Systematic Study of Cosmic Rays in Star-Forming and Starburst Galaxies using Fermi-LAT and Multiwavelength Data

arXiv:2611.07189 · astro-ph.HE · Submitted 2026-11-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Systematic Study of Cosmic Rays in Star-Forming and Starburst Galaxies using Fermi-LAT and Multiwavelength Data".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The majority of γ rays from star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and starburst galaxies (SBGs) are expected to originate from interactions between highenergy cosmic rays (CRs) and the interstellar medium, making γ-ray observations a powerful tool for probing CR populations and interstellar environments The majority of γ rays from star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and starburst galaxies (SBGs) are expected to originate from interactions between highenergy cosmic rays (CRs) and the interstellar medium, making γ-ray observations a powerful tool for probing CR populations and interstellar environments Systematic Study Scope The study conducted a systematic analysis of seven sources using 15 years of Fermi-LAT data to characterize GeV and sub-GeV γ-ray emission from SFGs and SBGs The sample included M82, NGC 253, M31, Arp 220, NGC 2146, Arp 299, and M33 Target selection focused on sources individually detected by Fermi-LAT using the 12-year catalog Sources were classified based on broadband spectral properties, with SFGs/SBGs selected from "normal galaxies" or "starburst galaxies" Spectral Modeling and CR Properties Detailed SED modeling of M82 and NGC 253 revealed a decrease in energy flux below a few hundred MeV, suggesting a substantially smaller contribution from CR electrons than previously inferred The electron-to-proton ratios in M82 and NGC 253 were found to be comparable to that of the Milky Way, although the CR energy densities in these two SBGs are 2.5–8 times lower than that of the magnetic field, unlike the Milky Way Calorimetric Efficiency and Theoretical Framework The analysis reduced γ-ray fluxes for several SBGs to levels comparable to or below the calorimetric limit, with efficiencies ranging from 0.33 to 1.20 A theoretical model of interstellar γ-ray emission was developed that successfully reproduces these observed calorimetric efficiencies, providing a robust framework for interpreting and predicting γ-ray emission from SFGs and SBGs Galaxy Specific Findings For M82, the logP model provided better agreement with the SED data points compared to the PL model, indicating mild curvature in its GeV and sub-GeV emission For NGC 253, similar findings were observed where the logP model was adopted to prevent bias in low-energy flux from affecting SED fitting M31's γ-ray emission consists of two point-like sources, with the central source displaying a soft spectrum and a compact size of less than 0.33, suggesting a considerable contribution from unresolved sources The results demonstrate that interstellar γ-ray emission dominates all SBGs in the sample The inferred CR energy densities of SBGs are well below energy equipartition with the magnetic field energy density, which could be due to strong loss of CR protons and electrons in dense environments Furthermore, the observed spectral indices for both CR protons and electrons are harder than those in the Milky Way, consistent with high CR calorimetric efficiency rather than significant CR escape The predicted π0-decay γ-ray emission peaks at ∼1 GeV and decays steeply below 200 MeV, being compatible with the data The revised analysis yields lower γ-ray flux estimates for several SBGs, aligning them with or below the calorimetric limit The updated γ-ray luminosities of the SBG sample members are comparable to or below the calorimetric limit, with observed fcal values ranging from 0.33 to 1.20 The study provides observation-based templates for future studies by showing that interstellar γ-ray emission dominates all SBGs in the sample The findings enable distinguishing nuclear emission from the starburst component in Seyfert galaxies The results provide a robust framework for interpreting and predicting interstellar γ-ray emission from SFGs and SBGs Acknowledgments The Fermi LAT Collaboration acknowledges generous ongoing support from a number of agencies and institutes that have supported both the development and the operation of the LAT as well as scientific data analysis Additional support for science analysis during the operations phase is gratefully acknowledged from the Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica in Italy and the Centre National d’Études Spatiales in France Funding was provided by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers 23K25882 and 23H04895 (T.M.), 26H00822 and 26H02063 (T.T.), and by JST SPRING Grant Number JPMJSP2108 (J.C.

Paper summary: Jocelyn: The paper "Systematic Study of Cosmic Rays in Star-Forming and Starburst Galaxies using Fermi-LAT and Multiwavelength Data" aims to characterize the gamma ray spectra of SFGs and SBGs by focusing on sources individually detected by Fermi-LAT.

Vera: The authors set out to understand the connection between these observed gamma rays and interstellar cosmic rays produced by star formation activity, rather than nuclear processes.

Subrahmanyan: The core claim seems to be that the majority of gamma rays from star-forming and starburst galaxies originate from interactions between high energy cosmic rays and the interstellar medium.

Jocelyn: They selected a sample of seven sources, M82, NGC two hundred fifty-three M31, Arp two hundred twenty NGC two thousand one hundred forty-six Arp two hundred ninety-nine and M33 <ref:2611.07189#pg1>.

Vera: The study uses fifteen years of Fermi-LAT data to characterize the GeV and sub-GeV gamma ray emission from these galaxies.

Subrahmanyan: They used broadband spectral properties from radio to X-ray energies to classify galaxies into normal ones, starburst galaxies, or Seyfert galaxies.

Jocelyn: The thesis points out that a strong correlation between observed GeV gamma ray luminosities and total infrared luminosities suggests the majority of gamma rays come from interstellar cosmic rays produced by star formation activity.

Vera: They found that the hard spectrum observed in SBGs, with a photon index Gamma approximately two point two, indicates these galaxies act as CR calorimeters, unlike the Milky Way which is escape-dominated.

Subrahmanyan: This observation prompts theoretical investigations into how cosmic rays transport in both starburst galaxies and our own Milky Way.

Jocelyn: The authors also found that the absence of a decrease in gamma ray flux below a few hundred MeV in M82, which would be expected if it were proton-dominated, suggests a high electron-to-proton ratio.

Vera: This is consistent with what they inferred from VERITAS data, indicating high cosmic ray calorimetric efficiency rather than significant cosmic ray escape.

Subrahmanyan: Essentially, the paper builds a robust framework for interpreting and predicting interstellar gamma ray emission from SFGs and SBGs based on these observations.

Conclusion: Vera: The paper "Systematic Study of Cosmic Rays in Star-Forming and Starburst Galaxies using Fermi-LAT and Multiwavelength Data" concludes that the interstellar gamma ray emission dominates all starburst galaxies in the sample they studied.

Jocelyn: They found that the inferred cosmic ray energy densities in these starburst galaxies are well below energy equipartition with the magnetic field energy density, which they suggest could be due to strong loss of cosmic ray protons and electrons in those dense environments.

Subrahmanyan: The authors also state that the observed spectral indices for both cosmic ray protons and electrons are harder than those in the Milky Way, which they attribute to high cosmic ray calorimetric efficiency instead of significant escape.

Vera: The predicted neutral pion decay gamma ray emission peaks around one GeV and falls steeply below two hundred MeV, which they found to be compatible with the data.

Jocelyn: Overall, this work provides observation-based templates for future studies by showing that interstellar gamma ray emission is the dominant component in starburst galaxies.

Subrahmanyan: The findings also enable distinguishing nuclear emission from the starburst component specifically in Seyfert galaxies, which is a useful application for mapping these sources.

Vera: This whole study gives us a robust framework for interpreting and predicting interstellar gamma ray emission from both star-forming and starburst galaxies.

Hinako OCHI, Tsunefumi MIZUNO, Yasushi FUKAZAWA, Noemi BARNIER, Susumu INOUE, Wataru IWAKIRI, Junling CHEN

Department of Physics, Graduate School of Advanced Science and Engineering, Hiroshima University · Hiroshima Astrophysical Science Center, Hiroshima University · International Center for Hadron Astrophysics, Chiba University · Department of Astronomy, School of Science, The University of Tokyo · Research Center for the Early Universe, School of Science, the University of Tokyo

astro-ph.HE

Submitted: 2026-11-04

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: This is a pre-copyedited, author-produced version of an article accepted for publication in PASJ following peer review

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: The majority of γ rays from star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and starburst galaxies (SBGs) are expected to originate from interactions between highenergy cosmic rays (CRs) and the interstellar medium…

Key concepts

Gamma Rays
High-energy photons emitted when cosmic rays interact with matter. The paper uses gamma rays as a tool to probe the high-energy particles (cosmic rays) and the gas/magnetic fields within galaxies like starburst galaxies.
Calorimetric Limit
A theoretical boundary where the energy gained by cosmic ray interactions is comparable to the total energy available in the surrounding interstellar medium. The study found that gamma-ray fluxes in these galaxies often fall at or below this limit, suggesting efficient energy conversion.
CR Energy Density
The amount of energy stored in cosmic rays (protons and electrons) per unit volume within a galaxy. The findings show that the CR energy densities in starburst galaxies are significantly lower than the magnetic field energy density, implying CRs are not fully equipartition with the magnetic field.
SED Modeling
Spectral Energy Distribution modeling is a technique used to fit observed data (like gamma-ray fluxes) across different energy bands. The researchers used this modeling to characterize the spectral properties of emission from galaxies like M82 and NGC 253.

Terminology

Summary

The majority of γ rays from star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and starburst galaxies (SBGs) are expected to originate from interactions between highenergy cosmic rays (CRs) and the interstellar medium, making γ-ray observations a powerful tool for probing CR populations and interstellar environments The majority of γ rays from star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and starburst galaxies (SBGs) are expected to originate from interactions between highenergy cosmic rays (CRs) and the interstellar medium, making γ-ray observations a powerful tool for probing CR populations and interstellar environments

Systematic Study Scope

The study conducted a systematic analysis of seven sources using 15 years of Fermi-LAT data to characterize GeV and sub-GeV γ-ray emission from SFGs and SBGs The sample included M82, NGC 253, M31, Arp 220, NGC 2146, Arp 299, and M33 Target selection focused on sources individually detected by Fermi-LAT using the 12-year catalog Sources were classified based on broadband spectral properties, with SFGs/SBGs selected from normal galaxies or starburst galaxies

Spectral Modeling and CR Properties

Detailed SED modeling of M82 and NGC 253 revealed a decrease in energy flux below a few hundred MeV, suggesting a substantially smaller contribution from CR electrons than previously inferred The electron-to-proton ratios in M82 and NGC 253 were found to be comparable to that of the Milky Way, although the CR energy densities in these two SBGs are 2.5–8 times lower than that of the magnetic field, unlike the Milky Way

Calorimetric Efficiency and Theoretical Framework

The analysis reduced γ-ray fluxes for several SBGs to levels comparable to or below the calorimetric limit, with efficiencies ranging from 0.33 to 1.20 A theoretical model of interstellar γ-ray emission was developed that successfully reproduces these observed calorimetric efficiencies, providing a robust framework for interpreting and predicting γ-ray emission from SFGs and SBGs

Galaxy Specific Findings

For M82, the logP model provided better agreement with the SED data points compared to the PL model, indicating mild curvature in its GeV and sub-GeV emission For NGC 253, similar findings were observed where the logP model was adopted to prevent bias in low-energy flux from affecting SED fitting M31's γ-ray emission consists of two point-like sources, with the central source displaying a soft spectrum and a compact size of less than 0.33, suggesting a considerable contribution from unresolved sources

Conclusion on Emission Origin

The results demonstrate that interstellar γ-ray emission dominates all SBGs in the sample The inferred CR energy densities of SBGs are well below energy equipartition with the magnetic field energy density, which could be due to strong loss of CR protons and electrons in dense environments Furthermore, the observed spectral indices for both CR protons and electrons are harder than those in the Milky Way, consistent with high CR calorimetric efficiency rather than significant CR escape The predicted π0-decay γ-ray emission peaks at ∼1 GeV and decays steeply below 200 MeV, being compatible with the data

Summary and Prospect

The revised analysis yields lower γ-ray flux estimates for several SBGs, aligning them with or below the calorimetric limit The updated γ-ray luminosities of the SBG sample members are comparable to or below the calorimetric limit, with observed fcal values ranging from 0.33 to 1.20 The study provides observation-based templates for future studies by showing that interstellar γ-ray emission dominates all SBGs in the sample The findings enable distinguishing nuclear emission from the starburst component in Seyfert galaxies The results provide a robust framework for interpreting and predicting interstellar γ-ray emission from SFGs and SBGs

Acknowledgments

The Fermi LAT Collaboration acknowledges generous ongoing support from a number of agencies and institutes that have supported both the development and the operation of the LAT as well as scientific data analysis Additional support for science analysis during the operations phase is gratefully acknowledged from the Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica in Italy and the Centre National d’Études Spatiales in France Funding was provided by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers 23K25882 and 23H04895 (T.M.), 26H00822 and 26H02063 (T.T.), and by JST SPRING Grant Number JPMJSP2108 (J. p. 3

Where the paper says it

To evaluate the detection significance in each energy interval, we used the test statistic (TS), defined as TS = 2 (lnL1 − lnL0), where L1 and L0 are the maximum likelihood values with and without the source, respectively. The TS approximately follows a χ 2 distribution with degrees of freedom equal to the number of free parameters (J.

C.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can accurately model gamma-ray spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of star-forming galaxies and starburst galaxies by incorporating a theoretical model for interstellar gamma-ray emission that successfully reproduces the observed calorimetric efficiencies.

  2. Improved AI can constrain cosmic ray properties, such as electron-to-proton ratios (Kep) and CR energy densities, by performing detailed multiwavelength SED fitting across radio to TeV gamma-ray energies and comparing results with theoretical calculations.

  3. Improved AI can distinguish between different emission components in nearby galaxies by analyzing spectral shapes; for instance, it can differentiate between the central source with a soft spectrum and the contribution from unresolved sources.

  4. Improved AI can develop robust frameworks for interpreting observational data by applying theoretical models to predict gamma-ray emission from star-forming galaxies and starburst galaxies, which provides a robust framework for interpreting and predicting gamma-ray emission from SFGs and SBGs.

Abstract

The majority of γ rays from star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and starburst galaxies (SBGs) are expected to originate from interactions between high-energy cosmic rays (CRs) and the interstellar medium, making γ-ray observations a powerful tool for probing CR populations and interstellar environments. Using 15 years of Fermi-LAT data, we conducted a systematic study of seven sources. The γ-ray spectra of the bright SBGs M82 and NGC 253 exhibit a decrease in energy flux below a few hundred MeV, suggesting a substantially smaller contribution from CR electrons than previously inferred. Detailed fits of the spectral energy distribution, which combine our GeV γ-ray measurements with reported radio and TeV γ-ray results, indicate that the electron-to-proton ratios in M82 and NGC 253 are comparable to that of the Milky Way. In contrast, energy densities of CRs in these two SBGs are 2.5--8 times lower than that of the magnetic field, unlike the Milky Way. For the nearby Local Group galaxy M31, we decomposed the γ-ray emission into two components, revealing a central source with a soft spectrum and a compact size of less than 0.33 degree, which indicates a considerable contribution from unresolved sources. Our new analysis also reduces the γ-ray fluxes of several SBGs, bringing all SBG sample members to levels comparable to or below the calorimetric limit, with calorimetric efficiencies ranging from 0.33 to 1.20. In contrast, all SFG sample members exhibit low efficiencies at the 10% level. We developed a theoretical model of interstellar γ-ray emission that successfully reproduces the observed calorimetric efficiencies, providing a robust framework for interpreting and predicting γ-ray emission from SFGs and SBGs.

Sources

Related papers