Emergent Symmetry in Constant-Density Flocks

arXiv:2611.07771 · cond-mat.stat-mech, cond-mat.soft · Submitted 2026-11-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Emergent Symmetry in Constant-Density Flocks".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In two dimensions, the ordered phase of constant-density flocks is described by a single angle field, which makes them arguably the simplest systems with a scale-free ordered phase of collective motion We show that the equation governing the corresponding Nambu–Goldstone mode, completed with terms previously discarded, possesses on large scales an invariance combining a shear and a Galilean boost Broken at the bare level, this symmetry is restored at the unique attractive fixed point, and the associated Ward identities fix the scaling exponents exactly, as confirmed numerically System Description The study focuses on constant-density flocks (CDF), which are a simpler class of systems showing scale-free collective motion compared to polar flocks These CDF are described at the continuum level by an equation governing a single vector field v that reads ∂tv + λ1 (v · ∇) v + λ2(∇ · v)v + λ3∇ v2 = D0∇2v + D1∇ (∇ · v) + a − bv2v + √2Tξ (1) This equation is also the continuum description of non-reciprocal XY models In d = 2, the hydrodynamic equation governing the corresponding Nambu–Goldstone mode features only a scalar field parameterizing the direction of order Emergent Symmetry and Scaling The ordered phase of CDF possesses an emergent symmetry that combines a shear transformation and a Galilean boost The Ward identities associated with the symmetry provide the scaling relation conjectured in

8: and thus put the scaling exponent values found there, χ = −1/4, ζ = 3/4 and z = 5/4, on a firm footing Interestingly, the sheared Galilean invariance is generically broken at bare level but restored at the renormalization group (RG) fixed point This restoration is confirmed by computing the RG flow at one-loop order, where we find that the unique attractive fixed point possesses the symmetry Renormalization Group Analysis The RG flow analysis reveals a stable fixed point on the symmetric manifold, which yields the scaling relations χ+z−1 = 0 and 2χ+z−ζ = 0, together with the relation z−2χ−1−ζ = 0 This leads to the exponent values χ = −1/4, ζ = 3/4, and z = 5/4 The RG flow equations are rewritten in terms of four dimensionless parameters proportional to the nonlinearities The fixed point found is (λˆy, λˆx, K, ˆ Mˆ) = 1/2, −√2/24, √2/4, 1/24 that lies on the symmetric manifold Numerical Confirmation The convergence toward the symmetric manifold is distinguished by introducing dimensionless variables δ1 and δ2 which vanish on the symmetric manifold The linearization at the fixed point yields two stable directions with eigenvalues −3/4 and −7/8 associated with δ1 and δ2 respectively The structure factor S(q) measured in a semispectral integration of Eq.

Kai: (3) shows an excellent agreement with the predicted scaling for parameters chosen on the symmetric manifold This is direct evidence of the emergence of the sheared Galilean symmetry on large scales The authors demonstrate that constant-density flocks possess a sheared Galilean invariance when the conditions of Eq.

Mira: (5) are satisfied by the parameters This symmetry is a consequence of the rotational invariance of the original system expressed in the comoving frame The symmetry is broken at bare level but it is restored on large scales, at the RG fixed point The scaling exponents are fixed exactly by this symmetry at the values conjectured in

8: and also obtained in a functional RG calculation The findings raise questions about whether this sheared Galilean invariance could be extended to other active systems and higher dimensions References

1: J.

Kai: Toner and Y.

Paper summary: Kai: We're looking at "Emergent Symmetry in Constant-Density Flocks" here. The authors start by saying that in two dimensions, constant-density flocks are described by just a single angle field.

Mira: That single angle field is what makes them arguably the simplest systems with a scale-free ordered phase of collective motion, which is the main context for this paper.

Kai: The core thesis they present is that the equation governing the corresponding Nambu–Goldstone mode—the mode associated with breaking rotational symmetry—possesses an invariance on large scales.

Mira: This invariance combines a shear transformation and a Galilean boost, which is what they call sheared Galilean invariance.

Kai: They claim this symmetry gets broken at the bare level of their equations, but it gets restored when you look at the unique attractive fixed point in their theory.

Mira: And crucially, those associated Ward identities then fix the scaling exponents exactly, which they check numerically and through functional renormalization group calculations.

Kai: It matters because it provides a way to precisely determine the exponents without relying on previous conjectures, using this symmetry as the foundation.

Mira: This suggests that even in these active matter systems, there's a hidden symmetry that dictates how they scale collectively on large scales.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the title "Emergent Symmetry in Constant-Density Flocks," it really captures the essence of what they are doing here—finding a symmetry that appears only under certain conditions.

Mira: And it's not just about finding a symmetry; it’s about showing how breaking and then restoring that symmetry at a fixed point dictates the very scaling laws of the system.

Kai: In simple terms, they found this shear and Galilean boost invariance, which is usually broken, reappears on large scales when you look at the correct physical state.

Mira: And because it reappears there, it locks down the scaling exponents to specific values that are derived directly from that symmetry.

Kai: So what does this mean for us outside of these two-dimensional flocks? It suggests we might be looking for these kinds of emergent symmetries in other active systems, perhaps in different dimensions or with different types of interactions.

Mira: It opens up a new avenue for investigation into how collective motion organizes itself non-trivially beyond the simple polar flock models we've seen before.

Kai: It’s about finding these underlying principles that govern scale-free order, regardless of the specific microscopic details of the system.

Kai: We're looking at this paper "Emergent Symmetry in Constant-Density Flocks" here. The authors start by saying that in two dimensions, constant-density flocks are described by just a single angle field.

Kai: Exactly. The paper shows that this symmetry is broken at the bare level but then it gets restored once you look at the unique attractive fixed point in their theory.

Kai: So, to sum up, the authors demonstrate that constant-density flocks possess a sheared Galilean invariance when the conditions of Eq. (five) are satisfied by their parameters.

Mira: This symmetry is a consequence of the rotational invariance expressed in the comoving frame.

Lev: And this symmetry is broken at bare level but it is restored on large scales, at the RG fixed point.

Kai: And finally, those scaling exponents are fixed exactly by this symmetry at the values conjectured in some other work and also obtained via functional renormalization group calculations.

Kai: So, looking at this paper "Emergent Symmetry in Constant-Density Flocks,"

Hugues Chaté, Alexandre Solon

Service de Physique de l’Etat Condens莈e, CEA, CNRS University Paris-Saclay, CEA-Saclay · Sorbonne University, CNRS, Laboratoire de Physique Théorique de la Matière Condens莈e

cond-mat.stat-mech, cond-mat.soft

Submitted: 2026-11-05

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 84/100

The gist: In two dimensions, the ordered phase of constant-density flocks is described by a single angle field, which makes them arguably the simplest systems with a scale-free ordered phase of collective…

Key concepts

Constant-Density Flocks (CDF)
These are a class of systems describing flocks where particles maintain a constant density. They are simpler than polar flocks but still display scale-free collective motion, making them ideal for studying emergent symmetries in active matter systems.
Sheared Galilean Invariance
This is an emergent symmetry combining a shear transformation and a Galilean boost. It describes how the system behaves under specific transformations that mix spatial shearing with uniform velocity shifts. It is not present at the starting point but reappears when the system reaches its stable state.
Renormalization Group (RG) Fixed Point
The RG fixed point is a stable state reached by flowing the system's parameters through a coarse-graining process. In this study, it is crucial because it restores the sheared Galilean symmetry and determines the exact scaling exponents of the flocking dynamics.
Scaling Exponents ($\chi$, $\zeta$, $z$)
These are critical numbers that describe how physical quantities in the system change with length scales. The paper shows that these exponents are fixed exactly by the emergent symmetry, yielding specific values ($\chi = -1/4$, $\zeta = 3/4$, $z = 5/4$) consistent with previous theoretical conjectures.

Terminology

Summary

In two dimensions, the ordered phase of constant-density flocks is described by a single angle field, which makes them arguably the simplest systems with a scale-free ordered phase of collective motion We show that the equation governing the corresponding Nambu–Goldstone mode, completed with terms previously discarded, possesses on large scales an invariance combining a shear and a Galilean boost Broken at the bare level, this symmetry is restored at the unique attractive fixed point, and the associated Ward identities fix the scaling exponents exactly, as confirmed numerically

System Description

The study focuses on constant-density flocks (CDF), which are a simpler class of systems showing scale-free collective motion compared to polar flocks These CDF are described at the continuum level by an equation governing a single vector field v that reads ∂tv + λ1 (v · ∇) v + λ2(∇ · v)v + λ3∇ v2 = D0∇2v + D1∇ (∇ · v) + a − bv2v + √2Tξ (1) This equation is also the continuum description of non-reciprocal XY models In d = 2, the hydrodynamic equation governing the corresponding Nambu–Goldstone mode features only a scalar field parameterizing the direction of order

Emergent Symmetry and Scaling

The ordered phase of CDF possesses an emergent symmetry that combines a shear transformation and a Galilean boost The Ward identities associated with the symmetry provide the scaling relation conjectured in [8] and thus put the scaling exponent values found there, χ = −1/4, ζ = 3/4 and z = 5/4, on a firm footing Interestingly, the sheared Galilean invariance is generically broken at bare level but restored at the renormalization group (RG) fixed point This restoration is confirmed by computing the RG flow at one-loop order, where we find that the unique attractive fixed point possesses the symmetry

Renormalization Group Analysis

The RG flow analysis reveals a stable fixed point on the symmetric manifold, which yields the scaling relations χ+z−1 = 0 and 2χ+z−ζ = 0, together with the relation z−2χ−1−ζ = 0 This leads to the exponent values χ = −1/4, ζ = 3/4, and z = 5/4 The RG flow equations are rewritten in terms of four dimensionless parameters proportional to the nonlinearities The fixed point found is (λˆy, λˆx, K, ˆ Mˆ) = 1/2, −√2/24, √2/4, 1/24 that lies on the symmetric manifold

Numerical Confirmation

The convergence toward the symmetric manifold is distinguished by introducing dimensionless variables δ1 and δ2 which vanish on the symmetric manifold The linearization at the fixed point yields two stable directions with eigenvalues −3/4 and −7/8 associated with δ1 and δ2 respectively The structure factor S(q) measured in a semispectral integration of Eq. (3) shows an excellent agreement with the predicted scaling for parameters chosen on the symmetric manifold This is direct evidence of the emergence of the sheared Galilean symmetry on large scales

Conclusion and Implications

The authors demonstrate that constant-density flocks possess a sheared Galilean invariance when the conditions of Eq. (5) are satisfied by the parameters This symmetry is a consequence of the rotational invariance of the original system expressed in the comoving frame The symmetry is broken at bare level but it is restored on large scales, at the RG fixed point The scaling exponents are fixed exactly by this symmetry at the values conjectured in [8] and also obtained in a functional RG calculation The findings raise questions about whether this sheared Galilean invariance could be extended to other active systems and higher dimensions

References

[1] J. Toner and Y. p. 0 p. 0 Tu, Long-range order in a twodimensional dynamical XY model: how birds fly together, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 75, 4326 (1995)

[2] J. Toner and Y. Tu, Flocks, herds, and schools: A quantitative theory of flocking, Physical review E 58, 4828 (1998)

[3] T. Vicsek, A. Czirók, E. p. 3 Ben-Jacob, I. p. 3 Cohen, and O. p. 3 Shochet, Novel type of phase transition in a system of self-driven particles, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995)

[4] N. D. Mermin and H. p. 0 Wagner, Absence of ferromagnetism or antiferromagnetism in one-or two-dimensional isotropic Heisenberg models, Physical Review Letters 17, 1133 (1966)

[5] P. Hohenberg, Existence of long-range order in one and two dimensions, Physical Review 158, 383 (1967)

[6] P. Jentsch and C. p. 0 F. Lee, New Universality Class Describes Vicsek’s Flocking Phase in Physical Dimensions, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 133, 128301 (2024)

[7] H. Ikeda, Minimum scaling model and exact exponents for the Nambu-Goldstone modes in the Vicsek Model, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 133, 258301 (2024)

[8] H. Chaté and A. p. 3 p. 3 p. 3 Solon, Dynamic scaling of twodimensional polar flocks, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 132, 268302 (2024)

[9] B. Mahault, F. p. 3 Ginelli, and H. p. 3 Chaté, Quantitative assessment of the Toner and Tu theory of polar flocks, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 123, 218001 (2019)

[10] L. Chen, P. Jentsch, C. p. 0 p. 0 F. Lee, A. Maitra, S. Ramaswamy, and J. p. 3 p. 3 Toner, The inconvenient truth about flocks, arXiv preprint arXiv:2503. p. 317064 (2025)

[11] H. Chaté and A. Solon, Comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chen et al, arXiv preprint arXiv:2504.13683 (2025)

[12] L. Chen, P. Jentsch, C. F. Lee, A. Maitra, S. Ramaswamy, and J. Toner, Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chaté and Solon, arXiv preprint arXiv:2505.21602 (2025)

[13] H. Chaté and A. Solon, Continuing the discussion on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chen et al, arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.13437 (2025)

[14] J. Toner, Birth, death, and flight: A theory of malthusian flocks, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 108, 088102 (2012)

[15] S. A. Loos, S. H. Klapp, and T. p. 3 Martynec, Long-range order and directional defect propagation in the nonreciprocal XY model with vision cone interactions, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 130, 198301 (2023)

[16] Y. Rouzaire, D. p. 3 J. Pearce, I. Pagonabarraga, and D. p. 3 Levis, Nonreciprocal interactions reshape topological defect annihilation, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 134, 167101 (2025)

[17] P. Popli, A. Maitra, and S. p. 3 Ramaswamy, Ordering and defect cloaking in nonreciprocal lattice XY models, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 135, 088303 (2025)

[18] D. Dopierala, H. p. 3 Chaté, X.-q. Shi, and A. p. 3 Solon, Inescapable anisotropy of nonreciprocal XY models, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 135, 088302 (2025)

[19] M. Besse, H. Chaté, and A. p. 3 Solon, Metastability of Constant-Density Flocks, Phys. p. 3 Rev. Lett. 129, 268003 (2022)

[20] P. Jentsch and A. p. 0 Erzberger, True and Quasi LongRange Order in Malthusian Flocks, arXiv preprint arXiv:2608. p. 405851 (2026)

[21] N. Dupuis, L. Canet, A. Eichhorn, W. p. 4 Metzner, J. p. 4 M. Pawlowski, M. p. 4 Tissier, and N. p. 3 Wschebor, The nonperturbative functional renormalization group and its applications, Physics Reports 910, 1 (2021)

[22] C. G. Callan Jr, Broken scale invariance in scalar field theory, Phys. p. 4 Rev. D 2, 1541 (1970)

[23] K. Symanzik, Small distance behaviour in field theory and power counting, Communications in Mathematical Physics 18, 227 (1970)

[24] G. Parisi, Field-theoretic approach to second-order phase transitions in two- and three dimensional systems, Journal of Statistical Physics 23, 49 (1980)

[25] E. Medina, T. Hwa, M. Kardar, and Y. p. 4-C. Zhang, Burgers equation with correlated noise: Renormalizationgroup analysis and applications to directed polymers and interface growth, Phys. p. 4 Rev. A 39, 3053 (1989)

[26] E. Frey and U. p. 4 C. Täuber, Two-loop renormalizationgroup analysis of the Burgers–Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equation, Phys. p. 4 Rev. E 50, 1024 (1994)

[27] L. Canet, H. Chaté, B. Delamotte, and N. p. 3 Wschebor, Nonperturbative renormalization group for the KardarParisi-Zhang equation: General framework and first applications, Phys. p. 4 Rev. E 84, 061128 (2011)

[28] M. Kardar, G. Parisi, and Y. p. 4-C. Zhang, Dynamic scaling of growing interfaces, Physical Review Letters 56, 889 (1986)

[29] M. Marsili, A. p. 4 Maritan, F. p. 4 Toigo, and J. p. 4 R. Banavar, Stochastic growth equations and reparametrization invariance, Reviews of Modern Physics 68, 963 (1996)

[30] K. T. Grosvenor and S. p. 4 P. Patil, On the Renormalization Group Flow of Active Flocks, arXiv preprint arXiv:2606. p. 420552 (2026)

[31] E. Sezik and G. p. 4 Pruessner, Large Spin-Wave Fluctuations Suppress Activity in Malthusian Flocks, arXiv preprint arXiv:2608. p. 405805 (2026)

[32] U. C. Täuber, Critical dynamics: a field theory approach to equilibrium and non-equilibrium scaling behavior (Cambridge University Press, 2014)

End Matter is the text under the final page of the paper The authors show that the hydrodynamic equation describing constant-density flocks, complete with terms that were previously discarded, possesses a sheared Galilean invariance when the conditions of Eq. (5) are satisfied by the parameters This symmetry is a consequence of the rotational invariance of the original system expressed in the comoving frame This is a situation akin to that of the KPZ equation [28] in which the tilt symmetry is a remnant of rotational symmetry for a growing interface [29] Here, the symmetry is broken at bare level but we demonstrated that it is restored on large scales, at the RG fixed point The scaling exponents are fixed exactly by the symmetry at the values conjectured in [8] and also obtained in a functional RG calculation This is rather direct evidence of the emergence of the sheared Galilean symmetry on large scales The authors show that the hydrodynamic equation describing constant-density flocks, complete with terms that were previously discarded, possesses a sheared Galilean invariance when the conditions of Eq. p. 3 (5) are satisfied by the parameters This symmetry is a consequence of the rotational invariance of the original system expressed in the comoving frame The scaling exponents are fixed exactly by this symmetry at the values conjectured in [8] and also obtained in a functional RG calculation

--- Page 5 ---

The authors show that the hydrodynamic equation describing constant-density flocks, complete with terms that were previously discarded, possesses a sheared Galilean invariance when the conditions of Eq. (5) are satisfied by the parameters This symmetry is a consequence of the rotational invariance of the original system expressed in the comoving frame The scaling exponents are fixed exactly by this symmetry at the values conjectured in [8] and also obtained in a functional RG calculation

--- Page 4 ---

In Fig. 2, we compare the behavior at large scales of the structure factor S(q) = ⟨θ(q)2⟩, measured in a semispectral integration of Eq. p. 2 (3), with the predicted scaling Choosing parameters on the symmetric manifold and Dx and Dy in order to minimize corrections to scaling, we find an excellent agreement with the predicted scaling (Fig. p. 2 2, left) This is rather direct evidence of the emergence of the sheared Galilean symmetry on large scales

--- Page 3 ---

The RG flow can then be rewritten in terms of four dimensionless parameters, which we choose proportional to the nonlinearities The flow (9) can then be rewritten as dλˆy ds= λˆy [1 − 15/4 λˆ2y + Kˆ 2 − 9/2Mˆ], dλˆx ds= λˆx [1 - 3λ̂2y + 3K̂ squared − 15M̂], dK̂ ds= K cubed − 9/4 λˆ2yKˆ − 15/2 KˆMˆ − 9λˆyλhatx, dMˆ ds=9λhatx2 - 3/2 λhat2yM̂ + 3K 2M̂ − 18M̂ squared This makes clear that, if starting with Kˆ = Mˆ = 0 as in [8, 10], K and M are switched on immediately, with dK/ ˆ ds = −9λˆyλhatx and dM / ˆ ds = 9λ 2x and thus need to be included in the theory

--- Page 6 ---

The fixed points of the flow Eq.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Simulation of constant-density flocks can be performed using a continuum description governed by an equation involving a single vector field v, which is applicable for large scales. This allows for modeling collective motion in systems where density is fixed by the carrying capacity of the medium.

  2. The improved system will exhibit emergent symmetry combining shear and Galilean boost on large scales, restoring this symmetry at the unique attractive renormalization group fixed point. This means that scaling exponents are exactly fixed to values like chi = -1/4, zeta = 3/4, and z = 5/4 through Ward identities.

  3. The system can accurately predict the structure factor S(q) at large scales by matching it to predicted scaling laws based on the symmetry of the hydrodynamic equation. This enables high-fidelity simulation and analysis of long-range ordered phases in active matter systems.

  4. The AI system can be trained to identify when sheared Galilean invariance is broken at bare levels versus when it is restored at the renormalization group fixed point by observing how early length scale simulations reach the scaling regime.

Sources

Related papers