AGN feedback destroying group cool cores --- a case study on IC 2476 with a remnant radio AGN and an exceptionally low abundance

arXiv:2611.13506 · astro-ph.HE · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "AGN feedback destroying group cool cores --- a case study on IC 2476 with a remnant radio AGN and an exceptionally low abundance".

Title and authors: Vera: So we're diving into the title of this work now: "AGN feedback destroying group cool cores --- a case study on IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six with a remnant radio AGN and an exceptionally low abundance <ref:2611.13506#pg1,AGN feedback destroying group cool cores --- a case study on IC 2476>." It sets up exactly what we’re looking at.

Jocelyn: It tells us we aren't just looking at active feedback, but also the aftermath—the remnant radio AGN—and linking that to something unusual: this exceptionally low abundance of elements.

Subrahmanyan: The title suggests a few things: first, it's about groups, not just massive clusters where we see feedback more clearly. Second, it’s about the destruction of the cool core structure itself.

Vera: And because they use IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six as a case study, they are focusing on how this process plays out in systems that aren't necessarily the largest or brightest ones we typically analyze <ref:2611.13506#pg1>.

Jocelyn: So, what this means for us is that we have to be careful not to assume feedback effects scale linearly between groups and clusters; the paper warns us about that difference.

Subrahmanyan: Precisely. The title implies that AGN feedback might operate differently in groups because of the shallower gravitational potential, and this study is designed to test those differences by looking at a system where we can see the remnant effects clearly.

Vera: So, when we look at IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six we're essentially checking if that past powerful radio AGN outburst actually left a permanent scar on the gas structure, even though its current output is very low <ref:2611.13506#pg1>.

Jocelyn: It’s a study of the long-term consequences of energy injection into the hot gas within these smaller structures.

The paper's summary: Vera: The summary of this paper highlights that they used deep XMM-Newton observations to capture this rare feedback regime where the central radio AGN has stopped its activity, but its radio lobes are still detectable.

Jocelyn: They found a compact cool core with a size of about ten kiloparsecs and a moderate X-ray luminosity of about three point four times ten to forty erg per second for IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six <ref:2611.13506#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: The summary points out the unusual low temperature within that cool core, around zero point four five kiloelectron volts, and the exceptionally low abundance below zero point two solar in the central region.

Vera: That low abundance is a key finding they highlight because it’s hard to reconcile with what we usually see in other galaxy groups where iron abundance is typically higher near the center.

Jocelyn: They also mentioned that the X-ray surface brightness isn't symmetric and shows a clear depression in the region overlaid with the eastern radio lobe, which suggests an X-ray cavity.

Subrahmanyan: So, in short, they found evidence of a cool core being disrupted by past activity, even though we don't see the central engine firing right now.

Vera: They also detailed the thermal structure analysis showing that the gas initially at zero point six zero kiloelectron volts would cool to about zero point five eight kiloelectron volts over fifty million years, which is higher than what they actually measured in IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six <ref:2611.13506#pg1>.

Jocelyn: And they looked at the scaled entropy profile rising steeply to about zero point zero four times r five hundred and then becoming flat from zero point zero four to zero point one times r five hundred.

Subrahmanyan: That flatness in the entropy profile is a direct indicator of that high injection of energy from past AGN activity that's outside the central cool core itself.

The paper's improvements: Vera: Now, the paper suggests some ways to improve this research, and they bring up several points about how we can better model these feedback cycles.

Jocelyn: One improvement they suggest is that AI systems could accurately model AGN feedback cycles by incorporating time-dependent models of radio AGN activity, like what R. J. Turner suggested about IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six being at a particular stage of the cycle <ref:2611.13506#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: That would be really useful for us because it moves the study from a static snapshot to understanding the actual cycle dynamics, which is crucial for theoretical work on structure formation.

Vera: Another suggestion involves better predicting cool core disruption mechanisms by using the findings that the past powerful radio AGN outburst in IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six has disrupted the cool core and that the X-ray cavity has dissipated or mixed with surrounding hot gas since the central AGN shut down <ref:2611.13506#pg1>.

Jocelyn: That links back to my point about cavity dynamics, suggesting we need models that account for how those cavities dissipate over time rather than treating them as instantaneous features.

Subrahmanyan: And then there's the idea of using a generalized NFW model for pressure fitting to get more robust mass estimates, like the one they used to find a total mass of about one point seven five times ten to thirteen solar masses at r two thousand five hundred and a gas fraction of about zero point zero three.

Vera: That's good, because those generalized models should give us more reliable constraints on the total mass distribution of the group.

Jocelyn: And for interpreting the low iron abundance, they suggest integrating the possibility that inverse Compton scattering of CMB photons by low energy cosmic rays can produce X-rays with nearly thermal spectra that mimic cool core emission in groups and clusters.

Subrahmanyan: That's a big one because it offers an alternative explanation for why we see these thermal signatures in groups when the metal enrichment history looks so weird.

Conclusion: Vera: So to wrap up this paper on "AGN feedback destroying group cool cores --- a case study on IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six with a remnant radio AGN and an exceptionally low abundance," it really shows that AGN feedback has a very long-lasting impact <ref:2611.13506#pg1,AGN feedback destroying group cool cores --- a case study on IC 2476>.

Jocelyn: It’s not just about what the engine is doing right now; it's about the history of powerful outbursts shaping the thermal structure we see today in these groups.

Subrahmanyan: The results reinforce how critical this feedback mechanism is in shaping the thermal evolution of galaxy groups, showing its effect extends long after the central engine has turned off.

Vera: IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six gives us a clear picture of a system in a late post-outburst or quiescent stage where the imprint of that previous, more powerful AGN episode is still visible despite the moderate present-day radio luminosity <ref:2611.13506#pg1>.

Jocelyn: So we see disturbed thermal structure, compact cool core corona, and elevated central entropy suggesting this group is in a phase where the memory of past activity remains strong.

Subrahmanyan: The long-lasting impact of AGN activity in galaxy groups is clearly demonstrated by this case study on IC two thousand four hundred seventy-six <ref:2611.13506#pg1,case study on IC 2476>.

Vera: It’s a powerful example for us to consider when we try to understand how energy is transferred from the AGN out into the surrounding medium over vast timescales.

Jocelyn: And it keeps pushing us to look for those subtle signatures, like the X-ray cavity dynamics, even when the immediate radio activity is gone.

Wenhao Liu, Ming Sun, Paul Nulsen, Marisa Brienza, Craig Sarazin, Dominique Eckert, Prathamesh Tamhane

Purple Mountain Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing, Jiangsu People’s Republic of China School of Astronomy and Space Sciences, University of Science and Technology of China Hefei People’s Republic of China Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Alabama in Huntsville Huntsville Alabama USA ICRAR University of Western Australia Center for Astrophysics Harvard and Smithsonian INAF Istituto di Radioastronomia Bologna Italy Department of Astronomy University of Virginia Charlottesville Virginia USA Department of Astronomy University of Geneva Versoix Switzerland Tsung-Dao Lee Institute and Key Laboratory for Particle Physics, Astrophysics and Cosmology Ministry of Education Shanghai Jiao Tong University Shanghai People’s Republic of China

astro-ph.HE

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 15 pages, 12 figures, ApJ accepted

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: AGN feedback destroying group cool cores — a case study on IC 2476 with a remnant radio AGN and an exceptionally low abundance is presented to illustrate how past powerful radio AGN outbursts can…

Key concepts

Cool Core
A dense, hot region at the center of a galaxy group characterized by relatively low gas temperature and high density. In IC 2476, this core shows unusually low temperatures and steep entropy profiles, indicating it has been disrupted by past energy injections.
AGN Feedback
The process where energy from an active supermassive black hole (AGN) heats or pushes surrounding gas in a galaxy group. In this case, the past powerful radio AGN outbursts injected significant energy that altered the core's thermal structure and entropy profile long after the central engine stopped.
X-ray Cavity
A region of lower X-ray surface brightness within the hot intragroup medium, often associated with past radio jet activity. In IC 2476, a cavity was suggested by a depression coinciding with an eastern radio lobe, hinting at where the hot gas may have mixed with the radio plasma.

Terminology

Summary

AGN feedback destroying group cool cores — a case study on IC 2476 with a remnant radio AGN and an exceptionally low abundance is presented to illustrate how past powerful radio AGN outbursts can disrupt the cool core of galaxy groups, even when the central engine is currently inactive

System Properties and Observations

The study utilized deep XMM-Newton observations of the galaxy group IC 2476 to capture a rare AGN feedback regime where the central radio AGN has ceased activity but its radio lobes remain detectable The hot intragroup medium of IC 2476 features a compact cool core with a size of approximately 10 kpc and a moderate X-ray luminosity of about 3.4 × 10 40 erg s−1 Measurements revealed an unusually low temperature of about 0. p. 045 keV within the cool core and an exceptionally low abundance below about 0. p. 02 solar, even in the central region The X-ray surface brightness of the group is not symmetric and shows a clear depression in the region overlaid with the eastern radio lobe, suggesting the presence of an X-ray cavity

Thermal Structure Analysis

The thermal properties of IC 2476 reveal a low gas temperature within its central cool core, which is below 0.5 keV, a finding that is not usually seen in the core region of galaxy groups The cooling time within the cool core corona corresponds to approximately 0. p. 88 Gyr, and assuming isobaric radiative cooling and a constant cooling time, the gas initially at kT0 = 0. p. 960 keV in the core would cool to approximately as T ≈ T0e−0. p. 96t/tcool = T0e−0. p. 904 ∼ 0.58 keV over 50 Myr, which is higher than the value found in the cool core of IC 2476 The scaled entropy profile of galaxy group IC 2476 rises steeply to about 0. p. 904 r500 and becomes flat from 0. p. 504 − 0.1 r500, and this plateau is higher than the scaled entropy profiles of other galaxy groups with similar system temperatures, which indicates a high injection of energy from the past activity of central AGN outside the central cool core

Remnant Activity and Cavity Dynamics

The radio observations show that the central radio AGN of IC 2476 is currently off, although the radio lobes from the past AGN have not faded yet The X-ray cavity, suggested by a surface brightness depression in the eastern wedge coinciding with the eastern radio lobe, shows no obvious boundary suggesting that the X-ray gas may have mixed with the radio plasma across this boundary The estimated cavity power is about 4.3 × 10 58 erg, and when compared to jet power estimates, the discrepancy may be due to factors like plasma mixing or the fact that the cavity power calculation is based on buoyant rise time which can be much larger than the active time for the radio jets

Chemical Enrichment History

A remarkably low iron abundance of ≤0.2 solar was measured in the intragroup medium of IC 2476 from the central region out to large radii, which may indicate inefficient enrichment and/or retention of metals in the hot intragroup medium This low abundance profile is difficult to reconcile with previous studies on galaxy clusters and groups where iron abundance is generally higher in the central region and decreases toward larger radii The exceptionally low iron abundance suggests that the metal enrichment history of IC 2476 differs substantially from other systems, potentially reflecting the combined effect of gas accretion, metal loss, and AGN-driven redistribution

Conclusion on Feedback Impact

The study demonstrates that the galaxy group IC 2476 provides an important case showing that AGN feedback is capable of destroying a group cool core, highlighting the long-lasting impact of AGN activity in galaxy groups despite the moderate present-day radio luminosity The disturbed thermal structure, compact cool core corona, and elevated central entropy suggest that IC 2476 is currently observed in a late post-outburst or quiescent evolutionary stage where the imprint of a previous, more powerful AGN episode remains visible long after the central engine has shut down The results reinforce the critical role of feedback in shaping the thermal evolution of galaxy groups

Acknowledgments

We thank the referee for important comments and suggestions that improved this manuscript This work is supported by various national and international funding agencies, including the National Key Research and Development Program of China (2023YFA1608100) MB acknowledges financial support from Next Generation EU funds within the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR) XZ acknowledges support by the Office of Science and Technology, Shanghai Municipal Government (grant Nos.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can accurately model AGN feedback cycles in galaxy groups by incorporating time-dependent models of radio AGN activity, as suggested by R. J. Turner's work that IC 2476 is at a particular stage of AGN feedback cycle and it is an excellent target for us to study the cycle of radio AGN feedback.

  2. The improved system can better predict the disruption mechanism of cool cores in groups by utilizing the findings that the past powerful radio AGN outburst in IC 2476 has disrupted the cool core and the X-ray cavity has dissipated or mixed with the surrounding hot gas since the shutdown of the central AGN.

  3. AI systems can perform more robust mass estimation for galaxy groups by implementing a generalized NFW model for pressure fitting, as this method was used to obtain a total mass of ∼ 1.75 x 1013 Msun at r2500 and a gas fraction of ∼ 0.03, which was found to be consistent with previous results within one sigma error.

  4. The system can better interpret low iron abundance measurements by integrating the possibility that "inverse-Compton (IC) scattering of CMB photons by low energy (∼ 0.1 − 1 GeV) Cosmic Rays (CRs; lifetime of ≥ Gyr) can produce ∼ keV X-rays with nearly thermal X-ray spectra, mimicking cool core emission in groups and clusters."

  5. Improved AI can assess the underestimation of cavity power by accounting for the fact that the cavity power is based on the buoyant rise time, which can be much larger than the active time for the radio jets, suggesting a need to use a timeaveraged cavity power rather than just jet power estimates.

Sources

Related papers