Investigating bottom quark effects in Higgs boson pair production

arXiv:2611.08183 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-11-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Investigating bottom quark effects in Higgs boson pair production".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Higgs boson pair production is investigated through different effects of bottom quark masses in Higgs boson pair production, considering both bottom quark loops and bottom quarks in the initial state While the effects are negligible at total cross section level, the situation is different for the Higgs boson pair invariant mass distribution close to the production threshold of the two Higgs bosons.

Kai: Effects of bottom quark loops in gluon fusion The investigation into bottom quark loops in gluon fusion considers both on-shell and MS schemes, as well as comparisons between four- and five-flavour schemes The largest effects of the bottom quarks will of course come from the top-bottom interference contribution.

Mira: The impact on the Higgs boson pair invariant mass distribution, dσ(pp→HH)dmHH, is shown to increase by approximately 6% when the bottom quark mass is renormalised in the MS scheme and a bin size of 25 GeV is used.

Kai: Conversely, if on-shell mass renormalization is used for the bottom quark, the differential cross section near the Higgs pair production threshold increases by approximately 12%.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Investigating bottom quark effects in Higgs boson pair production." The main idea here is checking how the mass of the bottom quark messes with di-Higgs production.

Mira: Right, it focuses on both the loops involving bottom quarks and also those where the bottom quarks are right there in the initial state. But they find that these effects are small for the total cross section, which is what you measure when you just count how many pairs of Higgs bosons happen per unit of energy.

Lev: That's interesting because for real hardware, we need to think about where these tiny corrections land when we try to measure them.

Kai: Exactly. The paper points out that the situation changes a lot if you look at the invariant mass distribution near the production threshold of the two Higgs bosons. This is where things get more pronounced than just looking at the total cross section.

Mira: And they look at this in detail, starting with bottom quark loops in gluon fusion, considering both on-shell and MS schemes, and even comparing four-flavor versus five-flavor schemes. They say the biggest effect comes from that top minus bottom interference contribution.

Lev: So if we were building a detector right now, knowing that the effect is small overall but big near the threshold tells us where to focus our precision efforts, right?

Kai: Precisely. For instance, when they use the MS scheme for renormalizing the bottom quark mass and a bin size of twenty five GeV, they see an increase of about six percent in how the differential cross section looks near that threshold.

Mira: If you switch to using the on-shell mass renormalization instead, that increase jumps up to about twelve percent near that threshold. That’s a significant difference depending on how you handle those masses.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, having such a big difference in how the correction scales with the scheme choice means our theoretical predictions need to be very careful about which mass definition we use for our simulations and what fidelity we expect from them.

Kai: Now they also looked at bottom quark annihilation as a channel at next-to-leading order, NLO QCD. They found that this contribution is really small for the total cross section, only about zero point zero three femtobarns for a one four teraelectronvolt center of mass energy.

Mira: But when you include it in the differential distribution calculation, they see relative corrections of up to eighteen percent compared to just looking at the leading order gluon fusion. That’s a big jump from leading order to next-to-leading order effects.

Lev: Eighteen percent is substantial if you have systematic uncertainties in your NLO calculations that you can't easily control, and it shows that even seemingly negligible channels can become important when looking at distributions rather than just total rates.

Kai: They also looked at how the different flavor number schemes work, comparing four flavors versus five flavors. They found that near the Higgs pair production threshold, the difference between those two schemes is less than one percent.

Mira: But as you increase the invariant mass of that Higgs pair, mHH, that difference starts to grow bigger between the four-flavor and five-flavor schemes. That tells us which scheme you pick depends on how far out in energy you are looking.

Lev: So for designing an experiment, if we plan to search at very high mHH values, we need to be aware that our theoretical background modeling will have a larger uncertainty due to that flavor scheme dependence.

Kai: The paper also explored how the order of alpha s running affects the mass conversion when you switch between mass renormalization schemes. They found this can be small, but it can hit about ten percent around half the Higgs pair invariant mass if you use both schemes for renormalizing both top and bottom quarks in the MS scheme.

Mira: It seems like even these subtle details about how we define our parameters matter a lot when you're trying to pin down those coupling measurements. The paper title, "Investigating bottom quark effects in Higgs boson pair production," really captures that focus on those specific quark masses.

Lev: I think the implication for us is that when we look at the di-Higgs cross section, we can’t just assume a single fixed value for the bottom quark mass; we have to account for these scheme and flavor effects depending on the kinematic region of our measurement.

Kai: So, to wrap up this segment, while the total cross section isn't strongly affected, the shape of that distribution right near the production threshold is sensitive to how we treat bottom quark masses and flavor schemes.

Mira: And this sensitivity depends on whether you are using an on-shell or MS scheme for those masses. Next time we look at how these effects change depending on the anomalous trilinear Higgs coupling, which is a bit more complex, and what that means for our ability to constrain the self-coupling of the Higgs boson.

Lev: We need to make sure our error budget accounts for this threshold sensitivity when we plan future searches.

Conclusion: Mira: So we’ve looked at how tweaking the bottom quark mass changes di-Higgs production, focusing on these loops and initial state effects.

Kai: That paper is called "Investigating bottom quark effects in Higgs boson pair production." It’s basically asking how much those bottom quarks actually matter in this process.

Mira: The authors show that while the total cross section isn't super sensitive, the shape of the distribution right near the threshold is where you see real changes depending on whether you use a specific mass definition.

Kai: They found that switching between different ways to define those quark masses—like using an on-shell mass versus an MS scheme—can change the correction by about twelve percent near that production threshold.

Mira: And they also looked at how different flavor schemes, like four flavors versus five flavors, affect things depending on how high the Higgs pair invariant mass is.

Kai: It seems like the authors are really digging into those small details to make sure we get the right picture when we try to measure these couplings later on.

Mira: The implication is that when we’re trying to figure out the properties of these Higgs bosons, we can't just assume a single bottom quark mass value across all measurements.

Kai: That means for any future experiment, you have to be super careful about which scheme you use and what kinematic region you are looking at when interpreting those results.

Mira: And that’s where we need to look next: how these bottom quark effects change depending on the anomalous trilinear Higgs coupling, which gets even more complicated.

David Bürg, Gudrun Heinrich, Philipp Rendler

Institute for Theoretical Physics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT)

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-05

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 25 pages, 9 figures, contribution to the Report 5 of the LHC Higgs Working Group

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Higgs boson pair production is investigated through different effects of bottom quark masses in Higgs boson pair production…

Key concepts

Bottom Quark Loops
These refer to quantum effects involving virtual bottom quarks in processes like gluon fusion. The study investigates these loops using different mass schemes (on-shell vs. MS) and flavor counting methods to see how they modify the distribution of the Higgs boson pair's invariant mass.
Bottom Quark Annihilation Channel
This is a specific process where two bottom quarks annihilate into Higgs bosons, calculated at next-to-leading order (NLO). Although this channel contributes little to the total cross section, including it at NLO QCD causes relative corrections of up to 18% in the invariant mass distribution compared to leading order calculations.
Invariant Mass Distribution (mHH)
This describes how the probability of producing a pair of Higgs bosons is distributed across different possible combined masses. The investigation focuses on how bottom quark effects change this distribution, particularly close to the kinematic threshold where production begins.
Flavor Number Schemes (4FS vs 5FS)
These are different theoretical frameworks used to count the number of quark flavors involved in calculations (four flavors vs. five flavors). The paper found that for bottom quarks, the results from both schemes are nearly identical near the threshold, suggesting this choice doesn't drastically change the observed effects.

Terminology

Summary

Higgs boson pair production is investigated through different effects of bottom quark masses in Higgs boson pair production, considering both bottom quark loops and bottom quarks in the initial state While the effects are negligible at total cross section level, the situation is different for the Higgs boson pair invariant mass distribution close to the production threshold of the two Higgs bosons. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract We investigate different effects of bottom quark masses in Higgs boson pair production, considering both bottom quark loops and bottom quarks in the initial state. While the effects are negligible at total cross section level, the situation is different for the Higgs boson pair invariant mass distribution close to the production threshold of the two Higgs bosons.

Effects of bottom quark loops in gluon fusion

The investigation into bottom quark loops in gluon fusion considers both on-shell and MS schemes, as well as comparisons between four- and five-flavour schemes The largest effects of the bottom quarks will of course come from the top-bottom interference contribution. The impact on the Higgs boson pair invariant mass distribution, dσ(pp→HH)dmHH, is shown to increase by approximately 6% when the bottom quark mass is renormalised in the MS scheme and a bin size of 25 GeV is used. p. 9

Where the paper says it

More precisely, the upper plot in Figure 2 shows this ratio for the top quark mass being renormalised in the on-shell scheme and the bottom quark mass being renormalised once in the on-shell and once in the MS scheme, while the lower plot in Figure 2 shows these ratios for the top quark mass being renormalised in the MS scheme. In both cases, regardless of whether the top quark mass is renormalised using the on-shell or the MS scheme, we obtain similar results: When the bottom quark mass is renormalised in the MS scheme and a bin size of 25 GeV is used, the differential cross section near the Higgs pair production threshold increases by approximately 6 %, taking massive bottom quark loops into account.

Conversely, if on-shell mass renormalization is used for the bottom quark, the differential cross section near the Higgs pair production threshold increases by approximately 12%. p. 9
Where the paper says it

More precisely, the upper plot in Figure 2 shows this ratio for the top quark mass being renormalised in the on-shell scheme and the bottom quark mass being renormalised once in the on-shell and once in the MS scheme, while the lower plot in Figure 2 shows these ratios for the top quark mass being renormalised in the MS scheme. In both cases, regardless of whether the top quark mass is renormalised using the on-shell or the MS scheme, we obtain similar results: When the bottom quark mass is renormalised in the MS scheme and a bin size of 25 GeV is used, the differential cross section near the Higgs pair production threshold increases by approximately 6 %, taking massive bottom quark loops into account.

Bottom quark annihilation channel

The contribution of bottom quark annihilation at next-to-leading order (NLO) QCD to the total cross section is on the order of O(0.03 fb) for a proton-proton centre-of-mass energy of 14 TeV, making its impact negligible compared to gluon fusion. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The contribution of this channel to the total cross section has been studied up to NNLO in Refs. For a proton-proton centre-of-mass energy of 14 TeV, the resulting total cross section was found to be of the order of O(0.

However, including this channel at NLO QCD results in relative corrections of up to +18% in the invariant mass distribution compared to LO gluon fusion. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we investigate the impact of bottom quark annihilation on differential distributions. We observe that including this channel at NLO QCD results in relative corrections of up to +18% in the invariant mass distribution compared to LO gluon fusion.

The inclusion of bottom quark annihilation at LO leads to an enhancement of up to 18% at low-mHH with respect to the LO gluon fusion, while the peak region and the tail of the mHH distribution are not affected. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 2, we investigate the effect of different scheme choices on the inclusion of bottom quarks at LO in gluon fusion. Section 3 is dedicated to Higgs boson pair production in bottom quark annihilation, before we conclude in Section 5.

Comparison of flavour number schemes

The results presented in Section 2.2.1 were calculated using the 4FS, and subsequent calculations in the 5FS show that the difference between both flavour number schemes is less than 1% near the Higgs pair production threshold but increases with increasing Higgs pair invariant mass mHH. p. 9

Where the paper says it

More precisely, the upper plot in Figure 2 shows this ratio for the top quark mass being renormalised in the on-shell scheme and the bottom quark mass being renormalised once in the on-shell and once in the MS scheme, while the lower plot in Figure 2 shows these ratios for the top quark mass being renormalised in the MS scheme. In both cases, regardless of whether the top quark mass is renormalised using the on-shell or the MS scheme, we obtain similar results: When the bottom quark mass is renormalised in the MS scheme and a bin size of 25 GeV is used, the differential cross section near the Higgs pair production threshold increases by approximately 6 %, taking massive bottom quark loops into account.

The effect of massive bottom quarks on the invariant mass distribution of Higgs boson pairs for different values of the anomalous trilinear Higgs coupling varies depending on whether the top quark mass is renormalised in the OS scheme and the bottom quark mass in the MS scheme. p. 9
Where the paper says it

1 Effect of massive bottom quarks The impact of massive bottom quarks on the Higgs boson pair invariant mass distribution, dσ(pp→HH) dmHH , is depicted in Figure 2, which shows the ratios of differential cross sections computed once with and once without massive bottom quark loops. More precisely, the upper plot in Figure 2 shows this ratio for the top quark mass being renormalised in the on-shell scheme and the bottom quark mass being renormalised once in the on-shell and once in the MS scheme, while the lower plot in Figure 2 shows these ratios for the top quark mass being renormalised in the MS scheme.

The flavour number scheme used is not decisive for the effects of massive bottom quarks investigated here, as both schemes show that they are almost identical. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(35) Therefore, when calculating the leading-order matrix element in the MS scheme, it is sufficient to use the leading-order matrix element from the on-shell scheme, replacing the on-shell mass with the MS mass. 2 Flavour schemes Since we are interested in the effects of massive bottom quarks on the differential leadingorder cross section of Higgs boson pair production via gluon fusion, we use the four-flavour scheme (4FS).

Sensitivity to coupling and scale variations

The effect of massive bottom quarks on the invariant mass distribution near the Higgs boson pair production threshold increases significantly as cHHH increases for values of the trilinear coupling in the vicinity of cHHH = 1. A different pattern emerges at larger values of the anomalous trilinear Higgs coupling, where massive bottom quarks in decrease the cross section near the Higgs boson pair production threshold compared to SM. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract We investigate different effects of bottom quark masses in Higgs boson pair production, considering both bottom quark loops and bottom quarks in the initial state. While the effects are negligible at total cross section level, the situation is different for the Higgs boson pair invariant mass distribution close to the production threshold of the two Higgs bosons.

Scale uncertainties can be artificially small when using µmt = µr, compared to a 21-point scale variation. p. 9
Where the paper says it

To compute these scale uncertainties, we use a 3-point scale variation for each mass renormalised in the MS scheme and a 7-point scale variation for the factorisation and renormalisation scales; i. we compute the differential cross section for all µmt ∈ mHH 2 {0.

The differences due to the order in αs that is used in the mass conversion are usually small, but can be of order 10% around mHH /2 ≃ mOS t if both the top- and the bottom quark are renormalised in the MS scheme. p. 2
Where the paper says it

SciPost Physics Community Reports Submission Figure 1: Example diagrams for Higgs boson pair production in gluon fusion, where we consider both top- and bottom quark loops. fore, we perform a detailed analysis of the effects of bottom quark loops in the on-shell and MS schemes, comparing also the four- and five-flavour schemes, and investigating the influence of the order of the αs -running when performing the mass conversion.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved calculation of differential cross section near threshold: The AI can now accurately calculate the effect of bottom quark annihilation on differential distributions, achieving a relative correction of up to +18% in the invariant mass distribution compared to LO gluon fusion by including this channel at NLO QCD.

  2. Enhanced sensitivity analysis for scale uncertainties: The system can perform detailed scale variations, such as a 7-point scale variation for the factorisation and renormalisation scales, allowing it to distinguish between different uncertainty estimates, noting that the upper plot in Figure 6 shows the scale uncertainties arising from the seven-point scale variation of the renormalisation and factorisation scales.

  3. Comprehensive scheme comparison: The AI can compare results across different mass renormalization schemes, such as the on-shell scheme or the MS scheme for the bottom quark mass, and analyze how this choice affects cross section increases, noting that When the bottom quark mass is renormalised in the MS scheme and a bin size of 25 GeV is used, the differential cross section near the Higgs pair production threshold increases by approximately 6 %.

  4. Flavour scheme independence assessment: The AI can determine if specific theoretical choices matter for heavy quarks, as it can conclude that the differences between both flavour number schemes are less than 1 % near the Higgs pair production threshold but increases with increasing Higgs pair invariant mass mHH, and that the bottom quark is almost identical in both flavour number schemes.

  5. Parametric sensitivity mapping: The AI can map the influence of external parameters, showing how the effect of massive bottom quarks on the invariant mass distribution of Higgs boson pairs varies for different values of the anomalous trilinear Higgs coupling, revealing a pronounced dip-peak structure near the top quark pair production threshold when cHHH is around 2.

  6. Higher order convergence assessment: The system can evaluate perturbative expansion orders, showing that the deviations in the low single-digit range shown in the upper plot of Figure 7 originate solely from the renormalisation group evolution of the MS mass of the bottom quark, and comparing this to results when expanded up to higher orders like O alpha 3s.

  7. Uncertainty reduction strategy: The AI can identify optimal scale setting strategies, noting that if the top mass renormalisation scale is not varied at all, i.e. µmt = mHH /2, the scale uncertainty is approximately constant, which suggests a way to obtain significantly lower uncertainties compared to a full 21-point variation in certain kinematic regions.

Abstract

We investigate different effects of bottom quark masses in Higgs boson pair production, considering both bottom quark loops and bottom quarks in the initial state. While the effects are negligible at total cross section level, the situation is different for the Higgs boson pair invariant mass distribution close to the production threshold of the two Higgs bosons.

Sources

Related papers