The Moving Frontier: How the National Justice Project Is Using Digital Technology to Expand Access to Justice
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.
Tom: We're looking at the paper: "The Moving Frontier".
Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Digital reporting platforms that transform individual experiences of harm into collective evidence equip civil society with the evidence needed to self-advocate and challenge institutional discrimination By using anonymised reporting, triage templates, and Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) architectures, platforms like Hear Me Out and Call It Out record experiences of discrimination that other institutions rarely seek to collect The aggregated data generated by the NJP’s platforms have directly informed parliamentary inquiries, supported annual analytical reports, and supplied data for royal commissions This article argues that direct-toconsumer digital reporting platforms, by transforming individual experiences of harm into collective evidence, equip civil society with the evidence needed to self-advocate and challenge institutional discrimination The Knowledge and Power Gap Individually reported experiences of discrimination, institutional misconduct, and administrative abuse are often dismissed by complaint bodies as isolated grievances Traditional legal oversight architectures often place the burden on affected individuals to identify a legal problem, find the institution with jurisdiction to address it, and engage with the formal reporting process without assistance For marginalised groups, this reliance on individual reporting creates a knowledge and power gap that, more broadly, prevents systemic patterns of harm less visible to legal institutions The NJP developed its technology projects as counterhegemonic infrastructure to address these limitations The Theory of Change The NJP’s theory of change operates through four interconnected pillars 1.
Tom: First, as an access to justice tool, plain-language digital interfaces scaffold user interactions, which enable individuals to identify potential rights violations and reporting processes, and to take action, without requiring formal legal representation 2.
Jane: Second, direct reporting functions as an act of rights advocacy, by allowing users to describe experiences in their own terms 3.
Tom: Third, aggregation operates as a form of data justice, by synthesising individual reports to reveal patterns of harm that may not be visible from individual complaints 4.
Paper summary: Jane: So, jumping into a summary of "The Moving Frontier: How the National Justice Project Is Using Digital Technology to Expand Access to Justice," the paper starts by noting that over three decades, technological advances have helped people access legal information and streamline dispute resolution.
Tom: But the key shift they highlight is that with generative artificial intelligence becoming more common, commercial technology is focusing on firm-level productivity, automating document creation and optimizing case management.
Jane: The paper argues that this focus on firm productivity overlooks a distinct class of technology: digital reporting platforms that enable people to record their experiences of harm in the community.
Lu: They emphasize that for marginalized groups, relying solely on individual reporting creates a knowledge and power gap, which prevents systemic patterns of harm from being visible to legal institutions.
Tom: Because they’re addressing this, the National Justice Project developed these technology-based access-to-justice initiatives to respond to those barriers by using digital reporting platforms like Call It Out and Hear Me Out.
Jane: These technologies have a dual purpose: first, to improve individual access to justice through automated triage and self-help, and second, to generate a body of empirical evidence capable of supporting systemic advocacy.
Meng: So the core claim is that these platforms reduce the practical work for users by helping them identify a complaint pathway, formulate a complaint, and contribute to a wider account of harm.
Lalam: That’s because they use plain-language digital interfaces and direct reporting functions that allow users to describe their experiences in their own terms.
Tom: And this aggregation of reports is what moves it from individual complaints to something that can reveal patterns of harm that might not be visible from just looking at one complaint.
Jane: It’s about using the data justice approach, synthesizing those individual reports to find those hidden patterns, which then provides a foundation for institutional accountability.
Lu: The paper also traces the evolution of this strategy, showing how it moved from early legal chatbots to community-led reporting initiatives and then into AI-assisted systems designed specifically for direct-to-consumer reporting.
Tom: And they examine this entire journey as a model for justice technology development, showing how each platform learns from the strengths and limitations of the one that came before it.
Jane: It’s essentially showing how to build technology that isn't just helpful for an individual complaint, but is also designed to be a tool for broader systemic change when used collectively.
Conclusion: Tom: So we’ve talked about how this paper lays out a model where digital reporting platforms turn individual experiences into collective evidence, which is the essence of "The Moving Frontier: How the National Justice Project Is Using Digital Technology to Expand Access to Justice."
Jane: It really boils down to this: when you design technology with two goals—helping an individual get help and helping society see patterns of harm—you create something much more effective for challenging systemic issues.
Lu: The authors are showing that justice technology isn't just about making legal documents easier; it’s about creating infrastructure where people can safely document what they experience without needing to navigate the entire complex legal system alone.
Meng: If you were deploying this, I’d be really focused on how the data governance works at scale and ensuring that the privacy protections are rock solid since these reports are sensitive.
Lalam: The implication for civil society is that they gain a way to self-advocate with hard evidence, which changes the power dynamic away from just waiting for an institution to notice something.
Tom: And it shifts the focus of legal oversight from reacting to single incidents toward proactively using aggregated data to demand structural change.
Jane: So what this paper suggests is that justice technology is most powerful when it connects digital self-help directly with the human and institutional pathways needed to actually act on what’s reported, rather than just being a standalone app.
Macquarie University · University of New South Wales · Jumbunna Institute for Indigenous Education and Research
cs.CY
Submitted: 2026-11-03
Updated: 2026-11-03
Comments: 6 Pages
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: Digital reporting platforms that transform individual experiences of harm into collective evidence equip civil society with the evidence needed to self-advocate and challenge institutional…
Key concepts
- Knowledge and Power Gap
- This refers to the imbalance where individuals reporting harm are often dismissed as isolated complaints. Traditional systems require people to know how to find the right legal path, creating a barrier for those without resources or knowledge, especially marginalized groups.
- Theory of Change Pillars
- The NJP's strategy rests on four steps: first, using easy-to-use interfaces for access; second, direct reporting as advocacy; third, aggregating reports to find patterns of harm; and finally, using this evidence to demand institutional accountability.
- Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
- This is an AI architecture used in the platforms that helps users access complaint systems. It allows the technology to intelligently help individuals navigate complex reporting processes by providing relevant information based on their specific experiences.
Terminology
Summary
Digital reporting platforms that transform individual experiences of harm into collective evidence equip civil society with the evidence needed to self-advocate and challenge institutional discrimination By using anonymised reporting, triage templates, and Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) architectures, platforms like Hear Me Out and Call It Out record experiences of discrimination that other institutions rarely seek to collect The aggregated data generated by the NJP’s platforms have directly informed parliamentary inquiries, supported annual analytical reports, and supplied data for royal commissions This article argues that direct-toconsumer digital reporting platforms, by transforming individual experiences of harm into collective evidence, equip civil society with the evidence needed to self-advocate and challenge institutional discrimination
The Knowledge and Power Gap
Individually reported experiences of discrimination, institutional misconduct, and administrative abuse are often dismissed by complaint bodies as isolated grievances Traditional legal oversight architectures often place the burden on affected individuals to identify a legal problem, find the institution with jurisdiction to address it, and engage with the formal reporting process without assistance For marginalised groups, this reliance on individual reporting creates a knowledge and power gap that, more broadly, prevents systemic patterns of harm less visible to legal institutions The NJP developed its technology projects as counterhegemonic infrastructure to address these limitations
The Theory of Change
The NJP’s theory of change operates through four interconnected pillars
-
First, as an access to justice tool, plain-language digital interfaces scaffold user interactions, which enable individuals to identify potential rights violations and reporting processes, and to take action, without requiring formal legal representation
-
Second, direct reporting functions as an act of rights advocacy, by allowing users to describe experiences in their own terms
-
Third, aggregation operates as a form of data justice, by synthesising individual reports to reveal patterns of harm that may not be visible from individual complaints
-
Lastly, empirical visibility provides a foundation for institutional accountability
Evolution of Technology
Justice technology evolves through iteration, with each platform emerging from the strengths and limitations of the model that preceded it The NJP’s digital strategy originated with CopWatch, which is a web application and community education program established in 2017 following reports to the NJP by First Nations families regarding pervasive police discrimination in Kalgoorlie following the death of Elijah Doughty The deployment has developed across three phases:
** Phase 1: Rules-Based Legal Chatbots and the Tech4Justice Clinic, which used an off-the-shelf no-code logic engine to map complex statutory frameworks into conversational decision pathways **
** Phase 2: Call It Out, a community governed platform designed to collect experiences of racism directly from First Nations communities using established community-led reporting initiatives **
** Phase 3: Hear Me Out, which extended the model by using artificial intelligence to help individuals access complaint-making systems while retaining the capacity to learn from the complaints that users make **
Future Directions and Governance
The development of the NJP’s technologies has identified areas where the model can be strengthened, particularly in relation to eliciting the relevant facts and circumstances, data governance, long-term funding and access to human assistance Concerns about aggregating sensitive reports require close attention to legal implications, privacy and data governance standards NJP addresses these concerns by limiting the information collected, instructing users not to provide personal details and neither platform retains identifiable information Sustainable funding is necessary for the continued operation and development of these platforms There is potential for the NJP to build on this model by creating a referral pathway from digital reporting to human assistance
Conclusion
The future of justice technology lies in connecting digital self-help with the human and institutional pathways required to act on what reporting reveals Justice technology is at its most powerful when the act of reporting becomes a means of documenting harm, building evidence and demanding a response The NJP's model demonstrates how technology, when thoughtfully designed and responsibly governed, can expand access to justice The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is Digital reporting platforms that transform individual experiences of harm into collective evidence equip civil society with the evidence needed to self-advocate and challenge institutional discrimination.
AI USE STATEMENT
Generative AI tools (ChatGPT) were used to help summarise background research materials All analysis, arguments and conclusions are the authors' own The authors reviewed and verified all AI-assisted content and take full responsibility for the paper.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Adaptive Triage Pathway Generation: The system can move beyond
rules-based systems
by using retrieval augmented generation (RAG) architectures to identify relevant information in plain language complaints and combine that with standardized jurisdictional templates to accurately determine relevant complaint pathways. -
Community-Governed Data Sovereignty: By ensuring that
data is held solely by the Jumbunna Institute, ensuring that information about First Nations experiences remains under First Nations control,
the AI system can maintain data governance aligned with First Nations data sovereignty principles. -
Multi-Modal Evidence Aggregation: The system can function
simultaneously as a legal assistant for the individual and as data infrastructure for civil society
by capturing and structuring metadata from every complaint lodged to generate empirical proof of systemic failures. -
Human Referral Pathway Integration: The improved system can build a
human pathway back into the model, through a dedicated clinic or referral mechanism,
connecting digital self-help withpersonal and systemic advocacy and legal assistance where appropriate.
Related papers
- AI-Mediated Communication Can Steer Collective Opinion
- Epistemic Infrastructures of Science in AI Era Should Rebalance Costs of Generation and Verification
- AI out-persuades expert humans in text-based dialogue
- Evaluating Ambient Clinical Scribes in India: The Need for Multilingual Real-World Clinical Conversation Data
- AI Value Alignment for Evolving Social Norms
- Voting Biases in Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO) Governance