Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their impact on the 3H-3He charge radius difference

arXiv:2611.11478 · nucl-ex · Submitted 2026-11-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their impact on the 3H-3He charge radius difference".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their impact on the 3H-3He charge radius difference is achieved by making a precise measurement of the 3H/3He form factor ratio at low momentum transfer, which provides an improved determination of the absolute normalization corrections of world data sets This will provide an improved determination of the absolute normalization corrections of world data sets, providing improved precision for the low-Q2 measurements that are most sensitive to the radius Measurement Strategy The goal of the experiment is to make a precise measurement of the 3H/3He form factor ratio at low momentum transfer The method involves measuring elastic scattering from nearly identical 3H and 3He targets, which allows for an extraction of the 3H/3He form factor ratio with significantly reduced systematic uncertainty, as identical systematic uncertainties will cancel in the target ratio They extract the elastic cross sections and the 3H/3He ratio at a single value of momentum transfer Data Extraction and Analysis The scattering cross section is extracted by counting the number of elastically scattered electrons, applying corrections for detector efficiency, spectrometer acceptance, and other losses The ratio of the measured yield to the simulated yield is then computed and applied as a multiplicative correction to the underlying cross section model They isolate the charge scattering contribution from which they extract the charge form factor, Fc(Q2), by subtracting the contribution to Fm(Q2) The 3H and 3He cross sections and charge form factors are given in Table III Impact on Charge Radius Extraction The sensitivity study shows that the new precision data points constrain the normalization of previous data sets, reducing the uncertainties by up to 12% and yielding a 4% improvement in the radius Including projected data based on an approved experiment yields improvements in the normalization factors of up to 20% and a 27% improvement in the 3H RMS charge radius extraction, allowing for an improved extraction of the 3H-3He radius difference from a direct fit to the form factor ratios over a range in Q2 Future Directions and Sensitivity The projected E12-14-009 data provides a stronger constraint on ∆R from the experimental uncertainties, is less sensitive to the shape of the form factor under the assumption of rescaled charge distributions, and provides data over a range in Q2 significant enough to test the assumption of identical charge distributions The inclusion of projected measurements at lower Q2 has a significant impact on the extraction of the charge radius This demonstrates the much greater value of high-precision ratio measurements at lower Q2, as originally proposed In a global fit, this improves the constraints on the relative experimental normalization factors but has minimal impact on the extraction of the 3H charge radius, as our new point is at relatively large Q2 values The current data only provides a significant improvement of this difference under the assumption that the two nuclei have charge distributions that are identical in shape and only differ in size The new data will provide a sensitive test of this assumption and, assuming that deviations from this are small, will allow for a dramatically improved uncertainty in the difference between the 3H and 3He charge radii Acknowledgments We acknowledge the contributions of the JLab target group and technical staff for the design and construction of the Tritium target and their support for this experiment This work was supported in part by the Department of Energy’s Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, under contracts DE-AC02- 05CH11231, DE-FG02-88ER40410, DE-SC0014168, DEFG02-96ER40950, DE-SC0013615, and DE-SC0014168 The National Science Foundation including grant NSF PHY-1714809, the Science Committee of the Republic of Armenia under grant 21AG- C085, the National Natural Science Foundation of China, under grant 12275148, the Tsinghua University Initiative Scientific Research Program, and DOE contract 89243126CSC000213 under which SURATech operates JLab The authors acknowledge the contributions of the JLab target group and technical staff for the design and construction of the Tritium target and their support for this experiment References

Title and authors: Kai: So we're diving into the specifics of how they approach this. The paper, "Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their impact on the 3H-3He charge radius difference," sets out to do this precise measurement at low momentum transfer <ref:2611.11478#pg1,Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their>.

Mira: They are combining that ratio with existing absolute 3He measurements to create a better measurement of the 3H form factor, which they say gives improved precision compared to what we have from world data sets <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

Lev: The method relies on measuring elastic scattering from nearly identical tritium and helium targets because that allows for an extraction of the 3H over 3He form factor ratio with significantly reduced systematic uncertainty <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

Kai: They describe how this is done by extracting the elastic cross sections and then computing the ratio of their measured yield to a simulated yield, which acts as a multiplicative correction to the underlying cross section model.

Mira: Then they isolate the charge scattering contribution from where they extract the charge form factor, Fc Q2, by subtracting that contribution from Fm Q2. They lay out the 3H and 3He cross sections and charge form factors in table three for us to see how this works numerically <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Kai: So to summarize what they are doing, the goal is making a precise measurement of that specific ratio at low momentum transfer, because that provides an improved determination of the absolute normalization corrections for all world data sets we have.

Mira: And that improved normalization then gives us much better precision specifically for those low Q2 measurements which are the ones most sensitive to the actual charge radius. It's a two-step process linking normalization correction to radius sensitivity.

Lev: They point out that this specific measurement of the form factor ratio at low Q2 provides a direct constraint on the 3H minus 3He radius difference, which is what they are really trying to pin down with this setup <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

Kai: And they make a key statement about the approximation they are using: only the leading term of equation two, Fc Q2 of 3H over Fc Q2 of 3He is approximately one minus Q2 times the R squared over six times, one minus Q2 times the R squared over six for 3He > one minus Q2 times R squared over six for 3H <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

Mira: That approximation only holds true when momentum transfer, that is Q square, multiplied by the radius squared is much smaller than six. If you go to larger momentum transfer, those higher order terms in equation two become significant and you need to fit in the R four and higher terms too.

The paper's improvements: Kai: They show that this new precision data points constrain the normalization of previous data sets, which reduces those uncertainties by up to twelve percent, leading to a four percent improvement in the radius determination.

Mira: Even when they include projected data based on an approved experiment, they see improvements in the normalization factors of up to twenty percent and a twenty-seven percent improvement specifically in the 3H RMS charge radius extraction <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

Lev: The paper mentions that including these projected measurements at lower momentum transfer has a significant impact on how we extract the charge radius, demonstrating the much greater value of high precision ratio measurements at lower momentum transfer, as they first proposed.

Kai: And they also use this data point to test an assumption about the charge distributions—specifically, whether the two nuclei have charge distributions that are identical in shape and only differ in size.

Mira: They suggest that a global fit improves constraints on the relative experimental normalization factors but has minimal impact on the extraction of the 3H charge radius because their new point is at relatively large Q2 values <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, in this paper, they improve constraints on the relative experimental normalization factors within a global fit, but they find that their new data point is at relatively large momentum transfer Q square values.

Mira: They say that under the assumption that the two nuclei have charge distributions identical in shape and only differ in size, this current data only provides a significant improvement in the difference between the 3H and 3He charge radii <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

Lev: And assuming those deviations from that identical shape assumption are small, this new data will allow for a dramatically improved uncertainty in the difference between the 3H and 3He charge radii <ref:2611.11478#pg1>.

Kai: It’s important to remember that they are testing that assumption, and if those deviations are small, we can expect a much tighter constraint on what the actual size difference is.

Mira: This whole study of "Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their impact on the 3H-3He charge radius difference" shows that high precision ratio measurements at low momentum transfer are still very valuable for probing these nuclear properties <ref:2611.11478#pg1,Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their>.

Lev: For our work in building real hardware, this tells us where we need to focus our error budgets when we try to implement these kinds of sensitive measurements on actual devices.

L. Kurbany, S. Li, S. N. Santiesteban, J. Arrington, D. Abrams, S. Alsalmi, D. Androic, K. Aniol, T. Averett, C Ayerbe Gayoso, J Bane, § S Barcus, § J Barrow A Beck V Bellini H Bhatt D Bhetuwal D Biswas A Camsonne J Castellanos J Chen J-P. Chen D Chrisman M E Christy C Clarke S Covrig R Cruz-Torres D Day D Dutta E Fuchey C Gal F Garibaldi T N Gautam T Gogami P Gu`eye T J Hague J O Hansen F Hauenstein W Henry D W Higinbotham R J Holt C Hyde K Itabashi M Kaneta A Karki A T Katramatou C E Keppel P M King T Kutz N Lashley-Colthirst W B Li H Liu N Liyanage E Long J Mammei P Markowitz R E McClellan F Meddi D Meekins R Michaels M Mihovilovićc A Moyer S Nagao D Nguyen M Nycz M Olson L Ou V Owen C Palatchi B Pandey A Papadopoulou S Park T Petkovic S Premathilake V Punjabi R D. Ransome P E. Reimer J Reinhold S Riordan V M Rodriguez A Schmidt B Schmookler E P. Segarra A Shahinyan S Sirca K Slifer T Su R Suleiman L Tang Y Tian W Tireman F Tortorici Y Toyama K Uehara G M Urciuoli D Votaw J Williamson B Wojtsekhowski S Wood Z H Ye J Zhang X Zheng, orgs_list_extracted_from_affiliations

University of New Hampshire · Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory · Argonne National Laboratory · University of Virginia · Kent State University · King Saud University · § University of Zagreb · § California State University Los Angeles Department of Energy Office of Science Office of Nuclear Physics National Science Foundation Tsinghua University

nucl-ex

Submitted: 2026-11-08

Updated: 2026-11-08

Comments: 11 pages, 7 figures, submitted to Phys. Rev. C

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 88/100

The gist: Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their impact on the 3H-3He charge radius difference is achieved by making a precise measurement of the 3H/3He form factor ratio at low…

Key concepts

Charge Form Factor Ratio
This is a comparison of how the charge distribution of Tritium and Helium-3 scatters electrons at different momentum transfers. Measuring this ratio directly helps correct systematic errors when determining the absolute scale (normalization) of experimental data sets, leading to more accurate radius values.
Low Momentum Transfer (low Q2)
This refers to measurements where the momentum transfer is small. Measurements at low Q2 are particularly sensitive to the overall size and shape of the charge distribution, making them crucial for accurately determining nuclear radii.
Charge Radius Difference ($\Delta R$)
This is the difference between the measured charge radius of Tritium and Helium-3. The new data helps constrain this difference, testing whether these two nuclei have identical charge distributions or if they differ in size.
Global Fit
A global fit involves combining all available experimental data points for both 3H and 3He form factors to create a single, highly constrained model. This method significantly tightens the constraints on the relative experimental normalization factors.

Terminology

Summary

Precise measurements of the 3H/3He charge form factor ratio and their impact on the 3H-3He charge radius difference is achieved by making a precise measurement of the 3H/3He form factor ratio at low momentum transfer, which provides an improved determination of the absolute normalization corrections of world data sets This will provide an improved determination of the absolute normalization corrections of world data sets, providing improved precision for the low-Q2 measurements that are most sensitive to the radius

Measurement Strategy

The goal of the experiment is to make a precise measurement of the 3H/3He form factor ratio at low momentum transfer The method involves measuring elastic scattering from nearly identical 3H and 3He targets, which allows for an extraction of the 3H/3He form factor ratio with significantly reduced systematic uncertainty, as identical systematic uncertainties will cancel in the target ratio They extract the elastic cross sections and the 3H/3He ratio at a single value of momentum transfer

Data Extraction and Analysis

The scattering cross section is extracted by counting the number of elastically scattered electrons, applying corrections for detector efficiency, spectrometer acceptance, and other losses The ratio of the measured yield to the simulated yield is then computed and applied as a multiplicative correction to the underlying cross section model They isolate the charge scattering contribution from which they extract the charge form factor, Fc(Q2), by subtracting the contribution to Fm(Q2) The 3H and 3He cross sections and charge form factors are given in Table III

Impact on Charge Radius Extraction

The sensitivity study shows that the new precision data points constrain the normalization of previous data sets, reducing the uncertainties by up to 12% and yielding a 4% improvement in the radius Including projected data based on an approved experiment yields improvements in the normalization factors of up to 20% and a 27% improvement in the 3H RMS charge radius extraction, allowing for an improved extraction of the 3H-3He radius difference from a direct fit to the form factor ratios over a range in Q2

Future Directions and Sensitivity

The projected E12-14-009 data provides a stronger constraint on ∆R from the experimental uncertainties, is less sensitive to the shape of the form factor under the assumption of rescaled charge distributions, and provides data over a range in Q2 significant enough to test the assumption of identical charge distributions The inclusion of projected measurements at lower Q2 has a significant impact on the extraction of the charge radius This demonstrates the much greater value of high-precision ratio measurements at lower Q2, as originally proposed

Conclusions

In a global fit, this improves the constraints on the relative experimental normalization factors but has minimal impact on the extraction of the 3H charge radius, as our new point is at relatively large Q2 values The current data only provides a significant improvement of this difference under the assumption that the two nuclei have charge distributions that are identical in shape and only differ in size The new data will provide a sensitive test of this assumption and, assuming that deviations from this are small, will allow for a dramatically improved uncertainty in the difference between the 3H and 3He charge radii

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge the contributions of the JLab target group and technical staff for the design and construction of the Tritium target and their support for this experiment This work was supported in part by the Department of Energy’s Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, under contracts DE-AC02- 05CH11231, DE-FG02-88ER40410, DE-SC0014168, DEFG02-96ER40950, DE-SC0013615, and DE-SC0014168 The National Science Foundation including grant NSF PHY-1714809, the Science Committee of the Republic of Armenia under grant 21AG-

C085, the National Natural Science Foundation of China, under grant

12275148, the Tsinghua University Initiative Scientific Research Program, and DOE contract 89243126CSC000213 under which SURATech operates JLab The authors acknowledge the contributions of the JLab target group and technical staff for the design and construction of the Tritium target and their support for this experiment

References

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Precise measurement of 3H/3He charge form factor ratio allows for improved determination of absolute normalization corrections by reducing uncertainties by up to 12% and yielding a 4% improvement in the radius.

  2. The improved system can perform a direct fit to the form factor ratios over a range in Q2, providing an improved extraction of the 3H-3He radius difference from a direct fit to the form factor ratios over a range in Q2.

  3. The AI system can utilize projected data based on an approved experiment to yield improvements in normalization factors of up to 20% and a 27% improvement in the 3H RMS charge radius extraction.

  4. The AI system can perform a simple sensitivity study by combining the new data point with a global fit of the 3He form factor to obtain a high-precision measurement for the 3H form factor at Q2 approximately equals three fm squared.

  5. The improved system can test the assumption that charge distributions are identical in shape and only differ in size by comparing results from different functional forms, such as dipole versus monopole form factors.

Related papers