Probing deformed nuclei: Experimental insights into excited states of 152,153,154 Gd isotopes through fusion-evaporation reactions

arXiv:2611.10164 · nucl-ex · Submitted 2026-11-06 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Probing deformed nuclei".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The rare-earth region has been the focus of various studies aiming at the understanding of nuclear structure and providing information on the details of the reaction mechanism The work reports an experimental attempt to populate excited states in isotopes 152, 153, and 154Gd using heavy-ion fusion-evaporation reactions, offering new branching ratios and relative cross sections Experimental Methodology The experiment employed the heavy-ion fusion reaction of 18O + 138Ba → 156−xGd + xn in the 58-64 MeV energy range (center-of-mass).

Kai: This study was conducted at the 9 MV FV Pelletron Tandem at the Horia Hulubei National Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering, utilizing the ROSPHERE array.

Mira: The target preparation involved covering both sides of the Barium target with thin layers of gold to slow down oxidation, and a natural Ba target was created through metallothermic reduction.

Kai: The detector array consisted of 15 HPGe detectors and 10 LaBr3(Ce) scintillators configured in five rings.

Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up this paper, "Probing deformed nuclei: Experimental insights into excited states of one hundred fifty-two one hundred fifty-three and one hundred fifty-four Gd isotopes through fusion-evaporation reactions," the authors provide new branching ratios and relative cross sections for these isotopes using a heavy-ion fusion-evaporation reaction mechanism > <ref:2611.10164#pg2>

Mira: The thesis is that the rare-earth region has open questions about structure, like inter band transitions or branching ratios in deformed states, and they're using these fusion reactions to address those gaps >

Lev: They mention that they found a strong deviation when comparing their relative cross sections for fifteen two gadolinium and fifteen four gadolinium with theoretical calculations from PACE four >

Kai: That deviation is expected because PACE four is fine-tuned for much higher energies than the Coulomb barrier, but the sub barrier experimental dataset they obtained aligns with existing data >

Mira: And they also discuss how the relative cross sections are deduced using a specific relation involving atomic mass and target thickness, which shows how they are making those comparisons >

Lev: They specifically look at transitions like the pure energy two plus to zero plus ground state for fifteen two gadolinium and twelve three point one keV for fifteen four gadolinium >

Kai: This is important because it gives us a concrete way to compare their experimental findings against existing theory, even if the theory isn't perfectly tuned for these energies >

Mira: And they report that the fusion reaction eighteen oxygen plus one hundred thirty eight barium is found to be the dominant channel for populating these states >

Lev: So this sets up a clear picture of which reaction channel is actually doing most of the work when you look at populating these nuclei >

Conclusion: Kai: So we've looked at how this work, "Probing deformed nuclei: Experimental insights into excited states of one hundred fifty-two one hundred fifty-three and one hundred fifty-four Gd isotopes through fusion-evaporation reactions," is building up states in those gadolinium isotopes >

Mira: Right, and the paper uses the heavy-ion fusion reaction eighteen oxygen plus one hundred thirty eight barium to get new data on the structure of these nuclei >

Lev: The authors are essentially using that reaction to create those specific isotopes like fifteen two gadolinium or fifteen three gadolinium >

Kai: They found some new branching ratios for energy levels in fifteen two gadolinium, which is pretty neat because it fills a gap in our knowledge on these transitional nuclei >

Mira: Exactly. They measured the transition from the seven minus one state to other states and got values that they say agree with each other well, and they reported the branching ratio for that seven minus one state for the first time >

Lev: And then there's this part about comparing their calculated cross sections with something called PACE four, and they found a deviation which they attribute to PACE four being tuned for higher energies >

Kai: So what does this mean if we look at it from the perspective of building hardware? The sub barrier data here is what matters because it’s where the real physics of fusion enhancement happens >

Mira: That sub barrier data is key because it lets us test whether those enhancements are due to real states being excited or just virtual effects in the coupling >

Lev: And they also get some excitation functions which helps us figure out the fusion barrier distributions, which would be super useful for modeling real fusion processes >

Kai: So overall, this work provides new experimental constraints on these transitional nuclei and gives us a better starting point for how we model sub barrier fusion enhancement >

S. Pelonisa, T.J. Mertzimekis, A. Chalila, P. Vasileioua, A. Zyrilioua, G. Zagoraiosa, D. Papaioannoua, F.C.L., Crespib, A. Braccob, N. Floreac, N. Margineanc, L., Stanc, A., Turturicac

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens · Universita degli Studi di Milano · National Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering

nucl-ex

Submitted: 2026-11-06

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: 13 pages, 8 figures. Accepted manuscript. Published in Nuclear Physics A 1047 (2024) 122888, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2024.122888

Journal ref: Nucl. Phys. A 1047 (2024) 122888

DOI: 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2024.122888

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: The rare-earth region has been the focus of various studies aiming at the understanding of nuclear structure and providing information on the details of the reaction mechanism The work reports an…

Key concepts

Heavy-ion fusion-evaporation reactions
This is a nuclear reaction where two heavy atomic nuclei (like 18O and 138Ba) collide with specific energies. The goal is to fuse them, forming a compound nucleus which then cools down by evaporating neutrons, resulting in the production of specific radioactive isotopes like Gd-152, Gd-153, or Gd-154.
Branching Ratios
Branching ratios describe the probability that a nucleus will decay through one specific path (transition) versus another when it is excited. In this study, experimental measurements were made for transitions in Gd-152 to determine these probabilities, which reveal details about the nuclear structure of these isotopes.
Sub-barrier fusion enhancement
This refers to the phenomenon where the probability of two nuclei fusing together at energies below their expected Coulomb barrier is unexpectedly high. The experimental data from this work will help new theoretical models determine if this enhancement comes from exciting low-lying states or from other mechanisms.
Fusion Barrier Distribution
The fusion barrier distribution describes how the energy required for the two nuclei to overcome the repulsive Coulomb force varies across different orientations and shapes of the colliding nuclei. Analyzing excitation functions helps researchers map out this distribution, which is crucial for understanding sub-barrier fusion processes.

Terminology

Summary

The rare-earth region has been the focus of various studies aiming at the understanding of nuclear structure and providing information on the details of the reaction mechanism The work reports an experimental attempt to populate excited states in isotopes 152, 153, and 154Gd using heavy-ion fusion-evaporation reactions, offering new branching ratios and relative cross sections

Experimental Methodology

The experiment employed the heavy-ion fusion reaction of 18O + 138Ba → 156−xGd + xn in the 58-64 MeV energy range (center-of-mass). This study was conducted at the 9 MV FV Pelletron Tandem at the Horia Hulubei National Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering, utilizing the ROSPHERE array. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this work, we report on an experimental attempt to populate the excited states in the isotopes 152,153,154Gd by employing the heavy-ion fusion reaction 18O+ 138Ba → 156−xGd + xn in the 58-64 MeV energy range (center-of-mass). The experiment was conducted at the 9 MV FV Pelletron Tandem at the Horia Hulubei National Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering, employing the ROSPHERE array.

The target preparation involved covering both sides of the Barium target with thin layers of gold to slow down oxidation, and a natural Ba target was created through metallothermic reduction. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The target The manufacturing of the Ba target poses certain difficulties, since Barium is a metal that oxidizes rapidly. To slow down the oxidation process, and protect the integrity of the measurement, both sides of the target were covered with thin layers of Au.

The detector array consisted of 15 HPGe detectors and 10 LaBr3(Ce) scintillators configured in five rings. p. 2
Where the paper says it

88 mg/cm2 thickness of the Au layer was performed by weighing on a precision scale, whereas for the other two foils, their values were determined by calculating the thickness of the initially used materials. Detector array For this experiment, the ROSPHERE array [25] was employed, in a configuration featuring 15 HPGe detectors and 10 LaBr3(Ce) scintillators.

Structural Insights from Decay Analysis

The analysis of gamma-gamma coincidence methods allowed the deduction of branching ratios for energy levels in 152Gd, providing new and updated values. For the 7−1 state in 152Gd, two different energy gates yielded branching ratios of 0. p. 4

Where the paper says it

To clear the spectra from the majority of the contaminant peaks, an energy gate was placed on the γ-transition that feeds the de-exciting levels. The branching of the 7− 1 state in 152Gd was studied with the application of two different energy gates, one on the 9− 1 → 7 − 1 transition (with Eγ = 451.

42(16) for the transition 7−1 → 5−1 de-excitation and 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

42(16) for the 7− 1 → 5 − 1 de-excitation and 0. 58(19) for the transition 7− 1 → 6 + 1 , after taking into account the relative efficiencies.

58(19) for the transition 7−1 → 6+1. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Figure adopted from [25]. Branching ratios If an energy level Elvl is de-populated by more than one γ-ray emission, then the relative intensities of those depopulations have to be determined to provide information on the transition matrix elements governing the particular decays.

These experimental values showed an excellent agreement with each other and were not previously measured in the literature. p. 4
Where the paper says it

54(23) for the transition 7− 1 → 6 + 1 . These two different set of values have an excellent agreement with each other and have not been measured before in literature.

The re-measured energy levels for Jπ = 23/2+ and Jπ = 4+2, 2+2, 11−1, 10−1 and 9−1 in were found to be in very good agreement with existing values The branching ratio value for the Jπ = 7−1 state in was deduced experimentally and reported for the first time. p. 9
Where the paper says it

It is worth mentioning that the last three of the above levels are not associated with any uncertainty in the values included in latest compilation of evaluated data [26], to which the present work provides experimental results for the first time. In addition, a branching ratio value for the J π = 7 − 1 state in 152Gd has been deduced experimentally and is reported for the first time.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

It is worth mentioning that the last three of the above levels are not associated with any uncertainty in the values included in latest compilation of evaluated data [26], to which the present work provides experimental results for the first time. In addition, a branching ratio value for the J π = 7 − 1 state in 152Gd has been deduced experimentally and is reported for the first time.

Cross Section Comparisons with Theory

Relative cross sections were measured for the fusion-evaporation reactions 138Ba(18O, 4n)152Gd, 138Ba(18O, 3n)153Gd, and 138Ba(18O, 2n)154Gd. The results for the relative cross sections (152Gd/153Gd) and (152Gd/154Gd) were compared with theoretical calculations from PACE4, showing a strong deviation. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Out of the main fusion channels, the one to 152Gd was found to be the dominant at all four beam energies. The experimentally deduced relative cross section results were compared with theoretical calculations from PACE4, showing a strong deviation.

This deviation is expected because PACE4 is fine-tuned for much higher energies than the Coulomb barrier, and the sub-barrier experimental dataset aligns with existing data. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The experimentally deduced relative cross section results were compared with theoretical calculations from PACE4, showing a strong deviation. This is a rather expected result, as PACE4 is known to be fine-tuned for much higher energies than the Coulomb barrier.

Nuclear Structure Implications

The re-measured branching ratios reflect the nuclear structure of the Gd isotopes, which are conveniently placed at the transitional region between rotational and vibrational nuclei. The results for Jπ = 7−1 state in were deduced experimentally and reported for the first time, filling a nuclear puzzle in this region. p. 9

Where the paper says it

It is worth mentioning that the last three of the above levels are not associated with any uncertainty in the values included in latest compilation of evaluated data [26], to which the present work provides experimental results for the first time. In addition, a branching ratio value for the J π = 7 − 1 state in 152Gd has been deduced experimentally and is reported for the first time.

The sub-barrier experimental dataset obtained from this work serves as a future starting point for new CC models to confirm whether enhancement effects are based on virtual or real excitation of low-lying excited states. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The sub-barrier experimental dataset obtained from this work align with existing data, while serving as a future starting point for new CC models. The latter can help confirm whether such effects are based on the virtual or real excitation of low-lying excited states.

The deduced excitation functions help to extract fusion barrier distributions, shining more light into the mechanisms of sub-barrier fusion enhancement. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Moreover, these models can further be used to normalise the present relative cross sections. The deduced excitation functions would then help to extract fusion barrier distributions, shining more light into the mechanisms of sub-barrier fusion enhancement.

Cross Section Analysis Details

The total cross section for a reaction populating the ground state can be expressed by a relation involving the atomic mass, Avogadro constant, and target thickness. The relative cross section for two different reaction channels α and β is deduced via the relation σrel = Ni(α)ϵabs(β) / Ni(β)ϵabs(α). p. 7

Where the paper says it

If there are more than one γ transitions that populate the ground state, then the total Yield is equal to: Y = X i Yi = X i Ni Nfϵabs (3) where Ni is the number of measured γ-rays, Nf is the number of incident particles on the target and ϵabs is the total efficiency of the setup, for the corresponding energy of the γ-rays. Considering the above, the relative cross section for two different reaction channels α and β can be deduced via: σrel = Ni(α)ϵabs(β) Ni(β)ϵabs(α) (4) For the cases of 152Gd and 154Gd, the transitions of interest are the pure (E2) 2+ 1 → 0 + gs with Eγ = 344.

For 152Gd and 154Gd, the transitions of interest are the pure (E2) 2+ → 0+gs with Eγ = 344. p. 7
Where the paper says it

If there are more than one γ transitions that populate the ground state, then the total Yield is equal to: Y = X i Yi = X i Ni Nfϵabs (3) where Ni is the number of measured γ-rays, Nf is the number of incident particles on the target and ϵabs is the total efficiency of the setup, for the corresponding energy of the γ-rays. Considering the above, the relative cross section for two different reaction channels α and β can be deduced via: σrel = Ni(α)ϵabs(β) Ni(β)ϵabs(α) (4) For the cases of 152Gd and 154Gd, the transitions of interest are the pure (E2) 2+ 1 → 0 + gs with Eγ = 344.

3 keV and 123. p. 6
Where the paper says it

All level and transition energies are given in keV. 5 718 371 123 0 816 681 2 + 0 + 0 + 4 + 6 + 2 + Figure 6: Partial level scheme of 154Gd.

1 keV, respectively. p. 7
Where the paper says it

3 keV and 123. 1 keV, respectively.

The situation for is different since the lowest measured state in is considered an isomer, leading to the (E2) transition 7−1+ → 13−5+ with Eγ = 226. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The situation is different for 153Gd, since the lowest measured state is the J π = 13 2 + , positioned at 138. No γ-rays appear to be emitted from this level, and according to the latest evaluation in Nuclear Data Sheets for this isotope [27], it is considered as an isomer.

5 keV being used for the deduction of the relevant cross section. p. 7
Where the paper says it

For this reason, the (E2) transition 17 2 + → 13 2 + with Eγ = 226. 5 keV is treated as the one for the deduction of the relevant, to 153Gd, cross section.

The PACE4 data show a similar trend to experimental values but significantly differ, which is expected given its fine-tuning for energies above the Coulomb barrier. p. 8
Where the paper says it

8, PACE4 data have a similar trend, but they significantly differ from the experimental values. This is somewhat expected however: PACE4 is a modified version of the JULIAN code, which is based on the Bass model [18] for the determination of the nuclear potential, during the fusion of two nuclei.

The sub-barrier experimental dataset obtained from this work aligns with existing data while serving as a future starting point for new CC models. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Although there is a justified disagreement with the PACE4 calculations, the same trend can be seen in a number of previous publications, with several being reported in [32]. The sub-barrier experimental dataset obtained from this work align with existing data, while serving as a future starting point for new CC models.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

Although there is a justified disagreement with the PACE4 calculations, the same trend can be seen in a number of previous publications, with several being reported in [32]. The sub-barrier experimental dataset obtained from this work align with existing data, while serving as a future starting point for new CC models.

The deduced excitation functions would then help to extract fusion barrier distributions. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Moreover, these models can further be used to normalise the present relative cross sections. The deduced excitation functions would then help to extract fusion barrier distributions, shining more light into the mechanisms of sub-barrier fusion enhancement.

Conclusion Summary

The experimental results complement the global data sets by providing new branching ratios and relative cross sections for the first time with this reaction mechanism. Although there is a justified disagreement with PACE4 calculations, the same trend can be seen in previous publications. p. 9

Where the paper says it

More specifically, on the cross section part of the work reported, relative cross section measurements have been produced for the first time with the particular reaction mechanism. Although there is a justified disagreement with the PACE4 calculations, the same trend can be seen in a number of previous publications, with several being reported in [32].

The sub-barrier experimental dataset obtained from this work aligns with existing data while serving as a future starting point for new CC models. The deduced excitation functions would then help to extract fusion barrier distributions, shining more light into the mechanisms of sub-barrier fusion enhancement. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Moreover, these models can further be used to normalise the present relative cross sections. The deduced excitation functions would then help to extract fusion barrier distributions, shining more light into the mechanisms of sub-barrier fusion enhancement.

This work provides input for future theoretical modelling of angular distributions of γ-rays following level depopulations. The results for the energy levels Jπ = 23/2+ and Jπ = 4+2, 2+2, 11−1, 10−1 and 9−1 in were re-measured and found to be in very good agreement with existing values. p. 9
Where the paper says it

From the nuclear structure point of view, several new and re-measured branching ratios in the deformed bands of 152,153Gd were determined, using γ-γ coincidence techniques and compared with literature values from [26, 27]. The results for the energy levels J π = 23 2 + in 153Gd and J π = 4 + 2 , 2+ 2 , 11− 1 , 10− 1 and 9− 1 in 152Gd were re-measured and found to be in a very good agreement with existing values.

The last three of the above levels are not associated with any uncertainty in the values included in latest compilation of evaluated data. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The results for the energy levels J π = 23 2 + in 153Gd and J π = 4 + 2 , 2+ 2 , 11− 1 , 10− 1 and 9− 1 in 152Gd were re-measured and found to be in a very good agreement with existing values. It is worth mentioning that the last three of the above levels are not associated with any uncertainty in the values included in latest compilation of evaluated data [26], to which the present work provides experimental results for the first time.

The branching ratio value for the Jπ = 7−1 state in was deduced experimentally and reported for the first time. The results for the relative cross sections (152Gd/153Gd) and (152Gd/154Gd) are shown graphically in Fig. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Table 4 contains a list of the transitions used for the cross section measurements. The results for the relative cross sections (152Gd/ 153Gd) and (152Gd/ 154Gd) are shown graphically in Fig.

8, along with theoretical calculations from PACE4. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The results for the relative cross sections (152Gd/ 153Gd) and (152Gd/ 154Gd) are shown graphically in Fig. 8, along with theoretical calculations from the PACE4 code.

The deviation between experimental and computed data becomes smaller as the difference between the barrier and Ee f f decreases. p. 9
Where the paper says it

[33], which is notably higher than all of the experimental Ee f f values. However, as it was expected and later observed, the deviation between the experimental and the computed data becomes smaller, as the difference between the barrier and Ee f f decreases.

The fusion reaction 18O + 138Ba → 156−xGd + xn is found to be the dominant channel for populating. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In addition, production cross sections of different reactions to Gd isotopes are largely unknown. In this work, we report on an experimental attempt to populate the excited states in the isotopes 152,153,154Gd by employing the heavy-ion fusion reaction 18O+ 138Ba → 156−xGd + xn in the 58-64 MeV energy range (center-of-mass).

The Coulomb barrier for this fusion reaction is approximately placed at 66. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Meanwhile, various experimental attempts have shown that this model tends to underestimate the cross section values below the barrier [32]. For the fusion reaction 18O+ 138Ba → h 156Gdi , the Coulomb barrier is approximately placed at 66.

2 MeV.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved data analysis pipeline for fusion-evaporation reactions can accurately extract branching ratios using gamma-gamma coincidence methods by implementing two different energy gate approaches to clear contaminant peaks, as seen in the results for 152Gd and 153Gd.

  2. Enhanced theoretical modeling capabilities should be integrated with experimental input by allowing coupled cluster calculations to reproduce fusion cross sections, specifically addressing the underestimation of cross sections under the Coulomb barrier when coupling to low-energy collective modes is considered.

  3. The AI system can perform comparative analysis between PACE4 theoretical calculations and experimental relative cross section measurements, identifying the trend where PACE4 data have a similar trend, but they significantly differ from the experimental values, which aids in understanding model limitations near the Coulomb barrier.

  4. The system can be trained to recognize and re-measure nuclear structure phenomena by comparing newly deduced branching ratios with literature values from different reaction mechanisms, as demonstrated by the agreement found for levels in 152Gd and 153Gd using a new reaction.

Abstract

The rare-earth region has been the focus of various studies aiming at the understanding of nuclear structure and providing information on the details of the reaction mechanism. The Gd isotopes belong to this group of nuclei and despite the available spectroscopic information, several open questions about their structure still exist, such as the inter-band transitions related to shape evolution or branching-ratios in deformed states. In addition, production cross sections of different reactions to Gd isotopes are largely unknown. In this work, we report on an experimental attempt to populate the excited states in the isotopes 152,153,154 Gd by employing the heavy-ion fusion reaction 18 O+ 138 Ba to 156-x Gd + xn in the 58-64 MeV energy range (center-of-mass). The experiment was conducted at the 9 MV FV Pelletron Tandem at the Horia Hulubei National Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering, employing the ROSPHERE array. Several branching-ratios for energy levels in 152,153 Gd have been measured, offering new and updated values. Furthermore, relative cross sections regarding the fusion-evaporation reactions 138 Ba(18 O, 4n) 152 Gd, 138 Ba(18 O, 3n) 153 Gd, and 138 Ba(18 O, 2n) 154 Gd have been measured and compared with theoretical calculations with PACE4.

Related papers