The Lee-Yang property of the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model

arXiv:2611.11484 · math-ph, math.MP · Submitted 2026-11-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The Lee-Yang property of the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper proves that for sufficiently large interaction intensities in the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model, its partition function possesses the Lee-Yang property.

Kai: The celebrated Lee-Yang theorem states that the continuation to complex values of the external magnetic field h of the partition function ZβN of the collection of N interacting Ising spins has purely imaginary zeros if the interaction is ferromagnetic.

Mira: This property implies that ZβN can be written in a specific form involving an infinite product over parameters γj satisfying certain constraints.

Kai: The partition function ZβN(h) is expressed as an exponential type entire function related to a finite measure χ by the representation (1.3).

Paper summary: Kai: So, looking back at "The Lee-Yang property of the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model," these authors have established that under certain conditions on interaction intensities—specifically those bounds involving Lambda Kij and the structural decomposition for higher temperatures—the partition function exhibits the Lee-Yang property.

Mira: It means that for sufficiently large interaction strengths in this model, we can guarantee that its partition function will have purely imaginary zeros when you look at it in the complex plane of an external magnetic field h. This is a significant result because it gives us a concrete mathematical framework for understanding the phase transitions or critical behavior in these systems under strong coupling.

Lev: For those of us working on error correction, this is useful because it tells us where we need to focus our efforts regarding the stability of these systems; we know that if we push the interactions past those calculated bounds, we can rely on this property for analysis.

Kai: The paper shows that even with terms like the quadrupole interaction term PKijS2i S2j being present, as long as those interaction intensities are above a certain threshold, the Lee-Yang property holds. That suggests that the model's underlying physics is robust enough to support this property under strong coupling.

Mira: The implication for condensed matter theory is that this provides a pathway to analyze the behavior of these complex spin models in regimes where they might otherwise be intractable using simpler methods. It opens up a new way to study when and where these systems can exhibit the characteristics described by the Lee-Yang theorem.

Lev: Ultimately, it sets clear criteria for when we can trust certain analytical tools for this model; if you are designing a simulation or trying to understand the limits of its applicability, you need to respect those interaction intensity bounds. That's what this paper delivers.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about proving that for a Blume-Emery-Griffiths model when you have strong enough interactions, its partition function has this Lee-Yang property.

Mira: Right, it’s showing that if you crank up the interaction strengths past a certain point, the math works out so that those zeros in the complex field space line up in a specific way.

Lev: From where I sit on error correction, what does that mean practically for us? Does this just mean we can simulate these things more reliably?

Kai: It means we have a solid mathematical foundation now for analyzing the behavior of these spin systems when they get really coupled together. The authors tackle the trouble that some of their quadrupole interaction term makes it hard to use standard proofs for the Lee-Yang property.

Mira: They showed that if you meet certain criteria on those interaction strengths, like J being bigger than Lambda Kij, then the whole partition function structure is sound. It’s about setting a threshold for coupling strength.

Lev: And that threshold is tied to these decomposition conditions they set up for higher temperatures too, which involves splitting the system into smaller pieces called dimers under certain circumstances. That adds another layer of complexity to the requirement for it to hold true.

Kai: So, basically, if you get the interactions intense enough—either by being strong enough overall or by meeting those specific structural requirements at different temperatures—you can trust that partition function behaves nicely in the complex plane.

Mira: It’s not just a nice result; it sets up a rigorous way to connect these microscopic spin interactions to macroscopic thermodynamic properties. It gives us a tool for when we think the system is behaving in that well-behaved regime.

Lev: For real hardware, if we can prove this property holds under these specific conditions, it tells us what kind of stability we can expect when scaling up the physical parameters in our actual qubit designs.

Kai: Exactly. This work shows that even with complicated interactions like the quadrupole one, there are definite limits where the system's behavior is predictable enough to be analyzed rigorously.

Mira: It opens up a new avenue for theorists to look at models that were previously too messy because they didn't meet those intensity requirements. We can now study them within this established framework.

Lev: And it gives engineers like me a clearer boundary on what kind of physical parameters we need to keep in check if we want our simulations or hardware setups to stay within the regime where this math applies.

YURI KOZITSKY

University of Marii Curie-Skłodowska

math-ph, math.MP

Submitted: 2026-11-08

Updated: 2026-11-08

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 62/100

The gist: The paper proves that for sufficiently large interaction intensities in the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model, its partition function possesses the Lee-Yang property.

Key concepts

Lee-Yang Property
This theorem states that for ferromagnetic systems, the partition function has zeros only on a specific line in the complex plane. This property implies that the partition function can be expressed as an infinite product over parameters, which is crucial for understanding thermodynamic behavior and phase transitions.
Blume-Emery-Griffiths Model
This is a statistical mechanics model used to study magnetic systems with three states per spin, often involving interactions between neighboring spins. The paper focuses on its partition function under conditions where interaction strengths are large enough to ensure the Lee-Yang property holds.
Quadrupole Interaction Term
This specific type of interaction term, denoted as $P_{Kij}S^2_i S^2_j$, is the challenge in proving the Lee-Yang property for this model. The authors develop techniques to exclude or manage this term's influence so that the overall partition function still exhibits the desired property.
Partition Function ZβN(h)
This function represents a fundamental quantity in statistical mechanics, describing all possible states of a system at a given temperature $eta$ and external magnetic field $h$. The paper analyzes its behavior when $h$ is treated as a complex variable to check for the existence of zeros.

Terminology

Summary

The paper proves that for sufficiently large interaction intensities in the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model, its partition function possesses the Lee-Yang property. p. 1

Where the paper says it

6) has the Lee-Yang property for all θ > 0 and Kij ∈ R if the interaction intensities Jij ≥ 0 are large enough. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first result of this kind for the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model.

Introduction to the Lee-Yang Property

The celebrated Lee-Yang theorem states that the continuation to complex values of the external magnetic field h of the partition function ZβN of the collection of N interacting Ising spins has purely imaginary zeros if the interaction is ferromagnetic. This property implies that ZβN can be written in a specific form involving an infinite product over parameters γj satisfying certain constraints. p. 0

Where the paper says it

[10], one readily concludes that it can be written in the form Z β N (h) = Z β (0)Y∞ j=1 (1 + γjh 2 ), (1. 1) where the collection {γj} – in this case, β- and N-dependent parameters – satisfies 0 < γj+1 ≤ γj , X∞ j=1 γj < ∞.

The partition function ZβN(h) is expressed as an exponential type entire function related to a finite measure χ by the representation (1. p. 1
Where the paper says it

2 YURI KOZITSKY representation Z β N (h) = Z RN exp (−βHN (S, h))Y N i=1 χ(dSi) (1. 3) = Z RN exp   X 1≤i<j≤N βJijSiSj + X N i=1 βhSi   Y N i=1 χ(dSi) =  exp   X 1≤i<j≤N βJijDiDj )   Y N i=1 ϕ(xi)   all xi=βh , Di = ∂ ∂xi , where ϕ is related to the aforementioned finite measure χ by ϕ(x) = Z R e xσχ(dσ).

3).

The Model and Necessary Conditions

The prototypical model studied corresponds to the partition function ZN(x) given in (1.6). The key challenge is that the quadrupole interaction term PKijS2i S2j is incompatible with some standard techniques for proving the Lee-Yang property. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Another essential obstacle to proving the Lee-Yang property of (1. 6) is the quadrupole interaction term PKijS 2 i S 2 j , which is incompatible with the technique of [11] or any other theory of this kind.

The paper aims to show that ZN given in (1. p. 1
Where the paper says it

6) is the quadrupole interaction term PKijS 2 i S 2 j , which is incompatible with the technique of [11] or any other theory of this kind. In this paper, we prove that ZN given in (1.

6) has the Lee-Yang property for all θ > 0 and Kij ∈ R if the interaction intensities Jij ≥ 0 are large enough. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we prove that ZN given in (1. 6) has the Lee-Yang property for all θ > 0 and Kij ∈ R if the interaction intensities Jij ≥ 0 are large enough.

The Main Result of Theorem 2. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The Result We begin by preparing the basic tool that we use to prove the main statement. The Lieb-Sokal theorem.

3

Theorem 2.3 states that FN given in (2. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The latter suggests that the Lee-Yang property of this model may hold only for sufficiently low temperatures. Introduction The celebrated Lee-Yang theorem states that the continuation to complex values of the external magnetic field h of the partition function Z β N of the collection of N interacting Ising spins has purely imaginary zeros if the interaction is ferromagnetic; see [3, 11, 14, 15] and the literature quoted therein.

4) is in FN, and thus the partition function ZN(x) = FN(x, · · ·, x), has the Lee-Yang property if conditions (a) and (b) hold. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The latter suggests that the Lee-Yang property of this model may hold only for sufficiently low temperatures. Introduction The celebrated Lee-Yang theorem states that the continuation to complex values of the external magnetic field h of the partition function Z β N of the collection of N interacting Ising spins has purely imaginary zeros if the interaction is ferromagnetic; see [3, 11, 14, 15] and the literature quoted therein.

(a) For θ ∈ (0, 1]: Jij ≥ Λ(Kij) for each pair i, j. p. 3

Where the paper says it

FN given in (2. 4) is in FN , and thus the partition function ZN (x) = FN (x, · · · , x), has the Lee-Yang property if the following holds: (a) For θ ∈ (0, 1]: Jij ≥ Λ(Kij ) for each pair i, j.

(b) For θ > 1: N = 2M, and there exists a division, the decomposition into disjoint two-element subsets (dimers) ϑk = (ik, jk) such that Jij ≥ Λ(Kij) + εijκ(θ2) for each pair i, j. p. 3

Where the paper says it

(b) For θ > 1: N = 2M, and there exists a division, {1, . , 2M} = ∪M k=1ϑk, into disjoint two-element subsets (dimers) ϑk = {ik, jk} such that Jij ≥ Λ(Kij ) + ϵijκ(θ 2 ) for each pair i, j.

The Proof Strategy

The proof begins by deriving formulas to exclude the quadrupole interaction term in the exponent (2.5). This leads to the determination of τ = Λ(κ) which is defined in (2. p. 1

Where the paper says it

4) The infinite-order differential operator in the last line of (1. 3) can be defined for all Jij ≥ 0 if ϕ is an entire function of order less than two, or of order two and of minimal type.

3). The proof then decomposes FN using (2. p. 4
Where the paper says it

For θ ≤ 1, we have ϕθ ∈ F1. Then the proof of claim (a) of Theorem 2.

4) and (2.12) to arrive at GN, which is expressed as an exponential involving Jeij + ϵijκ˜(θ2). p. 4
Where the paper says it

6), we can write exp JijSiSj + KijS 2 i S 2 j (2. 12) = (1 + AijSiSj )(1 + BijSiSj ) exp [Jeij + ϵijκ˜(θ 2 )]SiSj , Jeij = Jij − Λ(Kij ) − ϵijκ˜(θ 2 ), κ˜(θ 2 ) = κ(θ 2 ) for θ ≥ 1, 0 otherwise.

For claim (b), the decomposition of GN follows a specific structure involving HN, which is then related to Φ(xik, xjk). p. 4
Where the paper says it

, xN ) = exp X M k=1 κ(θ 2 )DikDjk ! Y N i=1 ϕθ(xi) = Y M k=1 Φ(xik , xjk ).

The final step involves showing that Φ ∈ F2 by demonstrating that the resulting functions φ± have the required property for stable polynomials. p. 2
Where the paper says it

, N; see [2, 15] and the literature quoted in these publications. Let FN be the set of exponential-type entire functions defined on C N , which are: (a) not identically zero; (b) obtained as limits of the sequences of stable polynomials taken in the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of C N .

Application to the BEG Model

The partition function ZβN(h) of the BEG model (with N = 2M) has the Lee-Yang property if J ≥ K + 2∆. For K ∆−1 ln 2, this condition simplifies to βJ ≥ β(K + 2∆) − ε(β). p. 7

Where the paper says it

Therefore, instead of (3. 4) one gets the following condition βJ ≥ 2β∆ − ln 4 + ln 1 + q 1 − e−4β∆/16 + 4e −βK/2 .

The paper concludes that the partition function of the BEG model ZβN has the Lee-Yang property for all β ≥ ∆−1 ln 2 whenever J ≥ K + 2∆. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The Lieb-Sokal theorem provides a tool for establishing the Lee-Yang property of the partition function of a spin model if the corresponding single-spin partition function has this property and the interaction term in its Hamiltonian is of the form − PJijSiSj with Jij ≥ 0. According to the result of this paper, the spin S = 1 model with the Hamiltonian − P(JijSiSj + KijS 2 i S 2 j ) + P∆S 2 i has the Lee-Yang property for all Kij ∈ R and ∆ > 0, whenever each Jij exceeds an explicitly computed bound C(β, ∆, Kij ) > 0, such that C(β, ∆, Kij ) → +∞ as β → 0.

For K > 0, a different condition is derived involving βJ ≥ 2β∆ − ln 4 + ln(1 + q 1 − e−4β∆/16) + 4e−βK/2. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Therefore, instead of (3. 4) one gets the following condition βJ ≥ 2β∆ − ln 4 + ln 1 + q 1 − e−4β∆/16 + 4e −βK/2 .

For K > 0 and β < ∆−1 ln 2, the condition becomes J ≥ β(-1)ln(1 + 2e−βK + 2e−βKp)/(1 + e βK). p. 7
Where the paper says it

For β < ∆−1 ln 2, instead of (3. 5) one obtains J ≥ β −1 ln 1 + 2e −βK + 2e −βKp 1 + e βK , which is also unbounded on β ∈ (0, ∆−1 ln 2).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can rigorously analyze spin model partition functions using the Lieb-Sokal theorem to determine if a model has a Lee-Yang property based on single-spin partition function properties and interaction terms of the form P Jij SiSj with Jij >= 0.

  2. The system can predict the temperature range for which the Lee-Yang property holds for models like the Blume-Emery-Griffiths (BEG) model by computing explicit bounds C(beta, Delta, Kij) where C(beta, Delta, Kij) → +infinity as beta → 0.

  3. The AI can determine if a partition function ZN given in equation (1.6) has the Lee-Yang property for the BEG model by verifying conditions (a) for theta 1, based on calculated interaction intensities Jij >= Λ(Kij).

  4. The system can identify necessary conditions for the Lee-Yang property of ZN in terms of interaction parameters, such as requiring J >= |K| + 2Delta for specific temperature regimes, derived from Theorem 2.3.

  5. The AI can analyze the structure of the partition function expansion using equation (1.3) to decompose F N into GN and HN, allowing it to check if GN is in FN based on the positivity of Jeij >= 0 and Aij, Bij.

Abstract

The Lieb-Sokal theorem provides a tool for establishing the Lee-Yang property of the partition function of a spin model if the corresponding single-spin partition function has this property and the interaction term in its Hamiltonian is of the form-sum J ij S iS j with J ij at least 0. According to the result of this paper, the spin S=1 model with the Hamiltonian-sum (J ij S iS j + K ijS i 2S j 2) + sum ΔS i squared has the Lee-Yang property for all K ij in and Δ>0, whenever each J ij exceeds an explicitly computed bound C(β, Δ, K ij)>0, such that C(β, Δ, K ij) to + infinity as β to 0. The latter suggests that the Lee-Yang property of this model may hold only for sufficiently low temperatures.

Sources

Related papers