Phenomenological investigation of order statistics for multi-jet events

arXiv:2611.07838 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-11-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Phenomenological investigation of order statistics for multi-jet events".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Phenomenological investigation of order statistics for multi-jet events investigates rank-ordered jet rapidity distributions as probes of multijet radiation in proton–proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV These observables retain information about the organization of jets within an event that is not resolved by the inclusive single-jet rapidity spectrum.

Kai: Theoretical Framework and Observables The study introduces a framework based on order statistics to map parent rapidity distributions to rank-ordered observables, assuming independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) rapidities as an idealization.

Mira: The cumulative distribution of the kth order statistic is given by a binomial upper-tail probability formula.

Kai: The normalized single-inclusive rapidity spectrum, defined as rho1(y) = 1/Ntotal jets dNjets dy, records where jets occur but not which other jets occur in the same event.

Paper summary: Kai: To recap where we are: this paper, "Phenomenological investigation of order statistics for multi-jet events," looks at how the distribution of jets in a collision can reveal information about multijet radiation, specifically by examining rank-ordered jet rapidity distributions.

Mira: The main thesis is that these observables help probe multijet radiation because they retain information about the organization of jets inside an event that just the inclusive single-jet rapidity spectrum misses.

Lev: They set up a framework using order statistics, assuming rapidities are independent and identically distributed as an idealization, to derive a mathematical mapping between a parent rapidity distribution and the distributions of those ordered jet rapidities.

Kai: They then compare two specific generators: BFKLex and PYTHIA eight point three zero six, measuring their agreement using total-variation distance and Wasserstein distance across several well-populated regions <ref:2611.07838#pg1>.

Mira: The results show that the differences between these predictions remain visible relative to the uncertainty bands in several populated regions, suggesting robustness under the variations they tested.

Lev: They also look at how much those differences change when you vary parameters like PDF sets and scale variations for both generators, which is important for checking how stable their predictions are.

Kai: The total asymmetric uncertainty is calculated by combining statistical, PDF, tune, and scale variations using quadrature to get a single measure of uncertainty.

Mira: And they conclude that the separation between the two predictions depends on both the rapidity rank and event selection. Requiring a rapidity-gap requirement of at least three units of rapidity reduces those distances for the extremal mb mf observables and for all three ranks when n equals three <ref:2611.07838#pg1>.

Lev: So, to put it simply, if you want to see a clear difference between these two models, you need to pick the right observable based on its rank and your event selection criteria.

Kai: It supports the idea that focusing on the second-most-extreme ranks is useful for this type of selection because they show that selective enhancement of separation.

Mira: The paper aims to provide a phenomenological foundation for using these rank distributions to study the differences between BFKLex and PYTHIA eight point three zero six descriptions of high-energy radiation in the configurations they studied here <ref:2611.07838#pg1>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this investigation into "Phenomenological investigation of order statistics for multi-jet events," the main point is that looking at rank-ordered jet rapidity distributions gives us a new way to probe multijet radiation in proton-proton collisions.

Mira: They found that by comparing the BFKLex and PYTHIA eight point three zero six predictions, we can see clear differences between them, but these differences are most apparent when you focus on specific ranks and apply a minimum rapidity separation requirement of three units <ref:2611.07838#pg1>.

Lev: The implication is that for anyone building real hardware or looking at experimental results, they need to know that the separation you measure depends heavily on the rank of the jet and your specific event selection.

Kai: It suggests we shouldn't just look at one averaged spectrum; instead, we should be paying attention to these rank distributions because they are more sensitive probes for distinguishing between these models.

Mira: The authors support using SMB and SMF observables because they show a greater separation between the generator predictions compared to other observables defined across multiplicities.

Lev: So the final thought is that this work provides a foundation for measuring these rank distributions, motivating their inclusion in future analyses of multijet production data.

S. Cerci, G. Chachamis, A. Sabio Vera, Z. S. Demiroglu, D. Sunar Cerci, D. Vaccaro

Department of Physics, Faculty of Arts and Science, Yildiz Technical University · Science Department, Universidad Pública de Navarra Campus de Arrosadia · Institute for Advanced Materials and Mathematics (INAMAT2) Universidad Pública de Navarra Campus de Arrosadia · Instituto de Física Teórica UAM/CSIC Nicolás Cabrera 15 Madrid · Theoretical Physics Department, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-05

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 29 pages, 21 figures, 1 table

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Phenomenological investigation of order statistics for multi-jet events investigates rank-ordered jet rapidity distributions as probes of multijet radiation in proton–proton collisions at √s = 13…

Key concepts

Order Statistics
This statistical method is used to analyze how jets are ranked within an event based on their rapidity. Instead of looking at all jets together, it focuses on the distribution of specific ranks (like the 1st or 2nd most central jet) to gain more detailed information about how radiation is organized in the collision.
Normalized Single-Inclusive Rapidity Spectrum
This observable records where individual jets occur without knowing which other jets are present. It is defined as the fraction of events where a jet occurs at a specific rapidity, offering exclusive insight into jet production patterns that standard inclusive spectra cannot provide.
Generator Comparison (BFKLex vs. PYTHIA 8.306)
This involves testing two different theoretical models—BFKLex and PYTHIA 8.306—against experimental data predictions for multi-jet events. The comparison uses metrics like total-variation distance to quantify how much the predictions from these two models differ in their predicted jet distributions.

Terminology

Summary

Phenomenological investigation of order statistics for multi-jet events investigates rank-ordered jet rapidity distributions as probes of multijet radiation in proton–proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV These observables retain information about the organization of jets within an event that is not resolved by the inclusive single-jet rapidity spectrum. p. 0

Theoretical Framework and Observables

The study introduces a framework based on order statistics to map parent rapidity distributions to rank-ordered observables, assuming independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) rapidities as an idealization. p. 2 The cumulative distribution of the kth order statistic is given by a binomial upper-tail probability formula. p. 2 The normalized single-inclusive rapidity spectrum, defined as rho1(y) = 1/Ntotal jets dNjets dy, records where jets occur but not which other jets occur in the same event. p. 3 This new class of observables could provide more exclusive information than the inclusive ones. p. 3

Generator Comparison and Shape Distances

The comparison is made between normalized predictions from the BFKL-based generator BFKLex and the collinear parton-shower generator PYTHIA 8.306. Differences are quantified using total-variation distance (TV) and Wasserstein distance (W1). p. 1 The results show that the differences remain visible relative to the evaluated uncertainty bands in several well-populated regions. p. 0 A minimum rapidity separation between the extremal jets modifies the discriminating power of the observables in a rank-dependent way. p. 0

Sensitivity to Uncertainties and Selections

The analysis assesses PDF and tune variations for PYTHIA 8.306, and PDF and factorization- and renormalization-scale variations for BFKLex. p. 0 The total asymmetric uncertainty is calculated by combining statistical, PDF, tune, scale variations using quadrature. p. 8 The results show that the separation between the two predictions depends on both the rapidity rank and the event selection. p. 7 p. 7 Requiring a rapidity-gap requirement of at least three units of rapidity, ∆YMF,MB ≥ 3, reduces both distances for the extremal MB/MF observables and for all three ranks at fixed N = 3. p. 7

Conclusion and Outlook

The results support the qualitative hierarchy observed in Ref. [31]: among the observables defined across multiplicities, SMB and SMF provide greater separation between the generator predictions. p. 0 The gap requirement therefore enhances the separation selectively, identifying the second-most-extreme ranks as particularly useful observables for this selection. p. 7 p. 7 p. 7 These findings support the use of rank distributions to investigate differences between the BFKLex and PYTHIA 8. p. 1306 descriptions of high-energy radiation in the configurations studied here. p. 0 The present study is intended to provide a phenomenological foundation for such measurements and to motivate their inclusion in future analyses of multijet production. p. 0 p. 0

Table 1 Summary

Table 1 summarizes the baseline distances for both selections, using the values displayed in the comparison plots. The observable TV W1 TV W1 Jet1 (N = 3) 0.121 0.467 0.0617 0.146 Jet2 (N = 3) 0.0916 0.237 0.0624 Jet3 (N = 3) 0.120 0.462 Jet MB 559 MB MF SMF SMB SMF

Table Summary

Table Summary Shape distances between the normalized PYTHIA 8.306 and BFKLex baseline predictions for the two rapidity-separation selections. p. 0 ∆YMF,MB ≥ 0 corresponds to no additional rapidity-separation requirement ∆YMF,MB ≥ 3

Figure Summary

Figure Summary The distributions remain remarkably stable under this variation, for the inclusive-extremal and second-extremal ranks as well as for the three ranks at fixed jet multiplicity N = 3. The infrared-cutoff variations are therefore retained as a numerical stability check, with λIR = 1 GeV used for the subsequent phenomenological comparisons. p. 9 Perturbative-scale and PDF-set sensitivity is substantially greater than that associated with the infrared cutoff. p. 9 The second-extremal ranks, especially with the ∆YMF,MB ≥ 3 separation requirement, are more sensitive to variations involving µR. p. 7

Table 4 Summary

Table 4 Uncertainty treatment for BFKLex is performed at leading-logarithmic (LL) accuracy. The nominal PDF set is NNPDF2. p. 93 LO (NNPDF23 lo as 0130 qed), with CT14LO and MMHT2014lo68cl as alternative PDF-set inputs. p. 9 The resulting variation therefore probes the combined change of PDF input and its associated αs treatment, and is not a fixed-αs PDF eigenvector or replica uncertainty. p. 9

Figure Summary The observed effect is therefore a selective increase in the discrimination provided by SMB and SMF, rather than a general increase in separation for every rank. The gap requirement therefore enhances the separation selectively, identifying the second-most-extreme ranks as particularly useful observables for this selection. The results show that the separation between the two predictions depends on both the rapidity rank and the event selection. The gap requirement therefore enhances the separation selectively, identifying the second-most-extreme ranks as particularly useful observables for this selection.

Table 5 Summary

Table 5 Comparison with the previous study supports the qualitative hierarchy observed in Ref. [31]: among the observables defined across multiplicities, MB and MF show comparatively small shape differences, whereas SMB and SMF provide greater separation between the generator predictions. p. 0 The broader central-rank distribution predicted by BFKLex at fixed N = 3 also persists. p. 4 The persistence of visible differences relative to these bands in several populated regions extends the earlier comparison of normalized shapes by assessing the uncertainty sources considered here. p. 0

Figure Summary In several well-populated regions, the differences between the baseline predictions remain visible relative to the displayed uncertainty bands. This supports their robustness under the variations considered. p. 9 Unit-area normalization removes common multiplicative rate factors, while retaining effects that change the shapes. p. 3 Experimentally, the observables require only reconstructed jet rapidities and event-by-event ordering. p. 2 Assessing their achievable precision requires a dedicated study of trigger efficiencies and effective luminosity, forward acceptance, detector response, and experimental systematic uncertainties. The present study is intended to provide a phenomenological foundation for such measurements and to motivate their inclusion in future analyses of multijet production. The work of D. p. 1 p. 1 Sunar Cerci and S. p. 0 Cerci was supported by the Yıldız Technical University Scientific Research Projects Coordination Unit (BAP) under project number FBG-2025-7370. p. 0 The work of G. p. 1 Chachamis was supported by the Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT, Portugal) through project EXPL/FIS-PAR/1195/2021 and by the PT-CERN PhD Grant (Call 2021/2). The work of D. Vaccaro was supported by the FCT through project EXPL/FIS-PAR/1195/2021 and by the PT-CERN PhD Grant (Call 2021/2). A. Sabio Vera acknowledges support from the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigación, grants PID2022-142545NB-C22 and IFT Centro de Excelencia Severo Ochoa CEX2020-001007-S, funded by MCIN/AEI/10.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Rank-ordered jet rapidity distributions can be used as probes of multijet radiation in proton-proton collisions at 13 TeV, retaining information about jet organization not resolved by inclusive single-jet spectra.

  2. The system can compare predictions from BFKLex and PYTHIA 8.306 using total variation and Wasserstein distances to quantify the separation between baseline shapes across fixed threejet configurations and rank observables defined across multiplicities.

  3. The improved AI system can assess the effects of PDF and tune variations for PYTHIA 8.306, including combining uncertainty envelopes with nominal Monte Carlo statistical uncertainty.

  4. The system can study variations of factorization and renormalization scales muF and muR, as well as PDF variations for BFKLex to evaluate robustness in predictions.

  5. The AI can analyze how the separation between BFKLex and PYTHIA 8.306 changes depending on the rapidity rank and selection, identifying that SMB and SMF exhibit larger shape differences than MB and MF.

  6. The system can determine that requiring a rapidity-gap requirement of at least three units of rapidity increases separation for SMB/SMF but reduces it for extremal MB/MF ranks.

Related papers