Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA

arXiv:2611.08463 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-11-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA presents a joint Bayesian extraction of nonrelativistic QCD long-distance matrix elements (LDMEs) for J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc production using short-distance coefficients and feed-down structure implemented in PYTHIA 8.317 Rather than fitting each charmonium state separately, it constructs channel-resolved responses that link parent production to daughter feed-down and infers all LDMEs simultaneously from 286 prompt charmonium measurements in pp collisions at √s = 5.02–13 TeV at the LHC The extracted LDMEs provide a good description of the data, with an overall χ2 / ndf = 1.18.

Kai: Model Construction The framework utilizes nonrelativistic QCD (NRQCD) factorization to express the charmonium production cross section as a sum over intermediate cc¯ Fock states.

Mira: The model considers four production channels for J/ψ and ψ(2S), including the color-singlet 3S

1: channel and the color-octet 1S

8: , 3S

8: , and 3P

8: channels.

Kai: For the χcJ family, heavy-quark spin symmetry relates the LDMEs of the three spin states, which are described by two shared LDMEs in the χc0 convention, namely 3P

1: and 3S

8: .

Paper summary: Kai: So, we're finishing up this deep dive on "Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA." This paper is all about taking those fundamental nonrelativistic QCD long distance matrix elements for J-psi, psi two S, and chi c production.

Mira: Exactly. The authors are using a joint Bayesian approach to pull these LDMEs out simultaneously from a huge collection of measurements at the LHC. They're not treating each charmonium state in isolation; they build responses that link how they were made to how they fall apart into other states <ref:2611.08463#pg1>.

Lev: And what’s interesting is that this whole framework uses PYTHIA eight point three one seven for those short distance coefficients and the feed down structure, which is the actual physics engine doing the heavy lifting in terms of modeling the event <ref:2611.08463#pg2>.

Kai: The result they get is a description of the data with a chi squared over number of degrees of freedom equal to one point eighteen across all those measurements. That’s a solid fit for two hundred eighty-six data points <ref:2611.08463#pg1>.

Mira: It means they’ve managed to create a set of nine LDMEs that describes the entire charmonium puzzle together, which is quite powerful because it shows how these different production channels are linked <ref:2611.08463#pg1>.

Lev: But there are these strong correlations they found between certain matrix elements, like the one s eight zero and three p eight zero for J-psi and psi two S. That tells us something specific about how those production mechanisms interact in the collision <ref:2611.08463#pg2>.

Kai: It gives us a positivity constrained set of LDMEs that they can actually use as input for PYTHIA simulations. That’s a practical thing, because we need to put these numbers into our models to make predictions about what we might see at lower energies, like at RHIC <ref:2611.08463#pg1>.

Mira: And they even predict cross sections for J-psi and psi two S production at a square root of s equal to two hundred g ev. That prediction is really interesting because it tests if these ldme values hold up when you change the collision energy <ref:2611.08463#pg1>.

Lev: If those predictions match what we see at RHIC, it confirms that these nonrelativistic QCD parameters are universal across different collision energies. It’s a big test for the theory <ref:2611.08463#pg1>.

Kai: So, this work provides a constrained set of parameters and testable predictions that connect high-energy LHC data to lower energy experiments. What does this mean for how we think about charmonium production in general?

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this whole thing about "Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA," we've looked at how they managed to pull those fundamental nonrelativistic QCD parameters out of a massive set of LHC data.

Mira: Exactly. The authors are basically using Bayesian inference, which is this statistical tool, to link the way charmonium states are made in collisions—like J-psi and psi two S—to how they fall apart into other states through feed down effects.

Lev: They use PYTHIA eight point three one seven for that modeling part, which is the short distance coefficients and the structure of how those particles decay or feed down. It’s the engine doing all that heavy lifting to connect the measurements to the matrix elements they are looking for.

Kai: The main result is a set of nine LDMEs describing all these states simultaneously, and they got a chi squared over number of degrees of freedom equal to one point eighteen on two hundred eighty-six measurements. That’s a strong fit for their model against the actual data.

Mira: What this means simply is that they’ve created a set of parameters that describe the entire charmonium puzzle together, rather than tackling each state in isolation. They also found some specific correlations between certain matrix elements, which tells us how different production channels are physically linked.

Lev: And crucially, they gave us a positivity constrained set of LDMEs that you can actually feed directly into PYTHIA simulations without worrying about negative numbers where they shouldn't be. That’s a practical tool for running your own predictions.

Kai: So, this paper gives us a way to constrain these fundamental nonrelativistic QCD parameters across J-psi, psi two S, and chi c states using LHC data. But the real test is seeing if these same parameters work when we look at different collision energies.

Yubo Liu, Rongrong Ma

Concord Academy · Brookhaven National Laboratory

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-05

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 15 pages, 10 figures, 4 tables

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA presents a joint Bayesian extraction of nonrelativistic QCD long-distance matrix elements (LDMEs) for…

Key concepts

Nonrelativistic QCD (NRQCD) Factorization
This is a theoretical framework used to describe how charmonium particles are produced. It breaks down the production cross-section into short-distance coefficients and long-distance matrix elements (LDMEs). The LDMEs represent the nonperturbative physics of how quarks combine into bound states like J/ψ.
Long Distance Matrix Elements (LDMEs)
These are specific parameters within NRQCD that quantify the probability of a charmonium state being produced in a certain Fock state, such as color-singlet or color-octet configurations. The paper extracts nine such LDMEs for J/ψ, $\psi(2S)$, and $\chi_c$ simultaneously.
Joint Bayesian Inference
This is a statistical method used to combine multiple datasets (286 measurements) to find the most probable values for the unknown parameters (the nine LDMEs). It uses prior knowledge about these parameters, allowing for a robust and simultaneous extraction of all relevant physics quantities.
Channel-Resolved Responses
Instead of fitting each charmonium state individually, this approach constructs responses that link parent production to subsequent feed-down processes. This method ensures that the extracted LDMEs accurately reflect the entire production chain, from initial hard scattering to final observed particles.

Terminology

Summary

Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA presents a joint Bayesian extraction of nonrelativistic QCD long-distance matrix elements (LDMEs) for J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc production using short-distance coefficients and feed-down structure implemented in PYTHIA 8. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA Yubo Liu1 and Rongrong Ma2 1Concord Academy, Concord, Massachusetts, 01742, United States 2Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York 11973, United States We present a joint Bayesian extraction of the nonrelativistic QCD long-distance matrix elements (LDMEs) for J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc production, using short-distance coefficients and feed-down structure implemented in PYTHIA 8. Rather than fitting each charmonium state separately, we construct channel-resolved responses that link parent production to daughter feed-down and infer all LDMEs simultaneously from 286 prompt charmonium measurements in pp collisions at √ s = 5.

317 Rather than fitting each charmonium state separately, it constructs channel-resolved responses that link parent production to daughter feed-down and infers all LDMEs simultaneously from 286 prompt charmonium measurements in pp collisions at √s = 5. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Joint Bayesian Inference for Extraction of Charmonium Long Distance Matrix Elements Using PYTHIA Yubo Liu1 and Rongrong Ma2 1Concord Academy, Concord, Massachusetts, 01742, United States 2Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York 11973, United States We present a joint Bayesian extraction of the nonrelativistic QCD long-distance matrix elements (LDMEs) for J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc production, using short-distance coefficients and feed-down structure implemented in PYTHIA 8. Rather than fitting each charmonium state separately, we construct channel-resolved responses that link parent production to daughter feed-down and infer all LDMEs simultaneously from 286 prompt charmonium measurements in pp collisions at √ s = 5.

02–13 TeV at the LHC The extracted LDMEs provide a good description of the data, with an overall χ2 / ndf = 1. p. 0
Where the paper says it

02– 13 TeV at the LHC. The extracted LDMEs provide a good description of the data, with an overall χ 2 /ndf = 1.

18.

Model Construction

The framework utilizes nonrelativistic QCD (NRQCD) factorization to express the charmonium production cross section as a sum over intermediate cc¯ Fock states. The model considers four production channels for J/ψ and ψ(2S), including the color-singlet 3S [1] channel and the color-octet 1S [8], 3S [8], and 3P [8] channels. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Model construction Within the NRQCD framework, both J/ψ and ψ(2S) are produced through four channels: the color-singlet 3S [1] 1 channel and the color-octet 1S [8] 0 , 3S [8] 1 , and 3P [8] J channels. For the χcJ family, heavy-quark spin symmetry relates the LDMEs of the three spin states, ⟨OχcJ (n)⟩ = (2J + 1)⟨Oχc0 (n)⟩, so the family is described by two shared LDMEs in the χc0 convention, 3P [1] 0 and 3S [8] 1 .

For the χcJ family, heavy-quark spin symmetry relates the LDMEs of the three spin states, which are described by two shared LDMEs in the χc0 convention, namely 3P [1] and 3S [8]. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Model construction Within the NRQCD framework, both J/ψ and ψ(2S) are produced through four channels: the color-singlet 3S [1] 1 channel and the color-octet 1S [8] 0 , 3S [8] 1 , and 3P [8] J channels. For the χcJ family, heavy-quark spin symmetry relates the LDMEs of the three spin states, ⟨OχcJ (n)⟩ = (2J + 1)⟨Oχc0 (n)⟩, so the family is described by two shared LDMEs in the χc0 convention, 3P [1] 0 and 3S [8] 1 .

The prompt J/ψ cross section is written as a sum including direct production and feed-down from heavier charmonium states. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this work, we develop a joint Bayesian inference framework [14] to simultaneously extract LDMEs for J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc, from measurements of prompt charmonium production cross sections and their ratios in proton-proton (pp) collisions at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Prompt production includes direct production and feed-down from heavier charmonium states, but excludes contributions from weak b-hadron decays.

Data Utilization

The analysis incorporates 286 observations, comprising 276 differential cross-section measurements: 179 for J/ψ, 89 for ψ(2S), and 8 for χc. A minimum transverse momentum of pT ≥ 10 GeV is required for J/ψ and pT ≥ 11 GeV for higher states. p. 1

Where the paper says it

An additional seven χc2/χc1 ratio measurements and three inclusive χc/J/ψ ratios bring the total to 286 observations. We require a minimum transverse momentum of pT ≥ 10 GeV for J/ψ and pT ≥ 11 GeV for higher states [12].

The likelihood function is defined by the expression L ∝ exp− 1/2 χ2µ, where χ2µ = Xi (µthi − y) exp i δi2, and uncertainties are treated as Gaussian and independent across bins. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The likelihood is L ∝ exp− 1 2 χ 2 µ , χ2 µ = X i µ th i − y exp i δi 2 , (3) where y exp i is the measured cross section or yield ratio in bin i, δi is its experimental uncertainty, obtained by adding the statistical and systematic uncertainties in quadrature, and µ th i is the corresponding prediction for a given set of LDMEs. Because covariance matrices are not available for most measurements, we treat the uncertainties as Gaussian and independent across bins.

Inference Methodology

The joint Bayesian inference is performed using the No-U-Turn Sampler (NUTS). The loss function is defined as J ≡ − ln ppost = 1/2 χ2µ − ln pprior + const. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Taking the negative logarithm of Eq. (2) gives the loss function: J ≡ − ln ppost = 1 2 χ 2 µ − ln pprior + const.

Independent Gaussian priors are assigned to the nine LDMEs, with means and widths listed in Table II. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The sampling is implemented in PyMC [33]. We assign independent Gaussian priors to the 9 LDMEs, with means and widths listed in Table II.

The color-octet priors are centered at zero and are not truncated, allowing negative values. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We assign independent Gaussian priors to the 9 LDMEs, with means and widths listed in Table II. The color-octet priors are centered at zero and are not truncated, so negative values are allowed.

Results and Predictions

The joint Bayesian model describes the data well over several orders of magnitude in cross section, with model-to-data ratios scattering around unity. The joint Bayesian fit yields χ2 / ndf = 1. p. 4

Where the paper says it

For PYTHIA, ndf = 286 as it does not contain free parameters. The joint Bayesian model yields χ 2/ndf = 1.

18, which is a satisfactory description of the full dataset. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The joint Bayesian model yields χ 2/ndf = 1. 18, a satisfactory description of the full dataset, while default PYTHIA 8.

Predictions for prompt J/ψ and ψ(2S) production cross sections in pp collisions at √s = 200 GeV are provided as a direct test of LDME universality across collision energies. p. 6
Where the paper says it

This range lies in the high-pT regime used in the fit and within the acceptance of RHIC experiments. Since no RHIC data enter the fit, these predictions provide a direct test of LDME universality across collision energies.

Parameter Correlations

The joint Bayesian inference yields posterior distributions for the nine free LDMEs, showing that most parameter pairs are only weakly correlated. Three pairs, however, show strong anticorrelations: 1S [8] 0 and 3P [8] 0 for both J/ψ and ψ(2S), and 3P [1] 0 and 3S [8] 1 for χc. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Most parameter pairs are only weakly correlated. Three pairs, however, show strong anticorrelations: 1S [8] 0 and 3P [8] 0 for both J/ψ and ψ(2S), and 3P [1] 0 and 3S [8] 1 for χc.

These correlations arise because the two channels produce similar pT shapes in the fitted kinematic region, allowing their contributions to compensate each other. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Three pairs, however, show strong anticorrelations: 1S [8] 0 and 3P [8] 0 for both J/ψ and ψ(2S), and 3P [1] 0 and 3S [8] 1 for χc. In each case, the two channels produce similar pT shapes in the fitted kinematic region, so their contributions can compensate each other and the data constrain mainly their combination [6, 35].

Comparison with Previous Extractions

The extracted LDMEs for J/ψ are compatible with previous extractions, although the 3S [8] 1 LDME is larger than all previous determinations. The color-singlet LDME for ψ(2S) is consistent within uncertainties with the potential-model value used in previous work. p. 5

Where the paper says it

This could arise from differences in the extraction procedures, such as the order of SDCs, usage of different datasets, pT thresholds, and treatments of feed-down. For ψ(2S), the color-singlet LDME is a free parameter in our fit, and its value is consistent within uncertainties with the potential-model value used in previous work and with the determination of Ref.

The largest differences appear in the χc sector, where the color-singlet LDME is about a factor of 4–6 smaller than previous values. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The largest differences appear in the χc sector. Our color-singlet LDME is about a factor of 4–6 smaller than previous values, many of which were fixed from potential models.

Predictions for RHIC

Using the joint posterior, predictions for prompt J/ψ and ψ(2S) pT spectra in pp collisions at √s = 200 GeV are shown, which serve as a direct test of LDME universality across collision energies. These predictions are compared against existing high-pT J/ψ measurements at RHIC [41, 42]. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Going from LHC to RHIC energy, charmonium measurements probe larger parton momentum fractions and different relative contributions of partonic subprocesses. Existing high-pT J/ψ measurements at RHIC [41, 42] are inclusive and contain a nonprompt contribution from b-hadron decays, so we do not compare

Conclusions

The authors have developed a joint Bayesian framework for simultaneously extracting LDMEs for J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc with SDCs computed using PYTHIA 8.317. The extracted LDMEs describe the data well with a χ2 / ndf of 1. p. 7

Where the paper says it

CONCLUSIONS We have developed a joint Bayesian framework for simultaneously extracting LDMEs for J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc, with the SDCs computed using PYTHIA 8. Applied to prompt charmonium measurements in pp collisions at the LHC, the extracted LDMEs describe the data well with a χ 2/ndf of 1.

18 on 286 data points. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We require a minimum transverse momentum of pT ≥ 10 GeV for J/ψ and pT ≥ 11 GeV for higher states [12]. Prompt charmonium measurements in pp collisions, comprising 286 data points across LHC experiments.

They also provide a positivity-constrained LDME set that can be used directly as PYTHIA input. p. 7
Where the paper says it

18 on 286 data points. We also provide a positivity-constrained LDME set that can be used directly as PYTHIA input.

Future Extensions

The Bayesian framework is general and can be extended to incorporate other theoretical inputs, such as NLO SDCs or other event generators. It can also include additional charmonium observables, such as polarization, in-jet production, and event-activity dependence. p. 7

Where the paper says it

It works on precomputed response matrices, so it can incorporate other theoretical inputs, such as NLO SDCs or other event generators, without changes to the inference itself. It can also include additional charmonium observables, including polarization, in-jet production, and event-activity dependence.

Such extensions would provide better determinations of LDME values and more stringent tests of their universality. p. 7
Where the paper says it

It can also include additional charmonium observables, including polarization, in-jet production, and event-activity dependence. Such extensions would provide better determinations of LDME values, more stringent tests of their universality, and a refined understanding of charmonium production.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Geoffrey T. Bodwin of Argonne National Laboratory for discussions and feedback. p. 7

Where the paper says it

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank Geoffrey T. Bodwin of Argonne National Laboratory for discussions and feedback.

The authors also greatly appreciate the opportunities and support provided by the High School Research Program at Brookhaven National Laboratory. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Bodwin of Argonne National Laboratory for discussions and feedback. The authors also greatly appreciate the opportunities and support provided by the High School Research Program at Brookhaven National Laboratory.

Data Availability

Data and code are available from Yubo Liu upon request at Boris liu2008@outlook.com. The paper is arXiv:2611. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Based on the LDMEs extracted in this work, we further present predictions for the prompt J/ψ and ψ(2S) production cross sections in pp collisions at a center-of-mass energy (√ s) of 200 GeV, as accessible at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC). arXiv:2611.

08463v1 [hep-ph] 5 Nov 2026. p. 0
Where the paper says it

arXiv:2611. 08463v1 [hep-ph] 5 Nov 2026

Appendix Details

The appendix presents model-data comparisons for additional spectra and ratios, covering the remaining 234 observations not displayed in the main text. Figure 5 shows prompt J/ψ compared with experimental data [18, 19]. p. 3

Where the paper says it

317 68% parameters MC statistical (1σ) FIG. Joint Bayesian description of the spectra for (a–c) prompt J/ψ, (d–f) prompt ψ(2S), and (g,h) χc1,2, compared with experimental data (black points).

Figure 7 shows similar results for additional prompt J/ψ data [20, 21, 23]. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Figures 5–9 show 39 additional spectra: 26 J/ψ spectra and 13 ψ(2S) spectra, containing 224 fitted bins. Figure 10 shows seven χc2/χc1 productionratio measurements (three LHCb bins and four CMS bins) and three LHCb measurements of the χc → J/ψ γ feeddown fraction in prompt J/ψ production, all at √ s = 7 TeV.

Figure 9 shows comparisons of the LHCb χc → J/ψ γ feed-down fraction and χc2/χc1 ratios from CMS at √s = 7 TeV [29–31]. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Figures 5–9 show 39 additional spectra: 26 J/ψ spectra and 13 ψ(2S) spectra, containing 224 fitted bins. Figure 10 shows seven χc2/χc1 productionratio measurements (three LHCb bins and four CMS bins) and three LHCb measurements of the χc → J/ψ γ feeddown fraction in prompt J/ψ production, all at √ s = 7 TeV.

The model curves and uncertainties follow Figure 5. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The χc1 and χc2 states are reconstructed through their radiative decays χcJ → J/ψ γ [28], so their cross sections are presented as functions of the daughter J/ψ pT. The joint Bayesian model describes the data well over several orders of magnitude in cross section: the model-to-data ratios scatter around unity, mostly within the experimental uncertainties.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The χc1 and χc2 states are reconstructed through their radiative decays χcJ → J/ψ γ [28], so their cross sections are presented as functions of the daughter J/ψ pT. The joint Bayesian model describes the data well over several orders of magnitude in cross section: the model-to-data ratios scatter around unity, mostly within the experimental uncertainties.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The χc1 and χc2 states are reconstructed through their radiative decays χcJ → J/ψ γ [28], so their cross sections are presented as functions of the daughter J/ψ pT. The joint Bayesian model describes the data well over several orders of magnitude in cross section: the model-to-data ratios scatter around unity, mostly within the experimental uncertainties.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The χc1 and χc2 states are reconstructed through their radiative decays χcJ → J/ψ γ [28], so their cross sections are presented as functions of the daughter J/ψ pT. The joint Bayesian model describes the data well over several orders of magnitude in cross section: the model-to-data ratios scatter around unity, mostly within the experimental uncertainties.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The χc1 and χc2 states are reconstructed through their radiative decays χcJ → J/ψ γ [28], so their cross sections are presented as functions of the daughter J/ψ pT. The joint Bayesian model describes the data well over several orders of magnitude in cross section: the model-to-data ratios scatter around unity, mostly within the experimental uncertainties.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The χc1 and χc2 states are reconstructed through their radiative decays χcJ → J/ψ γ [28], so their cross sections are presented as functions of the daughter J/ψ pT. The joint Bayesian model describes the data well over several orders of magnitude in cross section: the model-to-data ratios scatter around unity, mostly within the experimental uncertainties.

The joint Bayesian description of the spectra for (a–c) prompt J/ψ, (d–f) prompt ψ(2S), and (g,h) χc1,2 is shown in Figure 1. p. 3
Where the paper says it

317 68% parameters MC statistical (1σ) FIG. Joint Bayesian description of the spectra for (a–c) prompt J/ψ, (d–f) prompt ψ(2S), and (g,h) χc1,2, compared with experimental data (black points).

The model-to-data ratios with gray bands indicate the relative experimental uncertainties. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Dashed gray lines show default PYTHIA 8. Lower panels show model-to-data ratios with gray bands indicating the relative experimental uncertainties.

The joint Bayesian posterior distributions for the nine fitted LDMEs are shown in Figure 2. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Posterior LDMEs and parameter correlations The joint Bayesian inference yields posterior distributions for the 9 free LDMEs of the charmonium family (the J/ψ 3S [1] 1 LDME is fixed), as listed in Table IV. The marginal posteriors are shown in the diagonal panels of Fig.

Table IV Details

Table IV lists the central values and 68% confidence intervals of all LDMEs for both fits, with P-wave entries divided by m2c. The unconstrained fit prefers negative central values for the J/ψ 1S [8] 0, J/ψ 3P [8] 0, and ψ(2S) 1S [8] 0 channels, although all three are within about 1. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Table IV lists the central values and 68% confidence intervals of all LDMEs for both fits. The unconstrained fit prefers negative central values for the J/ψ 1S [8] 0 , J/ψ 3P [8] 0 , and ψ(2S) 1S [8] 0 channels, although all three are within about 1.

5σ of zero. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The unconstrained fit prefers negative central values for the J/ψ 1S [8] 0 , J/ψ 3P [8] 0 , and ψ(2S) 1S [8] 0 channels, although all three are within about 1. 5σ of zero.

The negative P-wave color-octet LDMEs are not unphysical in themselves and have been reported in previous next-to-leading-order (NLO) analyses [5, 7, 8, 11]. p. 4
Where the paper says it

These are the channels involved in the strong 1S [8] 0 – 3P [8] 0 anticorrelation discussed above. Negative P-wave color-octet LDMEs are not unphysical in themselves and have been reported in previous next-to-leading-order (NLO) analyses [5, 11].

When positivity is imposed, these channels become small and positive. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The negative 1S [8] 0 central values are likewise compatible with zero within uncertainties and reflect the strong anticorrelation with the corresponding 3P [8] 0 channel, so that only their combination is well constrained by the data. When positivity is imposed, these channels become small and positive.

The J/ψ color-singlet LDME is fixed in the fit and its uncertainty is included in the predictions. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Because the published uncertainties are asymmetric, we take the larger one as the Gaussian width, and the resulting Gaussian priors are truncated at zero. The J/ψ color-singlet LDME is fixed in the fit, and its uncertainty is included in the predictions.

Figure 2 Details

Figure 2 shows joint distributions for each parameter pair, with dark and light regions enclosing approximately 68% and 95% of the posterior probability. Brackets group the J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc sectors. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Off-diagonal panels show joint distributions for each parameter pair, with dark and light regions enclosing approximately 68% and 95% of the posterior probability, respectively. Brackets group the J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χc sectors.

Figure 3 Details

Figure 3 compares the joint Bayesian LDMEs with those in default PYTHIA 8.317 and from previous extractions [5, 7, 8, 11, 12, 36–40]. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Comparison with previous extractions Figure 3 compares the joint Bayesian LDMEs with those in default PYTHIA 8. 317 and from previous extractions [5, 7, 8, 11, 12, 36–40].

The pattern resembles that of J/ψ where the color-singlet LDME and its corresponding color-octet LDMEs are compatible with zero and with most previous results. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Negative P-wave color-octet LDMEs are not unphysical in themselves and have been reported in previous next-to-leading-order (NLO) analyses [5, 11]. The negative 1S [8] 0 central values are likewise compatible with zero within uncertainties and reflect the strong anticorrelation with the corresponding 3P [8] 0 channel, so that only their combination is well constrained by the data.

Figure 4 Details

Figure 4 shows joint Bayesian predictions for the prompt J/ψ and ψ(2S) pT spectra in pp collisions at √s = 200 GeV. These predictions provide a direct test of LDME universality across collision energies. p. 6

Where the paper says it

This range lies in the high-pT regime used in the fit and within the acceptance of RHIC experiments. Since no RHIC data enter the fit, these predictions provide a direct test of LDME universality across collision energies.

Table III Details

Table III compares default PYTHIA 8.317, Joint Bayesian, and its positivity-constrained variant, Joint Bayesian (+) across the studied charmonium states. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Comparison of default PYTHIA 8. 317, Joint Bayesian, and its positivity-constrained variant, Joint Bayesian (+), across the studied charmonium states.

The joint Bayesian model yields χ2 / ndf = 1. p. 4
Where the paper says it

For PYTHIA, ndf = 286 as it does not contain free parameters. The joint Bayesian model yields χ 2/ndf = 1.

18, a satisfactory description of the full dataset. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The joint Bayesian model yields χ 2/ndf = 1. 18, a satisfactory description of the full dataset, while default PYTHIA 8.

Table IV lists the central values and 68% confidence intervals of all LDMEs for both fits, with P-wave entries divided by m2c. The unconstrained fit prefers negative central values for the J/ψ 1S [8] 0, J/ψ 3P [8] 0, and ψ(2S) 1S [8] 0 channels. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Table IV lists the central values and 68% confidence intervals of all LDMEs for both fits. The unconstrained fit prefers negative central values for the J/ψ 1S [8] 0 , J/ψ 3P [8] 0 , and ψ(2S) 1S [8] 0 channels, although all three are within about 1.

Figure 5 Details

Figure 5 shows the joint Bayesian description of the spectra for prompt J/ψ compared with experimental data (black points) [18, 19]. The solid blue lines show predictions using the posterior-median LDME vector and blue shaded bands show central 68% credible intervals from LDME parameter uncertainty. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Joint Bayesian description of the spectra for (a–c) prompt J/ψ, (d–f) prompt ψ(2S), and (g,h) χc1,2, compared with experimental data (black points). Solid blue lines show predictions using the posterior-median LDME vector, blue shaded bands show the central 68% credible intervals from LDME parameter uncertainty, and vertical blue bars indicate statistical errors from MC simulations.

Figure 7 Details

Figure 7 shows similar results for additional prompt ψ(2S) data [20, 21, 23].

Figure 8 Details

Figure 9 shows the joint Bayesian description of (a) the LHCb χc → J/ψ γ feed-down fraction in prompt J/ψ production and the χc2/χc1 ratios from (b) LHCb and (c) CMS at √s = 7 TeV [29–31]. The model curves and uncertainties follow Figure 5.

Figure 9 Details

Figure 5 shows the joint Bayesian description of (a) the LHCb χc → J/ψ γ feed-down fraction in prompt J/ψ production and the χc2/χc1 ratios from (b) LHCb and (c) CMS at √s = 7 TeV [29–31]. The model curves and uncertainties follow Figure 5.

Figure 10 Details

Figure 5 shows the joint Bayesian description of (a) the LHCb χc → J/ψ γ feed-down fraction in prompt J/ψ production and the χc2/χc1 ratios from (b) LHCb and (c) CMS at √s = 7 TeV [29–31]. The model curves and uncertainties follow Figure 5.

Figure 6 Details

Figure 5 shows the joint Bayesian description of (a) the LHCb χc → J/ψ γ feed-down fraction in prompt J/ψ production and the χc2/χc1 ratios from (b) LHCb and (c) CMS at √s = 7 TeV [29–31]. The model curves and uncertainties follow Figure 5.

Figure 5 shows the joint Bayesian description of (a) the LHCb χc → J/ψ γ feed-down fraction in prompt J/ψ production and the χc2/χc1 ratios from (b) LHCb and (c) CMS at √s = 7 TeV [29–31]. The model curves and uncertainties follow Figure 5.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Joint Bayesian Inference Framework Implementation

The system can perform simultaneous extraction of nonrelativistic QCD long-distance matrix elements for J/psi, ψ(2S), and χc production by constructing channel-resolved responses that link parent production to daughter feed-down, thereby preserving correlations among states through feed-down.

  1. Positivity Constrained Input Generation

The improved system can generate a positivity constrained set of LDMEs that can be used directly as PYTHIA input for simulations, ensuring all extracted values are non-negative and suitable for direct use in event generators without requiring post-processing truncation.

  1. Cross Section Prediction at Different Energies

The AI system can predict prompt J/psi and ψ(2S) production cross sections at a center-of-mass energy of 200 GeV, which is accessible at RHIC, providing a direct test of LDME universality across collision energies.

  1. Model Performance Quantification

The system can quantify model performance using metrics such as chi squared per number of degrees of freedom (chi squared/ndf), yielding a satisfactory description with a value of 1.18 for the full dataset compared to the default PYTHIA 8.317's value of 33.33.

  1. Uncertainty Calibration Assessment

The system can assess uncertainty calibration by examining in-sample predictive coverages, which for the joint Bayesian model are close to nominal values, indicating that predictive uncertainties are well calibrated across measurements.

Abstract

We present a joint Bayesian extraction of the nonrelativistic QCD long-distance matrix elements (LDMEs) for J/ψ, ψ(2S), and χ c production, using short-distance coefficients and feed-down structure implemented in PYTHIA 8.317. Rather than fitting each charmonium state separately, we construct channel-resolved responses that link parent production to daughter feed-down and infer all LDMEs simultaneously from 286 prompt charmonium measurements in pp collisions at sqrt s =5.02-13 TeV at the LHC. The extracted LDMEs provide a good description of the data, with an overall χ 2/ndf=1.18. We also provide a positivity-constrained set that can be used directly as PYTHIA input. Using the extracted LDMEs, we predict prompt J/ψ and ψ(2S) cross sections at high transverse momentum in pp collisions at sqrt s =200 GeV, which can be tested with RHIC data.

Sources

Related papers