Testing the Spin of New Physics with Top Precision Measurements

arXiv:2611.08459 · hep-ph, hep-ex · Submitted 2026-11-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Testing the Spin of New Physics with Top Precision Measurements".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Precision measurements can reveal not only the presence of new physics, but also information about the dynamics that generated it The study compares three top-philic scenarios—a colored scalar top partner, a colored vector-like fermion, and a spin-one Z′ mediator—to test their distinct dynamical origins using differential top-pair production measurements Top-Philic BSM Scenarios The paper introduces three simple UV extensions of the Standard Model covering distinct spin assignments for the BSM states 1.

Kai: Scalar Top-partner contains a top-like spin 0 particle singlet under SU(2)L, φT, and a spin 1/2 particle, χ, which is a singlet under the entire SM gauge group and plays the role of a DM candidate 2.

Mira: Vector-like Fermionic Top-partner (VLF) contains a vector-like top-partner, ψT, which is also a singlet under SU(2)L and a fermionic field, ϕ, which is a DM candidate 3.

Kai: Top-philic Z′ corresponds to a simplified U(1)' model with couplings to light quarks and top quarks The Lagrangians for these new fields are provided in equations (2.1), (2.2), and (2.3) For the Scalar and VLF scenarios, the interaction between the dark matter particle and the SM are entirely controlled by the coupling yDM The Z′ model can also accommodate a Dark Matter candidate and is a standard benchmark for resonance and dark matter searches at the LHC Impact on Top Observables The BSM models considered here couple predominantly to the top quark and can modify both the total production rate of top-quark pairs and the shapes of their kinematic distributions 3.1 BSM Form Factors The leading corrections for the Scalar and VLF models arise at one loop from new BSM states, whereas in the Z′ model, the leading contribution already appears at tree level through s-channel Z′ exchange The form factors FµScalar and FµVLF have different structures originating directly from the spin assignments of the particles running in the loop In the low-energy regime, s/M2 ≪ 1, these differences reduce to different matching coefficients multiplying the same effective interaction Near threshold, however, the local expansion ceases to provide an adequate description Shape Discrimination in the pT Spectrum The analysis focuses on using the transverse momentum (pT) of the hardest top quark as a promising observable for identifying an excess over the SM prediction 5.1 Statistical Method The best fit parameters are obtained by maximizing the binned Poisson likelihood

56–58: The test statistic is then defined by the likelihood ratio q = −2 ln L(µ = 0) L(ˆµ) Where the gains come from The results show that it is significantly easier to distinguish the Z′ (spin 1) hypothesis from the Scalar one than differentiating the VLF and Scalar hypotheses The discrimination power for the broad Z′ model is shown to be among the largest, reaching around 8σ at 3 ab−1 The results obtained under each true hypothesis are summarized in Fig.

Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper called "Testing the Spin of New Physics with Top Precision Measurements," and what it does is compare three different ideas for new physics that couple to the top quark: a colored scalar top partner, a colored vector-like fermion, and a spin one Z prime mediator.

Mira: It seems like the main idea here is using precision measurements of top-pair production to test the fundamental dynamics behind these different scenarios. They are trying to see what kind of new physics might be lurking out there by looking at how it affects the top quarks we already study so much.

Lev: What's interesting is that they are looking at how these different particles contribute, because the scalar and vector-like fermion models show up through loop corrections, while the Z prime mediator contributes right away at tree level. That difference in when they show up is a key thing to track.

Kai: Right, so the core argument is that even though the scalar and vector-like fermion scenarios look similar at low energies because they match onto the same effective operator structure, their full loop amplitudes develop different patterns near or above threshold.

Mira: That's what they're pointing out—the way those momentum-dependent interference patterns appear in things like the top transverse momentum spectrum is what separates them. They aren't just looking for a simple bump; they are looking for a specific shape.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, if you were to build hardware to measure this, you'd need good statistics because the distinction relies on these subtle interference patterns that might be washed out by noise in the measurement record.

Kai: The paper uses the top transverse momentum spectrum as a promising observable for this discrimination. They define a statistical test using the likelihood ratio where they compare a zero signal hypothesis to an alternative hypothesis.

Mira: And what they're saying is that this approach has some real power, especially when testing the spin of new physics. They found that distinguishing the Z prime from the scalar partner is relatively easy compared to separating the scalar and vector-like fermion hypotheses.

Lev: It's a bit of a trade-off in terms of difficulty; they say it's significantly easier to tell those two apart than differentiating the VLF and Scalar hypotheses. But they also highlight that the Z prime model has one of the largest discrimination powers, reaching around eight sigma at three ab minus one.

Kai: So, what this means for us is that differential measurements can probe not just how big a deviation is, but also its analytic structure. It’s not just about finding a signal; it’s about understanding the physics that created it.

Mira: Exactly. The paper suggests a multidimensional analysis could combine the magnitude of the deviation with this structural information from different types of measurements to get a fuller picture.

Lev: But they also have their limitations, and they state that if the particles causing a deviation aren't parametrically heavier than the energies being probed, the expansion in external momenta over the new physics scale might not converge rapidly. That's where things can get tricky for any real test of these models.

Kai: So to wrap up this summary of "Testing the Spin of New Physics with Top Precision Measurements," it really comes down to using differential top measurements to probe the dynamics that generated new physics, comparing a colored scalar partner, a vector-like fermion, and a Z prime mediator.

Mira: The authors point out that while the scalar and vector-like fermion scenarios match at low energies, their full loop effects create distinct momentum-dependent interference patterns when you look near or above threshold.

Lev: And for practical implementation on hardware, the results suggest that resonant and loop-induced effects are relatively easy to distinguish using the top transverse momentum spectrum, though it depends heavily on the precision of that measurement record.

Kai: Moving into the conclusion of this paper, they discuss how important it is to look at these different scenarios and what they imply about new physics beyond the Standard Model.

Mira: The authors emphasize that while distinguishing a Z prime from a loop-induced scenario is relatively robust, the more challenging problem for them seems to be differentiating between the scalar and vector-like fermion hypotheses.

Lev: They conclude that differential measurements can probe not only the magnitude of a deviation but also its analytic structure, which suggests combining different types of information might be essential.

Kai: Ultimately, they suggest that getting a precisely measured Standard Model process combined with new particles in an experimentally accessible range of momentum transfer is what you need to really test these ideas.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at how to use top quark measurements to test if new physics has spin one or spin zero, and now we're wrapping up this paper, "Testing the Spin of New Physics with Top Precision Measurements."

Mira: It really boils down to comparing three different simple models—a scalar top partner, a vector-like fermion, and a Z prime mediator—using just how those new particles affect the top pair production data.

Lev: The authors are using the transverse momentum spectrum of the hardest top quark as their main tool to tell these scenarios apart.

Kai: And what they found is that it's actually easier to distinguish a Z prime model from a scalar one than it is to separate those two, and that the Z prime model shows some pretty strong power, hitting around eight sigma at three ab minus one.

Mira: That's interesting because the paper also points out that even though the scalar and vector-like fermion models look similar at low energies, their loop corrections create different shapes in the data when you get closer to the energy threshold.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means we need a very precise measurement record to see those subtle differences clearly on real hardware.

Kai: So what this means for us is that differential measurements can give us structural information about the physics, not just how big a deviation is. It suggests combining different types of measurements could give us a more complete picture.

Mira: The authors stress that the most interesting problem they found isn't just finding *a* deviation, but figuring out the actual analytic structure of what we see.

Lev: It points toward needing more than just a single measurement to constrain these BSM models properly.

Kai: So, if we can map out that structure across different measurements, it gives us a much better way to test these ideas. That leads us right into how this kind of precision probing connects to the actual dark matter candidates these models propose.

André Lessa, Vinícius Rocca, Veronica Sanz

Instituto de Física, Universidade de São Paulo · Instituto de Física Corpuscular (IFIC), Universidad de Valencia-CSIC

hep-ph, hep-ex

Submitted: 2026-11-05

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 33 pages, 12 figures. The datasets and code used to obtain all the results presented here as well as additional details are available in https://github.com/andlessa/UnfoldingBSMttbar/releases

Code: https://github.com/andlessa/UnfoldingBSMttbar

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Precision measurements can reveal not only the presence of new physics, but also information about the dynamics that generated it The study compares three top-philic scenarios—a colored scalar top…

Key concepts

Top-philic BSM Scenarios
These are three simple extensions to the Standard Model that involve new particles interacting strongly with top quarks. They include a spin-0 scalar partner, a spin-1/2 vector-like fermion, and a spin-1 Z' mediator. Each scenario has different fundamental properties regarding its particle type and how it couples to the known particles.
Differential Top-Pair Production
This involves measuring specific kinematic features of top quark pairs produced in collisions, such as the transverse momentum (pT) of the hardest top quark. Analyzing these distributions helps researchers distinguish between different new physics models because each model predicts a unique shape for these measurements.
Form Factors
These describe how the interaction strength between new physics particles and top quarks changes depending on their spin. The scalar and VLF models have different structures for their form factors, which can be detected in the production rates of top pairs, especially when comparing loop-induced corrections to tree-level contributions.
Asimov Significance
This is a statistical measure used to quantify how significant a potential discovery or deviation from the Standard Model prediction is. The paper uses this metric to show the expected sensitivity of future experiments, like the High-Luminosity LHC, to distinguish between different new physics hypotheses.

Terminology

Summary

Precision measurements can reveal not only the presence of new physics, but also information about the dynamics that generated it The study compares three top-philic scenarios—a colored scalar top partner, a colored vector-like fermion, and a spin-one Z′ mediator—to test their distinct dynamical origins using differential top-pair production measurements

Top-Philic BSM Scenarios

The paper introduces three simple UV extensions of the Standard Model covering distinct spin assignments for the BSM states 1. Scalar Top-partner contains a top-like spin 0 particle singlet under SU(2)L, φT, and a spin 1/2 particle, χ, which is a singlet under the entire SM gauge group and plays the role of a DM candidate 2. p. 3

Where the paper says it

2 Top-Philic BSM Scenarios We consider three simple UV extensions of the SM covering distinct spin assignments for the BSM states: 1. Scalar Top-partner: contains a top-like spin 0 particle singlet under SU(2)L, φT , and a spin 1/2 particle, χ, which is a singlet under the entire SM gauge group and plays the role of a DM candidate.

Vector-like Fermionic Top-partner (VLF) contains a vector-like top-partner, ψT, which is also a singlet under SU(2)L and a fermionic field, ϕ, which is a DM candidate 3. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Both φT and χ are odd under a Z2-type symmetry. Vector-like Fermionic Top-partner (VLF): contains a vector-like top-partner, ψT , which is also a singlet under SU(2)L and a fermionic field, ϕ, which is a DM candidate.

Top-philic Z′ corresponds to a simplified U(1)' model with couplings to light quarks and top quarks The Lagrangians for these new fields are provided in equations (2.1), (2.2), and (2.3) For the Scalar and VLF scenarios, the interaction between the dark matter particle and the SM are entirely controlled by the coupling yDM The Z′ model can also accommodate a Dark Matter candidate and is a standard benchmark for resonance and dark matter searches at the LHC

Impact on Top Observables

The BSM models considered here couple predominantly to the top quark and can modify both the total production rate of top-quark pairs and the shapes of their kinematic distributions 3.1 BSM Form Factors The leading corrections for the Scalar and VLF models arise at one loop from new BSM states, whereas in the Z′ model, the leading contribution already appears at tree level through s-channel Z′ exchange The form factors FµScalar and FµVLF have different structures originating directly from the spin assignments of the particles running in the loop In the low-energy regime, s/M2 ≪ 1, these differences reduce to different matching coefficients multiplying the same effective interaction Near threshold, however, the local expansion ceases to provide an adequate description

Shape Discrimination in the pT Spectrum

The analysis focuses on using the transverse momentum (pT) of the hardest top quark as a promising observable for identifying an excess over the SM prediction 5.1 Statistical Method The best fit parameters are obtained by maximizing the binned Poisson likelihood [56–58] The test statistic is then defined by the likelihood ratio q = −2 ln L(µ = 0) L(ˆµ)

Where the gains come from

The results show that it is significantly easier to distinguish the Z′ (spin 1) hypothesis from the Scalar one than differentiating the VLF and Scalar hypotheses The discrimination power for the broad Z′ model is shown to be among the largest, reaching around 8σ at 3 ab−1 The results obtained under each true hypothesis are summarized in Fig. 12, where we show the Asimov significance for the full HL-LHC integrated luminosity

Conclusions

The distinction between a Z′ -like contribution and the loop-induced scenarios is comparatively robust The more interesting and genuinely difficult problem is the discrimination between the Scalar and VLF hypotheses Differential measurements can then probe not only the magnitude of a deviation but also its analytic structure A multidimensional analysis can combine these complementary pieces of information The essential ingredients are a precisely measured SM process and new particles that contribute virtually over an experimentally accessible range of momentum transfer

Data availability

All data and results presented in this work, together with code required to reproduce the figures, are publicly available on GitHub [63] The paper is 2611.08459.

--- Page 33 ---

[32] Aram Hayrapetyan et al. Search for a top-philic Z’ boson decaying into a t¯t pair in a final state with jets and an electron or muon in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Before discussing the behavior of FScalar and FVLF as a function of the parton level center of mass energy, it is useful to express the BSM contribution in the Z ′ model in a similar form. As discussed above, the leading BSM contribution to top quark pair production in this case arises from the tree level s channel exchange of the Z ′ boson, as illustrated in Fig.

6 TeV. 8 2026.

[33] Antonio Boveia and Caterina Doglioni. Dark Matter Searches at Colliders. p. 4

Where the paper says it

In contrast, in the framework considered here yDM is treated as a free parameter and can take values as large as allowed by perturbativity, yDM ≲ 4π. The Z ′ model can also accommodate a Dark Matter candidate and is a standard benchmark for resonance and dark matter searches at the LHC, as extensively discussed in the literature [24, 33–36].

Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci., 68:429–459, 2018

[34] Satomi Okada. z′ portal dark matter in the minimal b − l model, 2018

[35] Zhen-Wei Wang, Zhi-Long Han, Fei Huang, Honglei Li, and Ang Liu. Reviving z′ portal dark matter with conversion mechanism, 2025

[36] Avirup Ghosh, Alexei H. Sopov, and Raymond R. Volkas. Dark matter freeze-in from a z′ reheaton, 2025

[37] Seungwon Baek, P. Ko, and Peiwen Wu. Top-philic scalar dark matter with a vector-like fermionic top partner. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Top-philic sectors provide a well-motivated setting for this question. Scalar and fermionic colored partners coupled to a neutral stable state occur in simplified dark matter models [24– 28].

Journal of High Energy Physics, 2016(10):117, 2016

[38] Thomas Hahn. Generating Feynman diagrams and amplitudes with FeynArts 3. p. 5

Where the paper says it

For this purpose, we first restrict the discussion to the quark-initiated subprocess, qq¯ → tt¯, for which the relevant BSM contribution can be traced back to the loop-induced correction to the g-t-t¯ vertex, as shown in Fig. q q¯ t t¯ (a) q¯ q t t¯ φT φT χ (b) q¯ q t t¯ ψ¯ T ψ¯ T ϕ (c) Figure 1: Representative Feynman diagrams for the qq¯ → tt¯ process: (a) tree-level SM contribution; (b) leading one-loop correction in the Scalar model; and (c) leading one-loop correction in the VLF model.

Comput. Phys. Commun., 140:418–431, 2001

[39] Vladyslav Shtabovenko, Rolf Mertig, and Frederik Orellana. FeynCalc 9. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The detailed expressions for the VLF and Scalar counterterms can be found in Appendix A. The loop integrals were evaluated using FeynArts [38] and FeynCalc [39–41], while the counterterms were obtained with NLOCT [42] in the on-shell renormalization scheme.

3: New features and improvements. p. 2
Where the paper says it

If the particles responsible for a deviation are not parametrically heavier than the energies probed, the expansion in external momenta over the new-physics scale need not converge rapidly. Thresholds, absorptive parts, and changes of sign are non-local features of amplitudes and cannot, in general, be reproduced by a truncation at a fixed EFT dimension.

Comput. Phys. Commun., 256:107478, 2020

[40] Vladyslav Shtabovenko, Rolf Mertig, and Frederik Orellana. New Developments in FeynCalc 9. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The detailed expressions for the VLF and Scalar counterterms can be found in Appendix A. The loop integrals were evaluated using FeynArts [38] and FeynCalc [39–41], while the counterterms were obtained with NLOCT [42] in the on-shell renormalization scheme.

0. Comput. Phys. Commun., 207:432–444, 2016

[41] R. Mertig, M. Bohm, and Ansgar Denner. FEYN CALC: Computer algebraic calculation of Feynman amplitudes. p. 5

Where the paper says it

For this purpose, we first restrict the discussion to the quark-initiated subprocess, qq¯ → tt¯, for which the relevant BSM contribution can be traced back to the loop-induced correction to the g-t-t¯ vertex, as shown in Fig. q q¯ t t¯ (a) q¯ q t t¯ φT φT χ (b) q¯ q t t¯ ψ¯ T ψ¯ T ϕ (c) Figure 1: Representative Feynman diagrams for the qq¯ → tt¯ process: (a) tree-level SM contribution; (b) leading one-loop correction in the Scalar model; and (c) leading one-loop correction in the VLF model.

Comput. Phys. Commun., 64:345–359, 1991

[42] Celine Degrande. Automatic evaluation of UV and R2 terms for beyond the Standard Model Lagrangians: a proof-of-principle. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Statistical Method 18 5. 2 Results 20 6 Conclusions 25 A One Loop Counterterms 28 1 Introduction The absence of unambiguous signals of new physics at the LHC has increased the importance of precision measurements as probes of physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM).

Comput. Phys. Commun., 197:239–262, 2015

[43] G. Passarino and M. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Passarino–Veltman reduction [43, 44], the form factors take the form F µ Scalar = p/1 PR [p µ 1 (C1 + 2C11) − p µ 2 (C1 + 2C12)] + p/2 PR [p µ 2 (C2 + 2C22) − p µ 1 (C2 + 2C12)] + 2γ µ (C00 + δR)PR + 2γ µ δLPL, (3. 4) F µ VLF = −p/1 PR [p µ 1 (2C1 + 2C11) − 2p µ 2C12] − p/2 PR [p µ 2 (2C2 + 2C22) − 2p µ 1C12] + p/2 γ µ p/1 PR(C0 + C1 + C2) + γ µPR B0 + (m2 − M2 )C0 + 2p 2 1C1 + 2p 2 2C2 − 2γ µPR(C00 − δR) + 2γ µ δLPL.

J. G. Veltman. One Loop Corrections for e+ e- Annihilation Into mu+ mu- in the Weinberg Model, Nucl. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Focusing on the process pp → tt¯, we compare the leading BSM effects in the three scenarios introduced in Sec. In the Scalar and VLF models, the leading corrections arise at one loop from the new BSM states, whereas in the Z ′ model the leading contribution already appears at tree level through s-channel Z ′ exchange.

Phys. B, 160:151–207, 1979

[44] Gerard ’t Hooft and M. J. G. Veltman. Scalar One Loop Integrals, Nucl. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The detailed expressions for the VLF and Scalar counterterms can be found in Appendix A. The loop integrals were evaluated using FeynArts [38] and FeynCalc [39–41], while the counterterms were obtained with NLOCT [42] in the on-shell renormalization scheme.

Phys. B, 153:365–401, 1979

[45] Johan Alwall, Michel Herquet, Fabio Maltoni, Olivier Mattelaer, and Tim Stelzer. MadGraph 5: Going Beyond. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Statistical Method 18 5. 2 Results 20 6 Conclusions 25 A One Loop Counterterms 28 1 Introduction The absence of unambiguous signals of new physics at the LHC has increased the importance of precision measurements as probes of physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM).

JHEP, 06:128, 2011

[46] Richard D. Ball et al. Parton distributions with LHC data. p. 7

Where the paper says it

This connection will be useful below when interpreting the invariant-mass distributions. Before discussing the behavior of FScalar and FVLF as a function of the parton level center of mass energy, it is useful to express the BSM contribution in the Z ′ model in a similar form.

Nucl. Phys. B, 867:244–289, 2013

[47] Mohammad Mahdi Altakach, Sabine Kraml, Andre Lessa, Sahana Narasimha, Timothée Pascal, Camila Ramos, Yoxara Villamizar, and Wolfgang Waltenberger. SModelS v3: going beyond Z2 topologies. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Statistical Method 18 5. 2 Results 20 6 Conclusions 25 A One Loop Counterterms 28 1 Introduction The absence of unambiguous signals of new physics at the LHC has increased the importance of precision measurements as probes of physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM).

JHEP, 11:074, 2024

[48] Mohammad Mahdi Altakach et al. SModelS v2.3: Enabling global likelihood analyses. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Once heavy new degrees of freedom are integrated out, their leading effects are encoded in higher-dimensional operators built from SM fields [9, 10]. Differential top data have become an essential ingredient of both dedicated top-sector analyses and global SMEFT fits [11–16].

SciPost Phys., 15(5):185, 2023

[49] Gaël Alguero et al. Constraining new physics with SModelS version 2. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Testing the Spin of New Physics with Top Precision Measurements André Lessa a Vinícius Rocca a and Veronica Sanz b a Instituto de Física, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 05508-090 SP, Brazil b Instituto de Física Corpuscular (IFIC), Universidad de Valencia-CSIC, E-46980 Valencia, Spain E-mail: lessa@if. br, rocca@if.

JHEP, 08:068, 2022

[50] Sabine Kraml et al. SModelS: a tool for interpreting simplified-model results from the LHC and its application to supersymmetry. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Statistical Method 18 5. 2 Results 20 6 Conclusions 25 A One Loop Counterterms 28 1 Introduction The absence of unambiguous signals of new physics at the LHC has increased the importance of precision measurements as probes of physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM).

Eur. Phys. J. C, 74:2868, 2014

[51] CMS Collaboration. Search for top squark production in fully-hadronic final states in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The experimental program is now directly probing related structures, including heavy scalar and pseudoscalar states in tt¯ [31] and top-philic Z ′ bosons at √ s = 13. 6 TeV [32].

Phys. Rev. D, 104:052001, 2021

[52] CMS Collaboration. Search for supersymmetry in proton-proton collisions at 13 tev in final states with jets and missing transverse momentum. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The experimental program is now directly probing related structures, including heavy scalar and pseudoscalar states in tt¯ [31] and top-philic Z ′ bosons at √ s = 13. 6 TeV [32].

JHEP, 10:244, 2019

[53] ATLAS Collaboration. Search for new resonances in mass distributions of jet pairs using 139 fb−1 of pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV with the atlas detector. p. 3

Where the paper says it

We assume, however, that the couplings to top quarks are enhanced, so Z ′ mostly decays to top pairs. 1 Using the particle content for the three scenarios described above and assuming topphilic couplings we can write the following Lagrangians for the new fields: LScalar = ¯χ i∂/ − 1 2 mχ χ + |DµφT | 2 − m2 φ|φT | 2 − yDM φ † T χ t ¯ R + h.

JHEP, 03:145, 2020

[54] CMS Collaboration. Search for high mass dijet resonances with a new background prediction method in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Differential distributions 11 4 Direct Search Constraints 14 5 Shape discrimination in the pT spectrum 17 5. 1 Statistical Method 18 5.

JHEP, 05:033, 2020

[55] ATLAS Collaboration. Search for tt¯ resonances in fully hadronic final states in pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV with the atlas detector. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The experimental program is now directly probing related structures, including heavy scalar and pseudoscalar states in tt¯ [31] and top-philic Z ′ bosons at √ s = 13. 6 TeV [32].

JHEP, 10:061, 2020

[56] G. Cowan. Statistical Data Analysis in Particle Physics. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Statistical Method 18 5. 2 Results 20 6 Conclusions 25 A One Loop Counterterms 28 1 Introduction The absence of unambiguous signals of new physics at the LHC has increased the importance of precision measurements as probes of physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM).

Oxford University Press, 1998

[57] R. J. Barlow. Statistics: A Guide to the Use of Statistical Methods in the Physical Sciences. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Differential distributions 11 4 Direct Search Constraints 14 5 Shape discrimination in the pT spectrum 17 5. 1 Statistical Method 18 5.

Wiley, 1989

[58] Glen Cowan, Kyle Cranmer, Eilam Gross, and Ofer Vitells. Asymptotic formulae for likelihood-based tests of new physics. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Testing the Spin of New Physics with Top Precision Measurements André Lessa a Vinícius Rocca a and Veronica Sanz b a Instituto de Física, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 05508-090 SP, Brazil b Instituto de Física Corpuscular (IFIC), Universidad de Valencia-CSIC, E-46980 Valencia, Spain E-mail: lessa@if. br, rocca@if.

Eur. Phys. J. C, 71:1554, 2011

[59] D. R. Cox. Tests of separate families of hypotheses. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The comparison is therefore not intended as a model-independent extraction of spin with all other physical properties held fixed. Rather, it tests whether representative – 2 –

1:105–123, 1961

[60] D. R. Cox. Further results on tests of separate families of hypotheses. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The comparison is therefore not intended as a model-independent extraction of spin with all other physical properties held fixed. Rather, it tests whether representative – 2 –

Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 24(2):406–424, 1962

[63] Andre Lessa, Vinicius Rocca, and Veronica Sanz. GitHub Repository v1.0. https://github.com/andlessa/UnfoldingBSMttbar/releases/tag/1.0, 2025

--- Page 34 ---

[64] P. Azzi et al. Report from Working Group 1: Standard Model Physics at the HL-LHC and HE-LHC. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Statistical Method 18 5. 2 Results 20 6 Conclusions 25 A One Loop Counterterms 28 1 Introduction The absence of unambiguous signals of new physics at the LHC has increased the importance of precision measurements as probes of physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM).

CERN Yellow Rep. Monogr., 7:1–220, 2019

--- Page 35 ---

[65] Celine Degrande, Jean-Marc Gerard, Christophe Grojean, Fabio Maltoni, and Geraldine Servant. Non-resonant New Physics in Top Pair Production at Hadron Colliders. p. 0

Where the paper says it

es Abstract: Precision measurements can reveal not only the presence of new physics, but also information about the dynamics that generated it. We study this question in top-pair production by comparing three top-philic scenarios: a colored scalar top partner, a colored vector-like fermion, and a spin-one Z ′ mediator.

JHEP, 03:125, 2011

[66] Celine Degrande et al. Top quark pair hadroproduction at next-to-next-leading order in QCD. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6]. Their interpretation is supported by fully differential QCD predictions at next-to-next-to-leading order [7, 8].

Phys. Rev. D, 99(5):051501, 2019

[67] Stefano Catani, Simone Devoto, Massimiliano Grazzini, Stefan Kallweit, Javier Mazzitelli, and Hayk Sargsyan. Top-quark pair production at the LHC: Fully differential QCD predictions at NNLO. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6]. Their interpretation is supported by fully differential QCD predictions at next-to-next-to-leading order [7, 8].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6]. Their interpretation is supported by fully differential QCD predictions at next-to-next-to-leading order [7, 8].

JHEP, 07:100, 2019

[68] Stefano Catani et al. Top-quark pair production at the LHC: Fully differential QCD predictions at NNLO. JHEP, 07:100, 2019

--- Page 35 ---

[69] Peter Meade and Matthew Reece. Top partners at the LHC: Spin and mass measurement. p. 1

Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

Phys. Rev. D, 74:015010, 2006

[73] Lian-Tao Wang and Itay Yavin. A Review of Spin Determination at the LHC. p. 1

Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the large Run 2 and Run 3 samples and the luminosity expected at the HighLuminosity LHC (HL-LHC) turn differential top measurements into precision observables over a wide range of energies [1]. Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6].

Int. J. Mod. Phys. A, 23:4647–4668, 2008

[75] Radja Boughezal and Markus Schulze. tt+large missing energy from top-quark partners: A comprehensive study at next-to-leading order QCD. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6]. Their interpretation is supported by fully differential QCD predictions at next-to-next-to-leading order [7, 8].

Phys. Rev. D, 88(11):114002, 2013

[77] CMS Collaboration. Combined searches for the production of supersymmetric top quark partners in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 tev. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Most spin studies exploit on-shell production, decay-angle correlations, endpoints, or production rates [20, 21]. For top partners followed by invisible particles, direct tt¯+Emiss T searches and their kinematic distributions likewise carry information about both the spectrum and the spin assignment [22].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

Most spin studies exploit on-shell production, decay-angle correlations, endpoints, or production rates [20, 21]. For top partners followed by invisible particles, direct tt¯+Emiss T searches and their kinematic distributions likewise carry information about both the spectrum and the spin assignment [22].

Eur. Phys. J. C, 81:970, 2021

[78] Daniel Abercrombie et al. Dark Matter benchmark models for early LHC Run-2 Searches: Report of the ATLAS/CMS Dark Matter Forum. p. 4

Where the paper says it

In contrast, in the framework considered here yDM is treated as a free parameter and can take values as large as allowed by perturbativity, yDM ≲ 4π. The Z ′ model can also accommodate a Dark Matter candidate and is a standard benchmark for resonance and dark matter searches at the LHC, as extensively discussed in the literature [24, 33–36].

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In contrast, in the framework considered here yDM is treated as a free parameter and can take values as large as allowed by perturbativity, yDM ≲ 4π. The Z ′ model can also accommodate a Dark Matter candidate and is a standard benchmark for resonance and dark matter searches at the LHC, as extensively discussed in the literature [24, 33–36].

Phys. Dark Univ., 27:100371, 2020

--- Page 35 ---

[69] Peter Meade and Matthew Reece. Top partners at the LHC: Spin and mass measurement. Phys. Rev. D, 74:015010, 206

[73] Lian-Tao Wang and Itay Yavin. A Review of Spin Determination at the LHC. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A, 23:4647–4668, 2008

[75] Radja Boughezal and Markus Schulze. tt+large missing energy from top-quark partners: A comprehensive study at next-leading order QCD. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6]. Their interpretation is supported by fully differential QCD predictions at next-to-next-to-leading order [7, 8].

Phys. Rev. D, 88(11):114002, 2013

[77] CMS Collaboration. Combined searches for the production of supersymmetric top quark partners in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 tev. Eur. Phys. J. C, 81:970, 2021

[78] Daniel Abercrombie et al. Dark Matter benchmark models for early LHC Run-2 Searches: Report of the ATLAS/CMS Dark Matter Forum. Phys. Dark Univ., 27:100371

--- Page 35 ---

[69] Peter Meade and Matthew Reece. Top partners at the LHC: Spin and mass measurement. Phys. Rev. D, 74:015010, 26

[73] Lian-Tao Wang and Itay Yavin. A Review of Spin Determination at the LHC. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A, 23:4647–4668

[75] Radja Boughezal and Markus Schulze. tt+large missing energy from top-quark partners: A comprehensive study at next-leading order QCD, Phys. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6]. Their interpretation is supported by fully differential QCD predictions at next-to-next-to-leading order [7, 8].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Measurements of tt¯ production now resolve the invariant mass, transverse momentum, rapidity, and additional-radiation dependence in several decay channels [2–5] as well as the tt¯ spin correlation [6]. Their interpretation is supported by fully differential QCD predictions at next-to-next-to-leading order [7, 8].

Rev. D, 88(11):114002, 2013

--- Page 35 ---

[69] Peter Meade and Matthew Reece. Top partners at the LHC: Spin and mass measurement. Phys. Rev. D, 74:015010, 26

[73] Lian-Tao Wang and Itay Yavin. A Review of Spin Determination at the LHC. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A, 23:4647–4668

--- Page 35 ---

[75] Radja Boughezal and Markus Schulze. tt+large missing energy from top-quark partners: A comprehensive study at next-leading order QCD, Phys. Rev. D, 88(11):114002, 2013

--- Page 35 ---

[69] Peter Meade and Matthew Reece. Top partners at the LHC: Spin and mass measurement. Phys. Rev. D, 74:015010, 26

[73] Lian-Tao Wang and Itay Yavin. A Review of Spin Determination at the LHC. Int. J. Mod. Phys.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can perform shape discrimination in top-pair production by comparing three top-philic scenarios—a colored scalar top partner, a colored vector-like fermion, and a spin-one Z prime mediator—by analyzing momentum dependent interference patterns in the top transverse momentum spectrum.

  2. The improved system can distinguish between the Scalar and Vector-like Fermion hypotheses by identifying that their different analytic structures leave measurable information in the shape of the distribution, even when they match onto the same effective operator structure at low energies.

  3. The system can quantify discrimination power for various integrated luminosities, predicting that the narrow Z prime hypothesis can be excluded with a significance of approximately 4.8 sigma at 500 fb-1 and exceeding the 5 sigma level at 3 ab-1 for both the narrow and broad scenarios.

  4. The system can assess discrimination between spin hypotheses by performing binned likelihood analyses on top transverse momentum spectra, noting that the VLF hypothesis provides a relatively good description of the Scalar distribution in the region carrying the largest statistical weight.

  5. The improved AI can identify that the distinction between a Z prime-like contribution and the loop-induced scenarios is comparatively robust, emphasizing that a propagating resonance and its associated interference pattern are difficult to reproduce by changing the parameters of the spin-0 or spin-1/2 models.

Abstract

Precision measurements can reveal not only the presence of new physics, but also information about the dynamics that generated it. We study this question in top-pair production by comparing three top-philic scenarios: a colored scalar top partner, a colored vector-like fermion, and a spin-one Z mediator. The first two contribute through loop corrections, while the Z contributes at tree level. We show that the scalar and vector-like fermion scenarios match onto the same effective operator structure at low energies,making their distinction unfeasible using the EFT approach. However, near or above threshold their full loop amplitudes develop distinct momentum-dependent interference patterns. Using the top transverse momentum spectrum we find that resonant and loop-induced effects are relatively easy to distinguish, whereas separating the scalar and vector-like hypotheses is substantially more challenging. Nevertheless, their different analytic structures leave measurable information in the shape of the distribution. These results illustrate how precision differential measurements can probe the spin and dynamics of virtual new states even when they are not directly reconstructed, and motivate more powerful multidimensional analyses.

Related papers