Real-Time Path Integral Resurgence: Which Classical Path Contributes?
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Real-Time Path Integral Resurgence".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Which complex classical paths contribute to a real-time Feynman path integral?
Kai: The paper shows that resurgence provides a practical alternative to Picard-Lefschetz theory for identifying relevant complex classical paths in the real-time Feynman path integral by computing asymptotic series and using the South-East rule to turn adjacency into relevance.
Mira: The Problem of Relevance The core question addressed is which classical paths are relevant to a quantum transition and which saddle points should be ignored The path integral, being infinite-dimensional and highly oscillatory, lacks a general rigorous definition as an integral over paths.
Kai: A clue for relevance comes from the divergence of perturbation theory, where the divergent tail reveals other classical paths and how strongly each couples to the first This information grew out of two centuries of asymptotic series analysis.
Title and authors: Mira: The paper introduces a specific method for identifying these relevant complex classical paths by looking at how those asymptotic series diverge and using a rule called the South-East rule to connect that divergence to actual physical relevance.
Kai: It’s about taking the structure of the divergent tails from those series and using Borel-Padé methods to read off which paths are important, which is a big step beyond just looking at stationary points in the action.
Lev: I’m interested in how they handle the complexity of those Stokes phenomena—those shifts where things change when you move a parameter slightly—because that's where the actual quantum tunneling information seems to live.
Kai: They show that these Stokes phenomena can happen in two ways: either an adjacency number changes when an edge enters or leaves a specific sector, or two edges change their order of firing, which is just an ordinary Stokes phenomenon.
Mira: But they also noted that the adjacency graph itself can change in a higher-order Stokes phenomenon when a singularity crosses the line segment between two adjacent paths.
Lev: If that higher-order change happens, it suggests there’s more complexity than just tracking where one path is next to another in this kind of system.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, they are essentially providing a way to define the path integral using a transseries—which is an expansion that includes terms that go beyond the simple semiclassical limit—without needing a proper integral over paths right away.
Mira: They use those transport recursion relations to build this transseries up to the intersection numbers, and those intersection numbers are fixed by adjacency relations derived from resurgence.
Lev: That’s a way to bypass the need for a full path integral definition by focusing on the structure of these series and how they connect.
Kai: For example, when they applied this to a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, they used that South-East rule to find the relevant complex paths in front of and behind the barrier, including one that handles quantum tunneling.
Mira: And what’s really interesting is that when you resum those series using Borel sums, they reproduce the exact propagator with exponential accuracy.
Lev: Exponential accuracy is a big deal because it means the approximation holds up even when you move away from the semiclassical limit, which is where most of our real-world quantum problems live.
The paper's improvements: Kai: They suggest that this method does more than just govern the semiclassical limit; they claim that Borel sums of these series actually approximate the real-time path integral at any value of Planck’s constant.
Mira: They also extend the analysis to relativistic systems, like world-line formulations of a relativistic particle and even the Wheeler-DeWitt equation in quantum cosmology.
Lev: Extending it to curved spacetime problems is challenging because you're dealing with constraints, but they manage to use the transport recursion method for these constrained systems, yielding cumulants that match those from integrating over the lapse in curved spacetime.
Kai: The South-East rule itself is key here; it translates the Stokes constants and geometry of the adjacency graph directly into intersection numbers to identify relevant paths.
Mira: They also discuss how this helps us decide which saddle points contribute in quantum gravity problems, which is something we really need as we look at those complicated constraints.
Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up, the main point of "Real-Time Path Integral Resurgence: Which Classical Path Contributes?" is that the real classical paths are always relevant because their intersection numbers are non-zero, and the South-East rule successfully turns that adjacency into relevance.
Mira: They confirm that these classical paths do more than just describe the semiclassical limit; they actually govern the path integral at any value of Planck’s constant because their Borel sums reproduce it with exponential accuracy.
Lev: For me, what this means for real hardware is that we have a roadmap for identifying which saddle points matter in quantum gravity problems, even though they admit that uniform asymptotic expansions are still needed where things get really messy like at caustics.
Kai: It’s a solid result because they verified it against the exact Rosen-Morse propagator and saw it through ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena.
Mira: And the paper points out a limitation, though, which is that there’s still no formal proof that the South-East rule definitively selects the relevant classical paths.
Lev: That lack of a formal proof is something we need to keep in mind as we try to build error correction schemes for these systems.
Kai: Exactly. But the overall direction is clear: this method offers a way to decide which saddle points contribute in quantum gravity and complex paths can capture things like vacuum decay and tunneling between vacua.
Mira: So, it’s a very constructive approach to dealing with the path integral by using resurgence to manage the infinite complexity of those classical paths.
Lev: We’ll keep an eye on how they plan to derive that South-East rule from the definition of the Green’s function in their next work.
Job Feldbrugge, Leung Center for Cosmology and Particle Astrophysics, Institute for Advanced Study
National Taiwan University · Institute for Advanced Study
math-ph, gr-qc, hep-th, math.MP
Submitted: 2026-11-09
Updated: 2026-11-09
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: Which complex classical paths contribute to a real-time Feynman path integral? The paper shows that resurgence provides a practical alternative to Picard-Lefschetz theory for identifying relevant…
Key concepts
- Resurgence
- Resurgence is a mathematical tool used to extract meaningful information from divergent asymptotic series. It connects the divergent behavior of perturbation theory to the structure of the underlying classical solutions, allowing researchers to identify which paths are physically relevant in the path integral.
- South-East Rule
- The South-East rule is a practical method applied to classical paths. It translates geometric properties of these paths and their adjacency into a criterion for relevance. It helps determine when a complex classical path contributes to the real-time path integral by analyzing how its associated ascent manifold interacts with the integration domain.
- Stokes Phenomena
- Stokes phenomena describe how asymptotic expansions change when one crosses certain lines in the complex plane. In this context, they indicate transitions where relevant classical paths can change or new contributions appear, which is crucial for understanding quantum tunneling and higher-order effects.
- Transport Recursion Method
- This method is used to efficiently calculate coefficients of the series associated with classical paths. It avoids the factorial growth issues found in standard Feynman diagram expansions by formulating the problem in terms of cumulants, providing a manageable way to obtain accurate asymptotic series.
Terminology
Summary
Which complex classical paths contribute to a real-time Feynman path integral? p. 0 Job Feldbrugge 1, 2, ∗
1Leung Center for Cosmology and Particle Astrophysics,
National Taiwan University, No. 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei 10617, Taiwan
2
Institute for Advanced Study, 1 Einstein Drive, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
Which complex classical paths contribute to a real-time Feynman path integral? We show that resurgence provides a practical alternative. We
compute the asymptotic series of the real and complex classical paths to high order, with Feynman
diagrams and with a transport recursion for the cumulants, and read off the adjacency of the
classical paths from the divergent tails of the series with Borel-Pad´e methods.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Problem of Relevance
The core question addressed is which classical paths are relevant to a quantum transition and which saddle points should be ignored The path integral, being infinite-dimensional and highly oscillatory, lacks a general rigorous definition as an integral over paths. A clue for relevance comes from the divergence of perturbation theory, where the divergent tail reveals other classical paths and how strongly each couples to the first This information grew out of two centuries of asymptotic series analysis. p. 0 Rather than
a curse, the divergent tail reveals the other classical paths, and how strongly each of them couples to the first. The theory that decodes this information grew out of two centuries of asymptotic series.Where the paper says it
Methodology for Path Identification
The paper develops a method using resurgence to identify relevant complex classical paths in the non-relativistic real-time path integral. This involves two primary approaches to develop the series of each classical path: (i) a Feynman-diagram expansion and (ii) a transport recursion method, both formulated in terms of cumulants. p. 1 Section III
develops the series of each classical path along two roads: (i) a Feynman-diagram expansion and (ii) a transport
recursion method. We formulate both in terms of cumulants. We formulate both in terms of cumulants. The recursion delivers dozens of coefficients at a
modest cost.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Application to Physical Systems
The South-East rule is applied to the classical paths of a non-relativistic particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, which serves as an ideal test case. This rule identifies relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that carries quantum tunnelling. p. 0 The South-East rule
then turns adjacency into relevance. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator. The resummed series reproduce the
propagator with exponential accuracy.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Path Contribution
The analysis confirms that the real classical paths are always relevant to the path integral, as their intersection numbers are non-zero. The South-East rule turns this adjacency into relevance. p. 0 We
compute the asymptotic series of the real and complex classical paths to high order, with Feynman
diagrams and with a transport recursion for the cumulants, and read off the adjacency of the
classical paths from the divergent tails of the series with Borel-Pad´e methods. The South-East rule
then turns adjacency into relevance. The real and
complex classical paths organise the integral into a set of Wiener-like integrals. The decomposition holds exactly, not
only in the limit ℏ → 0, and for a real and positive Planck constant the intersection numbers nj do not depend on ℏ;
we assume ℏ > 0 throughout.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Extension to Relativistic Systems
The work outlines how the expansion extends to relativistic path integrals governed by a Hamiltonian constraint, such as the world-line formulation of a relativistic particle and the Wheeler-DeWitt equation of quantum cosmology. The transport recursion method is extended to these constrained systems, yielding cumulants that mirror those from the integral over the lapse in curved spacetime. p. 1 Section III
develops the series of each classical path along two roads: (i) a Feynman-diagram expansion and (ii) a transport
recursion method. We formulate both in terms of cumulants.Where the paper says it
The Role of Stokes Phenomena
The analysis shows that relevant complex classical paths can change in two ways: (i) an intersection number changes when an edge enters or leaves the South-East sector, or when two edges change their order of firing, which is an ordinary Stokes phenomenon. (ii) the adjacency graph can change in a higher-order Stokes phenomenon when a singularity crosses the line segment between two adjacent paths. p. 1 Stokes made asymptotic series a working
tool of physics when he evaluated Airy’s rainbow integral by truncating its divergent series near the smallest term
[37]. He also found that the coefficient of an exponentially small contribution jumps when a parameter crosses a
line in the complex plane, the Stokes phenomenon [38], and Poincar´e gave the asymptotic expansion its precise
definition [39]. The South-East rule
then turns adjacency into relevance. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Definition of the Path Integral
The paper suggests that a definition of the path integral in terms of the transseries can be constructed without referring to a proper integral over paths. The transport recursion relations provide this transseries up to the intersection numbers, which are fixed by resurgence adjacency relations. p. 9 The saddle point survives the crossing
as an equivalence class of classical paths along deformed time contours [26, 27, 29]. Adjacency relations
After finding the classical paths, we evaluate the cumulants σ
(j)
m and the associated series coefficients a
(j)
m with the
transport recursion relations. Kawai, Takei, and collaborators developed this exact WKB analysis into a theory of Stokes curves and
connection formulae [47, 48], which today links resurgence to exact quantisation conditions, thermodynamic Bethe
ansatz equations, cluster algebras, and the spectral networks of supersymmetric gauge theories [49–53]. Exact WKB
analysis answers the question of relevance for an ordinary differential equation: the Stokes graph, drawn from the
turning points, tells which WKB solutions appear in which region.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The South-East Rule's Function
The South-East rule is used to identify relevant complex classical paths by translating the Stokes constants and geometry of the adjacency graph into intersection numbers. It confirms that the real classical paths are always relevant, while complex classical paths contribute when their associated ascent manifold intersects the original integration domain. p. 2 The non-degenerate real classical
paths, central to classical mechanics, always contribute, |nj | = 1. For the complex classical paths qj , capturing classically forbidden behaviour including quantum tunnelling, Picard-Lefschetz theory identifies the intersection number
nj with the number of intersections of the steepest ascent manifold Kj of the classical path qj with the original
integration domain Cx0,x1
, i. The South-East rule
then turns adjacency into relevance. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Role of Borel-Padé Methods
Borel-Padé methods are employed to approximate the integral and identify adjacency relations by truncating the Borel transform and computing its diagonal Padé approximant. The poles of the Padé approximant mimic singularities, and their structure reveals trails mimicking branch cuts behind adjacent saddle points. p. 8 To avoid the caustics, deform
the time domain [0, T] into a contour that leaves the real axis before each caustic and rejoins it after, and integrate
all equations along this contour. At a simple zero of det Y , the cumulants have poles but no branch points, so their
values at the time T do not depend on the side of the detour. The South-East rule
then turns adjacency into relevance. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Final Verdict
The agreement with the exact Rosen-Morse propagator, to exponential accuracy and through ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena, supports both claims. p. 0 For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator. The resummed series reproduce the
propagator with exponential accuracy. The real and
complex classical paths organise the integral into a set of Wiener-like integrals. The decomposition holds exactly, not
only in the limit ℏ → 0, and for a real and positive Planck constant the intersection numbers nj do not depend on ℏ;
we assume ℏ > 0 throughout. We show that resurgence provides a practical alternative. We
compute the asymptotic series of the real and complex classical paths to high order, with Feynman
diagrams and with a transport recursion for the cumulants, and read off the adjacency of the
classical paths from the divergent tails of the series with Borel-Pad´e methods. Section IV applies Borel-Pad´e methods to the classical paths of a non-relativistic particle that meets a
Rosen-Morse barrier: the divergent tails reveal the adjacency of the paths, and the South-East rule turns adjacency
into relevance. A spectral evaluation of the exact propagator confirms the verdict.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Future Direction
In a future paper, the authors plan to explore whether it suffices to compute the adjacency graph in one well-chosen configuration and propagate the adjacency relations to other configurations using higher-order Stokes phenomena. The goal is to derive the South-East rule from the definition of the Green’s function, although this proposal currently fails to explain its link to Feynman and Wheeler's original construction. The adjacency graph records which contributions see each other in the Borel plane and carries Stokes constants, which change in higher-order Stokes phenomena. p. 0 The South-East rule
then turns adjacency into relevance. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator. In
quantum gravity, Kontsevich and Segal, and Witten, proposed to admit only the complex metrics on which quantum
fields remain well behaved [65, 66]. Such criteria rule out saddle points, but they do not decide which of the allowed
saddle points contribute. The real and
complex classical paths organise the integral into a set of Wiener-like integrals. The decomposition holds exactly, not
only in the limit ℏ → 0, and for a real and positive Planck constant the intersection numbers nj do not depend on ℏ;
we assume ℏ > 0 throughout. A spectral evaluation of the exact propagator confirms the verdict. The Borel-Pad´e sums of the
relevant paths reproduce the propagator to the accuracy of the spectral integral at large 1/ℏ.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Significance for Quantum Gravity
The method offers a way to decide which saddle points contribute in quantum gravity, addressing criteria that rule out some saddle points but do not decide which ones contribute. The classical paths in complex or imaginary time carry effects like the decay of a false vacuum and tunnelling between vacua. p. 1 The question of relevant complex classical paths reaches far beyond quantum mechanics. Classical paths in complex
or imaginary time, the instantons, carry the effects that perturbation theory misses [61]: the decay of a false vacuum
[62], the tunnelling between the vacua of quantum chromodynamics [63], and the creation of a universe from nothing
[11, 23].Where the paper says it
The Need for Rigor
The real-time path integral as a genuine integral over paths defined in terms of a σ-measure lacks a generally accepted rigorous definition. The construction of the path integral in terms of absolutely convergent integrals over Lefschetz thimbles suggests such a definition exists but does not formally establish it. p. 2 Solutions with a complex initial
velocity (with non-zero imaginary parts) form the complex classical paths, which can describe classically forbidden
processes such as quantum tunnelling. Following Picard-Lefschetz theory, we continuously deform the space of paths interpolating between x0 and x1
into the space of complex paths, expressing the oscillatory integral in terms of a set of convergent integrals along the
descent manifolds Jj associated with the saddle points qj ,
G[x1, x0; T] = X
j
njG
(j)
[x1, x0; T] , (9)
with the intersection numbers nj ∈ Z, a sum that includes the equivalence classes of classical paths that arise when
a path crosses a singularity of the potential (see section IV), and the integral along the associated steepest descent
manifold Jj ,
G
(j)
[x1, x0; T] = Z
Jj
e
iS[q(t)]/ℏDq(t). The South-East rule
then turns adjacency into relevance. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator. The South-East rule
then turns adjacency into relevance. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Role of Images
The relevant classical paths are confirmed by the exact propagator, which includes images that contribute at exponentially smaller weight. The Borel-Padé sums of the real and the tunnelling path reproduce it to the accuracy of the spectral integral from 1/ħ = 6 on. p. 1 The Borel-Pad´e sums of the
relevant paths reproduce the propagator to the accuracy of the spectral integral at large 1/ℏ. A sweep of the final
point reveals higher-order Stokes phenomena, and across the barrier, a complex path with an energy far below the
barrier top carries the tunnelling amplitude. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the
relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that
carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point
moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator. The resummed series reproduce the
propagator with exponential accuracy. The Borel-Pad´e sums of the
relevant paths reproduce the propagator to the accuracy of the spectral integral at large 1/ℏ. A sweep of the final
point reveals higher-order Stokes phenomena, and across the barrier, a complex path with an energy far below the
barrier top carries the tunnelling amplitude.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Real-time path integral solvers can be enhanced to identify relevant complex classical paths by implementing a South-East rule that translates adjacency of saddle points directly into relevance, as described in Section IV. This allows the system to select which saddle points contribute to the integral without needing to compute every steepest ascent manifold in infinite dimensions.
-
The AI system can utilize transport recursion methods for computing cumulants, which circumvents the factorial growth of terms present in Feynman diagram expansions. This method yields coefficients at a modest cost, enabling the calculation of asymptotic series with exponential accuracy beyond the semiclassical regime as shown in Section III B.
-
The system can employ Borel-Padé methods to approximate the path integral by truncating its Borel transform and computing diagonal Padé approximants. This provides an exponentially accurate approximation of the propagator, which is particularly useful for verifying results against exact spectral representations, such as those found for the Rosen-Morse barrier in Appendix A.
-
The AI system can perform Stokes phenomenon detection by varying the phase of Planck's constant and observing changes in adjacency graphs across different angles in the Borel plane. This capability allows the system to identify when a complex classical path becomes relevant, which is crucial for understanding quantum tunnelling and higher-order Stokes phenomena as shown in Section IV.
-
The system can be extended to relativistic theories governed by Hamiltonian constraints by using the world-line quantization method and constrained transport recursion relations. This allows for the computation of cumulants in curved configuration spaces, providing a path integral road to Stokes phenomena in quantum gravity, as outlined in Section V.
Abstract
Which complex classical paths contribute to a real-time Feynman path integral? Picard-Lefschetz theory answers this question with the intersection numbers of the thimbles, which are notoriously hard to compute in infinite dimensions. We show that resurgence provides a practical alternative. We compute the asymptotic series of the real and complex classical paths to high order, with Feynman diagrams and with a transport recursion for the cumulants, and read off the adjacency of the classical paths from the divergent tails of the series with Borel-Padé methods. The South-East rule then turns adjacency into relevance. For a particle meeting a Rosen-Morse barrier, we identify the relevant complex classical paths in front of and behind the barrier, including the complex path that carries quantum tunnelling, follow ordinary and higher-order Stokes phenomena as the final point moves, and verify the predictions with the exact propagator. The resummed series reproduce the propagator with exponential accuracy. Finally, we outline how the expansion extends to relativistic path integrals governed by a Hamiltonian constraint.
Sources
- Analytic Continuation Of Chern-Simons Theory
- High density QCD on a Lefschetz thimble?
- Hybrid Monte Carlo on Lefschetz Thimbles -- A study of the residual sign problem
- Lorentzian Quantum Cosmology
- What is QFT? Resurgent trans-series, Lefschetz thimbles, and new exact saddles
- Deconstructing zero: resurgence, supersymmetry and complex saddles
- Existence of real time quantum path integrals
- Crossing singularities in the saddle point approximation
- Multi-Instantons and Exact Results I: Conjectures, WKB Expansions, and Instanton Interactions
- Multi-Instantons and Exact Results II: Specific Cases, Higher-Order Effects, and Numerical Calculations
- Uniform WKB, Multi-instantons, and Resurgent Trans-Series
- On exact-WKB analysis, resurgent structure, and quantization conditions
- TBA equations and resurgent Quantum Mechanics
- Exact WKB analysis and cluster algebras
- Spectral networks
- Resurgence and Hyperasymptotics in Wave Optics Astronomy
- Which Saddles Contribute? The South-East Rule for Multidimensional Integrals
- A universal approach to saddle-point methods in attosecond science
- Wick rotation and the positivity of energy in quantum field theory
- A Note On Complex Spacetime Metrics
Related papers
- Existence of a fluid phase for the two-dimensional one-component plasma
- The Huang-Yang conjecture for the low-density Fermi gas
- Anderson localisation in infinite and finite resonator crystals with long-range interactions
- Free energy and spectral edge of the SYK model
- Anderson localization for 1-d quasi-periodic Schr"odinger operators with degenerate weights
- Irregular SLE(4) martingales and isomonodromic deformations