An Algebraic Foundation of Rate-Product Style Quantity Calculus

arXiv:2611.12428 · math-ph, math.MP · Submitted 2026-11-09 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "An Algebraic Foundation of Rate-Product Style Quantity Calculus".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in

1: is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Kai: Foundational Concepts The paper introduces a generalization of quantity calculus by using the notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Mira: This framework aims to address limitations in previous approaches, such as the marginalization of ratios in favor of products, by proposing a unified system for handling magnitudes and rates.

Kai: The core ideas draw inspiration from Euclid's premodern theory of quantities, which involved numbers, magnitudes, and kinds of magnitudes.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper titled "An Algebraic Foundation of Rate-Product Style Quantity Calculus". The main idea is generalizing quantity calculus using a new concept called a scalable right monoid heap. It’s trying to bring in quantities that don't multiply well, like weak rates and products of quantities, instead of just ratios or simple products <ref:2611.12428#pg1>.

Mira: Exactly. The paper claims this new structure addresses limitations in previous approaches where people often marginalized ratios in favor of just products <ref:2611.12428#pg3>. They propose a unified system for handling both magnitudes and rates, drawing inspiration from older ideas about numbers and magnitudes from Euclid's theory <ref:2611.12428#pg3>.

Lev: From an engineering side, I’m interested in what this structure means for actual computation. The paper introduces R-sets, which are these specific non-trivial semirings with an R-action, and magnitude spaces defined as R-sets with a commutative action <ref:2611.12428#pg3>.

Kai: That sounds abstract, but the goal is to define how we handle magnitudes and rates in a way that unifies them. They focus on creating a common core for both sum-style and rate-product style calculus <ref:2611.12428#pg3>.

Mira: The sum-style part deals with addition and scalar multiplication of magnitudes, which they show is possible in unit dense magnitude spaces, defining it as x sub omega y equals mu plus nu times a unit <ref:2611.12428#pg3>.

Lev: And the main innovation for me seems to be this scalable right monoid heap concept. It replaces standard multiplication with ternary operations that allow for weak rates and products of rates, like x colon y z equals the norm of x, y, and z <ref:2611.12428#pg3>.

Kai: So it’s not just about multiplying things anymore; they are looking at how to define these weaker operations systematically using this heap structure.

Conclusion: Mira: Looking at the paper, "An Algebraic Foundation of Rate-Product Style Quantity Calculus", the authors are essentially proposing a new algebraic foundation for quantity calculus <ref:2611.12428#pg1>. They are extending the original idea from Euclid's theory by incorporating these scalable right monoid heaps to handle quantities that don't multiply as well as both rates and products <ref:2611.12428#pg3>.

Kai: The core of what they claim is this ability to unify sum-style and rate-product style calculus, which was a big issue in earlier work where ratios got sidelined for products <ref:2611.12428#pg3>. It matters because it offers an alternative framework to the product-style calculus that has been used previously in physics <ref:2611.12428#pg3>.

Lev: For us building hardware, the implication is figuring out how these weak rates and products of rates translate into actual operations on real systems. It gives a new language for expressing physical relationships beyond simple multiplication <ref:2611.12428#pg3>.

Mira: In simpler terms, they are providing a more comprehensive algebraic system for dealing with the different ways we describe physical quantities <ref:2611.12428#pg3>. It suggests that the way we model things in physics might benefit from this unified approach.

Kai: The authors are suggesting this framework could offer a more physically meaningful interpretation of quantities compared to just relying on product-style calculus <ref:2611.12428#pg3>. It’s about finding a structure that fits the physical reality better.

DAN JONSSON

math-ph, math.MP

Submitted: 2026-11-09

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 27 pages

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 54/100

The gist: Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and…

Key concepts

Scalable (Right) Monoid-Heap
This structure replaces standard multiplication with ternary operations to allow for the definition of weak rates. It is an R-set equipped with a specific function that enables the calculation of quantities like x:y(z), extending calculus beyond simple products and ratios.
Magnitude Spaces (R-sets)
These are formal structures used to define magnitudes by removing the concept of ratios. They are non-trivial, non-associative semirings with an R-action. Magnitudes in these spaces are equivalent if they satisfy a specific scaling relationship involving elements from the set R.
Euclidean Quantity Space
This is a multiplicative Euclidean magnitude space where every non-zero element has a unique inverse. It synthesizes rate and product styles, offering an alternative framework for physical quantities that provides more physically meaningful interpretations than traditional product-style calculus.

Terminology

Summary

Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities. p. 0

Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Foundational Concepts

The paper introduces a generalization of quantity calculus by using the notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities. This framework aims to address limitations in previous approaches, such as the marginalization of ratios in favor of products, by proposing a unified system for handling magnitudes and rates. p. 2

Where the paper says it

For example, ”11 dollars per 10 euros” and ”16 grams per 1 mole” make sense although 11 $/10 € cannot be interpreted as (11 $) (10 €) −1 and 16 g/1 mol can hardly be interpreted as (16 g) (1 mol)−1 . We propose to address the omissions and limitations just sketched by (a) including in quantity calculus magnitudes that may not be possible to multiply and (b) complementing products of quantities by rates, rather than replacing rates by products.

The core ideas draw inspiration from Euclid's premodern theory of quantities, which involved numbers, magnitudes, and kinds of magnitudes.

Magnitude Spaces

The paper defines a common core of rate-style and product-style quantity calculus as a natural extension by removing the notion of a ratio of magnitudes from Euclid’s theory. It formalizes this through R-sets, which are non-trivial, non-associative semirings with an R-action. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Definition 2. A non-trivial, non-associative semiring, or half-ring for brevity, is a set with addition and multiplication which is a commutative monoid under addition and a unital magma under multiplication, where the additive and multiplicative identity elements are distinct (0 ̸= 1), and we have the identities 0x = x0 = 0, x (y + z) = xy + xz, (y + z) x = yx + zx.

Magnitude spaces are defined as R-sets with a commutative R-action, where the equivalence relation between magnitudes is formalized by the relation x ∼ y if and only if α · x = β · y for some α, β ∈ R. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The intuitive notion of a magnitude x being of the same kind as a magnitude y is obviously an equivalence relation. This relation can be formalized in terms of a commutative R-action.

Sorts are then defined as the equivalence classes of this relation. p. 4
Where the paper says it

□ Definition 2. The equivalence classes for ∼ are called sorts.

Sum-Style Calculus

The sum-style quantity calculus focuses on addition and scalar multiplication of magnitudes, which is possible in unit-dense magnitude spaces. This structure is formalized by defining addition of magnitudes of the same kind using a unit, leading to the definition x∔y = (µ + ν)· u. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Thus, a scalable monoid with an appropriate set of units can be given a distributive structure, but it does not thereby become a ring since addition of magnitudes is limited to magnitudes of the same sort. Several important, desirable properties of sets of units come together in the following definition.

For a non-trivial ring R and a unit-dense magnitude space X, it is shown that C with scalar multiplication inherited from Definition 2. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Let R be a non-trivial ring and X be a magnitude space over R such that there exists a unit for C ∈ X/∼. Then C with scalar multiplication inherited from Definition 2.

2 and addition given by Definition 2. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2 we also have α · (β · x) = αβ · x and 1 · x = x (an identity overlooked by Euclid). Finally, if R is a ring then C is a group under addition as given by Definition 2.

15 is a free module of rank 1. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2 and addition given by Definition 2. 15 is a free module of rank 1.

Rate-Product Style Calculus

The main innovation lies in the notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, where multiplication is replaced by closely related ternary operations. A scalable right (biunit) monoid heap over R is an R-set with a function ˜t: X × Y × X → X, satisfying specific properties. p. 0

Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

This structure allows for the definition of weak rates, such as x: y (z) = ∥x, y, z∥. p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Furthermore, it introduces weak products of rates and rates of rates to extend the calculus beyond simple products and ratios. p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Euclidean Magnitude Spaces

The paper concludes by defining a multiplicative Euclidean magnitude space as a Euclidean magnitude space with a chosen non-zero element 1Q, where Jx, y, zK is defined for every non-zero y. This structure is shown to be equivalent to a scalable monoid where every non-zero y ∈ X has a unique inverse. p. 2

Where the paper says it

RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS 3 • an associative, commutative and distributive product xy of quantities such that (α · x) (β · y) = αβ · xy, a quantity 1 such that 1x = x1 = x for all x, and the inverse quantity x −1 such that x −1x = xx−1 = 1 for any non-zero quantity x; • for every quantity x an associated dimension [x] such that for every [x] there is a unique zero quantity 0[x] , [1] is isomorphic to a field, [x] [y] = [xy], and the set of dimensions with this operation is a free abelian group with identity element [1] and [x] −1 = x −1 for any non-zero quantity x. 1 In short, recently proposed formalizations of product-style quantity calculus converge to a common theory that satisfies de Boer’s requirements [1, pp.

The synthesis of rate and product styles leads to the notion of a Euclidean quantity space, which provides an alternative framework for physical quantities. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In Sections 8 and 9, we suggest a way to combine rates and products of quantities in a Euclidean quantity space, while Section 10 contains comments on further research. Magnitude spaces In this section, we define a common core of rate-style and product-style quantity calculus, obtained as a natural extension of what remains if we remove the notion of a ratio of magnitudes from Euclid’s theory of magnitudes.

Applications in Physics

The paper illustrates the utility of this calculus through examples such as the law of the lever, where it can express physical laws using both products and rates. It also shows how physical quantities like pressure, shear stress, and energy density can be modeled using weak rates or as reduced forms in Euclidean quantity spaces. p. 0

Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

The framework is shown to offer more physically meaningful interpretations of quantities compared to product-style calculus in certain contexts. p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Future Directions

The authors suggest that further research is needed to clarify how physical quantities and laws should be modeled, as the current algebraic structures do not suffice for operations like differentiation and integration of quantity functions. The work also points towards the possibility of combining this framework with tensor products of vector algebras to accommodate vector quantities. p. 6

Where the paper says it

In particular, if R is a field then every unit-dense magnitude space over R is a unique union of disjoint one-dimensional vector spaces. Sum-style quantity calculus There is something to say also about rudimentary quantity calculus without the notions of rates and products of magnitudes – what we may call sum-style quantity calculus since addition and scalar multiplication of magnitudes is nevertheless possible.

References

[1] Jonsson, D. Scalable monoids and quantity calculus. p. 3

Where the paper says it

4 DAN JONSSON article, starting with the sum-style quantity calculus briefly discussed in Section 3. In Section 4, we recall the formulation of product-style quantity calculus based on the notions of scalable monoids and quantity spaces [1].

p. 3
Where the paper says it

4 DAN JONSSON article, starting with the sum-style quantity calculus briefly discussed in Section 3. In Section 4, we recall the formulation of product-style quantity calculus based on the notions of scalable monoids and quantity spaces [1].

Semigroup Forum 107, 158–187 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00233-023-10371-0

[2] Euclid (of Alexandria). Stoicheia (The Elements) (c 300 BC). p. 0

Where the paper says it

Introduction In physics, and quantitative science in general, quantity calculus is a set of formal rules for calculating directly with underlying quantities rather than with their associated scalars (measures) [1, p. To understand the key ideas of modern quantity calculus, it is useful to be somewhat familiar with its precursor in early Greek mathematics, presented by Euclid in Book V of his Elements [2].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Introduction In physics, and quantitative science in general, quantity calculus is a set of formal rules for calculating directly with underlying quantities rather than with their associated scalars (measures) [1, p. To understand the key ideas of modern quantity calculus, it is useful to be somewhat familiar with its precursor in early Greek mathematics, presented by Euclid in Book V of his Elements [2].

[3] Newton, I. p. 0

Where the paper says it

To extend this narrow notion of numbers, a fraction µ/ν was represented as a ratio (µ · x) : (ν · x) of magnitudes of the same kind. As late as 1720, a number was defined in Newton’s Universal Arithmetick [3, p.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

To extend this narrow notion of numbers, a fraction µ/ν was represented as a ratio (µ · x) : (ν · x) of magnitudes of the same kind. As late as 1720, a number was defined in Newton’s Universal Arithmetick [3, p.

Universal Arithmetick. p. 0
Where the paper says it

To extend this narrow notion of numbers, a fraction µ/ν was represented as a ratio (µ · x) : (ν · x) of magnitudes of the same kind. As late as 1720, a number was defined in Newton’s Universal Arithmetick [3, p.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

To extend this narrow notion of numbers, a fraction µ/ν was represented as a ratio (µ · x) : (ν · x) of magnitudes of the same kind. As late as 1720, a number was defined in Newton’s Universal Arithmetick [3, p.

London (1720). p. 0
Where the paper says it

To extend this narrow notion of numbers, a fraction µ/ν was represented as a ratio (µ · x) : (ν · x) of magnitudes of the same kind. As late as 1720, a number was defined in Newton’s Universal Arithmetick [3, p.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

To extend this narrow notion of numbers, a fraction µ/ν was represented as a ratio (µ · x) : (ν · x) of magnitudes of the same kind. As late as 1720, a number was defined in Newton’s Universal Arithmetick [3, p.

[4] Malet, A. Renaissance notions of number and magnitude. p. 6

Where the paper says it

In particular, if R is a field then every unit-dense magnitude space over R is a unique union of disjoint one-dimensional vector spaces. Sum-style quantity calculus There is something to say also about rudimentary quantity calculus without the notions of rates and products of magnitudes – what we may call sum-style quantity calculus since addition and scalar multiplication of magnitudes is nevertheless possible.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

In particular, if R is a field then every unit-dense magnitude space over R is a unique union of disjoint one-dimensional vector spaces. Sum-style quantity calculus There is something to say also about rudimentary quantity calculus without the notions of rates and products of magnitudes – what we may call sum-style quantity calculus since addition and scalar multiplication of magnitudes is nevertheless possible.

Hist. Math. 33, 63–81 (2006).

[5] Fourier, J. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 DAN JONSSON While Euclid’s geometry was taught in secondary schools until it was hit by the New Math tsunami in the second half of the 20th century, his theory of magnitudes was largely forgotten already towards the end of the 17th century [4, pp. Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

2 DAN JONSSON While Euclid’s geometry was taught in secondary schools until it was hit by the New Math tsunami in the second half of the 20th century, his theory of magnitudes was largely forgotten already towards the end of the 17th century [4, pp. Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp.

B.J. The Analytical Theory of Heat (translation of Théorie Analytique de la Chaleur (1822). p. 1
Where the paper says it

83], and he did not write his law of gravitation as F = G Mm r 2 but expressed it in terms of proportionality between the acceleration due to gravitation of a body towards another body and the mass of each body as well as inverse proportionality with the square of the distance between the bodies. However, already in Mécanique analytique [8] Lagrange used products such as Mm and Mmr−2 , initially regarded as products of numbers.

Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2009).

[6] Maxwell, J. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp. 126–130] partially formalized the notion of “dimensional homogeneity”, or equivalently “kind of quantity”, and when Maxwell [6, p.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp. 126–130] partially formalized the notion of “dimensional homogeneity”, or equivalently “kind of quantity”, and when Maxwell [6, p.

Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism, vol. 1. Clarendon, Oxford (1873).

[7] Newton, I. p. 0

Where the paper says it

To extend this narrow notion of numbers, a fraction µ/ν was represented as a ratio (µ · x) : (ν · x) of magnitudes of the same kind. As late as 1720, a number was defined in Newton’s Universal Arithmetick [3, p.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

To extend this narrow notion of numbers, a fraction µ/ν was represented as a ratio (µ · x) : (ν · x) of magnitudes of the same kind. As late as 1720, a number was defined in Newton’s Universal Arithmetick [3, p.

Newton’s Principia. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Newton was actually among the last physicists to think in terms of ratios (or rates) rather than products. For example, in Principia he did not write F = ma but stated that “the alteration of motion is ever proportional to the motive force impressed” [7, p.

The Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In Sections 8 and 9, we suggest a way to combine rates and products of quantities in a Euclidean quantity space, while Section 10 contains comments on further research. Magnitude spaces In this section, we define a common core of rate-style and product-style quantity calculus, obtained as a natural extension of what remains if we remove the notion of a ratio of magnitudes from Euclid’s theory of magnitudes.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

In Sections 8 and 9, we suggest a way to combine rates and products of quantities in a Euclidean quantity space, while Section 10 contains comments on further research. Magnitude spaces In this section, we define a common core of rate-style and product-style quantity calculus, obtained as a natural extension of what remains if we remove the notion of a ratio of magnitudes from Euclid’s theory of magnitudes.

New York (1846) [Project Gutenberg]. p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

[8] Lagrange, Joseph-Louis. p. 1

Where the paper says it

83], and he did not write his law of gravitation as F = G Mm r 2 but expressed it in terms of proportionality between the acceleration due to gravitation of a body towards another body and the mass of each body as well as inverse proportionality with the square of the distance between the bodies. However, already in Mécanique analytique [8] Lagrange used products such as Mm and Mmr−2 , initially regarded as products of numbers.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

83], and he did not write his law of gravitation as F = G Mm r 2 but expressed it in terms of proportionality between the acceleration due to gravitation of a body towards another body and the mass of each body as well as inverse proportionality with the square of the distance between the bodies. However, already in Mécanique analytique [8] Lagrange used products such as Mm and Mmr−2 , initially regarded as products of numbers.

Mécanique Analytique. p. 1
Where the paper says it

83], and he did not write his law of gravitation as F = G Mm r 2 but expressed it in terms of proportionality between the acceleration due to gravitation of a body towards another body and the mass of each body as well as inverse proportionality with the square of the distance between the bodies. However, already in Mécanique analytique [8] Lagrange used products such as Mm and Mmr−2 , initially regarded as products of numbers.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

83], and he did not write his law of gravitation as F = G Mm r 2 but expressed it in terms of proportionality between the acceleration due to gravitation of a body towards another body and the mass of each body as well as inverse proportionality with the square of the distance between the bodies. However, already in Mécanique analytique [8] Lagrange used products such as Mm and Mmr−2 , initially regarded as products of numbers.

Courcier (1811). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2009).

[9] Drobot, S. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Systematic efforts to construct a rigorous quantity calculus again did not gain traction until the 20th century, clearly inspired by the rise of abstract algebra, especially the theory of abstract vector spaces. In a ground-breaking article, Drobot [9] proposed a formalization of product-style quantity calculus, using a multiplicatively written vector space.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Systematic efforts to construct a rigorous quantity calculus again did not gain traction until the 20th century, clearly inspired by the rise of abstract algebra, especially the theory of abstract vector spaces. In a ground-breaking article, Drobot [9] proposed a formalization of product-style quantity calculus, using a multiplicatively written vector space.

On the foundations of dimensional analysis. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp. 126–130] partially formalized the notion of “dimensional homogeneity”, or equivalently “kind of quantity”, and when Maxwell [6, p.

Stud. Math. 14, 84–99 (1953).

[10] Quade, W. Über die algebraische Struktur des Größenkalküls der Physik. Abh. Braunschw. Wiss. Ges. 13, 24–65 (1961).

[11] Whitney, H. The mathematics of physical quantities, part II: Quantity structures and dimensional analysis (Am. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17]. Although using different formulations, these new algebraic structures are essentially equivalent, and incorporate the following central notions: • quantities, expressed through but distinct from their measures, scalar multiplication of quantities by numbers, the notion of a zero quantity such that 0 · x = x, kinds of quantities and sums of quantities of the same kind, and the notion of a unit, a quantity u such that any quantity of the same kind as u has a unique measure relative to u;

Math. Mon., 75, 227–256 (1968).

[12] Szekeres, P. The mathematical foundations of dimensional analysis and the question of fundamental units (International Journal of Theoretical Physics 17, 957–974 (1978).

[13] Carlson, D.E. A mathematical theory of physical units, dimensions and measures (Arch. p. 2

Where the paper says it

RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS 3 • an associative, commutative and distributive product xy of quantities such that (α · x) (β · y) = αβ · xy, a quantity 1 such that 1x = x1 = x for all x, and the inverse quantity x −1 such that x −1x = xx−1 = 1 for any non-zero quantity x; • for every quantity x an associated dimension [x] such that for every [x] there is a unique zero quantity 0[x] , [1] is isomorphic to a field, [x] [y] = [xy], and the set of dimensions with this operation is a free abelian group with identity element [1] and [x] −1 = x −1 for any non-zero quantity x. 1 In short, recently proposed formalizations of product-style quantity calculus converge to a common theory that satisfies de Boer’s requirements [1, pp.

Rat. Mech. Anal., 70, 289–304 (1979).

[14] Curtis, W.D., Logan, J.D., Parker, W.A. Dimensional analysis and the pi theorem (Linear Algebra Appl. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Counterparts of basic Euclidean notions such as kinds of quantities, scalar multiplication of quantities and addition of quantities of the same kind were also used, but not rigorously and systematically. Systematic efforts to construct a rigorous quantity calculus again did not gain traction until the 20th century, clearly inspired by the rise of abstract algebra, especially the theory of abstract vector spaces.

, 47 (1982), 117–126). p. 1
Where the paper says it

Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp. 126–130] partially formalized the notion of “dimensional homogeneity”, or equivalently “kind of quantity”, and when Maxwell [6, p.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp. 126–130] partially formalized the notion of “dimensional homogeneity”, or equivalently “kind of quantity”, and when Maxwell [6, p.

https://doi.org/10.1016/0024-3795(82)90229-4

[15] Kock, A. Mathematical structure of physical quantities (Arch. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Then the unit ui can be a single entity such as a molecule or a quantum, or a collection of entities such as 12 entity-typei (a dozen), 8 bit(s) (a byte) or 602 214 076×1023 elementary entities (a mole). Physical quantities such as half a dozen eggs, 1.

Rat. Mech. Anal., 107, 99–104 (1989).

[16] Jonsson, D. p. 0

Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Magnitudes, scalable monoids and quantity spaces (arXiv:2108. p. 0
Where the paper says it

One may use the term rate for a ratio of magnitudes of possibly different kinds, such as a rate of exchange of currencies or a velocity. 1 arXiv:2611.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

4 DAN JONSSON article, starting with the sum-style quantity calculus briefly discussed in Section 3. In Section 4, we recall the formulation of product-style quantity calculus based on the notions of scalable monoids and quantity spaces [1].

p. 3
Where the paper says it

4 DAN JONSSON article, starting with the sum-style quantity calculus briefly discussed in Section 3. In Section 4, we recall the formulation of product-style quantity calculus based on the notions of scalable monoids and quantity spaces [1].

02106 [math. p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 arXiv:2611. 12428v1 [math-ph] 9 Nov 2026

p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 arXiv:2611. 12428v1 [math-ph] 9 Nov 2026

p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 arXiv:2611. 12428v1 [math-ph] 9 Nov 2026

RA]). https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv. p. 0
Where the paper says it

One may use the term rate for a ratio of magnitudes of possibly different kinds, such as a rate of exchange of currencies or a velocity. 1 arXiv:2611.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

One may use the term rate for a ratio of magnitudes of possibly different kinds, such as a rate of exchange of currencies or a velocity. 1 arXiv:2611.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

One may use the term rate for a ratio of magnitudes of possibly different kinds, such as a rate of exchange of currencies or a velocity. 1 arXiv:2611.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

One may use the term rate for a ratio of magnitudes of possibly different kinds, such as a rate of exchange of currencies or a velocity. 1 arXiv:2611.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

One may use the term rate for a ratio of magnitudes of possibly different kinds, such as a rate of exchange of currencies or a velocity. 1 arXiv:2611.

2108.02106

[17] de Boer, J. On the history of quantity calculus and the international system (Metrologia 31, 405–429 (1994). p. 1

Where the paper says it

This attempt at formalization was followed by others [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15], but especially the notions of quantities of the same kind and addition of such quantities proved difficult to define concisely and rigorously [16, Appendix B1]. In a survey article from 1994, de Boer [17] concluded that quantity calculus had not yet found its final form.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

This attempt at formalization was followed by others [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15], but especially the notions of quantities of the same kind and addition of such quantities proved difficult to define concisely and rigorously [16, Appendix B1]. In a survey article from 1994, de Boer [17] concluded that quantity calculus had not yet found its final form.

[18] Raposo, A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

P. The algebraic structure of quantity calculus (Meas. p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Sci. Rev., 18, 147–157 (2018).

[19] Alymov, G. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

Physical quantities as a partially additive field (arXiv:2502. p. 1
Where the paper says it

2 DAN JONSSON While Euclid’s geometry was taught in secondary schools until it was hit by the New Math tsunami in the second half of the 20th century, his theory of magnitudes was largely forgotten already towards the end of the 17th century [4, pp. Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

2 DAN JONSSON While Euclid’s geometry was taught in secondary schools until it was hit by the New Math tsunami in the second half of the 20th century, his theory of magnitudes was largely forgotten already towards the end of the 17th century [4, pp. Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp.

00967 [math-ph]). p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 arXiv:2611. 12428v1 [math-ph] 9 Nov 2026

p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 arXiv:2611. 12428v1 [math-ph] 9 Nov 2026

p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 arXiv:2611. 12428v1 [math-ph] 9 Nov 2026

https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2502.00967

[20] Bureau International des Poids et Mesures: The International System of Units, 9th ed (2019).

[21] Kuehn, K. The Law of the Lever (In: A Student’s Guide Through the Great Physics Texts. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In the tradition from Euclid, multiplication of quantities (except lengths) was considered to be impossible; only the forming of ratios of quantities of the same kind was allowed. Following Archimedes, Galileo still expressed the law of the lever as the ratio f1/f2 = ℓ2/ℓ1, not as f1ℓ1 = f2ℓ2.

Undergraduate Lecture Notes in Physics. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities. Several examples are given of applications in metrology and physics.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities. Several examples are given of applications in metrology and physics.

Springer, New York, NY). p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-1366-4 6

[22] Flater, D. Dealing with counts and other quantal quantities in quantity calculus (Measurement: Journal of the International Measurement Confederation (IMEKO), [online] (2023). p. 5

Where the paper says it

Let X be a magnitude space. A unit (of measurement) is a magnitude u ∈ X such that for every x ∼ u there is a unique µ ∈ R such that x = µ · u.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.measurement. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Let X be a magnitude space. A unit (of measurement) is a magnitude u ∈ X such that for every x ∼ u there is a unique µ ∈ R such that x = µ · u.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

Let X be a magnitude space. A unit (of measurement) is a magnitude u ∈ X such that for every x ∼ u there is a unique µ ∈ R such that x = µ · u.

2022.112226

[30] Emerson, W.H., On quantity calculus and units of measurement (Metrologia 45, 134–138 (2008). p. 8

Where the paper says it

This is the familiar formula that shows how measures change when units do. Scalable monoids and quantity spaces In this section, we briefly review the foundation of product-style quantity calculus presented in [1].

p. 8
Where the paper says it

This is the familiar formula that shows how measures change when units do. Scalable monoids and quantity spaces In this section, we briefly review the foundation of product-style quantity calculus presented in [1].

doi:10.1088/0026-1394/45/2/002

[31] Jonsson, D., Raposo, A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

P. Scalar Quantities and Vector Quantities: A Unified Algebraic Framework (in prep. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17]. Although using different formulations, these new algebraic structures are essentially equivalent, and incorporate the following central notions: • quantities, expressed through but distinct from their measures, scalar multiplication of quantities by numbers, the notion of a zero quantity such that 0 · x = x, kinds of quantities and sums of quantities of the same kind, and the notion of a unit, a quantity u such that any quantity of the same kind as u has a unique measure relative to u;

).

[32] Raposo, A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

P. The Algebraic Structure of Quantity Calculus II: Dimensional Analysis and Differential and Integral Calculus (Meas. p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Sci. Rev., 19, 70–78 (2019). doi:10.2478/msr2019-0012

[33] Bureau International des Poids et Mesures, Consultative Committee for Units: Report of the 21st meeting to the International Committee for Weights and Measures, 18–20 (2013).

[34] Fleischmann, R. Die Struktur des physikalischen Begriffssystems (Z. Phys. 129, 377–400 (1951).

[35] Krystek, M. The term ’dimension’ in the international system of units (Metrologia, 52, 297–300 (2015). p. 5

Where the paper says it

A (minimally) unit-dense magnitude space X is a magnitude space such that there exists some (minimal) dense set of units U ⊆ X. An element of a unit-dense magnitude space is called a measurable magnitude, and a system of units for X is a minimal dense set of units U ⊆ X.

[36] Jonsson, D. p. 0

Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Magnitudes, scalable monoids and quantity spaces (arXiv:2108.02106 [math.RA]). arXiv:2108.02106

[37] de Boer, J. On the history of quantity calculus and the international system (Metrologia 31, 405–429 (1994).

[38] Raposo, A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In recent years, significant progress has been made concerning de Boer’s program. Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17].

P. The algebraic structure of quantity calculus II: Dimensional Analysis and Differential and Integral Calculus (Meas. p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Sci. Rev., 19, 70–78 (2019). doi:10.2478/msr2019-0012

[39] Alymov, G. Physical quantities as a partially additive field (arXiv:2502.00967 [math-ph]). https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2502.00967

[41] Fleischmann, R., Die Struktur des physikalischen Begriffssystems (Z. Phys. 129, 377–400 (1951).

[43] Krystek, M., The term ’dimension’ in the international system of units (Metrologia, 52, 297–300 (2015). p. 5

Where the paper says it

A (minimally) unit-dense magnitude space X is a magnitude space such that there exists some (minimal) dense set of units U ⊆ X. An element of a unit-dense magnitude space is called a measurable magnitude, and a system of units for X is a minimal dense set of units U ⊆ X.

[44] Fleischmann, R., Die Struktur des physikalischen Begriffssystems (Z. Phys. 129, 377–400 (1951).

[46] Hollings, C.D., Lawson, M.V. Wagner’s theory of generalised heaps (Springer (2017). p. 3

Where the paper says it

Then we switch track to rate-style quantity calculus. In Sections 5 and 6, we introduce (right) scalable monoid-heaps, corresponding to scalable monoids, define (weak) rates on (right) scalable monoid-heaps, and investigate sets of rates regarded as scalable groups.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Then we switch track to rate-style quantity calculus. In Sections 5 and 6, we introduce (right) scalable monoid-heaps, corresponding to scalable monoids, define (weak) rates on (right) scalable monoid-heaps, and investigate sets of rates regarded as scalable groups.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper discusses the various operations and structures within the proposed calculus. It details how weak rates can be defined as functions ˜r (x, y) = ∥x, y, z∥. p. 0

Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

The concept of a rate space ˜r (X) is established as a magnitude space over R. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In Sections 8 and 9, we suggest a way to combine rates and products of quantities in a Euclidean quantity space, while Section 10 contains comments on further research. Magnitude spaces In this section, we define a common core of rate-style and product-style quantity calculus, obtained as a natural extension of what remains if we remove the notion of a ratio of magnitudes from Euclid’s theory of magnitudes.

The product of weak rates and the product of rates are defined using ternary operations involving the heap structure. p. 0
Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

How the training signal is built

The paper details how to combine different types of operations, such as nested heap brackets and rate complexes, which allow for complex compositions of functions. Specific constructions like (R1) through (R7) are presented to illustrate these compositions using dash notation and asterisk notation. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Blurring the subtle distinction between counts of entities and counts of units, it is convenient to write a count of units in the the same format as a count of entities, that is, to write n ui instead of n · ui . Similar notation is used for other magnitudes than counts.

Where the gains come from

The primary gain is the ability to express physical laws in multiple ways, such as the law of the lever, using either products or rates. The framework allows for a unified quantity calculus based on Euclidean quantity spaces, which can be seen as an alternative to product-style calculus. p. 3

Where the paper says it

4 DAN JONSSON article, starting with the sum-style quantity calculus briefly discussed in Section 3. In Section 4, we recall the formulation of product-style quantity calculus based on the notions of scalable monoids and quantity spaces [1].

This synthesis aims to provide a foundation for dimensional analysis while retaining more physically meaningful interpretations of quantities. The ability to model quantities like rainfall or dynamic viscosity provides concrete examples of the framework's application in physics.

Further Research

The authors note that the algebraic structures presented do not yet suffice for operations such as differentiation and integration of quantity functions. They also indicate that generalizing product-style calculus to accommodate vector quantities is an open question but has seen significant progress through tensor products of vector algebras. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In a ground-breaking article, Drobot [9] proposed a formalization of product-style quantity calculus, using a multiplicatively written vector space. This attempt at formalization was followed by others [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15], but especially the notions of quantities of the same kind and addition of such quantities proved difficult to define concisely and rigorously [16, Appendix B1].

The paper emphasizes the need for further research with input from physics and metrology to clarify how physical quantities and laws should be modeled. p. 7
Where the paper says it

83 m cannot be modeled as magnitudes that are counts of the units used. To accommodate such physical quantities, we need a more finely graded number system than the integers.

[1] Jonsson, D. Scalable monoids and quantity calculus. Semigroup Forum 107, 158–187 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00233-023-10371-0

[2] Euclid (of Alexandria). Stoicheia (The Elements) (c 300 BC).

[3] Newton, I. Universal Arithmetick. London (1720).

[4] Malet, A. Renaissance notions of number and magnitude. Hist. Math. 33, 63–81 (2006).

[5] Fourier, J.B.J., The Analytical Theory of Heat (translation of Théorie Analytique de la Chaleur (1822). p. 1

Where the paper says it

83], and he did not write his law of gravitation as F = G Mm r 2 but expressed it in terms of proportionality between the acceleration due to gravitation of a body towards another body and the mass of each body as well as inverse proportionality with the square of the distance between the bodies. However, already in Mécanique analytique [8] Lagrange used products such as Mm and Mmr−2 , initially regarded as products of numbers.

Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2009).

[6] Maxwell, J., Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism, vol. 1. Clarendon, Oxford (1873).

[7] Newton, I., Newton’s Principia. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Newton was actually among the last physicists to think in terms of ratios (or rates) rather than products. For example, in Principia he did not write F = ma but stated that “the alteration of motion is ever proportional to the motive force impressed” [7, p.

The Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy. New York (1846) [Project Gutenberg].

[8] Lagrange, Joseph-Louis. Mécanique Analytique. Courcier (1811). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2009).

[9] Drobot, S., On the foundations of dimensional analysis. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp. 126–130] partially formalized the notion of “dimensional homogeneity”, or equivalently “kind of quantity”, and when Maxwell [6, p.

Stud. Math. 14, 84–99 (1953).

[10] Quade, W., Über die algebraische Struktur des Größenkalküls der Physik. Abh. Braunschwiss Wiss.-Ges. 13, 24–65 (1961).

[11] Whitney, H., The mathematics of physical quantities, part II: Quantity structures and dimensional analysis (Am. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17]. Although using different formulations, these new algebraic structures are essentially equivalent, and incorporate the following central notions: • quantities, expressed through but distinct from their measures, scalar multiplication of quantities by numbers, the notion of a zero quantity such that 0 · x = x, kinds of quantities and sums of quantities of the same kind, and the notion of a unit, a quantity u such that any quantity of the same kind as u has a unique measure relative to u;

Math. Mon., 75, 227–256 (1968).

[12] Szekeres, P., The mathematical foundations of dimensional analysis and the question of fundamental units (International Journal of Theoretical Physics 17, 957–974 (1978).

[13] Carlson, D.E., A mathematical theory of physical units, dimensions and measures (Arch. p. 2

Where the paper says it

RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS 3 • an associative, commutative and distributive product xy of quantities such that (α · x) (β · y) = αβ · xy, a quantity 1 such that 1x = x1 = x for all x, and the inverse quantity x −1 such that x −1x = xx−1 = 1 for any non-zero quantity x; • for every quantity x an associated dimension [x] such that for every [x] there is a unique zero quantity 0[x] , [1] is isomorphic to a field, [x] [y] = [xy], and the set of dimensions with this operation is a free abelian group with identity element [1] and [x] −1 = x −1 for any non-zero quantity x. 1 In short, recently proposed formalizations of product-style quantity calculus converge to a common theory that satisfies de Boer’s requirements [1, pp.

Rat. Mech. Anal., 70, 289–304 (1979).

[14] Curtis, W.D., Logan, J.D., Parker, W.A., Dimensional analysis and the pi theorem (Linear Algebra Appl. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Counterparts of basic Euclidean notions such as kinds of quantities, scalar multiplication of quantities and addition of quantities of the same kind were also used, but not rigorously and systematically. Systematic efforts to construct a rigorous quantity calculus again did not gain traction until the 20th century, clearly inspired by the rise of abstract algebra, especially the theory of abstract vector spaces.

, 47 (1982), 117–126). https://doi.org/10.1016/0024-3795(82)90229-4

[15] Kock, A., Mathematical structure of physical quantities (Arch. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Then the unit ui can be a single entity such as a molecule or a quantum, or a collection of entities such as 12 entity-typei (a dozen), 8 bit(s) (a byte) or 602 214 076×1023 elementary entities (a mole). Physical quantities such as half a dozen eggs, 1.

Rat. Mech. Anal., 107, 99–104 (1989).

[16] Jonsson, D., Magnitudes, scalable monoids and quantity spaces (arXiv:2108. p. 3

Where the paper says it

4 DAN JONSSON article, starting with the sum-style quantity calculus briefly discussed in Section 3. In Section 4, we recall the formulation of product-style quantity calculus based on the notions of scalable monoids and quantity spaces [1].

02106 [math.RA]). https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2108.02106

[17] de Boer, J., On the history of quantity calculus and the international system (Metrologia 31, 405–429 (1994). p. 1

Where the paper says it

This attempt at formalization was followed by others [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15], but especially the notions of quantities of the same kind and addition of such quantities proved difficult to define concisely and rigorously [16, Appendix B1]. In a survey article from 1994, de Boer [17] concluded that quantity calculus had not yet found its final form.

[18] Raposo, A.P., The algebraic structure of quantity calculus (Meas. p. 0

Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Sci. Rev., 18, 147–157 (2018).

[19] Alymov, G., Physical quantities as a partially additive field (arXiv:2502. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 DAN JONSSON While Euclid’s geometry was taught in secondary schools until it was hit by the New Math tsunami in the second half of the 20th century, his theory of magnitudes was largely forgotten already towards the end of the 17th century [4, pp. Magnitudes, or quantities, were partially reinvented later in special contexts, as when Fourier [5, pp.

00967 [math-ph]). https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2502.00967

[20] Bureau International des Poids et Mesures: The International System of Units, 9th ed (2019).

[21] Kuehn, K., The Law of the Lever (In: A Student’s Guide Through the Great Physics Texts. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In the tradition from Euclid, multiplication of quantities (except lengths) was considered to be impossible; only the forming of ratios of quantities of the same kind was allowed. Following Archimedes, Galileo still expressed the law of the lever as the ratio f1/f2 = ℓ2/ℓ1, not as f1ℓ1 = f2ℓ2.

Undergraduate Lecture Notes in Physics. Springer, New York, NY). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-1366-4 6

[22] Flater, D., Dealing with counts and other quantal quantities in quantity calculus (Measurement: Journal of the International Measurement Confederation (IMEKO), [online] (2023). p. 5

Where the paper says it

Let X be a magnitude space. A unit (of measurement) is a magnitude u ∈ X such that for every x ∼ u there is a unique µ ∈ R such that x = µ · u.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.measurement.2022.112226

[30] Emerson, W.H., On quantity calculus and units of measurement (Metrologia 45, 134–138 (2008). doi:10.1088/0026-1394/45/2/002

[31] Jonsson, D., Raposo, A.P., Scalar Quantities and Vector Quantities: A Unified Algebraic Framework (in prep. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Raposo and Jonsson [18, 1], influenced by de Boer, and Alymov [19] have, independently of each other, proposed algebraic structures that satisfy the criteria in [17]. Although using different formulations, these new algebraic structures are essentially equivalent, and incorporate the following central notions: • quantities, expressed through but distinct from their measures, scalar multiplication of quantities by numbers, the notion of a zero quantity such that 0 · x = x, kinds of quantities and sums of quantities of the same kind, and the notion of a unit, a quantity u such that any quantity of the same kind as u has a unique measure relative to u;

).

[32] Raposo, A.P., The Algebraic Structure of Quantity Calculus II: Dimensional Analysis and Differential and Integral Calculus (Meas. p. 0

Where the paper says it

AN ALGEBRAIC FOUNDATION OF RATE-PRODUCT STYLE QUANTITY CALCULUS DAN JONSSON Abstract. Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities.

Sci. Rev., 19, 70–78 (2019). doi:10.2478/msr2019-0012

[33] Bureau International des Poids et Mesures, Consultative Committee for Units: Report of the 21st meeting to the International Committee for Weights and Measures, 18–20 (2013).

[45] Hollings, C.D., Lawson, M.V. Wagner’s theory of generalised heaps (Springer (2017).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced quantity calculus capabilities allow for calculating quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities. This enables applications in metrology and physics where traditional methods fail due to non-multiplicative relationships between physical properties.

  2. The system can model physical laws using equality of rates, such as the law of the lever, by expressing them in terms of ratios rather than just products or vice versa. This provides a unified framework for modeling different types of physical relationships and units.

  3. AI systems can perform conversion between magnitudes with high precision by utilizing formulas derived from quantity calculus, such as (7.1) x/y star z = alpha/beta · z when x ∼ y and z is of the same sort as y. This allows for accurate scaling between different physical units or measurements.

  4. The system can model complex physical phenomena like dynamic viscosity by combining rates and products using a unified expression such as F/A (l x / t) / l y, which simplifies to a form recognizable in SI base units, offering a more physically meaningful representation than purely product-style calculus.

  5. The system can handle quantities with distinct sorts by defining weak rates of sorts, such as [x] : [y], allowing for the modeling of relative physical properties like relative lengths or relative mass densities. This capability is crucial for distinguishing between quantities that have different fundamental dimensions.

Abstract

Using the new notion of a scalable (right) monoid-heap, the quantity calculus in [1] is generalized to include quantities that may not be possible to multiply as well as both (weak) rates and products of quantities. Several examples are given of applications in metrology and physics

Sources

Related papers