A Central Limit Theorem For Random Variables Under A Constraint
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.
Ada: We're looking at the paper: "A Central Limit Theorem For Random Variables Under A Constraint".
Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. A Central Limit Theorem For Random Variables Under A Constraint shows that under mild assumptions as n → ∞, any weighted sum of the random coordinates is asymptotically Gaussian, provided that no weight dominates <ref:2611.08446#pg6>.
Ada: The paper studies sequences of random variables under explicit dependencies introduced by a geometrical constraint.
Emmy: This constraint is given by the equation Xn j=1 Vj (Xj) = an.
Ada: The motivation is to develop an approach that does not require homogeneity, symmetry, or identically distributed coordinates.
Paper summary: Emmy: So we've been talking about this paper, "A Central Limit Theorem For Random Variables Under A Constraint," which essentially states that under mild assumptions as n goes to infinity, any weighted sum of random coordinates on these hypersurfaces will be asymptotically Gaussian when no single weight dominates.
Ada: And what I find important is how they use the soft constraint model to smoothly bridge the gap between the unconstrained case and the hard constrained case, which lets them compare different statistical ensembles directly.
Kolya: From a probabilistic standpoint, it’s significant because they provide a way to quantify how much that constraint actually reduces the variance compared to when you don't have any constraint at all, which is something we need when dealing with real-world data where structure often imposes limitations.
Emmy: And the paper’s title suggests a focus on the central limit theorem specifically under these constraints, showing that this asymptotic normality holds for projections in directions where no weight dominates.
Ada: It really shows that you don't need homogeneity or symmetry for these results to hold; you can have very general surfaces defined by different functions V(n) j and still get the CLT result.
Kolya: So, the implication is that we can apply central limit theorems to much more diverse geometric settings than we used to think possible, as long as we respect those mild assumptions about curvature of the surface.
Emmy: And it’s a neat way to connect concepts like microcanonical and canonical measures by showing how their variances are related through that Schur complement term.
Ada: It’s a solid piece of work because it takes the classical CLT and puts it into a context where you can analyze complex dependencies without needing everything to be perfectly i.i.d.
Kolya: The authors also pointed out that they use an explicit representation of the characteristic function in terms of independent variables from P n, beta, which is a powerful tool for proving convergence to the normal distribution using the Lindeberg Feller CLT, provided you have those necessary decay rates from those auxiliary lemmas.
Emmy: So, we've seen how these ideas about geometric measure theory and probability can work together to establish asymptotic normality under constraints in high dimensions.
Conclusion: Ada: So, we're wrapping up our discussion on "A Central Limit Theorem For Random Variables Under A Constraint." This paper shows how you can get that normal distribution result even when you have a geometric constraint on your random variables.
Emmy: I think the title is pretty direct. It’s about taking a set of random coordinates and seeing what happens to their sums when they are forced onto a specific shape, like a surface defined by some function V.
Kolya: The authors are tackling this by looking at how different statistical ensembles behave under that constraint. They compare the unconstrained case with the constrained case using an interpolation method.
Ada: It’s interesting because they aren't just looking for one single answer. They show how these two different ways of measuring things—the microcanonical and canonical measures—are connected through a variance term, which is that Schur complement.
Emmy: That connection implies that you can use the structure from the unconstrained case to understand the constrained one, as long as you track that specific quantity correctly.
Kolya: The big takeaway for me is how they prove this convergence using independent random variables from a different distribution. That technique lets them apply standard central limit theorems, like Lindeberg Feller, even when things are complicated.
Ada: So the core implication is that this CLT result holds under mild assumptions as n goes to infinity, provided no single weight in your sum dominates the whole thing.
Emmy: It suggests a lot about how geometry and probability interact in high dimensions when you're dealing with constrained systems.
Kolya: And it opens the door for applying these types of limit theorems to a wider variety of random variables, not just the standard ones we usually work with.
JACK CROMWELL, MARTIN VENKER
math.PR
Submitted: 2026-11-05
Updated: 2026-11-05
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
Importance score: 77/100
The gist: A Central Limit Theorem For Random Variables Under A Constraint shows that under mild assumptions as n → ∞, any weighted sum of the random coordinates is asymptotically Gaussian…
Key concepts
- Microcanonical Measure
- This is a specific probability measure defined on the constraint surface $S_{a,V}$. It is constructed by scaling the standard volume measure of a thin shell as its thickness approaches zero. This measure is natural for analyzing systems constrained to a specific geometric shape.
- Soft Constraint Model ($P_{n,SC}$)
- This model interpolates between an unconstrained system and a hard constraint. It uses an exponential term involving the potential $V(X_j)$ and the scaling factor $rac{1}{etaar{n}}$ to smoothly transition between different statistical regimes.
- Asymptotic Gaussianity
- This means that when you take weighted sums of the random coordinates in certain directions, their distribution approaches a normal (Gaussian) distribution as the number of variables ($n$) becomes very large. This is the core result showing convergence to normality under the given constraints.
Terminology
Summary
A Central Limit Theorem For Random Variables Under A Constraint shows that under mild assumptions as n → ∞, any weighted sum of the random coordinates is asymptotically Gaussian, provided that no weight dominates <ref:2611. p. 0 These in general asymmetric surfaces generalize classical spheres and include unbounded and disconnected surfaces. We show
that under mild assumptions as n → ∞, any weighted sum of the random coordinates
is asymptotically Gaussian, provided that no weight dominates.Where the paper says it
Introduction to the Problem
The paper studies sequences of random variables under explicit dependencies introduced by a geometrical constraint. This constraint is given by the equation Xn j=1 Vj (Xj) = an. p. 6 The next theorem deals with the soft constraint case. Let Assumptions 1 and 2 hold, let γ > 0 be fixed and let for each n,
λ = λ
(n) ∈ R
n
be given such that (1. is to develop an approach that does not require homogeneity, symmetry, or identically
distributed coordinates. Allowing the Vj to differ with j, and even change with n, leads to a wide variety
of hypersurfaces. The standard simplex, obtained
for Vj (x) := x on [0, ∞), lies at the boundary of our framework and is excluded by our
curvature requirements, however, for this case we point the reader to [13] where random
vectors under several linear constraints are studied. To make our setup precise, let for each n ≥ 1 continuous functions V
(n)
1
, .Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Measure Definition and Setup
The paper equips Sa,V with the so-called microcanonical measure dµSa,V (x):= 1/∥∇V (x)∥ dHn−1(x). This measure is natural when disintegrating via level sets and is obtained by scaling the n-dimensional Lebesgue measure of a thin shell as ε → 0. p. 2 Another instructive view on the difference of Hn−1 and µSa,V is looking at how they
derive from the Lebesgue measure in ambient space. The microcanonical measure is
obtained from scaling the n-dimensional Lebesgue measure of the thin shell {x ∈ R
n
:
an − ε ≤
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) ≤ an + ε} as ε → 0. Let now measurable functions fj = f
(n)
j
: R → [0, ∞) be given and define
dPn(x) := 1
Zn
Yn
j=1
fj (xj )dµSa,V (x), Zn := Z
Sa,V
Yn
j=1
fj (xj )dµSa,V (x). 5)
Pn is a probability measure on Sa,V , where Zn is its normalizing constant.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Constraint Modeling and Ensembles
The paper introduces a soft constraint model Pn,SC(x) with density Pn,SC(x):= 1/Zn,SC e−γ/√1n Pn j=1 Vj (xj)−a/√n2 Yn j=1 fj (xj). This interpolates between the unconstrained case γ = 0 and the hard constraint obtained for γ → ∞. p. 3 2), the strength of this penalization depending on the
value of γ. It formally interpolates between the unconstrained case γ = 0 and the hard
constraint obtained for γ → ∞ (Proposition 2. To define this measure, Sa,V must be starshaped, which is in general not the case. Where it is defined, it has a density proportional
to
⟨x, ∇V (x)⟩
∥∇V (x)∥
dHn−1
(x).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Main Results and Theorems
The main results are presented in Theorem 1.4 for the hard constraint and Theorem 1. p. 0 A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}. unbounded random variables to be bounded. 2) might be understood as a hard constraint, we will also consider a model
representing a soft constraint, under which deviations of Pn
j=1 Vj (Xj ) from an are possible
but penalized. 4 shows that any projection of the centered random element from the
high-dimensional Sa,V onto the real line in directions λ with (1. 11) is asymptotically Gaussian. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. Introduction and Statement of Main Results
The central limit theorem (CLT) is generally regarded as one of the most important
results in probability theory. A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}. We see that under Pn the variance is reduced by a regression term that captures how much of the linear statistic Pn
j=1 λjXj
is explained by the constraint
Pn
j=1 Vj (Xj ) = an. The constrained variance σ
2
n
in the hard constraint case
is the Schur complement of Pn
j=1 Varn,β(Vj (Xj )) in the covariance matrix of
(
Pn
j=1 Vj (Xj ),
Pn
j=1 λjXj ), see the proof of Lemma 3.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Key Technical Tools
The proof relies on a representation formula for Pn in terms of independent random variables under a different distribution Pn,β. This allows the use of the Lindeberg Feller CLT to show convergence to a normal distribution. p. 0 1)
in distribution as n → ∞, where Z is a random variable with a standard normal distribution. While it is standard to extend this classical CLT to independent but non-identically
distributed random variables, extending to dependent random variables generally depends
on the type of dependence. Assumption 1. 3 is designed to provide that decay at the rate |r|
−1/p by means of
the van der Corput lemma, see Lemma 2. Similarly, in the soft constraint case, (1. 9)
ensures the existence of a β ≥ β0 satisfying the modified constraint En,β Pn
j=1 Vj (Xj )
=
(a + β/(2γ)) n. We also study a model
with penalization of deviations from the constraint, interpolating between the unconstrained and the constrained case. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Examples and Scope
The paper illustrates the scope of the model through several examples, including mixed exponents spheres, double well potentials, and unbounded surfaces. These examples demonstrate the model's ability to generalize lp-spheres, include disconnected supports, and handle n-dependence. The results hold for every direction λ with λmax → 0. p. 6 From this point
of view we study the high-dimensional Sa,V by looking at one-dimensional projections. Our main results below will in particular show that these projections behave similarly as
n → ∞ for every direction λ in which no single weight dominates.Where the paper says it
Conclusion
The work provides a conditional central limit theorem for random variables under a constraint, establishing asymptotic normality for projections in directions where no single weight dominates. The results are significant because they extend classical CLT to non-identically distributed coordinates and explicitly quantify the difference between microcanonical and canonical ensembles through the interpolation variance. p. 0 1)
in distribution as n → ∞, where Z is a random variable with a standard normal distribution. While it is standard to extend this classical CLT to independent but non-identically
distributed random variables, extending to dependent random variables generally depends
on the type of dependence.Where the paper says it
References
[1] R. Adamczak, P. Pivovarov, and P. Simanjuntak. “Limit theorems for the volumes of small codimensional random sections of l n p-balls”. p. 0 This is usually achieved by
explicit representations of distributions on these balls or spheres obtained by normalizing
a vector of i. d random variables. This is usually achieved by
explicit representations of distributions on these balls or spheres obtained by normalizing
a vector of i. d random variables. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. Introduction and Statement of Main Results
The central limit theorem (CLT) is generally regarded as one of the most important
results in probability theory. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. Introduction and Statement of Main Results
The central limit theorem (CLT) is generally regarded as one of the most important
results in probability theory.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[2] G. Akemann, M. Cikovic, and M. Venker. “Universality at weak and strong nonHermiticity beyond the elliptic Ginibre ensemble”. p. 3 7)
where β ≥ 0 such that the normalizing constant Zn,β is finite. In the spirit of classical
statistical mechanics,
P
Pn corresponds to a microcanonical ensemble of fixed “energy”
n
j=1 Vj (xj ), whereas Pn,β corresponds to a canonical ensemble at inverse temperature β.Where the paper says it
[3] A. Baci, Z. Kabluchko, J. Prochno, M. Sonnleitner, and C. Th¨ale. “Limit theorems for random points in a simplex”. p. 0 A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}. A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[4] F. Barthe, O. Gu´edon, S. Mendelson, and A. Naor. “A probabilistic approach to the geometry of the l n p-ball”. p. 5 1
become significantly stronger and we can no longer utilize fj (x) := 1. With our analytic setup in place, we move to two more assumptions of a more probabilistic nature.Where the paper says it
[5] F. Barthe and P. Wolff. “Volume properties of high-dimensional Orlicz balls”. p. 0 A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}. A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[6] M. S. Bartlett. “The characteristic function of a conditional statistic”. p. 0 We also study a model
with penalization of deviations from the constraint, interpolating between the unconstrained and the constrained case. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. We also study a model
with penalization of deviations from the constraint, interpolating between the unconstrained and the constrained case. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. 1
arXiv:2611. 08446v1 [math.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[7] S. G. Bobkov. “On concentration of distributions of random weighted sums”. p. 0 These in general asymmetric surfaces generalize classical spheres and include unbounded and disconnected surfaces. We show
that under mild assumptions as n → ∞, any weighted sum of the random coordinates
is asymptotically Gaussian, provided that no weight dominates. These in general asymmetric surfaces generalize classical spheres and include unbounded and disconnected surfaces. We show
that under mild assumptions as n → ∞, any weighted sum of the random coordinates
is asymptotically Gaussian, provided that no weight dominates.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[8] N. Cancrini and S. Olla. “Ensemble dependence of fluctuations: canonical microcanonical equivalence of ensembles”. p. 3 Expectations of local quantities are classically expected to agree between the two ensembles as n → ∞ by equivalence of ensembles. However, this equivalence does not extend
to fluctuations, indeed our results rigorously quantify this difference. Expectations of local quantities are classically expected to agree between the two ensembles as n → ∞ by equivalence of ensembles. However, this equivalence does not extend
to fluctuations, indeed our results rigorously quantify this difference.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[9] M. S. S. Challa and J. H. Hetherington. “Gaussian Ensemble as an Interpolating Ensemble”. p. 3 In the spirit of classical
statistical mechanics,
P
Pn corresponds to a microcanonical ensemble of fixed “energy”
n
j=1 Vj (xj ), whereas Pn,β corresponds to a canonical ensemble at inverse temperature β. Pn,SC corresponds to an interpolating ensemble, it has in fact been considered as such in
the statistical mechanics literature before, see [9], and [2] for an application in random
matrix theory. In the spirit of classical
statistical mechanics,
P
Pn corresponds to a microcanonical ensemble of fixed “energy”
n
j=1 Vj (xj ), whereas Pn,β corresponds to a canonical ensemble at inverse temperature β. Pn,SC corresponds to an interpolating ensemble, it has in fact been considered as such in
the statistical mechanics literature before, see [9], and [2] for an application in random
matrix theory.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[10] P. Diaconis and D. Freedman. “A dozen de Finetti-style results in search of a theory”. p. 0 Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. Introduction and Statement of Main Results
The central limit theorem (CLT) is generally regarded as one of the most important
results in probability theory. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. Introduction and Statement of Main Results
The central limit theorem (CLT) is generally regarded as one of the most important
results in probability theory.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[11] H. Federer. Geometric measure theory. p. 1 There are at least three different measures
that have been considered in the literature as measures for surfaces like Sa,V , the Hausdorff
or surface measure Hn−1
, the microcanonical measure µSa,V , and the cone measure. While the Hausdorff measure might seem the most natural from a geometric point of
view, the co-area formula from geometric measure theory ([11, Theorem 3. Assumption 1. 3 is designed to provide that decay at the rate |r|
−1/p by means of
the van der Corput lemma, see Lemma 2. Assumption 1. 3 can be relaxed to allow for weaker or changing types
of decay; this would however lengthen the technical parts of this paper significantly
and obstruct the main new ideas. Assumption 1. 3 can be relaxed to allow for weaker or changing types
of decay; this would however lengthen the technical parts of this paper significantly
and obstruct the main new ideas.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[12] F. Gamboa, T. Klein, and C. Prieur. “Conditional large and moderate deviations for sums of discrete random variables. p. 2 We assume here
that Zn > 0, finiteness of Zn for large n will follow from Proposition 2. The reader
might want to think of the probability measure Pn as realizing random variables Xj with
densities proportional to fj but subject to the constraint (1.Where the paper says it
[13] F. Gamboa and M. Venker. Limit Theorems Under Several Linear Constraints. p. 1 Our assumptions on the Vj will be very general and mild,
generally relying on a small bit of curvature of Sa,V . The standard simplex, obtained
for Vj (x) := x on [0, ∞), lies at the boundary of our framework and is excluded by our
curvature requirements, however, for this case we point the reader to [13] where random
vectors under several linear constraints are studied.Where the paper says it
[14] N. Gantert, S. S. Kim, and K. Ramanan. “Large deviations for random projections of l p balls”. p. 0 This is usually achieved by
explicit representations of distributions on these balls or spheres obtained by normalizing
a vector of i. d random variables.Where the paper says it
[15] L. Holst. “Two conditional limit theorems with applications”. p. 3 However, this equivalence does not extend
to fluctuations, indeed our results rigorously quantify this difference. Our approach will
link the two ensembles directly for every finite n, not just in the limit.Where the paper says it
[16] S. Janson. “Moment convergence in conditional limit theorems”. p. 1 4) establishes the microcanonical measure µSa,V as the natural measure when
disintegrating via level sets. In particular, if X has a density g, then the conditional
2Where the paper says it
[17] Z. Kabluchko and J. Prochno. “The maximum entropy principle and volumetric properties of Orlicz balls”. p. 6 Our first result deals with the hard constraint. To state it, we recall that ∥ · ∥2 denotes
the Euclidean norm, and we denote by ∥· ∥max the maximum norm. While it is standard to extend this classical CLT to independent but non-identically
distributed random variables, extending to dependent random variables generally depends
on the type of dependence. In this paper we study sequences of random variables under explicit dependencies
introduced by the geometrical constraint
Xn
j=1
Vj (Xj ) = an (1.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[18] Z. Kabluchko, J. Prochno, and M. Sonnleitner. “A probabilistic approach to Lorentz balls l n q,1”. p. 0 More
generally, Vj (xj ) := |xj
|
p
for 0 < p < ∞ gives the lp-spheres. Much work has been done on
lp-spheres, balls and related spaces as we will outline below. It formally interpolates between the unconstrained case γ = 0 and the hard
constraint obtained for γ → ∞ (Proposition 2. As the analysis of Pn,SC is similar to
the one of Pn, and in fact the analysis of the hard constraint case Pn proceeds via the
soft constraint case Pn,SC, we will treat both cases in parallel.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[19] Z. Kabluchko, J. Prochno, and C. Th¨ale. “Sanov-type large deviations in Schatten classes”. p. 0 1)
in distribution as n → ∞, where Z is a random variable with a standard normal distribution. While it is standard to extend this classical CLT to independent but non-identically
distributed random variables, extending to dependent random variables generally depends
on the type of dependence.Where the paper says it
[20] B. Klartag. “A central limit theorem for convex sets”. p. 0 A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}.Where the paper says it
[21] B. Klartag. “Power-law estimates for the central limit theorem for convex sets”. p. 0 A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}.Where the paper says it
[22] B. Klartag. “A Berry-Esseen type inequality for convex bodies with an unconditional basis”. p. 0 1)
in distribution as n → ∞, where Z is a random variable with a standard normal distribution. While it is standard to extend this classical CLT to independent but non-identically
distributed random variables, extending to dependent random variables generally depends
on the type of dependence. More
generally, Vj (xj ) := |xj
|
p
for 0 < p < ∞ gives the lp-spheres. Much work has been done on
lp-spheres, balls and related spaces as we will outline below.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[23] J. L. Lebowitz, J. K. Percus, and L. Verlet. “Ensemble Dependence of Fluctuations with Application to Machine Computations”. p. 3 In the spirit of classical
statistical mechanics,
P
Pn corresponds to a microcanonical ensemble of fixed “energy”
n
j=1 Vj (xj ), whereas Pn,β corresponds to a canonical ensemble at inverse temperature β. Pn,SC corresponds to an interpolating ensemble, it has in fact been considered as such in
the statistical mechanics literature before, see [9], and [2] for an application in random
matrix theory.Where the paper says it
[24] E. Lukacs. Characteristic functions. p. 3 Proposition 2. 2
below expresses the characteristic functions of Pn and Pn,SC exactly in terms of Pn,β, with
β chosen such that the constraint holds in expectation under Pn,β. Assumption 1. 3 can be relaxed to allow for weaker or changing types
of decay; this would however lengthen the technical parts of this paper significantly
and obstruct the main new ideas. Assumption 1. 3 can be relaxed to allow for weaker or changing types
of decay; this would however lengthen the technical parts of this paper significantly
and obstruct the main new ideas.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[25] E. Meckes. “Approximation of projections of random vectors”. p. 6 10) is the scalar projection of the centered random vector onto λ. From this point
of view we study the high-dimensional Sa,V by looking at one-dimensional projections.Where the paper says it
[26] M. W. Meckes. “Gaussian marginals of convex bodies with symmetries”. p. 0 These in general asymmetric surfaces generalize classical spheres and include unbounded and disconnected surfaces. We show
that under mild assumptions as n → ∞, any weighted sum of the random coordinates
is asymptotically Gaussian, provided that no weight dominates.Where the paper says it
[27] A. Naor. “The surface measure and cone measure on the sphere of l n p”. p. 1 1 (On different measures on Sa,V ). There are at least three different measures
that have been considered in the literature as measures for surfaces like Sa,V , the Hausdorff
or surface measure Hn−1
, the microcanonical measure µSa,V , and the cone measure.Where the paper says it
[28] A. Naor and D. Romik. “Projecting the surface measure of the sphere of l n p”. p. 1 1 (On different measures on Sa,V ). There are at least three different measures
that have been considered in the literature as measures for surfaces like Sa,V , the Hausdorff
or surface measure Hn−1
, the microcanonical measure µSa,V , and the cone measure.Where the paper says it
[29] G. Paouris, P. Pivovarov, and J. Zinn. “A central limit theorem for projections of the cube”. p. 0 A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}. A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. Introduction and Statement of Main Results
The central limit theorem (CLT) is generally regarded as one of the most important
results in probability theory. Our approach involves an explicit representation of
the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent
random variables. Introduction and Statement of Main Results
The central limit theorem (CLT) is generally regarded as one of the most important
results in probability theory.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[30] J. Prochno, C. Thaele, and P. Tuchel. “Limit Theorems for the Volume of Random Projections and Sections of l N p-balls”. p. 0 This is usually achieved by
explicit representations of distributions on these balls or spheres obtained by normalizing
a vector of i. d random variables. This is usually achieved by
explicit representations of distributions on these balls or spheres obtained by normalizing
a vector of i. d random variables. A main motivation of this paper
Date: November 6, 2026. 1
arXiv:2611. A main motivation of this paper
Date: November 6, 2026. 1
arXiv:2611.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[31] J. Prochno, C. Th¨ale, and N. Turchi. “Geometry of l n p-balls: Classical results and recent developments”. p. 5 , Xn) has the distribution Pn,β. As with a classical CLT we make moment assumptions to ensure validity of
our results. A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[32] G. Schechtman and J. Zinn. “On the volume of the intersection of two L n p balls”. p. 0 More
generally, Vj (xj ) := |xj
|
p
for 0 < p < ∞ gives the lp-spheres. Much work has been done on
lp-spheres, balls and related spaces as we will outline below.Where the paper says it
[33] G. P. Steck. “Limit theorems for conditional distributions”. p. 0 Much work has been done on
lp-spheres, balls and related spaces as we will outline below. This is usually achieved by
explicit representations of distributions on these balls or spheres obtained by normalizing
a vector of i.Where the paper says it
[34] E. M. Stein, Harmonic analysis: real-variable methods, orthogonality, and oscillatory integrals. p. 0 ) real-valued random variables with common mean µ ∈ R and finite variance σ
2 > 0 we have
1
√
σ
2n
Xn
j=1
(Xj − µ) → Z (1. 1)
in distribution as n → ∞, where Z is a random variable with a standard normal distribution. It formally interpolates between the unconstrained case γ = 0 and the hard
constraint obtained for γ → ∞ (Proposition 2. As the analysis of Pn,SC is similar to
the one of Pn, and in fact the analysis of the hard constraint case Pn proceeds via the
soft constraint case Pn,SC, we will treat both cases in parallel.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[35] V. N. Sudakov. “Typical distributions of linear functionals in finite-dimensional spaces of high dimension”. p. 0 Much work has been done on
lp-spheres, balls and related spaces as we will outline below. This is usually achieved by
explicit representations of distributions on these balls or spheres obtained by normalizing
a vector of i.Where the paper says it
[36] H. von Weizs¨acker. “Sudakov’s typical marginals, random linear functionals and a conditional central limit theorem”. p. 0 A CENTRAL LIMIT THEOREM FOR RANDOM VARIABLES UNDER
A CONSTRAINT
JACK CROMWELL AND MARTIN VENKER
Abstract. We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces
of the form {x ∈ R
n :
Pn
j=1 Vj (xj ) = an}. More
generally, Vj (xj ) := |xj
|
p
for 0 < p < ∞ gives the lp-spheres. Much work has been done on
lp-spheres, balls and related spaces as we will outline below.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[37] R. Adamczak, P. Pivovarov, and P. Simanjuntak. “Limit theorems for the volumes of small codimensional random sections of l n p-balls”. In: The Annals of Probability 52.1 (2024), pp. 93–126.
[38] A. Baci, Z. Kabluchko, J. Prochno, M. Sonnleitner, and C. Th¨ale. “Limit theorems for random points in a simplex”. In: J Appl Probab 59.3 (2022), pp. 685–701.
[39] G. Paouris, P. Pivovarov, and J. Zinn. “A central limit theorem for projections of the cube”. In: Probability Theory and Related Fields 159.3 (2014), pp. 701–719.
[40] J. Prochno, C. Thaele, and P. Tuchel. “Limit Theorems for the Volume of Random Projections and Sections of l N p-balls”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2412.16054 (2024), pp. 121–150.
[43] E. Lukacs, Characteristic functions. p. 3 Proposition 2. 2
below expresses the characteristic functions of Pn and Pn,SC exactly in terms of Pn,β, with
β chosen such that the constraint holds in expectation under Pn,β.Where the paper says it
[46] M. S. Bartlett. “The characteristic function of a conditional statistic”. In: J London Math Soc 13. p. 0 1
arXiv:2611. 08446v1 [math.Where the paper says it
[47] S. G. Bobkov. “On concentration of distributions of random weighted sums”. In: Ann. Probab. 31.1 (2003), pp. 195–215.
[48] N. Cancrini and S. Olla. “Ensemble dependence of fluctuations: canonical microcanonical equivalence of ensembles”. In: J Stat. Phys. 168.4 (2017), pp. 707–730.
[49] M. S. S. Challa and J Hetherington. “Gaussian Ensemble as an Interpolating Ensemble”. In: Phys. Rev Lett 60 (2 Jan 1988), pp. 77–80.
[50] P. Diaconis and D. Freedman. “A dozen de Finetti-style results in search of a theory”. In: Annales de l’IHP Probabilit´es et statistiques 23.S2 (1987), pp.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced ability to analyze non-homogeneous geometric constraints by utilizing
explicit representation of the characteristic function of constrained random variables in terms of independent random variables,
which allows for a full-dimensional analysis through an auxiliary measure Pn,beta. -
Capability to rigorously quantify fluctuations by deriving the Schur complement as the residual variance term, which captures
how much of the linear statistic Pn j=1 λjXj is explained by the constraint.
-
Implementation of an interpolating ensemble analysis where a soft constraint model (Pn,SC) can be directly related to a hard constraint model (Pn) via the parameter gamma and its associated characteristic function structure.
-
Execution of conditional central limit theorems for non-identically distributed random variables under constraints, specifically by applying the Lindeberg Feller CLT in high dimensions with appropriate scaling factors derived from the constraint structure.
-
Quantitative estimation of variance bounds using Lemma 3.2, which provides a lower bound on the variance terms like sVj (Xj) + tλbjXj, ensuring that fluctuations are bounded away from zero and infinity under specified conditions.
-
Ability to perform asymptotic analysis of joint characteristic functions by utilizing Proposition 3.4 to obtain uniform asymptotic bounds for the joint characteristic function of Vj (Xj) and Xj under Pn,beta for all relevant parameter ranges.
Abstract
We consider vectors chosen randomly from high-dimensional hypersurfaces of the form x in R n: sum from j=1 to n V j(x j)=an. These in general asymmetric surfaces generalize classical spheres and include unbounded and disconnected surfaces. We show that under mild assumptions as n to infinity, any weighted sum of the random coordinates is asymptotically Gaussian, provided that no weight dominates. An explicit reduction in the variance compared to the unconstrained case is observed. We also study a model with penalization of deviations from the constraint, interpolating between the unconstrained and the constrained case. Our approach involves an explicit representation of the characteristic function of the constrained random variables in terms of independent random variables.
Sources
- Limit Theorems Under Several Linear Constraints
- Limit Theorems for the Volume of Random Projections and Sections of $\ell_p^N$-balls
Related papers
- Rank-One HCIZ Integrals and Multiplicative Convolutions
- Repeated averaging on random d-regular graphs
- Precise cover times for branching random walks on Hamming graphs: (iterated) logarithmic corrections
- Markov Chain CLTs: Resolving Open Problems
- Marked stable L'evy processes in Brownian local time
- A Sharp Refinement of Samuels' Inequality via Cap Moves