Deriving physical parameters of unresolved star clusters. X. Size evolution of young star clusters in the M31 disc

arXiv:2611.13836 · astro-ph.GA · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Deriving physical parameters of unresolved star clusters. X. Size evolution of young star clusters in the M31 disc".

Paper summary: Vera: So, to summarize what this paper does, they take their M31 disc cluster parameter catalogue and use it to see how the structural properties change with age.

Jocelyn: They are looking at the half-light radius, or R50, as a key measure of size for these young clusters.

Subrahmanyan: The paper points out a specific trend: they observe that young clusters in M31 disc are compact when they're young, with an R50 of about one point eight two plus zero point seven six minus zero point five seven parsecs, and then they track how this size evolves over time.

Vera: And the key finding they highlight is that these clusters expand rapidly during the first about twenty million years of their lives, more than doubling in size during that period.

Jocelyn: They apply a criterion where they reject unbound objects by using a three sigma clipped statistic, and once they do that, they see a trend where the median R50 increases with age.

Subrahmanyan: The most significant expansion happens within the first about twenty million years when applying that limit, where the median R50 increases by more than a factor of two, from about zero point six parsec to about one point four parsec.

Vera: Then they continue tracking this evolution out to older ages, finding that the median R50 keeps increasing and reaches about two parsecs over the next seven hundred million years.

Jocelyn: They also find a power-law relation for clusters older than about twenty million years, which is R50 proportional to time t with a slope of alpha equal to zero point one two plus or minus zero point zero one.

Subrahmanyan: That power-law index of alpha equal to zero point one two plus or minus zero point zero one suggests a specific rate at which the clusters are expanding after that initial burst. It connects directly to how internal cluster processes drive this change over time.

Conclusion: Vera: So, looking at the title and the authors, Karolis Daugevicius, Eimantas Kriščiūnas, Rima Stonkutė, and Vladas Vansevičius from the Center for Physical Sciences and Technology. This is a team focused on observational astrophysics and structure formation in galactic discs.

Jocelyn: And what this paper ultimately says is that bound clusters in the disc of M31 expand really fast during the first about twenty million years, with their R50 increasing by more than a factor of two.

Subrahmanyan: They conclude that this structural evolution is driven by internal cluster processes, like mass loss due to stellar evolution and two-body relaxation, which means they are gradually evolving towards a tidally limited state where they reach virial equilibrium.

Vera: And importantly for the context of this study, they found no significant dependence of the R50 on the galactocentric distance in M31.

Jocelyn: That lack of dependence suggests that most young M31 disc clusters aren't yet tidally limited by external forces.

Subrahmanyan: So, to put it simply, this paper shows that the early structural changes we see are primarily due to what's happening inside the cluster itself, not because they are being pulled apart by the galaxy.

Vera: That means we can interpret this observed early evolution as expansion of initially compact clusters that aren't tidally limited yet.

Jocelyn: It’s a crucial piece of evidence supporting the idea that internal processes like stellar feedback and gravitational interactions shape how these clusters grow in their infancy.

Karolis Daugevicius, Eimantas Krišciunas, Rima Stonkutພ, Vladas Vansevišcius

Center for Physical Sciences and Technology

astro-ph.GA

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 12 pages, 9 figures, accepted in A&A

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 77/100

The gist: Young clusters in the disc of M 31 are compact (R50 ∼ 1.8 pc) and expand rapidly during the first ∼20 Myr…

Key concepts

R50
This is the median half-light radius of a star cluster, representing its characteristic size. The study found that young M31 clusters start compact (around 1.8 pc) and grow significantly over time, expanding rapidly in the initial phase.
Age-Radius Relation
The paper investigates how the size (radius) of these clusters changes as they get older. For M31, a power-law relationship was found for clusters older than 20 million years, showing that their median radius increases steadily with age.
Internal Cluster Processes
The observed early expansion is attributed to internal mechanisms within the cluster itself. These include mass loss due to stellar evolution and gravitational interactions between stars (two-body relaxation), which drive the clusters away from their initial compact state.
Tidal Limitation
This refers to the point where an external galactic tidal field would eventually halt a cluster's expansion and cause it to reach virial equilibrium. The study found no evidence that M31 clusters are currently tidally limited, meaning their early evolution is dominated by internal dynamics.

Terminology

Summary

Young clusters in the disc of M 31 are compact (R50 ∼ 1. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We perform statistical analysis to determine how cluster structural parameters relate to their physical characteristics and location within the disc. Young clusters in the disc of M 31 are compact (R50 ∼ 1.

8 pc) and expand rapidly during the first ∼20 Myr, more than doubling in size The study aims to examine the structural evolution of M 31 disc clusters and determine how their sizes correlate with physical and spatial properties This research provides constraints on cluster formation and evolution in spiral galaxy discs

Structural Characterization of M 31 Clusters

The analysis utilized the M 31 disc cluster parameter catalogue based on photometric measurements from the Panchromatic Hubble Andromeda Treasury survey data Physical and structural parameters, including age, mass, and extinction, were determined using broad-band HST aperture photometry compared with stochastic stellar population models The final sample consists of 1918 SCs younger than 800 Myr spanning a wide range of mass from ∼300–30 000 M⊙ Cluster size estimates for the MW are taken from the Hunt & Reffert (2024) Gaia SC catalogue, where radii are derived using a different method based on counting cluster member stars The 3σ-clipped statistics show that M 31 clusters have a median half-light radius of R˜50 = 1.82+0.76−0.57 pc.

Evolutionary Trends with Age

Young clusters in the disc of M 31 are compact (R50 ∼ 1.8 pc) and expand rapidly during the first ∼20 Myr, more than doubling in size Once the Π > 1 criterion is applied to reject unbound objects, a trend of the median R50 increasing with age is observed The most significant cluster expansion happens within the first ∼20 Myr, when adopting the Π > 1 limit, the median R50 increases by more than a factor of two—from ∼0. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Once the Π > 1 criterion is applied to reject unbound objects, we observe a trend of the median R50 increasing with age. The most significant cluster expansion happens within the first ∼20 Myr.

6 pc to ∼1.4 pc. At older ages, the median R50 continues to increase, reaching ∼2 pc over the subsequent ∼700 Myr A power-law relation R50 ∝ t α is obtained for clusters older than ∼20 Myr with a slope of α = 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

At older ages, the median R50 continues to increase, albeit at a significantly slower rate, reaching ∼2 pc over the subsequent ∼700 Myr. We quantify the age–radius relation for clusters older than ∼20 Myr, since this sample is largely unaffected by the adopted Π selection and can therefore be determined relatively robustly.

12±0.01.

Mass-Radius Relations and Correlations

For clusters older than 100 Myr, a shallow mass–radius relation emerges for M 31 (R50 ∝ M0.18±0.01) This slope is similar to that found in M 51 by Hwang & Lee (2010) (0. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Nonetheless, the main result remains unchanged: clusters older than 100 Myr in the M 31 disc exhibit a shallow mass–radius relation. The derived slope is similar to that found in M 51 by Hwang & Lee (2010) (0.

16±0.02), but shallower than the relations reported for individual galaxies outside the Local Group or for SC samples combined from multiple nearby galaxies The mass–radius relation is generally consistent with a general scaling of constant density R50 ∝ M1/3

Environmental Dependence and Conclusion

We detect no significant dependence of R50 on galactocentric distance, suggesting that the majority of young M 31 disc clusters are not yet tidally limited This supports our conclusion that the observed early structural evolution in M 31 is driven by internal cluster processes The results suggest that bound clusters undergo rapid expansion during the first ∼20 Myr, increasing their sizes by more than a factor of two This behaviour is similar to recent findings for young clusters in the MW. Beyond 20 Myr, M 31 clusters follow a shallow age–radius relation, R50 ∝ t0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

8 pc) and expand rapidly during the first ∼20 Myr, more than doubling in size. At older ages, M 31 clusters follow a weak age–radius relation (R50 ∝ t 0.

12±0.01 The mass–radius relation varies substantially within the Local Group, indicating that it depends strongly on global galactic environments. p. 1
Where the paper says it

2015, 2017; Brown & Gnedin 2021). Therefore, detailed studies within the Local Group are needed to probe the low-mass regime and obtain a more complete understanding of cluster formation and evolution in star-forming galactic discs.

Summary and Conclusions

We demonstrate that bound clusters in the disc of M 31 undergo rapid expansion during the first ∼20 Myr, with R50 increasing by more than a factor of two We interpret the observed structural evolution as expansion driven by internal cluster processes, such as stellarevolution-driven mass loss and two-body relaxation, gradually evolving towards a tidally limited virialised state Our results are highly consistent with recent findings for young clusters in the MW We find that M 31 disc clusters show no correlation between their sizes and distances from the galactic centre, indicating that external tidal effects are likely to be insignificant in their early evolution The observed early structural evolution in M 31 is driven by internal cluster processes. We therefore interpret the observed early structural evolution of the clusters as expansion of initially compact, not tidally limited clusters, driven mainly by stellarevolution-induced mass loss and two-body relaxation The clusters are gradually evolving towards a tidally limited regime, eventually reaching virial equilibrium. p. 7

Where the paper says it

We therefore interpret the observed early structural evolution of the clusters as expansion of initially compact, not tidally limited clusters, driven mainly by stellarevolution-induced mass loss and two-body relaxation, which happens after the early residual natal gas removal. These clusters are gradually evolving towards a tidally limited regime, eventually reaching virial equilibrium.

We find a rather weak mass–radius relation for clusters younger than 100 Myr In contrast, clusters older than 100 Myr exhibit a clear relation, R50 ∝ M0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A shallow mass–radius relation emerges for clusters older than 100 Myr (R50 ∝ M0. 01), while the trend for younger clusters remains uncertain.

18±0.01 However, this slope, together with the observed mass–radius relations we find for M 33 and MW clusters and those reported in more distant galaxies highlights the need for further theoretical work to consistently explain the wide range of slope variations. p. 0
Where the paper says it

01), while the trend for younger clusters remains uncertain. The diversity of mass–radius relations observed in nearby spiral galaxies, both within and beyond the Local Group, highlights the need for further theoretical work on cluster formation and evolution.

The mass–radius relation likely depends strongly on global galactic environments This variety of scaling values may be driven by differences in pressure, natal gas density, metallicity, tidal field strength, turbulence, the frequency of tidal shocks, and other physical processes governing star formation and cluster evolution. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We further find that M 31 disc clusters show no correlation between their sizes and distances from the galactic centre, indicating that external tidal effects are likely to be insignificant in their early evolution. We therefore interpret the observed early structural evolution of the clusters as expansion of initially compact, not tidally limited clusters, driven mainly by stellarevolution-induced mass loss and two-body relaxation, which happens after the early residual natal gas removal.

How the training signal is built

The structural parameters were determined from growth curves in the ACS/WFC F475W passband which offers the best signal-to-noise and is least affected by contamination from resolved field stars of old M 31 stellar populations The final sample includes clusters younger than 800 Myr spanning a wide range of mass, ∼300–30 000 M⊙ Cluster physical parameters were derived assuming a fixed solar metallicity The analysis used the prescription of Gieles & Portegies Zwart (2011) to distinguish clusters from associations by introducing the dynamical age, Π = t/tcr

Where the gains come from

The similarity of the evolutionary trends between our observational results and the SPHGAL + KETJU models suggests that a similar mechanism—driven by internal cluster processes such as mass loss due to stellar feedback, stellar evolution, and internal gravitational interactions—may be responsible for the early structural evolution of SCs in the M 31 disc N-body simulations of star clusters in which the residual starforming gas has a shallower density profile than the embedded stellar component show that, within the first 20 Myr after gas expulsion, clusters can lose a large fraction of their mass and expand substantially This provides further support for interpreting our observational results as evidence of a similar phase of rapid early cluster expansion The offset in cluster size between M 31 SCs and SPHGAL + KETJU tracks is most likely a cluster mass effect—all simulated clusters have masses ≲800 M⊙, whereas the majority of SCs in our sample are ≳1000 M⊙ The similarity between observations and the state-of-the-art modelling results is nevertheless encouraging

Mass–Radius Relation Analysis

Figure 9 shows that for clusters older than 100 Myr, we obtain a more robust relation, R50 ∝ M0.18±0.01 The derived slope is similar to that found in M 51 by Hwang & Lee (2010) (0. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Nonetheless, the main result remains unchanged: clusters older than 100 Myr in the M 31 disc exhibit a shallow mass–radius relation. The derived slope is similar to that found in M 51 by Hwang & Lee (2010) (0.

16±0.02), but shallower than the relations reported for individual galaxies outside the Local Group or for SC samples combined from multiple nearby galaxies The MW shows a significantly shallower relation, R50 ∝ M0. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The derived slope is similar to that found in M 51 by Hwang & Lee (2010) (0. 02), but shallower than the relations reported for individual galaxies outside the Local Group or for SC samples combined from multiple nearby galaxies (R50 ∝ M0.

06±0.01 This trend is consistent with results reported for some galaxies beyond the Local Group The derived slope is similar to that found in M 51 by Hwang & Lee (2010) (0. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The derived slope is similar to that found in M 51 by Hwang & Lee (2010) (0. 02), but shallower than the relations reported for individual galaxies outside the Local Group or for SC samples combined from multiple nearby galaxies (R50 ∝ M0.

16±0.02), but shallower than the relations reported for individual galaxies outside the Local Group or for SC samples combined from multiple nearby galaxies The mass–radius relation is steeper than the Gieles & Renaud (2016) equilibrium relation (R50 ∝ M1/9), yet significantly shallower than the R50 ∝ M1/2 (Choksi & Kruijssen 2021), or R50 ∝ M1/3 (Grudic et al. p. 9
Where the paper says it

2019; Brown & Gnedin 2021). It is steeper than the Gieles & Renaud (2016) equilibrium relation (R50 ∝ M1/9 ), yet significantly shallower than the R50 ∝ M1/2 (Choksi & Kruijssen 2021), or R50 ∝ M1/3 (Grudic et al.

´ 2021) scaling relations The inner blue dashed contour encloses 39. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The blue dashed contours represent KDEs, with the inner contour denoting an area enclosing 39. 3% of the KDE integral around the KDE peak (corresponding to a 1σ region), while the outer one encloses 86.

3% (1σ region) of the KDE integral around the KDE peak, while the outer one encloses 86. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The blue dashed contours represent KDEs, with the inner contour denoting an area enclosing 39. 3% of the KDE integral around the KDE peak (corresponding to a 1σ region), while the outer one encloses 86.

5% (2σ region)

Conclusion

In summary, we demonstrate that bound clusters in the disc of M 31 undergo rapid expansion during the first ∼20 Myr, with R50 increasing by more than a factor of two We detect no significant dependence of R50 on galactocentric distance, suggesting that the majority of young M 31 disc clusters are not yet tidally limited This further supports our conclusion that the observed early structural evolution in M 31 is driven by internal cluster processes We therefore interpret the observed early structural evolution of the clusters as expansion of initially compact, not tidally limited clusters, driven mainly by stellarevolution-induced mass loss and two-body relaxation The clusters are gradually evolving towards a tidally limited regime, eventually reaching virial equilibrium This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED), which is funded by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and operated by the California Institute of Technology It is based on observations made with the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope, and obtained from the Hubble Legacy Archive Computations were performed on the supercomputer GALAX of the Center for Physical Sciences and Technology, Lithuania The paper is structured as follows; in Sec. 2, we describe the cluster parameter catalogue used in this study In Sec. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The paper is structured as follows. 2, we describe the cluster parameter catalogue used in this study.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The paper is structured as follows. 2, we describe the cluster parameter catalogue used in this study.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The paper is structured as follows. 2, we describe the cluster parameter catalogue used in this study.

3, we examine the structural evolution of clusters with age In Sec. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Therefore, we cannot conclude that the observed trend – which is similar to that seen in M 31 – reflects a genuine structural evolution of MW clusters, especially given that the method used to measure the radii for Galactic SCs is fundamentally different, as discussed in Sec. Beyond ∼30 Myr, the MW cluster population follows an age–radius relation identical to that found for M 31, with a slope of α = 0.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Therefore, we cannot conclude that the observed trend – which is similar to that seen in M 31 – reflects a genuine structural evolution of MW clusters, especially given that the method used to measure the radii for Galactic SCs is fundamentally different, as discussed in Sec. Beyond ∼30 Myr, the MW cluster population follows an age–radius relation identical to that found for M 31, with a slope of α = 0.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Therefore, we cannot conclude that the observed trend – which is similar to that seen in M 31 – reflects a genuine structural evolution of MW clusters, especially given that the method used to measure the radii for Galactic SCs is fundamentally different, as discussed in Sec. Beyond ∼30 Myr, the MW cluster population follows an age–radius relation identical to that found for M 31, with a slope of α = 0.

4, we investigate the cluster mass–radius relation Finally, in Sec. p. 1
Where the paper says it

4, we investigate the cluster mass–radius relation. Finally, in Sec.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

4, we investigate the cluster mass–radius relation. Finally, in Sec.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

4, we investigate the cluster mass–radius relation. Finally, in Sec.

5, we summarise our results and present conclusions The paper is structured as follows; in Sec. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Finally, in Sec. 5, we summarise our results and present conclusions.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Finally, in Sec. 5, we summarise our results and present conclusions.

2, we describe the cluster parameter catalogue used in this study In Sec. 3, we examine the structural evolution of clusters with age In Sec. 4, we investigate the cluster mass–radius relation Finally, in Sec. 5, we summarise our results and present conclusions The paper is structured as follows; in Sec. 2, we describe the cluster parameter catalogue used in this study In Sec. 3, we examine the structural evolution of clusters with age In Sec. 4, we investigate the cluster mass–radius relation Finally, in Sec. 5, we summarise our results and present conclusions. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Finally, in Sec. 5, we summarise our results and present conclusions.

References

Adamo, A., Ryon, J. E., Messa, M., et al. 2017, ApJ, 841, 131

Bastian, N., Adamo, A. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Therefore, to achieve a more complete understanding of cluster formation and evolution across diverse disc environments (Krumholz et al. 2019; Adamo et al.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Therefore, to achieve a more complete understanding of cluster formation and evolution across diverse disc environments (Krumholz et al. 2019; Adamo et al.

, Gieles, M. p. 0
Where the paper says it

2020; Webb & Sills 2021) – extragalactic SCs must be studied. Although kinematic data are scarce beyond the MW and are hampered by the effects of binaries (Gieles et al.

, et al. 2012, MNRAS, 419, 2606

Brown, G. & Gnedin, O. p. 0

Where the paper says it

2024), and direct real-time observation of cluster evolution is impossible due to astronomical timescales, statistically large cluster samples allow us to investigate how structural parameters vary and correlate with other cluster properties, such as their age, mass, and location within the host galaxy (Ryon et al. 2015; Brown & Gnedin 2021; Tang et al.

Y. 2021, MNRAS, 508, 5935

Gieles, M., & Portegies Zwart, S. p. 0

Where the paper says it

galaxies: star clusters: general – galaxies: individual: M 31 1. Introduction Since the majority of stars form in clustered environments (Lada & Lada 2003; Portegies Zwart et al.

F. 2011, MNRAS, 410, L6

Lahén, N., Rantala, A., Naab, T., et al. 2025, MNRAS, 538, 2129

Ryon, J. E., Bastian, N. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Considering individual nearby spiral galaxies, the SC population in M 51 has been studied extensively. Using HST WFPC2+NICMOS3 data, Bastian et al.

, Adamo, A., et al. 2015, MNRAS, 452, 525

Brown & Gnedin (2021)

Choksi & Kruijssen (2021)

Grudic et al. 2023

Heggie & Hut, P. 2003

Hunt & Reffert, S. 2024

Lahén et al. 2025

Zepf et al.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved system can perform detailed structural evolution analysis by incorporating dynamical age selection criteria, as described in Section 3, to distinguish bound clusters from associations using a ratio of cluster age to crossing time (Π = t/tcr).

  2. Improved system can accurately model and predict the trend of cluster half-light radius R50 as a function of age by fitting power-law relations (R50 proportional to t alpha) across different mass intervals, specifically identifying the rapid early expansion phase within 20 Myr.

  3. Improved system can assess the influence of environmental effects on cluster structure by performing statistical analysis on the correlation between cluster size and galactocentric distance (RGC), confirming whether observed structural evolution is driven by internal processes or galactic tidal fields.

  4. Improved system can derive the mass radius relation for star clusters, specifically determining the power-law index of R50 as a function of mass, distinguishing between young clusters younger than 100 Myr and older ones.

  5. Improved system can compare observational results with theoretical models by assessing the similarity between observed structural evolution trends and those from simulations like SPHGAL + KETJU models, noting where mass effects might cause offsets in cluster size.

Abstract

Context. Star cluster structural properties and their correlations with other cluster parameters (age, mass, galactocentric distance) provide key constraints on cluster formation and dynamical evolution within star-forming galactic discs. In the tenth paper of this series, we analysed structural parameters of 1918 young star clusters (up to 800 Myr) in the disc of M31. Aims. We aim to examine the structural evolution of M31 disc clusters and determine how their sizes correlate with physical and spatial properties. Our goal is to improve the understanding of cluster formation and evolution in spiral galaxy discs. Methods. We use the M31 disc cluster parameter catalogue based on photometric measurements of the Panchromatic Hubble Andromeda Treasury survey data. We perform statistical analysis to determine how cluster structural parameters relate to their physical characteristics and location within the disc. Results. Young clusters in the disc of M31 are compact (R 50 about1.8 pc) and expand rapidly during the first about 20 Myr, more than doubling in size. At older ages, M31 clusters follow a weak age-radius relation (R 50 proportional to t 0.12 plus or minus0.01,,). We find no significant correlation between cluster size and galactocentric distance, indicating that internal processes dominate their early evolution, with minimal impact from the galactic tidal field. Our results suggest that stellar-evolution-driven mass loss and internal dynamical interactions are likely drivers of early cluster structural evolution in the M31 disc. A shallow mass-radius relation emerges for clusters older than 100 Myr (R 50 proportional to M 0.18 plus or minus0.01,,), while the trend for younger clusters remains uncertain. The diversity of mass-radius relations observed in nearby spiral galaxies, both within and beyond the Local Group, highlights the need for further theoretical work on cluster formation and evolution.

Sources

Related papers