Scale separation and partial supersymmetry breaking

arXiv:2611.13130 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-11-09 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Scale separation and partial supersymmetry breaking".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We propose new candidate string theory vacua in which partial supersymmetry breaking occurs within the lower-dimensional effective theory in anti-de Sitter space The construction gives three-dimensional anti-de Sitter solutions of massless type IIA supergravity with smeared O6-planes, whose effective action is reproduced by a three-dimensional N = 2 gauged supergravity with an N = 1 anti-de Sitter vacuum Scale separation and partial supersymmetry breaking are therefore realized dynamically and simultaneously, allowing the latter to be studied within the lower-dimensional effective description.

Kai: Model Construction The model under consideration arises as a variant of a setup recently put forward in

32: The geometry of the internal space is described by an orientifold of the toroidal orbifold T˜6/Z2 × Z2, which is compactified on a circle without an additional orbifold action.

Mira: This setup involves an Iwasawa nilmanifold T˜6 and specifies the geometry using left-invariant one-forms ηi satisfying Maurer–Cartan equations The SU(3) structure on M7 is specified by a real two-form J and a locally decomposable complex three-form omega.

Kai: Flux and Geometry The orbifold and orientifold projections restrict the left-invariant forms on which the internal fields can be expanded, fixing the metric to be diagonal in terms of left-invariant one-forms compatible with the projections.

Title and authors: Mira: We just talked about how they find these new candidate string theory vacua that feature partial supersymmetry breaking in the lower-dimensional effective theory within anti-de Sitter space. They are solving the equations of motion for massless type IIA supergravity in the smeared approximation and showing they exhibit scale separation at both weak and strong coupling.

Kai: It's interesting because they show how this setup is reproduced as N equals one supersymmetric phases of a three dimensional N equals two gauged supergravity, which is a specific kind of theory we can actually analyze.

Lev: When you look at the geometry, they use an orientifold of the toroidal orbifold T6 over Z2 times Z2, and then they fix the metric using left invariant one forms that satisfy Maurer cartan equations.

Mira: They specify the SU(three) structure on their seven dimensional space by defining a real two form J and a locally decomposable complex three form Omega, which are constrained by T6 <ref:2611.13130#pg2>.

Kai: And they determine the torsion classes w1, w2, and w3 explicitly using those metric fluxes a i to lock down the geometry imposed by the projections.

Lev: The main thing I'm wondering is how this geometric machinery translates into actual physics that we can measure or simulate on real hardware.

Mira: They analyze the supersymmetry in the left invariant sector and find that there is no left invariant N equals one one extension compatible with their chosen projections, which they extend to coordinate dependent spinors smooth on the covering space at a common fixed point.

Kai: That algebraic contradiction is what rules out those N equals one one enhancements, which is a strong piece of evidence against a simple supersymmetric extension.

Lev: So they're saying that even if you try to push for that higher supersymmetry in this setup, the geometry itself stops it cold before you even get to the actual breaking mechanism.

Mira: Then they connect this back to gauged supergravity, where it spontaneously breaks supersymmetry such that only N equals one is preserved on the vacuum.

Kai: And they pinpoint exactly where the breaking happens: they find that the r equals two sector preserves supersymmetry while its r equals one sector exhibits partial supersymmetry breaking at the anti-de Sitter scale.

Lev: That distinction between the sectors sounds useful for understanding where things are stable, right?

Mira: Exactly. And then they show how to achieve parametric scale separation by relating internal radii to the anti-de Sitter radius and string coupling across weak and strong coupling regimes.

The paper's summary: Kai: So we've covered the main findings, but what about the improvements they suggest for this setup? They seem to be pushing beyond just describing it.

Mira: They suggest that their method provides a way to clarify the obstructions they found in analyzing higher supersymmetry by systematically tracing how geometric constraints like SU(three) structures and O6-plane projections restrict spinor components <ref:2611.13130#pg2>.

Lev: I'm hoping this means we get a better handle on what those obstructions actually mean physically, not just abstract algebra.

Kai: And they also suggest an enhancement in determining the structure of four form flux parameters by solving the algebraic equation Xfour i equals two for various flux configurations.

Mira: That would give us explicit conditions for moduli stabilization, which is crucial because those are the things that usually make these models work or fail.

Lev: If you can explicitly determine those conditions, it moves this from a conceptual idea to something that could actually be tested with numerical simulation overhead.

Kai: And they also improve the way they perform dimensional reduction and matching between ten dimensional supergravity and three dimensional gauged supergravity by correctly identifying how axionic gaugings resolve discrepancies in supersymmetry counting.

Mira: That's important because it fixes a known problem where people often get confused about how axionic gaugings should affect the counting of supersymmetries.

Lev: So they are fixing some of the inconsistencies in the mapping between theories, which is a significant step for any researcher working on this kind of thing.

Kai: And finally, they improve the precision in calculating the three dimensional scalar potential by systematically collecting contributions from internal curvature, NS/RR field strengths, external two form fluxes and O6 tensions into the full potential expression.

Mira: That means we get a much more accurate picture of the vacuum energy landscape without having to guess which terms are dominant.

Lev: Accurate potentials are always better for testing than just rough estimates that you can't trust when you try to run them on real hardware.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, wrapping up "Scale separation and partial supersymmetry breaking", the main implication is that scale separation might favor minimal supersymmetry through a nontrivial interplay between partial supersymmetry breaking and geometric restrictions imposed by the geometry and sources.

Mira: This construction realizes partial supersymmetry breaking parametrically below the Kaluza-Klein scale.

Lev: The gravitino associated with the broken supersymmetry has a mass parameter of three over two times the anti-de Sitter radius, which means it breaks at that anti-de Sitter scale, so partial supersymmetry breaking happens parametrically below the Kaluza-Klein scale.

Kai: This work provides a preliminary consistency check for a possible eleven dimensional uplift in the strong coupling regime.

Mira: It points toward new avenues to study how these features manifest in real string theory.

Lev: For me, it's just that this gives us a target structure to aim for when we design systems that need to be built.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've looked at the paper "Scale separation and partial supersymmetry breaking," which is about finding these new candidate string theory vacua where you get partial supersymmetry breaking in the low dimensional effective theory inside anti-de Sitter space.

Mira: Right, and what they found is that by looking at massless type IIA supergravity with smeared O6 planes, you can reproduce it with a three dimensional N equals two gauged supergravity.

Lev: That mapping is key because it means the physics we see in the lower dimension actually has a description in terms of a gauged theory, which is something you can actually study.

Kai: They show that scale separation and partial supersymmetry breaking are realized dynamically and at the same time, which is pretty neat because it lets you study the latter within that lower dimensional description.

Mira: The geometry they use involves an orientifold of the six torus over Z two times Z two, compactified on a circle without extra orbifold actions.

Lev: They fix the metric using left invariant one forms that satisfy Maurer cartan equations to describe the internal space structure.

Kai: And they define the su three structure on their seven dimensional space using a real two form J and a complex three form Omega constrained by the torus.

Mira: They then determine all those torsion classes w one, w two, and w three explicitly using those metric fluxes a i that are present in the setup.

Lev: The analysis of supersymmetry in the left invariant sector is where they find something interesting—there is no left invariant n equals one one extension compatible with their chosen projections.

Kai: They even extend this to coordinate dependent spinors smooth on the covering space at a common fixed point, and that algebraic contradiction rules out those n equals one one enhancements.

Mira: Then they connect this to the effective three dimensional description, which is a gauged n equals two supergravity that spontaneously breaks supersymmetry down to just n equals one on the vacuum.

Lev: The vacuum analysis shows that the r equal two sector preserves supersymmetry, but the r equal one sector has partial supersymmetry breaking at the anti-de Sitter scale.

Kai: And they show they can get parametric scale separation by making all internal radii parametrically large in string units under certain flux scalings.

Mira: This scale separation happens at both weak and strong string coupling, with explicit scaling relations provided for the internal radii, the string coupling, and the anti-de Sitter radius.

Lev: The conclusion is that scale separation might favor minimal supersymmetry because of how partial supersymmetry breaking interacts with geometric restrictions imposed by the geometry and those sources.

Kai: They realize partial supersymmetry breaking parametrically below the Kaluza-Klein scale, which is a big deal for understanding where things break down.

Mira: These solutions give a preliminary check for eleven dimensional uplift in the strong coupling regime.

Lev: The paper also details how O6 plane charge and tadpole cancellation work, determining the O6 plane charge based on counting them on the twisted torus.

Kai: Direct dimensional reduction gives you a three dimensional bosonic effective action that includes scalar kinetic terms, a vector kinetic term, and a scalar potential.

Mira: The potential at zero axions matches what they get from direct dimensional reduction in appendix B.

Lev: The complete first order action replaces the Maxwell term with a bf coupling and reproduces the full potential including contributions from internal curvature, fluxes, and O6 tensions.

Kai: You get a vector kinetic term that acquires a mass of order the anti-de Sitter scale, which is about e four D cubed over nine y squared.

Mira: The scalar potential at zero axions comes out to be something like e four D cubed over thirty six, which matches the einstein equation when you use l ad s equal six over delta.

Lev: And the gravitino associated with the broken supersymmetry has a mass parameter of three over two times l three equals eight over l ad s, so supersymmetry breaking occurs at that anti-de Sitter scale.

Kai: So basically, they found a way to get partial supersymmetry breaking parametrically below the Kaluza-Klein scale in this setup.

Mira: This work really suggests that partial supersymmetry breaking is favored by the interplay between the geometry and those sources.

Lev: It’s a good starting point for seeing how these concepts can actually be built into real hardware simulations.

Kai: We're looking forward to seeing how these findings fit with what we're building for our qubit experiments next week.

Niccoló Cribiori, Fotis Farakos, Alexandros Zarafonitis

KU Leuven · National Technical University of Athens

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-11-09

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 52 pages

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 69/100

The gist: We propose new candidate string theory vacua in which partial supersymmetry breaking occurs within the lower-dimensional effective theory in anti-de Sitter space The construction gives…

Key concepts

Partial Supersymmetry Breaking
This means that not all supersymmetry is broken in the vacuum. In this model, only one fraction of the original supersymmetry is preserved on average. This breaking occurs parametrically below the Kaluza-Klein scale, meaning it happens at a much lower energy level than expected.
Scale Separation
This describes a situation where different physical scales—like the size of internal dimensions and string coupling—can be made very large relative to each other. The model achieves this by making all internal radii parametrically large, allowing the theory to be studied consistently at both weak and strong string coupling regimes.
O6-planes
These are specific geometric objects in string theory that carry a certain charge. In this construction, they are smeared over the internal space. Their presence is crucial for satisfying tadpole cancellation conditions, which ensures the consistency of the theory at different dimensions.
Gauged Supergravity
This is a lower-dimensional description of string theory where supersymmetry is spontaneously broken by introducing gauge fields. The paper uses an N=2 gauged supergravity to describe the effective three-dimensional physics, which naturally leads to the observed partial supersymmetry breaking pattern.

Terminology

Summary

We propose new candidate string theory vacua in which partial supersymmetry breaking occurs within the lower-dimensional effective theory in anti-de Sitter space The construction gives three-dimensional anti-de Sitter solutions of massless type IIA supergravity with smeared O6-planes, whose effective action is reproduced by a three-dimensional N = 2 gauged supergravity with an N = 1 anti-de Sitter vacuum Scale separation and partial supersymmetry breaking are therefore realized dynamically and simultaneously, allowing the latter to be studied within the lower-dimensional effective description. p. 0

Model Construction

The model under consideration arises as a variant of a setup recently put forward in [32] The geometry of the internal space is described by an orientifold of the toroidal orbifold T˜6/Z2 × Z2, which is compactified on a circle without an additional orbifold action. This setup involves an Iwasawa nilmanifold T˜6 and specifies the geometry using left-invariant one-forms ηi satisfying Maurer–Cartan equations The SU(3) structure on M7 is specified by a real two-form J and a locally decomposable complex three-form omega. p. 5

Flux and Geometry

The orbifold and orientifold projections restrict the left-invariant forms on which the internal fields can be expanded, fixing the metric to be diagonal in terms of left-invariant one-forms compatible with the projections. The SU(3) structure is specified by J ∈ Λ2−(T˜6), Re omega ∈ Λ3+(T˜6), and Im omega ∈ Λ3−(T˜6). p. 5 The torsion classes w1, w2, and w3 are explicitly determined by the metric fluxes a i. p. 4

Supersymmetry Analysis

The analysis of the supersymmetry in the left-invariant sector shows that there is no left-invariant N = (1, 1) extension compatible with the chosen projections. The argument extends to coordinate-dependent spinors smooth on the covering space at a common fixed point, where an algebraic contradiction leads to the exclusion of N = (1, 1) enhancements. p. 1

Gauged Supergravity and Breaking

The effective three-dimensional description is reproduced by a gauged N = 2 supergravity, which spontaneously breaks supersymmetry such that only N = 1 is preserved on the vacuum. The vacuum analysis shows that the r = 2 sector preserves supersymmetry, while the r = 1 sector exhibits partial supersymmetry breaking at the anti-de Sitter scale. p. 3

Scale Separation and Coupling Dependence

The solutions admit parametric scale separation with all internal radii parametrically large in string units under certain conditions on flux scalings. This scale separation is realized simultaneously at both weak and strong string coupling, with explicit scaling relations provided for the internal radii, string coupling, and the anti-de Sitter radius. p. 3

Conclusion

The work suggests that scale separation may favor minimal supersymmetry through a nontrivial interplay between partial supersymmetry breaking and restrictions imposed by the geometry and sources. The resulting vacuum realizes partial supersymmetry breaking parametrically below the Kaluza–Klein scale. p. 3 The solutions provide a preliminary consistency check for a possible eleven-dimensional uplift in the strong coupling regime. p. 3

A O6-plane charge and tadpole cancellation

The O6-plane charge QO6 entering the tadpole condition is determined by counting the O6-planes on the twisted torus, resulting in QO6 = −m0h of section 2.3. This leads to integer solutions for m0 and h when h is even or odd. p. 9

Direct dimensional reduction

The direct dimensional reduction yields the three-dimensional bosonic effective action, which includes scalar kinetic terms, a vector kinetic term, and a scalar potential. The potential at zero axions is shown to match the one obtained by direct dimensional reduction in appendix B. p. 3

First-order formulation

The complete first-order action is derived, replacing the Maxwell term with a BF coupling, and this formulation reproduces the full potential including contributions from internal curvature, fluxes, and O6 tensions. The resulting vacuum satisfies the Einstein equation in the normalization R3,E/2 − V, using LAdS = 6/∆. p. 7

Vector Kinetic Term

The Kaluza–Klein vector acquires a mass of order the anti-de Sitter scale, m2A = r24∆ 2/9y squared = e4D ∆29. This mass is on the order of the anti-de Sitter scale. p. 3

Scalar Potential

The total scalar potential at zero axions is given by Vno axions = e4D 527 + g2s4 m20t21 + N2t22 + R2f t3 + Fbg4 58. The complete potential is Vfull = Vno axions + e4D H3,int 7S + g2sG4 7S + g2sV26(M+ρ) squared - M2.

O6 Tensions

The O6 tensions contribute to the potential as VO6 = −∆23/ 4. The total scalar potential at zero axions is V0 = e4D" ∆2/ 3 + 1/6 + 1/36 + 1/36 - 1/3.

Final Results

The final result for the vacuum potential is V0 = −e4D ∆2 / 36 = −e4D / L2AdS, which agrees with the Einstein equation in the normalization R3,E/2 − V, using LAdS = 6/∆. The vacuum also has two physical RR axionic flat directions. p. 3 The gravitino associated with the broken supersymmetry has mass parameter m3/2,broken = 3/(2L3,E), so supersymmetry breaking occurs at the anti-de Sitter scale. p. 3 Partial supersymmetry breaking therefore occurs parametrically below the Kaluza–Klein scale. p. 3

Acknowledgments

The work of N.C. is supported by the Research Foundation Flanders (FWO grant 1259125N). We acknowledge the use of large language models to assist with editing and checking calculations in this manuscript.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to analyze complex string theory vacua by systematically tracing how geometric constraints like SU(3) structures and O6-plane projections restrict spinor components, leading to a rigorous proof of obstruction to N=(1, 1) enhancement.

  2. Enhanced capability in determining the structure of four-form flux parameters by solving the algebraic equation X4i=2 for various flux configurations, allowing for explicit determination of moduli stabilization conditions.

  3. Stronger capacity to perform dimensional reduction and matching between ten-dimensional supergravity and three-dimensional gauged supergravity, specifically by correctly identifying how axionic gaugings resolve discrepancies in supersymmetry counting.

  4. Improved precision in calculating the three-dimensional scalar potential by systematically collecting contributions from internal curvature, NS/RR field strengths, external two-form fluxes, and O6 tensions into the full potential expression.

  5. Advanced skill in analyzing parametric scale separation by relating internal radii to the anti-de Sitter radius and string coupling across weak and strong coupling regimes, providing explicit scaling relationships for all seven radii in terms of flux parameters.

Sources

Related papers