Effective scalar-fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities

arXiv:2611.13102 · hep-th, gr-qc, hep-ph · Submitted 2026-11-09 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Effective scalar-fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Effective scalar–fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities shows that the nature of the spinodal instability is linked to thermodynamic stability, determined by the sign of the specific heat When the specific heat is positive, sound modes are stable and there is a non-hydrodynamic instability The holographic calculation confirms the validity of the effective description at long wavelengths, improving on the purely hydrodynamic description We also identify a friction coefficient that governs the bubble wall velocity and can be extracted from a holographic correlator.

Kai: Thermodynamic Stability and Instability Link The nature of the spinodal instability is linked to thermodynamic stability, determined by the sign of the specific heat When the specific heat is positive, sound modes are stable and there is a non-hydrodynamic instability When it is negative, a sound mode becomes unstable instead.

Mira: This distinction arises from whether the phase transition takes place in a sector with degrees of freedom comparable to the whole system or much smaller than that.

Kai: The sound mode instability can be identified with having a negative specific heat cv < 0, which gives an imaginary speed of sound cs through the usual formula c2s = s/cv, with s the entropy density.

Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up what this paper, "Effective scalar-fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities," is trying to do, it's setting up this effective field theory where you have a classical scalar field interacting with a fluid. They then look at the thermodynamic equilibrium and the linearized fluctuations around that state >

Mira: What they claim is that the nature of the spinodal instability depends entirely on whether the specific heat is positive or negative; if it's positive, sound modes are stable, but there's a non-hydrodynamic instability present >

Lev: And they show that this distinction arises because of whether the phase transition happens in a sector with degrees of freedom comparable to the whole system or much smaller than that >

Kai: They use holographic modeling with five dimensional Einstein gravity coupled to a scalar field to map out the phase diagram, and they find different families of diagrams depending on some parameter called psi Q >

Mira: And for theory A specifically, they found that the specific heat changes sign along the spinodal branch, while theory B stays negative >

Lev: The dynamical stability analysis shows that when the speed of sound squared is greater than zero and the specific heat is positive, all modes have a negative imaginary part for their frequency, meaning they are dynamically stable >

Kai: But they point out that where the nature of this instability switches happens precisely where the specific heat vanishes, when it hits zero >

Conclusion: Kai: Looking at this whole piece, "Effective scalar-fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities," the authors are essentially showing us a way to use a simplified model to understand the complex physics happening during these phase transitions in the early universe or in other high energy scenarios >

Mira: The main implication I see is that we can predict exactly when these systems become unstable dynamically, based on just looking at how their specific heat behaves across different temperatures or pressures >

Lev: It means we can start to identify which instabilities are truly hydrodynamic and which ones require this more sophisticated, non-hydrodynamic description involving those friction coefficients >

Kai: And the paper confirms that this effective theory actually works pretty well for sound modes up to a certain momentum scale, around two times the temperature of the transition >

Mira: So what we get is a clearer picture of how these systems evolve away from equilibrium, especially when you consider those non-hydrodynamic modes which are lighter than other gapped modes in the full microscopic theory >

Institute for Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics and Würzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence ctd.qmat · Department of Natural and Health Sciences, Abo Akademi University · Helsinki Institute of Physics, University of Helsinki · Department of Physics, Universidad de Oviedo · Instituto de Ciáncias y Tecnologóas Espaciales de Asturias · School of Mathematics & Statistics, University College Dublin · Departament de Fúsica Qu`antica i Astrofúsica, Universitat de Barcelona · Institut de Ci`encies del Cosmos (ICC), Universitat de Barcelona

hep-th, gr-qc, hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-09

Updated: 2026-11-19

Comments: 37 pages, 19 figures

Code: https://github.com/pedrota2000/QUASTELL

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Effective scalar–fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities shows that the nature of the spinodal instability is linked to thermodynamic stability…

Key concepts

Spinodal Instability
This occurs when a system becomes thermodynamically unstable during a phase transition. It is linked to the specific heat of the system; if specific heat is positive, sound modes are stable, but if it's negative, sound modes can become unstable.
Effective Field Theory (EFT)
This describes bubble dynamics as a classical scalar field coupled to a fluid. The interaction between them arises from how masses depend on the field and create an effective force when gradients are present in the system.
Holographic Modeling
The microscopic theory is studied using five-dimensional Einstein gravity coupled to a real scalar field. This method helps map out phase diagrams by examining free energies of different states as temperature changes, identifying spinodal points where extrema merge.

Terminology

Summary

Effective scalar–fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities shows that the nature of the spinodal instability is linked to thermodynamic stability, determined by the sign of the specific heat When the specific heat is positive, sound modes are stable and there is a non-hydrodynamic instability The holographic calculation confirms the validity of the effective description at long wavelengths, improving on the purely hydrodynamic description We also identify a friction coefficient that governs the bubble wall velocity and can be extracted from a holographic correlator. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The holographic calculation confirms the validity of the effective description at long wavelengths, improving on the purely hydrodynamic description. We also identify a friction coefficient that governs the bubble wall velocity and can be extracted from a holographic correlator.

Thermodynamic Stability and Instability Link

The nature of the spinodal instability is linked to thermodynamic stability, determined by the sign of the specific heat When the specific heat is positive, sound modes are stable and there is a non-hydrodynamic instability When it is negative, a sound mode becomes unstable instead. This distinction arises from whether the phase transition takes place in a sector with degrees of freedom comparable to the whole system or much smaller than that. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The energy density on the other hand is a well-defined observable in any equilibrium or non-equilibrium state. In the other case, with stable sound modes, the phase transition takes place in a sector with a number of degrees of freedom that is much smaller than that of the whole system.

The sound mode instability can be identified with having a negative specific heat cv < 0, which gives an imaginary speed of sound cs through the usual formula c2s = s/cv, with s the entropy density. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The difference between the number of degrees of freedom can be translated into the thermodynamic stability of the unstable phase. The sound mode instability can be identified with having a negative specific heat cv < 0, which gives an imaginary speed of sound cs through the usual formula c 2 s = s/cv, with s the entropy density.

Effective Field Theory Construction

The description of bubble dynamics in a cosmological phase transition is typically discussed in the context of the electroweak transition The effective theory is that of a classical scalar field coupled to a fluid. The interaction between the two emerges from the dependence of masses on the field, which produces an effective force on particles when gradients are non-zero. p. 4

Where the paper says it

the masses of the particles on the field, which produces an effective force on the particles when the gradients of the field are non-zero. Since the total energy and momentum are conserved, there is a backreaction on the scalar that modifies its equation of motion.

The most general form of the action at second order in derivatives is S = Z d/dx sqrt(-g Z0 squared (uµ∂µϕ) squared - Zs squared Pµν∂µϕ∂νϕ - V). p. 5
Where the paper says it

[29–35], but we will simply add dissipative terms by hand to the equations after deriving the non-dissipative part from the effective action. To second order in derivatives of the scalar, the most general form of the action is S = Z d dx √ −g Z0 2 (u µ ∂µϕ) 2 − Zs 2 P µν∂µϕ∂νϕ − V .

Holographic Modeling and Phase Diagrams

The holographic dual of a first-order phase transition is studied using a five-dimensional Einstein gravity coupled to a real scalar field. The phase diagram is determined by the free energies of two states crossing as temperature is varied, leading to the identification of spinodal points where maximum and minimum extrema merge. p. 8

Where the paper says it

spinodal branch. The transition from three extrema to one extremum occurs when a maximum and a minimum merge and go away, at the so-called spinodal points.

Different families of phase diagrams are obtained for different fixed ψQ values, and theory A has a specific heat that changes sign along the spinodal branch, while theory B remains negative. p. 3
Where the paper says it

It is actually possible to find models where the specific heat changes between positive and negative values within the same unstable phase. 1 shows two possible cases, one where the specific heat changes sign in the unstable branch and another where it is negative throughout.

Dynamical Stability Analysis

The dispersion relation of fluctuations around equilibrium is given by 0 = -ω2Z0 + q2Zs + ∂2ϕV − iωγ − iωT A2−iωC + sq 2−iω+Γq squared. In the stable branches ∂2ϕV > 0 and cv > 0, all modes have dispersion relations with a negative imaginary part for the frequency, meaning these states are dynamically stable. p. 0

Where the paper says it

When the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable and there is a non-hydrodynamic instability. When it is negative, a sound mode becomes unstable instead.

The point where the nature of the dynamical instability of the spinodal branch switches is where the specific heat vanishes, cv = 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We formulate an improved scalar–fluid effective description of first-order phase transitions in relativistic theories, and test it against a microscopic calculation in a holographic model. The effective theory shows that the nature of the spinodal instability is linked to thermodynamic stability, determined by the sign of the specific heat.

Comparison and Validity

The effective theory accurately reproduces the dispersion relation of sound modes and the lightest non-hydrodynamic mode, in most cases up to q ∼ 2T. The microscopic calculation confirms the validity of the EFT in the expected regime. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Within this effective description, we then derive a link between thermodynamic stability and the type of dynamical instability in the unstable phase. We test the validity of the EFT at the linear level by comparing with a microscopic calculation for strongly coupled theories with holographic duals.

The comparison between the effective theory and quasinormal modes shows that it captures qualitative and often quantitative features of the spectrum at q ∼ T, including mode collisions, which are absent in hydrodynamics. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In section 3 we introduce the microscopic theory as a holographic model, derive its thermodynamics and study the phase diagram with changing backreaction. Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with the quasinormal modes.

The EFT is more accurate when non-hydrodynamic modes are lighter than other gapped quasinormal modes present in the full microscopic theory. p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

The scenario with cv > 0 on a large portion of the spinodal branch arises generically when the sector driving the transition is small compared to the full system. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In [17], it was argued that there can be a quasistatic decrease of the energy density such that the system remains close to equilibrium in the metastable state until it enters an unstable state. This phase has unstable sound modes that are identified with a spinodal instability that would introduce density inhomogeneities driving the system to a phase-separated state.

The comparison confirms that for q ≳ 2T, qmax is around its largest value and there is another mode at zero frequency with q2 < q2max. p. 0
Where the paper says it

When it is negative, a sound mode becomes unstable instead. The holographic calculation confirms the validity of the effective description at long wavelengths, improving on the purely hydrodynamic description.

The EFT captures correct behavior of sound modes up to q ∼ 2T, similarly to the purely hydrodynamic sound dispersion relation, although it reproduces the imaginary part of the sound dispersion relation more accurately. p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

The EFT is more accurate when the gapped mode becomes lighter. p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

For theory B, the instability in the spinodal region is always due to the sound mode. p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

Terminal Wall Speed Prediction

The key player in calculating the terminal wall speed of expanding bubbles is the parameter γ(ϕ, T), which gives rise to a friction force on the wall balancing pressure difference that drives expansion. The EFT differs from usual cases through non-canonical kinetic terms Z0 and Zs, which can lead to interesting modifications. Agreement between the two methods establishes that the gradient expansion remains predictive far from equilibrium. p. 5

Where the paper says it

12) The coefficients in the kinetic terms of the scalar and the potential are both functions of the scalar and the temperature: Z0 = Z0(T, ϕ), Zs = Zs(T, ϕ), V = V (T, ϕ). 13) In principle, we could add terms that have two derivatives of the temperature or the velocity, but those will not be contributing at leading order in the gradient expansion.

A computation of the wall speed is meaningful only to the extent that higher-derivative corrections remain negligible on the scale of the wall thickness. The EFT could provide a good approximate description for bubble wall speed. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We test the validity of the EFT at the linear level by comparing with a microscopic calculation for strongly coupled theories with holographic duals. The holographic duality, or AdS/CFT correspondence [7–9] has previously been used to determine the bubble wall velocity [10–15], estimate the gravitational wave spectrum [16–18], and to find an effective action for the order parameter [19, 20].

The EFT is a truncated derivative expansion—and, as discussed above, a truncation in field content—whereas a bubble wall can involve large gradients. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In later sections we will study how γ enters in the dispersion relations of fluctuations around equilibrium, particularly concerning the spinodal instability in the unstable branch of the phase diagram. Here, we will first provide a generalization of this picture that does not assume Lorentz invariance of the kinetic terms in the effective action for the scalar, and that includes viscous terms in the energy-momentum tensor of the fluid, that could be of the same order as the gradients of the scalar in a derivative expansion.

Conclusion on Stability

In the part of the spinodal branch where the specific heat is positive, the system is dynamically unstable but thermodynamically stable. This can be viewed as a counterexample to the so-called “correlated stability conjecture” (CSC) [45]. p. 8

Where the paper says it

spinodal branch. The transition from three extrema to one extremum occurs when a maximum and a minimum merge and go away, at the so-called spinodal points.

Allowing for a more general notion of thermodynamic variables, the resulting susceptibility matrix always has exactly one unstable eigenvalue on the spinodal branch, matching the fact that there is always one dynamically unstable mode there. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Thus, assuming C > 0, we have “generalized” thermodynamic stability as long as the potential is convex. On the spinodal branch, where ∂ 2 ϕV < 0, H always has exactly one unstable eigenvalue, signaling instability.

The construction is justified by a separation of scales: near the spinodal the order-parameter mode becomes light, parametrically separated from the remaining tower of quasinormal modes. p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

The EFT captures qualitative and often quantitative features of the spectrum at q ∼ 2T, including mode collisions. p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

In summary, the microscopic calculation confirms the validity of the EFT in the expected regime. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Within this effective description, we then derive a link between thermodynamic stability and the type of dynamical instability in the unstable phase. We test the validity of the EFT at the linear level by comparing with a microscopic calculation for strongly coupled theories with holographic duals.

The paper is organized as follows: in section 2 we introduce the effective theory of the coupled scalar and fluid and discuss its thermodynamics and spectrum of linear fluctuations around equilibrium We also explain the relation between backreaction and thermodynamic stability. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The paper is organized as follows: in section 2 we introduce the effective theory of the coupled scalar and fluid and discuss its thermodynamics and spectrum of linear fluctuations around equilibrium. We also explain the relation between backreaction and thermodynamic stability.

In section 3 we introduce the microscopic theory as a holographic model, derive its thermodynamics and study the phase diagram with changing backreaction Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with quasinormal modes. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In section 3 we introduce the microscopic theory as a holographic model, derive its thermodynamics and study the phase diagram with changing backreaction. Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with the quasinormal modes.

Finally, in section 5, we summarize and discuss our results and possible future directions. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with the quasinormal modes. Finally, in section 5, we summarize and discuss our results and possible future directions.

The paper is organized as follows: in section 2 we introduce the effective theory of the coupled scalar and fluid and discuss its thermodynamics and spectrum of linear fluctuations around equilibrium We also explain the relation between backreaction and thermodynamic stability In section 3 we introduce the microscopic theory as a holographic model, derive its thermodynamics and study the phase diagram with changing backreaction Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with quasinormal modes. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In section 3 we introduce the microscopic theory as a holographic model, derive its thermodynamics and study the phase diagram with changing backreaction. Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with the quasinormal modes.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

In section 3 we introduce the microscopic theory as a holographic model, derive its thermodynamics and study the phase diagram with changing backreaction. Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with the quasinormal modes.

Finally, in section 5, we summarize and discuss our results and possible future directions We would like to thank Blaise Gout´eraux and Elias Kiritsis for useful comments. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with the quasinormal modes. Finally, in section 5, we summarize and discuss our results and possible future directions.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with the quasinormal modes. Finally, in section 5, we summarize and discuss our results and possible future directions.

A.C. acknowledges support from the German Research Foundation (DFG) through the Collaborative Research Center ToCoTronics, Project-ID 258499086–SFB 1170, and from Germany’s Excellence Strategy through the W¨urzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence on Complexity, Topology and Dynamics in Quantum Matter - ctd. p. 0
Where the paper says it

HIP-2026-22/TH Effective scalar–fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities Alessio Caddeo,a Oscar Henriksson,b,c Carlos Hoyos,d,e Mikel Sanchez-Garitaonandia,f Pedro Taranc´on-Alvarez ´ g,h a Institute for Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics and W¨urzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence ctd. qmat, Julius-Maximilians-Universit¨at W¨urzburg, Am Hubland, DE-97074 W¨urzburg, Germany bDepartment of Natural and Health Sciences, ˚Abo Akademi University, Henrikinkatu 2, FI-20500 Turku, Finland cHelsinki Institute of Physics, P.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

HIP-2026-22/TH Effective scalar–fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities Alessio Caddeo,a Oscar Henriksson,b,c Carlos Hoyos,d,e Mikel Sanchez-Garitaonandia,f Pedro Taranc´on-Alvarez ´ g,h a Institute for Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics and W¨urzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence ctd. qmat, Julius-Maximilians-Universit¨at W¨urzburg, Am Hubland, DE-97074 W¨urzburg, Germany bDepartment of Natural and Health Sciences, ˚Abo Akademi University, Henrikinkatu 2, FI-20500 Turku, Finland cHelsinki Institute of Physics, P.

qmat (EXC 2147, Project-ID 390858490). p. 0
Where the paper says it

HIP-2026-22/TH Effective scalar–fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities Alessio Caddeo,a Oscar Henriksson,b,c Carlos Hoyos,d,e Mikel Sanchez-Garitaonandia,f Pedro Taranc´on-Alvarez ´ g,h a Institute for Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics and W¨urzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence ctd. qmat, Julius-Maximilians-Universit¨at W¨urzburg, Am Hubland, DE-97074 W¨urzburg, Germany bDepartment of Natural and Health Sciences, ˚Abo Akademi University, Henrikinkatu 2, FI-20500 Turku, Finland cHelsinki Institute of Physics, P.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

HIP-2026-22/TH Effective scalar–fluid description of thermal first-order phase transitions and their spinodal instabilities Alessio Caddeo,a Oscar Henriksson,b,c Carlos Hoyos,d,e Mikel Sanchez-Garitaonandia,f Pedro Taranc´on-Alvarez ´ g,h a Institute for Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics and W¨urzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence ctd. qmat, Julius-Maximilians-Universit¨at W¨urzburg, Am Hubland, DE-97074 W¨urzburg, Germany bDepartment of Natural and Health Sciences, ˚Abo Akademi University, Henrikinkatu 2, FI-20500 Turku, Finland cHelsinki Institute of Physics, P.

O.H. acknowledges support from the Waldemar von Frenckell foundation. C.H. acknowledges support from the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigación and Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovaci´on y Universidades through the grant PID2024-161500NB-I00. M.S.G. acknowledges support from a Royal Society - Research Ireland University Research Fellowship via grants URF/R1/211027 and RF/ERE/231191. p. 0
Where the paper says it

qmat, Julius-Maximilians-Universit¨at W¨urzburg, Am Hubland, DE-97074 W¨urzburg, Germany bDepartment of Natural and Health Sciences, ˚Abo Akademi University, Henrikinkatu 2, FI-20500 Turku, Finland cHelsinki Institute of Physics, P. Box 64, FI-00014 University of Helsinki, Finland dDepartment of Physics, Universidad de Oviedo, c/ Leopoldo Calvo Sotelo 18, ES-33007 Oviedo, Spain e Instituto de Ciencias y Tecnolog´ıas Espaciales de Asturias, c/ Independencia 13, ES-33004 Oviedo, Spain f School of Mathematics & Statistics, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, D04 V1W8, Ireland gDepartament de F´ısica Qu`antica i Astrof´ısica, Universitat de Barcelona, Mart´ı i Franqu`es 1, ES-08028, Barcelona, Spain h Institut de Ci`encies del Cosmos (ICC), Universitat de Barcelona, Mart´ı i Franqu`es 1, ES-08028, Barcelona, Spain E-mail: alessio.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

qmat, Julius-Maximilians-Universit¨at W¨urzburg, Am Hubland, DE-97074 W¨urzburg, Germany bDepartment of Natural and Health Sciences, ˚Abo Akademi University, Henrikinkatu 2, FI-20500 Turku, Finland cHelsinki Institute of Physics, P. Box 64, FI-00014 University of Helsinki, Finland dDepartment of Physics, Universidad de Oviedo, c/ Leopoldo Calvo Sotelo 18, ES-33007 Oviedo, Spain e Instituto de Ciencias y Tecnolog´ıas Espaciales de Asturias, c/ Independencia 13, ES-33004 Oviedo, Spain f School of Mathematics & Statistics, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, D04 V1W8, Ireland gDepartament de F´ısica Qu`antica i Astrof´ısica, Universitat de Barcelona, Mart´ı i Franqu`es 1, ES-08028, Barcelona, Spain h Institut de Ci`encies del Cosmos (ICC), Universitat de Barcelona, Mart´ı i Franqu`es 1, ES-08028, Barcelona, Spain E-mail: alessio.

P.T. acknowledges support from the project “Dark Energy and the Origin of the Universe” (PRE2022-102220) funded by MCIN/AEI/10. p. 2
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Phase transitions can take place in systems that span a huge range of scales, from nuclear physics to cosmology. A first-order phase transition (FOPT) taking place in the early universe can leave an observable signal on the cosmological gravitational wave background that could be detected in the near future.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Phase transitions can take place in systems that span a huge range of scales, from nuclear physics to cosmology. A first-order phase transition (FOPT) taking place in the early universe can leave an observable signal on the cosmological gravitational wave background that could be detected in the near future.

13039/501100011033, from grant No. 00775 from the Simons Foundation, and from project PID264899 and PID-I 4899. AI tools did not contribute to the scientific content of this work, and the authors take full responsibility for the code, results and manuscript. The paper is organized as follows: in section 2 we introduce the effective theory of the coupled scalar and fluid and discuss its thermodynamics and spectrum of linear fluctuations around equilibrium We also explain the relation between backreaction and thermodynamic stability In section 3 we introduce the microscopic theory as a holographic model, derive its thermodynamics and study the phase diagram with changing backreaction Next, in section 4 we compute the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the holographic theory, fit the parameters of the effective theory at low momentum, and test the validity of the effective theory by comparing dispersion relations at finite momentum with quasinormal modes. Finally, in section 5, we summarize and discuss our results and possible future directions We would like to thank Blaise Gout´eraux and Elias Kiritsis for useful comments. A.C. acknowledges support from the German Research Foundation (DFG) through the Collaborative Research Center ToCoTronics, Project-ID 258499086–SFB 1170, and from Germany’s Excellence Strategy through the W¨urzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence on Complexity, Topology and Dynamics in Quantum Matter - ctd.qmat (EXC 2147, Project-ID 390858490). O.H. acknowledges support from the Waldemar von Frenckell foundation. C.H. acknowledges support from the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigación and Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovaci´on y Universidades through the grant PID2024-161500NB-I00. M.S.G. acknowledges support from a Royal Society - Research Ireland University Research Fellowship via grants URF/R1/211027 and RF/ERE/231191. P.T. acknowledges support from the project “Dark Energy and the Origin of the Universe” (PRE2022-102220) funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, from grant No. 4675 from the Simons Foundation, and from project PID-I 4899.

--- Page 26 ---

Figure 4. Real (left) and imaginary (right) part of the quasinormal mode frequencies at q = 0 for theory A, as a function of the background scalar field at the horizon. p. 5

Where the paper says it

1 Generalization of the effective action and dissipative terms We can combine the scalar field and the fluid in a single effective action that captures the nondissipative part of the system. For the fluid, we follow [27, 28], where one introduces a nowhere vanishing time-like vector field U µ coupled to a background metric gµν, such that the local temperature and fluid velocity are given by T = T0 √ −U2 , uµ = U µ √ −U2 , U2 = gµνU µU ν , (2.

Highlighted with red and cyan are the non-hydrodynamic QNMs that we match to the effective theory

--- Page 30 ---

Figure 8. Speed of sound squared (left) and sound attenuation constant Γs (right) as a function of the scalar field at the horizon for theory A. p. 2

Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

The red lines are obtained from the background solutions using the relations (3. p. 5
Where the paper says it

10) Evaluated at thermal equilibrium, P(Teq) = p is the pressure of the fluid. The energy-momentum of the ideal fluid is obtained from the variation of the action with respect to the background metric T µν f = 2 √ −g δSf δgµν = pP µν + εuµu ν , (2.

12) (left) and (3.11) (right), whereas the blue dots are computed from the sound QNMs, namely (4. p. 1
Where the paper says it

3 Validity of the effective theory 23 4. 4 QNMs with varying backreaction 27 5 Discussion 29 A Expectation values of dual operators 32 B EFT parameters for theory B 33 – 2 –

5c) (left) and (4.5d).

--- Page 20 ---

Figure 9. Effective theory parameters as functions of the scalar field at the horizon for theory A: M1 and M2 squared = (γ/2Z0) squared (top-left), cv/C (top-right), Zs/Z0 (bottom-left) and Γ (bottom-right). p. 4

Where the paper says it

4) The equation of motion for the scalar that is derived from this picture takes the form −∂µ∂ µϕ + ∂ϕVT = −γuµ ∂µϕ, (2. 5) where the term on the right-hand side is the effective force that is produced by the change in the mass of the particles.

--- Page 19 ---

Figure 7. Value of qmax/T squared as a function of the scalar field at the horizon ψH for theory A. p. 8

Where the paper says it

It has been noted that one could treat the source for the scalar order parameter as a thermodynamic variable — albeit one that is not associated to a conserved charge [36, 37]. Consider then the free energy as a function of the temperature and scalar source, formed by a Legendre transform of the potential V (T, ϕ), i.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

It has been noted that one could treat the source for the scalar order parameter as a thermodynamic variable — albeit one that is not associated to a conserved charge [36, 37]. Consider then the free energy as a function of the temperature and scalar source, formed by a Legendre transform of the potential V (T, ϕ), i.

--- Page 21 ---

Figure 6. Dispersion relation of the unstable modes in the spinodal branch for background 3 (left) where sound is unstable, and background 4 (right) where the gapped mode is unstable. p. 0

Where the paper says it

When the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable and there is a non-hydrodynamic instability. When it is negative, a sound mode becomes unstable instead.

--- Page 22 ---

Figure 8. Speed of sound squared (left) and sound attenuation constant Γs (right) as a function of the scalar field at the horizon for theory A.

--- Page 21 ---

Figure 7. Value of qmax/T squared as a function of the scalar field at the horizon ψH for theory A.

--- Page 18 ---

Figure 16. Real (left) and imaginary (right) parts of the QNM frequencies at q = 0 as a function of χ, for the backgrounds marked with dashed gray lines in Fig. 3.

--- Page 27 ---

Figure 14. Effective theory (in solid red) and quasinormal mode (black dots) comparison for theory B for backgrounds (top) 1 and bottom) 5. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Varying the backreaction 16 4 Dynamical (in-)stability and comparison with the effective description 18 4. 1 Quasinormal modes 18 4.

--- Page 28 ---

Figure 17. Speed of sound squared (left plot) and sound attenuation constant Γs (right plot) as a function of the scalar field at the horizon for theory B. p. 2

Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable, and the instability must instead reside in a non-hydrodynamic mode. In this work, we propose an effective field theory (EFT) of a fluid coupled to a scalar order parameter, extending previous proposals introduced to describe the evolution of nucleated bubbles in cosmological phase transitions [5, 6].

--- Page 29 ---

Figure 19. Effective theory parameters as functions of the scalar field at the horizon for theory B: M1 and M2 squared = (γ/2Z0) squared (top-left), cv/C (top-right), Zs/Z0 (bottom-left) and Γ (bottom-right). p. 4

Where the paper says it

4) The equation of motion for the scalar that is derived from this picture takes the form −∂µ∂ µϕ + ∂ϕVT = −γuµ ∂µϕ, (2. 5) where the term on the right-hand side is the effective force that is produced by the change in the mass of the particles.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

4) The equation of motion for the scalar that is derived from this picture takes the form −∂µ∂ µϕ + ∂ϕVT = −γuµ ∂µϕ, (2. 5) where the term on the right-hand side is the effective force that is produced by the change in the mass of the particles.

--- Page 34 ---

Figure 18. Value of qmax/T squared as a function of the scalar field at the horizon ψH for theory B. p. 8

Where the paper says it

It has been noted that one could treat the source for the scalar order parameter as a thermodynamic variable — albeit one that is not associated to a conserved charge [36, 37]. Consider then the free energy as a function of the temperature and scalar source, formed by a Legendre transform of the potential V (T, ϕ), i.

--- Page 17 ---

Figure 16. Real (left) and imaginary (right) parts of the QNM frequencies at q = 0 as a function of χ, for the backgrounds marked with dashed gray lines in Fig. 3.

--- Page 24 ---

Figure 10. Effective theory (in solid red) and quasinormal mode (black dots) comparison for theory A for backgrounds (top) 1 and bottom) 6. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Varying the backreaction 16 4 Dynamical (in-)stability and comparison with the effective description 18 4. 1 Quasinormal modes 18 4.

--- Page 25 ---

Figure 11. Effective theory (in solid red) and quasinormal mode (black dots) comparison for theory A for background 2. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Varying the backreaction 16 4 Dynamical (in-)stability and comparison with the effective description 18 4. 1 Quasinormal modes 18 4.

--- Page 26 ---

Figure 12. Effective theory (in solid red) and quasinormal mode (black dots) comparison for theory A for backgrounds (top) 3 and bottom) 5. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Varying the backreaction 16 4 Dynamical (in-)stability and comparison with the effective description 18 4. 1 Quasinormal modes 18 4.

--- Page 27 ---

Figure 13. Effective theory (in solid red) and quasinormal mode (black dots) comparison for theory A for background 4. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Varying the backreaction 16 4 Dynamical (in-)stability and comparison with the effective description 18 4. 1 Quasinormal modes 18 4.

--- Page 28 ---

Figure 16. Real (left) and imaginary (right) parts of the QNM frequencies at q = 0 as a function of χ, for the backgrounds marked with dashed gray lines in Fig. 3.

--- Page 29 ---

Figure 17. Speed of sound squared (left plot) and sound attenuation constant Γs (right plot) as a function of the scalar field at the horizon for theory B.

--- Page 30 ---

Figure 19. Effective theory parameters as functions of the scalar field at the horizon for theory B: M1 and M2 squared = (γ/2Z0) squared (top-left), cv/C (top-right), Zs/Z0 (bottom-left) and Γ (bottom-right).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved system can predict bubble wall velocity by extracting a friction coefficient from holographic correlators, as described in We also identify a friction coefficient that governs the bubble wall velocity and can be extracted from a holographic correlator.

  2. Improved system can determine if dynamical instability is hydrodynamic or non-hydrodynamic by analyzing the sign of the specific heat, linking it to thermodynamic stability: When the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable and there is a non-hydrodynamic instability. When it is negative, a sound mode becomes unstable instead.

  3. Improved system can map out phase diagrams for holographic models by varying parameters like psiM and psiQ in the superpotential to distinguish between first-order transitions and crossovers: For different values of psiM and psiQ in the superpotential (3.3), we obtain different families of phase diagrams that are qualitatively analogous to each other.

  4. Improved system can compare effective field theory predictions with microscopic holographic calculations for quasinormal modes at finite momentum, which tests the validity of the EFT: We test the validity of the EFT at the linear level by comparing with a microscopic calculation for strongly coupled theories with holographic duals.

  5. Improved system can extract thermodynamic quantities like specific heat cv and sound attenuation constant Gamma s from both background solutions and quasinormal modes, confirming agreement within numerical precision: For both quantities, the background and QNM calculations agree within numerical precision.

  6. Improved system can predict the terminal wall speed of expanding bubbles by using the constructed EFT, which involves the parameter gamma phi T: The key player in this calculation is the parameter gamma phi T, which gives rise to a friction force on the wall balancing the pressure difference that drives the expansion.

Abstract

We formulate an improved scalar-fluid effective description of first-order phase transitions in relativistic theories, and test it against a microscopic calculation in a holographic model. The effective theory shows that the nature of the spinodal instability is linked to thermodynamic stability, determined by the sign of the specific heat. When the specific heat is positive, the sound modes are stable and there is a non-hydrodynamic instability. When it is negative, a sound mode becomes unstable instead. The holographic calculation confirms the validity of the effective description at long wavelengths, improving on the purely hydrodynamic description. We also identify a friction coefficient that governs the bubble wall velocity and can be extracted from a holographic correlator.

Sources

Related papers