Dressed Newton-Cartan geometry and Euclidean thermal configurations in 3D

arXiv:2611.08471 · hep-th, gr-qc · Submitted 2026-11-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The three-dimensional Galilean black hole".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The authors report a novel solution of three-dimensional Galilean Anti-de Sitter gravity, which provides the first black hole solution in this non-relativistic gravitational theory without assuming an underlying Lorentzian spacetime geometry The resulting configuration is characterized by four conserved charges: energy E, angular momentum J, intrinsic spin S, and rest mass M This solution establishes the first explicit realization of black hole thermodynamics in a non-relativistic gravitational theory without assuming an underlying Lorentzian spacetime geometry Black Hole Characterization in Galilean Gravity The black hole character must be established without invoking necessarily an analogue of the event horizon, instead following the gauge-theoretic characterization of the generalized black holes in

22: The authors impose a trivial holonomy condition along the contractible thermal cycle to determine associated temperature (and other chemical potentials) and entropy in terms of conserved charges This approach allows for the recovery of black hole thermodynamics without relying on the area of a metric horizon Conserved Charges and Spin Bound The resulting configuration is characterized by four conserved charges: energy E, angular momentum J, intrinsic spin S, and rest mass M Remarkably, the last two turn out to be related through the rotation parameter a of the solution (associated with its angular velocity) as S = aM This relation establishes an interesting bound for the magnitude of the spin as they show below The magnitude of the intrinsic spin is bounded from above by the rest mass of the configuration, namely, S ≤ lM Thermodynamic Quantities and Extremal Configurations The temperature T is given in (34), while the angular velocity omega is given by omega = al(1 + α) The chemical potentials associated to the rest mass and the intrinsic spin charges read ΦM = lα(1 + α)h(2 − α)A + (α − 1)(α + 2)B i, and ΦS = aα(1 + αl"(α − 2)A + (2 + α)/(1+α)!B i The first law of thermodynamics δS = βδE − βomegaδJ − βΦMδM − βΦS δS holds in the micro-canonical ensemble for the Galilean black hole Asymptotic Symmetries and Further Directions The asymptotic symmetries turn out to be given by the direct sum of two copies of the infinite-dimensional extension of the Maxwell algebra in three dimensions, previously introduced in

65: The configuration introduced in this work was obtained within a purely intrinsic Galilean framework It would be interesting to study whether the nonrelativistic black hole admits a relativistic parent geometry from which it can be obtained through a suitable non-relativistic limit The gauge-theoretic formulation of the theory provides a natural framework for a systematic investigation of the solution space using holonomies and Wilson loops The authors have found that it is possible to define extremal configurations in the sense of a vanishing temperature T = 0 This extreme solution is reached when the intrinsic spin S takes its maximum possible value, which is equal to its rest mass M, namely, S = lM As a consequence, the magnitude of the angular momentum also equates to the one of the energy of the configuration The value α = 0 turns out to be a sort of extreme configuration, i.e., with a vanishing temperature T = 0 This extreme solution is reached when the intrinsic spin S takes its maximum possible value, which is equal to its rest mass M, namely, S = lM The magnitude of the angular momentum also equates to the one of the energy of the configuration (33) The bound a squared ≤ l squared for the rotation parameter, which will have direct implication on the allowed values for the intrinsic spin of the solution The relation (1) implies that the magnitude of the intrinsic spin is bounded from above by the rest mass of the solution, namely, S ≤ lM The bound between the energy E and the angular momentum J for arbitrary values of the integration constants A and B cannot be established However, in the extreme case of α = 0 in (23) (or a squared = l 2), the magnitude of the energy and angular momentum become equal E squared = J squared Indeed, the value α = 0 turns out to be a sort of extreme configuration, i.e., with a vanishing temperature T, as we can anticipate from its expression β = T−1 = 4πgα The magnitude of the angular momentum also equates to the one of the energy of the configuration (33).

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap where we are, this paper introduces a novel solution for three-dimensional Galilean Anti-de Sitter gravity. The core thesis is that they've established the first black hole solution in this non-relativistic theory without needing an underlying Lorentzian spacetime geometry.

Mira: They claim that this resulting configuration is characterized by four conserved charges: energy E, angular momentum J, intrinsic spin S, and rest mass M.

Lev: And they found a key relationship between the spin and the rest mass where S equals a times M, which links it to the rotation parameter a of the solution.

Kai: They also showed that this gives an interesting bound for how large the magnitude of that intrinsic spin can be compared to its rest mass, saying S is at most l times M.

Mira: The paper establishes black hole thermodynamics in this non-relativistic theory by imposing a trivial holonomy condition along a contractible thermal cycle to determine temperature and entropy from those conserved charges.

Lev: It’s important to note that they are doing this by following the gauge-theoretic characterization of generalized black holes described in work from twenty-two, which avoids relying on an analogue of the event horizon <ref:2611.08471#pg2,following the gauge-theoretic characterization of>.

Kai: This means they aren't invoking a standard metric horizon; they're using the gauge-theoretic description instead, which is a different way to define what a black hole configuration is in this context.

Mira: The paper also gives us specific expressions for temperature and angular velocity based on the rotation parameter alpha, as well as chemical potentials for the rest mass and spin charges.

Lev: I see those expressions involving A and B i, which are related to integration constants, suggesting that the thermodynamic variables depend heavily on how you define your integration constants.

Kai: It’s a lot of information packed into these equations, but it really sets up the framework for what's possible in this type of gravity.

Conclusion: Mira: Thinking about the title, "The three-dimensional Galilean black hole," it really captures the essence of what they did: finding a black hole solution within a specific non-relativistic gravitational theory framework.

Kai: The authors are Luis Avil´es, Oscar Fuentealba, Diego Hidalgo, and Pablo Rodr´ıguez. They’ve taken a theory based on Galilean structures and successfully constructed a black hole configuration within it.

Lev: What this means for the broader field is that it shows we can define thermodynamic properties for black holes even when we are outside the realm of standard relativity, using these gauge-theoretic tools.

Mira: It opens up a path to systematically investigate this solution space using holonomies and Wilson loops, which gives a natural framework for exploring what other solutions might exist.

Kai: And I think the most interesting thing they pointed out is the idea of extremal configurations where the temperature goes to zero, which happens when the intrinsic spin reaches its maximum possible value, equal to its rest mass M.

Lev: That extreme case also means that the angular momentum and energy become equal in magnitude, and there’s a constraint on that rotation parameter a being less than or equal to l squared.

Mira: So, while it's a different kind of black hole than what we see in general relativity, this work provides concrete mathematical tools to study these non-relativistic gravitational objects rigorously.

Kai: It’s a solid foundation for understanding how gravity might behave in systems where relativistic effects are small or where non-relativistic limits are important.

Instituto de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales (ICEN) · Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Arturo Prat · International Solvay Institutes · Nordita, KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Stockholm University · Departamento de Ciencias Exactas, Universidad de Los Lagos

hep-th, gr-qc

Submitted: 2026-11-05

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: 7 pages, no figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: The authors report a novel solution of three-dimensional Galilean Anti-de Sitter gravity, which provides the first black hole solution in this non-relativistic gravitational theory without assuming…

Key concepts

Galilean Anti-de Sitter Gravity
This is a specific type of non-relativistic gravitational theory being studied. It describes gravity in three dimensions within a Galilean framework, which is different from standard relativistic gravity, allowing for the study of black holes without assuming a Lorentzian spacetime geometry.
Conserved Charges (E, J, S, M)
The black hole solution is defined by four conserved quantities: energy (E), angular momentum (J), intrinsic spin (S), and rest mass (M). These charges characterize the physical properties of the non-relativistic black hole configuration.
Black Hole Thermodynamics in Galilean Gravity
The paper establishes a way to define black hole thermodynamics using gauge-theoretic methods rather than relying on an event horizon. Temperature and entropy are derived from conserved charges through a trivial holonomy condition along a thermal cycle, allowing thermodynamic laws to be applied.
Extremal Configurations (T=0)
The authors found extremal states where the temperature is zero (T=0). This occurs when the intrinsic spin reaches its maximum possible value, equal to the rest mass (|S| = |M|), leading to specific relationships between energy and angular momentum.

Terminology

Summary

The authors report a novel solution of three-dimensional Galilean Anti-de Sitter gravity, which provides the first black hole solution in this non-relativistic gravitational theory without assuming an underlying Lorentzian spacetime geometry The resulting configuration is characterized by four conserved charges: energy E, angular momentum J, intrinsic spin S, and rest mass M This solution establishes the first explicit realization of black hole thermodynamics in a non-relativistic gravitational theory without assuming an underlying Lorentzian spacetime geometry

Black Hole Characterization in Galilean Gravity

The black hole character must be established without invoking necessarily an analogue of the event horizon, instead following the gauge-theoretic characterization of the generalized black holes in [22] The authors impose a trivial holonomy condition along the contractible thermal cycle to determine associated temperature (and other chemical potentials) and entropy in terms of conserved charges This approach allows for the recovery of black hole thermodynamics without relying on the area of a metric horizon

Conserved Charges and Spin Bound

The resulting configuration is characterized by four conserved charges: energy E, angular momentum J, intrinsic spin S, and rest mass M Remarkably, the last two turn out to be related through the rotation parameter a of the solution (associated with its angular velocity) as S = aM This relation establishes an interesting bound for the magnitude of the spin as they show below The magnitude of the intrinsic spin is bounded from above by the rest mass of the configuration, namely, S ≤ lM

Thermodynamic Quantities and Extremal Configurations

The temperature T is given in (34), while the angular velocity omega is given by omega = al(1 + α) The chemical potentials associated to the rest mass and the intrinsic spin charges read ΦM = lα(1 + α)h(2 − α)A + (α − 1)(α + 2)B i, and ΦS = aα(1 + αl"(α − 2)A + (2 + α)/(1+α)!B i The first law of thermodynamics δS = βδE − βomegaδJ − βΦMδM − βΦS δS holds in the micro-canonical ensemble for the Galilean black hole

Asymptotic Symmetries and Further Directions

The asymptotic symmetries turn out to be given by the direct sum of two copies of the infinite-dimensional extension of the Maxwell algebra in three dimensions, previously introduced in [65] The configuration introduced in this work was obtained within a purely intrinsic Galilean framework It would be interesting to study whether the nonrelativistic black hole admits a relativistic parent geometry from which it can be obtained through a suitable non-relativistic limit The gauge-theoretic formulation of the theory provides a natural framework for a systematic investigation of the solution space using holonomies and Wilson loops

Conclusion on Extremal States

The authors have found that it is possible to define extremal configurations in the sense of a vanishing temperature T = 0 This extreme solution is reached when the intrinsic spin S takes its maximum possible value, which is equal to its rest mass M, namely, S = lM As a consequence, the magnitude of the angular momentum also equates to the one of the energy of the configuration The value α = 0 turns out to be a sort of extreme configuration, i.e., with a vanishing temperature T = 0 This extreme solution is reached when the intrinsic spin S takes its maximum possible value, which is equal to its rest mass M, namely, S = lM The magnitude of the angular momentum also equates to the one of the energy of the configuration (33) The bound a squared ≤ l squared for the rotation parameter, which will have direct implication on the allowed values for the intrinsic spin of the solution The relation (1) implies that the magnitude of the intrinsic spin is bounded from above by the rest mass of the solution, namely, S ≤ lM The bound between the energy E and the angular momentum J for arbitrary values of the integration constants A and B cannot be established However, in the extreme case of α = 0 in (23) (or a squared = l 2), the magnitude of the energy and angular momentum become equal E squared = J squared Indeed, the value α = 0 turns out to be a sort of extreme configuration, i. p. 3

Where the paper says it

This extreme solution is reached when the intrinsic spin S takes its maximum possible value, which is equal to its rest mass M, namely, |S| = ℓM. As a consequence, the magnitude of the angular momentum also equates to the one of the energy of the configuration (33).

e., with a vanishing temperature T, as we can anticipate from its expression β = T−1 = 4πgα The magnitude of the angular momentum also equates to the one of the energy of the configuration (33). p. 3
Where the paper says it

This extreme solution is reached when the intrinsic spin S takes its maximum possible value, which is equal to its rest mass M, namely, |S| = ℓM. As a consequence, the magnitude of the angular momentum also equates to the one of the energy of the configuration (33).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can solve problems in non-relativistic gravitational physics by formulating them as Chern-Simons gauge theories invariant under doubly extended Newton-Hooke group in three dimensions. This allows for a systematic investigation of solution spaces using holonomies and Wilson loops, providing a natural framework for black hole configurations without assuming Lorentzian spacetime geometry.

  2. Improved AI system can calculate conserved charges for Galilean Anti-de Sitter gravity solutions, specifically energy E, angular momentum J, intrinsic spin S, and rest mass M. It can also derive thermodynamic quantities such as temperature T and chemical potentials associated with rest mass and spin by imposing regularity conditions on the Euclidean continuation of the solution.

  3. Improved AI system can determine bounds on physical quantities within Galilean black hole solutions. Specifically, it can establish that the magnitude of the spin turns out to be bounded from above by the rest mass as stated in equation (1), or S <= lM in analogy to relativistic gravity results.

  4. Improved AI system can identify and characterize extreme configurations in non-relativistic gravity. It can determine that it is possible to define extremal configurations in the sense of a vanishing temperature T = 0, which corresponds to the configuration where the intrinsic spin S takes its maximum possible value, which is equal to its rest mass M, namely, |S| = lM.

  5. Improved AI system can perform asymptotic analysis on Galilean AdS3 gravity solutions. It can determine that the asymptotic symmetries turn out to be given by the direct sum of two copies of the infinite-dimensional extension of the Maxwell algebra in three dimensions, which is described by specific commutation relations (42) through (45).

Abstract

We report a novel solution of three-dimensional Galilean Anti-de Sitter gravity. The theory can be formulated as a topological gauge theory invariant under the doubly extended Newton-Hooke group in three dimensions. The solution possesses four conserved charges: energy, angular momentum, spin and rest mass. Interestingly, the magnitude of the spin turns out to bounded from above by the rest mass. The solution exhibits the thermal properties that define a black hole configuration in terms of its gauge theoretical description. Temperature, angular velocity and other chemical potentials are obtained from suitable regularity conditions associated with the topology of the Euclidean continuation of the solution. At zero temperature, an extreme configuration is shown to emerge provided the bound between the spin and the rest mass saturates.

Sources

Related papers