Flavor decomposition of the nucleon axial and tensor charges from lattice QCD
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Lattice. The day in lattice field theory: what the simulations put on the table.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Flavor decomposition of the nucleon axial and tensor charges from lattice QCD".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Flavor decomposition of the nucleon axial and tensor charges from lattice QCD determines the nucleon axial and tensor charges using four ensembles of twisted-mass cloverimproved fermions with approximately equal physical volumes of about 5.5 fm and four lattice spacings.
Kai: The results provide important benchmarks for lattice QCD calculations and deliver essential theoretical input for precision studies probing BSM interactions, CP violation, and dark-matter interactions <ref:2611.10816#pg5>.
Mira: Determination of Nucleon Charges The nucleon charges for each quark flavor f, denoted as g f A,T, are derived from the nucleon matrix elements of the corresponding axial and tensor operators at zero momentum transfer where they are defined as ⟨Nψ¯fΓA,T ψ fN⟩ = g f A,T u¯N ΓA,T uN, (1) <ref:2611.10816#pg4>.
Kai: The computation uses twisted-mass fermion discretization which provides automatic O(a) improvement and the action incorporates a clover term which helps suppress isospin-breaking effects associated with the twisted mass fermion formulation.
Paper summary: Kai: So, this paper "Flavor decomposition of the nucleon axial and tensor charges from lattice QCD" is doing a lot of work by systematically breaking down the axial and tensor charges based on quark flavor using four different ensembles <ref:2611.10816#pg1>.
Mira: And what it means in simpler terms is that we are getting concrete numbers for how the nucleon's properties are distributed among its constituent quarks, which is important for testing models of strong interactions and beyond <ref:2611.10816#pg5>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this work gives us a set of reference values to check against when we try to run these simulations on real hardware, but it also highlights how much overhead those error corrections add <ref:two thousand six hundred eleven point one zero eight one six#pg2.
Kai: They've shown good agreement with other lattice QCD results, especially for the isovector axial charge matching experimental data <ref:2611.10816#pg5>.
Mira: The main point of this paper is that it provides these flavor decomposition results for the axial and tensor charges, which helps constrain our understanding of how quarks contribute to those properties <ref:2611.10816#pg5>.
Lev: So, the work on "Flavor decomposition of the nucleon axial and tensor charges from lattice QCD" is a solid contribution to the field because it provides these flavor decomposition results for the axial and tensor charges <ref:2610.02543>
Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is all about breaking down those nucleon axial and tensor charges by quark flavor using lattice QCD simulations <ref:2611.10816#pg4>.
Mira: It takes four different simulation setups, twisted-mass clover improved fermions, and they tuned the quark masses to be pretty close to what we see in nature.
Lev: They're getting the axial and tensor charges for up, down, strange, and charm quarks. That’s a lot of data points to look at on real hardware later.
Kai: The main thing is that they are comparing these lattice results with other calculations from different groups to make sure their numbers hold up.
Mira: They found the results generally line up well with what other lattice QCD papers have reported, which is good because it validates the method itself.
Lev: But they also flagged some differences, especially for the up-quark axial charge when comparing it to some specific models called PNDME.
Kai: It shows that even though these fundamental properties are being calculated in a controlled way on a computer, there's still room for things to be different between different theoretical approaches.
Mira: The flavor decomposition itself gives us a clearer picture of how the internal structure of the nucleon is influenced by those different quark types.
Lev: And they did have to be careful with their error estimates too, especially dealing with excited states in those calculations, which adds some complexity when you try to extract those final values.
Kai: So what this means is that we're getting these better constraints on the nucleon's structure from first principles, but we still have to dig into the nuances of the math and how much uncertainty there is.
C. Alexandrou, S. Bacchio, M. Di Carlo, A. Evangelista, C. Iona, F. Pittler, G. Spanoudes
Department of Physics, University of Cyprus · Computation-based Science and Technology Research Center, The Cyprus Institute · Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Roma Tor Vergata
hep-lat, hep-ph, nucl-ex, nucl-th
Submitted: 2026-11-07
Updated: 2026-11-07
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: Flavor decomposition of the nucleon axial and tensor charges from lattice QCD determines the nucleon axial and tensor charges using four ensembles of twisted-mass cloverimproved fermions with…
Key concepts
- Nucleon Charges ($g_f^{A,T}$)
- These are physical properties of the nucleon (proton/neutron) related to its axial and tensor currents. They are calculated by measuring matrix elements of these currents between nucleon states at zero momentum transfer, providing crucial input for understanding nucleon structure.
- Twisted-Mass Clover Improved Fermions
- This is a specific numerical technique used in lattice QCD simulations. It helps improve the accuracy of calculations by automatically achieving O(a) improvement and incorporating a clover term to reduce unwanted effects like isospin breaking, leading to more precise results.
- Three-Point Function Ratio ($R_{\mu A}$)
- To isolate the desired nucleon matrix element from noisy correlation functions, the ratio of a three-point function (involving both axial and nucleon currents) to a two-point function is calculated. In the limit of large time separations, this ratio yields the ground state axial charge ($g_A$ or $g_T$ for tensor charges).
- Continuum Extrapolation
- Lattice simulations are performed on a discrete spacetime grid with spacing 'a'. To get physical results, calculations must be extrapolated to the continuum limit ($a=0$). This is done by fitting results from different lattice spacings, often using constant or linear-in-$a^2$ models.
Terminology
Summary
Flavor decomposition of the nucleon axial and tensor charges from lattice QCD determines the nucleon axial and tensor charges using four ensembles of twisted-mass cloverimproved fermions with approximately equal physical volumes of about 5. p. 05 fm and four lattice spacings. p. 0 The results provide important benchmarks for lattice QCD calculations and deliver essential theoretical input for precision studies probing BSM interactions, CP violation, and dark-matter interactions <ref:2611. p. 010816#pg5>.
Determination of Nucleon Charges
The nucleon charges for each quark flavor f, denoted as g f A,T, are derived from the nucleon matrix elements of the corresponding axial and tensor operators at zero momentum transfer where they are defined as ⟨Nψ¯fΓA,T ψ fN⟩ = g f A,T u¯N ΓA,T uN, (1) <ref:2611.10816#pg4>. The computation uses twisted-mass fermion discretization which provides automatic O(a) improvement and the action incorporates a clover term which helps suppress isospin-breaking effects associated with the twisted mass fermion formulation. p. 1 The ensembles are generated by the Extended Twisted Mass Collaboration (ETMC) with a mass degenerate up and down quark doublet and strange and charm quarks (Nf = 2 + 1 + 1), with all quark masses tuned to approximately their physical values. p. 0
Methodology for Correlator Computation
The determination of the nucleon matrix elements requires the evaluation of both three- and two-point Euclidean time correlation functions. The two-point function is given by C(Γ0,⃗p;ts) = X⃗xs e−i⃗xs·⃗p× Tr h Γ0 ⟨JN (ts,⃗xs)J¯N (0,vec0)⟩ i, (2). p. 2 To enhance the overlap of the interpolating field with the nucleon ground state and suppress excited-state contamination, Gaussian smearing is applied to the quark fields that enter the interpolating field. p. 2 The three-point function for e. p. 2g. the axial-vector for an arbitrary momentum transfer ⃗q is given by Cµ(Γk,⃗q, p⃗';ts, tins) = X⃗xs,vecxins e i⃗xins·q e−i⃗xs·p′× Tr h Γk ⟨JN (ts,vecxs)Aµ(tins,vecxins)J¯N (0,vec0)⟩ i, (6).
Analysis of Correlators and Charge Extraction
The spectral decomposition of the two- and three-point functions is given respectively by C(Γ0,⃗0;ts) = X∞ i=0 cie−Ei ts and Cµ(Γk,⃗0;ts, tins) =X∞ i=0,j=0 A i,j µ (Γk)e−Ei(ts−tins)−Ej tins. To isolate the matrix elements from Ai,j µ these unknown overlaps must be removed and for the ground-state matrix element, we build the ratio of the three-point function to the two-point function RµA(Γk;ts, tins) = Cµ(Γk,⃗0;ts, tins) C(Γ0,⃗0;ts). p. 3 In the limit of large time separations, ∆E(ts−tins) ≫ 1 and ∆E1tins ≫ 1, the energy difference between the first excited state and the ground state, this ratio gives the desired axial charge RµA(Γk;ts, tins) → gA. p. 3 The corresponding ratio RµνT for the tensor operator yields the tensor charge gT = ZT ϵ ijk T0,0 ij (Γk) c0, (16). p. 3
Renormalization and Continuum Extrapolation
The matrix elements of the axial-vector Aµ and tensor Tµν currents are renormalized nonperturbatively in the RI′ -MOM scheme [28] followed by perturbative conversion to the MS scheme at the reference scale µ = 2 GeV. The continuum limit is obtained using a model average of constant and linear-in-a squared fits. p. 8 p. 8 p. 8 Importantly, the continuum extrapolation is performed using ensembles simulated at approximately the physical pion mass, avoiding the need for a chiral extrapolation and the possible associated uncontrolled systematics. p. 0
Comparison with Other Results
Our results show overall good agreement with other recent lattice QCD determinations. p. 9 p. 9 In particular, the isovector axial charge is consistent with both the available lattice results and the experimental determination. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 The flavor-diagonal axial and tensor charges are also generally consistent with the results from other lattice calculations, while the isovector tensor charge shows a somewhat larger spread among the different determinations. p. 0
Summary and Conclusions
The nucleon axial and tensor charges are determined using four Nf = 2 + 1 + 1 twisted-mass clover-improved ensembles with quark masses tuned closely to their physical values. The calculation includes both connected and disconnected contributions, allowing us to determine the isovector, isoscalar, and individual flavor contributions to the axial and tensor charges. p. 0 p. 0 Our results show overall good agreement with other recent lattice QCD determinations. In particular, the isovector axial charge is consistent with both the available lattice results and the experimental determination. The flavor-diagonal axial and tensor charges are also generally consistent with the results from other lattice calculations. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 The continuum limit is obtained using a model average of constant and linear-in-a squared fits. Although the latticespacing dependence is mild, the extrapolation to a = 0 has a non-negligible effect and is therefore important for obtaining the physical values, together with a comprehensive treatment of the systematic uncertainties due to excited-state contamination. The continuum extrapolation is performed using ensembles simulated at approximately the physical pion mass, avoiding the need for a chiral extrapolation and the possible associated uncontrolled systematics. p. 0 p. 0
Systematic Uncertainties
We investigate systematics arising from the analysis of excited states, where no AIC average was done. For the connected contributions we will use the summation method to estimate the systematic error. p. 9 For the disconnected contributions, instead of performing a single plateau fit to all selected values of ts > tlow s simultaneously, we fit to a constant at each ts value and take the weighted average after convergence, which is typically observed for the same values of tlow s as the common fit to all separations. p. 9 The systematic uncertainty on the continuum value is computed by taking the absolute difference between the central value of the preferred analysis and the one when changing the procedure as described above, after continuum extrapolation. p. 9
Our results are shown with the red square and red error band. In Figs. 20 and 21 we compare our results for the up- (left), down- (center), and strange-quark (right) contributions to the axial charge with other lattice QCD studies. p. 0 The tensor charges show particularly good consistency among the different calculations. p. 0 p. 0 For the axial charges, our results are also generally consistent with the other determinations. p. 0 p. 0 The main visible difference is in the up-quark axial charge, where the PNDME result is smaller than ours. p. 3 p. 3
Flavor Decomposition Results
The continuum results for the flavor decomposition of the axial charge are shown in Figs. 17 and 18. The continuum values are given with statistical and systematic errors. p. 5 The flavor decomposition results show overall good agreement with the available lattice results. p. 9
Table of Extrapolated Values
Table VI gives the values for the axial non-singlet and singlet combinations (top) and the extracted single flavor charges (bottom) for each ensemble and in the continuum limit, using the model average strategy described in the text. The final results are given as a = 0 g u A = 0. p. 4 p. 4 p. 4860(19)(7) -0.404(19)(19) -0.036(70)(10) -0.036(78)(8). The final results are given as a = 0 g u T = 0. p. 4 p. 4 p. 4951(21)(5) 0. p. 0 p. 0556(16)(5) 0. p. 0 p. 0570(22)(5) 0.945(18)(7). The final results are given as a = 0 g d T = -0. p. 4 p. 4 p. 41973(61)(3) -0.0050(37)(3) -0.942(45)(12) 0.558(16)(6). The final results are given as a = 0 g s T = -0. p. 4 p. 4 p. 40032(21)(5) -0.945(18)(7) 0.545(11)(8). The final results are given as a = 0 g c T = -0. p. 4 p. 4 p. 40059(65) -0.942(45)(12) 0.546(13)(8). The final results are given as a = 0 g u A = 0.850(16) -0.391(15) -0.037(85) -0.429(19)(15). The final results are given as a = 0 g d A = -0. p. 4 p. 4378(11) -0.378(64) -0.397(85)(64) -0.429(19)(15). The final results are given as a = 0 g s A = -0. p. 4 p. 40375(88) -0.375(65) -0.429(19)(15). The final results are given as a = 0 g c A = -0. p. 4 p. 40375(88) -0.429(19)(15). The final results are given as a = 0 g u T = 0.747(12) -0.337(3) -0.558(64) -0.942(45)(12). The final results are given as a = 0 g d T = -0.951(21)(5) -0. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 0378(64) -0.5337(43) -0.942(45)(12). The final results are given as a = 0 g s T = -0.951(21)(5) -0.378(64) -0.557(64) -0.942(45)(12). The final results are given as a = 0 g c T = -0.951(21)(5) -0.378(64) -0.557(64) -0.942(45)(12). The final results are given as a = 0 g u A = 0.895(21) -0.420(19) -0.034(48) -0.528(77)(101). The final results are given as a = 0 g d A = -0.378(64) -0.397(85)(64) -0.528(77)(101). The final results are given as a = 0 g s A = -0.429(19)(15) -0.375(88) -0.528(77)(101). The final results are given as a = 0 g c A = -0.429(19)(15) -0.375(88).
Table of Extrapolated Values for Tensor Charges
Table VII gives the values for the tensor non-singlet and singlet combinations (top) and the extracted single flavor charges (bottom) for each ensemble and in the continuum limit. The final results are given as a = 0 g u T = 0.951(21)(5) 0.556(16)(5) 0.570(22)(5). The final results are given as a = 0 g d T = -0.942(45)(12) 0.553(13)(8) 0.546(13)(8). The final results are given as a = 0 g s T = -0.951(21)(5) -0.378(64) -0.557(64) -0.942(45)(12). The final results are given as a = 0 g c T = -0.951(21)(5) -0.378(64) -0.557(64) -0.942(45)(12).
Comparison with Other Lattice QCD Results
In Figs. 19, 17 and 18 we compare our results for the nucleon charges with values from other collaborations. p. 0 For the isovector axial charge, our result is in good agreement with the results from the other collaborations and compatible with the experimental determination. p. 0 The flavor-diagonal axial and tensor charges are also generally consistent with the results from other lattice calculations. The tensor charges show particularly good consistency among the different calculations. For the axial charges, our results are also generally consistent with the other determinations. The main visible difference is in the up-quark axial charge, where the PNDME result is smaller than ours.
Final Conclusion
The nucleon axial and tensor charges are determined using four Nf = 2 + 1 + 1 twisted-mass clover-improved ensembles with quark masses tuned closely to their physical values. The calculation includes both connected and disconnected contributions, allowing us to determine the isovector, isoscalar, and individual flavor contributions to the axial and tensor charges. Our results show overall good agreement with other recent lattice QCD determinations. In particular, the isovector axial charge is consistent with both the available lattice results and the experimental determination. The flavor-diagonal axial and tensor charges are also generally consistent with the results from other lattice calculations. The continuum limit is obtained using a model average of constant and linear-in-a squared fits. Although the latticespacing dependence is mild, the extrapolation to a = 0 has a non-negligible effect and is therefore important for obtaining the physical values, together with a comprehensive treatment of the systematic uncertainties due to excited-state contamination. The continuum extrapolation is performed using ensembles simulated at approximately the physical pion mass, avoiding the need for a chiral extrapolation and the possible associated uncontrolled systematics.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved data analysis capability for nucleon charges by implementing a two-step fitting strategy consisting of an effective mass fit followed by a ratio fit to isolate ground state matrix elements, as described in Section IV.
-
Enhanced ability to perform continuum extrapolation using a model average of constant and linear in alpha squared fits, which is more robust than relying solely on one type of fit or ensemble combination.
-
Increased precision in extracting flavor-diagonal charges by incorporating renormalization factors computed nonperturbatively in the RI prime-MOM scheme and performing a joint fit across all four lattice spacings.
-
Capability to compare lattice QCD results with phenomenological extractions, such as the value of a8 extracted from hyperon decays using the Cabibbo Model and assuming SU(3)-flavor symmetry, for consistency checks.
-
Ability to perform systematic uncertainty estimation by applying a summation method for connected contributions and fitting to a constant at each time separation for disconnected contributions when excited state contamination is not significant.
Sources
- Probing Novel Scalar and Tensor Interactions from (Ultra)Cold Neutrons to the LHC
- General Neutrino Interactions at the DUNE Near Detector
- Observation of Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering
- Dark matter direct-detection experiments
- Search for Tensor Interactions in Kaon Decays at DA$\Phi$NE
- New tensor interaction as the source of the observed CP asymmetry in $\tau \to K_{S}\pi\nu_{\tau}$
- Transversity distributions and tensor charges of the nucleon: extraction from dihadron production and their universal nature
- Strange and charm quark contributions to the muon anomalous magnetic moment in lattice QCD with twisted-mass fermions
- Lattice QCD with a chirally twisted mass term
- Chirally improving Wilson fermions - I. O(a) improvement
- Simulating twisted mass fermions at physical light, strange and charm quark masses
- Twisted mass gauge ensembles at physical values of the light, strange and charm quark masses
- Quark masses using twisted mass fermion gauge ensembles
- Chiral extrapolation of lattice moments of proton quark distributions
- Decay width of light quark hybrid meson from the lattice
- Deflation as a Method of Variance Reduction for Estimating the Trace of a Matrix Inverse
- Performance of Low Mode Averaging on Twisted-Mass Fermion Ensembles at the physical pion mass point
- Hierarchical probing for estimating the trace of the matrix inverse on toroidal lattices
- Disconnected diagrams with twisted-mass fermions
- The Static Approximation of Heavy-Light Quark-Systems - A Systematic Lattice Study
Related papers
- Heavy-Meson Bag Parameters using Gradient Flow
- Impact of Irrep Truncations on Quantum Simulations of QCD
- Evaluating generative samplers for lattice field theory by scale
- Renormalized symmetry probes for emergent symmetries and non-chiral lattice fermions
- Scalable Generative Sampling and Multilevel Estimation for Lattice Field Theories Near Criticality
- Lattice QCD study of the K*(892) resonance at the physical point