagonal because the ensembles are independent. The fit thus extrapolates σ(a) to the continuum in one step.

The statistical and systematic errors are added in quadrature. The final uncertainty, given last, is the sum of the two in quadrature. p. 2
Where the paper says it

1) MeV = 58. 1) MeV, (6) σc = 112(28)(25) MeV = 112(38) MeV, where the first error is statistical and the second systematic, and the final uncertainty, given last, is the sum of the two in quadrature.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Global fit extrapolation for sigma terms allows for a single step continuum limit by setting sigma q equals sigma plus b a squared and fitting parameters like b in Eq (4). This enables the AI system to provide continuum values directly from global fits across all ensembles.

  2. Accommodation of multiparticle states by extracting an energy gap close to the Npi pi threshold, which is consistent with a variational analysis for B64, substantially reduces the time dependence of the light-quark ratio. This allows AI systems to more accurately determine nucleon matrix elements by accounting for excited-state contamination.

  3. The system can utilize a two-step procedure where it first fits the ratio on each ensemble and then performs a continuum extrapolation using a term linear in a squared lattice spacing, sigma (a) = sigma + b a squared. This provides an alternative route to continuum results based on fitting individual ensembles separately.

  4. The AI system can perform simultaneous global fits by including an a squared dependence in the fit parameters that describe physical quantities, specifically setting sigma j equals sigma(aj) and DeltaE3pt j equals DeltaE3pt(aj). This approach extrapolates sigma a to the continuum in one step by fitting all ensembles together.

  5. The system can perform specialized fits for strange and charm terms where the charm ratio is fitted with a constant, the same on every ensemble, while the light and strange ratios are fitted using both global fits and per-ensemble continuum extrapolations.

Abstract

We determine the light, strange and charm σ-terms of the nucleon in lattice QCD using four N f=2+1+1 twisted-mass gauge ensembles simulated at physical pion masses and with approximately the same spatial volumes. The four lattice spacings ranging from 0.080 fm to 0.049 fm, with an action that has O(a) improvement, enable extrapolating the results to the continuum limit. Both valence and sea quark contributions are analysed accounting for excited-state contamination from low-lying multihadron states. We perform global fits to all ensembles, that yield σ πN=53.0(7.4)(1.6) MeV, σ s=58.2(17.0)(2.1) MeV and σ c=112(28)(25) MeV, with statistical and systematic uncertainties, respectively.

Sources

Related papers