Measuring the Milky Way potential with the phase snail shape curves

arXiv:2611.13837 · astro-ph.GA · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Measuring the Milky Way potential with the phase snail shape curves".

Title and authors: Vera: So we're starting with "Measuring the Milky Way potential with the phase snail shape curves." What does that title actually tell us about what they are trying to achieve?

Jocelyn: It tells us they are taking these spirals, these phase snails found in the vertical space of our galaxy, and using their shapes to figure out the actual gravitational pull of the Milky Way.

Subrahmanyan: It suggests that the way these snails wrap around in this vertical space naturally holds information about the potential itself, which is a very deep connection they are making.

Vera: So instead of just looking at rotation curves or stellar distributions, they’re using these specific shapes to build a map of our galaxy's gravity.

Jocelyn: That’s right, and it moves us beyond just measuring how fast things orbit in the plane to understanding the true three dee gravitational field.

Subrahmanyan: This approach connects directly to structure formation because it helps us constrain the underlying mass distribution that dictates how things clump together in the universe.

The paper's summary: Vera: So, what’s the core finding of "Measuring the Milky Way potential with the phase snail shape curves" regarding their main results?

Jocelyn: They found that these spiral shapes in vertical space provide a much clearer picture of Galactic gravity than just looking at rotation curves alone.

Subrahmanyan: They are probing something that’s not easily seen in simple density maps, which is interesting because we usually have to guess the potential based on just rotation curves or stellar distributions.

Vera: They managed to get a local dark matter density of zero point zero zero nine seven plus two minus negative three times per cubic parsec when they combine all their data.

Jocelyn: That local constraint is really important for us right now because we need those precise numbers to test our cosmological models about dark matter halos.

Subrahmanyan: If we can get these kinds of constraints in more places, it’s a strong confirmation that the structure seen in simulations matches what we actually observe.

Vera: They also reported a median perturbation time of five hundred sixty-four million years for this disk evolution, which fits with other methods we've used to study how the galaxy has changed over time.

Jocelyn: That timescale helps us figure out if the disk is settling down vertically or if it’s still going through big changes in its vertical motion.

Subrahmanyan: The fact that different mass models all end up converging on the same total vertical potential shape is a really strong piece of evidence for the physics they are trying to measure.

The paper's improvements: Vera: So, how are they making this method better than previous attempts, what specific improvements did they suggest in "Measuring the Milky Way potential with the phase snail shape curves"?

Jocelyn: They’ve focused on cleaning up the data processing and getting more reliable numbers by making their measurement steps more precise.

Subrahmanyan: What are these specific technical improvements that enhance this method?

Vera: First, they suggest combining the phase snails with our rotation curve data to get an even better constraint on that local dark matter density.

Jocelyn: That’s a big deal because it gives us a more precise number for how much dark matter is in our solar neighborhood, which we need for cosmological models.

Subrahmanyan: So they are improving the precision of that local dark matter density measurement by using both sets of data together.

Vera: They also improved how the method handles errors by adding an empirical correction for the potential radius when binning those snails by their radial distance, Rg.

Jocelyn: That sounds like a practical fix to prevent those systematic underestimations of the vertical potential that we discussed earlier.

Subrahmanyan: So they are addressing a specific bias in the data processing pipeline, which is important for getting clean results from observational surveys.

Vera: Plus, they showed that different mass models actually converge on the same total vertical potential shape when you look at those snail shapes, which makes the method more robust to uncertainties in our assumed components.

Jocelyn: That convergence means we can be more confident that the potential shape we are recovering is real, not just a result of our specific model choices.

Conclusion: Vera: So looking at "Measuring the Milky Way potential with the phase snail shape curves," what’s our final summary of what this paper actually achieved?

Jocelyn: It’s important because it gives us a way to constrain the mass distribution, which is fundamental to understanding how structure forms in the universe.

Subrahmanyan: Exactly. This method probes something that isn't directly observable through simple density maps, which is intriguing because we often have to model potentials based on just rotation curves or stellar distributions.

Vera: They managed to nail down a local dark matter density of zero point zero zero nine seven plus zero point zero two minus negative three times per cubic parsec when combining all their data.

Jocelyn: We’re looking forward to seeing if we can use these vertical constraints to build those three dimensional potential maps they mentioned.

Subrahmanyan: The overall measurement of perturbation time for both models is in the range of four hundred to seven hundred fifty million years with a median of five hundred sixty-four million years.

Vera: I think we'll keep watching how these vertical constraints evolve as we gather more data from surveys like Gaia DR3.

Jocelyn: Next time, we’ll be diving into some of those GRB data from GRB 250702B to look at how relativistic jets evolve over time.

Rui Guo, Zhao-Yu Li, Juntai Shen, Jie Wang, Shude Mao

National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences · Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University · State Key Laboratory of Dark Matter Physics, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University · Key Laboratory for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (MOE) / Shanghai Key Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology · Institute for Frontiers in Astronomy and Astrophysics, Beijing Normal University · University of Chinese Academy of Sciences · Department of Astronomy, Westlake University

astro-ph.GA

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 19 pages + Appendix (3 pages); 16 figures; accepted for publication in A&A

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 85/100

The gist: Phase spirals found in the vertical phase-space (z − Vz) indicate that the Galactic disk is in disequilibrium.

Key concepts

Phase Snail Shape Curves
These are curves extracted from density contrast maps that encode information about the vertical structure of the Galactic disk. They are used as proxies to infer how much a potential, like gravity, is shaping the disk's motion in the vertical direction.
Vertical Frequency-Action Angle ($\Omega_z - \theta_z$ space)
This is a mathematical space where orbital integration data from phase snails is plotted. The key idea is that the vertical and in-plane motions are separable, allowing a linear relationship between the vertical frequency ($\Omega_z$) and the phase angle ($\theta_z$), which helps constrain potential models.
Perturbation Time ($T_{evol}$)
This parameter estimates how long ago a significant event, like a disk perturbation, occurred. The snail analysis constrains this time to be between 456 and 738 million years, suggesting the vertical velocity kick happened in this timeframe.
Local Dark Matter Density ($\rho_{dm}, \odot$)
This is the density of dark matter specifically in our solar neighborhood. Combining snail shape measurements with rotation curve data provides a very tight constraint on this value, resulting in a precise measurement of approximately $0.0097 ext{ pc}^{-3}$.

Terminology

Summary

Phase spirals found in the vertical phase-space (z − Vz) indicate that the Galactic disk is in disequilibrium. p. 0

Where the paper says it

aa60089-26corr ©ESO 2026 November 11, 2026 Measuring the Milky Way potential with the phase snail shape curves Rui Guo1, 2, 3⋆, Zhao-Yu Li2, 3, 4⋆⋆, Juntai Shen2, 3, 4⋆⋆⋆, Jie Wang1, 5, 6 , and Shude Mao7 1 National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100012, China 2 Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, 800 Dongchuan Road, Shanghai 200240, People’s Republic of China 3 State Key Laboratory of Dark Matter Physics, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, People’s Republic of China 4 Key Laboratory for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (MOE) / Shanghai Key Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Shanghai 200240, People’s Republic of China 5 Institute for Frontiers in Astronomy and Astrophysics, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 102206, China 6 University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 19 A Yuquan Rd, Shijingshan District, Beijing, 100049, China 7 Deparatment of Astronomy, Westlake University, Hangzhou 310030, Zhejiang Province, China Received March 27, 2026 ABSTRACT Aims. Phase spirals found in the vertical phase-space (z − Vz) indicate that the Galactic disk is in disequilibrium.

The wrapping of phase snails is dominated by the vertical potential profiles, naturally encoding potential information in their shapes. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Phase spirals found in the vertical phase-space (z − Vz) indicate that the Galactic disk is in disequilibrium. Although the origin remains elusive, the wrapping of phase snails is dominated by the vertical potential profiles, naturally encoding potential information in their shapes.

We attempt to measure the Galactic potential utilizing the snail shape curves. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Although the origin remains elusive, the wrapping of phase snails is dominated by the vertical potential profiles, naturally encoding potential information in their shapes. We attempt to measure the Galactic potential utilizing the snail shape curves.

Methodology for Potential Measurement

The method involves extracting phase snail shape curves from density contrast maps and transforming them into the vertical frequency-action angle (omegaz − θz) space via orbital integration. This transformation is based on the assumption that the vertical and in-plane motions are separable, allowing for a linear relationship between the vertical frequency, omegaz, and vertical phase angle, θz. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The 1D orbital integration method is based on the assumption that the vertical and in-plane motions are separable. Thus, the vertical energy1 , Ez , is conserved for a vertically oscillating star, which moves in the vertical phase space following a certain closed orbit.

The orbital integration method uses the conserved vertical energy to calculate the orbital period P(Ez) and subsequently the vertical frequency omegaz. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The orbital frequency, Ωz (equally the period P(Ez)), can be calculated through the numerical integration to a relative accuracy of 10−6 . Similarly, we can adopt the numerical integration to calculate the phase angle, θz , which is defined as the fraction of elapsed time relative to the orbit period.

This frequency is then related to the phase angle by a linear relation θz = θz,0 + omegaz × Tevol. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(4) Therefore, according to the orbital symmetry in the four quadrants, the phase angle can be calculated as θz(z, Vz) =    2πt/P (z ≥ 0, Vz ≥ 0), π − 2πt/P (z ≥ 0, Vz < 0), π + 2πt/P (z < 0, Vz ≤ 0), 2π − 2πt/P (z < 0, Vz > 0). (5) This definition results in the critical linear relation between the phase angle, θz , and the orbit frequency, Ωz , as given by θz = θz,0 + Ωz × Tevol, (6) where Tevol is the evolution time since the perturbation and θz,0 is the initial phase angle.

The snail shape curves are then transformed into data points in the omegaz − θz space, and a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) technique is applied to compare linear fitting of different potential models. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Unlike them, we first extract the snail shape curves from the observation, and then transform the z − Vz phase-space snail into data points in the frequency-action angle space (Ωz − θz). We then apply the Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) technique to compare the linear fitting in Ωz −θz space of different potential models, to obtain parameter estimations of the vertical potential.

Verification and Simulation Results

The method was verified with a test particle simulation using Model I from Irrgang et al. (2013), where the disk perturbation was set to mimic the impulse approximation. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The test particles traced a thin disk population with a QuasiIsothermal distribution function (DF; Binney 2010; Binney & McMillan 2011) and basic properties (scale lengths and velocity dispersion) set to be dynamically cold. The disk perturbation was set to mimic the impulse approximation by imposing a downward vertical velocity with no vertical displacement.

The recovered Galactic vertical potential profiles in the simulation showed excellent agreement with input potential models. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We verified our method with a test particle simulation with the disk perturbation included within the impulse approximation. Our method performs well in the test particle simulation, with the recovered Galactic vertical potential profiles in excellent agreement with the input potential models.

In the observational data analysis, the snail shape curves were extracted by separating density contrast maps into 24 wedges and finding density peaks to represent the snail shape curve. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We attempt to measure the Galactic potential utilizing the snail shape curves. To measure the Galactic potential, we extracted the phase snail shape curves from density contrast maps and transformed them into the vertical frequency-action angle (Ωz − θz) space via orbital integration, then performed linear fitting to derive potential parameters.

The measured snail shapes were found to be qualitatively consistent with the toy model snails calculated from the input vertical potential in the inner region where uncertainties are smaller. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The measured snail shapes always locate inside (outside) the toy model snails in the outer (inner) phase space, indicating smaller (larger) vertical energy at high (low) z. This indicates a biased potential profile represented by the measured snail shape.

Constraints from Combined Data

When combining the phase snails and the rotation curve, an improved model was derived which yielded a Galactic virial mass of M200 = 0.87+0.31−0.33 × 1012 M⊙ and a local dark matter density of ρdm,⊙ = 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The model yields a Galactic virial mass of M200 = 0. 23 × 1012 M⊙ and a local dark matter density of ρdm,⊙ = 0.

0097+0.0002−- - - pc−3. This improved model also results in an estimation of the perturbation time in a range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The high precision of ρdm,⊙ results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood. p. 0

Where the paper says it

0009 M⊙ pc−3 . The high precision of ρdm,⊙ results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood.

We also obtain an estimation of the perturbation time in a range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr, consistent with recent measurements.

The high precision of ρdm,⊙ results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood.

Comparison with Literature and Limitations

The recovered vertical potential was found to be in excellent agreement with popular Milky Way potential models. However, the best-fit model yielded a flatter rotation curve than the observation from Zhou et al. p. 8

Where the paper says it

We note that the outer region should be more carefully studied in the future, due to the larger noise, fewer wraps, and more susceptible to the influence of self-gravity. Although our best-fit model shows a good linear performance in Ωz − θz space and a good consistency in the measured vertical potential compared to the MWPotential2014, the rotation curve from the best-fit model is not consistent with that from Zhou et al.

(2023). The degeneracy between disk parameters and perturbation time Tevol was noted as strong, with negative correlations observed. p. 5
Where the paper says it

5, there is a negative correlation between Tevol and disk mass Md, and positive correlations between Tevol and disk scale length ad and scale height bd. This degeneracy could be understood from the tests in Appendix B, where we investigate the variation in the curve in Ωz − θz space with the vertical potential deviating from the input one by arbitrarily scaling it.

Furthermore, the method's performance is sensitive to the approximation of 1D orbital integration and the potential radius correction applied to Rg-binned snails.

Final Constraints and Future Directions

The combined model with rotation curve constraints resulted in a DM halo mass of M200 = 0.87+0.31−0.33 × 1012 M⊙ and a local DM density of ρdm,⊙ = 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The model yields a Galactic virial mass of M200 = 0. 23 × 1012 M⊙ and a local dark matter density of ρdm,⊙ = 0.

0097+0.0- - - pc−3. The overall measurement of Tevol for both models is in the range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The high precision of ρdm,⊙ results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood. We also obtain an estimation of the perturbation time in a range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr, consistent with recent measurements.

The method demonstrates the wealth of information contained in phase snails to constrain the Galactic potential and mass distribution. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Our work demonstrates the wealth of information contained in the phase snails to constrain the Galactic potential and mass distribution. We expect to apply our method to the widely existed phase snails across the disk to explore the 3D potential maps and mass distributions in the future.

The work suggests that future applications could explore 3D potential maps and mass distributions by applying this method across the entire disk. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Our work demonstrates the wealth of information contained in the phase snails to constrain the Galactic potential and mass distribution. We expect to apply our method to the widely existed phase snails across the disk to explore the 3D potential maps and mass distributions in the future.

Appendix A: Mass and potential models for different components

The Plummer sphere has a potential given by Φb(r) = −GMb q r squared + b 2/b, (A.1). The Miyamoto-Nagai disk potential is expressed as Φd(R,z) = −GMd r / R squared + ad + q z squared + b 2/d squared, (A. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Therefore, the initial phase angle was θz,0 = π and the evolution time of the perturbation was Tevol = 500 Myr. The potential of Irrgang13I consists of a Plummer bulge (Plummer 1911), a Miyamoto-Nagai disk (Miyamoto & Nagai 1975), and a specific DM halo profile constructed to have approximately flat rotation curve and finite halo mass at a cutoff radius.

4). The NFW DM halo profile is given by ρNFW(r) = ρ0(r/rs)(1 + r/rs) squared, (A. p. 7
Where the paper says it

ah is the scale radius of the halo profile. This mass model replaces the halo profile of the test particle simulation with a NFW profile, without a cutoff radius.

10).

Appendix B: Variation in the omegaz − θz profile with scaled input potential

The zigzag pattern of the omegaz − θz curves arises when a globally scaled potential is used, as shown by the blue and red lines. The deformation of the frequency contour changes this trend, resulting in a zigzag pattern of the omegaz − θz curve in the middle panel of Fig. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Decreasing ad and bd will lead to steeper vertical potential and thus smaller Tevol, resulting in the positive correlations between them. The globally scaled potential will also result in a zigzag pattern for the curve in Ωz − θz space, leading to a large dispersion in the linear fitting.

B.2.

Appendix C: Mass model setup for the observational data

The mass model utilized for observational data consists of a Plummer sphere bulge, a Miyamoto-Nagai disk, and an NFW DM halo. For the observational data, the NFW DM halo profile is adopted by Navarro et al. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The snails are well represented by a large number of points (321 points in total) with 1 − 3 wraps, which are then utilized to measure the vertical potential of our Milky Way. Mass model setup for the observational data When measuring the vertical potential with the observed snail shape curves, we utilized a potential model consisting of a Plummer sphere bulge (Plummer 1911), a Miyamoto-Nagai disk (Miyamoto & Nagai 1975), and a NFW DM halo (Navarro et al.

(1996). The parameters for this potential model are p = (Mb, Md, Mh, bb, ad, bd, ah). p. 4
Where the paper says it

The measured snail shapes (black points), as well as the toy model snails calculated from the 1D orbit integration (black lines), are overplotted on the density contrast (orange) maps. Table 1: Parameters in recovering the vertical potential with the simulated phase snails.

Appendix D: Variation in the omegaz − θz profile with scaled input potential

The results from scaling the input potential by a factor of α ranging from 0.4 to 1.6 show that the omegaz − θz curves are still close to straight lines when the scaled potentials are within ∼15% of the original potential profile. p. 3

Where the paper says it

To quantify the difference between the 1D and 3D integrations, we calculated the vertical potentials represented by the snails under these two integrations. The potential difference profiles display wave-like patterns, and show slightly large discrepancy at points close to the mid-plane points (Vz ∼ ±Vz,max), which are more easily influenced by the in-plane motions.

When the scaled potential deviates further away from the input, the omegaz − θz curves display a clear zigzag pattern. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Decreasing ad and bd will lead to steeper vertical potential and thus smaller Tevol, resulting in the positive correlations between them. The globally scaled potential will also result in a zigzag pattern for the curve in Ωz − θz space, leading to a large dispersion in the linear fitting.

The results with a second-order polynomial scaling function show that the omegaz − θz curves display roughly linear relations without significant zigzag pattern. p. 5
Where the paper says it

For other situations, when the potential of high z and low z regions are scaled oppositely, their shifts in Ωz − θz space are also in opposite directions, resulting in significantly changed slope and Tevol. In some extreme cases, when the potential at high z is scaled up while that at low z is scaled down, the Ωz − θz curve show roughly linear relations but with strongly biased slopes Tevol, up to an overestimation of 5 times.

Appendix E: Two-armed spiral and secondary branches

Two-armed snails are found at inner radii of Rg ≈ 6.3 kpc, which could be due to multiple origins or a vertical resonance. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2025), a decelerating bar (Li et al. 2023), or a vertical resonance that breaks the disk adiabaticity (Chiba et al.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

2025), a decelerating bar (Li et al. 2023), or a vertical resonance that breaks the disk adiabaticity (Chiba et al.

The modeling of two-armed snails in the inner region is complicated and possibly subject to the inner non-axisymmetric components like the Galactic bar. p. 1
Where the paper says it

2021; Alinder et al. Another interesting feature of the phase snail is the two-armed spiral found firstly in the outer disk in the simulation and subsequently in the inner disk of the observation (Hunt et al.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

2021; Alinder et al. Another interesting feature of the phase snail is the two-armed spiral found firstly in the outer disk in the simulation and subsequently in the inner disk of the observation (Hunt et al.

Appendix F: Method comparison with previous works

The work differs from Widmark et al. (2021a) by focusing on the linear relationship of the omegaz − θz curve instead of constructing the analytical function of phase snail. p. 1

Where the paper says it

This linear relationship between Ωz and θz can be utilized to measure the vertical potential. In this work, we attempt to utilize the 1D orbital integration method to transform the snail shape curve extracted from z − Vz space to data points in Ωz − θz space, where we can perform linear fitting and apply MCMC technique to obtain the estimation of the vertical potential.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

This linear relationship between Ωz and θz can be utilized to measure the vertical potential. In this work, we attempt to utilize the 1D orbital integration method to transform the snail shape curve extracted from z − Vz space to data points in Ωz − θz space, where we can perform linear fitting and apply MCMC technique to obtain the estimation of the vertical potential.

Appendix G: Method verification with test particle simulation

The method performs well in the test particle simulation, with recovered vertical potential profiles in excellent agreement with the input potential models. The snail shape curves extracted are well consistent with the density contrast maps and the toy model snails calculated from the input vertical potential. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The measured snail shapes (black points), as well as the toy model snails calculated from the 1D orbit integration (black lines), are overplotted on the density contrast (orange) maps. Table 1: Parameters in recovering the vertical potential with the simulated phase snails.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

The measured snail shapes (black points), as well as the toy model snails calculated from the 1D orbit integration (black lines), are overplotted on the density contrast (orange) maps. Table 1: Parameters in recovering the vertical potential with the simulated phase snails.

Appendix H: Data

The data used include Gaia DR3 (Gaia Collaboration et al. 2023) to extract snail shape curves at different radii. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Gaia snails We used the data from Gaia DR3 (Gaia Collaboration et al. 2023) to extract the snail shape curves at different radii.

The stellar guiding center radii Rg were calculated based on the rotation curve from Zhou et al. p. 5
Where the paper says it

We utilized the geometric distances from Bailer-Jones et al. We calculated the stellar guiding center radii, Rg, based on the rotation curve from Zhou et al.

(2023).

Appendix I: Mass model setup for the observational data

When measuring the vertical potential with observed snail shape curves, a potential model consisting of a Plummer sphere bulge, a Miyamoto-Nagai disk, and an NFW DM halo is utilized. The parameters for this model are p = (Mb, Md, Mh, bb, ad, bd). p. 4

Where the paper says it

The measured snail shapes (black points), as well as the toy model snails calculated from the 1D orbit integration (black lines), are overplotted on the density contrast (orange) maps. Table 1: Parameters in recovering the vertical potential with the simulated phase snails.

Appendix J: Variation in the omegaz − θz profile with scaled input potential

The investigation into the variation of the curve in omegaz − θz space with a vertically scaled input potential helps to understand uncertainties of the potential constrained by the snail shape. The results show that globally scaled potentials lead to shifted omegaz − θz curves along omegaz, with obvious wiggles although slightly changed slopes. p. 5

Where the paper says it

For other situations, when the potential of high z and low z regions are scaled oppositely, their shifts in Ωz − θz space are also in opposite directions, resulting in significantly changed slope and Tevol. In some extreme cases, when the potential at high z is scaled up while that at low z is scaled down, the Ωz − θz curve show roughly linear relations but with strongly biased slopes Tevol, up to an overestimation of 5 times.

Appendix K: Constraint on the perturbation time

The estimation of Tevol and θz,0 at different Rg is displayed in Fig. 14. The median values of θz,0 are always close to π. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The accurate snail shape measurement in the test particle simulation leads to this nearly ideal case. The best-fit and median values of Tevol are 492 Myr and 491+22 −19 Myr, respectively, while those values for θz,0 are 1.

Appendix L: Comparison of the perturbation time with previous works

The estimation of Tevol ranges from 400 to 750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr. The median values are consistent with several recent works utilizing different methods. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Recent studies on the phase snail have focused on several key aspects. First, the time since the disk perturbation (Tevol) is usually estimated to be between 300 Myr and 900 Myr, through various methods (e.

Appendix M: Comparison of the DM halo quantities

The local DM density derived from combining snails and rotation curve is ρdm,⊙ = 0.0097+0.0- - - pc−3. This high precision is due to the strong constraint resulting from the combination of the rotation curve and phase snails in the solar neighborhood. p. 0

Where the paper says it

0009 M⊙ pc−3 . The high precision of ρdm,⊙ results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood.

Appendix N: Constraint on the perturbation time

The estimation of Tevol is consistent with recent works utilizing different methods. The median values are in the range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The high precision of ρdm,⊙ results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood. We also obtain an estimation of the perturbation time in a range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr, consistent with recent measurements.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The high precision of ρdm,⊙ results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood. We also obtain an estimation of the perturbation time in a range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr, consistent with recent measurements.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The high precision of ρdm,⊙ results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood. We also obtain an estimation of the perturbation time in a range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr, consistent with recent measurements.

Appendix O: Comparison of the rotation curve

The best-fit model's rotation curve is not consistent with that from Zhou et al. (2023). The difference results from the radial range explored being only 8 ≤ R ≤ 11 kpc. p. 8

Where the paper says it

83 km s−1 kpc−1 up to R = 25 kpc, while our rotation curve is flatter. This difference results from the fact that the radial range explored here is only 8 ≤ R ≤ 11 kpc, leading to a weak constraint on the radial variation in the rotation curve.

Appendix P: Constraint on the perturbation time

The overall measurement of Tevol for both models is in the range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr. The initial phase angle, θz,0, in our work is always close to π. p. 1

Where the paper says it

(2024), in this work we attempt to utilize the whole snail shape curve and the 1D phase-space orbital integration method to measure the vertical potential, similar to Widmark et al. Unlike them, we first extract the snail shape curves from the observation, and then transform the z − Vz phase-space snail into data points in the frequency-action angle space (Ωz − θz).

Appendix Q: Comparison of the vertical potential and vertical force

The profile derived under the combined constraints from the snails and rotation curve is systematically steeper than the red line. The lower panel of Fig. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We then take the median profile as the 1D density contrast profile, with the uncertainty taken from the standard deviation. The density contrast profiles of 24 wedges are shown as the corresponding colored lines in the lower panel of Fig.

15 shows a comparison of the vertical force at z = 1. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Note that the points in outer wraps have larger orbital periods, and thus lower frequencies, leading to smaller phase angles. Figure 4 shows the comparison of the input vertical potential and those from MCMC results.

1 kpc.

Appendix R: Constraint on the DM halo quantities

The local DM density derived by combining both constraints results in ρdm,⊙ = 0.0097+0.0- - - pc−3.

Appendix S: Comparison of the perturbation time with previous works

The estimation of Tevol ranges from 400 to 750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr. The different weakly decreasing trend could be due to the self-consistent potential model derived from the snail shape curves. p. 9

Where the paper says it

The model predicts steeper vertical potential profiles than those derived from the snail shape curves only, as indicated by the shaded regions in Fig. The bestfit model is now more consistent with the median profiles from all posterior parameter sets, which are more consistent with the vertical potential at Rg from the MWPotential2014 model, rather than those at Rpot.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

The model predicts steeper vertical potential profiles than those derived from the snail shape curves only, as indicated by the shaded regions in Fig. The bestfit model is now more consistent with the median profiles from all posterior parameter sets, which are more consistent with the vertical potential at Rg from the MWPotential2014 model, rather than those at Rpot.

Appendix T: Constraint on the perturbation time

The initial phase angle, θz,0, in our work is always close to π.

Appendix U: Comparison of the rotation curve

The best-fit model's rotation curve is not consistent with that from Zhou et al. (2023).

Appendix V: Constraint on the DM halo quantities

The measurements of M200 and R200 are both consistent with recent estimations. The larger concentration of the latter model results from the weakly declining rotation curve. p. 9

Where the paper says it

The bestfit model is now more consistent with the median profiles from all posterior parameter sets, which are more consistent with the vertical potential at Rg from the MWPotential2014 model, rather than those at Rpot. This discrepancy could be due to the weakly declining observed rotation curve, which leads to larger inner total densities, and thus steeper inner vertical potential profiles, and also a faster radial variation (smaller disk radial length).

Appendix W: Constraint on the perturbation time

The estimation of Tevol is consistent with recent works utilizing different methods. The median values are in the range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr.

Appendix X: Comparison of the rotation curve

The best-fit model's rotation curve is not consistent with that from Zhou et al. (2023).

Appendix Y: Constraint on the perturbation time

The estimation of Tevol ranges from 400 to 750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr. The different weakly decreasing trend could be due to the self-consistent potential model derived from the snail shape curves.

Appendix Z: Two-armed spiral and secondary branches

The two-armed snails are found at inner radii of Rg ≈ 6.3 kpc, which could be due to multiple origins or a vertical resonance. The modeling of two-armed snails in the inner region is complicated and possibly subject to the inner non-axisymmetric components like the Galactic bar.

Appendix AA: Mass and potential models for different components

The potential and mass functions of a Plummer sphere are described as Φb(r) = −GMb q r squared + b 2/b, (A.1). The rotation curve can thus be written as Vc, b = GMbr / r squared + b 2/b(3/2). p. 9

Where the paper says it

The bestfit model is now more consistent with the median profiles from all posterior parameter sets, which are more consistent with the vertical potential at Rg from the MWPotential2014 model, rather than those at Rpot. This discrepancy could be due to the weakly declining observed rotation curve, which leads to larger inner total densities, and thus steeper inner vertical potential profiles, and also a faster radial variation (smaller disk radial length).

Appendix BB: Mass and potential models for different components

The potential and mass functions of a Miyamoto-Nagai disk are expressed as Φd(R,z) = −GMd r / R squared + ad + q z squared + b 2/d squared, (A.5). The rotation curve of the Miyamoto-Nagai disk is Vc, d(R) = GMdR / R squared + (ad + bd) squared i3/2. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Therefore, the initial phase angle was θz,0 = π and the evolution time of the perturbation was Tevol = 500 Myr. The potential of Irrgang13I consists of a Plummer bulge (Plummer 1911), a Miyamoto-Nagai disk (Miyamoto & Nagai 1975), and a specific DM halo profile constructed to have approximately flat rotation curve and finite halo mass at a cutoff radius.

Appendix CC: Constraint on the perturbation time

The estimation of Tevol is consistent with recent works utilizing different methods. The median values are in the range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr.

Appendix DD: Variation in the omegaz − θz profile with scaled input potential

The results show that globally scaled potentials lead to shifted omegaz − θz curves along omegaz, with obvious wiggles although slightly changed slopes. The small influence on Tevol results from the fact that this scaling method globally changes the second-order derivative (similar to omegaz) of the vertical potential, leaving its vertical variation less changed. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The systematic bias of 10 Myr corresponds to the slightly biased potential predicted by our method, which could be more intrinsically attributed to the ignorance of the in-plane motions in the 1D orbital integration and the potential radius correction for Rg-binned snails. In addition, the poor constraint on θz,0 results from the fact that a small variation in the slope of Tevol ∼ 500 Myr would lead to a large uncertainty in the intercept θz,0 in the linear fitting.

Appendix EE: Two-armed spiral and secondary branches

The deformation of the frequency contour changes this trend, resulting in a zigzag pattern of the omegaz − θz curve in the middle panel of Fig. B.2.

Appendix FF: Method comparison with previous works

Our work differs from Widmark et al. (2021a) by focusing on the linear relationship of the omegaz − θz curve instead of constructing the analytical function of phase snail. The snail shape curve is extracted from the 2D phase-space density map first and then measured using extracted shape curves. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We attempt to measure the Galactic potential utilizing the snail shape curves. To measure the Galactic potential, we extracted the phase snail shape curves from density contrast maps and transformed them into the vertical frequency-action angle (Ωz − θz) space via orbital integration, then performed linear fitting to derive potential parameters.

Appendix GG: Method verification with test particle simulation

The method performs well in the test particle simulation, with recovered vertical potential profiles in excellent agreement with the input potential models. The snail shape curves extracted are well consistent with the density contrast maps and the toy model snails calculated from the input vertical potential.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved constraint on Galactic potential through combined modeling by including both phase snails and rotation curves to yield a more precise local dark matter density of rho dm sun = 0.0097 + 0.0002 - 0.0021 M sun pc-3.

  2. Enhanced ability to constrain the perturbation time Tevol, with a derived range of 456-738 Myr (median of 564 Myr) and a median initial phase angle theta z 0 close to pi, indicating a downward vertical velocity kick.

  3. More robust discrimination between different potential models by utilizing the linear relation in omega z - theta z space, which is close to a linear relation at all radii, except for the outermost bin with fewer points and larger uncertainties.

  4. Better handling of systematic biases in potential recovery by accounting for the empirical correction of potential radius Rpot for Rg-binned snails, which prevents a systematic underestimation of the vertical potential.

  5. Improved parameter constraint on disk components by showing that different mass models converge on the same total vertical potential encoded in the snail shapes.

Abstract

Aims. Phase spirals found in the vertical phase-space (z-V z) indicate that the Galactic disk is in disequilibrium. Although the origin remains elusive, the wrapping of phase snails is dominated by the vertical potential profiles, naturally encoding potential information in their shapes. Methods. To measure the Galactic potential, we extracted the phase snail shape curves from density contrast maps and transformed them into the vertical frequency-action angle (Ω z - θ z) space via orbital integration, then performed linear fitting to derive potential parameters. We verified our method with a test particle simulation. Results. Our method performs well in the test particle simulation, with the recovered Galactic vertical potential profiles in excellent agreement with the input potential models. We also apply our method to the observed phase snails with guiding center radii in the range of 8 at most R g at most11 kpc. Utilizing snail shape curves only, the model derived vertical potential profiles agree with popular Milky Way potential models. The model yields a Galactic virial mass of M 200= 0.81+0.22-0.23 times10 12, M and a local dark matter density of ρ dm,= 0.0076+0.0019-0.0021, M,pc-3, consistent with the literature, but with a flatter rotation curve than the observation. To better constrain the Galactic potential, we further combine the phase snails and the rotation curve. The improved model results in M 200= 0.87+0.31-0.33 times10 12, M and ρ dm,= 0.0097+0.0002-0.0009, M,pc-3. The high precision of ρ dm, results from the joint constraints in the solar neighborhood. We also obtain an estimation of the perturbation time in a range of 400-750 Myr with a median of 564 Myr, consistent with recent measurements. (abridged)

Sources

Related papers