Double Neutron Star Mergers and Fast Blue Optical Transients: A Circumbinary Disk Connection
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Double Neutron Star Mergers and Fast Blue Optical Transients".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Double Neutron Star Mergers and Fast Blue Optical Transients: A Circumbinary Disk Connection is a framework developed to model how circumbinary disks (CBDs) formed after common-envelope evolution affect the subsequent binary evolution, leading to a reduction in double neutron star merger rates and the potential powering of luminous fast blue optical transients.
Vera: Modeling CBD Formation and Orbital Evolution The authors developed a formalism to study the effect of CBDs formed around the central binary from leftover envelope that remains bound after the CEE phase on a population level, integrating it into the rapid population synthesis code compas The condition for forming a CBD is evaluated by comparing javail, the post-CEE specific angular momentum retained by the bound envelope material and available for disk formation, to jKEP, the Keplerian specific angular momentum required to support a CBD If javail ≥ jKEP, it is assumed that the leftover envelope material has enough specific angular momentum to form a centrifugally supported CBD around the post-CEE binary The framework uses spindler (Valli et al.
Jocelyn: 2024), which interpolates across the hydrodynamical simulations of Siwek et al.
Vera: (2023a,b), to model the CBD-driven evolution of the semimajor axis, eccentricity, and component masses of the binary shaped by gravitational and accretion forces Impact on DNS Mergers and LFBOTs The interactions between the CBD and the central binary typically shrink the orbit (Fig.
Paper summary: Vera: So to recap this paper on "Double Neutron Star Mergers and Fast Blue Optical Transients: A Circumbinary Disk Connection," the main idea is that post-common-envelope evolution can leave behind a circumbinary disk around the core and its companion.
Jocelyn: This disk acts as a physical medium that exchanges angular momentum with the inner binary, which changes its subsequent orbital evolution in a way that affects merger rates for double neutron stars.
Subrahmanyan: The central thesis is that this interaction modifies the evolutionary path of these binaries, leading to both a reduction in double neutron star merger rates and the potential powering of fast blue optical transients.
Vera: The authors are developing a framework to model this effect at a population level, specifically by checking if javail is greater than or equal to jKEP before assuming a CBD forms.
Jocelyn: They use results from hydrodynamical simulations, interpolating across those simulations to build their model of the binary's semimajor axis and eccentricity over time.
Subrahmanyan: The framework essentially uses a decision tree in compas to decide whether to continue regular evolution or if a CBD forms based on the criterion of specific angular momentum.
Vera: They found that this interaction can cause orbital shrinkage, which brings components closer together, potentially leading them into the gravitational wave merger regime or shortening the timescale for systems that were already supposed to merge.
Jocelyn: That orbital shrinkage is mostly seen through ‘premature’ mergers between the neutron star and the giant’s core in systems that would otherwise become merging neutron stars.
Subrahmanyan: Those premature NS core mergers are what drive the reduction in DNS merger rates, but they are also compensated by systems that would be disrupted during a second supernova or form too wide for a merger instead become merging neutron stars due to this CBD-driven orbital contraction.
Vera: These premature NS core mergers happen before the disk material is depleted, which is what allows them to give rise to fast blue optical transients.
Jocelyn: The study also found that these CBD-induced LFBOTs occur at a fiducial rate of about eleven Gpc-three per year, and this rate is robust across their population study.
Conclusion: Vera: So we're wrapping up the discussion on "Double Neutron Star Mergers and Fast Blue Optical Transients: A Circumbinary Disk Connection." The authors essentially argue that circumbinary disks play a role in altering binary evolution in post-CEE systems.
Jocelyn: They show that these disks don't just suppress merger rates; they actively change the population of mergers we expect to see when we look at double neutron star mergers.
Subrahmanyan: The main implication is that if you observe a population of double neutron stars, you need to account for these circumbinary disks in your calculations to get an accurate picture.
Vera: Because without them, the predicted rates would be too high at early times, but with them, the rates align better with what we see observed across different cosmic timescales.
Jocelyn: And they also showed that this framework provides a general tool for studying CBD-binary interactions in post-CEE systems.
Subrahmanyan: The work gives us a way to study the interaction between these disks and binaries, but it’s important to remember that the thickness and viscosity of those disks are still things they haven't fully modeled yet.
Steward Observatory and Department of Astronomy, University of Arizona · Max Planck Institute for Astrophysics, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str. · Institute of Science and Technology Austria (ISTA) · School of Physics and Astronomy, Monash University · The ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Wave Discovery—OzGrav · Center for Cosmology and Particle Physics, New York University
astro-ph.HE, astro-ph.SR
Submitted: 2026-11-05
Updated: 2026-11-05
Comments: Comments are Welcome!
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 87/100
The gist: Double Neutron Star Mergers and Fast Blue Optical Transients: A Circumbinary Disk Connection is a framework developed to model how circumbinary disks (CBDs) formed after common-envelope evolution…
Key concepts
- Circumbinary Disk (CBD)
- A disk of material that forms around a binary system after a common-envelope evolution. The paper models how this leftover envelope material, which retains specific angular momentum, can form a centrifugally supported disk that interacts with the central binary.
- Specific Angular Momentum Comparison
- This is the criterion used to determine if a CBD forms. It compares 'javail,' the angular momentum retained by the bound envelope material, against 'jKEP,' which is the minimum angular momentum needed to support a disk around the post-common-envelope binary.
- Fast Blue Optical Transients (LFBOTs)
- These are luminous optical events potentially powered by 'premature' mergers between a neutron star and a giant's core. The model suggests that orbital shrinkage caused by CBD interactions drives these premature mergers, leading to the production of LFBOTs.
- Chirp-Mass Distribution Shift
- The accretion of mass onto neutron stars within the fiducial CBD model causes a shift in the distribution of merging neutron star chirp masses towards higher values. This finding is consistent with observations like GW190425, suggesting CBD interactions play a role.
Terminology
Summary
Double Neutron Star Mergers and Fast Blue Optical Transients: A Circumbinary Disk Connection is a framework developed to model how circumbinary disks (CBDs) formed after common-envelope evolution affect the subsequent binary evolution, leading to a reduction in double neutron star merger rates and the potential powering of luminous fast blue optical transients. p. 0 Draft version November 6, 2026
Typeset using LATEX twocolumn style in AASTeX63
Double Neutron Star Mergers and Fast Blue Optical Transients: A Circumbinary Disk Connection
Aldana Grichener,
1 Ruggero Valli,
2, 3 Mathieu Renzo,
1
Ilya Mandel,
4, 5 Kaitlin M. Kratter,
1
Magdalena Siwek,
6 Koushik Sen,
1 and Neev Shah1
1Steward Observatory and Department of Astronomy, University of Arizona, 933 North Cherry Avenue, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA
2Max Planck Institute for Astrophysics, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str.Where the paper says it
Modeling CBD Formation and Orbital Evolution
The authors developed a formalism to study the effect of CBDs formed around the central binary from leftover envelope that remains bound after the CEE phase on a population level, integrating it into the rapid population synthesis code compas The condition for forming a CBD is evaluated by comparing javail, the post-CEE specific angular momentum retained by the bound envelope material and available for disk formation, to jKEP, the Keplerian specific angular momentum required to support a CBD If javail ≥ jKEP, it is assumed that the leftover envelope material has enough specific angular momentum to form a centrifugally supported CBD around the post-CEE binary The framework uses spindler (Valli et al. 2024), which interpolates across the hydrodynamical simulations of Siwek et al. p. 2 For systems where the condition in Equation 5 is satisfied, we incorporate the effect of CBDs on the evolution using spindler (Valli et al. 2024), an interpolation across the hydrodynamical simulations of Siwek
et al.Where the paper says it
Impact on DNS Mergers and LFBOTs
The interactions between the CBD and the central binary typically shrink the orbit (Fig. 4), changing the binary population that results in DNS mergers (Fig. p. 0 Leveraging
results of scale-free hydrodynamical simulations, we develop a framework to model the effect of such
disks on subsequent binary evolution, and implement it in the population synthesis code compas. Applying our framework to double neutron star (DNS) merger progenitors, we find that CBDs generally
induce substantial orbital shrinkage, changing the merging DNS population and lowering the overall
merger rate.Where the paper says it
Merger Rate Suppression and Chirp-Mass Shifts
CBD interactions prevent ≃ 29% of the binaries that would otherwise have evolved to merging DNSs from doing so (left panel of Fig. 5), while enabling the formation of new merging DNSs in systems that would otherwise result in different evolutionary outcomes In most cases, CBD interactions reduce the overall rate of merging DNSs, and this reduction is strongest for β ≲ 1. p. 7 As shown in Fig. 5, CBD interactions prevent
≃ 29% of the binaries that would otherwise have evolved
to merging DNSs from doing so (left panel), while enabling the formation of new merging DNSs in systems
that would otherwise result in different evolutionary outcomes, accounting for ≃ 23% of the new DNS merger
population (right panel). This mass gain leads
to heavier NSs, and, consequently, higher binary chirp
masses (see Section 6). The super-Eddington accretion
rates onto the NS also raise the possibility that some of
these post-CEE binaries could appear as ultraluminous
X-ray sources during their interaction with the CBD
(e.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Implications for R-process Enrichment and Observational Constraints
The strong decrease in the DNS merger rates at timescales of ≲ 40 Myr due to CBD-induced ‘premature’ mergers makes this tension even more severe The authors find that CBD interactions mostly suppress mergers at short delay times, lowering their rate by 40% for delay times below ≃ 40 Myr CBD-induced LFBOTs are expected to remain spatially associated with their local progenitor environment, with natal kicks causing only a minor displacement relative to the local stellar population The high chirp mass of GW190425 is much more compatible with models that include CBD interactions, as the fraction of DNS mergers with GW190425-like chirp masses increases to ≃ 10%
Limitations and Future Work
The thickness and viscosity of the disk play a crucial role in shaping its interaction with the inner binary and its subsequent orbital evolution The authors note that the effect of CBD torques on mass transfer is not explicitly accounted for, suggesting that continued angular momentum extraction from the binary by the disk could enhance the mass-transfer rate Future work should involve relaxing assumptions about disk thickness or adopting an analytic CBD framework to test the robustness of results The paper emphasizes that more massive Galactic DNSs tend to have shorter GW inspiral times, and these are less likely to be represented in the present-day Galactic DNS population
Summary of Findings
The authors conclude that CBDs tend to decrease the numbers of merging DNSs, especially at early times They also find that CBD-induced LFBOTs occur at a fiducial rate of ≃ 11 Gpc−3 yr−1, and are robust across our population study The overall conclusion is that CBD interactions reduce the predicted merger rate relative to analogous models without CBDs in most cases (Figs. 6, 10) They also find that the high chirp mass of GW190425 is much more compatible with models that include CBD interactions The work provides a general tool for studying CBD–binary interactions in post-CEE systems
Acknowledgments and Data Availability
The authors thank Mike Lau, Michaela Mapelli, Smadar Naoz, Fabian Schneider, and Fritz R¨opke for helpful discussions The population synthesis data generated for this project is publicly available on Zenodo at 10.5281/zenodo.23851460 Simulations in this paper used a modified version of the open-source rapid binary population synthesis code compas, incorporating the CBD framework developed in this work The CBD framework is integrated in compas, starting from version 03. p. 1 We discuss
the implications of the reduction in prompt DNS mergers for r-process enrichment and the caveats of our work
in Section 7 and summarize in Section 8. CBD Framework in Population Synthesis
We build a formalism to study the effect of CBDs
formed around the central binary from leftover envelope
that remains bound after the CEE phase on a population level, and integrate it into the rapid population
synthesis code compas (Stevenson et al. Since this gas carries
substantial angular momentum, it cannot be re-accreted
directly onto either component. Instead, it circularizes
at radii comparable to a few times the post-CEE orbital separation, forming a rotationally supported CBD
arXiv:2611.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
More accurately predict DNS merger rates by incorporating a CBD framework that models how 'premature' mergers between neutron stars and giant cores can power luminous fast blue optical transients (LFBOTs).
-
Quantify the effect of different CBD parameters, such as specific angular momentum retention parameter beta and disk mass, on the volumetric DNS merger rate to better constrain its dependence on these physical properties.
-
Predict the shift in chirp-mass distribution of merging DNS systems by incorporating mass accretion from a CBD, potentially explaining high observed masses like GW190425.
-
Estimate the typical offset of LFBOTs from their local stellar population by combining post-SN systemic velocities with time elapsed between the first SN and the 'premature' merger, providing a first-order estimate of displacement.
-
Assess how different stellar evolution prescriptions, such as SN explosion recipes and mass transfer stability criteria, affect DNS merger rates to determine which uncertainties most significantly impact predictions.
Abstract
Post-common-envelope evolution (CEE) circumbinary disks (CBDs) form when part of the ejected envelope remains bound and circularizes around the stripped core and its companion. Leveraging results of scale-free hydrodynamical simulations, we develop a framework to model the effect of such disks on subsequent binary evolution, and implement it in the population synthesis code COMPAS. Applying our framework to double neutron star (DNS) merger progenitors, we find that CBDs generally induce substantial orbital shrinkage, changing the merging DNS population and lowering the overall merger rate. We explore an extensive grid of binary-evolution and disk models, and find that CBD interactions reduce the DNS merger rate by up to 28%, primarily through 'premature' mergers between the neutron star (NS) and the giant's core. These mergers may power luminous fast blue optical transients (LFBOTs), occurring at a fiducial rate of 11: Gpc-3 yr-1. Our results indicate that natal kicks contribute little to LFBOT offsets, and that they should be associated with young stellar populations, though not necessarily active star-forming regions. Since LFBOT progenitors would otherwise produce short-delay DNS mergers, CBDs further challenge DNS mergers as the source of early r-process enrichment. For surviving DNS mergers, accretion from the disk leads to higher chirp masses, potentially explaining the puzzling mass of GW190425. Our framework provides a general tool for studying CBD-binary interactions in post-CEE systems.
Sources
- Eccentric Binaries Accreting from Thin Disks: Orbital Evolution
- On Bimodality in the Eccentricity Distribution of Galactic Double Neutron Stars
- The Environments of Luminous Fast Blue Optical Transients: Evidence for a Compact Object and Wolf-Rayet Star Merger Origin
- Mergers Fall Short: Non-merger Channels Required for Galactic Heavy Element Production
- Detection of relativistic orbital deformation from improved timing of PSR J1757 - 1854
- The early r-process nucleosynthesis scenarios
- GWTC-4.0: Population Properties of Merging Compact Binaries
- GWTC-5.0: Population Properties of Merging Compact Binaries
- The r-Process: History, Required Conditions, Astrophysical Sites, and Observations
- Not just winds: why models find binary black hole formation is metallicity dependent, while binary neutron star formation is not
Related papers
- Low- T/W instabilities in differentially rotating neutron stars resembling merger remnants
- The imprint of individual neutron star spins on ejecta, r-process nucleosynthesis, and kilonovae in binary neutron star mergers
- Early panchromatic spectra reveal helium in the thermonuclear supernova 2024kce
- The Double-Peaked Calcium-Strong SN 2025coe: Progenitor Constraints from Early Interaction and Ejecta Asymmetries
- The pulsar population of Omega Centauri: New TRAPUM searches, timing, and cluster dynamics with MeerKAT and Parkes
- One year of broadband radio monitoring of the enigmatic transient GRB 250702B reveals the evolution of the relativistic jet